Full Opinion

Opinion No. 2026-068 November 5, 2026 The Honorable Richard McGrew State Representative 324 Ouachita Avenue Hot Springs, Arkansas 71901-5209 Dear Representative McGrew: You report that “[a] need arises occasionally for clothing for indigent defendants who are represented by the Public Defender’s Office to appear in court for criminal cases in Garland County Circuit and District Courts.” You have asked the following questions, which I have reorganized for clarity: 1. Is the county required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear to court appearances pursuant to these statutes or any other law? Regardless of whether it is required to pay, may the county lawfully pay for this expense if it so chooses? Brief response: The county is not required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances. But Amendment 55 and A.C.A. §§ 14-14-802(a)(1), 14-14-802(b), and 14-20-102(a) likely allow a county to purchase clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances before juries. 2. Is the Public Defender Commission required to pay for such clothing pursuant to these statutes or any other law? Regardless of whether it is required to pay, may the Public Defender Commission lawfully pay for this expense if it so chooses? Brief response: No, the Public Defender Commission is not required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at jury trials or other court appearances. And no state law expressly authorizes the Commission to purchase clothing for indigent defendants. 3. May the indigent defendants keep any clothing purchased by the county, or must it be returned to the county after use? BOB R. BROOKS JR. JUSTICE BUILDING 101 WEST CAPITOL AVENUE LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS 72201 The Honorable Richard McGrew State Representative Opinion No. 2026-068 Page 2 Brief response: In general, if the county purchases clothing for indigent defendants, that clothing would constitute county personal property. And the county ordinarily may not donate such property to private individuals. However, a reviewing court would likely find that the quorum court may, under A.C.A. § 14-20-102(a)(4), enact an ordinance to either (1) designate the clothing as a consumable expenditure that need not be returned to the county or (2) authorize the county judge to transfer title to the clothing to the defendant as an indigent-defense expenditure. 4. May the indigent defendants keep any clothing purchased by the Public Defender Commission, or must it be returned to the county after use? Brief response: Please see my response to Question 2. 5. May the Quorum Court lawfully appropriate county funds for this purpose? Brief response: Probably yes; a reviewing court would likely find that a quorum court may appropriate county funds for this purpose because (1) no state law prohibits the expenditure and (2) the expenditure is sufficiently related to county affairs under Amendment 55 and A.C.A. §§ 14-14-802 and 14-20-102(a). 6. Assuming that a county may lawfully pay this expense and funds may lawfully be appropriated, may a Circuit or District Court lawfully order the county to pay for this expense, or must such an expense be approved by the County Judge through the regular approval and disbursement process for county claims set forth in Amendment 55, Section 3? Brief response: As discussed above, the county is not required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances. Thus, a circuit or district court cannot lawfully order the county to pay for this expense, and the expense must be approved through the county’s regular approval and disbursement process for county claims. 7. May the County Treasurer lawfully pay such an expense without an approved claim from the County Judge? Brief response: Please see my response to Question 1. A reviewing court would likely find that Amendment 55 allows a county to pay this expense through its regular approval and disbursement process for county claims. The Honorable Richard McGrew State Representative Opinion No. 2026-068 Page 3 DISCUSSION Question 1: Is the county required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear to court appearances pursuant to these statutes or any other law? Regardless of whether it is required to pay, may the county lawfully pay for this expense if it so chooses? No statute or case law requires the county to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances before juries. Both the Arkansas Constitution and the United States Constitution protect a criminal defendant’s right to appear in civilian clothing during appearances before a jury. 1 “The rule in Arkansas remains that the accused may not be forced to trial in prison garb absent a waiver” because “the wearing of such attire serves no useful State purpose” and it may prejudice the jury against the defendant. 2 But this rule does not establish a funding mandate requiring the purchase of civilian clothes for indigent defendants. 3 In my opinion, a reviewing court would likely conclude that a county may nevertheless choose to pay this expense. Amendment 55 authorizes county quorum courts to legislate county affairs so long as the legislation does not conflict with the Arkansas Constitution or other state laws. 4 No state law prohibits a county from purchasing clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances before juries, so the remaining question is whether this purchase relates to county affairs. Several statutes suggest that it does. Under A.C.A. § 14-14-802(a)(1), the county, “acting through the county quorum court, shall provide, through ordinance, for … the administration of justice through the several courts of record of the county.” And A.C.A. § 14-14-802(b) allows that a county, “acting through the county quorum court, may provide through ordinance for … social and rehabilitative services … [and] other services related to county affairs.” Finally, under A.C.A. § 14-20-102(a)(4), “the quorum court is authorized to supplement the fund [for defense of indigents] by additional appropriation from the county general fund, and expenditures from the 1 Box v. State, 348 Ark. 116, 123, 71 S.W.3d 552, 556 (2002) (“There cannot be any doubt that appellant had a right to appear in civilian clothing.”); Estelle v. Williams, 425 U.S. 501 (1976) (holding that the state cannot, consistent with the Fourteenth Amendment, compel an accused to stand trial before a jury while dressed in identifiable prison clothes). But see Tarver v. State, 2018 Ark. 202, 547 S.W.3d 689 (“There is no equivalent right to wear civilian clothing in appearances before a judge alone, however.”); Hinton v. State, 2017 Ark. 107, 8–10, 515 S.W.3d 121, 126–27 (holding that defendants are not entitled to wear civilian clothing when they are charged with offenses that occurred while incarcerated). 2 Box, 348 Ark. at 124, 71 S.W.3d at 557. 3 Croston v. State, 95 Ark. App. 157, 234 S.W.3d 909 (2006) (“A criminal defendant does not have a constitutional right to be provided clothing of a particular style; the Constitution merely prohibits compelling a criminal defendant to appear in clearly identifiable jail clothing.”). 4 Ark. Const., Amend. 55, § 1(a) (“A county acting through its Quorum Court may exercise local legislative authority not denied by the Constitution or by law”). See also A.C.A. § 14-14-801(a) (“As provided by Arkansas Constitution, Amendment 55, § 1, Part (a), a county government, acting through its county quorum court, may exercise local legislative authority not expressly prohibited by the Arkansas Constitution or by law for the affairs of the county”). The Honorable Richard McGrew State Representative Opinion No. 2026-068 Page 4 fund shall be made in the manner and amounts prescribed by the quorum court.” Because county quorum courts “enjoy considerable latitude in crafting local laws,” 5 an ordinance directing the county to purchase clothing for indigent defendants to wear at jury appearances likely serves a valid county purpose. Thus, a reviewing court would likely conclude that purchasing clothing for indigent defendants to wear during jury appearances is sufficiently related to county affairs to be authorized by Amendment 55 and A.C.A. §§ 14-14-802(a)(1), 14-14-802(b), and 14-20-102(a). Question 2: Is the Public Defender Commission required to pay for such clothing pursuant to these statutes or any other law? Regardless of whether it is required to pay, may the Public Defender Commission lawfully pay for this expense if it so chooses? No, the Public Defender Commission is not required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at jury trials or other court appearances. And no state law expressly authorizes the Commission to purchase clothing for indigent defendants. Under A.C.A. § 16-87-212(a), “the Commission is authorized to pay for certain expenses regarding the defense of indigents.” The statute provides several non-exhaustive examples of covered expenses, including “fees for counsel appointed by the court, expert witnesses, temporary investigators, testing, and travel.” 6 These examples all involve expenses directly related to the provision of a legal defense. Clothing is not among the listed expenses, nor is it analogous to the professional services or investigative activities listed in the statute. Therefore, it is my opinion that clothing for indigent defendants falls outside the types of expenses the Commission is authorized to pay. 7 Further, the Arkansas Supreme Court has recognized that the Commission may not expend public funds unless authorized by statute. 8 Question 3: May the indigent defendants keep any clothing purchased by the county, or must it be returned to the county after use? In general, if the county purchases clothing for indigent defendants, that clothing would constitute county personal property. Under A.C.A. § 14-14-1102(b)(3)(A), the county judge has custody of all county property and “is responsible for the administration, care, and keeping of such property, including the right to dispose of county property in the manner and procedure provided by law for the disposal of county property by the county court.” And A.C.A. § 14-16-105(b) sets out the specific process county officials must follow to dispose of personal property. That process does not allow the county to donate clothing to indigent defendants. 5 Ark. Att’y Gen. Op. 2021-065. 6 A.C.A. § 16-87-212(a)(2)(A). 7 McKinney v. Robbins, 319 Ark. 596, 600, 892 S.W.2d 502, 504 (1995) (“[T]he rule of construction known as noscitur a sociis (It is known from its associates) requires that general language be construed to be comparable to the specific language of its context.”) (internal quotations and citations omitted). 8 See Ark. Pub. Def. Com’n v. Burnett, 340 Ark. 233, 237–38, 12 S.W.3d 191, 194 (2000) (holding that the Commission could not be required to pay for legal representation of minors in a civil case). The Honorable Richard McGrew State Representative Opinion No. 2026-068 Page 5 However, A.C.A. § 14-20-102(a)(4) allows a quorum court to supplement the fund for defense of indigents and to dictate “the manner and amounts” of expenditures from this supplementation. Thus, a reviewing court would likely find that the quorum court may enact an ordinance to either (1) designate the clothing as a consumable expenditure that need not be returned to the county or (2) authorize the county judge to transfer title to the clothing to the defendant as part of an indigent- defense expenditure. Question 4: May the indigent defendants keep any clothing purchased by the Public Defender Commission, or must it be returned to the commission after use? Please see my response to Question 2. Question 5: May the Quorum Court lawfully appropriate county funds for this purpose? Probably yes. As discussed more fully above, a reviewing court would likely find that a quorum court may appropriate county funds for this purpose because (1) no state law prohibits the expenditure and (2) the expenditure is sufficiently related to county affairs under Amendment 55 and A.C.A. §§ 14-14-802 and 14-20-102(a). Question 6: Assuming that a county may lawfully pay this expense and funds may lawfully be appropriated, may a Circuit or District Court lawfully order the county to pay for this expense, or must such an expense be approved by the County Judge through the regular approval and disbursement process for county claims set forth in Amendment 55, Section 3? As discussed above, the county is not required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances. Thus, a circuit or district court cannot lawfully order the county to pay for this expense, and the expense must be approved through the county’s regular approval and disbursement process for county claims. Question 7: May the County Treasurer lawfully pay such an expense without an approved claim from the County Judge? Please see my response to Question 1. A reviewing court would likely find that Amendment 55 allows a county to pay this expense through its regular approval and disbursement process for county claims. Assistant Attorney General Jodie Keener prepared this opinion, which I hereby approve. Sincerely, TIM GRIFFIN Attorney General