Cargill Meat Solutions Corp. v. A. K. A. Wahbah (WCAB)
CourtCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket1157 C.D. 2025
JudgeFizzano Cannon
StatusUnpublished
đ° News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Cargill Meat Solutions Corp., :
Petitioner :
:
v. :
:
Abdul Karim A. Wahbah (Workersâ :
Compensation Appeal Board), : No. 1157 C.D. 2025
Respondent : Submitted: September 14, 2026
BEFORE: HONORABLE CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge
HONORABLE LORI A. DUMAS, Judge
HONORABLE BONNIE BRIGANCE LEADBETTER, Senior Judge
OPINION NOT REPORTED
MEMORANDUM OPINION
BY JUDGE FIZZANO CANNON FILED: November 16, 2026
Cargill Meat Solutions Corp. (Employer) petitions for review of the
August 8, 2025 Opinion (Board Opinion) of the Workersâ Compensation Appeal
Board (Board), which affirmed a July 10, 2024 decision (WCJ Decision) of a
Workersâ Compensation Judge (WCJ) that granted, in part, a claim petition filed by
Abdul Karim A. Wahbah (Claimant). Upon review, we affirm the Board Opinion.
I. Factual and Procedural Background
Claimant began working for Employer in October of 2022 as a meat
packer and cutter, positions that required repetitive motion/use of his right arm and
hand for eight hours a day. See WCJ Decision at 3, Findings of Fact (F.F.) 5-6,
Certified Record (C.R.) at 30. On February 16, 2023, Claimant sustained an injury
in the course of his employment described as a right wrist strain. See Board Opinion
at 1, C.R. at 77; see also WCJ Decision at 3, F.F. 1, C.R. at 30. Employer issued a
Medical Only Notice of Temporary Compensation Payable on March 2, 2023, which
converted to a Notice of Compensation Payable by operation of law on May 18,
2023. See Board Opinion at 1, C.R. at 77; WCJ Decision at 3, F.F. 1, C.R. at 30; see
also Notice of Conversion of Temporary Compensation Payable to Compensation
Payable, C.R. at 557-59.
On May 23, 2023, Claimant filed a claim petition seeking to expand the
description of his work injury to include right hand extensor tendinitis and cervical
radiculopathy (Claim Petition). See Board Opinion at 1, C.R. at 77; see also WCJ
Decision at 3, F.F. 2, C.R. at 30. Claimant also sought total disability benefits from
February 17, 2023, and ongoing via the Claim Petition. See Board Opinion at 1,
C.R. at 77; see also WCJ Decision at 3, F.F. 2, C.R. at 30.
Claimant testified before the WCJ in the hearing on the Claim Petition.1
See WCJ Decision at 3-5, F.F. 5-20, C.R. at 30-32; see also August 9, 2023
Transcript (Tr. 8-9-2023) at 6-12, C.R. at 114-20; August 30, 2023 Transcript (Tr.
8-30-2023) at 8-51, C.R. at 132-75. Claimant testified that, starting in October of
2022, he worked for Employer in multiple positions, including as a meatpacker,
which positions required repeated motion of his right arm and hand. See WCJ
Decision at 3, F.F. 5-6, C.R. at 30; see also Tr. 8-9-2023 at 9-12, C.R. at 117-20; Tr.
8-30-2023 at 10-13, C.R. at 134-37. Claimant testified that he began to experience
pain in his right shoulder and right wrist in November of 2022. See WCJ Decision
at 3, F.F. 7, C.R. at 30; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 14-15, C.R. at 138-39. He explained
1
Claimant first testified before the WCJ remotely on August 9, 2023. See WCJ Decision
at 3, C.R. at 30. However, due to technical difficulties, the WCJ took only minimal testimony on
August 9, 2023. See id. Claimant continued his testimony in person on August 30, 2023. See id.
2
that he spoke to his supervisor about the symptoms two or three times and treated
with the staff nurse, who said that Claimantâs condition was normal, provided him
with ibuprofen, and ultimately returned him to work. See WCJ Decision at 3, F.F.
7-8, C.R. at 30; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 15, C.R. at 139. Claimant was given
alternative duties for a time but was ultimately returned to his regular duty
assignment. See WCJ Decision at 3, F.F. 8, C.R. at 30; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 16,
C.R. at 140.
Claimant testified that he then began work as a meat cutter in January
2023. See WCJ Decision at 3, F.F. 8, C.R. at 30; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 17-18,
C.R. at 141-42. Claimant experienced pain again later that month while shaving fat
off of meat. See WCJ Decision at 3, F.F. 9, C.R. at 30; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 18,
C.R. at 142. His arm became swollen and he reported to his supervisor, who sent
Claimant to the staff nurse. See WCJ Decision at 3, F.F. 9, C.R. at 30; see also Tr.
8-30-2023 at 18-19, C.R. at 142-43.
Claimant subsequently presented to the emergency room of the
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC) in Harrisburg for medical
treatment on February 17, 2023, and a physician took him out of work for two or
three days. See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F. 10, C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at
19-20, C.R. at 143-44. UPMC personnel gave Claimant a 10-pound lifting
restriction and directed that he not use his right hand. See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F.
11, C.R. at 31. Upon his return to work, Employer gave Claimant left-handed work
that consisted of placing cards on meat, which task Claimant testified he performed
inside a freezer. See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F. 11, C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023
at 22, C.R. at 146. Claimant explained that he experienced pain in his neck, his right
shoulder, and his right hand when performing the modified duty position in the cold
3
environment. See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F. 11, C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at
23-24, C.R. at 147-48.
Claimant did not work for a 4-week period in March 2023 through April
of 2023. See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F. 19, C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 48-
50, C.R. at 172-74. He returned on April 7, 2023, with restrictions from his treating
physician that included the previous 10-pound lifting restriction and an additional
restriction against working in cold environments.2 See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F. 19,
C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 49-51, C.R. at 173-74. Claimant requested to
be moved from the cold environment work but was informed there was no work
available for him within his restrictions. See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F. 12, C.R. at 31;
see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 24, C.R. at 148. Believing he had no choice due to the
excruciating and intolerable pain, Claimant left his employment in April of 2023.
See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F. 12, C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 25-27, C.R. at
149-51.
Claimant currently works as a Lyft driver, which he has done since
August of 2023. See WCJ Decision at 4, F.F. 17, C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023
at 8-9 & 31-32, C.R. at 132-33 & 155-56. He has received injections in his neck and
continues to experience neck, right shoulder, and right hand pain. See WCJ Decision
at 4, F.F. 13, C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 27-28, C.R. at 151-52.
Claimant also presented the deposition testimony of William A. Rolle,
Jr., M.D., before the WCJ. See WCJ Decision at 5-8, F.F. 21-46, C.R. at 32-35; see
also Rolle Depo., C.R. at 215-286. Dr. Rolle is board-certified in physical medicine
2
Claimant stated that he reported to his doctors that he worked in a cold environment but
expressly denied that he requested restrictions from working in cold environments. See WCJ
Decision at 4, F.F. 16, C.R. at 31; see also Tr. 8-30-2023 at 48, C.R. at 172.
4
and rehabilitation with a subspecialty certification in pain management. 3 See Rolle
Depo. at 5-6, C.R. at 219-20. Dr. Rolle is Claimantâs treating physician at the
Orthopedic Institute of PA (OIP). See Rolle Depo. at 6, C.R. at 220. Dr. Rolle
reviewed Claimantâs medical records from the UPMC emergency room, as well as
those from his practice, OIP, and from OSS Health Urgent Care (OSS), the medical
provider to which Employer had sent Claimant. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 21,
C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 8, C.R. at 222. He also reviewed the Independent
Medical Evaluation (IME) report of Dr. Jay V. Kalawadia. See Rolle Depo. at 8,
C.R. at 222.
Dr. Rolle explained that Claimant presented to the UPMC Emergency
Room on February 17, 2023, with pain and swelling in his right hand. See WCJ
Decision at 5, F.F. 21, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 9, C.R. at 223. Physical
examination revealed mild swelling over the dorsal aspect of Claimantâs right hand.
See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 21, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 9, C.R. at 223.
X-rays were taken of Claimantâs hand, which proved negative. See WCJ Decision
at 5, F.F. 21, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 11, C.R. at 225. UPMC Emergency
Room physicians prescribed Naprosyn, an anti-inflammatory, and recommended
Claimant see an orthopedist. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 21, C.R. at 32; see also
Rolle Depo. at 9, C.R. at 223.
Dr. Rolle testified that, on February 20, 2023, Claimant presented to
OIP and was seen by a physicianâs assistant for complaints of swelling and pain in
his right hand. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 22, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at
3
Dr. Rolle completed his undergraduate degree at the University of Rochester in 1985 and
his medical degree at Hahnemann University in 1990. See Rolle Depo. at 5-6, C.R. at 219-20. He
completed his residency in physical medicine and rehabilitation at Jefferson Hospital in
Philadelphia in 1994. See id.
5
9, C.R. at 223. Claimant explained that he was a meat cutter and used a knife to
chop meat all day, which work he described as repetitive, indicating that it led to
pain over the dorsal aspect of his right hand. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 22, C.R.
at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 10-11, C.R. at 224-25. OIP personnel diagnosed
Claimant with right hand extensor tendonitis, prescribed a course of oral steroids to
reduce inflammation, and gave Claimant a right-hand splint. See WCJ Decision at
5, F.F. 22, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 10, C.R. at 224.
Dr. Rolle further testified that, on February 21, 2023, Claimant
presented to OSS with complaints of right wrist and hand pain. See WCJ Decision
at 5, F.F. 23, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 11, C.R. at 225. Claimant had told
OSS personnel that his symptoms began approximately one week prior and he gave
a history of repetitive motions performed at work. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 23,
C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 11, C.R. at 225. The physical exam at OSS
revealed mild swelling over the dorsal aspect of Claimantâs right wrist and hand,
tenderness over the dorsal aspect of his right wrist and hand, and mild tenderness
over his right forearm. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 23, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle
Depo. at 11-12, C.R. at 225-26. A decreased range of motion was observed due to
wrist pain. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 23, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 12,
C.R. at 226. OSS personnel allowed Claimant to return to work full-time with the
restrictions of wearing a right wrist brace and no use of his right upper extremity.
See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 23, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 12, C.R. at 226.
Dr. Rolle testified that Claimant returned to OSS on March 1, 2023,
with complaints of pain from his right hand up into his elbow and right
shoulder/shoulder blade area. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 24, C.R. at 32; see also
Rolle Depo. at 12-13, C.R. at 226-27. At this time, Claimant stated that the pain
6
actually began two to three months prior and had been gradually increasing. See
WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 24, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 13, C.R. at 227. OSS
personnel diagnosed Claimant with cervical radiculopathy, neck pain, and pain in
the right arm and wrist. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 24, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle
Depo. at 13, C.R. at 227. OSS personnel also ordered physical therapy (PT) and
directed Claimant to follow up with physiatry in two to three weeks. See Rolle Depo.
at 14, C.R. at 228. Claimant was then recommended to complete the course of
prednisone4 and was released back to work with restrictions of no right extremity
use. See Rolle Depo. at 14, C.R. at 228.
Dr. Rolle testified that Claimant returned to his practice on March 10,
2023, this time with complaints of pain in his neck, right shoulder, and right arm, in
addition to the pain in his right hand and wrist. See WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 26, C.R.
at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 16, C.R. at 230. Claimant now reported pain radiating
down to his right hand with intermittent numbness and paresthesias in the hand. See
WCJ Decision at 5, F.F. 26, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 16, C.R. at 230.
Claimant stated that his pain rating at this time was an 8 out of 10. See WCJ Decision
at 5, F.F. 26, C.R. at 32; see also Rolle Depo. at 17, C.R. at 231. Claimant also
reported that the symptoms were made worse by cold environments, which
environments Dr. Rolle explained can decrease circulation, and in turn decrease
blood flow, which can cause stiffness and a restricted range-of-motion, and can
exacerbate pain. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 26, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo.
at 17, C.R. at 231. Dr. Rolle diagnosed Claimant with cervical radiculopathy, which
he explained was irritation of the cervical spine nerves on the right side. See WCJ
4
Dr. Rolle explained that prednisone is an oral steroid used to treat inflammation. See
Rolle Depo. at 14, C.R. at 228.
7
Decision at 6, F.F. 26, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 17, C.R. at 231. Dr. Rolle
also diagnosed Claimant with right hand extensor tendonitis. See WCJ Decision at
6, F.F. 26, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 17, C.R. at 231. As a result of these
diagnoses, Dr. Rolle started Claimant on gabapentin,5 continued Claimantâs work
restrictions of no overhead lifting and no lifting of more than 10 pounds with right
upper limb, and extended his work restrictions to include no work in cold
environments. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 28, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at
18, C.R. at 232. Dr. Rolle also prescribed PT for Claimantâs cervical spine pain.
See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 28, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 18, C.R. at 232.
On March 16, 2023, Claimant again presented to OSS with continued
complaints of right shoulder, arm, and hand pain. See Rolle Depo. at 14, C.R. at
228. Claimant explained that the course of prednisone had helped his condition. See
Rolle Depo. at 14, C.R. at 228. Dr. Rolle explained that his impression to a
reasonable degree of medical certainty at that time was that Claimant suffered from
two separate conditions: first, tendonitis in the right wrist and hand; second,
shoulder, neck, and arm symptoms most likely related to cervical spine nerve
irritation. See Rolle Depo. at 14-15, C.R. at 228-29. Dr. Rolle also opined to a
reasonable degree of medical certainty that Claimantâs cervical symptoms were
exacerbated by his work. See Rolle Depo. at 15-16, C.R. at 229-30. Claimantâs
treatment plan called for conservative treatment, including PT and oral anti-
inflammatory medication (diclofenac). See Rolle Depo. at 14-15, C.R. at 228-29.
Claimantâs working restrictions continued at that time with no upper right extremity
use. See Rolle Depo. at 15, C.R. at 229.
5
Gabapentin is a medication used to treat nerve irritation. See Rolle Depo. at 18, C.R. at
232.
8
Dr. Rolle testified that he next saw Claimant personally when Claimant
returned for an office visit on April 7, 2023. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 29, C.R.
at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 19, C.R. at 233. Claimantâs condition remained
relatively unchanged at that time. See Rolle Depo. at 19, C.R. at 233. PT had not
resolved Claimantâs symptoms, and his pain remained at a seven to eight out of 10.
See Rolle Depo. at 19, C.R. at 233. Dr. Rolleâs diagnosis remained unchanged at
this time. See Rolle Depo. at 19-20, C.R. at 233-34.
Dr. Rolle ordered an MRI study to determine if Claimant was a
candidate for epidural injections, which study was done on April 20, 2023. See WCJ
Decision at 6, F.F. 29, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 20, C.R. at 234. The MRI
revealed degenerative changes at the C4-5 and C5-6 disc levels of Claimantâs spine,
arthritis in the oculovertebral joints, an impingement on the right side of the spine at
C5-6, and some disc bulging at C6-7. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 29, C.R. at 33;
see also Rolle Depo. at 20-21, C.R. at 234-35.
Following the MRI, Claimant again presented to Dr. Rolle on April 25,
2023. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 30, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 21, C.R.
at 235. At that time, Claimant still complained of neck and upper right arm pain as
well as numbness and tingling in his arm/hand. See Rolle Depo. at 21-22, C.R. at
235-36. Accordingly, Dr. Rolle ordered a cervical epidural steroid injection for
Claimant. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 30, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 21,
C.R. at 235. Dr. Rolle performed the injection at the C7-T1 level on May 15, 2023,
without complications. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 30, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle
Depo. at 22, C.R. at 236.
Dr. Rolle next saw Claimant at a follow-up visit on August 7, 2023.
See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 31, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 22, C.R. at 236.
9
Claimant reported that the injection had resulted in a 50% reduction of his symptoms
for approximately two weeks followed by a regression of his pain relief. See WCJ
Decision at 6, F.F. 31, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 22, C.R. at 236. Dr. Rolle
updated Claimantâs restrictions to a 10-pound lifting restriction and no working in a
cold environment. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 31, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo.
at 22-23, C.R. at 236-37.
Dr. Rolle testified that Claimant underwent a second epidural steroid
injection at C7-T1 on September 6, 2023. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 32, C.R. at
33; see also Rolle Depo. at 23, C.R. at 237. However, Claimant had no relief from
his symptoms and returned to Dr. Rolleâs practice on September 20, 2023, for a
surgical consultation with an orthopedic spinal surgeon, Dr. Michael Fernandez. See
WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 32-33, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 24-25, C.R. at
238-39. Dr. Rolle explained that Dr. Fernandez diagnosed Claimant with
aggravation of cervical spondylosis and aggravation of âcervical viscosity fight
complexâ6 with cervical radiculopathy at C5-6, with which diagnosis Dr. Rolle
agreed. See WCJ Decision at 6, F.F. 33, C.R. at 33; see also Rolle Depo. at 25, C.R.
at 239. Claimant remained reluctant to undergo spinal surgery after discussing the
surgical options, but indicated that he would consider surgery if there were no other
options. See Rolle Depo. at 25, C.R. at 239. Dr. Fernandez recommended a
6
In questioning regarding Claimantâs medical records, Dr. Rolle read into the record Dr.
Fernandezâs assessment of Claimantâs condition, which the deposition transcript identifies as
â[a]ggravation of cervical spondylosis and aggravation of cervical viscosity fight complex with
cervical radiculopathy at C5-6.â Rolle Depo. at 25, C.R. at 239. The WCJ questioned whether
âcervical viscosity fight complexâ was a transcription error. See WCJ Decision at 6 n.3, C.R. at
33. Because Dr. Rolle subsequently described the relevant condition in his own words as âspinal
nerve irritation on the basis of preexisting cervical spondylosis at C5-6,â the precise wording of
Dr. Fernandezâs assessment does not affect our analysis. Rolle Depo. at 27, C.R. at 241.
10
combination of topical and oral medications to relieve symptoms and requested
reevaluation in four to six weeks. See WCJ Decision at 6-7, F.F. 33, C.R. at 33-34;
see also Rolle Depo. at 26, C.R. at 240. Dr. Rolle explained, however, that this was
the Claimantâs last office visit with OIP. See WCJ Decision at 7, F.F. 33, C.R. at
34; see also Rolle Depo. at 26, C.R. at 240.
Dr. Rolle further testified that he reviewed the IME authored by Dr.
Kalawadia. See Rolle Depo. at 28, C.R. at 242. Dr. Rolle agreed that Claimant had
recovered from the hand symptoms as of the July 20, 2023 IME. See WCJ Decision
at 7, F.F. 35, C.R. at 34; see also Rolle Depo. at 28, C.R. at 242. Dr. Rolle explained,
however, that Claimantâs current symptoms are more neck, shoulder, and arm and
are related to the radiculopathy. See WCJ Decision at 7, F.F. 34, C.R. at 34; see also
Rolle Depo. at 28, C.R. at 242. Dr. Rolle agrees with Dr. Kalawadia that Claimant
is symptomatic of right C-6 radiculopathy, but he does not agree that Claimantâs
condition is not work-related. See WCJ Decision at 7, F.F. 34, C.R. at 34; see also
Rolle Depo. at 28, C.R. at 242. Instead, Dr. Rolle explained that he believes that the
radiculopathy is, in fact, work related. See WCJ Decision at 7, F.F. 34, C.R. at 34;
see also Rolle Depo. at 28, C.R. at 242. Dr. Rolle reiterated that there was no one
event that led to the onset of Claimantâs symptoms, which resulted instead from a
repetitive motion injury from his work as a meat cutter and meat packer. See WCJ
Decision at 7, F.F. 34, C.R. at 34; see also Rolle Depo. at 28-29, C.R. at 242-43.
Employer presented Dr. Kalawadiaâs deposition testimony before the
WCJ. See WCJ Decision at 10-13, F.F. 63-85, C.R. at 37-40; see also Transcript of
Kalawadia Deposition (Kalawadia Depo.), C.R. at 464-552. Dr. Kalawadia7
7
Dr. Kalawadia graduated from medical school at Northwestern University in 2009 and
completed an orthopedic surgical residency in 2014. See WCJ Decision at 10, F.F. 63, C.R. at 37;
11
independently examined Claimant on July 20, 2023.8 See WCJ Decision at 10, F.F.
63, C.R. at 37; see also Kalawadia Depo. at 7, C.R. at 471. By way of history,
Claimant told Dr. Kalawadia that he worked in Employerâs packaging department
cutting meat. See WCJ Decision at 10, F.F. 64, C.R. at 37; see also Kalawadia Depo.
at 8-9, C.R. at 473-74. Claimant also told Dr. Kalawadia that he developed pain in
his neck and hand as a result of the repetitive motions of his work. See WCJ
Decision at 10, F.F. 64-66, C.R. at 37; see also Kalawadia Depo. at 8-9, C.R. at 473-
74. Dr. Kalawadia also reviewed and testified regarding Claimantâs medical records.
See WCJ Decision at 10-11, F.F. 67-72, C.R. at 37-38; see also Kalawadia Depo. at
9-14, C.R. at 474-78.
Dr. Kalawadia explained that he believed Claimant exhibited
significant symptom exaggeration during his physical examination. See WCJ
Decision at 12, F.F. 78-80, C.R. at 39; see also Kalawadia Depo. at 18-19, C.R. at
482-83. Dr. Kalawadia testified that Claimantâs job should not have caused his
cervical spine complaints because it was a very low-demand task that did not involve
significant motion or energy imparted to the cervical spine. See Kalawadia Depo. at
14-15, C.R. at 478-79. Ultimately, Dr. Kalawadia opined that Claimantâs
mechanism of injury did not support the purported injury to Claimantâs cervical
see also Kalawadia Depo. at 5, C.R. at 469. He completed an orthopedic sports medicine and
surgical fellowship and arthroscopic fellowship at the University of Pittsburgh in 2015. See WCJ
Decision at 10, F.F. 63, C.R. at 37; see also Kalawadia Depo. at 5, C.R. at 469. As a general
orthopedic surgeon, Dr. Kalawadia regularly performs operations on upper extremities, shoulders,
elbows, hips, knees, and ankles. He does not do surgery on the spine, although he did so during
his residency and his practice involves evaluating spinal health issues in relation to other
orthopedic problems. See WCJ Decision at 10, F.F. 63, C.R. at 37; see also Kalawadia Depo. at
5-6, C.R. at 469-70.
8
Dr. Kalawadia explained that he regularly performs 10-15 IMEs per month. See
Kalawadia Depo. at 7, C.R. at 471.
12
spine and that he did not believe Claimantâs cervical spine issues were work-related.
See WCJ Decision at 12-13, F.F. 81-82, C.R. at 39-40; see also Kalawadia Depo. at
25-31, C.R. at 489-95. He also opined that Claimant was fully recovered from his
right-hand extensor tendonitis and had no further restrictions as a result of that
injury. See WCJ Decision at 12, F.F. 80, C.R. at 39; see also Kalawadia Depo. at 24
& 28-29, C.R. at 488 & 492-93.
Diane Howarth, R.N.,9 also testified on Employerâs behalf before the
WCJ. See WCJ Decision at 8-10, F.F. 47-62, C.R. at 35-37; see also Transcript of
WCJ Hearing, January 12, 2024 (Tr. 1-12-2024), C.R. at 319-463. Nurse Howarth
testified that Claimant worked for Employer since October of 2022 as a knife worker
on the second shift.10 See WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 48, C.R. at 35; see also Tr. 1-12-
2024 at 11-12, C.R. at 330-31. She testified that Claimant cut meat to order using a
repetitive motion. See WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 48, C.R. at 35; see also Tr. 1-12-
2024 at 11-13, C.R. at 331-32. She explained that Claimantâs job required primarily
his hands and wrists, not his neck or shoulders. See WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 48,
C.R. at 35; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 11-13, C.R. at 331-32.
9
Nurse Howarth testified that she worked as Occupational Health nurse manager for
Employerâs health services. See WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 47, C.R. at 35; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at
6, C.R. at 325. She explained that Employerâs health services provide first aid services and care
treatment to employees with both work-related injuries and non-work-related health issues. See
WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 47, C.R. at 35; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 7, C.R. at 326. Nurse Howarth
also explained that she handles all workersâ compensation injuries for Employer. See WCJ
Decision at 8, F.F. 47, C.R. at 35; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 7-8, C.R. at 326-27.
10
Nurse Howarth testified that Claimant began with Employer in February of 2022. See
WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 48 & n.4, C.R. at 35; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 11, C.R. at 330. Employer
records submitted during Nurse Howarthâs deposition indicated that Employer initially hired
Claimant in February of 2022, but that he quit for personal reasons less than two weeks thereafter,
only to be re-hired in October of 2022. See WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 48 & n.4, C.R. at 35.
13
Nurse Howarth testified that Claimant first reported a work injury on
February 21, 2023, and that was for right wrist and hand pain. See WCJ Decision at
8-9, F.F. 51, C.R. at 35-36; Tr. 1-12-2024 at 17-18, C.R. 336-37. She testified that
Claimant never complained of shoulder or neck problems prior to March 1, 2023.
See WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 50, C.R. at 35; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 28-29, C.R. at
347-48. Nurse Howarth explained that, upon receiving his lifting and mobility
restrictions from medical providers, Claimant was placed on limited duty work that
required the use of only one hand. See WCJ Decision at 8, F.F. 48, C.R. at 35; see
also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 11-13, C.R. at 331-32.
Nurse Howarth agreed that Claimant was given a restriction to not work
in a cold environment, but she explained that Claimant did not work in a freezer, as
none of Employerâs employees work in freezers for any reason. See WCJ Decision
at 9, F.F. 55-56, C.R. at 36; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 22-24, C.R. at 341-43. Nurse
Howarth explained that the production floor is kept at an average of 34 degrees, so
it is a cold environment, but that all employees are instructed to wear appropriate
and adequate clothing. See WCJ Decision at 9, F.F. 55, C.R. at 36; see also Tr. 1-
12-2024 at 24-25, C.R. at 343-44. Nurse Howarth further testified that on April 7,
2023, Claimant voluntarily quit to find a warmer job after she explained that
Employer had no work that could accommodate Claimantâs cold restriction. See
WCJ Decision at 9-10, F.F. 59, C.R. at 36; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 32-33, C.R. at
351-52.
Nurse Howarth denied that Claimantâs injury was work-related. See
WCJ Decision at 9, F.F. 57, C.R. at 36; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 28-29, C.R. at 347-
48. She reiterated that Claimant had not reported the neck and shoulder issue until
March 2023, which was several weeks after he initially reported his right hand and
14
wrist issues. See WCJ Decision at 9, F.F. 57, C.R. at 36; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at
29, C.R. at 348-49. However, an exhibit at Nurse Howarthâs deposition consisted
of Employer notes that indicated Claimant had made complaints concerning his right
shoulder in early February 2023. See WCJ Decision at 10, Reproduced Record
(R.R.) at 37a. Ultimately, Nurse Howarth testified that she did not believe that
Claimantâs neck issues and restrictions for those issues were due to work-related
causes. See WCJ Decision at 9, F.F. 57-58, C.R. at 36; see also Tr. 1-12-2024 at 31-
32, C.R. at 350-51.
The WCJ issued the WCJ Decision on July 10, 2024. See Board
Opinion at 1, C.R. at 77; see also WCJ Decision, C.R. at 28-47. In the WCJ
Decision, the WCJ granted the Claim Petition, determining that Claimant had met
his burden of proving that he sustained a work injury on February 16, 2023,
described as right extensor tenosynovitis and aggravation of cervical spondylosis
with cervical radiculopathy at C5-6. See Board Opinion at 1, C.R. at 77; see also
WCJ Decision at 16 & 20, C.R. at 43 & 47. The WCJ awarded Claimant wage loss
benefits. See Board Opinion at 1, C.R. at 77; see also WCJ Decision at 16-17 & 20,
C.R. at 43-44 & 47. Employer appealed and the Board affirmed via the Board
Opinion filed August 8, 2025. See Board Opinion, C.R. at 75-82. Employer timely
appealed to this Court.11
11
We observe that, in addition to Claimantâs Claim Petition, on August 2, 2023, Employer
filed a Termination Petition that alleged that Claimant had fully recovered from his work injury as
of July 20, 2023. See Board Opinion at 1, C.R. at 77; see also WCJ Decision at 3, F.F. 3, C.R. at
30. The WCJ Decision granted the Termination Petition, in part. See Board Opinion at 1, C.R. at
77; see also WCJ Decision at 3, 16 & 20, C.R. at 30, 43 & 47. Neither party appealed this aspect
of the WCJ Decision to the Board, and it forms no part of the instant appeal.
15
II. Issues
On appeal,12 Employer argues that the WCJ and the Board erred by
determining that Claimant met his burden to prove a work-related aggravation of a
pre-existing cervical condition because Claimant presented insufficient evidence to
establish causation. See Employerâs Br. at 4 & 28-38. Specifically, Employer argues
that Claimantâs proffered medical evidence was incompetent to prove a work-related
aggravation of a pre-existing degenerative cervical condition because Dr. Rolleâs
testimony and conclusions were based on a lack of understanding of Claimantâs job
duties and an unverified, non-medical record. See id. Employer also argues that the
Board improperly characterized its competency challenge of Dr. Rolleâs testimony
as a credibility issue. See id.
III. Discussion
Initially, we observe that, â[w]ith respect to a claim petition, the
claimant bears the initial burden of proving that [an] injury arose in the course of
employment and was related thereto.â Frankiewicz v. Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd.
(Kinder Morgan, Inc.), 177 A.3d 991, 995 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2017). âGenerally, if there
is no obvious relationship between the disability and the work-related cause,
unequivocal medical testimony is required to meet this burden of
proof.â Id. âMedical evidence is considered unequivocal if the medical expert, after
providing a foundation, testifies that in his medical opinion, he thinks the facts
12
Our review in a workersâ compensation appeal is limited to determining whether
necessary findings of fact are supported by substantial evidence, whether an error of law was
committed, or whether constitutional rights were violated. Henderson v. WP Ventures, Inc.
(Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd.), 269 A.3d 1272, 1275 n.2 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2022).
16
exist.â Craftsmen v. Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Krouchick), 809 A.2d 434, 439
(Pa. Cmwlth. 2002).
âThe terms âaggravation of a pre-existing conditionâ and ârecurrence of
a prior injuryâ are legal terms of art that are utilized to attribute causation of the
current disability to a particular event or series of events.â S. Abington Twp. v.
Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Becker & ITT Specialty Risk Servs.), 831 A.2d 175,
181-82 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2003). âIn workersâ compensation law, âaggravationâ is a term
of art denoting a new injury, as opposed to the resumption or manifestation of
symptoms from a past injury[,]â which is known as a ârecurrenceâ of the prior injury.
Zurn Indus. v. Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Bottoni), 755 A.2d 108, 111 (Pa.
Cmwlth. 2000). Both aggravations and recurrences of prior work-related injuries
are compensable under the Workersâ Compensation Act13 (Act). Chik-Fil-A v.
Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Mollick), 792 A.2d 678, 688â89 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2002).
âA work-related aggravation of a prior non-work-related condition is [also]
compensable.â Am. Contracting Enters., Inc. v. Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd.
(Hurley), 789 A.2d 391, 396 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2001) (claimant with history of shoulder
problems). However, âa disability that results from the natural progression of a non-
work-related pre-existing condition is not compensable under the Act.â Locher v.
Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd. (City of Johnstown), 782 A.2d 35, 38 (Pa. Cmwlth.
2001).
This Court has explained:
An employee who experiences an injury based on the
aggravation of a pre-existing condition is entitled to
benefits if she shows that the aggravation arose in the
13
Act of June 2, 1915, P.L. 736, as amended, 77 P.S. §§ 1-1041.4, 2501-2710.
17
course of employment, the aggravation was related to the
employment, and disability resulted. To show that an
injury was related to employment, the employee must
establish a causal connection between work and the
injury. When the connection between the injury or the
aggravation and work is not obvious, unequivocal medical
testimony is necessary. Moreover, where a claimant had
an underlying condition that is not work related, she must
show continuing existing disability in order to receive
benefits. Therefore, if restrictions are placed on a claimant
that are causally related to the work-related aggravation,
the claimant is entitled to benefits.
Chik-Fil-A, 792 A.2d at 688-89 (internal citations omitted).
Additionally, as this Court has previously noted:
[t]he WCJ is the fact finder, and it is solely for the WCJ
. . . to assess credibility and to resolve conflicts in the
evidence. Neither the Board nor this Court may reweigh
the evidence or the WCJâs credibility determinations. In
addition, it is solely for the WCJ, as the factfinder, to
determine what weight to give to any evidence. . . . As
such, the WCJ may reject the testimony of any witness in
whole or in part, even if that testimony is uncontradicted.
Hawbaker v. Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Krinerâs Quality Roofing Servs. &
Uninsured Emp. Guar. Fund), 159 A.3d 61, 69 (Pa. Cmwlth.), appeal denied, 173
A.3d 252 (Pa. 2017) (internal citations, quotations, and brackets omitted). The
competency of medical testimony is a question of law that this Court may address.
Pryor v. Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Colin Serv. Sys.), 923 A.2d 1197, 1203 (Pa.
Cmwlth. 2006). The doctorâs entire testimony must be reviewed and taken as a
whole, and a final decision âshould not rest upon a few words taken out of context
of the entire testimony.â City of Phila. v. Workersâ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Kriebel), 29
A.3d 762, 770 (Pa. 2011).
18
The WCJ made extensive findings of fact based on the above-described
testimony of Claimant, Dr. Rolle, Dr. Kalawadia, and Nurse Howarth, as well as
wage documents submitted into evidence. See WCJ Decision at 3-13, F.F. 4-87,
C.R. at 30-40. The WCJ also made the following express credibility determinations
as findings of fact:
88. Claimantâs testimony is credible based on the
following:
A. All of Claimantâs complaints focused on the
neck and right upper extremity minimizing the
impact of the treatment notes from February 17,
February 20, and February 21, 2023 recording
only hand complaints.
B. Claimant directly responded to questions not
only on direct examination, but also on cross-
examination. His responses were given in a
straightforward manner.
C. Employerâs own evidence confirms that
Claimant did have right shoulder complaints prior
to February 16, 2023, contrary to the testimony of
Employerâs lay witness.
89. Nurse Howarthâs testimony is credible, in part, based
on the following:
A. Nurse Howarthâs statement that Claimant was
provided with a panel list after notifying Employer
of the work injury is confirmed by Claimantâs
signature on the panel list with the date of
February 21, 2023. Employerâs Ex. No. 4, p. 94.
Claimantâs testimony confirmed he was provided
with the same.
19
B. Nurse Howarth recalled that as of April 7, 2023,
Claimant quit to look for a warmer job. She added
Employer could not accommodate the cold
[restriction] and the work was in a cold
environment. It is reiterated that in April 2023,
Claimant requested a position where he would not
be in a cold environment but was told there was no
such work available. Upon hearing this, he handed
over some items and left. Both Ms. Howarth and
Claimantâs testimony is consistent on this issue.
90. Nurse Howarthâs testimony is rejected based on the
following:
A. Nurse Howarth suggested the first mention of
any shoulder complaints to Employer was made
via a March 1, 2023 treatment note from OSS.
Employerâs internal documentation, however,
reveals right shoulder complaints were
documented in a daily recap log from February 2,
2023. Employerâs Ex. No. 4, p. 137. The daily
recap log from February 2, 2023, as well as any
other daily recap logs from the first few months of
2023, were not reviewable for any relevant
information as they were destroyed. Id. at 17-18.
B. Nurse Howarthâs belief that Claiman