C. Ng v. Dept. of State (OOR)
CourtCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket1498 C.D. 2025
JudgeFizzano Cannon
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Carlos Ng, Jr., :
Petitioner :
:
v. :
:
Department of State (Office of :
Open Records), : No. 1498 C.D. 2025
Respondent : Submitted: October 13, 2026
BEFORE: HONORABLE RENÉE COHN JUBELIRER, President Judge
HONORABLE CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge (P.)
HONORABLE BONNIE BRIGANCE LEADBETTER, Senior Judge
OPINION NOT REPORTED
MEMORANDUM OPINION
BY JUDGE FIZZANO CANNON FILED: November 18, 2026
Carlos Ng, Jr. (Petitioner), pro se, petitions for review of the October
21, 2025 Final Determination of the Office of Open Records (OOR), which held that
the documents requested by Petitioner were not subject to disclosure pursuant to the
noncriminal investigatory exemption under the Right-to-Know Law (RTKL).1 Upon
review, we find that Petitioner has waived all issues on appeal as a result of his
failure to develop any arguments pursuant to Rule 2119(a) of the Pennsylvania Rules
of Appellate Procedure, Pa.R.A.P. 2119(a). Therefore, we affirm the October 21,
2025 Final Determination of the OOR.
I. Background
After Petitioner’s father died in a hospital, Petitioner filed a complaint
with the Pennsylvania Department of State (Department) against four medical
1
Act of February 14, 2008, P.L. 6, 65 P.S. §§ 67.101-67.3104.
licensees, whom the Department decided not to prosecute. Certified Record (C.R.)
at 9 & 15. 2 On August 29, 2025, Petitioner submitted an RTKL request (Request)
to the Department, seeking a “report of [his] father[’s] investigation and the medical
report from the forensic department[’s] findings after reviewing [his] father’s
medical records.” C.R. at 33. The Department partially granted the Request and
provided Petitioner with a responsive closing letter regarding Petitioner’s medical
licensure complaint.3 Id. at 15 & 33. However, the Department withheld responsive
records relating to the Department’s noncriminal investigation of the complaint
pursuant to Section 708(b)(17) of the RTKL.4 Id. at 13; see also 65 P.S.
§ 67.708(b)(17).
Petitioner appealed to the OOR on September 4, 2025, challenging the
Department’s denial and arguing that the forensic investigatory documents were
necessary for Petitioner’s administration of his father’s estate. C.R. at 8-9. The
OOR invited both parties to supplement the record and directed the Department to
2
Certified Record citations are to electronic pagination.
3
The Department redacted personal addresses and email addresses from the closing letter
pursuant to Section 708(b)(1)(ii) and 708(b)(6) of the RTKL, 65 P.S. § 67.708(b)(1)(ii) & (b)(6).
Petitioner does not challenge these redactions on appeal. C.R. at 9.
4
In relevant part, Section 708(b)(17) exempts:
[a] record of an agency relating to a noncriminal investigation,
including:
(i) Complaints submitted to an agency.
(ii) Investigative materials, notes, correspondence and reports.
....
(iv) A record that includes information made confidential by
law.
....
(vi) A record that, if disclosed, would do any of the following:
(A) Reveal the institution, progress or result of an agency
investigation[.]
65 P.S. § 67.708(b)(17).
2
notify the OOR if any third parties had a direct interest in the appeal. Id. at 19. On
September 16, 2025, the Department submitted a position statement and two sworn
declarations authored by both Janelle Hawthorne, J.D., Agency OOR Officer
(Hawthorne), and Shana Walter, Esquire, Deputy Chief Counsel of the Department’s
Prosecution Division (Walter). Id. at 27-34. Hawthorne and Walter each attested
that the forensic medical report and related responsive records pertained to a
noncriminal investigation and that licensure-related complaints and investigations
undertaken by the Department are “confidential and privileged” by law. Id.; see 63
Pa.C.S. § 3109(a)(1) (“All records under [S]ection 708(b)(17) of the [RTKL],
relating to a noncriminal investigation . . . concerning a licensure-related complaint
filed with the Department [ ] shall be confidential and privileged.”). Petitioner did
not submit any additional information for consideration.
On October 21, 2025, the OOR denied Petitioner’s appeal, finding that
the challenged responsive records were exempt under Section 708(b)(17) of the
RTKL, 65 P.S. § 67.708(b)(17). C.R. at 44. Petitioner thereafter filed a timely
appeal with this Court.
II. Issues
Before this Court,5 Petitioner makes several brief assertions regarding
the merits of the instant matter in his statement of questions involved and statement
of the case, which we reproduce verbatim as follows:
1. The Petitioner is just asking for forensic report of my
father’s records.
2. I think there is a possible criminal investigation.
5
This Court’s standard of review under the RTKL is de novo, and we may adopt the
agency’s findings or substitute them with our own. Bowling v. Off. of Open Recs., 75 A.3d 453,
474 (Pa. 2013). Our scope of review is plenary, and we may expand the record through additional
hearings or remand. Id. at 476.
3
3. If the records was review there’s no way they don’t see
what a certified doctor saw in those records.
....
My father’s stay on a hospital went wrong after a biopsy I
was seeking informations on his issues everywhere , I
complaint to the Department of Health , all offices in the
Department [ ]. To have a closed and get answer of my
father stay in the hospital I open the investigation with the
Bureau of Enforcement and Investigation and Prosecuting
Division of the Department [ ]. And they send the report
to the general counsel, which is keeping the thruth hiding.
....
My position on appeal is the same , I need to know what
are does finding , I have my ideas.
Petitioner’s Br. at 5-6 (verbatim) (headings omitted). These assertions standing
alone are insufficient to allow meaningful appellate review, and Petitioner fails to
raise or develop any issues in an argument section of his brief. The Department
argues that Petitioner waived all issues on appeal by failing to provide any
substantive arguments sufficient to permit meaningful appellate review.
Department’s Br. at 13. Petitioner maintains that he did not waive all issues on
appeal because his arguments never changed. Petitioner’s Reply Br. at 6.
III. Discussion
Under Rule 2111(a)(8) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Appellate
Procedure, an appellate brief must have a separate and distinct argument section.
Pa.R.A.P. 2111(a)(8). This argument section “shall be divided into as many parts as
there are questions to be argued; and shall have at the head of each part . . . the
particular point treated therein, followed by such discussion and citation of
authorities as are deemed pertinent.” Pa.R.A.P. 2119(a). Where an appellant fails
to provide any discussion of a claim with citation to relevant legal authority or fails
to develop an issue in “any other meaningful fashion capable of review, that claim
is waived.” Commonwealth v. Johnson, 985 A.2d 915, 924 (Pa. 2009) (holding that
4
an appellant’s single sentence “arguments” failed to provide sufficient discussion
and reasoned development of his claims); see also City of Phila. v. Berman, 863
A.2d 156, 161 n.11 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2004) (noting that arguments raised in the
statement of questions involved section must be developed in the argument portion
of a brief to avoid waiver). While courts may liberally construe materials filed by a
pro se litigant, pro se litigants are subject to the same rules of procedure as
represented litigants and “a court cannot be expected to become a litigant’s counsel
or find more in a written pro se submission than is fairly conveyed in the [brief].”
Marietta v. Fayette Cnty., Pa. (Pa. Cmwlth., No. 338 C.D. 2024, filed Dec. 31, 2025)
(quoting Commonwealth v. Blakeney, 108 A.3d 739, 766 (Pa. 2014)).6
Here, Petitioner briefly reiterates his desire to receive his father’s
forensic medical report and baldly asserts that the Department is “hiding” the truth
regarding the circumstances of his father’s hospitalization. Petitioner’s Br. at 6.
However, Petitioner fails to include an argument section in his brief. Instead,
Petitioner merely attaches to his brief an alleged doctor’s analysis of Petitioner’s
father’s “disastrous medical care” that does not otherwise appear in the record. Id.
at 9. This Court cannot consider material attached to a brief, as such material is not
part of the record before us. See Pa.R.A.P. 1921 (providing that the record on appeal
consists of “[t]he original papers and exhibits filed in the lower court, paper copies
of legal papers filed with the prothonotary by means of electronic filing, the
transcript of proceedings, if any, and a certified copy of the docket entries . . .”);
Dep’t of Pub. Welfare v. Gant, 142 A.3d 964, 992 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2016) (explaining
that this Court may consider “only those facts that have been duly certified in the
record on appeal” and that, “[f]or purposes of appellate review, that which is not part
6
Under Rule 414(a) of the Commonwealth Court’s Internal Operating Procedures,
unreported decisions of the Commonwealth Court issued after January 14, 2008, may be cited for
their persuasive value. 210 Pa. Code § 69.414(a).
5
of the certified record does not exist. Documents attached to a brief as an appendix
or reproduced record may not be considered by an appellate court when they are not
part of the certified record.”) (quoting B.K. v. Dep’t of Pub. Welfare, 36 A.3d 649,
657 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2012) (additional quotation marks omitted)).
Further, Petitioner does not cite to any legal authority or otherwise
develop any issues for this Court to review beyond single-sentence accusations in
his statement of questions involved and statement of the case. This Court has
previously emphasized that it is “neither obliged, nor even particularly equipped, to
develop an argument”7 for a party, particularly where a party’s brief “poses a litany
of rhetorical and hypothetical questions, along with undeveloped arguments that
invite this Court to rule in [his] favor out of sympathy[.]” Skytop Meadow Cmty.
Ass’n, 177 A.3d at 384; see also Browne v. Dep’t of Transp., 843 A.2d 429, 435
(Pa. Cmwlth. 2004) (holding that mere summaries of issues are “insufficient to
constitute the type of argument and discussion envisioned in a brief”); Wert v. Dep’t
of Transp., Bureau of Driver Licensing, 821 A.2d 182, 190 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2003)
(holding that an argument presented in a conclusory fashion, without explanation, is
waived). Because Petitioner failed to sufficiently develop any issues for this Court’s
appellate review, we are left guessing about the basis of Petitioner’s averments.
Accordingly, we are constrained to hold that he waived all issues for consideration
on appeal.8 See Johnson, 985 A.2d at 924; Berman, 863 A.2d at 161 n.11.
7
Skytop Meadow Cmty. Ass’n v. Paige, 177 A.3d 377, 384 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017) (quoting
In re S.T.S., Jr., 76 A.3d 24, 42 (Pa. Super. 2013)).
8
Even if Petitioner had not waived all issues for consideration on appeal, we would still
affirm the Final Determination of the OOR on the merits. The RTKL expressly exempts the
disclosure of records of an agency relating to a noncriminal investigation, including complaints
submitted to an agency and investigative materials, notes, correspondence, and reports. 65
P.S. § 67.708(b)(17)(i)-(ii). Further, licensure-related complaints and investigations undertaken
by the Department are also specifically “confidential and privileged” by law pursuant to Section
6
IV. Conclusion
Based on the foregoing discussion, the October 21, 2025 Final
Determination of the OOR is affirmed.
__________________________________
CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge
3109, 63 Pa.C.S. § 3109(a)(1) (“All records under [S]ection 708(b)(17) of the [RTKL], relating to
a noncriminal investigation . . . concerning a licensure-related complaint filed with the Department
[ ] shall be confidential and privileged.”). Here, Petitioner expressly requests investigatory
documents in connection with his medical malpractice complaint to support the allegations
contained therein. C.R. at 33. However, the Hawthorne and Walter attestations each attest that
the responsive forensic medical report and related records pertained to a licensure-related
complaint and investigation. Id. at 27-34. Because “[t]estimonial affidavits found to be relevant
and credible may provide sufficient evidence in support of a claimed exemption,” the record
supports the OOR’s Final Determination that the responsive records were exempt pursuant to the
noncriminal investigative exemption, 65 P.S. § 67.708(b)(17). McGowan v. Pa. Dep’t of Env’t
Prot., 103 A.3d 374, 381 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2014) (quoting Heavens v. Dep’t of Env’t Prot., 65 A.3d
1069, 1073 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2013)).
7
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Carlos Ng, Jr., :
Petitioner :
:
v. :
:
Department of State (Office of :
Open Records), : No. 1498 C.D. 2025
Respondent :
ORDER
AND NOW, this 18th day of November, 2026, the October 21, 2025
Final Determination of the Office of Open Records is AFFIRMED.
__________________________________
CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge