In re Ernesto M. CA2/8
CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 17, 2026
DocketB348269
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Filed 11/17/26 In re Ernesto M. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re Ernesto M. et al., Persons B348269
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law.
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP02994A–B)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
D.P.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Stephen C. Marpet, Commissioner. Affirmed.
Caitlin Christian, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant D.P.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Jacklyn K. Louie,
Assistant County Counsel, and Aileen Wong, Principal Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Janette Freeman Cochran, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Minors Ernesto M. and Ana M.
_________________________________
INTRODUCTION
This is an appeal from the juvenile court’s orders at an
18-month permanency review hearing held for minors Ernesto M.
and Ana M. under Welfare and Institutions Code section366.22.1
At that hearing, the juvenile court found that the Los Angeles
County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS)
provided the children’s mother, D.P. (Mother), with reasonable
services, and granted a continuance of the hearing with further
reunification services for Mother. In her appeal, Mother argues
the court erred in finding that she was provided with reasonable
services. In their appeal, the children assert the court erred in
extending Mother’s reunification services beyond the 18-month
period under section 352. We conclude there was substantial
evidence to support the reasonable services finding, and the
juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in granting the
continuance and further reunification services to Mother.
We accordingly affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A portion of the factual and procedural background in this
case is taken from this court’s prior opinion in case No. B343495.
(In re Ernesto M. (May 18, 2026, B343495) [nonpub. opn.].) On
our own motion, we take judicial notice of this opinion. (Evid.
Code, §§ 452, 459.)
1. Section 300 petition
Mother and Francisco M. (Father) are the parents of two
children, Ernesto (a boy born in January 2012) and Ana (a girl
born in May 2015). Mother was previously diagnosed with an
1 Unless otherwise stated, all further undesignated statutory
references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
2
intellectual disability and receives Regional Center services.
Ernesto, who is severely autistic, also receives Regional Center
services and requires assistance with daily activities.
The current matter came to DCFS’s attention in August
2023 after Mother was hospitalized due to methamphetamine
use. Prior to that time, Mother and the children resided with the
paternal grandparents, who assisted Mother with the day-to-day
care of the children. Following her release from the hospital,
Mother began residing in a group home for developmentally
disabled adults while the children remained in the paternal
grandparents’ home.
On September 5, 2023, DCFS filed a section 300 petition for
the children, alleging they were at substantial risk of harm based
on Mother’s substance abuse and Father’s failure to protect the
children from Mother. On March 18, 2024, the juvenile court
sustained the petition as pled and declared the children
dependents of the court under section 300, subdivision (b). The
court removed the children from both Mother and Father, and
ordered that they remain placed with the paternal grandparents
under the supervision of DCFS. The court granted the parents
reunification services, including monitored visitation with the
children. Mother’s case plan consisted of a six-month drug and
alcohol program with weekly on-demand testing, a 12-step
program with a sponsor, a developmentally appropriate
parenting class, and individual counseling to address case issues.
2. June to November 2024 status review reports
On April 9, 2024, the social worker contacted Daisy
Villanueva, Mother’s Regional Center service coordinator, to
inquire what support the Regional Center could provide to assist
Mother in completing her court-ordered case plan. The following
3
day, Villanueva advised the social worker that she contacted
Shields for Families and confirmed that Mother was on their
waiting list for therapy. Villanueva noted that she also offered
Mother referrals for substance abuse programs and parenting
classes, but Mother declined to participate. Villanueva planned
to contact the Regional Center’s START program for assistance in
offering resources to Mother and ensuring that she understood
the case plan.
On April 15, 2024, the social worker met in person with
Mother and members of her support system, which included
Villaneuva, Ricardo Ruiz (the START program clinical team
leader), and Tair Funches (Mother’s group home caregiver).
The social worker provided Mother with a copy of the court’s
orders and reviewed the case plan with her. Mother indicated
that she understood the court’s orders, but did not understand
why she had to complete a substance abuse program or attend a
12-step program because she did not use drugs. Although the
social worker reminded Mother of her recent positive test for
methamphetamine, Mother did not appear to understand.
During the meeting, the social worker also provided Mother with
several referrals for substance abuse programs, counseling
services, and parenting classes. Ruiz and Funches indicated that
they could assist Mother in enrolling in services if she agreed.
On April 29, 2024, Villanueva informed the social worker
that she would be reaching out to Mother to again offer her
services. Villaneuva also reported Mother had been assigned a
therapist at Shields for Families, but despite multiple reminders,
Mother had not responded to the agency’s attempts to schedule
an intake assessment with her.
4
Between April and May 2024, Mother tested negative for
drugs on four occasions, but missed a number of other tests.
On May 17, 2024, the social worker met with Mother about her
compliance with her case plan. Mother indicated that she had
not enrolled in any services because she had been busy cleaning
the house, washing clothes, and visiting the maternal
grandmother. She also stated that she was “done” with drug
testing because she was tired. The social worker again reviewed
the case plan with Mother and provided her with an additional
referral for individual counseling and a parenting class.
On June 10, 2024, the social worker met with Mother and
asked her about her progress with services. Mother replied that
she had not had an opportunity to call any service providers
because she was busy. With Mother’s consent, the social worker
assisted her in calling a substance abuse program to begin the
intake process. During the call, Mother was advised that she
would be contacted within the next week for an initial
assessment and then connected to a program in her area.
On June 16, 2024, Mother showed up outside the paternal
grandparents’ home where she began hitting the windows and
screaming for the children. When the police arrived, Mother
assaulted the responding officer and resisted arrest. Mother
later admitted to the social worker that she was under the
influence of drugs during the incident.
Throughout June 2024, Mother failed to appear for her
on-demand drug tests. During a July 10, 2024 meeting with the
social worker, Mother indicated that she still had not enrolled in
any services, but she could not explain why. When asked about
her missed drug tests, Mother responded that she was busy
visiting the maternal grandmother and cleaning the restroom.
5
During the meeting, the social worker provided Mother with
several additional referrals for a parenting class.
On July 29, 2024, Mother told the social worker that she
had enrolled in a parenting class and substance abuse program,
but could not recall the names of the providers. That same day,
the social worker spoke with Angela Johnson from the VL Open
Hearts program, which was assisting Mother with her services.
According to Johnson, Mother recently began attending an online
parenting class. Johnson sat with Mother during the class and
explained the material to her because Mother would not be able
to comprehend it on her own. Mother had not enrolled in a
substance abuse program, but she had started attending
Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) meetings twice a week accompanied
by Johnson. Mother had not enrolled in any other services.
On August 20, 2024, the social worker met with Mother
about her failure to drug test. Mother replied that she was busy
washing her clothes. She also indicated that she called the
testing line, but did not need to test that day. At the social
worker’s request, Mother demonstrated how she checked whether
she was required to test, and appeared to be able to
independently call the line for drug testing.
In a September 2024 status review report, DCFS informed
the court that Mother was assigned to a new Regional Center
service coordinator, Natalie Yousef, on August 20, 2024. In an
August 2024 e-mail exchange with the DCFS social worker,
Yousef explained that due to Mother’s intellectual disability,
Mother had difficulty retaining information and seemed “a bit
overwhelmed with all that is being asked of her.” However,
Yousef also stated that “[a]s long as [Mother] wants to put in the
work to follow through with the conditions of her DCFS case and
6
ultimately regain custody of her children, we are all supplying
her with the necessary tools and resources to make that happen.”
On August 26, 2024, the social worker assisted Mother with
submitting a referral to a substance abuse program, and Mother
was scheduled for an intake appointment two days later.
Although the social worker provided the appointment
information to Mother as well as to her Regional Center service
coordinator and providers, Mother did not follow through with
enrolling in the program. Additionally, while Mother had been
attending AA meetings since July 2024, she reported that she
had not participated in the meetings because she was not ready
to share. She also continued to miss the majority of her
on-demand drug tests. Mother was attending a parenting class
with the assistance of VL Open Hearts, which provided her with
additional services such as child development resources and
parenting skills workshops. Yet when asked what she learned in
the class and how she would implement those lessons with her
children, Mother was only able to articulate “ ‘not hitting kids, be
good, love each other.’ ” With respect to individual counseling,
Yousef indicated that Mother was linked to mental health
services through the Regional Center, but due to inconsistent
participation, Mother would not be assigned a therapist until she
agreed to ongoing services.
In a last minute information report filed in September
2024, DCFS informed the court that Mother recently tested
positive for cocaine in two on-demand tests. DCFS also reported
that, although Mother attended a screening for a substance abuse
program on September 6, 2024, she failed to appear for her
treatment assessment appointment a few days later. When the
social worker followed up with Mother about the program, she
7
stated that she was not sure if she wanted to participate because
it would require a lot of time and she was busy going out,
washing clothes, and staying home to watch movies. On
September 16, 2024, the juvenile court set a contested six-month
review hearing at Mother’s request.
In its November 2024 status review report, DCFS provided
an update on Mother’s progress with her case plan. In late
September 2024, Mother enrolled in a substance abuse program
consisting of two hours of early intervention services each week.
Mother’s substance abuse counselor did not recommend an
outpatient program for Mother due to her intellectual disability,
and instead determined that the one-on-one support provided by
her current program best suited her abilities. In September
2024, Mother also agreed to participate in individual counseling.
Yousef advised DCFS that the START program would provide a
referral and assist Mother in enrolling in counseling using her
managed care plan. Due to an issue with Mother’s insurance
coverage, she did not begin individual counseling until mid-
November 2024. During this period, Mother continued to attend
AA meetings and an online parenting class with the assistance of
her caregiver from VL Open Hearts. In October 2024, the
facilitator for the parenting class informed DCFS that Mother
might benefit from retaking the class in person because she did
not appear to understand the lessons. However, following a one-
on-one meeting, the facilitator determined that Mother had a fair
understanding of the class material, and provided a letter of
completion for Mother in November 2024.
3. Contested six-month and 12-month review hearing
On November 19, 2024, the juvenile court held a combined
six-month and 12-month review hearing. At the conclusion of the
8
hearing, the juvenile court found that continued jurisdiction over
the children was necessary, and that it would be detrimental to
return the children to the parents’ custody at that time. The
court further found that DCFS provided reasonable services to
the parents. The court terminated reunification services for
Father based on his lack of compliance with his case plan and
ordered continued reunification services for Mother. The court
also ordered DCFS to continue assisting Mother with her
reunification services by providing “ ‘hands on’ ” help with her
programs and visits. The court set a nonappearance progress
hearing for January 2025 to address Mother’s progress with her
case plan.
4. Mother’s prior appeal
Mother filed an appeal in case No. B343495 from the
juvenile court’s orders at the combined six-month and 12-month
review hearing held on November 19, 2024. In that appeal,
Mother argued the juvenile court erred in finding that she was
provided with reasonable services because DCFS failed to make
and implement a reunification plan tailored toward Mother’s
specific needs as a developmentally disabled person. On May 18,
2026, we affirmed the juvenile court’s November 19, 2024 orders,
concluding that substantial evidence supported the finding that
reasonable services were provided to Mother.
5. December 2024 to June 2025 status review reports
In an interim review report filed in December 2024, DCFS
reported that Mother continued to participate in her court-
ordered services, including individual counseling and a substance
abuse program. Due to her intellectual disability, Mother had
difficulty recalling many of the concepts discussed during her
services, but she was receptive to feedback. Mother also
9
consistently attended monitored visitation with the children and
was punctual and prepared for those visits. DCFS observed that
Mother engaged well with Ernesto, and that the child appeared
bonded with Mother as he often sought her attention and
affection. Although Ana seemed happy and comfortable during
the visits, she did not appear to share a bond with Mother, and
Mother only engaged with Ana when prompted by others. In
December 2024, Ana began therapeutic visits with Mother under
the supervision of Dr. Ranney from Sunrise Psychological
Services.
At a January 13, 2025 nonappearance progress hearing, the
juvenile court stopped the weekly drug testing requirement due
to Mother’s intellectual disability, and ordered that Mother was
only required to submit to testing if DCFS suspected that she was
under the influence of drugs or alcohol. The court also ordered
DCFS to continue assisting Mother with her reunification
services.
In a status review report filed in February 2025, DCFS
provided an update on Mother’s progress with her reunification
services. As described by DCFS, Mother was in compliance with
her court-ordered case plan. She completed a substance abuse
program and a parenting program, and continued to attend AA
meetings and individual therapy. However, due to her
intellectual disability, Mother was unable to articulate what she
had learned in those programs. Mother’s therapist reported that
she was direct and repetitive during their sessions to
accommodate Mother’s disability. The therapist also indicated
that she explored what caring for the children meant to Mother,
that were major gaps in Mother’s understanding of what such
care entailed, and that she did not believe Mother fully
10
understood what reunification meant. At a child and family team
meeting held in January 2025, the participants agreed that the
Regional Center would assign a new service coordinator to
Mother, and that DCFS and the coordinator would work together
to review what services were available to the family.
As of February 2025, Mother continued to attend monitored
visits with the children. The social worker reported, however,
that Mother required constant prompting and guidance during
the visits to ensure the children’s needs were met. While Ernesto
was generally happy and engaged during the visits, there were
times when the child would have behavioral outbursts, and in
response, Mother was unable to deescalate the situation and
regulate her own emotions. In addition, even with assistance,
Mother had difficulty caring for Ernesto’s daily needs such as
teeth brushing and nail trimming. While Ana continued to
attend therapeutic visits with Mother, the child disclosed that
she did not look forward to the visits and instead felt forced to
attend. In supervising the visits, Dr. Ranney observed that
Mother appeared to get frustrated because Ana was not
interested in engaging with her, and that Mother often had to be
reminded to change her tone when addressing the child.
Dr. Ranney recommended that the therapeutic visits continue to
help Mother strengthen her parenting skills.
In an interim review report filed in April 2025, DCFS
indicated that Mother continued to participate in individual
therapy and a 12-step program, and maintained consistent
monitored visitation with the children. During weekly visits at
DCFS’s offices, Ernesto was observed to be affectionate with
Mother and bonded to her. In an April 2025 therapeutic visit
with Ana, Mother and the child generally engaged well with each
11
other, but there were times when Mother appeared to daydream
and Ana interacted with the social worker or therapist instead of
Mother. Although Ana also was scheduled to have monitored
family time with Mother after the weekly therapeutic visits, the
child refused to stay for the family visits.
In an April 2025 progress letter about Mother’s individual
counseling, her therapist reported that Mother had completed 16
of 20 sessions. Mother was cooperative, participated fully in her
sessions, and was open to discussion regarding the issues
outlined by the juvenile court.
In an April 2025 letter about the therapeutic visits between
Mother and Ana, Dr. Ranney reported that gradual progress had
been observed as Mother had become more flexible, playful, and
engaging with the child. Both Mother and Ana seemed more
relaxed and joyous in their interactions, and while Ana did not
allow physical affection from Mother, she showed that she was
building trust in their relationship. Dr. Ranney noted that, due
to Mother’s intellectual disability, there were limitations in her
conceptual understanding as she appeared confused at times
during parenting feedback sessions. As a result, the therapist
working with Mother used a gentle, practical, and repetitive
approach when providing feedback. Dr. Ranney further
explained that, although Mother “experiences cognitive deficit,
she continues to approach the provided parenting material with
enthusiasm and willingness to implement.”
In May 2025, Dr. Ranney provided an updated letter on the
therapeutic visits. According to Dr. Ranney, Mother continued to
demonstrate a willingness to try new approaches and incorporate
skills learned in her parenting feedback sessions. Mother used
more positive praise with Ana as well as slowly integrating
12
boundaries into their playtime together. Mother also continued
to allow Ana to take the lead during the visits and to openly
express herself within healthy limits. Ana in turn appeared to be
more relaxed and engaged in her interactions with Mother,
including showing Mother physical affection and concern for her
well-being during a recent visit.
6. Contested 18-month permanency review hearing
Starting on May 20, 2025, the juvenile court held the
18-month permanency review hearing. In addition to admitting
into evidence DCFS’s reports, the court admitted numerous
exhibits offered by Mother. Among other documents, Mother’s
exhibits included: (1) a November 2024 letter of completion for
a parenting education program; (2) a December 2024 certificate of
completion for a drug treatment program; (3) attendance cards
and a May 2025 letter confirming Mother’s participation in a
12-step program; (4) the April 2025 progress letter from Mother’s
therapist about her individual counseling sessions; (5) the April
and May 2025 progress letters from Dr. Ranney about Mother’s
therapeutic visits with Ana; (6) two May 2025 letters from the
Regional Center about services available to the family; and (7) a
2016 Operational Agreement between DCFS and the Regional
Center. During the multi-day hearing, the court also heard
testimony from the DCFS social worker, Mother, and various
individuals involved in providing Regional Center services to
Mother and Ernesto.
Araceli Arriaga, the DCFS social worker, testified that,
during the most recent review period, she had contact with
Mother three to four times a week. Arriaga also had in-person
meetings with Mother once a month during which Arriaga would
review Mother’s case plan with her and make sure that Mother’s
13
calendar listed all of her service appointments and scheduled
visits with the children. In addition, Arriaga had almost daily
contact with members of Mother’s support team, including the
Regional Center, to ensure that “[e]verything that has to do with
Mother is shared with her team.” Early in the case, Arriaga
provided Mother’s Regional Center service coordinator with a
copy of the court-ordered case plan, and as Mother’s coordinators
changed over time, Arriaga communicated with each of them to
review Mother’s services. Arriaga did not refer Mother to
services specifically designed for adults with intellectual
disabilities. However, Arriaga worked with the Regional Center
to coordinate what types of services it could provide to help
Mother with her case plan. Within the past six months, Arriaga
communicated with Mother’s Regional Center service providers
at least once per week. Regional Center staff also participated in
the child and family team meetings that DCFS held for Mother
and the children in January and April 2025. Compared to her
other cases, Arriaga spent more time with Mother and her
support team than average because of the family’s needs.
Arriaga believed an additional period of reunification services
would benefit Mother, but not the children given their need for
permanency.
Mother testified that she never lived on her own with the
children and that the children always lived with the paternal
grandparents. Mother also never had to make medical decisions
for the children. Mother was aware that Ernesto had autism and
that he needed help with activities such as bathing and brushing
his teeth. When asked what she would do if the children were
sick while in her care, Mother indicated that she would give them
medicine, and in an emergency, she would call 911 and take the
14
children to the hospital. Mother testified that she did not know
why she had an open case with DCFS. She admitted that she
used cocaine on one occasion but denied any other drug use.
April Loya, Mother’s current Regional Center service
coordinator, testified that she was assigned to Mother’s case in
January 2025. Mother’s services through the Regional Center
included case management, placement in a group home,
parenting support, and employment assistance. The children
could visit with Mother in the group home but could not reside
there with her. The Regional Center was in the process of
assessing whether Mother could transition to independent living
so that the children could be returned to her care. If Mother
qualified for independent living services, those services could
possibly include 24-hour support. Loya first learned that Mother
was receiving court-ordered reunification services when she was
assigned to Mother’s case.
Elizabeth Guerra, Ernesto’s current Regional Center
service coordinator, testified that she was assigned to Ernesto’s
case in September 2024. Although Guerra had been in contact
with the DCFS social worker, she was not aware that Mother was
attempting to reunify with the children until the January 2025
child and family team meeting. Guerra further testified that one
of the Regional Center services that she recommended for
Ernesto was applied behavior analysis therapy, and that the
child had been on a waitlist for that service since May 2024.
Lizzet Bobadilla, a Regional Center program manager and
Guerra’s supervisor, testified that she was assigned to Ernesto’s
case in May 2024. Bobadilla first had contact with the DCFS
social worker in January 2025, and was informed then that the
goal for the family was reunification. Bobadilla acknowledged,
15
however, that it was possible that Ernesto’s prior service
coordinator was in contact with DCFS. Bobadilla stated that the
services offered to Ernesto might have been different if the
Regional Center had known earlier that Mother was trying to
reunify with the children. When asked how the Regional Center
would service Ernesto’s case differently now that it was aware of
the reunification goal, Bobadilla explained: “We will have a
different set of … planning for both where he’s residing now,
where he will be residing in the future with Mom.… We can start
setting goals and setting plans where we can make sure that
transition is easy for Ernesto and Mother.”
Teodoro Bilbao, the chief of case management at the
Regional Center, testified that he was responsible for placing
Mother in a group home facility. At that time, Bilbao understood
that only Mother needed a placement so he did not look for
housing that would allow the children to live with her. The
Regional Center was in the process of assessing whether Mother
qualified for supported living services that would allow her to
reside in her own apartment. If the children were returned to
her care, Mother also could be eligible for parenting services.
Bilbao estimated that it could take three to six months for
Mother to transition to an independent living situation.
Following the witness testimony, the juvenile court heard
argument from counsel for the parties. Mother’s counsel asked
the court to find that Mother was in compliance with her case
plan, and that DCFS failed to provide her with reasonable
services. Mother’s counsel also requested that the court continue
Mother’s reunification services for an additional six months
under section 352. Counsel for DCFS and counsel for the
children joined in asking the court to find that DCFS provided
16
reasonable services to Mother, and to order that Mother’s
reunification services be terminated.
On July 2, 2025, after taking the matter under submission,
the juvenile court issued its ruling. The court found that DCFS
provided Mother with reasonable services, and that Mother made
substantial progress with her case plan. The court declined to
terminate Mother’s reunification services, and concluded that
there was good cause to continue the 18-month permanency
review hearing under section 352. The court also granted further
reunification services to Mother and ordered DCFS to continue
working with the Regional Center to assist Mother with her case
plan. The court set a subsequent permanency review hearing for
September 23, 2025. In granting the continuance, the court
stated that it was “going to come back in a couple of months to
see what’s happening, see what [the] Regional Center has been
able to provide the family in the meantime so that, hopefully, we
can get this family reunited as soon as possible.”
Both Mother and the children filed an appeal from the
juvenile court’s orders at the 18-month permanency review
hearing.
DISCUSSION
In her appeal, Mother challenges the sufficiency of the
evidence supporting the juvenile court’s finding at the 18-month
review hearing that DCFS provided her with reasonable services.
In their appeal, the children contend the juvenile court abused its
discretion when it extended Mother’s reunification services at
that same hearing under section 352. We conclude the juvenile
court’s reasonable services finding was supported by substantial
evidence. We further conclude the juvenile court acted within its
17
discretion in granting a short continuance of the hearing while
extending Mother’s reunification services under section 352.
1. Reasonable services finding
1.1. Governing law
At the 18-month permanency review hearing, the juvenile
court must “determine by clear and convincing evidence whether
reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or
legal guardian.” (§ 366.22, subd. (a)(3).) If the child is not
returned to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian
at the 18-month review hearing, “and the court finds that
reasonable services have not been provided, … the court shall
extend reunification services for an additional six months” (id.,
subd. (b)(2)(A)) unless it “finds by clear and convincing evidence
based on competent evidence from a mental health professional
that extending the time period for reunification services would be
detrimental to the child” (id., subd. (b)(2)(B)).
“To support a finding that reasonable services were offered
or provided … ‘the record should show that the supervising
agency identified the problems leading to the loss of custody,
offered services designed to remedy those problems, maintained
reasonable contact with the parents during the course of the
service plan, and made reasonable efforts to assist the parents in
areas where compliance proved difficult.’ ” (In re A.G. (2017)
12 Cal.App.5th 994, 1001; accord, In re J.E. (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th
557, 566.) The agency “must make a ‘ “ ‘good faith effort’ ” ’ … to
provide reasonable reunification services in spite of difficulties in
doing so or the prospects of success.” (In re Taylor J. (2014)
223 Cal.App.4th 1446, 1451.) Moreover, “[r]eunification services
should be tailored to the particular needs of the family,” which
includes “accommodat[ing] the special needs of disabled …
18
parents.” (Tracy J. v. Superior Court (2012) 202 Cal.App.4th
1415, 1425–1426.) “The ‘adequacy of reunification plans and the
reasonableness of the [Agency’s] efforts are judged according to
the circumstances of each case.’ ” (Id. at p. 1426.) The standard
is not whether the services “ ‘were the best that might be
provided in an ideal world, but whether the services were
reasonable under the circumstances.’ ” (In re J.E., at p. 566.)
We review the juvenile court’s reasonable services finding for
substantial evidence. (In re J.P. (2017) 14 Cal.App.5th 616, 624.)
1.2. Substantial evidence supported the juvenile
court’s finding that reasonable services were
provided to Mother
In this case, the relevant period for the juvenile court’s
finding that Mother was provided with reasonable services is
from November 19, 2024 (the date of the last finding) through
July 2, 2025 (the date of the challenged finding). (See Serena M.
v. Superior Court (2020) 52 Cal.App.5th 659, 675 [appellate
review of a reasonable services finding is ordinarily “limited to
that period following the last reasonable services finding”].)
The record reflects that, during this review period, DCFS
actively assisted Mother in complying with her court-ordered case
plan. Arriaga, the social worker assigned to the case, had contact
with Mother three to four times per week. In addition, during
their monthly in-person meetings, Arriaga reviewed Mother’s
reunification services and goals with her, and entered into
Mother’s calendar each of her scheduled service appointments
and visits with the children. Arriaga also made sure that any
changes to the schedule were communicated to Mother and
placed on Mother’s calendar. Moreover, Arriaga maintained
frequent, at times daily, contact with Mother’s support team,
19
including her Regional Center providers, to ensure that
“[e]verything that has to do with Mother is shared with her
team.” Each time that the Regional Center assigned a new
service coordinator to Mother, Arriaga made contact with that
individual to review Mother’s reunification services. Arriaga
then worked directly with the service coordinator to determine
what Regional Center services might be available to assist
Mother in complying with her case plan.
On appeal, Mother argues that DCFS made no effort to
assess her needs as a developmentally disabled parent or to
identify services that were tailored to meet those needs. While
Arriaga did not refer Mother to services designed for parents with
intellectual disabilities, she worked with Mother’s support team
to ensure that Mother was enrolled in services that could be
tailored to accommodate her disability. These services included a
substance abuse program that provided one-on-one support and a
parenting education class that allowed for an aide to be present
to explain the material. The therapists assigned to work with
Mother also modified their counseling sessions to accommodate
her disability, such as implementing practical, gentle, and
repetitive techniques to address Mother’s cognitive limitations.
As a result, between November 2024 and July 2025, Mother was
able to make substantial progress with her court-ordered
services. During this period, she completed a substance abuse
program and a parenting education program, and she continued
to attend a 12-step program and individual counseling. In
addition, Mother maintained weekly visitation with the children,
and during the monitored visits, both the social worker and
Mother’s parent support provided her with guidance and
feedback. During this period, Mother also began participating in
20
therapeutic visits with Ana, which included weekly feedback
sessions with the supervising therapist to strengthen Mother’s
parenting skills.
In challenging the reasonable services finding, Mother
claims that DCFS failed to provide her with access to services
that were essential to reunification, such as an updated
psychological evaluation and housing assistance. However, there
is no indication in the record that, as of the 18-month review
hearing, Mother’s counsel asked the juvenile court to order these
services for Mother as part of her reunification plan. With
respect to a psychological evaluation, although Mother’s counsel
repeatedly argued that DCFS was failing to provide services that
accommodated Mother’s intellectual disability, her counsel never
requested an updated psychological evaluation for Mother nor
suggested to the juvenile court that one was necessary to
determine the nature and scope of Mother’s disability or her
service needs.
With respect to housing assistance, the record shows that,
since the start of the case, the Regional Center provided Mother
with housing by placing her in an assisted living facility with
24-hour support. The record further shows that, in May 2025,
shortly before the 18-month review hearing, the Regional Center
reported that Mother was being assessed for supported living
services, which, if approved, could teach her independent living
skills and assist her in transitioning to her own apartment.
However, as of the hearing, the Regional Center still had not
obtained approval for those housing services. Mother contends
that DCFS should have initiated an assessment of her
independent living needs earlier in the case and worked with the
Regional Center to identify and secure the necessary housing for
21
her to assume custody of the children. But as of the 18-month
review hearing, Mother had not yet begun having unmonitored
visits with the children, and DCFS remained concerned that
Mother was unable to adequately supervise the children during
the monitored visits even with parent support. Under these
circumstances, DCFS’s failure to provide Mother with housing
assistance did not preclude the juvenile court from finding that
the services that were provided were reasonable.
Contrary to Mother’s characterization, DCFS did not “just
sit back while the reunification period tolls.” Rather, the totality
of the record demonstrates that DCFS offered Mother services
that accommodated her intellectual disability, maintained
regular contact with Mother and her support team over the
course of the reunification period, and made good faith efforts to
assist Mother in complying with her case plan even where
compliance proved difficult. On this record, the juvenile court’s
finding at the 18-month review hearing that DCFS provided
Mother with reasonable services was supported by substantial
evidence.
2. Continuance of the 18-month review hearing
2.1. Governing law
At the 18-month permanency review hearing, the juvenile
court must order a child returned to the custody of his or her
parent unless it finds that the return of the child will create a
substantial risk of detriment to his or her safety, protection, or
physical or emotional well-being. (§ 366.22, subd. (a)(1).) Subject
to certain statutory exceptions not applicable here, when a child
is not returned to parental custody at the 18-month review
hearing, the court generally must terminate reunification
22
services and order a section 366.26 permanency planning hearing
for the child. (§ 366.22, subd. (a)(3).)
Under section 352, however, the juvenile court has the
discretion to continue the 18-month permanency review hearing
and to extend