Gareeno Mackey v. State of Arkansas
CourtSupreme Court of Arkansas
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Cite as 2026 Ark. 200
SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS
No. CR-26-505
Opinion Delivered: November 19, 2026
GAREENO MACKEY
APPELLANT
V.
STATE OF ARKANSAS
APPELLEE
SHOW-CAUSE ORDER ISSUED.
PER CURIAM
Appellant Gareeno Mackey moves this court to order court reporter Dana Beck to
show cause as to why the designated transcript of proceedings has not yet been completed
in this matter and why she went directly to the circuit court to ask for an extension without
notifying his counsel. Because this court issued a writ of certiorari to complete the record
on September 10, 2026, wherein we ordered that the complete record was due by October
10, Mackey further requests an extension of time to complete the record in accordance with
the writ. Alternatively, Mackey moves this court to assign a new court reporter to prepare
the transcript of proceedings in this matter, and if no complete record can be produced, for
a new trial.
Mackey was convicted of attempted capital murder and numerous other felonies, for
which he was sentenced to an aggregate term of life imprisonment. On December 5, 2025,
Mackey’s sentencing order was entered. On December 29, Mackey’s counsel filed a notice
of appeal wherein counsel designated “the entire record and all proceedings: including, but
not limited to, any pre-trial proceedings, transcripts, exhibits, voir dire, evidence and
documents introduced into evidence or offered into evidence at all hearings to be contained
in the record on appeal.” Arkansas Rule of Appellate Procedure –Crim. 4(b) provides that
“[w]hen an appeal is taken by the defendant, the record on appeal shall be filed with the
clerk of the appellate court and docketed therein within ninety (90) days from the filing of
the notice of appeal”. The rule further provides “[i]f any party has designated
stenographically reported material for inclusion in the record on appeal, the circuit court,
by order entered before expiration of the period prescribed by subdivision (b) of this rule
or by a prior extension order, may extend the time for filing the record.” Ark. R. App. P.
–Crim. 4(c)(1). However, “[i]n no event shall the time for filing the record be extended
more than seven (7) months from the date of the entry of the judgment or order.” Ark. R.
App. P. –Crim. 4(c)(2).
Beck was assigned to prepare the transcript portion of the record for Mackey’s appeal,
and the record was due to be filed with this court no later than March 29, 2026. On March
23, at Beck’s request, Mackey filed a motion for extension of time to complete and file the
record. The circuit court granted the motion and extended the filing deadline to June 27.
In April, Mackey’s counsel sent numerous e-mails to Beck in an attempt to learn whether
she would have the transcript completed by the June 27 deadline, and Beck indicated that
she believed that the transcript would be timely. Mackey’s counsel inquired again about the
status of the transcript in early June, and on June 12, Beck responded that portions of the
transcript were finished but said that she would “be happy” to request an additional thirty-
2
day extension from Judge Karren to afford her more time if she needed it, as she believed
an extension to July 29 would be within the record filing requirements set forth in Rule 4.
However, Mackey’s counsel believed that the seven-month deadline for filing the appellate
record would have been July 6—seven months from the date of the sentencing order. 1 On
June 23, Mackey followed up with Beck about the status of the transcript. Beck responded
with a copy of an order—signed by Judge Karren—extending the deadline to July 29 and
said, “Here is an extension until July 29th. So we are good.” However, because it was
counsel’s understanding that the seven-month deadline would have expired before July 29,
he had not requested such an extension.
Rule 4 provides that “[i]f the appellant has obtained the maximum seven-month
extension available from the circuit court, or demonstrates (by affidavit or otherwise) an
inability to obtain entry of an order of extension, then before expiration of the period
prescribed by subdivision (b) of this rule or a prior extension order, the appellant may file
with the clerk of the appellate court a petition for writ of certiorari pursuant to Rule 3-5 of
the Rules of the Supreme Court and Court of Appeals.” Ark. R. App. P. –Crim. 4(c)(3).2
Pursuant to Rule 4(c)(3), on July 15, Mackey’s counsel filed with this court a motion for
rule on clerk and petition for writ of certiorari to complete the record. The motion
1
Here, seven months from the date of the sentencing order would have fallen on
Sunday, July 5, 2026. Pursuant to our rules, the deadline to lodge the record would therefore
have been extended to the next business day, July 6. See Ark. R. App. P. –Crim. 17.
2
Rule 3-5(a) provides that “[w]hen jurisdiction is conferred by filing, within the time
allowed for appeal, a dated and certified copy of the order or judgment appealed from, the
Clerk may, upon authorization by the Court, issue a writ of certiorari to the clerk of the
circuit court, the reporter, or any other person charged with the duty of preparing the record
on appeal, directing that any omissions or errors in the record be corrected.”
3
explained that Mackey’s counsel had not yet received the transcript and requested that we
direct the clerk to accept a partial record for filing and issue a writ of certiorari to complete
the record. On July 28, Mackey’s counsel inquired about the status of the transcript, to
which Beck responded that she was making progress on the transcript but would not have
it ready by the deadline. On September 10, we granted the motion and issued a writ of
certiorari ordering that the complete record was due no later than October 10. See Mackey
v. State, CR-26-505 (Ark. Sept. 10, 2026) (order granting appellant’s motion for rule on
clerk and petition for writ of certiorari to complete the record). On October 6, Mackey’s
counsel filed in this court the instant motion to extend time, motion to show cause and
alternative to substitute certified court reporter, or motion for new trial. On October 12,
counsel filed a supplement to the October 6 motion explaining that Beck did not, in fact,
complete the transcript by the October 10 deadline. Mackey’s counsel affirms that he has
acted in good faith throughout the appellate process and has taken all reasonable steps
available to secure completion of the record yet is unable to comply with the mandatory
appellate rules because of Beck’s inability to produce a record of the transcript. According
to counsel, Beck has not provided a completion date for the transcript and has exhibited
that she is having difficulty preparing appellate records in a timely manner by her failure to
do so in this matter.
To date, a complete record has neither been filed nor tendered for filing in this case.
Over four months have passed since the seven-month deadline set forth in Rule 4(c)(2), and
more than a month has passed since the deadline set by this court for the complete record
to be lodged. Accordingly, we order Dana Beck to provide a written response explaining
4
her conduct in this case and why she should not be held in contempt for failing to timely
prepare the transcript of proceedings in the present case and failing to comply with our
September 10 writ of certiorari to complete the record. Beck’s response must be filed by
Monday, November 30, 2026, at 5:00 p.m. The court reserves its ruling on Mackey’s
remaining requests for relief.
It is so ordered.
Special Justice CORY COX joins.
WEBB, J., not participating.
5