Gomez, J. v. Gomez, K.
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket1600 WDA 2025
JudgeMcLaughlin
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
J-A16004-26
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
JOHN PAUL GOMEZ : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
Appellant :
:
:
v. :
:
:
KEYSHA L. GOMEZ : No. 1600 WDA 2025
Appeal from the Order Entered December 8, 2025
In the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County Family Court at
No(s): FD-20-000355-007
BEFORE: McLAUGHLIN, J., KING, J., and BENDER, P.J.E.
MEMORANDUM BY McLAUGHLIN, J.: FILED: November 16, 2026
John Paul Gomez (“Husband”) appeals from the order dismissing his
petition under the Protection from Abuse Act (“PFA”)1 against his wife, Keysha
L. Gomez (“Wife”). He challenges the admission of evidence, the dismissal of
the petition, and the denial of his motion to correct and supplement the
hearing transcript. We affirm.
The trial court aptly summarized the history of this case as follows:
By way of background, prior to the subject litigation, the
parties filed two (2) cross-Petitions for Protection from
Abuse against each other, first in March 2020, and again in
July 2025. Of note, the July 2025 PFA petitions were
resolved by Consent Agreements dated September 25,
2025.
On November 21, 2025, [Husband] filed his third PFA
Petition against [Wife]. In his Petition, [Husband] averred
that he was in a Zoom meeting with his work leader when
____________________________________________
1 See 23 Pa.C.S.A. §§ 6101-6122.
J-A16004-26
[Wife] walked into the room while she was on the phone.
According to [Husband], [Wife] began recording him while
she was on the phone, and [Husband] himself then began
to record [Wife]. [Husband] left the house to “deescalate.”
When he returned, [Wife] allegedly came out of the house
and blocked him from going into his daughter’s room to get
some of his belongings. [Husband] also averred that on
October 2[1], 2025, [Wife] backed up her vehicle
“aggressively” towards him and locked him out of the home,
called him crazy and made false statements about him to
their three (3) minor children.
[The court] issued a Temporary PFA Order on November
21, 2025. This Order excluded [Wife] from the residence
and granted primary physical custody of the Children to
[Husband]. [Wife] was ordered to have partial custody at
the dates, times, and circumstances listed by [Husband],
and the children could initiate telephone calls to [Wife].
Pa.R.A.P. 1925(a) Opinion, filed 1/8/26, at 2-3.
At the final PFA hearing, on December 3, 2025, Husband appeared pro
se and Wife was represented by counsel. Husband testified similarly to the
allegations of his PFA petition. Husband also testified about an incident that
occurred while he was in the bathroom of the parties’ marital residence. He
stated that while he was showering, Wife came into the bathroom and would
not let him leave the bathroom. N.T., Final PFA Hearing, 12/3/25, at 44-45.
Husband testified that he called 911 and recorded the incident on his cell
phone. Id. The parties stipulated that Husband called 911 on the day of the
incident, and Husband moved to admit the 911 recording and a cell phone
video recording of the incident. The court excluded both pieces of evidence. It
found that the video was inadmissible under the Wiretapping Electronic
-2-
J-A16004-26
Surveillance Control Act (“Wiretap Act”)2 and the 911 recording was
inadmissible hearsay.
At the conclusion of the hearing, Wife’s counsel argued that Husband
failed to meet the burden of proof for a PFA petition and asked the court to
dismiss the petition. See id. at 81-82. The court dismissed the petition, finding
that Husband “failed to establish sufficient evidence” under the PFA. See
Protection from Abuse Dismissal Order, filed 12/8/25. This timely appeal
followed. See Notice of Appeal, filed 12/15/25.
The court ordered Husband to file a Statement of Matters Complained
of on Appeal and Husband complied. See Statement of Errors Complained of
on Appeal (“Rule 1925(b) Statement”), filed 1/2/26.3 Husband also filed a
Motion to Correct and Supplement the Transcript Pursuant to Pa.R.A.P. 1926.
He alleged that the transcript omitted numerous comments by the trial court.
See Motion to Correct and Supplement the Transcript Pursuant to Pa.R.A.P.
1926, filed 1/2/26. The court denied the motion. See Order, filed 1/28/26.
Husband raises the following questions on appeal:
1. Due Process: Whether the trial court violated [Husband’s]
right to procedural due process by prematurely closing his
testimony, constraining relevant evidence, and requiring
cross-examination before he completed his case-in-chief.
____________________________________________
2 See 18 Pa.C.S.A. §§ 5701-5782.
3 Although not in the certified record, Husband’s Rule 1925(b) statement is in
the reproduced record. Since there is no dispute about the accuracy of the
copy in the reproduced record, we consider it. See Commonwealth v.
Holston, 211 A.3d 1264, 1276 (Pa.Super. 2019) (en banc).
-3-
J-A16004-26
2. Evidentiary Exclusion: Whether the trial court erred in
excluding corroborating contemporaneous video and 911
call recordings, thereby materially impairing [Husband’s]
ability to establish abuse under the PFA Act and depriving
the appellate court of a complete record.
3. Dismissal Based on Court-Created Gaps: Whether the
trial court erred in dismissing [Husband’s] PFA petition
based on evidentiary gaps it created, resulting in inequitable
outcomes favoring [Wife] regarding custody and possession
of the marital residence.
4. Record Integrity: Whether the trial court erred by failing
to rule on [Husband’s] motions under Pa.R.A.P. 1926,
leaving unresolved questions regarding the accuracy,
completeness, and sealing of the record for appellate
review.
Husband’s Br. at 10-11 (emphasis removed).
We review the denial of a PFA petition for an abuse of discretion. See
Kaur v. Singh, 259 A.3d 505, 509 (Pa.Super. 2021). An abuse of discretion
occurs “where the judgment is manifestly unreasonable or where the law is
not applied or where the record shows that the action is a result of partiality,
prejudice, bias, or ill will.” Id. (citation omitted). We “review the evidence of
record in the light most favorable to, and grant all reasonable inferences to,
the party that prevailed before the PFA court.” Goldner on Behalf of K.M. v.
Manigault, 345 A.3d 1212, 1216 (Pa.Super. 2025) (citation omitted).
In his first issue, Husband alleges that the trial court violated his right
to procedural due process. “In determining whether procedural due process
violations have occurred, our standard of review is de novo and our scope of
review is plenary.” Int of K.L., 286 A.3d 1267, 1271 (Pa.Super. 2022).
Procedural due process entails “adequate notice, the opportunity to be heard,
-4-
J-A16004-26
and the chance to defend oneself before a fair and impartial tribunal having
jurisdiction over the case.” Commonwealth v. Turner, 80 A.3d 754, 764
(Pa. 2013). When a party claims a deprivation of procedural due process, we
first determine if “there is a life, liberty, or property interest that the state has
interfered with[.]” Id. We then ask “whether the procedures attendant to that
deprivation were constitutionally sufficient.” Id.
Husband claims the court “interrupted [his] testimony and directed
cross[-]examination to begin before [he] had completed his presentation of
evidence.” Husband’s Br. at 19. He quotes the following portions of the
transcript:
[Husband]: “Your Honor, I didn’t—”
The Court: “No. I’m in the middle of asking a question of
counsel so if you can allow me to finish that, please.” ([N.T.]
at 54).
“We’re going to do things out of order. You’re going to start
cross.” (N.T. 12/3/25 at 57-58).
***
[The Court]: “It is not your turn to continue to testify,
because your testimony is closed at this point.” (Id. at
74)[.] . . .
[Husband]: “Before she cross-examine[d] me, I wasn’t done
presenting all of the evidence that I have.” (Id.)[.]
Id. (some capitalization omitted).
Husband fails to establish any procedural due process violation. He
bases his argument on statements in isolation. When viewed in context, it is
plain that no violation occurred. Before the court stated that it was speaking
-5-
J-A16004-26
to Wife’s counsel, the court inquired with Husband about what form of child
custody he would be requesting. See N.T. at 48-51. The court then asked
Husband if he had shared his exhibits with Wife’s counsel, and he responded
that he had not. Id. at 51. The court went to recess to allow Husband to do
so. Id. at 51-52. When the court returned, it asked counsel if she had any
objections to the exhibits. It was during the court’s discussion with Wife’s
counsel about objections to the exhibits that Husband started speaking, and
the court interrupted Husband and explained that it was speaking with
counsel.
The Court: What is your position regarding utilizing a cell
phone video in the proceeding?
[Counsel]: I’m not sure that the first video is relevant. It’s
the recording of his work meeting. I wouldn’t object to him
showing it to the Court, necessarily, because I don’t think it
shows anything.
The Court: Okay.
[Counsel]: But I don’t think it demonstrates exactly what he
thinks.
The Court: Did you see the second one at all?
[Counsel]: I only saw the very first moment of it. I’m sorry.
The Court: Go ahead and show it to her while I’m right
there. I’ll just note for the record [Husband is] pulling his
phone out for the video.
(Video playing.)
[Counsel]: She didn’t lock the door.
[Husband]: She did.
The Court: Don’t argue about the evidence. I’m only
wanting you to look at it, Counsel.
-6-
J-A16004-26
[Counsel]: I’m sorry.
The Court: So that you can formulate if you have any
objections. So I’m going to ask you again to turn your phone
off. You don’t have to shut it all the way down, just make
sure it’s silent.
[Husband]: Your Honor, I didn’t - -
The Court: No, I’m in the middle of asking a question
of counsel, so if you can allow me to finish that,
please.
[Husband]: All right.
Id. at 53-54 (emphasis added).
Next, when the court spoke of doing “things out of order,” it was in
reference to the admission of the video evidence for the court’s viewing. See
id. at 57.
[Counsel]: I don’t have any evidentiary objection to the
video.
The Court: Okay. I just have the problem with - - if you
don’t object then I guess it could come in. I’m just
concerned that you need to cross-examine him.
[Counsel]: Right.
The Court: You may be calling your client, I don’t know. But
we can try to get both videos up on the screen. So that’s a
process. Why don’t we do this. We’re going to do things
out of order.
You’re going to start cross and then [the court] will work on
the video, on our end of the videos. So go ahead counsel.
Id. at 56-57 (emphasis added).
Additionally, immediately after Husband informed the court that he
“wasn’t done presenting all of the evidence,” the court asked, “What other
evidence do you have?” Id. at 74. Husband stated that he had another video,
-7-
J-A16004-26
and the court asked Husband to write a list of all the other evidence he wished
to present. Id. at 75. Husband did so and after reviewing the list, he told the
court that he was resting his case. Id. at 79. The court responded, “I want
you to take a moment, look at the papers in front of you, look at your list and
see if there’s anything else that you think, to the best of your ability if you
understand the Rules of Evidence, that might be relevant.” Id. Husband
reviewed the list and again stated, “I will rest at this point, Your Honor.” Id.
The court inquired a final time whether Husband wished to rest his case, and
he replied, “Yes, ma’am.” Id. at 80-81. This claim lacks merit.
We recently addressed whether a court’s interruptions during a hearing
amounted to a due process violation in Interest of J.H., --- A.3d ---, 2026
WL 2168099, at *5 (Pa.Super. filed July 23, 2026). J.H. had absconded while
on interim probation. Once J.H. was apprehended, the court held a hearing.
During the hearing, the court questioned J.H. about his whereabouts but
continually interrupted J.H. when he was attempting to respond to the court’s
questioning. The court also did not permit the juvenile’s counsel to question
the probation officer who testified about J.H. absconding and did not permit
the juvenile’s counsel to present evidence or make an argument on behalf of
J.H. The court adjudicated J.H. delinquent, and J.H. appealed to this Court.
On appeal, J.H. claimed that the court violated his due process rights.
We agreed and vacated the adjudication. We noted that the court failed to
allow J.H. to call his own witnesses, failed to permit cross-examination of
witnesses, and did not permit J.H. to answer in response to the court’s
-8-
J-A16004-26
questioning. Id. at *5-6. We also noted that although juvenile proceedings
are less formal than adult criminal proceedings, the right to due process
nonetheless applies and “demands that parties be permitted to question
witnesses, and witnesses be permitted to answer questions unless those
questions or answers are legally objectionable.” Id. at *6.
Unlike in J.H., in the instant case, the trial court provided ample
opportunity for Husband to be heard and to present his testimony and
evidence within the confines of Pennsylvania law. Husband’s claim is meritless.
Cf. In the Interest of K.B., 331 A.3d 50, 62 (Pa.Super. 2025) (per curiam)
(concluding trial court violated Department of Human Services’ right to due
process during dependency hearing, when court excluded relevant evidence
regarding mother’s ability to care for minor and told counsel for minor and
mother that cross-examination was not needed).
Next, Husband argues that the court erred in excluding the cell phone
video footage and 911 recording. Husband maintains that both pieces of
evidence were “highly probative.” Husband’s Br. at 22. He argues that the 911
call was admissible under the present sense impression or excited utterance
exceptions to the hearsay rule. See id. (citing Pa.R.E. 803(1), (2)). He also
argues that the “bathroom video was offered to document whether [Wife]
physically blocked [Husband’s] exit, which was central to the abuse
allegations.” Id.
The admission or exclusion of evidence is within the discretion of the
trial court, and this Court will not reverse the decision of the court absent an
-9-
J-A16004-26
abuse of discretion. Commonwealth v. Smith, 47 A.3d 862, 865 (Pa.Super.
2012).
To the extent Husband argues that the 911 recording was admissible
under the aforementioned hearsay exceptions, this argument is waived
because he did not raise either exception before the trial court. Id. at 866
(stating “In order to preserve application of a hearsay exception for appellate
review, that specific exception must first be raised before the trial court”).
Regarding the video evidence, the court determined that Wife did not
give consent to being recorded, and the admission of the video would be in
violation of the Wiretap Act. See N.T. at 78-79.
“In general, the Wiretap Act prohibits the interception, disclosure or use
of any wire, electronic or oral communication,” unless an exception applies.
Commonwealth v. Byrd, 235 A.3d 311, 319 (Pa. 2020) (citation and internal
quotation marks omitted); see 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 5704. One such exception is
“where all parties to the communication have given prior consent to such
interception.” 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 5704(4). The Wiretap Act defines “[o]ral
communication” as “oral communication uttered by a person possessing an
expectation that such communication is not subject to interception under
circumstances justifying such expectation.” 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 5702. It further
provides that “no person shall disclose the contents of any wire, electronic or
oral communication, or evidence derived therefrom, in any proceeding in any
court, board or agency of this Commonwealth.” 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 5721.1(a)(1).
- 10 -
J-A16004-26
Under the Wiretap Act, the question is “whether the speaker had a
specific expectation that the contents of the discussion would not be
intercepted, and whether that expectation was justifiable under the existing
circumstances.” Agnew v. Dupler, 717 A.2d 519, 523 (Pa. 1998). It is settled
that a person in their home has a reasonable expectation of privacy. See
Commonwealth v. Kurtz, 348 A.3d 133, 141 (Pa. 2025) (stating “[t]he
home stands as the most essential bastion of privacy recognized by the law”)
(citation and internal quotation marks omitted).
The court committed no error in excluding the video pursuant to the
Wiretap Act. The recording occurred in Husband and Wife’s marital residence,
and there was no testimony that Wife did not live in the residence. Husband
also affirmed that Wife did not give consent to be recorded. Thus, Wife had a
reasonable expectation of privacy, and the unconsented recording of the
incident was inadmissible under the Wiretap Act. Furthermore, Husband did
not raise any exception before the trial court that would allow for the
admission of the recording.
Next, Husband claims that the court’s dismissal of his petition “was
based on a court-created evidentiary gap[.]” Husband’s Br. at 24. He
references his argument that the court “curtailed [his] testimony and excluded
corroborating video recordings[.]” Id. at 23. Having determined that the court
did not err in excluding the recordings and did not limit Husband’s testimony,
we conclude that this claim is meritless.
- 11 -
J-A16004-26
For his final issue, Husband alleges that the court failed to address his
Motion to Correct and Supplement the PFA hearing transcript. Husband
maintains that pursuant to Pa.R.A.P. 1926, the court was required to resolve
what he describes as inaccuracies and omissions in the transcript. In his
Motion to Correct, Husband claimed that the PFA hearing transcript omitted
the court’s laughter; the court’s comment that “This is actually funny”; that
the court stated, “Overruled,” regarding the admission of the 911 recording
although an objection had not been lodged by opposing counsel; the court’s
statement that a paragraph in the PFA was “general language” and “typed into
the form document”; and that the court described Husband’s testimony about
Wife as being in a “bad light” rather than the words “poor light” used in the
transcript. See Motion to Correct at 2-3. Husband notes that he also filed an
Application to Supplement the final PFA hearing transcript, but the court
denied his request, citing the local court policy that does not permit litigants
access to audio recordings of court proceedings. He maintains that the court’s
ruling “is incompatible with Rule 1926” and “the court effectively refused to
perform the function mandated by Rule 1926.” Husband’s Br. at 26. He argues
that “[d]enying access to the audio recording while requiring reliance on a
potentially incomplete transcript effectively deprives litigants of any
meaningful mechanism to challenge record inaccuracies.” Id.
Rule 1926 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Appellate Procedure governs the
correction or modification of the record. It states:
- 12 -
J-A16004-26
(a) If any difference arises as to whether the record truly
discloses what occurred in the trial court, the
difference shall be submitted to and settled by that
court after notice to the parties and opportunity for
objection, and the record made to conform to the
truth.
(b) If anything material to a party is omitted from the
record by error, breakdown in processes of the court,
or accident or is misstated therein, the omission or
misstatement may be corrected by the following
means:
(1) by the trial court or the appellate court upon
application or on its own initiative at any time;
in the event of correction or modification by the
trial court, that court shall direct that a
supplemental record be certified and
transmitted if necessary; or
(2) by the parties by stipulation filed in the trial
court, in which case, if the trial court clerk has
already certified the record, the parties shall file
in the appellate court a copy of any stipulation
filed pursuant to this rule, and the trial court
clerk shall certify and transmit as a
supplemental record the materials described in
the stipulation.
(c) The trial court clerk shall transmit any supplemental
record required by this rule within 14 days of the order
or stipulation that requires it.
(d) All other questions as to the form and content of the
record shall be presented to the appellate court.
Pa.R.A.P. 1926.
Husband’s claim is meritless. In the case of a “difference” “as to whether
the record truly discloses what occurred in the trial court,” Rule 1926 requires
the difference to be “submitted to and settled by that court after notice to the
parties and opportunity for objection[.]” Id. at 1926(a). For omissions to the
- 13 -
J-A16004-26
record caused by error, breakdown in the processes of the court, accident or
misstatements, the errors may be corrected “by the trial court . . . upon
application or on its own initiative at any time[.]” Id. at 1926(b)(1).
Here, the court, upon Husband’s motion, followed the strictures of Rule
1926. It provided notice to the parties and gave opportunity for objection. It
also reviewed the record and “determined that no apparent discrepancies,
omissions, or misstatements exist.” Order of Court, filed 1/14/26. The court’s
findings are supported by the record, and it committed no error.
Furthermore, the local policy is not inconsistent with Rule 1926.
Certainly, it states that digital audio files “are strictly for transcription aid” and
“shall not be disclosed . . . to attorneys, parties, participants, or the public.”
County Recording Protocol at 2. However, it has a safety-valve provision that
permits a litigant “[f]or good cause shown, . . . [to] petition the presiding
judge for the disclosure of a digital audio file for the purpose of challenging
the accuracy of a transcription.” Id. (emphasis added). The policy is not
inconsistent with Rule 1926 because it permits a litigant to petition the
presiding judge for disclosure of the recordings of hearings. Husband did not
avail himself of this procedure. No relief is due. See Commonwealth v.
Szakal, 50 A.3d 210, 216-17 (Pa.Super. 2012) (citation omitted) (rejecting
appellant’s claim of entitlement to audio recording of hearing where appellant
failed to obtain relief from trial court under Pa.R.A.P. 1922 or Pa.R.A.P. 1926
and determining that “meaningful review” of appellant’s issues was not
precluded by lack of audio recording because court had access to transcript
- 14 -
J-A16004-26
and counsel’s claimed omissions were not “material alterations to or
elimination of any witness testimony”).
Order affirmed.
DATE: 11/16/2026
- 15 -