Full Opinion

NOTICE: NOT FOR OFFICIAL PUBLICATION. UNDER ARIZONA RULE OF THE SUPREME COURT 111(c), THIS DECISION IS NOT PRECEDENTIAL AND MAY BE CITED ONLY AS AUTHORIZED BY RULE. IN THE ARIZONA COURT OF APPEALS DIVISION ONE STATE OF ARIZONA, Respondent, v. CARLTON ALVIN EMERICH, Petitioner. No. 1 CA-CR 26-0349 PRPC FILED 11-20-2026 Petition for Review from the Superior Court in Mohave County No. CR-2015-00090 The Honorable Billy K. Sipe Jr., Judge Pro Tempore REVIEW GRANTED; RELIEF DENIED COUNSEL Mohave County Attorney’s Office, Kingman By Matthew J. Smith Counsel for Respondent Carlton Alvin Emerich, Kingman Petitioner MEMORANDUM DECISION Presiding Judge Andrew M. Jacobs delivered the decision of the Court, in which Judge Daniel J. Kiley and Chief Judge Randall M. Howe joined. STATE v. EMERICH Decision of the Court J A C O B S, Judge: ¶1 Carlton Alvin Emerich seeks review of the superior court’s dismissal of his second post-conviction relief (“PCR”) proceeding filed under Arizona Rule of Criminal Procedure (“Rule”) 33.1. We grant review but deny relief. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY ¶2 In 2016, Emerich and the State entered into a plea agreement that resolved four cases pending against Emerich. Under the plea agreement, Emerich would plead guilty to three forgery charges and an attempted second-degree burglary charge. The parties stipulated that for his convictions, the court would sentence Emerich to up to 10 years in prison and he would pay “restitution to victims on all counts, including dismissed counts.” But if Emerich paid $5,000 of restitution before the court entered judgment, the State would stipulate to a 5-year prison sentence. ¶3 Emerich didn’t pay $5,000 of restitution before sentencing, so the court imposed a sentence totaling nine and a half years’ incarceration. At the sentencing hearing, the court ordered that Emerich “shall pay Restitution in the amount of at least $11,221.23.” Regarding restitution, the court ordered that Emerich must pay the monies within one year and four months following his release from the Department of Corrections (“DOC”). While Emerich was in prison, the court ordered DOC to withdraw from his “spendable account the maximum amount allowable pursuant to A.R.S. § 31-230(C) each month.” The court specifically stated that it would “give him credit for payments” made by others toward the amount. ¶4 The presentence report cataloged the various restitution amounts requested by the victims. At the sentencing hearing, Emerich told the court that he had a chance to read the presentence report, and he said he found no corrections or mistakes in the report. Emerich did not object to the restitution amount or request a restitution hearing. ¶5 Emerich filed a timely PCR notice after his sentencing. The court appointed counsel who ultimately filed a completion notice stating she could not find a colorable claim to present in a PCR petition. Emerich filed a pro se PCR petition. In his petition, Emerich argued his attorney rendered ineffective assistance for various reasons. Emerich didn’t challenge the restitution judgment the court entered. The court summarily denied the PCR petition, and Emerich did not seek review with this court. 2 STATE v. EMERICH Decision of the Court ¶6 Eight years after the court dismissed the first PCR proceedings, Emerich began his second. See Ariz. R. Crim. P. 33.3(b) (“If a court receives any type of application or request for relief—however titled—that challenges . . . a sentence following entry of a plea . . . it must treat the application as a petition for post-conviction relief.”). In his petition, Emerich argued the court failed to provide him a restitution hearing and that the court should have divided the restitution obligation among four people. The court denied the petition, finding Emerich had not objected to the restitution amount at sentencing, and that there were no codefendants from the case that led to the restitution award. ¶7 Emerich petitioned this Court to review the denial of his second PCR proceeding under Rule 33.16. We have jurisdiction. A.R.S. § 13-4239(C). DISCUSSION ¶8 In his petition in this Court, Emerich claims the superior court erroneously: (1) failed to provide him with an evidentiary hearing on the amount of restitution owed to the victims; (2) issued an order directing DOC to withhold 50% of any money Emerich received on his account; (3) claimed he had no codefendants; and (4) denied Emerich’s request for the sentencing transcripts needed to file his petition. ¶9 We will not disturb the superior court’s ruling on a PCR petition absent an abuse of discretion or error of law. State v. Evans, 252 Ariz. 590, 594 ¶ 7 (App. 2022) (citing State v. Gutierrez, 229 Ariz. 573, 577 ¶ 19 (2012)). We review the court’s legal conclusions de novo. Evans, 252 Ariz. at 594 ¶ 7 (citing State v. Pandeli, 242 Ariz. 175, 180 ¶ 4 (2017)). “It is a petitioner’s burden to show the superior court abused its discretion by denying the petitioner for post-conviction relief.” State v. Reed, 252 Ariz. 236, 238 ¶ 6 (App. 2021). Emerich’s Second PCR Petition Was Untimely, So the Issues He Raises Are Precluded. ¶10 Rule 33.4 sets forth three general timing requirements for PCR proceedings by defendants who pled guilty. Claims asserting a constitutional basis must be filed within 90 days of sentencing. Ariz. R. Crim. P. 33.4(b)(3)(A). Claims of ineffective assistance of the first PCR counsel must be filed within 30 days of the final order in the first PCR proceeding. Ariz. R. Crim. P. 33.4(b)(3)(C). Any other claim (Rule 33.1(b) through (h)) must be filed “within a reasonable time after discovering the basis for the claim.” Ariz. R. Crim. P. 33.4(b)(3)(B). 3 STATE v. EMERICH Decision of the Court ¶11 In his PCR petition in the superior court, Emerich raised two claims: that he was entitled to an evidentiary hearing on the restitution amount and that all codefendants should have shared the total amount. At most, the claims would be due process violations that could be raised in a PCR proceeding under Rule 33.1(a). But Emerich did not raise those claims in his first PCR proceeding, thus waiving them. Ariz. R. Crim. P. 32.2(a)(3). ¶12 Even if Emerich had raised the claims in his first PCR petition, he waived them. At the sentencing hearing, the court ordered the challenged restitution amount based on the presentence report. Emerich didn’t dispute the amount or request a hearing, which is waiver. See State v. Alvarez, 228 Ariz. 579, 583 ¶ 16 (App. 2012); State v. Wideman, 165 Ariz. 364, 367-68 (App. 1990); State v. Baltzell, 175 Ariz. 437, 438-39 (App. 1992). ¶13 As to severable liability with his codefendants, the court ordered that any monies paid by any party be credited to the total restitution amount. That is consistent with A.R.S. § 13-804(F), which provides that “[i]f more than one defendant is convicted of the offense that caused the loss, the defendants are jointly and severally liable for the restitution.” A.R.S. § 13-804(F). Here, we have no record showing whether any codefendants were convicted or ordered to pay restitution. Thus, we see no error in the court’s restitution order. ¶14 Finally, Emerich’s claim that the court failed to provide him transcripts of the sentencing hearing in his PCR proceeding is not supported by the record, for two reasons. First, Emerich’s first PCR counsel received the transcripts. Second, as the court wrote, there was no PCR proceeding pending when he requested a further copy. We see no error. CONCLUSION ¶15 We grant review but deny relief. MATTHEW J. MARTIN • Clerk of the Court FILED: JR 4