S.J. v. Superior Court CA1/5
CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketA177352
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Filed 11/18/26 S.J. v. Superior Court CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
S.J.,
Petitioner,
v.
THE SUPERIOR COURT OF A177352
ALAMEDA COUNTY,
(Alameda County
Respondent;
Super. Ct. No. JD-038873-01)
ALAMEDA COUNTY AGENCY OF
SOCIAL SERVICES, et al.,
Real Parties in Interest.
Petitioner S.J. (mother) seeks extraordinary writ review (Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 8.452) of a juvenile court order setting a permanency planning
hearing for her child N.J. (minor) under Welfare and Institutions Code
section 366.26.1 Mother contends that the court erred in terminating
reunification services because real party in interest Alameda County Agency
of Social Services (Agency) did not offer or provide reunification services
tailored to her mental health needs. We disagree and deny mother’s petition.
1 All statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code, and
all rule references are to the California Rules of Court.
1
I. BACKGROUND
A. Detention/Jurisdiction/Disposition Proceedings
On January 21, 2025, the Agency filed a section 300, subdivision (b)(1)
juvenile dependency petition (petition) on behalf of minor, then ten-years old.
The petition alleged that earlier that month, mother was placed on a section
5150 hold at a mental health facility “for suicidal ideation and left [five days
later] against medical advice.” The petition further alleged that mother
continued to “exhibit[ ] manic symptoms such as paranoid thoughts . . .,
placing the minor . . . in substantial risk of serious physical and emotional
harm.” The petition also alleged that mother provided an unsafe
environment for minor and failed to provide “proper supervision for the
minor.” More specifically, it described examples of unhealthy conditions in
the home and alleged that mother left minor “without . . . proper supervision
and food when . . . mother is out of the home.” Finally, the petition noted
that minor’s father was deceased and that minor was placed in the care of her
maternal grandparents.
In its detention report, the Agency stated that mother had
“unaddressed mental health issues.” It then described: (1) mother’s threats
of suicide to minor, stating it would be minor’s fault, and harm to the family
pet; (2) demeaning statements made by mother to minor; and (3) mother’s
lack of “proper arrangements for food or supervision for [minor] while
[mother was] intoxicated or out of the home.” The Agency also noted a report
that mother hit minor “on the head with a metal plate” when mother was
“under the influence of alcohol.” The Agency concluded that there was a risk
of emotional and physical harm to minor, that minor would not have her
basic needs met, and that minor could become ill from unhealthy conditions
in the home. The Agency found that minor was in “imminent danger”
2
because of mother’s “untreated mental health needs and . . . history of
substance [ab]use,” her prior hitting of minor, and her prior demeaning
statements to minor.
At the detention hearing, mother entered a general denial. The
juvenile court issued a detention order that removed minor from mother,
finding a prima facie showing was made with the Agency’s report as the
factual basis, and granted supervised visits.
In its February 2025 jurisdiction/disposition report, the Agency
recommended that minor be declared a dependent of the court and that
mother receive reunification services. The report summarized past referrals
that alleged abuse or neglect of minor, conversations with mother, minor and
the maternal grandparents, and mother’s 2022 arrest for driving under the
influence of alcohol. In its initial case plan, the Agency recommended
multiple services. As for mental health services, the Agency recommended
that mother: (1) get evaluated for medication and comply with any
recommendations from that evaluation; (2) participate in individual
counseling to “address the issues” that resulted in the petition; (3) participate
in family therapy sessions with minor; and (4) successfully complete a parent
education course. The case plan also required mother to sign releases so the
Agency could speak with her caregivers. Mother disagreed with these
recommendations and the matter was set for a contested hearing.
Before the hearing, the Agency filed an amended petition, which added
an allegation that mother had substance abuse issues that placed minor “at
substantial risk of serious physical harm,” citing her 2022 DUI arrest. The
Agency also added allegations that mother gave minor alcohol, that minor
received inappropriate discipline while mother was intoxicated, that alcohol
3
and marijuana were left in areas accessible to minor, and that mother did not
arrange for appropriate care of minor when she was intoxicated.
At a disposition hearing, the juvenile court found the allegations in the
amended petition to be true, declared minor a dependent, and adopted the
Agency’s recommendations in its jurisdiction/disposition report. The court
also ordered the Agency to provide reunification services to mother and
minor, who, in turn, were ordered to “participate in all aspects of the case
plan,” including therapeutic or supervised visits. The court highlighted that
reunification services were time limited and would not be provided after
twelve months absent a finding of “a substantial probability that the minor
will be returned within a total of 18 months from the date of removal.” The
Agency filed an updated case plan seven days after the disposition hearing,
which added substance abuse services, including a drug and alcohol
assessment, treatment, and random testing.
B. Six-Month Review
Before the six-month review hearing, the Agency filed a psychological
report with the juvenile court. The report recommended “ongoing medication
evaluation and management by a psychiatrist,” an intensive outpatient
psychiatric treatment plan through mother’s caregiver, psychotherapy, a
twelve-step program for substance abuse, mental health support programs,
and crisis planning through mother’s caregiver.
In its six-month status review report, the Agency recommended that
minor remain a dependent in out-of-home placement and that reunification
services be continued. The report noted that mother’s DUI charges based on
her 2022 arrest were dismissed due to delays in the case. Mother stated that
she was seeing a psychiatrist and regularly taking her medications. But the
Agency did not have “contact information or a release of information” to
4
confirm mother’s statements. The Agency expressed concern about the lack
of “verified information that [mother] has stabilized her mental health.” The
Agency had also received no drug and alcohol testing results at the time of
the report. However, mother’s weekly family therapeutic visits were
reportedly going well. Mother also informed the Agency that she was one
class away from finishing her parenting program. Although mother’s position
on the Agency’s recommendations was “unknown,” the juvenile court set the
matter for a contested hearing.
In an interim report filed before the contested hearing, the Agency
reaffirmed the recommendations in its six-month report but noted that
mother disagreed with them.
In an addendum report filed before the contested hearing, the Agency
reaffirmed its recommendations and mother’s disagreement with them. The
report noted that mother had successfully completed her parenting class.
And in October 2025, the Agency had made a referral for individual therapy.
However, the referral was still active as of November 2025 because mother
had not completed the intake process. In December 2025, mother reported to
the Agency that she was participating in therapy through the BetterHelp
online therapy platform. But the Agency was unable to reach the BetterHelp
therapist to confirm. The Agency also contacted Kaiser Permanente (Kaiser)
and received confirmation that mother was a psychiatry patient since 2019.
But Kaiser told the Agency to contact member services for any additional
information, and the Agency was unable to reach someone in member
services.
As for substance abuse treatment and drug and alcohol testing, the
addendum report stated that mother completed her intake for a substance
abuse treatment program. But the contact person at the program reported a
5
concern about mother’s reluctance to complete testing. In a subsequent
update, that contact person advised the Agency that mother had attended
two virtual group sessions, missed one in-person group session, and refused
to participate in testing. Mother told the Agency that she intended to begin
testing in December 2025 because she was currently addressing medical
issues. In December, the testing location reported that mother tested
positive for marijuana twice.
As for therapeutic visitation, the Agency stated that mother and minor
were “making progress toward rebuilding trust and improving
communication.” The Agency also noted that there was ongoing conflict
between mother and the maternal grandparents, which “pose[d]
complications.” When the Agency spoke with minor in November 2025,
minor reported that she enjoyed visits with mother but did not want to live
with mother at that time due to “past experiences that made her feel
uncomfortable and unsafe.” Minor was, however, open to increased
visitation.
In February 2026, the Agency submitted a second addendum report.
The Agency’s recommendations and mother’s disagreement with them did not
change. But the report provided updates on the Agency’s conversations with
mother’s providers. For example, the Agency spoke with mother’s BetterHelp
therapist, who stated that mother had been receiving therapy services once or
twice a week since November 2025. Mother sought treatment for “anxiety
and depression following [Agency] involvement and separation from her
daughter.” The goals were to reduce mother’s anxiety and depression so she
could better manage daily stressors.
The Agency also spoke with mother’s psychiatrist at Kaiser and
received follow-up correspondence stating that mother had been under their
6
care since 2021, describing mother’s diagnoses, and stating that mother was
taking her prescribed medications.
Mother’s substance abuse treatment program reported that mother was
consistently attending counseling sessions. She was also completing drug
and alcohol tests twice a week and was testing negative for all substances
except her prescribed medications.
The hours of mother’s supervised therapeutic visits with minor had
been reduced out of concern for minor’s homework time and minor’s “self-
report that she would prefer shorter visits.” Minor also reported that she was
not ready for unsupervised visits because she would “not feel emotionally
comfortable.”
After the contested hearing, the juvenile court found “[b]y clear and
convincing evidence [that] reasonable services have been offered or provided.”
The court also noted that mother had made “substantial” progress and
continued her reunification services.
C. 12-Month Review
In its 12-month review report, the Agency recommended terminating
reunification services and setting a section 366.26 hearing to determine a
permanent plan for minor. Mother disagreed with the recommendation.
The report noted that mother stated she was a practicing attorney and
homeowner and could meet minor’s basic needs. The report stated that
mother attempted to falsify a drug and alcohol test by using outside urine in
February 2026. According to the report, mother felt wronged by her parents
and “all her previous [social] workers despite the progress that she has made
thus far.” Minor reported wanting to stop all therapeutic visits because she
could not get her homework done and because she did not like the visits.
Minor also reported that she did not want to live with mother. The Agency
7
expressed concern “that [mother] is unable to accept accountability for her
involvement in [minor’s] removal and her substance [ab]use, thus being
unable to make meaningful changes.” According to the Agency, mother
blamed her parents for her positive marijuana test and the treatment
program for her attempt to use outside urine for a drug test.
On a more positive note, the report stated that mother was
“participating in individual therapy and psychiatric services . . . .” However,
the Agency recommended that mother enroll in a residential treatment
program or intensive outpatient mental health program in light of her
attempt to use outside urine for the February 2026 drug test. To make
referrals to these services, the Agency stated that it needed mother to sign a
release of information. The Agency recommended that minor be permanently
placed with her maternal grandparents.
At the review hearing in March 2026, mother made a Marsden motion,
seeking new counsel, which the juvenile court denied. Mother then made a
Faretta motion to represent herself, which the court granted. The court,
however, ordered that appointed counsel remain available to advise mother.
During the hearing, mother denied that she attempted to falsify her
drug test and stated that she was traumatized by a male staff member who
walked into the restroom during her test. The juvenile court stated that the
issue could be resolved if mother submitted to a hair follicle test but mother
refused on cultural and religious grounds. The court then scheduled a
contested 12-month review hearing.
In April 2026, the juvenile court began the contested 12-month review
hearing. The court admitted into evidence the six-month review report, the
interim and addendum reports, and the 12-month review report. The Agency
rested and mother began calling her witnesses. On the first hearing date, a
8
social worker testified that the Agency recommended terminating
reunification services because mother was not far enough along in addressing
her substance abuse or repairing her relationship with minor, citing minor’s
refusal to attend visits at that time. The court eventually continued the
hearing to June. In response, the Agency stated that it planned to file an 18-
month report.
In its 18-month report, the Agency continued to recommend
terminating reunification services and mother continued to disagree. The
report noted that mother had not participated in testing for substance use
since February 2026. Minor also reported that she no longer wanted to
attend in-person visits with mother because mother was not validating
minor’s feelings, which made minor “emotional and uncomfortable.” As for
mother’s mental health services, the Agency was unable to determine if
mother was continuing to receive therapy or psychological treatment or take
medication because mother declined to sign a release of information.
As for therapeutic and supervised visits, the report stated that mother
would not validate minor’s “experiences and feelings” so “the visits have had
to stop.” After a May 2026 visit, minor reported that she did not want to see
mother in person anymore so they were doing video calls. The report
identified four instances where minor refused to attend a visitation session.
The minor also stated that she did not want to live with mother anymore.
The report expressed concern that mother was “unable to make meaningful
changes” due to her lack of accountability for “her involvement in [minor’s]
removal and her substance use . . . .”
The juvenile court held four additional days of contested hearing. In
addition to testimony from the social worker who first testified in April 2026,
9
the maternal grandfather, another social worker, and the therapist who
attended the therapeutic visits, mother and minor testified.
Mother testified that she was participating in individual therapy.
Minor testified in chambers that she did not want to return to mother. As for
mother’s substance use testing, mother did submit a hair follicle test but the
Agency was unable to verify the results of that test because mother would not
sign a release of information.
On August 7, 2026, the juvenile court terminated reunification services
and set a hearing under section 366.26. The court concluded that returning
minor to mother “would create a substantial detriment to [minor,]
particularly [her] emotional well-being.” In reaching this conclusion, the
court found minor credible and gave “significant weight to her expressed
safety concerns and emotional impact particularly when given the history of
trauma that was found to be true . . . .” The court told mother that she
“repeatedly . . . talked about how [she had] done everything that’s been asked
of [her], and [it] just [didn’t] see that as being the fact” based on her “lack of
progress particularly on [the] substance use disorder [and] testing . . . .” The
court further observed that mother’s arguments were not supported by the
record, and her “refusal . . . to promptly and fully address the sobriety
concerns supports the conclusion . . . that [her] substance use concerns
remain unresolved.” The court did note, however, that it believed that
mother had “continued with therapy” and that mother loved minor.
As for the reasonableness of the reunification services provided to
mother, the juvenile court acknowledged that services “ha[d] not been perfect,
but that’s not what’s required by the law.” The court believed that “the
biggest impediment ha[d] been [mother’s] refusal to meet with the Agency.”
In support, the court cited mother’s failure, since February 2026, to
10
participate in substance use treatment or “to discuss the case plan,” along
with minor’s refusal to attend visits with mother, which the Agency could not
force. The court also observed that mother had not “acknowledged any harm
that was caused” by her actions. The court concluded that the Agency had
“offered reasonable services” to the best of its ability based on the
circumstances presented.
The juvenile court therefore concluded “by clear and convincing
evidence that reasonable services ha[d] been offered or provided.” After
terminating reunification services and setting a section 366.26 hearing on
August 7, 2026, the court reappointed mother’s advisory counsel to represent
her, finding that mother’s self-representation had caused delays that were
not in minor’s best interest. The court then informed mother and her counsel
that to preserve an appeal from the order setting the section 366.26 hearing,
mother had to seek writ relief. The court set the section 366.26 hearing for
December 2, 2026.
On August 17, 2026, mother’s counsel electronically filed a notice of
intent to file a writ petition. Counsel then filed this petition challenging the
juvenile court’s August 7 order and requesting a stay of the section 366.26
hearing. We issued an order to show cause why the petition should not be
granted, and the Agency filed an opposition.
II. DISCUSSION
Mother contends there was insufficient evidence to support the juvenile
court’s determination that reasonable reunification services were offered or
provided. We reject her contention.2
2 After reviewing the parties’ supplemental briefs, we deny the Agency’s
request to dismiss mother’s petition as untimely based on a late-filed notice of
intent to file the writ petition. We find exceptional good cause to consider the
merits of mother’s petition because, through no fault of her own, trial counsel
11
A. Law and Standard of Review
Under section 366.21, subdivision (g)(1), a juvenile court may continue
a “permanency review hearing” for up to six months but that hearing must
“occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the
physical custody of their parent . . . .” Before terminating reunification
services and setting a section 366.26 hearing, the court must find by “clear
and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or
offered to the parent . . . .” (§ 366.22, subd. (b)(3)(C)(iii).)
To satisfy the reasonable services requirement, an agency must provide
“services responsive to the unique needs of each family,” “ ‘ “ ‘specifically
tailored to fit the circumstances of each family,’ ” ’ ” and “ ‘ “ ‘designed to
eliminate those conditions which led to the juvenile court’s jurisdictional
finding.’ ” ’ ” (Patricia W. v. Superior Court (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 397, 420
(Patricia W.), quoting In re K.C. (2012) 212 Cal.App.4th 323, 329.)
Specifically, “the record must show the agency identified the problems
leading to the loss of custody, offered services designed to remedy those
problems, maintained reasonable contact with the parent[ ] during the
duration of the service plan, and made reasonable efforts to assist the
parent[ ] when compliance was difficult.” (Patricia W., at p. 420.) “[W]hen a
parent or guardian has a mental illness . . ., that condition must be the
‘starting point’ for a family reunification plan[,] which should be tailored to
accommodate their unique needs.” (Ibid., quoting In re K.C., at pp. 332–333.)
However, the services need not be perfect; all that is required is that they
appeared to file the notice late by one court day. (See Jonathan M. v.
Superior Court (1995) 39 Cal.App.4th 1826, 1831 [good cause exists if the
delay is “attributable to someone other than petitioner”]; Rule 8.450(d).)
12
“were reasonable under the circumstances.” (Elijah R. v. Superior Court
(1998) 66 Cal.App.4th 965, 969.)
We review the juvenile court’s finding that reasonable services were
provided for substantial evidence, viewing the evidence in the light most
favorable to the Agency. (In re Misako R. (1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 538, 545.)
And “when reviewing a finding that a fact has been proved by clear and
convincing evidence, the question before the appellate court is whether the
record as a whole contains substantial evidence from which a reasonable fact
finder could have found it highly probable that the fact was true.”
(Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 995–996.)
B. Analysis
Mother’s sole argument is that reunification services were not
adequately tailored to her mental health conditions, contending that her
“unwillingness to follow the case plan stem[med] from” those conditions. She
argues that “the Agency . . . failed to realize” the “reasonably necessary”
services that mother needed most of all: “one that would allow her to
acknowledge that her disabilities were causing the barriers to return.”
According to mother, “the Agency needed to . . . teach empathy to [mother]
. . . [so she could] learn and reflect empathy. Instead, the Agency referred her
to services and expected [mother] to fix herself.” The Agency maintains that
it offered or “provided reasonable services to [mother]” and that those
services were tailored to her mental health needs. Upon reviewing the
record, we agree with the Agency.3
The evidence in the record shows that the Agency identified mother’s
“unaddressed mental health issues” that led to court intervention. In its
3 We reject the Agency’s contention that mother forfeited her challenge
to the reasonableness of the mental health services offered or provided by the
13
initial case plan, the Agency offered services to address those mental health
issues, including a psychiatric evaluation. Mother completed that evaluation,
and the evaluation identified the mental health conditions that mother
needed to address. And to help her do so, the Agency offered and provided
“parenting classes, individual therapy, substance abuse treatment, and
therapeutic visitation.” It also confirmed that mother was “under the care of
a psychiatrist who prescribed her psychotropic medication.” When mother
experienced setbacks in her substance use treatment in early 2026, the
Agency recommended a residential treatment program or an intensive out-
patient mental health program. But the Agency was unable to help mother
access those services because she refused to sign releases of information.
This evidence is more than sufficient to establish that the Agency did what it
was required to do under Patricia W., supra, 244 Cal.App.4th at pages 420 to
421.
In sum, we agree that the Agency “provided reasonable services aimed
at addressing the fundamental issues of mental health, substance abuse, and
a damaged parent-child relationship in this case.” Therefore, we find that
substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s decision to terminate
reunification services.
Agency. At the contested hearing before reunification services were
terminated, mother argued that the Agency did not provide or offer
reasonable reunification services, which necessarily encompasses mental
health services. Thus, she preserved the issue for review.
14
III. DISPOSITION
The petition is denied. Because the section 366.26 hearing is set for
December 2, 2026, our decision is final as to this court immediately. (Rules
8.452(i), 8.490(b)(2)(A).)
CHOU, J.
WE CONCUR.
SIMONS, Acting P. J.
BURNS, J.
15