In re A.A. CA3
CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketC105553
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Filed 11/18/26 In re A.A. CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Yolo)
In re A.A., Persons Coming Under the Juvenile Court C105553
Law.
(Super. Ct. Nos. JV2025-
YOLO COUNTY HEALTH AND HUMAN 0222-1 & JV2025-0222-2)
SERVICES AGENCY,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
R.W. et al.,
Defendants;
A.A. et al.,
Appellants.
Appellants A.A. and A.W. (the minors) appeal from the juvenile court’s order
dismissing their dependency cases over their objection and without allowing them to
present evidence at a jurisdictional hearing. Respondent Yolo County Health and Human
Services Agency (the Agency or Agency) agrees the juvenile court erred. Nonetheless,
the Agency urges this court to find the matter has been mooted by subsequent family law
court proceedings and A.A.’s 18th birthday during the pendency of the appeal. As we
shall explain, we agree that the juvenile court erred and do not find the issue mooted.
Accordingly, we will reverse.
1
I
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In September 2025, the Agency learned A.A.’s home had over 60 rabbits, which
were not consistently cared for and had been permitted to roam free, multiply, chew her
mattress, and defecate throughout the home. Given the unsanitary living conditions,
many rabbits had died and were stored in both the carport freezer and the family’s food
freezer. Further, A.A. complained that several days a week food would not be available
to her because either the food in the home had expired or because there simply was no
food. On those days, father and stepmother provided money to have food delivered.
An Agency social worker visited father’s home on October 1, 2025, and noted
numerous rabbits of various sizes and a pet possum running free around and inside the
home. The furniture and floor were saturated with animal urine and feces, rendering the
furniture unusable, and the wood floor was spongy. Rabbits had burrowed inside
furniture, including the minors’ mattresses. Deceased rabbits were observed inside the
family’s indoor freezer directly below frozen chicken. A.A. reported that her stepmother
made them put the rabbits in the freezer after they died, and some rabbits had been frozen
for up to five years.
Animal control officers responded and discovered 57 dead rabbits in the family’s
food freezer. The officer estimated the number of live rabbits “in the hundreds” and
advised the air in the home was unsafe to breathe given the home’s condition.
Stepmother’s daughter complained of “habitual headaches, nausea, breathing problems,
and feeling overall sick from the rabbits in the home.” Some of the live rabbits had
maggots, and stepmother reported that the family had been taking sick and injured rabbits
to the family vet. Animal control ultimately seized approximately 383 dead animals,
including a snake, 17 cats, two guinea pigs, a possum, two chickens, a bearded dragon, a
skunk, and 358 rabbits.
2
The minors’ mother responded to the home, and father reluctantly agreed that the
minors would stay with her until October 31, 2025, so that father could clean the house
and the Agency could complete its investigation. Father accused the Agency of
“ ‘overkill’ ” and “ ‘overreach’ ” and protested that the minors “ ‘were living a very
normal life.’ ”
In October 2025, the Agency filed a dependency petition alleging the minors were
individuals described by section 300, subdivision (b) of the Welfare and Institutions
Code1 in that the minors were at substantial risk of harm due to “unsafe and unsanitary
conditions in the home” including floors saturated with animal feces and urine from
having over 100 rabbits (some of which were sick and infested with maggots) as well as
over 350 frozen animals in the family’s freezers. Father refused to acknowledge the
dangers associated with these conditions. The minors were temporarily placed in their
mother’s care.
By the detention hearing, father had removed the deceased rabbits, reduced the
live animals to four rabbits, and painted the floors such that the house was “considerably
cleaner than it was before.” He had had primary custody of the minors for five years
through a family law matter in Sacramento. Nonetheless, the Agency continued to seek
removal because father and stepmother did not acknowledge the problems with the
original condition of the home, leading to concerns regarding denial or mental health.
Ultimately, the matter was set for a contested detention hearing.
The Agency’s October 2025 addendum detention report recommended the minors’
detention from father and continued placement with mother. The actual condition of
father’s home was worse than originally understood. For example, the director of animal
control advised the sheer amount of animal urine and feces in the home “posed a
1 Undesignated section references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
3
significant health hazard to anyone breathing the air.” Moreover, while father
represented that he had worked with animal control for years to dispose of the animals,
animal control had no record of such contact and would have cremated the animals for
free. Father also misrepresented the number of rabbits still in his home and said he had
replaced the animal urine soaked, feces stained, chewed mattresses when he had not.
Although father had painted the floors, the ammonia levels likely remained dangerously
high without replacement of the damaged flooring. The minors were also in danger from
the spores found in rabbit urine that can be inhaled and are toxic to humans. Father’s
pressure washing the floor likely aerosolized the toxins. Moreover, several of the rabbits
seized by animal control tested positive for Pasteurella and Zoonotic bacteria, both of
which can be transmitted to humans and live on surfaces. Finally, the four remaining
rabbits still needed to be examined/tested by animal control to confirm they were disease
free and spayed/neutered. Thus, the Agency reported that a return to father would be
premature.
Father submitted on the reports at the contested detention hearing, but intended to
obtain an expert for the jurisdiction hearing, and the juvenile court detained the minors as
recommended.
The Agency’s November 2025 jurisdiction report recommended the juvenile court
sustain the dependency petition with the minors remaining with mother pending
disposition. As of November 14th, father continued in his remediation efforts. The
flooring had been removed down to the subfloor and uninstalled replacement flooring
was present in the home. The family had one undamaged mattress and one heavily
stained mattress that still needed to be replaced. The family’s four remaining rabbits
were being neutered by animal control. Father explained they first obtained two rabbits
in approximately 2019, which they thought were both female. The rabbits began
multiplying in 2020, but the house was kept clean until father’s appendicitis in July 2025.
While father had been previously diagnosed with Autism and ADHD, father and
4
stepmother denied that the situation was caused by mental health issues or that they
intentionally hoarded the animals.
The minors were individually interviewed and confirmed the conditions in the
home had existed for years. A.A. also complained that stepmother had been physically
aggressive and verbally abusive with A.W. A.W. explained this aggression had lessened
when she stopped sticking up for herself. Father had recently punched a hole in a door
while arguing with stepmother concerning his drinking. While A.A. did not want to visit
father or return to his care, A.W. wanted visits. Mother reported father had a history of
alcohol abuse, cutting, and threats to shoot the family, but had been granted primary
custody of the girls in 2020 when mother moved to Auburn without the juvenile court’s
permission.
The juvenile court granted father’s request for a contested jurisdiction and
disposition hearing. The Agency’s disposition report recommended joint custody with
family maintenance for A.W., and as to A.A., reunification services for father and family
maintenance for mother. Father remediated the home conditions leading to the
dependency petition and had maintained a clean home for two months. Nonetheless,
A.A. refused to have contact with father, and parents’ contentious custody issues dating
back nine years urgently needed family therapy. The family had been referred for a
substance abuse and mental health assessment, individual counseling, a children’s mental
health referral, an Alta Regional Center referral, and supervised visitation.
By the time of the contested hearing, however, the Agency had reassessed the case
and made a motion to dismiss the dependency petition given the remediated condition of
the home. In the Agency’s opinion, the remaining concerns about the family did not rise
to a substantial risk of harm to the minors sufficient to justify jurisdiction (§ 300, subd.
(b)). The minors’ counsel objected and requested an evidentiary hearing to better vet
father’s ability to parent and to address remaining concerns impacting the minors’ safety.
Following that hearing, minors’ counsel intended to move to conform the petition to
5
proof. The Agency acknowledged the minors’ right to an evidentiary hearing. Despite
this, the juvenile court ruled it was not proper for the court to take on the Agency’s
executive branch role and force the Agency to bring the case. Accordingly, despite
lingering concerns about the family, the court dismissed the petition, taking the matter off
calendar. The minors timely appealed.
II
DISCUSSION
The parties agree, as do we, that the juvenile court erred in refusing minors’
counsel’s request to present evidence before deciding whether to grant the Agency’s
motion to dismiss.
Except under specified circumstances, California Rules of Court, rule 5.520
(former Cal. Rules of Court, rule 1406) vests a child protective agency with “sole
discretion” over whether to file a dependency petition pursuant to section 300. (Cal.
Rules of Court, rule 5.520(a).) It does not follow, however, that the child protective
agency has the absolute right to dismiss a dependency proceeding once it has been filed.
(Allen M. v. Superior Court (1992) 6 Cal.App.4th 1069, 1071, 1073 (Allen M.).) Rather,
the sufficiency of the evidence in support of a dependency petition presents a legal
question for the court. (Id. at pp. 1073-1074.) As such, “the juvenile court must
determine whether dismissal is in the interests of justice and the welfare of the minor.”
(Id. at pp. 1071, 1074.)
Moreover, as part of those proceedings, a minor has the right to present evidence
supporting the exercise of dependency jurisdiction. (Allen M., supra, 6 Cal.App.4th at
pp. 1074-1075; In re E.A. (2018) 24 Cal.App.5th 648, 655-656, fn. 5, 665; cf. § 350,
subd. (c) [recognizing the minor’s right to present evidence at the jurisdictional phase
prior to the determination of a motion to dismiss by a parent, guardian, or on the court’s
own motion].) Further, the evidence presented is not limited to the previously alleged
basis for jurisdiction, and the juvenile court may conform the dependency petition
6
according to proof following the hearing. (In re E.A., at pp. 664-665, fn. 10.)
Accordingly, we agree with the parties that the juvenile court erred in refusing minors’
request to present evidence concerning father’s parenting ability and other remaining
issues.2
Furthermore, we are not persuaded by the Agency’s argument that this court
should dismiss this appeal because subsequent family law court proceedings and A.A.’s
18th birthday have mooted the issue. Our decision is limited to the record before the
juvenile court at the time it made the decision appealed from. (Guadalupe A. v. Superior
Court (1991) 234 Cal.App.3d 100, 109.) Moreover, given that A.W.’s dependency case
would remain viable, we need not decide whether the juvenile court has jurisdiction over
A.A. on remand, but do note that the proceedings were initiated before her 18th birthday,
and the juvenile court may, under some circumstances, maintain jurisdiction over a child
up to his or her 21st birthday. (§ 303; Seiser & Kumli, Cal. Juvenile Courts Practice and
Procedure (2026) § 2.81, Part 1, Ch. 2, part II, E.)
2 Given this conclusion, we do not reach A.A.’s argument that her rights to due
process were also violated by the juvenile court’s actions.
7
III
DISPOSITION
The order of dismissal is reversed, and the matter is remanded for further
proceedings consistent with this opinion.
\s\
KRAUSE, J.
We concur:
\s\
MAURO, Acting P. J.
\s\
BOULWARE EURIE, J.
8