Marple Newtown School District v. UCBR
CourtCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket475 C.D. 2025
JudgeWojcik
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Marple Newtown School District,:
:
Petitioner :
:
v. : No. 475 C.D. 2025
: Submitted: June 16, 2026
Unemployment Compensation :
Board of Review, :
:
Respondent :
BEFORE: HONORABLE RENÉE COHN JUBELIRER, President Judge
HONORABLE MICHAEL H. WOJCIK, Judge
HONORABLE CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge
OPINION NOT REPORTED
MEMORANDUM OPINION
BY JUDGE WOJCIK FILED: November 18, 2026
Marple Newtown School District (Employer) petitions for review of the
order of the Unemployment Compensation Board of Review (Board) affirming the
decision of a referee that Zaren Holbrook (Claimant) is not ineligible for
Unemployment Compensation (UC) benefits under Section 402(e) of the
Unemployment Compensation Law (Law).1 Upon careful review, we affirm because
the Board’s findings are supported by substantial evidence, its credibility
1
Act of December 5, 1936, Second Ex. Sess., P.L. (1937) 2897, as amended, 43 P.S.
§802(e). Section 402(e) of the Law, provides in relevant part: “[A]n employe shall be ineligible
for compensation for any week . . . [i]n which his unemployment is due to his discharge or
temporary suspension from work for willful misconduct connected with his work . . . .” Id.
determinations are binding on this Court, and Employer failed to establish willful
misconduct as a matter of law.2
Claimant worked for Employer as a custodian for approximately 18
years, most recently as a Lead Custodian. Reproduced Record (R.R.) at 9a. In
January 2023, Employer placed Claimant on a Performance Improvement Plan
(PIP), with follow‑up meetings in February, April, and June 2023. See id. at 95a-
114a. On September 13, 2023, Employer suspended Claimant without pay pending
his termination. Id. at 73a-76a. Claimant was officially terminated on November
28, 2023, for alleged poor work performance. Id. at 35a-36a.
As a result, Claimant filed an application for UC benefits. On
November 20, 2023, the UC Service Center determined that he is not eligible for
benefits under Section 402(e) of the Law. See R.R. at 2a. Claimant appealed the
Service Center’s determination to a Referee.
A Referee conducted a hearing on January 29, 2024. Claimant,
Employer’s counsel, and Employer witnesses Janeen Partridge and Mike Facciolo
testified. Based on the testimony and evidence presented, the Referee found that
Employer failed to establish willful misconduct. Notably, the Referee concluded
that Employer’s witnesses did not witness firsthand several of the incidents forming
the basis of the termination, rendering the evidence uncorroborated hearsay. R.R.
126a-29a. The Referee further found Claimant’s testimony credible, particularly his
explanations regarding workload, confusion about directives, and performance to
the best of his ability. Id. at 41a-42a.
2
“The issue of whether Claimant’s conduct constituted willful misconduct under Section
402(e) of the Law is a question of law fully reviewable by this Court. Ductmate Indus[tries], Inc.
v. Unemployment Comp[ensation] B[oard] of Review, 949 A.2d 338 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2008).” Johns
v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 87 A.3d 1006, 1010 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2014).
2
Employer then appealed the Referee’s decision to the Board. On March
13, 2025, the Board issued the instant order specifically adopting the Referee’s
findings and conclusions and affirmed the Referee’s decision.3 Employer now
petitions this Court for review.
On appeal,4 Employer contends that the Board erred in affirming the
Referee’s award of benefits because it is not supported by substantial evidence, and
improperly disregarded Employer’s corroborating evidence demonstrating that
Claimant engaged in willful misconduct. We do not agree.
As stated, Section 402(e) renders a claimant ineligible where the
discharge is due to willful misconduct. 43 P.S. §802(e). Although not defined in
the Law, precedent establishes that the term includes: (1) wanton or willful disregard
of the employer’s interests; (2) deliberate violation of rules; (3) disregard of
3
As the Board explained:
In this matter, [E]mployer terminated [C]laimant for his
unsatisfactory work performance. [E]mployer’s decision to
terminate [C]laimant was partially based on complaints they
received; however, the individuals who made these complaints did
not appear at the hearing to corroborate their statements, supporting
the finding that the [E]mployer’s evidence lacks firsthand
knowledge in some regards to the allegations of misconduct. At the
hearing, [C]laimant credibly testified that his job responsibilities
were overwhelming, and the workload exceeded his capacity; he
subsequently reported his concerns to the assistant director of
[Human Resources]. Additionally, [C]laimant presented credible
testimony and evidence demonstrating that he performed the
responsibilities assigned to him to the best of his ability. [C]laimant
acted in good faith to fulfill his job responsibilities.
Certified Record (C.R.) at 273.
4
Our review is limited to determining whether constitutional rights were violated, an error
of law was committed, or the necessary factual findings are supported by substantial evidence.
Section 704 of the Administrative Agency Law, 2 Pa. C.S. §704.
3
standards the employer may rightfully expect; or (4) negligence manifesting
intentional disregard. Grieb v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 827
A.2d 422, 426 (Pa. 2003). Employer bears the burden of proving that the misconduct
was intentional or deliberate. Kelly v. Unemployment Compensation Board of
Review, 747 A.2d 436, 438 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2000). “Mere incompetence, inexperience,
or inability to perform a job” does not suffice. Myers v. Unemployment
Compensation Board of Review, 625 A.2d 622, 625 (Pa. 1993); see also Coleman v.
Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 407 A.2d 130, 131-32 (Pa. Cmwlth.
1979) (“It is settled that an employee’s negligence does not constitute willful
misconduct unless it is of ‘such degree or recurrence as to manifest culpability,
wrongful intent, or evil design, or show an intentional and substantial disregard of
the employer’s interest or of the employee’s duties and obligations to the
employer.’”) (citation omitted).
The record herein demonstrates that the Board credited Claimant’s
testimony that: his workload was overwhelming and duties were repeatedly changed,
contributing to confusion; Employer did not inform him at the time that specific
actions were incorrect, causing misunderstanding about expectations; he performed
his duties to the best of his ability and sought help when needed; and he reported
concerns to the assistant director of HR. See R.R. at 37a-40a. In addition, he also
provided detailed, plausible explanations for instances Employer characterized as
misconduct: the “fortress” of cafeteria tables was necessary for him to scrape gum
from underside surfaces; the trash bags on his feet were related to power‑washing
the bathroom floors; the furniture that was moved into hallways had been stored in
bathrooms during floor stripping and needed removal for cleaning. See id.
Moreover, Claimant disputed the floor-scrubber allegations, explaining that the
4
machine cannot run by itself while plugged in. See id. at 40a-41a. The Board
expressly adopted these credibility determinations, which we are bound to accept on
our review.5
In making that determination, the Board agreed with the Referee that
Employer’s evidence consisted largely of uncorroborated hearsay. R.R. at 126a-29a.
Key allegations relied on documented complaints in Exhibit ER1, including
assertions that Claimant laughed about creating messes, dared supervisors to fire
him, or behaved erratically. See R.R. at 73a-76a. However, none of the individuals
who made these statements appeared at the hearing.
Furthermore, Facciolo admitted he did not personally witness Claimant
leaving the floor scrubber running; other people had access to the kitchen; and he
found the scrubber during a period in which Claimant was not scheduled to be at
work. R.R. at 33a. Other allegations likewise relied on reports from individuals
who did not testify, including kitchen staff, secretaries, and other custodians. See
id. at 24a-25a.
Employer’s own witnesses testified that Claimant had been a
satisfactory employee for nearly two decades, with the alleged decline beginning in
August 2022. R.R. at 23a-25a; 31a. This history strongly supports the Board’s
determination that Claimant lacked the requisite intent to commit willful
5
As this Court has explained, “[i]n UC cases, the Board is the ultimate fact[]finder and is
empowered to resolve all issues of witness credibility, conflicting evidence, and evidentiary
weight.” Pierce-Boyce v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 289 A.3d 130, 135 (Pa.
Cmwlth. 2022) (citation omitted). “It is irrelevant whether the record contains evidence that would
support findings other than those made by the Board; the proper inquiry is whether the evidence
supports the findings actually made.” Id. at 135-36. Moreover, we must examine the evidence in
a light most favorable to . . . the party who prevailed before the Board, and to give [them] the
benefit of all inferences that can be logically and reasonably drawn from the testimony. Taylor v.
Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 378 A.2d 829, 831 (Pa. 1977).
5
misconduct. Where an employee has previously performed satisfactorily, and later
struggles due to confusion, workload, or misunderstanding, Pennsylvania precedent
holds that willful misconduct cannot be inferred. Myers; Coleman; see also Rieder
v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 325 A.2d 347, 348 (Pa. Cmwlth.
1974) (“[M]erely being discharged for unsatisfactory work resulting from inability,
inexperience, or lack of coordination does not disqualify the discharged employe as
being guilty of willful misconduct.”).
In sum, accepting that Claimant failed to meet certain Employer
expectations, the Board reasonably found no substantial evidence of deliberate or
intentional disregard of Employer’s interests. The credited substantial evidence in
this case may have established confusion, workload pressures, and lack of
contemporaneous guidance, but not willful misconduct.6 Because Employer bore
the burden to show intentional wrongdoing and did not meet it, the Board properly
affirmed the award of benefits. The fact that Employer presented evidence
supporting the opposite conclusion does not compel this Court to disturb the Board’s
determination in this regard. Pierce-Boyce.
Accordingly, the Board’s order is affirmed.
MICHAEL H. WOJCIK, Judge
6
Thus, any purported error with respect to the Board’s treatment of the hearsay evidence
is harmless. See, e.g., Wallace v. Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole, 548 A.2d 1291,
1294 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1988) (“While [the witness’s] testimony of what [the victim] said is hearsay, it
was harmless error inasmuch as [the victim’s] own testimony constituted substantial evidence of
the assault and possession of a weapon.”).
6
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Marple Newtown School District,:
:
Petitioner :
:
v. : No. 475 C.D. 2025
:
Unemployment Compensation :
Board of Review, :
:
Respondent :
ORDER
AND NOW, this 18th day of November, 2026, the order of the
Unemployment Compensation Board of Review dated March 13, 2025, is
AFFIRMED.
MICHAEL H. WOJCIK, Judge