Tonya McClellan and Dave McClellan v. Kelley's Construction and Demolition, LLC, Evanston Insurance Company, Terry D. Kelly Individually and D/B/A Outlaw Tree Service and CNS Millworks and Progressive Palo Verde Insurance Company
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket56,914-CW(Consolidated Cases)
JudgeEllender
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Judgment rendered November 18, 2026.
Application for rehearing may be filed
within the delay allowed by Art. 2166,
La. C.C.P.
No. 56,914-CW
No. 56,913-CW
(Consolidated Cases)
COURT OF APPEAL
SECOND CIRCUIT
STATE OF LOUISIANA
*****
TONYA MCCLELLAN AND Plaintiffs-Applicants
DAVE MCCLELLAN
versus
KELLEY’S CONSTRUCTION Defendants-Respondents
AND DEMOLITION, LLC,
EVANSTON INSURANCE
COMPANY, TERRY D. KELLY
INDIVIDUALLY AND D/B/A
OUTLAW TREE SERVICE AND
CNS MILLWORKS AND
PROGRESSIVE PALO VERDE
INSURANCE COMPANY
*****
On Application for Writs from the
Fourth Judicial District Court for the
Parish of Ouachita, Louisiana
Trial Court No. 2023-1209
Honorable Frederick Douglass Jones, Judge
*****
HUDSON, POTTS & BERNSTEIN, LLP Counsel for Applicants,
By : Robert McCuller Baldwin Tonya McClellan and
Dave McClellan
DEGAN, BLANCHARD & NASH Counsel for Respondent,
By: Sidney Wallis Degan, III Evanston Insurance
Travis Louis Bourgeois Company
Karl H. Schmid
Simone M. Almon
CHARLES WILLIAM HEROLD, III, APLC
JONES WALKER LLP Counsel for Respondents,
By: Ian Alexander MacDonald Progressive Palo Verde
Insurance Company;
Kelly’s Construction and
Demolition, LLC; and
Terry D. Kelly
*****
Before THOMPSON, ROBINSON, and ELLENDER, JJ.
ELLENDER, J.
Tonya and Dave McClellan seek review of a ruling that denied their
motion for summary judgment declaring coverage for their claims under a
commercial general liability insurance policy issued by Evanston Insurance
Company. In the companion case, Docket No. 56,914, Evanston seeks review
of a concurrent ruling that denied its motion for summary judgment declaring
the exclusion of coverage.
The facts, procedural history, arguments of the parties, and conclusions
of this court are laid out extensively in the companion opinion, Docket No.
56,914. For the reasons expressed therein, we find the Evanston policy
provides coverage for the McClellans’ claims.
For these reasons, the McClellans’ writ application is granted, their
motion for summary judgment is granted, and judgment is rendered herein
declaring coverage under the Evanston policy. All costs are to be paid by
Evanston Insurance Company.
WRIT GRANTED; MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
GRANTED; JUDGMENT RENDERED DECLARING COVERAGE
UNDER THE EVANSTON POLICY. CASE REMANDED.