Full Opinion

Filed 11/19/26 Mohaddess v. Patel CA3 NOT TO BE PUBLISHED California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115. IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT (Sacramento) SEYED MOHADDESS et al., C104339 Plaintiffs and Respondents, (Super. Ct. No. v. 34202000272959CUCOGDS) HASMUKH PATEL, Defendant and Appellant. Plaintiffs Seyed and Leila Mohaddess (buyers) sued defendant Hasmukh Patel (seller) for breach of contract and specific performance of an agreement to purchase real property at the end of a two-year lease. The trial court held a bench trial and entered judgment in favor of buyers in 2023. The judgment has long been final. Seller appeals from a 2025 minute order, which he asserts constitutes the trial court’s denial of his new trial motion that was filed almost a year and a half after the trial court entered judgment in favor of buyers. We dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction. 1 1 The parties did not specifically brief whether we have jurisdiction under the facts of this case. We need not and did not request supplemental briefing on that question because the issue of appellate jurisdiction is present in every appeal (see Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.204(a)(2)(B) [opening brief must include statement or explanation of appealability]) and thus the protections of Government Code section 68081 are not 1 FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND In November 2017, seller and California Family Home Buyers, LLC (company) entered into a residential lease and option to purchase real estate agreement, wherein seller agreed to sell a house to the company at the end of a two-year lease. A month later, the company entered into a sublease with buyers. With approximately two weeks left on the two-year contract term, the company sent a letter to seller that it was exercising the right to purchase the property; seller refused to sell. The company assigned its right to purchase the property to buyers, who thereafter sent seller a demand for specific performance of the purchase option in the agreement. When seller did not provide a satisfactory response, buyers sued for breach of contract and specific performance. In 2023, the trial court held a bench trial and entered judgment in favor of buyers. The trial court granted buyers’ request for specific performance, requiring seller to sell the property to buyers within a specified timeframe. The judgment provides that if seller fails to comply with the judgment, buyers may seek relief through an order to show cause or an amended judgment directing the clerk of the trial court to execute and deposit into escrow a grant deed that conveys the property to them upon deposit of the purchase price. Seller appealed the judgment to this court in February 2024. Approximately three months later, the appeal was dismissed for failure to file a civil case information statement. Seller’s subsequent motion to reinstate the appeal was also denied. The remittitur was issued on September 19, 2024. 2 implicated. (People v. Alice (2007) 41 Cal.4th 668, 679 [“The parties need only have been given an opportunity to brief the issue decided by the court, and the fact that a party does not address an issue, mode of analysis, or authority that is raised or fairly included within the issues raised does not implicate the protections of [Government Code] section 68081.”].) 2 We take judicial notice of this fact on our own motion. (Evid. Code, § 459, subd. (a) [reviewing court may take judicial notice of any matter specified in Evid. Code, § 452]; id., § 452, subd. (d) [judicial notice may be taken of records of this court].) 2 Seller defied the judgment by failing and refusing to open escrow, sign escrow instructions, or deliver the grant deed transferring the subject property to buyers. Buyers filed a motion to amend the judgment, requesting that the clerk of the trial court execute and deposit the grant deed into escrow. The trial court heard the motion on February 4, 2025. Ten days later, seller filed a motion for reconsideration. Seller argued new facts and evidence were available for the trial court to “reconsider its ruling of February 4, 2025.” 3 The trial court denied the motion for reconsideration later that month. The trial court found that the content of seller’s affidavit was “largely a rehashing of [his] position at trial” and he presented no new evidence or a satisfactory explanation for the failure to produce the evidence earlier. The trial court granted buyers’ motion to amend the judgment on March 19, 2025. In the amended judgment, the trial court appointed the clerk of the trial court as elisor under Code of Civil Procedure 4 section 128, subdivision (a)(4) and directed the clerk to sign the grant deed or quitclaim deed attached to the amended judgment, at the buyers’ discretion. It further imposed other requirements related to the property transfer. The notice of entry of the amended judgment was filed on March 25, 2025, and served by buyers on seller the same day. In April 2025, seller filed a motion for new trial. Seller argued “the judgment is against the weight of the evidence” and the trial “included significant prejudicial misconduct by [two] witnesses.” On May 23, 2025, the trial court held a hearing, which the minute order describes as a hearing on “motion to vacate amended 3 The record does not contain a reporter’s transcript or minute order pertaining to the hearing. 4 Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure. 3 judgment/acceptance of grant deed.” (Boldface omitted.) 5 The minute order states the trial court denied seller’s motion for reconsideration filed in February 2025. 6 The trial court also ordered buyers to submit an amendment to the amended judgment (without providing any further details). The notice of entry of the minute order was filed on May 28, 2025, and served by buyers on seller the same day. The trial court thereafter, on July 15, 2025, filed an amendment to the amended judgment. Therein, the trial court deleted and replaced the grant deed exhibit attached to the amended judgment to comport with the title company’s requirements. On July 28, 2025, seller filed a notice of appeal, indicating that he was appealing from an order entered on May 28, 2025, under section 904.1, subdivision (a)(3)-(13). Seller attached the May 28, 2025 notice of entry of the May 23, 2025 minute order to his notice of appeal. In his civil case information statement, seller stated that he was appealing from the denial of his new trial motion. DISCUSSION 7 Seller’s notice of appeal identifies the May 2025 minute order as the order subject to appeal under section 904.1, subdivision (a)(3)-(13) In his opening brief, however, seller asserts that the appeal is “taken from a final judgment affecting title to real property” under section 904.1, subdivision (a)(1). Seller’s arguments in the opening brief 5 The record does not contain a reporter’s transcript of the hearing. 6 As stated ante, seller’s motion for reconsideration filed in February 2025 was denied later that month. As explained post, seller asserts the trial court intended to deny the motion for new trial instead. 7 After seller filed his opening brief, buyers filed a motion to dismiss and a supporting request for judicial notice. Buyers argue the appeal is moot because the property has been conveyed to them and seller did not seek a stay pending appeal under section 917.4. We deny the motion to dismiss and request for judicial notice because we dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction, as we next explain. 4 appear to pertain solely to purported errors in the 2023 final judgment. Indeed, seller requests that this court reverse the judgment, vacate the order compelling transfer of title, and direct entry of judgment in his favor or alternatively remand for a new trial. We do not reach the merits of seller’s arguments because we lack jurisdiction over this appeal. “The right to appeal is statutory only, and a party may not appeal a trial court’s judgment, order or ruling unless such is expressly made appealable by statute.” (People v. Loper (2015) 60 Cal.4th 1155, 1159.) If an appeal is authorized by statute, the “[j]urisdiction of the Court of Appeal is limited in scope to the notice of appeal and the judgment[, order, or ruling] appealed from.” (Dakota Payphone, LLC v. Alcaraz (2011) 192 Cal.App.4th 493, 504.) We must liberally construe a notice of appeal in favor of its sufficiency (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.100(a)(2)), “ ‘if it is reasonably clear what [the] appellant was trying to appeal from, and where the respondent could not possibly have been misled or prejudiced’ ” (In re Joshua S. (2007) 41 Cal.4th 261, 272, italics added). However, “a notice of appeal will not be considered adequate if it completely omits any reference to the judgment being appealed.” (Shiver, McGrane & Martin v. Littell (1990) 217 Cal.App.3d 1041, 1045.) An appellate court has “no jurisdiction over an order not mentioned in the notice of appeal.” (Faunce v. Cate (2013) 222 Cal.App.4th 166, 170.) Further, “ ‘[i]f a judgment or order is appealable, an aggrieved party must file a timely appeal or forever lose the opportunity to obtain appellate review.’ ” (Norman I. Krug Real Estate Investments, Inc. v. Praszker (1990) 220 Cal.App.3d 35, 46.) “Unless otherwise provided by law, a notice of appeal must be filed on or before the earliest of three dates: (1) 60 days after the court clerk serves a notice of entry of judgment or a file- stamped copy of the judgment on the appealing party, (2) 60 days after the appealing party serves or is served by the opposing party with a notice of entry of judgment, or (3) 180 days after entry of judgment. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.104(a).) ‘If a notice of appeal is filed late, the reviewing court must dismiss the appeal.’ (Id., rule 8.104(b).)” (Torres v. City of San Diego (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th 214, 221-222.) 5 Here, the notice of appeal identified and attached only the May 2025 minute order as the basis for the appeal. Seller specified that the appeal of that order was taken under section 904.1, subdivision (a)(3)-(13). The minute order is not, however, an appealable order under section 904.1, irrespective of whether it constitutes a second and duplicative denial of seller’s February 2025 motion for reconsideration (as stated in the order) or a denial of the new trial motion (as asserted by seller). (See § 1008, subd. (g) [an order denying a motion for reconsideration is not appealable, but may be reviewed on a proper appeal from the order that the trial court refused to reconsider]; Walker v. Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority (2005) 35 Cal.4th 15, 18 [denial of new trial motion not an appealable order but notice of appeal from such order should be treated as “appeal from the underlying judgment” if “ ‘ “it is reasonably clear what appellant was trying to appeal from” ’ and ‘no prejudice would accrue to the respondent’ ”].) We cannot liberally construe the notice of appeal to encompass an appeal of the original judgment or amended judgment because it omits any reference to such judgments (Shiver, McGrane & Martin v. Littell, supra, 217 Cal.App.3d at p. 1045) and an appeal of those judgments would be untimely (Hollister Convalescent Hosp., Inc. v. Rico (1975) 15 Cal.3d 660, 669 [it is a “general and well-established rule that a notice of appeal which specifies a nonappealable order but is timely with respect to an existing appealable order or judgment will be construed to apply to the latter judgment or order”]). The notice of entry of the original judgment was served on seller in December 2023, and the notice of entry of the amended judgment was served on seller on March 25, 2025. The notices triggered the 60-day period in which seller was required to file a notice of appeal under California Rules of Court, rule 8.104(a)(1)(B). The present notice of appeal was filed well beyond the 60-day deadline as to both judgments. We also cannot liberally construe the notice of appeal to encompass an appeal of the amendment to the amended judgment, filed on July 15, 2025, even if such an appeal 6 could be deemed timely. 8 The amendment was filed after entry of the May 2025 minute order and was not identified in the notice of appeal. Nothing in the record indicates that it is reasonably clear seller was trying to appeal from the amendment that deleted and replaced the grant deed exhibit attached to the amended judgment. (In re Joshua S., supra, 41 Cal.4th at p. 272.) Indeed, in his civil case information statement, seller stated that he was appealing from the denial of his new trial motion and the arguments in his opening brief focus solely on purported errors as to the original and final judgment. For the foregoing reasons, we dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction. DISPOSITION The appeal is dismissed. Buyers shall recover their costs on appeal. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.278(a)(1)-(2).) /s/ BOULWARE EURIE, J. We concur: /s/ MAURO, Acting P. J. /s/ MESIWALA, J. 8 In that regard, the amendment to the amended judgment did not reopen the time to appeal the original judgment (that seller attempts to challenge in this appeal) because the original judgment is final. (Torres v. City of San Diego, supra, 154 Cal.App.4th at p. 222 [“ ‘When the trial court amends a nonfinal judgment in a manner amounting to a substantial modification of the judgment (e.g., on motion for new trial or motion to vacate and enter different judgment), the amended judgment supersedes the original and becomes the appealable judgment (there can only be one “final judgment” in an action…).’ ” (first italics added)].) 7