Full Opinion

NOT FOR PUBLICATION WITHOUT THE APPROVAL OF THE APPELLATE DIVISION This opinion shall not "constitute precedent or be binding upon any court ." Although it is posted on the internet, this opinion is binding only on the parties in the case and its use in other cases is limited . R. 1:36-3. SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY APPELLATE DIVISION DOCKET NOS. A-3876-24 A-3877-24 TEAM 3 FINANCIAL, LLC, Plaintiff-Respondent, v. 125 BERCKMAN ST LLC and NAYANA PATEL, Defendants, and JAMES E. SHELTON, Defendant-Appellant. ________________________ Argued October 6, 2026 ‒ Decided November 19, 2026 Before Judges Bishop-Thompson and Jablonski. On appeal from the Superior Court of New Jersey, Chancery Division, Union County, Docket Nos. F- 001427-24 and F-001430-24. Allison L. Domowitch argued the cause for appellant (Fleischer, Suglia, Dopke & Domowitch, PC, attorneys; Allison L. Domowitch, on the briefs). Hugh A. Keffer argued the cause for respondent (Fidelity National Title Group, attorneys; Hugh A. Keffer, on the briefs). PER CURIAM In these two matters, calendared back-to-back for the purposes of issuing a single opinion, defendant James Shelton appeals from the trial court's August 4, 2025 orders, denying his objection to the amount due fixed by the court and remanding the matter to the Office of Foreclosure to proceed as an uncontested matter on plaintiff Team 3 Financial LLC's (Team 3 Financial) motion for final judgment. We affirm. I. Shelton holds a Texas judgment, entered on June 30, 2020, against defendant 125 Berckman St, LLC (Berckman) and Bhavesh Patel1 in the amount of $154,905.76, inclusive of damages, attorney's fees, and 5% interest. Shelton 1 We refer to Nayana Patel and Bhavesh Patel by their first names to avoid any confusion caused by the common surname; no disrespect is intended. The record does not identify any relationship between them. In addition, Berckman and Nayana are not parties to this appeal because the sole issue is lien priority, which does involve them. A-3876-24 2 domesticated the judgment in New Jersey on October 14, 2020, at which point it became a lien on real property owned by Berckman and Bhavesh. On July 18, 2022, Shelton conditionally agreed to accept $40,000 in full satisfaction of his judgment against Berckman and Bhavesh. The agreement, however, was never reduced to writing. Nonetheless, Shelton executed a warrant to satisfy the judgment and delivered the notarized original to the title company, with instructions to hold it in escrow pending payment of the settlement amount. He neither received the settlement funds nor authorized the warrant's release or recording. The warrant was later released to another title insurance agency and recorded on October 27, 2022. The recorded warrant identified Joseph M. Carney as the party whose judgment had been satisfied, although he was not a party to the judgment. In September 2022, Advantage Capital, LLC (Advantage) extended a commercial loan to Berckman, secured by a note in the principal amount of $220,000, with a mortgage on the property located on Sumner Avenue in Plainfield. That mortgage was recorded in the Union County Clerk's Office on September 23, 2022. The following month, Advantage extended a second commercial loan to Berckman, secured by a note in the principal amount of $225,000, with a A-3876-24 3 mortgage on the property located on Berckman Street also in Plainfield. That mortgage was also recorded in the clerk's office on November 1, 2022. Both loans were further secured by an "Assignment of Leases and Rents." Nayana, the manager and sole member of Berckman, executed a guaranty and a pledge and security agreement for both loans. Thereafter, both mortgages were assigned to Advantage's affiliated entity, Team 3 Financial. Before the closing of Team 3 Financial's loan, the title agency obtained a title commitment that included a judgment search. That search disclosed the Shelton judgment. At the closing, the settlement agent was provided with the original notarized warrant, and Berckman furnished an affidavit of title. The settlement agent disbursed funds to clear Berckman and Nayana's title and thereby secured Team 3 Financial a first-priority mortgage on each property. With regard to the Sumner Avenue property, the agent paid off a mortgage lien, property tax obligation, municipal utility authority charges, and a 2018 judgment, totaling $211,499.64. As to the Berckman Street property, the agent paid off a mortgage lien, property tax obligation, and municipal utility authority charges, totaling $207,321.42. The loan nevertheless closed without any payment to Shelton, who received no notice of the closing. A-3876-24 4 Shelton learned of the unauthorized filing and confirmed the warrant had been recorded. He then moved to vacate the warrant, which was granted on June 9, 2023. In November 2022, Berckman and Nayana defaulted on both loans and failed to respond to the notices of default. On February 8, 2024, Advantage filed separate foreclosure complaints in the Chancery Division against Berckman and Nayana concerning the Sumner and Berckman Street properties. Shelton moved to intervene in these actions but later withdrew his motions. Advantage thereafter filed amended complaints in both matters, adding Shelton as a defendant. Shelton filed a contested answer and counterclaim, seeking a declaration that his interest as a judgment creditor was superior to Advantage's interest. On August 12, 2024, the court entered an order substituting Team 3 Financial as plaintiff. In October 2024, Team 3 Financial moved for summary judgment in both actions, seeking a determination of the priority of the parties' liens based on equitable subrogation. Shelton cross-moved for summary judgment objecting to the amount due to him. On November 22, 2024, the motion court granted Team 3 Financial's motion and denied Shelton's cross-motion. In an accompanying statement of A-3876-24 5 reasons, the court concluded that, under the doctrine of equitable subrogation, Team 3 Financial was entitled to the same priority as the mortgagees and creditors whose senior interest it had discharged. Because Shelton's judgment was junior to those interests, the court held Team 3 Financial's mortgage interest in both properties was superior to Shelton's judgment lien to the extent it s loan proceeds were used to satisfy those senior obligations. Accordingly, Team 3 Financial's mortgage interest was superior in the amount of $207,321.42 for the Berckman property and $211,499.65 for the Sumner Avenue property. In separate orders dated January 3, 2025, the court granted Team 3 Financial's unopposed motion to enforce the contractual default interest rate of 2% per month, or 24% per year. Although the motion was unopposed, the court nevertheless made findings of fact and conclusions of law in a statement of reasons. It found the 24% default rate reasonable because it was expressly provided for in the note, mortgage, and related loan documents governing these commercial transactions. The court further determined since defendants defaulted on December 1, 2022, default interest accrued from that date through entry of final judgment and would continue to accrue until the judgment was paid in full. A-3876-24 6 Team 3 Financial then moved before the Foreclosure Unit for entry of final judgment, which was unopposed. On March 14, 2025, the court entered separate final judgment in the full amount of the notes, $358,425.70 for the Berckman Street property and $351,459.71 for the Sumner Avenue property and issued a writ of execution. Both orders calculated the amount due, together with interest at the contractual default interest rate, costs, and attorney's fees calculated as of January 31, 2025. A writ of execution was issued on April 14, 2025. On May 23, 2025, the court vacated both final judgments pursuant to Rule 4:50-1. In its statement of reasons, the court concluded the judgment failed to account for Shelton's lien priority in relation to Team 3 Financial's total interest. The court explained the judgments improperly merged Team 3 Financial's first- and third-priority interests into a single judgment, thereby extinguishing Shelton's second-priority interest in contravention of the summary judgment order. It further found Team 3 Financial had no right to extinguish Shelton's interest. Team 3 Financial again moved for final judgment in both matters and proposed the sale proceeds be distributed as follows: from the Sumner Avenue property, Team 3 Financial was to be paid first $337,459.71, representing 96% A-3876-24 7 of the judgment, plus accrued interest; from the Berckman Street property, it would be paid first $329,751.64, representing 92% of the judgment, plus accrued interest. Shelton was to be paid second $154,905.76, plus post-judgment interest accruing from June 30, 2020, and Team 3 Financial would be paid the remaining balance of the judgment from the sale proceeds. Shelton objected, arguing the final judgment sought by Team 3 Financial remained inconsistent with the court's prior summary judgment and vacatur orders. The appendix submitted to us, however, does not include Shelton's objection. He contended the court expressly held Team 3 Financial's first- priority interest was capped at $207,321.42. On August 4, 2025, the court entered final judgment and denied Shelton's objection. In its well-reasoned written opinion, the motion court rejected Shelton's argument, concluding Team 3 Financial would suffer no prejudice if its recovery were limited to the same contractual interest and related costs Advantage could have recovered had Team 3 Financial never become involved. The court found that result consistent with Sovereign Bank v. Gillis, 432 N.J. Super. 36 (App. Div. 2013). The court further observed Shelton had not identified any prejudice resulting from the scope of the subrogation—whether by showing his second-priority lien could not be fully satisfied through a A-3876-24 8 sheriff's sale or by demonstrating the terms of Team 3 Financial's note were materially less favorable than those of Advantage's note. The matter was again remanded to the Officer of Foreclosure to proceed uncontested. II. On appeal, Shelton contends the motion court erred in concluding Team 3 Financial's lien retained first-priority over Shelton's judgment in an amount exceeding beyond the $207,321.42 fixed in the November 22, 2024 summary judgment order. He argues any interest accruing beyond the amount Team 3 Financial paid to satisfy the mortgage falls outside the protection of equitable subrogation. Shelton further asserts Team 3 Financial neither raised nor addressed, in its motion for summary judgment or its motion for default interest rate, both the $337,459.71 and $329,751.64 priority calculation ultimately adopted by the court. Upon review of the record, we conclude the motion court properly granted Team 3 Financial's motion for final judgment and denied Shelton's objections; we affirm substantially for the reasons expressed in its well-reasoned opinion. We add the following comments. Our scope of review of a trial court's decision to apply an equitable doctrine is limited. Ocwen Loan Servs., LLC v. Quinn, 450 N.J. Super. 393, A-3876-24 9 397 (App. Div. 2016). A decision to apply equitable subrogation is "left to the sound discretion of the trial judge, and we will not substitute our judgment for that of the trial judge in the absence of a clear abuse of discretion." N.Y. Mortg. Tr. 2005-3 v. Deely, 466 N.J. Super. 387, 397 (App. Div. 2021) (quoting Ocwen, 450 N.J. Super. at 397). We review a trial court's decision to apply equitable subrogation for abuse of discretion and will not substitute our judgment for that of the court unless the decision falls outside the range of acceptable choices or is based on a mistaken understanding of the law. Deely, 466 N.J. Super. at 397. The factual findings adopted by the trial court in an equity case are entitled to deference on appeal when they are supported by "adequate, substantial and credible evidence" in the record. Marioni v. Roxy Garments Delivery Co., Inc., 417 N.J. Super. 269, 275 (App. Div. 2010). No special deference is afforded to the trial court's interpretations of the law and legal consequences that flow from established facts. Invs. Bank v. Torres, 243 N.J. 25, 47 (2020) (citing Templo Fuente De Vida Corp. v. Nat'l Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, 224 N.J. 189, 199 (2016)). New Jersey follows a race-notice recording scheme; as a general matter, the party who first records its interest, without notice of a prior unrecorded interest, has priority. Sovereign, 432 N.J. Super. at 43; N.J.S.A. 46:26A-1 to - A-3876-24 10 12. An established exception to that rule is the doctrine of equitable subrogation, which permits a refinancing lender to assume, in whole or in part, the priority position of the mortgage its loan proceeds satisfied, notwithstanding the existence of an intervening lien, provided the new lender's funds were in fact used to discharge the prior mortgage. Id. at 44 (citing Invs Sav. Bank v. Keybank Nat'l Ass'n, 424 N.J. Super. 439, 443 (App. Div. 2012)). This favored doctrine is grounded in principles of fairness and designed to prevent unjust enrichment by requiring that the party who, in good conscience, ought to satisfy the obligation ultimately do so. U.S. Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. Hylton, 403 N.J. Super. 630, 637-38 (App. Div. 2008). We reject Shelton's contention that the trial court erred in awarding Team 3 Financial first-priority status in amounts exceeding $211,499.65 on the Sumner Avenue property and $207,321.42 on the Berckman Street property, or that the court is required to adhere strictly to the November 2024 order. We likewise reject Shelton's argument Team 3 Financial did not raise, either in its summary judgment motion or its motion to enforce default interest, the final judgment amounts of $358,425.70 and $329,751.64, or its first-priority calculations. A-3876-24 11 Even though Shelton opposed Team 3 Financial's renewed application for entry of final judgment, his objection rested on the misapprehension of the doctrine. He argues equitable subrogation permits a new lender to assume the original lien position only to the extent of the funds actually used to pay off the prior lien, and not as to any excess funds. Shelton reprises those same arguments on appeal. As the motion court correctly observed, the first-priority amounts of $337,401.32 and $329,751.64 do not prejudice Shelton because they both are calculated using the contractual default interest rate. Because Team 3 Financial stands in Advantage's shoes, it is entitled to recover the stipulated damages caused by defendants' default and are "presumptively reasonable" when applied to "commercial contract[s] between sophisticated parties." Metlife Cap. Fin. Corp. v. Washington Ave. Assocs., L.P., 159 N.J. 484, 496, 501 (1999). Here, those stipulated damages consist of the 24% default interest rate the parties negotiated to apply to the outstanding principal balance. The motion court correctly determined the original final judgment did not carve out the portion of the recovery attributable to Shelton's intervening interest. Nor did the judgment include the default interest. By contrast, the August 4, 2025 order expressly recognized and fixed Shelton's judgment, as A-3876-24 12 reflected in the court's analysis and its application of percentage allocations to Team 3 Financial. See ibid. On this record, we conclude the court properly exercised its discretion in finding the contract default rate reasonable and in applying the resulting percentages to the Sumner Avenue and Berckman Street properties. The court therefore did not err in concluding Team 3 Financial retained priority over Shelton's judgment. Affirmed. A-3876-24 13