In the Interest of J.H, A.H, J.H a Child v. Department of Family and Protective Services
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston)
Date FiledNovember 10, 2026
Docket01-25-00854-CV
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Opinion issued November 10, 2026
In The
Court of Appeals
For The
First District of Texas
————————————
NO. 01-25-00854-CV
———————————
IN THE INTEREST OF J.H, A.H, J.H., AND Z.H., MINOR CHILDREN
On Appeal from the 306th District Court
Galveston County, Texas
Trial Court Case No. 23-CP-0087
MEMORANDUM OPINION ON REHEARING
Appellants R.H. (“Mother”) and D.H. (“Father”) filed motions for rehearing
of our April 10, 2026 opinion and judgment. We deny the motions for rehearing,
withdraw our opinion and judgment of April 10, 2026, and issue this memorandum
opinion and judgment in their stead. Our disposition remains the same.1
R.H. (“Mother”) and D.H. (“Father”) challenge the final decree rendered in a
consolidated case terminating their parental rights to their minor children J.H.
(“James”), A.H. (“Alex”), J.H. (“Joseph”), and Z.H. (“Zoe”)2 based on the court’s
findings that both Mother and Father committed the predicate acts under Texas
Family Code Section 161.001(b)(1)(D), (E), and (L), and the termination of their
rights was in the best interest of James, Alex, Joseph, and Zoe.
On appeal, both parents argue that the trial court lacked jurisdiction because
the final decree was entered after the statutory dismissal date and the
commencement and recess of trial was a sham to circumvent the Texas Family
Code.
Both parents have challenged the legal and factual sufficiency of the
evidence to support the trial court’s finding that the Department made reasonable
efforts to return the children before commencement of trial on the merits and
despite those reasonable efforts, a continuing danger remains in the home that
1
Because we issue a new opinion, the motions for en banc reconsideration are
moot. See In re Wagner, 560 S.W.3d 311, 312 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.]
2018, orig. proceeding) (“Because we issue a new opinion in connection with
denial of rehearing, the motion for en banc reconsideration is rendered moot”).
2
We refer to appellants as Mother or Father, to the children by aliases, and to other
individuals by their initials or relationships to the children or parents. See TEX.
FAM. CODE § 109.002(d); TEX. R. APP. P. 9.8(b)(2).
2
prevents the return of the child to the parent. See TEX. FAM. CODE § 161.001(f).
Both parents challenge the legal and factual sufficiency to support the trial court’s
predicate act findings and its finding that termination of their rights was in the best
interest of their children. Father also argues that the court abused its discretion by
permitting the Department to amend its pleadings mid-trial.
We conclude that the trial court had jurisdiction when it entered its final
decree because the earlier commencement and recess of trial was not a sham to
circumvent the Texas Family Code. We affirm the trial court’s termination decree.
Background
I. Family History with Department
Mother has had eight children, four of whom she had with Father and are the
subject of this case. The Department was involved with the family seven times
between 2020 and November 2023, when James, Alex, and Joseph were removed.
The allegations included neglectful supervision of the children, medical neglect,
domestic violence, physical abuse of the children, intoxication (Mother), substance
abuse (marijuana and cocaine, both parents). The medical neglect case was ruled
out, and the two referrals from February and April 2020 were ruled “unable to
determine.” But in 2021 and three times in 2023, the cases were ruled “reason to
believe” for neglectful supervision and physical abuse of at least one older child. In
these instances, Mother or both Mother and Father tested positive for cocaine or
3
cocaine and marijuana by hair testing. Due to concern about the parents’ volatile
relationship, a safety plan was put in place in late September 2023 requiring Father
not to live with Mother and requiring both parents to remain sober.
II. Removal of James, Alex, and Joseph
In November 2023, three of Mother’s older four children were living with
Mother and Father along with James (4), Alex (3), and Joseph (2). In early
November 2023, Mother’s fourteen-year-old son came home in the evening and
found his mother intoxicated. The son complained about her intoxication, and a
verbal dispute turned physical. Mother threw an empty wine bottle at his head,
broke two additional wine bottles, and threw glass shards at him. He was cut on his
neck.
Galveston County Sheriff’s Deputy Guyton testified at trial that he had
responded to disturbances and family issues at Mother and Father’s house multiple
times in 2023, and he did so in November 2023. Mother claimed that the
disturbance was merely a disciplinary dispute because her son did not want to give
up his cell phone. The son’s wound was cleaned and treated by responding EMTs.
Mother was arrested for injury to a child. Mother was heavily intoxicated at the
time of her arrest, and she kicked Deputy Guyton as he led her, handcuffed, to his
patrol car. Thus, she was also charged with assault on a public servant. The three
older children left the home to stay with relatives and are not part of this case.
4
Father was working and not at home when this incident occurred. He posted bond
for Mother’s release from jail because he needed her to care for James, Alex, and
Joseph.
After the incident, Department investigator Marla Allen visited the family in
person. She spoke to the parents and explained that the Department was concerned
about the children due to the parents’ history with the Department and ongoing
issues with domestic violence and substance abuse. Mother believed she had not
done anything wrong, and Father did not understand the Department’s concern. He
believed that since the older children had left the home, the situation had been
resolved. Allen spent several hours with the parents attempting to contact friends
and relatives who could take custody of James, Alex, and Joseph, and when they
were unable to find someone, the Department removed the children from the home
and placed them in foster care.
According to Allen, when she removed them from the home that night, the
children were dirty and hungry, they had full and dirty diapers, and though the
parents packed a bag with belongings, it did not contain enough items to constitute
even a single outfit for one child. She testified that she found “reason to believe”
neglectful supervision by both parents of all three children, who were 2, 3, and 4
years old at the time of removal. The next day, she contacted Father to request
additional clothes for the children, and he expressed that he still did not understand
5
why the children had been removed. She testified that she explained the situation
and concerns to Father “multiple times, multiple ways.”
Hair samples were taken from the children after removal, and each tested
positive for cocaine. As a result, on November 17, 2023, Mother and Father were
each charged with abandoning or endangering a child. See TEX. PENAL CODE
22.041. They were arrested. Mother spent three or four months in Galveston
County Jail beginning in January 2024. Each parent had three separate indictments:
one for each child. On February 8, 2024, Father pleaded guilty and was placed on
five years’ deferred adjudication community supervision, running concurrently on
his three cases. On April 22, 2024, Mother pleaded guilty and was placed on five
years’ deferred adjudication community supervision, running concurrently on her
three cases. Among other things, both parents’ conditions of probation included the
requirements to commit no crimes, “abstain from the use or possession of any
drugs, except those taken or possessed under doctor’s orders,” “never become
intoxicated,” “abstain from the use of alcohol in any form at any time,” participate
in a drug screening program by submitting to a minimum of one drug test every 15
days. The conditions of probation stated that “failure to get a clean report from
such drug screening may alone be sufficient to revoke his/her Community
Supervision.”
6
III. Mother’s Pregnancy, Zoe’s Birth and Removal, Mother’s Third Arrest
Not long after the children were removed, Mother became pregnant with
Father’s child. On June 30, 2024, she was admitted to Harris Health System for
preterm labor. She was discharged the next day, and the discharge summary noted
that “her alcohol level on admit was 0.34.”
Zoe was born on August 17, 2024. When Zoe was two days old, Department
investigator Rose Evans-Stinson met with Mother, who was still in the hospital.
Mother informed her that she last used cocaine in 2023, and Mother denied
drinking alcohol. Mother had no recollection of the June 30, 2024 admission at
Harris Health when she had an elevated blood alcohol content. The investigator
tried contacting Father, but his phone number had been disconnected, so she
initiated a search for him. At that time, Mother and Father were no longer living
together, and Mother was living with E.E., an elderly woman, in Galveston. Due to
the history of Department involvement, the ongoing case, Mother’s history of
substance abuse, and the more recent hospitalization with high blood alcohol
content, the Department was concerned about a safe placement for Zoe. The
investigator concluded that there was reason to believe that Mother had committed
“neglectful supervision” based on her documented intoxication during the third
trimester of her pregnancy with Zoe in violation of the orders entered in the
ongoing case.
7
The investigator spent time with Mother trying to locate a suitable placement
for Zoe, but when they were unable to locate such a placement, the Department
sought custody of the newborn. Upon release from the hospital on August 20,
2024, the Department placed the baby with Mother’s friend, L.P. The Department
allowed Mother and L.P. to work out days and times of visitation because they
were on good terms, with the caveat that Mother was to be supervised during all
periods of visitation. While L.P. had custody of Zoe, Mother saw her daily.
A month later, on September 20, 2024, L.P. told Mother that she would no
longer be caring for Zoe. Mother testified that she “freaked out” and took Zoe to
her friend E.E.’s house. At trial, Mother acknowledged that she lacked permission
to take Zoe and that this was not a good decision. After a conversation with her
counsel, Mother turned Zoe over to a Department caseworker around 10:00 p.m.
that night. But when the new foster mother took custody, she noticed that Zoe was
displaying signs of pain, grunting, and unable to move one arm. With permission
from the Department, Zoe was taken to the hospital, where she was found to have
suffered a spiral fracture to her left arm, which the hospital records described as a
“nonaccidental injury to a child.”
Mother was indicted for the felony offense of injury to a child “by criminal
negligence, caus[ing] bodily injury to Z.H., a child 14 years of age or younger, by
recklessly picking up the infant child in such a way as to cause a fracture in the
8
child’s arm.” Based on this alleged offense and other violations of the conditions
of probation, the State filed a motion to adjudicate Mother’s guilt and revoke
community supervision in each of the three cases of abandoning or endangering a
child. For the third time in the course of this case, Mother was again confined in
the Galveston County Jail. At trial, she testified that she had turned down a plea
deal and had been in jail for about seven or eight months.
IV. Trial Testimony
At trial, the Department presented testimony from M.H. (foster mother), T.J.
Williams (the Department’s conservatorship worker), Mark Knox (Court
Appointed Special Advocates volunteer), the Galveston County Sheriff’s Deputy
who responded to the incident with the thrown wine bottle, and the two
Department investigators who investigated the removals of the boys and then Zoe.3
The Department also introduced Family Service Plans, court orders, medical
records, drug test results, indictments, orders of deferred adjudication, motions to
adjudicate, Zoe’s birth certificate, photographs, DNA test results, a report from
Mother’s psychosocial assessment, and various other documents. Mother also
testified.
3
The testimony of the Galveston County Sheriff’s Deputy and the two Department
investigators has already been detailed in sections II and III, above.
9
A. M.H.’s testimony
M.H. is the foster mother who welcomed James, Alex, and Joseph in
November 2023. At the time of trial, Alex and Joseph remained in her home, along
with her three biological children. She testified that while she is licensed as a
foster-to-adopt placement, she did not intend to adopt Alex or Joseph, but they
were welcome to stay in her home as long as needed to find them a permanent
placement. Because M.H. is a stay-at-home mother, she was with James, Alex, and
Joseph all the time when they initially came into care.
James. M.H. said that James was in her home for about 13 months before he
was moved to an adoptive placement at the end of 2024. She said he had just
turned 4 years old when he arrived, and she described his behavior as “typical,”
noting that he easily became upset, displayed jealousy with his siblings, and had
difficulty sharing. He attended weekly play therapy to learn to use words instead of
emotional outbursts and to learn to share. M.H. took him to all his appointments.
Alex. Alex was almost 3 years old when he came into foster care. At first, he
had outbursts involving throwing himself on the ground, hitting and kicking his
brothers and other family members, hurting himself, throwing things, and
screaming. Alex had difficulty with eye contact, speech delays, and repetitive
behaviors. He was diagnosed with autism, for which he receives 10 hours a week
of Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA) therapy at home. M.H. said the ABA
10
therapy is typically three or four days a week from the time Alex comes home from
school until bedtime. The ABA therapy is helping him learn to communicate about
toileting needs, share toys, be gentler with caregivers and siblings, and reduce the
duration and frequency of tantrums. He attends a full-day special education
program at a local public school, and he rides a bus. Alex receives 30 minutes of
group speech therapy weekly at his school.
M.H. testified that Alex’s speech has improved during foster care, and he
now speaks in sentences. Though he still has daily tantrums, she finds that he can
be redirected, and he less frequently throws himself on the ground. However,
sometimes he hurts himself during tantrums. She said that his tantrums tend to be
triggered by wanting something that another person has, being told “no,” and times
of transition. He does not display stimming behavior.
M.H. said that Alex takes a “tiny dose” of clonidine at bedtime to help him
sleep. Though it has been effective for about a year, his doctor is considering
transitioning him off of the medication.
Joseph. Joseph was 2 years old when he came into foster care. M.H. said
that Joseph had some speech delays and difficulty expressing himself when he
arrived. Initially, she took him to multiple early childhood intervention
appointments each week. She also ensured that he received twice monthly
therapies at home. Most of the therapies and interventions were aimed at
11
addressing speech and motor skills. At trial, she said that Joseph attends afternoon,
half-day pre-kindergarten at the local public school where he receives special
education instruction. He receives 30 minutes of group speech therapy once a week
at school, and 45 minutes to one hour of speech therapy every other week at
UTMB. As a result of the interventions and therapies, Joseph is now talking more
and better able to express his wants and needs. She said he still has some tantrums,
and they are working on that aspect of his behavior.
Joseph, who sees a behavioral doctor every three months for sleep issues,
wakes early about twice a week, remaining awake for four hours. When he
awakens early, he displays “stimming” behavior. M.H. said that she usually stays
awake with him. Sometimes he displays stimming behavior during the day as well,
and M.H. testified that she had been advised to ignore the behaviors unless he is
harming himself. Joseph wears a helmet every day because he sometimes hits his
head. At the time of trial, he was still in diapers. Joseph takes melatonin at night to
help him calm down and sleep.
M.H. said that both Alex and Joseph have hit her, her husband, their three
biological children, and their older brother James. Both become emotional after
visits with Father, crying, screaming, and having difficulty falling asleep. Joseph
routinely wakes up around 2:00 a.m. after visits with Father. She said they display
similar behaviors after visits with Mother, especially being emotional and crying.
12
However, neither displayed any reaction when James was moved to an adoptive
placement.
B. Department Caseworker T.J. Williams’s Testimony
Williams testified that he had been assigned to the case involving James,
Alex, and Joseph since just after they were initially removed to foster care. He later
also became the conservatorship worker for Zoe.
James. Williams testified at trial that James had been in his placement five
or six months, and the foster parents have expressed interest in adopting him.
Alex and Joseph. Because Alex and Joseph were not in an adoptive
placement, the Department planned to search for a permanent placement for them.
He said that because of the autism and developmental delay diagnoses, it “would
be a more delicate process.” However, Williams testified that neither Alex nor
Joseph would be moved except to an adoptive placement. Williams also said that
when Alex was initially diagnosed and the children were receiving therapy, he
invited Mother and Father to attend, particularly because he wanted to ensure that
they understood Alex’s autism diagnosis and could be equipped to deal with those
behaviors if the children were reunified with the parents. Mother did not attend the
therapies, but Williams acknowledged that it was possible she had a conflict with
employment. Father attended only one session, and when he was invited to other
appointments, he said that he was working.
13
Williams testified that Joseph is suspected to be on the autism spectrum and
has a diagnosed speech disorder for which he receives speech therapy at school
once or twice a week.
Zoe. Williams testified that Father was confirmed by DNA testing to be the
biological father of Zoe. He testified that she is in an adoptive placement, and the
caregivers work with him to facilitate sibling visitation at least twice a month. He
mentioned there was an additional visit for her recent birthday. He said the
children are all familiar with each other and have an opportunity to interact.
Williams testified that while Mother’s family service plan required her to
remain alcohol-free, she was hospitalized in the third trimester of her pregnancy
with Zoe with a blood alcohol content of 0.34. Williams said this concerned the
Department because he believed that “level of intoxication . . . could be
significantly damaging to the infant,” but he acknowledged that Zoe did not test
positive for alcohol at birth and was not showing signs of fetal alcohol syndrome.
Williams testified about the night Mother took Zoe from L.P.’s home and
later returned her to Williams at a nearby firehouse. He said that he took the baby
back to L.P.’s house to retrieve some care items before taking her to her foster care
placement around 9:00 or 10:00 p.m. When he returned home about 20 minutes
later, the foster mother called and told him that Zoe’s “arm was not moving
correctly and that she was very fussy and upset.” Williams joined the foster mother
14
and Zoe at the hospital, where Zoe was diagnosed with a fractured arm. He said
she did not need surgery because she was able to heal with immobilization.
He testified that this incident was the basis for Mother’s recent indictment,
which was pending, along with the motions to adjudicate on the three earlier
counts of child endangerment.
Mother. Williams testified that Mother missed a number of her visits with
the children, including some because she attempted to confirm just outside the
required 24-hour window. Williams testified that he tried to work with Mother on
that by offering to set up text or email reminders or an alarm and by reminding her
that she did not need to confirm only the day before the visit and that she could
confirm much earlier. He also agreed to virtual visits with the boys when Mother
was pregnant with Zoe and informed Williams she needed to be on bed rest.
Williams said Mother had monthly visits with the boys and weekly visits
with Zoe after she was placed in foster care. He testified that Mother attended
around half of the visits with the boys, but she missed over half of the visits with
Zoe. Williams testified that the visits with the boys went “okay,” but there “were a
couple of days where some concerning things occurred.” For example, once when
she was pregnant with Zoe, Williams witnessed her grab James “in an aggressive
manner” after he ran from her to play on the slides instead of staying with her and
his little brothers. Williams said she once brought gifts for the children and
15
prepared a meal for one visit early on. He testified that Mother was prepared for
visits with Zoe, and she brought a homemade lotion she used when changing her.
Williams said that Mother’s behavior at some visits made him question her
sobriety.
Williams testified that Mother completed many of the services on her family
service plan. Williams said he went over the family service plan with Mother twice
in depth and once in a rush. Mother completed parenting class, she was doing
individual therapy while in jail, she built a support group, she completed a drug
and alcohol assessment, she participated in some random drug testing. Williams
testified that Mother had multiple urine drug and alcohol tests that were negative,
and two positive tests for alcohol. He also testified that she tested negative on hair
follicle testing in June 2024, but she twice refused hair follicle testing.
Williams testified that Mother did not provide stable housing. He visited the
house she shared with E.E., an elderly woman, in Galveston. He testified that the
first time he saw the residence it showed damage from flooding, including a hole in
the living room floor that permitted entry of pests. At one point, he saw roaches
gathered at the top of the ceiling. A few months later, there was evidence of
repairs, but the floor was unfinished, and he noticed issues with cleanliness. He
said the house “still wasn’t safe for any youth.” Mother told Williams that she did
16
not have a lease, but she had an agreement with E.E. to perform various tasks in
exchange for living there.
Williams testified that in addition to the disrepair of the house, return of the
children to Mother to live with E.E. was problematic because he had not been able
to run a background check E.E.’s adult son who either lived in the house or
frequently had access to it. He testified that he did not recall whether he had asked
the son for identifying information to run the background check, but E.E. had
refused to provide the information.
On the last day of trial, in September 2025, Williams testified that Mother
was in the Galveston County Jail awaiting a court date on her charge of injury to
child regarding the fracture of Zoe’s arm. Williams said that Mother’s
incarceration was an impediment to reunification because there is no way to do a
monitored return of the children when the parent is in jail.
Williams testified that he made efforts to help Mother reunify with her
children, by assuring her classes and services continued, reaching out to contact
family members, and working with Mexican consulate regarding a potential
placement. He said he visited Mother four or five times in the Galveston County
Jail. He said he saw Mother in September 2025, reviewed aspects of the case, and
showed her a slideshow of all her children.
17
Mother spent a few months in Galveston County Jail beginning in January
2024. Mother’s psychosocial assessment found that she had “experienced
significant trauma and abuse during childhood and has continued this pattern with
her own children. She has a history of involving herself with abusive partners
which likely stems from her childhood.” Mother was diagnosed with major
depressive disorder and alcohol abuse. Individual counseling was recommended,
and she participated.
Throughout the case, Mother lived in a variety of places, including homeless
shelters, motels, on friends’ couches, and with E.E. Mother told the Department
that she worked for close family friends and neighbors, and that she worked three
days a week for a local beauty supply store. The record did not include evidence of
how long she worked there or how much she earned.
Williams testified the Department would not consider returning the children
to Mother because she had not provided proof of residency, she was currently
incarcerated, and there was a lingering question about her sobriety. He also said he
had not seen a positive change in Mother’s behavior, and he believed it was in the
best interest of all the children for Mother’s rights to be terminated.
Father. Williams testified that Father had a history of domestic violence and
substance abuse and was unable to meet the children’s basic needs.
18
Williams testified that Father’s visits with the boys “went really, really
well.” He said Father missed at least five visits with them, but he did not regularly
visit with Zoe. He said Father mostly said he missed visits with Zoe due to his
work schedule or being “busy.” At one point, Father said he was being evicted.
Father missed “a lot” of visits with Zoe because he failed to confirm at least 24
hours in advance. While Father claimed to miss visits with his children due to
work, Williams testified that in September 2025 Father had not provided a check
stub in the preceding six months, and that the last check stub he saw from Father
was from December 2024. Williams testified that he told Father if he could provide
proof of employment, the Department would add time to the next visit or add a
Saturday visit.
Father was required by his family service plan to demonstrate sobriety
through urine and hair follicle testing. Father’s family service plan, like Mother’s,
states: “Throughout the life of this case, [Father] will submit to random drug
testing (urinalysis or hair follicle) at the discretion of the Department. All drug
tests will produce a negative result. A photo ID is required to take all drug tests. If
[Father’s] drug tests are adulterated, or he fails to submit to testing on the
requested date, the test will be treated as a positive test.”
Father tested positive for cocaine by urinalysis in July 2024, for cocaine by
hair follicle analysis in August 2024, and for cocaine by urinalysis in April 2025.
19
Williams also testified that Father tested positive in January 2025 for cocaine
based on a test required by community supervision.
Williams said Father participated in less than half of the requested random
drug tests. On more than one occasion, Father submitted for the urinalysis test, but
not on the date requested, which allowed him to “dilute or cheat the test.” Father
missed more than one urinalysis test completely. Father refused hair follicle testing
after the positive result in April 2025. Williams said: “At the level in which his
hair follicle produced in April, the Department would want to see another hair
follicle of a decreasing result.” Williams also said that he had seen Father with a
beard multiple times since April 2025, and Father had enough facial hair to submit
for testing. Williams frequently reminded Father about residency, proof of
employment, and submitting to hair follicle testing. Williams testified that missed
drug tests are considered to be positive test results.
Earlier in 2025, Williams visited the home where Father was living and
observed both serious and minor issues. Father had duct taped a microwave to the
wall, creating a hazard because it could fall on a child. The home had power but
limited light. It was excessively dusty and needed cleaning. Williams offered to
bring Father cleaning supplies and help him clean the residence the following
weekend, but Father declined the offer. Father later told Williams that he was
being evicted from that home. But at trial Williams said he was not certain where
20
Father lived. Father had refused to provide the information or promised to bring it
with him to visits with his children and failed to do so.
Williams testified that Father had provided only three or four check stubs
proving that he was employed. Williams testified in September 2025 Father had
not provided a check stub in the preceding six months and that the last check stub
he saw from Father was from December 2024. Father repeatedly promised to bring
the documentation to visits with his children, but he did not. Father told Williams
that he worked for Amazon or a third-party company that did package handling
and delivery for Amazon. However, Father had filed a pauper’s oath application on
August 18, 2025, in a criminal case pending in Galveston County. While the nature
of the criminal charges was not disclosed at trial, the content of the pauper’s oath
application showed that Father had “$0” in earnings and “$0” at home, in savings,
in checking, owed to him, or in a safety deposit box. Father listed “Galveston
Yacht Marina” as the last job he had or efforts to gain employment, but Williams
said Father never mentioned working there. Williams said that the address on the
pauper’s oath application was the same address from which Father said he had
been evicted.
Williams said Father was living with his girlfriend, K.W., who leased the
home in her name. Williams said he looked into K.W.’s background and found two
21
concerning elements that would have prevented the Department from placing the
children in a home with her.
Williams testified that he did not believe that Father understood Alex’s or
Joseph’s special needs and had only expressed “a limited capacity” for willingness
to learn about autism and necessary therapies. Williams testified that he did not
believe it was safe to return the children to Father because he did not know where
Father lives, whether he is sober, or the nature of his relationship with K.W. He
believed it was in the best interest of all the children for Father’s rights to be
terminated.
C. CASA Mark Knox’s Testimony
CASA volunteer Mark Knox testified that he had been working the case
since James, Alex, and Joseph were removed, about 22 months in total by the time
of trial. He said that he visited the children and the foster families in their homes,
attended doctor’s appointments and therapies, observed visits with Mother and
Father, and interacted with their schools. On average, he estimated that he
interacted with the children at least once a week.
Zoe. Mark testified that Zoe had been in a foster-to-adopt placement since
February 2025, and she was the only child in the home. He said she was doing
“very well.” He testified that Zoe was up-to-date on all medical and dental
appointments, was developmentally on target, and had no special needs. He said
22
that CASA’s goal for Zoe was termination of parental rights and adoption. Knox
testified Father attended 6 of 23 visits scheduled with Zoe, and Mother attended 6
of about 21 scheduled visits with Zoe. Knox testified that Father’s visits with Zoe
were “okay,” and that he has been attentive to Zoe, talking to her, playing with her,
and cuddling with her. As to Mother’s visits, he said, “She, especially at first, was
nurturing but sometimes she would also get kind of emotional and almost erratic
and would quite frequently end the visit very abruptly.”
James, Alex, Joseph. Knox was aware that all three boys had tested positive
for cocaine just after removal. Knox testified that James’s adoptive placement was
going well, that he was succeeding in school, attending lots of activities, and was
nurtured.
Mother and Father. Knox testified that Father attended 16 of 23 visits
scheduled with the boys. He testified that Father’s hour-long visits with the boys
went “fairly well.” He described Father as attentive and nurturing. Mother attended
more than half of the 16 visits scheduled with the boys but not as many as Father
attended. Knox testified that Mother’s visits with the children “go okay,” but that
she “can be distracted,” “can get agitated,” and “is not as capable of supervising
them, keeping them in control.” Knox testified that he did not believe that either
parent had the skills and knowledge to pursue autism therapies with Alex and
Joseph. As to Father, he based his opinion in part on his in-person observations of
23
Father, his home, and Knox’s opinion that Father “cannot even establish a safe
home for himself.”
Based on Mother’s testimony about Father’s use of cocaine, Knox was
concerned that Father was still using cocaine. Knox testified that it was in the best
interest of all the children for their parents’ rights to be terminated because neither
had “established [a] safe place to live, stable employment, they haven’t avoided
criminal activity, they haven’t maintained sobriety.” He believed that returning the
children to the parents would create a risk of the children regressing and
experiencing future trauma. He said he had not seen a positive change in Father’s
behavior or Mother’s behavior and that there would be no benefit in returning the
children to their parents. He also testified that neither parent had given any proof to
him that he or she could provide a safe home for the children. Knox also
considered the parents’ positive drug tests during the course of the case, their lack
of income, and Mother’s incarceration. He also testified that he had tried to make
contact with people whose names Mother or Father gave him as potential
placements for the children.
D. Mother’s Testimony
Mother was 39 years old when she testified at trial in September 2025. She
is the mother of eight children. Two live with relatives in Arlington, Texas, one
24
lives with his father in Houston, and five are in foster care. Four are the subject of
this case.
Mother said that in November 2023, she was drinking alcohol on weekends,
but she did not recall how much she drank. She denied being intoxicated during the
incident in which she threw a wine bottle at her son. She said alcohol did not affect
her judgment, and it was a dispute about his cell phone. She acknowledged that it
was not a good decision, but she said she wanted his phone because the family was
about to have dinner. She said the three little boys were in the living room during
the altercation with her teen son. Mother also acknowledged that she was working
on services with the Department at the time, and she was supposed to remain drug-
and alcohol- free. She denied seeing any injury on her son. She testified that she
spent a week in jail and was sentenced to time served.
Mother testified that she was on deferred adjudication community
supervision for child endangerment stemming from the little boys’ positive cocaine
tests. She said she had to follow conditions including reporting to a probation
officer, completing community service, paying fees, discontinuing communication
with Father, submitting to drug testing, and avoiding more criminal charges.
Mother initially admitted that she had previously used marijuana but denied
ever using cocaine. She said she was aware that Father used cocaine when the
children were asleep. She said he used cocaine in the bathroom (a bathroom
25
accessible to the children), and she could tell he had used based on his behavioral
changes and the money missing from their account.
Mother then admitted that she used cocaine with Father once a month in an
attempt to keep him from going to bars and spending the family’s rent money. She
said she was charged with child endangerment for allowing cocaine to be in the
house around the children. She acknowledged a point of view from which that
could be wrong, but she said, “From my point of view, I just try to keep a roof over
my kids’ head.” In November 2023, Father was the sole breadwinner for the
family. She said she could not kick him out of the house because his name was on
the lease.
In January 2024, she was in the Galveston County Jail for three or four
months. After that, she lived in shelters or with friends before living with E.E. for
about six months. Mother said she primarily worked for E.E., but she also worked
at “the cotton shed” in Galveston for a month because her schedule was 7 days a
week, 13-hour shifts, and that schedule did not allow her to see her children.
At trial in September 2025, Mother said she had been in Galveston County
Jail for seven months and had turned down a plea deal. She said the Department
went over the family service plan with her, and it was mentioned in court, but she
did not really understand what she had to do. She was not sure what services were
left to be completed on her family service plan, and she believed she had complied
26
with drug testing. She did, however, acknowledge missing some drug tests due to
lack of transportation. She said she asked for help with transportation but did not
rece