Full Opinion

STATE OF LOUISIANA COURT OF APPEAL FIRST CIRCUIT 2026 -CA -0494 DARRELL BERRY, PRO SE, CONSTANCE LAFAYETTE, PRO SE VERSUS WELLS FARGO BANK, NA; MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATION SYSTEM, (MERS); LSF 10 MORTGAGE HOLDINGS, LLC, DEAN MORRIS, L.L. C., CANDANCE A. COURTEAU, SPECIALIZED LOAN SERVICING, hf LLC ( SLS), U.S. BANK TRUST NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRUSTEE FOR LSF 10 MASTER PARTICIPATION TRUST, FAY SERVICING LLC, CALIBER HOME LOANS INC., DOES I THROUGH 100 INCLUSIVE, ET AL. Judgment Rendered: NOV 20 2026 Appealed from the Nineteenth Judicial District Court In and for the Parish of East Baton Rouge State of Louisiana Case No. C724405 Honorable Beau M. Higginbotham, Judge Presiding Darrell Berry and Constance Lafayette In Proper Person Baton Rouge, Louisiana Christopher D. Meyer Counsel for Defendant Jackson, Mississippi Wells Fargo Bank N. A. Elizabeth Crowell Price Counsel for Defendants John C. Morris, III Dean Morris, L.L.C. and Candace A. Monroe, Louisiana Courteau Eric J. Simonson Counsel for Defendant/Appellee Laura C. Cannon Specialized Loan Servicing, LLC New Orleans, Louisiana Peyton C. Lambert Counsel for Defendants New Orleans, Louisiana LSF 10 Mortgage Holdings, LLC; U. S. Bank Trust National Association as Trustee for LSF 10 Master Participation Trust; Fay Servicing LLC; Mortgage Electronic Registration System, Inc. ( MERS); Caliber Home Loans, Inc. BEFORE: PENZATO, LANIER, AND FIELDS, JJ. LANIER, J. In this matter, pro se plaintiffs/ appellants, Darrell Berry and Constance Lafayette (" plaintiffs"), appeal the district court' s July 1, 2024 judgment granting the peremptory exception raising the objection of res judicata filed by the defendant/ appellee, Specialized Loan Servicing, LLC (" Specialized Loan"), and dismissing all claims against it, while also continuing without date Specialized Loan' s other peremptory exceptions raising objections of no cause of action, prescription, and peremption. For the following reasons, we affirm the judgment in part as to the exception raising the objection of res judicata, and we amend in part to dismiss the remaining exceptions as moot. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY This matter originated when plaintiffs borrowed a sum of money and executed a promissory note that was secured by a mortgage encumbering their property on December 27, 2005. Plaintiffs defaulted, and in 2017 Wells Fargo instituted an executory process suit in the 19" Judicial District Court, Suit No. 656991, seeking the seizure and sale of the property. The district court issued an order authorizing executory process and a writ of seizure and sale. Subsequently, plaintiffs filed a separate suit in the 19th Judicial District Court, Suit No. 672792, that was removed to the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana, Berry v. LoanCity, 489 F. Supp. 3d 441, 444 ( M.D. La. 2020) Berry T'). They named LoanCity; Wells Fargo; Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (" Freddie Mac"); Freddie Mac Multiclass Certificates, Series 3113 Trust, Mortgage Electronic Registration System (" MERS"); and John Does 1- 100 as defendants. Plaintiffs asserted the following causes of action: lack of standing/wrongful foreclosure, unconscionable contract, breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, quiet title, slander of title, injunctive relief, and declaratory relief. Plaintiffs were given an opportunity to amend their petition, and they ON replicated their prior petition while also adding claims that: ( 1) Wells Fargo falsely told the district court it had riot foreclosed, and ( 2) the mortgage and note were cancelled; thus, any assignment was null and void. The federal district court dismissed the claims against Wells Fargo and the Freddie Mac defendants with prejudice, and the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal affirmed Berry I's dismissal of the Wells Fargo and the Freddie Mac defendants. Berry v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 20- 306705 21- 30060, 2022 WL 728969 ( 5th Cir. 3/ 10/ 22) ( per curiam). The U.S. Supreme Court also denied certiorari. Berry v. Wells Fargo Bank, NA., 143 S. Ct. 2585, 216 L.Ed.2d 1194 ( 2023). After Berry I's dismissal was affirmed, plaintiffs filed this suit in the 19" Judicial District Court, Suit No. 724405 (" Berry If'), and named the following defendants: Wells Fargo, NERS, LLC; Caliber Home Loans, Inc.; Fay Servicing, LLC; LSF 10 Mortgage Holdings, LLC; U.S. Bank Trust National Association as Trustee for LSF 10 Master Participation Trust; Specialized Loan; Candance A. Courteau; and Dean Morris, LLC. Plaintiffs alleged the defendants have no interest in the mortgage or note because they first acquired the property through a promissory note and mortgage issued by Equifirst that was cancelled without transferring it. They asserted claims for lack of standing/wrongful foreclosure, breach of fiduciary duty, quiet title, unconscionability of contract, injunctive relief, declaratory judgment, unfair and deceptive practices in unauthorized collections, abandoned executory process, unfair and deceptive consumer practices as to loan servicing, and fraud. Wells Fargo and NMRS were defendants in Berry 1, and Specialized Loan was added in Berry 11. Specialized Loan was assigned the loan by Wells Fargo in 2018 according to the federal district court, but plaintiffs claim this assignment was false. Unlike Berry 1, however, plaintiffs now allege facts specific to the executory 3 proceeding, attach the foreclosure judgment, and seek declaratory and injunctive relief as to the foreclosure judgment. Defendants removed Berry 11 to federal court, but it was remanded to the state court where several defendants filed exceptions, and the state district court allowed plaintiffs to file an amended petition that largely duplicated their original petition in Berry 11. Plaintiffs added several claims related to the 2017 foreclosure that challenged the various lenders/ servicers' standing under the note and mortgage. In response, pertinent to this appeal, Specialized Loan filed peremptory exceptions raising the objections of no cause of action, res judicata ( based on Berry P, and prescription. A hearing was held on May 13, 2024, and the district court rendered the following judgment on July 1, 2024: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that the Peremptory Exception of Res Judicata filed by Specialized Loan Servicing, LLC is GRANTED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that all claims against Specialized Loan Servicing, LLC in the above -numbered and entitled proceeding are hereby DISMISSED from the docket of the Court WITH PREJUDICE. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that the Peremptory Exception of No Cause of Action, Exception of Prescription, and Exception of Peremption filed by Specialized Loan Servicing, LLC are CONTINUED WITHOUT DATE. Plaintiffs timely appealed. In conjunction with this appeal, plaintiffs filed the following motions: Motion to Stay Appellate Proceedings Pending Supervisory Review"; " Notice of Supreme Court Mandamus Proceeding and Renewed Request for Stay of Proceedings"; " Motion to Vacate and Strike Briefing Schedule for Lack of Jurisdiction"; " Motion for Judicial Notice of Absence of Lodged Appellate Record"; and " Motion to Dismiss Appeal for Lack of Appellate Jurisdiction ( Filed 0 Under Protest)." We have considered plaintiffs' motions and find they all lack merit; thus, they are denied. DISCUSSION Procedural Issues Plaintiffs first note their appellant brief is filed under protest to prevent abandonment, and they do not submit to this court' s jurisdiction. They maintain that appellate jurisdiction has not attached because the appellate record in Suit No. 656991 ( the foreclosure proceeding) has not been lodged in this court. In sum, plaintiffs ask this court to determine appellate jurisdiction has not attached and dismiss the appeal for lack ofjurisdiction. Alternatively, they ask that all proceedings be stayed pending resolution of the jurisdictional matter by the Louisiana Supreme Court; or alternatively, decline to proceed until the missing appellate record is lodged. Contrarily, Specialized Loan argues this court has jurisdiction, and plaintiffs abandoned their claims on the merits by failing to brief them. Regarding this court' s jurisdiction, the judgment on appeal here arose in Suit No. 724405 ( plaintiffs' petition alleging defendants had no right to foreclose), and the record from this case has been lodged with this court. Plaintiffs maintain, however, that the record for Suit No. 656991 ( executory foreclosure proceeding) should have been lodged as well. We find that the two matters are separate and, by plaintiffs' own admission, have never been consolidated; thus, the record on appeal before us is complete. As to plaintiffs' application for a writ of mandamus before the Louisiana Supreme Court asking that it order the 19' Judicial District Clerk to lodge the record from Suit No. 656991 with this court, such a filing does not divest this court of jurisdiction over this appeal. See Metro Riverboat Associates, Inc. v. Louisiana Gaming Control Bd., 1999- 2241 ( La. App. 1st Cir. 3/ 7/ 01), 798 So.2d 143, 148, E writ denied, 2001- 0818 ( La. 1/ 4/ 02), 805 So. 2d 1188 ( explaining that a " writ of mandamus is a separate and distinct remedy" from an appeal). Further, we note the Louisiana Supreme Court denied that writ application. Berry v. Wells Fargo Bank, NA, 2026- 00525 ( La. 9/ 16/ 26), 436 So. 3d 1263. As to abandonment, Specialized Loan argues the issue before us is whether the district court properly granted its exception raising the objection of res judicata, but plaintiffs did not address the merits; thus, they abandoned their position. The Uniform Rules of Louisiana Courts of Appeal, Rule 2- 12. 4( B)( 4), provides that "[ a] ll assignments of error and issues for review shall be briefed. The court may deem as abandoned any assignment of error or issue for review which has not been briefed." This court has found that assignments of error neither briefed nor argued are abandoned. See State v. Gordon, 2004- 0633 ( La. App. 1st Cir. 10/ 29/ 04), 896 So. 2d 1053, 1065, writ denied, 2004- 3144 ( La. 4/ 1/ 05), 897 So. 2d 600; Deubler v. Bogalusa City Schools, 2018- 0312 ( La. App. 1st Cir. 9/ 21/ 18), 262 So. 3d 393, 401. Regarding pro se briefs, however, this court reads such filings " indulgently and attempts to construe briefs as though assignments of error were properly raised." Brown v. Terrebonne Parish Sheriff's Office, 2017- 1305 ( La. App. 1st Cir. 4/ 13/ 18), 249 So. 3d 864, 869 n. 7. Reading plaintiffs' brief "indulgently," we find they addressed the merits of the res judicata exception, although they did so tangentially. Plaintiffs spent the bulk of their brief arguing that it was a " protective" brief filed " under protest and does not constitute submission to the jurisdiction of this court" because appellate jurisdiction had not attached due to the failure to lodge the record from Suit No. 656991. Nevertheless, plaintiffs argued in the alternative that if this court ruled on the merits, the district court should be reversed; thus, they did not abandon their argument. Co Res Judicata As to the merits regarding res judicata, Louisiana Revised Statutes 13: 4231 provides: Except as otherwise provided by law, a valid and final judgment is conclusive between the same parties, except on appeal or other direct review, to the following extent: 1) If the judgment is in favor of the plaintiff, all causes of action existing at the time of final judgment arising out of the transaction or occurrence that is the subject matter of the litigation are extinguished and merged in the judgment. 2) If the judgment is in favor of the defendant, all causes of action existing at the time of final judgment arising out of the transaction or occurrence that is the subject matter of the litigation are extinguished and the judgment bars a subsequent action on those causes of action. 3) A judgment in favor of either the plaintiff or the defendant is conclusive, in any subsequent action between them, with respect to any issue actually litigated and determined if its determination was essential to that judgment. The central question is " whether the second action asserts a cause of action that arises out of the transaction or occurrence that was the subject matter of the first action." Slaughter v. Louisiana State Employees' Retirement System, 2023- 1168 ( La. App. 1st Cir. 10/ 11/ 24), 405 So. 3d 879, 884. The following elements must be satisfied in order for res judicata to preclude a second action: ( 1) the judgment is valid; ( 2) the judgment is final; ( 3) the parties are the same; ( 4) the cause( s) of action asserted in the second suit existed at the time of final judgment in the first litigation; and ( 5) the cause( s) of action asserted in the second suit arose out of the transaction or occurrence that was the subject matter of the first litigation. Id. The burden of proving these facts is on the party asserting res judicata, and if any doubt exists as to its application, the objection must be overruled and the second lawsuit maintained. Id. When an exception raising the objection of res judicata is asserted before the case is submitted and evidence is received, the standard of review on appeal is traditionally manifest error. State ex rel. Tureau v. BEPCO, L.P., 2020- 0595 ( La. N App. 1st Cir. 10/ 7/ 21), 330 So. 3d 1107, 1111, writ denied, 2021- 01773 ( La. 3/ 14/ 23), 357 So. 3d 829. However, the res judicata effect of a prior judgment is a question of law that is reviewed de novo. Id. Plaintiffs argue the executory foreclosure judgment was rendered without filing the required authentic evidence. Thus, they maintain the district court should be reversed because the foreclosure judgment in Suit No. 656991 is fatally defective and subsequent enforcement actions are improper. Contrarily, Specialized Loan argues the district court properly granted the exception because plaintiffs' claims could have been resolved in a prior final judgment issued in Berry I by the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana and upheld by the U.S. Fifth Circuit. First, we find the Berry Ijudgment is valid. A judgment is valid if rendered by a court with jurisdiction over the subject matter and parties, and the parties had proper notice. Burguieres v. Pollingue, 2002- 1385 ( La. 2/ 25/ 03), 843 So. 2d 1049, 1053. The U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana had subject matter jurisdiction in Berry I through diversity jurisdiction, as confirmed by the U.S. Fifth Circuit, and plaintiffs received notice; thus, the judgment was valid. Berry v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 20- 30670, 21- 30060, 2022 WL 728969, * 2 ( 5th Cir. 3/ 10/ 22) ( per curiam), cert. denied, 143 S. Ct. 2585, 216 L.Ed.2d 1194 ( 2023). Next, the Berry I judgment was final. A valid judgment disposes of the merits in whole or in part. Burguieres, 843 So.2d at 1053. Berry I dismissed the claims asserted against all defendants with prejudice. Berry, 489 F. Supp. 3d at 444. Specialized Loan argues it was in privy with all defendants named because Specialized Loan was assigned the rights and duties of servicers or holders of the same promissory note and mortgage in Berry I. We agree. Parties are considered the " same" when there is an " identity of parties" that exists: M whenever the same parties, their successors, or others appear so long as they share the same quality as parties. A person has the same quality when he or she appears in the same capacity in both suits, or when he or she is in privy to a party in the prior suit. State ex. rel. Guilbeau v. BEPCO, L.P., 2020- 0429 ( La. App. I st Cir. 9/ 20/ 21), 341 So. 3d 1, 9, writ denied, 2022- 00882 ( La. 4/ 4/ 23), 358 So. 3d 854. At the hearing, Further, Berry admitted that " Wells Fargo conveyed it to [ Specialized Loan]." Berry admitted that Specialized Loan was not a party to Berry 1, but he did name Wells Fargo. Further, according to Berry I, Specialized Loan was assigned the loan by Wells Fargo in 2018. Berry, 489 F. Supp.3d at 444 n. 1 The dismissed defendants in Berry I were Wells Fargo, the Freddie Mac Defendants, and MFRS, which previously held or serviced the same note and mortgage at issue in this action. Specialized Loan had also been assigned rights as a servicer of the same note and mortgage; thus, we find Specialized Loan is in privy with those dismissed defendants in Berry L Because there is an identity of parties between the holders and servicers of a mortgage, this element of the res judicata analysis is satisfied. Regarding whether the causes of action asserted in the current suit existed at the time of the Berry I judgment, we find that they did. Plaintiffs now specifically allege facts related to the foreclosure judgment and expressly seek to have the foreclosure judgment reversed, but that judgment was issued in 2017, years before the federal district court' s Berry I judgment. We find that nothing prevented plaintiffs from asserting specific claims related to the foreclosure judgment in Berry -1, therefore, the current causes of action existed at the time of Berry I as well; thus, this element is satisfied. Lastly, we also find that the current causes of action arose out of the same transaction or occurrence that was the subject matter of Berry I. Both Berry I and Berry H invoke claims regarding the servicing of the note and mortgage and the W related foreclosure action. Thus, we find the current lawsuit arises out of the same transaction or occurrence. See Giuffria v. Metro Bank, 99- 0052, ( La. App. 4th Cir. 612/ 99), 735 So.2d 943, writ denied, 99- 2246 ( La. 11/ 5! 99), 750 So. 2d 191. Therefore, because Berry I included a final judgment from a competent court dismissing all defendants in privy with Specialized Loan with prejudice as to causes of actions that arose from the same transaction or occurrence presented in this matter, we find the district court properly sustained Specialized Loan' s exception raising the objection of res judicata. CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, we affirm the district court' s July 1, 2024 judgment in part to the extent it granted the peremptory exception raising the objection of res judicata filed by the defendant, Specialized Loan Servicing, LLC. However, we amend the judgment in part to the extent it passed the remaining exceptions without date, and we dismiss them as moot. We assess all costs of this appeal to the plaintiffs, Darrell Berry and Constance Lafayette. AFFIRMED IN PART AND AMENDED IN PART; MOTION TO STAY APPELLATE PROCEEDINGS PENDING SUPERVISORY REVIEW DENIED; NOTICE OF SUPREME COURT MANDAMUS PROCEEDINGS AND RENEWED REQUEST FOR STAY OF PROCEEDINGS DENIED; MOTION TO VACATE AND STRIKE BRIEFING SCHEDULE FOR LACK OF JURISDICTION DENIED; MOTION FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE OF ABSENCE OF LODGED APPELLATE RECORD DENIED; AND MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL FOR LACK OF APPELLATE JURISDICTION FILED UNDER PROTEST) DENIED. 10