Full Opinion

Cite as 2026 Ark. App. 557 ARKANSAS COURT OF APPEALS DIVISION I No. CV-25-381 ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW Opinion Delivered: November 18, 2026 ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS AND APPEAL FROM THE SEBASTIAN TRAINING COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT, APPELLANT GREENWOOD DISTRICT [NO. 66GCV-23-326] V. HONORABLE GREG MAGNESS, JAMAR CUMMINGS JUDGE APPELLEE REVERSED STEPHANIE POTTER BARRETT, Judge The Arkansas Commission on Law Enforcement Standards and Training (“the Commission”) appeals a final order of the Sebastian County Circuit Court reversing the Commission’s decision to revoke appellee Jamar Cummings’s law enforcement certification. On appeal, the Commission argues its decision to decertify Cummings was supported by substantial evidence and was not vague, arbitrary, or capricious. We agree with the Commission and affirm its decision to decertify Cummings as a law enforcement offer. Therefore, we reverse the circuit court’s order and remand for entry of an order consistent with this opinion. I. Relevant Background This appeal arises out of an order of the Commission dated November 15, 2023, revoking Cummings’s certification. The Commission found Cummings had resigned from the Fort Smith Police Department while six internal investigations were pending and concluded his conduct violated Rule 1034(1)(b)(iv), Rule 1034(1)(b)(vii), and the Law Enforcement Code of Ethics in Rule 1020. 015.10.1 Ark. Admin. Code § 1034(1)(b)(iv), (vii) & § 1020 (WL current through July 15, 2025). Cummings began working for the Fort Smith Police Department in March 2021. In 2022, the department opened internal investigations concerning incomplete reports, an arrestee’s missing property, an overdue accident report, an alleged refusal to obey an order, the use of force and profane language during an arrest, and simultaneous employment with another police department. Lieutenant Dewey Young explained that the department generally sought to complete internal investigations within thirty days, although investigators could request extensions. He attributed delays in processing complaints to an unsuccessful software transition from IAPro to Benchmark, which sometimes prevented complaints entered by supervisors from reaching the office of professional standards. The department returned to IAPro around June 2022. The first investigation, IC2022-023, arose from a May 11, 2022 complaint that Cummings failed to complete reports before the end of his shifts. Lieutenant Michael McCoy interviewed Cummings on June 12. Cummings acknowledged forgetting some reports but explained that others had been incorrectly coded or were completed but still in his inbox. 2 McCoy reported the listed reports were completed by the time he made his notes. On July 11, McCoy forwarded the matter to the office of professional standards with the notation “Investigation Complete.” The case was routed for chain-of-command review on September 1, and supervisors recommended counseling. The record lists September 13 as the completion date and resignation as the disposition. Young’s September 18 memorandum states the investigation was complete but remained in supervisory review when Cummings submitted his resignation. The department opened IC2022-029 on June 27 after an arrestee reported his backpack and wallet had not been returned. Officers located the backpack in the patrol vehicle, but the wallet was not recovered. Video showed the wallet on the hood of the vehicle before Cummings stopped recording the arrest. Young’s September 14 memorandum states Cummings was not interviewed before resigning, and the investigation would be closed with his resignation. The next investigation, IC2022-030, began June 28 when a citizen reported he could not obtain an accident report from a June 17 incident. Cummings completed and uploaded the accident report on July 8. Young’s September 14 memorandum states Cummings was not interviewed, and this investigation also would be closed with his resignation. Both electronic files list September 14 as their completion date. Investigation IC2022-034 concerned Cummings’s decision to work a July 30 overtime patrol shift while temporarily assigned to community relations. Lieutenant Lee McCabe reported that, during a July 29 meeting, he told Cummings not to work patrol until August 3 1. McCabe filed the complaint on August 1 after learning Cummings worked the patrol shift. Young interviewed McCabe and Officer Shoptaw, who described Cummings’s awareness of the restriction. The file also contains emails concerning overtime and an approved overtime form. In a September 15 memorandum, Young stated he could not interview Cummings because Cummings resigned and the investigation would be closed with the resignation. The use-of-force investigation, IC2022-036, followed an August 14 encounter in which Cummings assisted Officer Tim Robinson in removing Anirudh Iyer from a vehicle that did not belong to Iyer. An internal complaint alleging excessive force and profane language was entered August 15. Lieutenant Jeff Carter interviewed Cummings on August 16, and Young interviewed Robinson on August 23. Young’s investigative notes are dated August 24. Those notes describe repeated Taser drive stuns, Taser probe deployments, physical strikes, use of pepper spray, and Cummings’s brief display of his handgun before the officers coordinated their efforts and removed Iyer. Young characterized Iyer’s resistance as passive and questioned the officers’ failure to de-escalate. Initial supervisory reviews recommended Cummings receive a predetermination hearing. An August 29 memorandum offered that opportunity, and Cummings signed a waiver of the hearing. Captain Daniel Grubbs’s September 1 disciplinary recommendation sustained the allegations and recommended an eight-day suspension. Sergeant Anthony Rice’s final recommendation, also for an eight-day suspension, is dated September 8. Lieutenant Steve Creek recommended an eight-day suspension for excessive force and a 4 written reprimand for profane language. Chief Danny Baker’s case-review sheet is dated September 21 and administratively closes the case, stating Cummings resigned on September 3 while the matter awaited supervisory review. Other electronic entries record Cummings’s allegations as closed with resignation on September 14. The combined file, which also concerned Robinson, lists November 25 as its completion date. The hearing notice explained if Cummings waived a hearing, a disciplinary recommendation would be forwarded to the chief. Cummings’s resignation memorandum is dated August 21 and stamped received August 26. It tentatively identified September 9 as his last workday, requested sick leave for the remainder of the week, and expressed a desire to retain reserve status. Handwritten notations state he resigned under investigation, was ineligible for rehire or reserve service, and tendered his resignation immediately on September 3. Young testified Cummings’s gun, badge, and building-access card were collected as part of paid administrative leave. The final investigation, IC2022-048, concerned Cummings’s employment with the Barling Police Department while the Fort Smith Police Department considered him still employed. Captain Wendall Sampson’s report states that, at approximately 1:00 a.m. on September 3, he learned Cummings transported a prisoner while wearing a Barling uniform. Sampson reported subsequent communications with Barling officers and Cummings concerning his employment status. The complaint was entered that morning. At 9:28 a.m., Baker emailed that Cummings was no longer employed by Fort Smith; at 9:45 a.m., Baker reported Cummings resigned effective immediately, Baker would seek decertification, and 5 open investigations should be documented as thoroughly as possible. The dual-employment file lists October 18 as its completion date and resignation as its disposition. At the November 15, 2023, decertification hearing, Cummings appeared with counsel, and the Commission heard testimony and received evidence including investigative records and body-camera footage. Young testified none of the investigations reached final resolution before Cummings resigned. He explained supervisors made recommendations, but the chief made the ultimate disciplinary decision. According to Young, Cummings was offered the opportunity to remain employed and resolve the investigations but chose to resign. During questioning about potential discipline, Commission counsel stipulated that the less serious complaints would not independently have resulted in termination and emphasized that resignation while the investigations were pending was the asserted ground for decertification. Young also explained the chief ultimately determined whether departmental rules or policies were violated. Cummings testified he believed the investigations were closed, and his employment with Fort Smith ended after he surrendered his gun and badge. Barling investigator Dalton Wagner described an early-morning conversation with Sampson during Cummings’s first Barling shift. Wagner recalled Sampson saying that, to his knowledge, Cummings was not under investigation for use of force but remained employed pending an exit interview. Barling Chief Bryan Fuller testified about Cummings’s performance and said the officers used the tools and training provided to them during the Iyer encounter. Cummings 6 denied using excessive force, testified Iyer kicked both officers, and explained his concern that Iyer could drive away and injure someone. In closing, counsel argued Rule 1034’s use of the word “may” provided no standards governing decertification and raised constitutional concerns. The Commission voted 7–1 to decertify Cummings and entered its written order that day. Cummings petitioned for judicial review on November 20, 2023, and the circuit court stayed the decertification order. The Commission did not expressly rule on Cummings’s constitutional objection. At the January 27, 2025 circuit court hearing, the parties stipulated to admission of a flash drive containing the encounter forming the basis of the excessive-force investigation, and the court stated it reviewed the recording. On February 25, the court reversed the decertification order and dismissed the matter. It found Cummings’s use of force was justified, his Fort Smith employment effectively ended when he surrendered his badge and equipment, and substantial evidence did not support decertification. The court declined to decide the constitutional vagueness challenge. II. Standard of Review Our review in this case is directed not to the circuit court’s decision but to the decision of the Commission. Ark. Hearing Instrument Dispenser Bd. v. Vance, 359 Ark. 325, 327, 197 S.W.3d 495, 497 (2004). We uphold the agency’s decision if it is supported by substantial evidence and is not arbitrary, capricious, or characterized by an abuse of discretion. Id. Substantial evidence means valid, legal, and persuasive evidence such that a reasonable person might accept it as adequate to support the conclusion. Id. When an 7 agency’s determination is supported by substantial evidence, the decision cannot be arbitrary or unreasonable. Id. We give the most probative weight to the evidence in favor of the agency’s determination and look to the entire record in making this determination. Id. III. Discussion The Commission first argues substantial evidence supports its finding that Cummings resigned while internal investigations were pending. We agree. Rule 1034(1)(b)(iv) authorizes the Commission, after written notice and a hearing, to revoke an officer’s certification when the officer “resigned or retired while the subject of a pending internal investigation.” 015.10.1 Ark. Admin. Code § 1034(1)(b)(iv). The rule makes resignation during a pending investigation an independent ground for decertification; it does not require proof that the underlying allegations would warrant termination. By preserving the Commission’s authority to act when an officer resigns before an investigation is complete, the rule prevents law enforcement officers from subverting consequences through resignation and promotes accountability. The question, therefore, is whether substantial evidence supports the Commission’s finding that an internal investigation remained pending when Cummings resigned. The record supports the Commission’s finding that Cummings resigned effective September 3. His resignation memorandum and the chief’s contemporaneous email document that date. Although Cummings believed his employment ended when he surrendered his weapons and badge, Young explained the equipment was collected as part of paid administrative leave, and Cummings declined an opportunity to remain employed 8 and resolve the investigations. Resolving that conflict was the Commission’s responsibility since witness credibility and the weight of the evidence are within the agency’s discretion. Ark. Dep’t of Corr. Sex Offender Assessment Comm. v. Hastings, 2024 Ark. App. 407, at 8, 699 S.W.3d 123, 129. The reviewing court asks whether the evidence supports the agency’s finding, not whether it could support a contrary finding. Id. Substantial evidence also supports the finding that investigations remained pending on September 3. Young’s memoranda identified unfinished work in investigation Nos. IC2022-029, IC2022-030, and IC2022-034, including interviews with Cummings that did not occur before resignation. The use-of-force investigation likewise remained under review: disciplinary review continued after the August 24 investigative notes, Rice’s final recommendation was dated September 8, and the chief administratively closed the matter on September 21. This evidence permitted the Commission to find that substantive investigative work and review remained unfinished rather than merely the paperwork necessary to record a completed decision. Neither the software delays nor the age of some complaints requires us to reach a different conclusion. Those circumstances explain delays in processing the complaints; they do not establish the outstanding interviews were completed. Moreover, the use-of-force complaint arose less than three weeks before Cummings resigned. The Commission’s finding rested on affirmative evidence of unfinished work, not simply the department’s failure to close its files. 9 The evidence concerning these matters is sufficient; therefore, we need not decide whether IC2022-023, which contained an earlier notation that the investigation was complete, independently supported decertification or resolve the timing of the dual- employment complaint. Nor does the stipulation that the less serious complaints would not independently warrant termination defeat decertification. Therefore, because substantial evidence supports the Commission’s finding, Cummings’s contention that the decision was arbitrary and capricious also fails. See Vance, 359 Ark. at 327, 197 S.W.3d at 497. Finally, Cummings argues Rules 1034 and 1020 are unconstitutionally vague because they provide inadequate standards governing decertification. Although counsel raised a constitution objection during closing argument, the Commission did not rule on it, and the circuit court expressly declined to decide it. A constitutional challenge must be presented to the agency and a ruling obtained to preserve the issue for judicial review. Holloway v. Ark. State Bd. of Architects, 352 Ark. 427, 433–34, 101 S.W.3d 805, 809 (2003). We therefore do not reach the constitutional challenge. See Hastings, 2024 Ark. App. 407, at 9–10, 699 S.W.3d at 129–30. Accordingly, we affirm the Commission’s decision that Cummings violated Rule 1034(a)(b)(iv) and need not decide whether Cummings’s use of force independently supported decertification under the Code of Ethics. We reverse the circuit court’s order and remand for entry of an order consistent with this opinion. Reversed. VIRDEN and WOOD, JJ., agree. 10 Tim Griffin, Att’y Gen., by: Daniel Ford, Sr. Ass’t Att’y Gen., for appellant. Sam Sexton III, for appellee. 11