Andrew DuPont, M.D. v. Willie Hawkins
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston)
Date FiledNovember 10, 2026
Docket01-25-00890-CV
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Opinion issued November 10, 2026
In The
Court of Appeals
For The
First District of Texas
————————————
NO. 01-25-00890-CV
———————————
ANDREW DUPONT, M.D., Appellant
V.
WILLIE HAWKINS, Appellee
On Appeal from the 113th District Court
Harris County, Texas
Trial Court Case No. 2024-80816
MEMORANDUM OPINION
This is an interlocutory appeal from the trial court’s order denying a motion
to dismiss a healthcare liability claim based on the failure to serve an expert report.
Willie Hawkins sued Dr. Andrew DuPont for medical negligence. To comply
with the Texas Medical Liability Act (“TMLA”), Hawkins was required to serve Dr.
DuPont with an expert report within 120 days after Dr. DuPont filed his original
answer. After the 120-day deadline, Dr. DuPont moved the trial court to dismiss the
suit against him for lack of service of any expert report.
In two issues, Dr. DuPont contends that the trial court erred by denying his
motion to dismiss because Hawkins failed to timely serve an expert report and res
ipsa loquitur does not create an exception to the expert report requirement.
We hold that Hawkins’s failure to serve an expert report by the statutory
deadline mandates dismissal of his claim against Dr. DuPont. We reverse and render.
Background
Willie Hawkins sued Dr. Andrew DuPont for medical negligence, alleging
that Dr. DuPont, while performing an endoscopic procedure to replace a stomach
tube used to administer medication, left the old tube inside Hawkins’s body. On
November 19, 2024, Dr. Jorge Carmona, a board-certified general surgeon, prepared
an expert report, but it was neither filed nor served on Dr. DuPont. On December
12, 2024, Dr. DuPont filed his original answer.
On April 22, 2025, Dr. DuPont moved the trial court to dismiss the claims
against him based on Hawkins’s failure to serve him with the expert report by the
statutory deadline. On May 19, 2025, Hawkins responded in opposition and attached
as an exhibit the expert report that he contends was inadvertently held in the draft
holding area of the efile system. He also attached a screen shot of his efile draft
section of the electronic filing system showing that he had a draft document that was
2
started on January 16, 2025. He explained the report was not filed due to a technical
issue of the efile system, and he was unaware the filing had not been completed until
Dr. DuPont moved to dismiss the suit. Hawkins requested that the trial court consider
his attempted filing as a deficiency, rather than a total failure to serve.
The trial court denied Dr. DuPont’s motion, and he appealed.
Analysis
In his first issue, Dr. DuPont contends that the trial court abused its discretion
in denying his motion to dismiss for failure to timely serve an expert report.
A. Standard of Review
We review a trial court’s decision on a motion to dismiss under the TMLA for
an abuse of discretion. Univ. of Tex. Health Sci. Ctr. v. Gutierrez, 237 S.W.3d 869,
871 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 2007, pet. denied). “Under that standard, [we]
defer to the trial court’s factual determinations if they are supported by evidence, but
review its legal determinations de novo.” Van Ness v. ETMC First Physicians, 461
S.W.3d 140, 142 (Tex. 2015). Whether the TMLA allows additional time beyond
the 120-day deadline is a legal question, which we review de novo. Stockton v.
Offenbach, 336 S.W.3d 610, 615 (Tex. 2011); Gutierrez, 237 S.W.3d at 871
(whether expert report was served was question of law reviewed de novo).
B. Applicable Law
3
A plaintiff asserting a health care liability claim must comply with the expert
report requirement of the Texas Medical Liability Act, Chapter 74 of the Texas Civil
Practice and Remedies Code (“TMLA”). Stockton, 336 S.W.3d at 614. The TMLA
requires a claimant to timely serve an expert report and the expert’s curriculum vitae
on each defendant physician and health care provider within 120 days after the
defendant’s original answer is filed. TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.351(a). If
the claimant has not served an expert report by the statutory deadline, “the court, on
the motion of the affected physician or health care provider, shall . . . dismiss[] the
claim . . . with prejudice.” Id. § 74.351(b). The TMLA’s 120-day deadline may be
extended under only two circumstances: (1) the affected parties have a written
agreement; and (2) the court grants one 30-day extension to allow the claimant to
cure a deficient report. Id. § 74.351(a), (c).
Although the TMLA does not define “serve,” Texas courts have interpreted
“serve” to require compliance with the Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 21a. See
Stockton, 336 S.W.3d at 615; Gutierrez, 237 S.W.3d at 872. This construction is
supported by the legislature’s replacement of the term “furnish” in the prior statute1
with the term “serve” when it enacted Chapter 74. See Stockton, 336 S.W.3d at 615;
Gutierrez, 237 S.W.3d at 872. Rule 21a authorizes service by electronic filing
1
TEX. REV. CIV. STAT. ANN. art. 4590i, § 13.01(d), repealed by Act of June 2,
2003, 78th Leg., R.S., ch. 204, § 10.09, 2003 Tex. Gen. Laws 847, 884.
4
manager, in person, by mail, by commercial delivery service, by fax, by email, or by
such other manner as the court in its discretion may direct. TEX. R. CIV. P. 21a.
Strict compliance with service of the expert report is mandatory, and the court
has no discretion to deny dismissal when no report was served and the parties did
not agree to extend the deadline. Zanchi v. Lane, 408 S.W.3d 373, 376 (Tex. 2013).
C. Failure to timely serve expert report
Dr. DuPont contends that he is entitled to dismissal of Hawkins’ medical
malpractice claims against him because Hawkins did not timely serve DuPont with
an expert report as required by the TMLA. Hawkins responds that he had fully
prepared the expert report within the 120-day deadline but failed to timely serve the
report because of a technical efile system malfunction, and the trial court correctly
treated the efile glitch as a curable deficiency, rather than an absent report.
The TMLA presents “a statute-of-limitations-type deadline within which
expert reports must be served.” Ogletree v. Matthews, 262 S.W.3d 316, 319 (Tex.
2007). If a claimant does not serve an expert report within the 120-day deadline, the
TMLA requires dismissal of the claim. TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.351(b);
see Garcia v. Gomez, 319 S.W.3d 638, 640 (Tex. 2010) (“If no report is timely
served, the trial court must, on motion, dismiss the claim and award reasonable
attorney’s fees and costs to the affected physician or provider.”).
5
Because Dr. DuPont filed his original answer on December 12, 2024,
Hawkins was required to serve his expert report by April 11, 2024. See TEX. CIV.
PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.351(b). The parties agree that Hawkins failed to serve a
report by the deadline.
Nevertheless, Hawkins contends his good faith effort combined with the efile
glitch constituted a curable deficiency rather than a total failure to serve an expert
report. Under the TMLA, “[i]f an expert report has not been served within the
[statutory period] because elements of the report are found deficient, the court may
grant one 30-day extension to the claimant in order to cure the deficiency.” Id.
§ 74.351(c). But “a deficient report differs from an absent report.” Hampton v.
Thome, 687 S.W.3d 496, 504 (Tex. 2024).
Hawkins explains he failed to timely serve the expert report because of a
technical glitch in the efile system. But a technical glitch does not excuse the
TMLA’s mandatory service requirement. See Thoyakulathu v. Brennan, 192 S.W.3d
849, 851 n.3, 853–54 (Tex. App.—Texarkana 2006, no pet.) (holding trial court
abused its discretion in denying motion to dismiss when claimant filed expert report
with court but did not timely serve it on defendant because of facsimile-machine
malfunction); see also Abilene Reg’l Med. Ctr. v. Pierce, 684 S.W.3d 564, 570–72
(Tex. App.—Eastland 2024, pet. denied) (holding trial court abused its discretion in
denying motion to dismiss when expert reports attached as exhibits to petition were
6
not served by automated or efiled service). “Electronic service is complete on
transmission of the document to the serving party’s electronic filing service
provider.” TEX. R. CIV. P. 21a(b)(3), quoted in Demerson v. Smith, 695 S.W.3d 853,
873 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 2024, pet. denied). A draft document that was
never transmitted is not recognized by Rule 21a or Section 74.351.2 See TEX. R. CIV.
P. 21a; TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.351(a), (c).
Additionally, a claimant’s good faith effort, due diligence, mistake, and lack
of prejudice on the party to be served cannot save a claimant from the TMLA’s
mandatory service requirement. Abilene Reg’l Med. Ctr., 684 S.W.3d at 570;
Herrera v. Seton Nw. Hosp., 212 S.W.3d 452, 459–60 (Tex. App.—Austin 2006, no
pet.) (expert report sent by regular mail was not service authorized by Rule 21a or
section 74.351(a)); Kendrick v. Garcia, 171 S.W.3d 698, 705 (Tex. App.—Eastland
2005, pet. denied) (holding trial court abused its discretion in denying motion to
dismiss based on claimant’s good faith effort to comply with TMLA’s mandatory
service requirement). “The plain language of the TMLA places the burden on the
2
At certain points in his brief, Hawkins explains he attempted to “file” the expert report
through the electronic filing system, but this Court has held that even timely filing an expert
report with the district clerk does not satisfy the TMLA’s service requirement. Acosta v.
Chheda, No. 01-07-00398-CV, 2007 WL 3227650, at *2 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.]
Nov. 1, 2007, pet. denied) (mem. op.); see TEX. R. CIV. P. 21a.
7
claimant to serve the report, not on the defendant to find the report.” Rinkle v. Graf,
658 S.W.3d 821, 826 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2022, no pet.)
The prior statute contained an exception for failure to timely furnish an expert
report if the court found the claimant’s failure “was not intentional or the result of
conscious indifference but was the result of an accident or mistake.” TEX. REV. CIV.
STAT. ANN. art. 4590i § 13.01(g) (2003), repealed by Act of June 2, 2003, 78th Leg.,
R.S., ch. 204, § 10.09, 2003 Tex. Gen. Laws 847, 884. But the legislature omitted
the “accident or mistake” exception when enacting Chapter 74. See TEX. CIV. PRAC.
& REM. CODE § 74.351; Kendrick, 171 S.W.3d at 705. Thus, whether the failure to
serve is the result of a mistake and whether no prejudice resulted are no longer
relevant concerns when deciding a motion to dismiss under Chapter 74. Badiga v.
Lopez, 274 S.W.3d 681, 684 (Tex. 2009).
Here, Hawkins demonstrated that the report existed and was in the draft
section of the efile system months before the deadline. However, when electronic
service is complete, “[t]he electronic filing manager will send confirmation of
service to the serving party.” TEX. R. CIV. P. 21a(b)(3). Hawkins apparently neither
received confirmation of service nor checked to see whether service occurred.
Hawkins’s mistake in failing to check service confirmation and the lack of prejudice
to Dr. DuPont do not prevent dismissal under Chapter 74. See Badiga, 274 S.W.3d
at 684 (finding irrelevant plaintiff’s explanation that failure to serve expert report
8
was mistake and medical records identifying doctor were already provided to
insurance carrier).
Hawkins contends that Rule 21(f)(6) should apply to give him a reasonable
extension to serve his expert report because his untimeliness was caused by a
technical failure. Rule 21(f)(6) states, “If a document is untimely due to a technical
failure or a system outage, the filing party may seek appropriate relief from the court.
If the missed deadline is one imposed by these rules, the filing party must be given
a reasonable extension of time to complete the filing.” TEX. R. CIV. P. 21(f)(6). But
that part of the rule addresses untimely electronic filing of court documents, not the
service of expert reports. See TEX. R. CIV. P. 21; Univ. of Tex. Med. Branch v. Callas,
497 S.W.3d 58, 65 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2016, pet. denied) (“An expert
report does not fall within any categories of filings listed in Rule 21 . . . .”). Further,
because the expert report service requirement is a statutory obligation under Chapter
74 rather than a filing deadline imposed by the Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule
21(f)(6) does not provide a basis for relief from the Chapter 74 service deadline. See
TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.002 (“In the event of a conflict between this
chapter and another law, including a rule of procedure . . . , this chapter controls to
the extent of the conflict.”).
9
We sustain Dr. DuPont’s first issue.3
Conclusion
We reverse the trial court’s denying Dr. DuPont’s motion to dismiss and
render judgment dismissing with prejudice Hawkins’s health care liability claim
against Dr. DuPont pursuant to section 74.351(b)(2).4 See TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM.
CODE § 74.351(b)(2).
Clint Morgan
Justice
Panel consists of Justices Caughey, Morgan, and Dokupil.
3
Because of our disposition of Dr. DuPont’s first issue, we need not reach his
second issue. See TEX. R. APP. P. 47.1.
4
Dr. DuPont does not seek reimbursement of his attorney’s fees or trial court costs.
See TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.351(b)(1).
10