Full Opinion

Opinion No. 2026-120 November 9, 2026 Mr. Clyde Crookham c/o James E. Patrick II Arkansas Department of Transportation Post Office Box 2261 Little Rock, Arkansas 72203-2261 Dear Mr. Crookham: You have requested an opinion from this Office regarding the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). Your request, which is made as the subject of the records, is based on A.C.A. § 25-19-105(c)(3)(B)(i). This subdivision authorizes the custodian, requester, or the subject of certain employee-related records to seek an opinion stating whether the custodian’s decision regarding the release of such records is consistent with the FOIA. According to correspondence forwarded to our Office, the Arkansas Department of Transportation received a FOIA request for certain records relating to your employment. The custodian of records has identified five responsive records. He has classified four of the records as your personnel records and determined that they are subject to release with redactions. He has classified the fifth record as an employee-evaluation record and has determined that it is subject to release, with certain redactions. You ask if the custodian’s decisions are consistent with the FOIA. RESPONSE In my opinion, the custodian’s decisions are mostly consistent with the FOIA. The custodian has correctly classified the first four records as your personnel records and has properly redacted certain exempt information from them. However, the second personnel record appears to contain your personal email address. If so, that information should be redacted before the record is released. The custodian has also correctly classified a suspension letter as an employee-evaluation record and has redacted what appears to be your home address and employee identification number. If that is the information that was redacted, that decision is likewise consistent with the FOIA. BOB R. BROOKS JR. JUSTICE BUILDING 101 WEST CAPITOL AVENUE LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS 72201 Clyde Crookham Opinion No. 2026-120 Page 2 DISCUSSION 1. General rules. A document must be disclosed in response to a FOIA request if (1) the request was directed to an entity subject to the FOIA, (2) the requested document is a public record, and (3) no exceptions allow the document to be withheld. 1 The first two elements appear to be met. The request was made to the Arkansas Department of Transportation, which is a public entity subject to the FOIA. And the records at issue appear to be public records. 2 Because these records are held by a public entity, they are presumed to be public records, 3 although that presumption is rebuttable. 4 Given that I have no information to suggest that the presumption can be rebutted here, I will focus on whether any exemptions prevent the documents’ disclosure. For purposes of the FOIA, employees’ personnel files 5 normally contain two distinct groups of records: “personnel records” and “employee-evaluation or job-performance records.” The test for whether these two types of documents may be released differs significantly. Thus, the custodian must first decide whether a record meets the definition of either a “personnel record” or an “employee-evaluation or job-performance record” and then apply the appropriate test for that record to determine whether the record should be released under the FOIA. 2. Personnel records. Personnel records are records that pertain to an individual employee that were not created by or at the behest of the employer to evaluate the employee. 6 A personnel record is open to public inspection except “to the extent that disclosure would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy.” 7 While the FOIA does not define the phrase “clearly 1 Harrill & Sutter, PLLC v. Farrar, 2012 Ark. 180, at 8, 402 S.W.3d 511, 515. 2 The FOIA defines public records as “writings, recorded sounds, films, tapes, electronic or computer-based information, or data compilations in any medium, required by law to be kept or otherwise kept, and that constitute a record of the performance or lack of performance of official functions … carried out by a public official or employee.” A.C.A. § 25-19-103(15)(A). 3 Id. 4 See Pulaski Cnty. v. Ark. Democrat-Gazette, Inc., 370 Ark. 435, 440–41, 260 S.W.3d 718, 722 (2007) (“[T]he presumption of public record status established by the FOIA can be rebutted if the records do not otherwise fall within the definition found in the first sentence, i.e., if they do not ‘constitute a record of the performance or lack of performance of official functions.”’ (quoting Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2005-095)). 5 “Personnel files” are not referenced in the FOIA but typically include the following documents: employment applications; school transcripts; payroll-related documents, such as information about reclassifications, promotions, or demotions; transfer records; health- and life-insurance forms; performance evaluations; recommendation letters; disciplinary-action records; requests for leave-without-pay; certificates of advanced training or education; and legal documents, such as subpoenas. E.g. Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2016-104, 97-368; John J. Watkins et al., The Arkansas Freedom of Information Act 203–04 (6th ed. 2017). 6 See, e.g., Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2015-072, 99-147. 7 A.C.A. § 25-19-105(b)(12). Clyde Crookham Opinion No. 2026-120 Page 3 unwarranted invasion of personal privacy,” the Arkansas Supreme Court has provided some guidance. In Young v. Rice, the Court applied a balancing test that weighs the public’s interest in accessing the records against the individual’s interest in keeping them private. 8 The balancing test, which takes place “with the scale tipped in favor of public access,” has two steps. 9 First, the custodian must assess whether the information contained in the requested document is of a personal or intimate nature such that it gives rise to a greater than de minimis privacy interest. 10 If the privacy interest is minimal, then the records should be disclosed. Second, if the information does give rise to a greater than de minimis privacy interest, then the custodian must determine whether that privacy interest is outweighed by the public’s interest in disclosure. 11 Because the exceptions must be narrowly construed, the person resisting disclosure bears the burden of showing that, under the circumstances, the employee’s privacy interests outweigh the public’s interest. 12 The fact that the subject of the records may consider release of the records an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy is irrelevant to the analysis because the test is objective. 13 Even if a document, when considered as a whole, meets the test for disclosure, it may contain discrete pieces of information that must be redacted, 14 such as personal contact information of public employees (including personal telephone numbers, email addresses, and home addresses); 15 employee personnel numbers or identification codes; 16 marital status of public employees; 17 information about children and dependents; 18 dates of birth of public employees; Social Security 8 308 Ark. 593, 826 S.W.2d 252 (1992). 9 Watkins et al., supra note 5, at 208. 10 Young, 308 Ark. at 598, 826 S.W.2d at 255. 11 Id. 12 Stilley v. McBride, 332 Ark. 306, 313, 965 S.W.2d 125, 128 (1998). 13 E.g., Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2016-055, 2001-112, 2001-028, 94-198; Watkins et al., supra note 5, at 207. 14 A.C.A. § 25-19-105(f). 15 See id. § 25-19-105(b)(13). 16 Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2022-032, 2014-094, 2007-070. Public employee personnel numbers are exempt from disclosure because “these numbers presumably provide access to computerized data, and records containing ‘personal identification numbers’ used for computer security functions are specifically exempt from disclosure under the FOIA.” Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2022-032; see also A.C.A. § 25-19-105(b)(11). 17 Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2001-080. 18 Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2018-084, 2018-083, 2001-080. Clyde Crookham Opinion No. 2026-120 Page 4 numbers; 19 driver’s license numbers; 20 insurance coverage; 21 tax information or withholdings;22 payroll deductions; 23 net pay; 24 banking information; 25 and other financial “records that would divulge intimate financial detail.” 26 3. Employee-evaluation records. The second relevant exception is for “employee evaluation or job performance records,” which are records (1) created by or at the behest of the employer (2) to evaluate the employee (3) that detail the employee’s performance or lack of performance on the job. 27 This exception includes records generated while investigating allegations of employee misconduct that detail incidents that gave rise to an allegation of misconduct. 28 If a document qualifies as an employee-evaluation record, the document cannot be released unless all the following elements have been met: 1. The employee was suspended or terminated (i.e., level of discipline); 2. There has been a final administrative resolution of the suspension or termination proceeding (i.e., finality); 3. The records in question formed a basis for the decision made in that proceeding to suspend or terminate the employee (i.e., relevance); and 4. The public has a compelling interest in the disclosure of the records in question (i.e., compelling interest). 29 19 Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2006-035, 2003-153. 20 Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2007-025. 21 Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2004-167. 22 Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2005-194, 2003-385. 23 Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 1998-126. 24 Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2018-064, 2018-015, 2002-043, 1998-126. 25 Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2005-194. 26 Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2005-194, 1998-126, 1995-242, 1995-110, 1994-235, 1991-093, 1987-422. 27 Thomas v. Hall, 2012 Ark. 66, at 8–9, 399 S.W.3d 387, 392; see also Davis v. Van Buren Sch. Dist., 2019 Ark. App. 466, 7–8, 572 S.W.3d 466, 471 (noting that “[o]ur supreme court has approved” the definition of employee-evaluation records developed by the Attorney General’s Office); Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2015-057, 2009-067, 2006-038, 2003- 073, 95-351, 93-055. 28 E.g., Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2015-057 (collecting citations). 29 A.C.A. § 25-19-105(c)(1); e.g., Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2008-065. Clyde Crookham Opinion No. 2026-120 Page 5 As for the final prong, the FOIA never defines the key phrase “compelling public interest.” But the leading commentators on the FOIA, referring to this Office’s opinions, have offered the following guidelines: [I]t seems that the following factors should be considered in determining whether a compelling public interest is present: (1) the nature of the infraction that led to suspension or termination, with particular concern as to whether violations of the public trust or gross incompetence are involved; (2) the existence of a public controversy related to the agency and its employees; and (3) the employee’s position within the agency. In short, a general interest in the performance of public employees should not be considered compelling because that concern, at least theoretically, always exists. However, a link between a given public controversy, an agency associated with the controversy in a specific way, and an employee within the agency who commits a serious breach of public trust should be sufficient to satisfy the “compelling public interest” requirement. 30 The primary purpose of this exception is to preserve the confidentiality of the formal job- evaluation process in order to promote honest exchanges between employees and their employers. 31 4. Classification and release of personnel records. The custodian has correctly classified the first four records as your personnel records. The custodian appears to have redacted your Social Security number, home address, personal telephone number, driver’s license number, employee identification number, network user ID, retirement number, and other personal data from those records. Those redactions are consistent with the FOIA. However, the second record appears to contain your personal email address without redaction. If that is your personal email address, it should be redacted before the record is released. 5. Classification and release of suspension letter. The final record, a suspension letter, qualifies as an employee-evaluation record because it was created by your employer to notify you of your suspension, and it details the misconduct that led to that disciplinary action. This Office has consistently concluded that suspension letters qualify as employee-evaluation records when they recount the grounds for suspension. 32 The custodian’s determination that this record is releasable is also consistent with the FOIA. The first three elements are satisfied because you were suspended, the suspension is final, and the letter is relevant to that suspension. The final element, whether the public has a compelling interest in the disclosure of the letter, also appears to be satisfied. This Office has consistently opined that 30 Watkins et al., supra note 5, at 238–39. 31 E.g., Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 96-168. 32 E.g., Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2024-067, 2001-276, 2001-244, 98-075. Clyde Crookham Opinion No. 2026-120 Page 6 because law enforcement officers are invested with a significant public trust, there is usually a compelling public interest in records that reflect violations of departmental policy. 33 Finally, the custodian has redacted what appears to be your home address and employee identification number from the letter. If those are the items that were redacted, the redactions are consistent with the FOIA. Deputy Attorney General Kelly Summerside prepared this opinion, which I hereby approve. Sincerely, TIM GRIFFIN Attorney General 33 Ark. Att’y Gen. Ops. 2023-013, 2014-129, 2009-146, 2006-158.