Brambila v. Superior Court CA5
CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketF090783
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Filed 11/18/26 Brambila v. Superior Court CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
RODOLFO A. BRAMBILA,
F090783
Petitioner,
(Fresno Super. Ct.
v. No. 25CESC00314)
THE SUPERIOR COURT OF FRESNO
COUNTY, OPINION
Respondent;
FRESNO COUNTY SHERIFF’S OFFICE,
Real Party in Interest.
THE COURT *
ORIGINAL PROCEEDINGS; petition for writ of mandate. Robert M. Whalen,
Jr., Judge.
Rodolfo A. Brambila, in pro. per., for Petitioner.
No appearance for Respondent.
* Before Meehan, Acting P. J., Snauffer, J. and Sandhu, J.
Douglas T. Sloan, County Counsel, and Scott C. Hawkins, Deputy County
Counsel, for Real Party in Interest.
-ooOoo-
Petitioner Rodolfo A. Brambila asks this court to issue a peremptory writ of
mandate directing the Fresno County Superior Court’s small claims division (hereafter
the small claims court) to vacate an August 12, 2025 judgment dismissing his action,
vacate an October 15, 2025 order dismissing his motion to vacate the August 12, 2025
judgment, and conduct a new trial. For the reasons set forth, we grant this requested
relief.
BACKGROUND
On March 18, 2025, Brambila—an inmate—commenced a small claims action
against Fresno County Sheriff John Zanoni (Sheriff) (case No. 25CESC00314).
Brambila alleged he had entrusted the safekeeping of his formal courtroom attire—i.e., a
navy blazer, two pairs of slacks, two button-down shirts, a tie, a reversible belt, and
leather shoes—to the Fresno County jail, but the jail staff either lost or stole his clothing
and Sheriff refused to reimburse him. Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure 1 section
116.540, subdivision (f), 2 Brambila submitted two declarations—his own and his
daughter’s—in support of the action. On August 12, 2025, the small claims court
dismissed the action on the basis of Brambila’s failure to appear.
1 Subsequent statutory citations refer to the Code of Civil Procedure.
2 “A party incarcerated in a county jail, a Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation facility, or a Division of Juvenile Facilities facility is not required to
personally appear, and may submit declarations to serve as evidence supporting their
claim, or may authorize another individual to appear and participate on their behalf if that
individual is serving without compensation and has appeared in small claims actions on
behalf of others no more than four times during the calendar year.” (§ 116.540,
subd. (f).)
2.
On September 2, 2025, pursuant to section 116.720, subdivision (a), 3 Brambila
filed a motion to vacate the August 12, 2025 judgment. Citing section 116.540,
subdivision (f), he argued the dismissal was erroneous because he was not required to
personally appear and submitted supporting declarations instead. A motion hearing was
scheduled for October 15, 2025, to be presided over by Judge Robert M. Whalen, Jr., and
a telephonic appearance via CourtCall was confirmed. Procedural information for the
CourtCall appearance was sent to the prison’s litigation coordinator. However, on the
day of the hearing, prison officials informed Brambila he was not scheduled for a
CourtCall appearance and did not allow him to make such an appearance. The small
claims court dismissed the motion on the basis of Brambila’s failure to appear.
On November 21, 2025, pursuant to section 116.798, subdivision (a)(1) and (2), 4
Brambila filed a petition for writ of mandate with this court. Specifically, he requested
issuance of a peremptory writ of mandate directing (1) the small claims court to vacate
the August 12, 2025 judgment, vacate the October 15, 2025 order, and conduct a new
trial; and (2) Judge Whalen to recuse himself from the proceeding. In a December 4,
2025 order, this court summarily denied the writ petition.
On December 22, 2025, Brambila filed a petition for review of this court’s
December 4, 2025 order with the California Supreme Court (case No. S294442). Under
the heading “ISSUES PRESENTED” (underscoring omitted), he wrote: “A single issue
is presented in this petition for review: [t]he right to submit declarations in lieu of
3 “A plaintiff who did not appear at the hearing in the small claims court may file
a motion to vacate the judgment with the clerk of the small claims court. The motion
shall be filed within 30 days after the clerk has mailed notice of entry of the judgment to
the parties.” (§ 116.720, subd. (a).)
4 “A petition that seeks a writ of review, a writ of mandate, or a writ of prohibition
relating to an act of the small claims division, other than a postjudgment enforcement
order, may be heard by a judge who is assigned to the appellate division of the superior
court.” (§ 116.798, subd. (a)(1).) “A petition described by paragraph (1) may also be
heard by the [C]ourt of [A]ppeal or by the Supreme Court.” (Id., subd. (a)(2).)
3.
appearance for a small claims proceeding, as granted to prisoners by … sec[tion]
116.540[, subdivision ](f).” On February 25, 2026, the Supreme Court granted
Brambila’s review petition and transferred the matter back to this court with directions to
(1) vacate the December 4, 2025 order denying writ relief; (2) reconsider the cause in
light of sections 116.540, subdivision (f), 116.720, subdivision (a), and 116.798,
subdivision (a)(1) and (2); and (3) issue an order to show cause why the relief sought in
the writ petition should not be granted.
On March 2, 2026, this court filed an order vacating the December 4, 2025 order.
This court also issued an order to show cause, instructing Sheriff to file a written return
and Brambila to file a reply thereto.
DISCUSSION
As noted, in his writ petition, Brambila asked this court to issue a peremptory writ
of mandate directing (1) the small claims court to vacate the August 12, 2025 judgment
dismissing his action, vacate the October 15, 2025 order dismissing his motion to vacate
the August 12, 2025 judgment, and conduct a new trial; and (2) Judge Whalen to recuse
himself from the proceeding. We address each request seriatim.
I. Directing the small claims court to vacate the August 12, 2025 judgment,
vacate the October 15, 2025 order, and conduct a new trial.
In a return filed April 28, 2026, County Counsel—on behalf of Sheriff—
answered:
“[Sheriff] does not oppose the relief described in the sole ‘issue presented’
for relief and sought by [Brambila] in the California Supreme Court case
no. S294442, to wit, the right to appear in Fresno County Superior Court,
Small Claims Division, in Case no. 25CESC00314, by declarations or other
permissible means as the Court may determine. To the extent it informs
this Court to know, [Sheriff] is actively working to resolve payment of the
underlying claim by [Brambila] in that action, for the reasonable value of
certain items of clothing alleged by [Brambila] to have gone missing.
[Sheriff] will seek to arrange for a voluntary dismissal of all related Court
matters and actions as soon as possible.”
4.
On July 22, 2026, after this case was fully briefed, 5 Brambila filed additional
documents. An April 28, 2026 letter from the County of Fresno (County) asked Brambila
to sign and return an “enclosed … release for $315[ 6] for settlement of [the] Claim for
Damages.” In a June 11, 2026 letter to County, Brambila acknowledged receipt of the
April 28, 2026 letter but indicated he would not sign the release because “[the] $315
settlement offer no longer covers the amount of [his] loss.” He specified he “incurred
court costs and other expenses as a result of Fresno County Jail’s refusal to reimburse
[his] loss in 2024 when it occurred,” provided an itemized list of said costs and expenses,
and stated he would “be happy to sign and return [the release] “[i]f [County] adjust[s]
[its] offer accordingly.” In a July 13, 2026 letter to this court, Brambila reported County
did not respond to his June 11, 2026 letter and “the matter seems to have stalled.” He
asked us to issue “a judgment/order consistent with” the Supreme Court’s February 25,
2026 order, this court’s March 2, 2025 order, and County Counsel’s April 28, 2026
return.
Sheriff did not oppose Brambila’s vacation and new trial requests. In addition,
while Sheriff offered to settle the matter to effect a voluntary dismissal, the amount
proposed did not account for costs and expenses related to the small claims action. (See
§§ 116.610, subd. (g)(1) [“The prevailing party is entitled to the costs of the action .…”];
116.820, subd. (c) [“The prevailing party in any action subject to this chapter is entitled
to the costs of enforcing the judgment and accrued interest.”].) In view of these
circumstances, we grant Brambila’s writ petition in part and issue a peremptory writ of
mandate directing the small claims court to vacate the August 12, 2025 judgment, vacate
the October 15, 2025 order, and conduct a new trial.
5 Brambila elected not to file a reply to County Counsel’s return.
6 Brambila valued the lost or stolen clothing at $315.
5.
II. Directing Judge Whalen to recuse himself from the proceeding.
“A judge shall be disqualified if …. [¶] … [t]he judge has personal knowledge of
disputed evidentiary facts concerning the proceeding.” (§ 170.1, subd. (a)(1)(A).) Citing
this provision, Brambila contends Judge Whalen should have recused himself because he
“participated in the underlying criminal case” by “issu[ing] a search warrant on, or about,
12/10/20, and, therefore had knowledge of facts of the case outside of the proceedings of
the instant case.” By Brambila’s own description, however, Judge Whalen’s purported
knowledge did not pertain to disputed evidentiary facts concerning the small claims
proceeding. (See People v. Snook (1997) 16 Cal.4th 1210, 1215 [“If there is no
ambiguity in the [statutory] language, we presume the Legislature meant what it said and
the plain meaning of the statute governs.”].) Therefore, we deny Brambila’s writ petition
in part. 7
DISPOSITION
Let a peremptory writ of mandate issue directing the small claims division of the
Fresno County Superior Court to vacate the August 12, 2025 judgment, vacate the
October 15, 2025 order, and conduct a new trial. Costs on appeal are awarded to
petitioner Rodolfo A. Brambila.
7 Given our disposition, Brambila’s July 13, 2026 request is moot.
6.