Wagoner v. Wood
CourtCourt of Appeals of Arizona
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket1 CA-CV 26-0141 FC
JudgeMichael S. Catlett
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NOTICE: NOT FOR OFFICIAL PUBLICATION.
UNDER ARIZONA RULE OF THE SUPREME COURT 111(c), THIS DECISION IS NOT PRECEDENTIAL
AND MAY BE CITED ONLY AS AUTHORIZED BY RULE.
IN THE
ARIZONA COURT OF APPEALS
DIVISION ONE
In re the Marriage of:
CHOC WAGONER, Petitioner/Appellee,
v.
BEVA WOOD (FKA: BEVA WAGONER), Respondent/Appellant.
No. 1 CA-CV 26-0141 FC
FILED 11-16-2026
Appeal from the Superior Court in Navajo County
No. S0900DO202200381
The Honorable Joseph Samuel Clark, Judge
AFFIRMED
COUNSEL
White Mountain Law Group PLC, Show Low
By Michael R. Ellsworth
Counsel for Petitioner/Appellee
Beva Wood, Snowflake
Respondent/Appellant
WAGONER v. WOOD
Decision of the Court
MEMORANDUM DECISION
Judge Michael S. Catlett delivered the decision of the Court, in which
Presiding Judge Veronika Fabian and Judge Kent E. Cattani joined.
C A T L E T T, Judge:
¶1 Beva Wood (“Wife”) appeals various orders the superior
court entered after dissolving her marriage to Choc Wagoner (“Husband”).
We lack jurisdiction over all but one of them. As to the one order over
which we have jurisdiction, we affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
¶2 The parties married in 2008. In 2022, Husband petitioned to
dissolve their marriage. In July 2023, the court entered a Decree of
Dissolution (“Decree”). The Decree ordered the parties to sell the marital
residence (“the Residence”) and divide the proceeds.
¶3 In October 2023, Husband petitioned to enforce the Decree’s
provisions about selling the Residence and find Wife in contempt, asserting
that Wife was uncooperative. Wife countered that Husband delayed the
sale by refusing to agree on a realtor. In March 2024, the court assigned a
realtor and ordered the parties to “promptly contact the realtor and sign
any and all documents needed to get the property listed for sale
immediately.” The court also denied Husband’s contempt petition, finding
the parties made a good-faith attempt to agree, but they had been
“hopelessly deadlocked” about choosing a realtor until the court
intervened.
¶4 Husband returned to court a year later and petitioned the
Court a second time to find Wife in contempt. He claimed Wife violated
the court’s March 2024 order by not cooperating with the realtor and
unreasonably delaying the sale of the Residence. In response, Wife
“adamantly denie[d]” that she disregarded the court order and claimed that
a dispute about the price listing and an unsatisfactory offer caused the
delay. The court again ordered the parties to cooperate with the real estate
agent to complete the sale.
¶5 Next, Wife moved for exclusive rights to list the Residence for
sale and to find Husband in contempt. She claimed Husband manipulated
2
WAGONER v. WOOD
Decision of the Court
the court into believing that any delays were Wife’s fault. The court denied
her motion, again ordered Husband and Wife to cooperate in selling the
Residence, and awarded Husband attorney fees. Wife did not appeal that
award.
¶6 In December 2025, Husband again petitioned the court for
contempt and attorney fees. He asserted that the real estate agent secured
buyers for the Residence, but Wife refused to sign paperwork regarding
costs for repairs made. Wife asked the court to stay the sale while she filed
another lawsuit to obtain Husband’s share of the Residence’s proceeds.
Wife did not dispute Husband’s request for attorney fees. On December 9,
2025, the court found that the buyers’ offer was appropriate, it was in the
parties’ best interests to sell the Residence, Wife acted unreasonably, and
Husband was entitled to attorney fees. Although the court did not find
Wife in contempt, the court ordered Wife to sign the paperwork facilitating
the sale of the Residence and directed Husband to file a China Doll affidavit
supporting his attorney fees. On January 27, 2026, after considering
Husband’s affidavit, the court awarded Husband $2,567.10 in attorney fees,
to be paid from Wife’s portion of the Residence’s sale.
¶7 Mother timely appealed the attorney fee award.
JURISDICTION
¶8 Wife argues the superior court erred by: (1) ordering and
enforcing the Residence’s sale; (2) failing to grant Rule 85 relief; (3) creating
an “unfair process” because of the “cumulative effect[] of errors[;]” and
(4) awarding Husband attorney fees.
¶9 We must ensure we have jurisdiction. Camasura v. Camasura,
238 Ariz. 179, 181 ¶ 5 (App. 2015). We lack jurisdiction over orders not
raised in the notice of appeal. Brionna J. v. Dep’t of Child Safety, 255 Ariz.
471, 480 ¶ 39 (2023); Lee v. Lee, 133 Ariz. 118, 124 (App. 1982); ARCAP 8(c)
(“The notice of appeal . . . must . . . [d]esignate the judgment or portion of
the judgment from which the party is appealing[.]”).
¶10 In Wife’s notice of appeal, she identified only the superior
court’s January 27 attorney fee award. And while she asked us in her
opening brief to “[r]everse the orders enforcing the sale of the property,”
she then conceded in her reply brief that she appealed only the attorney fee
award. Wife asserts that although she “addressed issues in her Opening
Brief that were not [a]ppealed,” she “presented this information as
evidence” of how the court abused its discretion by awarding attorney fees;
3
WAGONER v. WOOD
Decision of the Court
she agreed she “has not asked [this court] for an appeal on [the other orders]
at this time.”
¶11 So in this appeal, we have jurisdiction only to consider the
court’s attorney fee award to Husband.1 See Brionna J., 255 Ariz. at ¶ 39;
A.R.S. § 12-2101(A)(1).
DISCUSSION
¶12 Wife argues the court abused its discretion by awarding
Husband attorney fees. But Wife did not oppose the fee award in the
superior court, and arguments not raised in the superior court are waived
on appeal. See BMO Harris Bank N.A. v. Espiau, 251 Ariz. 588, 594 ¶ 25 (App.
2021). Even if we overlooked waiver, Wife would not prevail.
¶13 The superior court may award attorney fees in dissolution
proceedings “after considering the financial resources of both parties and
the reasonableness of the positions each party has taken throughout[.]”
A.R.S. § 25-324(A). We review a fee award under § 25-324 for an abuse of
discretion and reverse only when such an award is clearly erroneous.
Hefner v. Hefner, 248 Ariz. 54, 57 ¶ 6 (App. 2019). “We will not disturb the
trial court’s discretionary award of fees if there is any reasonable basis for
it.” Orfaly v. Tucson Symphony Soc’y, 209 Ariz. 260, 265 ¶ 18 (App. 2004)
(citation modified).
¶14 Wife argues the court abused its discretion by awarding
Husband attorney fees despite evidence of Husband’s noncompliance with
court orders, disputed facts, and “[p]rocedural irregularities affecting
fairness.” The superior court found that Wife acted unreasonably by not
responding to the realtor’s request to sign documents finalizing the
Residence’s sale. On multiple occasions, the court ordered Wife to
cooperate with the real estate agent and sign those sale documents.
Reasonable evidence in the record supports that Wife failed to cooperate
with the realtor and acted unreasonably. So the court did not err by
awarding Husband attorney fees. See Orfaly, 209 Ariz. at 265 ¶ 18.
ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS
¶15 Husband requests attorney fees under A.R.S. § 25-324 and
both parties request costs. In our discretion, we award Husband his
1 Wife filed a second notice of appeal identifying other orders. The parties
are currently briefing that appeal, which is not before us.
4
WAGONER v. WOOD
Decision of the Court
attorney fees and costs on appeal upon compliance with Arizona Rule of
Civil Appellate Procedure 21. We deny Wife’s request for costs.
CONCLUSION
¶16 We dismiss any issue Wife raises other than her challenge to
the superior court’s January 27 attorney fee award, which we affirm.
MATTHEW J. MARTIN • Clerk of the Court
FILED: JR
5