Full Opinion

NOTICE: NOT FOR OFFICIAL PUBLICATION. UNDER ARIZONA RULE OF THE SUPREME COURT 111(c), THIS DECISION IS NOT PRECEDENTIAL AND MAY BE CITED ONLY AS AUTHORIZED BY RULE. IN THE ARIZONA COURT OF APPEALS DIVISION ONE US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, Plaintiff/Appellee, v. JAIME RYAN AGUILERA, Defendant/Appellant. No. 1 CA-CV 26-0288 FILED 11-18-2026 Appeal from the Superior Court in Maricopa County No. CV2025-023877 The Honorable Michael J. Herrod, Judge AFFIRMED COUNSEL Albertelli Law, Phoenix By Carson T. H. Emmons Counsel for Plaintiff/Appellee Jaime Ryan Aguilera, Scottsdale Defendant/Appellant US BANK v. AGUILERA Decision of the Court MEMORANDUM DECISION Presiding Judge Jennifer M. Perkins delivered the decision of the Court, in which Judge Brian Y. Furuya and Judge D. Andrew Gaona joined. P E R K I N S, Judge: ¶1 Jaime Ryan Aguilera appeals the superior court’s grant of summary judgment entitling U.S. Bank to repossess a truck from Aguilera. Aguilera also appeals from the superior court’s denial of his Arizona Rules of Civil Procedure 56(d) motion for an extension of time to file a response to U.S. Bank’s summary judgment motion. Because Aguilera failed to comply with Rule 56(d)’s requirements and waived all arguments on the merits by failing to file a response, we affirm. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND ¶2 In June 2023, Bret Holm, a non-party in this case, forged his mother, Kelly’s, name on a truck purchase contract from Oxendale Hyundai. The contract assigned Oxendale Hyundai’s interest as seller- creditor to U.S. Bank, whose name was listed on the title to the truck alongside Kelly Holm. ¶3 The loan required monthly payments, but no valid payments were made, and the loan went into default. Upon default, the terms of the loan allowed U.S. Bank to repossess the truck. ¶4 In October 2023, Aguilera purchased the truck from Bret Holm for $105,000. He paid part to Bret directly, and the remainder to Dakota Community Bank. Neither was listed on the title. The Bill of Sale to Aguilera erroneously listed Bret as the current owner. ¶5 In July 2025, U.S. Bank filed a “complaint for replevin” against Aguilera, asking for the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office’s assistance in repossessing the truck. In responding, Aguilera stated that he had insufficient evidence to determine whether any of U.S. Bank’s allegations were true. ¶6 U.S. Bank moved for summary judgment on November 3, 2025. Aguilera never responded, but on December 3, 2025, he moved for extension, explaining he needed more time to research the facts and law. 2 US BANK v. AGUILERA Decision of the Court On December 9, U.S. Bank filed a notice that Aguilera failed to respond to its summary judgment motion, arguing that the rules thus required the court to enter judgment for U.S. Bank. In early January, the superior court denied Aguilera’s motion for extension of time for failure to comply with Rule 56 or consult with U.S. Bank’s counsel. In the same ruling, the court granted summary judgment to U.S. Bank, finding that Aguilera could not be a bona fide purchaser for value, and that U.S. Bank had a valid lien and right to repossess. ¶7 Aguilera timely appealed and we have jurisdiction. A.R.S. §§ 12-120.21(A)(1), 12-2101(A)(1) DISCUSSION ¶8 Aguilera argues that the superior court erred by denying his motion for an extension of time and granting U.S. Bank’s motion for summary judgment. Because Aguilera did not comply with Rule 56’s requirements for motions to extend, the superior court properly denied his motion. And because Aguilera failed to respond to U.S. Bank’s motion for summary judgment, he waived all arguments against summary judgment. For these reasons, we affirm. I. The Superior Court Properly Denied Aguilera’s Invocation of Rule 56(d). ¶9 Aguilera contends the superior court should have granted Rule 56(d) relief, an issue we review for an abuse of discretion. St. George v. Plimpton, 241 Ariz. 163, 165 ¶ 11 (App. 2016) (citing former Rule 56(f)). A party opposing a motion for summary judgment must respond within 30 days. Ariz. R. Civ. P. 56(c)(2). If the opposing party needs more time for additional discovery, he may request an extension under Rule 56(d). But such a request “must be accompanied” by a supporting affidavit containing certain information. Ariz. R. Civ. P. 56(d)(1)(A). Failure to comply is grounds for denial. See St. George, 241 Ariz. at 168 ¶¶ 29–32. ¶10 Aguilera failed to substantively respond throughout this case, including at the summary judgment stage. In his Answer, he checked the box “I have insufficient information to determine whether true or false” for every allegation against him. In the defenses and denials section, he only checked one box: “[f]ailure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.” He provided no additional explanation or detail. The record does not reflect any requests or attempts to engage in discovery, beyond Aguilera’s statement in his extension request that he was “currently 3 US BANK v. AGUILERA Decision of the Court researching the applicable Arizona statutes and case law, obtaining documentation, and attempting to clarify the chain of title and lien history.” ¶11 Aguilera waited until the deadline for his summary judgment response before requesting an extension of time. See Ariz. R. Civ. Pro. 56(c)(2). And he failed to include the necessary affidavit. ¶12 On this record, the superior court did not err in denying Aguilera’s Rule 56(d) extension request. II. Aguilera’s Failure to Respond to U.S. Bank’s Motion for Summary Judgment Waives His Arguments on Appeal. ¶13 In reviewing the grant of summary judgment “we apply the same standard in determining whether genuine issues of material fact exist and the proper application of the law as . . . the trial court.” Schwab v. Ames Constr., 207 Ariz. 56, 60 ¶ 17 (App. 2004). If a party opposing a motion for summary judgment fails to respond with specific facts showing a genuine issue for trial, “summary judgment, if appropriate, shall be entered against that party.” Ariz. R. Civ. P. 56(e). ¶14 We recognize that “[a] failure to respond to a motion for summary judgment with a written memorandum or opposing affidavits cannot, by itself, entitle the moving party to summary judgment.” Schwab, 207 Ariz. at 59 ¶ 15. For example, a defendant who admits to all of plaintiff’s allegations in its motion for summary judgment will not prevail on the sole basis of the plaintiff’s failure to respond to that motion. Markel v. Transamerica Title Ins. Co., 103 Ariz. 353, 358–59 (1968), overruled on other grounds by Burch & Cracchiolo, P.A. v. Pugliani, 144 Ariz. 281 (1985). Likewise, when a movant’s own brief “fail[s] to make a prima facie case—either by omitting evidence of essential elements of its claim or by providing evidence which supported conflicting inferences on a material issue—then there [is] no basis for awarding summary judgment.” United Bank of Ariz. v. Allyn, 167 Ariz. 191, 197 (App. 1990). But when there is no dispute of material fact, “judgment must be for plaintiff . . . if the legal issues are resolved in [its] favor.” Markel, 103 Ariz. at 358–59. ¶15 Once we have confirmed there are no material disputes of fact, we turn to the legal issues. When a party fails to raise an argument so that the superior court can first address its merits, that argument is waived on appeal. BMO Harris Bank N.A. v. Espiau, 251 Ariz. 588, 594 ¶ 25 (App. 2021). Such arguments do not warrant consideration on the merits. Kenyon v. Kenyon, 5 Ariz. App. 267, 271 (1967). Whether a party waived an argument by failing to raise it to the superior court is a question of law that 4 US BANK v. AGUILERA Decision of the Court we review de novo. Est. of Dominguez v. Dominguez, 259 Ariz. 404, 407 ¶ 8 (2025). ¶16 Aguilera points us to no dispute of material facts. And his opening brief does not comply with our procedural rules, which require “citations of legal authorities and appropriate references to the portions of the record on which” he relies. ARCAP 13(a)(7)(A). Rather, Aguilera merely lists facts in the record and offers little to no argument or authority supporting the issues he raises. He thereby made his case effectively unreviewable on the merits. CONCLUSION ¶17 We affirm. MATTHEW J. MARTIN • Clerk of the Court FILED: JR 5