E. Conde v. Lycatel, LLC (WCAB)
CourtCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket919 C.D. 2025
JudgeCohn Jubelirer
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Elhadj Conde, :
Petitioner :
:
v. : No. 919 C.D. 2025
: Submitted: April 13, 2026
Lycatel, LLC (Workers’ :
Compensation Appeal Board), :
Respondent :
BEFORE: HONORABLE RENÉE COHN JUBELIRER, President Judge
HONORABLE MATTHEW S. WOLF, Judge
HONORABLE BONNIE BRIGANCE LEADBETTER, Senior Judge
OPINION NOT REPORTED
MEMORANDUM OPINION BY
PRESIDENT JUDGE COHN JUBELIRER FILED: November 16, 2026
Elhadj Conde (Claimant), representing himself, petitions for review of the
Order of the Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board (Board) that affirmed the
decision of a Workers’ Compensation Judge (WCJ) granting Claimant’s Claim
Petition for a closed period of time and terminating Claimant’s workers’
compensation (WC) benefits as of July 27, 2023, based on Claimant’s full recovery
from his work-related injuries. On appeal, Claimant argues the WCJ erred in
terminating his benefits because he has not fully recovered from his work injuries,
which are more extensive than found by the WCJ. Upon careful review, we affirm
because the decision to terminate Claimant’s benefits based on his full recovery from
his work-related injuries is supported by substantial evidence.
I. BACKGROUND
Claimant worked for Lycatel, LLC (Employer) as a team leader, travelling to
various retail stores to sell Employer’s products, including SIM cards. (WCJ
Decision, Finding of Fact (FOF) ¶¶ 2, 4(a).) Claimant sustained injuries when a
vehicle struck the driver’s side of his Employer-provided vehicle while Claimant
was parked at a gas station during his workday on March 8, 2023. (Id. ¶ 4(b).) On
April 4, 2023, Claimant filed the Petition, with assistance of counsel, asserting he
sustained the following disabling injuries in the motor vehicle accident: a
concussion, a head injury, and a strain and sprain of the left ankle. (Id. ¶ 1.)
Employer filed an answer denying the Petition’s allegations and, later, issued a
Notice of Compensation Denial acknowledging that the accident occurred, but
denying that Claimant sustained any work-related injuries. (Id. ¶¶ 2-3.) The matter
was assigned to the WCJ, who held a hearing at which Claimant presented his own
testimony and the deposition testimony of William Pavlou, M.D., his treating
physician,1 and Employer presented the testimony of its human resources director
(HR Director) and the deposition of its medical expert, Vinit Pande, M.D.
A. Claimant’s Evidence
Claimant testified, both live before the WCJ and by deposition.2 Claimant
described his position as requiring significant driving and the March 8, 2023
1
Claimant has attempted on several occasions to provide additional documents for the
Court’s review, and his reproduced record contains numerous medical records that were not
introduced during the proceedings before the WCJ. Because these items are not in the certified
record, they cannot be considered by the Court. See Kimberly Clark Corp. v. Workers’ Comp.
Appeal Bd. (Bullard), 790 A.2d 1072, 1075-76 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2001) (stating that items not part of
the record created before the WCJ may not be considered on appeal).
2
Claimant’s testimony is summarized in findings of fact 4 and 5 and is found at Item
numbers 11 and 13 of the Certified Record.
2
accident, and that he advised Employer of the accident on that day. Following the
accident, Claimant had pain but went home. After awakening in more pain,
Claimant went to the emergency room, where he underwent diagnostic testing and
was told he had a concussion. Claimant obtained additional treatment at this hospital
on two more occasions, and, on March 13, 2023, was released to unrestricted work.
Employer obtained a rental car for Claimant to use, but at some point, Employer
advised Claimant that he could no longer use a company car and had to return the
rental car. Thereafter, Employer discharged Claimant for misusing his Employer-
provided gas card. Claimant indicated that his gas card, the password for the gas
card, and SIM cards were stolen from the rental car; he reported that break-in and
theft to the police and to Employer.
After his discharge, Claimant began treating with Dr. Pavlou on March 30,
2023, who provided Claimant with physical therapy for the lower back and referred
Claimant to other physicians in Dr. Pavlou’s office for headaches. Claimant began
treatment for his headaches on July 5, 2023. Claimant, who has been diagnosed with
sickle cell trait, described his ongoing treatment with, among others, Dr. Pavlou, and
his current symptoms, including “constant headache with pain in his left shoulder
into his left hand with numbness in his fingers,” aching in his left knee, and pain in
his low back. (FOF ¶ 4(g).) Claimant also maintained he needed surgery on his left
shoulder because of the March 2023 accident, he has difficulty sleeping due to pain,
he has no strength on his left side, has not been released to work, and is incapable of
working due to his left upper body issues. Claimant denied initially having prior
work injuries but later acknowledged that: he had been in a work-related motor
vehicle accident in January 2023 in which he injured his lower back; he was treating
that injury at the time of the March 2023 accident; he continued to receive treatment
3
for that injury as of July 2023; and he had not fully recovered from that low back
injury.
Dr. Pavlou,3 who is board-certified in family medicine, began treating
Claimant on March 30, 2023, at which time Claimant provided a history of the
January 2023 and March 2023 accidents and described his immediate symptoms and
treatment at the emergency room and with Concentra. Dr. Pavlou described
Claimant’s complaints, which included headaches, dizziness, left shoulder and knee
pain, low back pain, and difficulty moving his left arm, and his physical examination
of Claimant, which was normal except for tenderness, loss of motion, and evidence
of impingement in his left shoulder. Based on Claimant’s description of the March
2023 accident and the mechanism of the injury which was that Claimant’s vehicle
was rear ended, Dr. Pavlou diagnosed Claimant with strains/sprains of the left
shoulder, left knee, and lumbar back, left shoulder tendinopathy, chest wall
contusion, and concussion with post-concussion symptoms. Dr. Pavlou prescribed,
among other treatments, medications and physical therapy, and referred Claimant to
other physicians for his headaches and shoulder. The neurologist prescribed
medication and cognitive and physical therapy for the concussive symptoms.
Following additional diagnostic testing and subsequent examinations of Claimant,
Dr. Pavlou opined that Claimant had recovered from his chest wall contusion and
added AC joint arthritis in the left shoulder and neuropathy to his prior diagnoses of
Claimant’s work-related injury. Claimant was not fully recovered from these
injuries and could not return to his preinjury position, but Dr. Pavlou was optimistic
3
Dr. Pavlou’s deposition testimony is summarized in finding of fact 7 and is found at Item
number 14 of the Certified Record.
4
as to Claimant’s concussion and left shoulder injuries because both showed signs of
improvement.4
Dr. Pavlou acknowledged on cross-examination that he did not review
Claimant’s emergency room records following the March 2023 accident or one of
Claimant’s Concentra visits. (Certified Record (C.R.), Item 14 at 27-28, 30.) He
also acknowledged that Claimant’s left arm neuropathy and objective weakness,
which would likely arise from a cervical injury, developed six months after the
March 2023 accident, and Claimant had no neck complaints and Claimant did not
injure his neck in the accident. Thus, he was unsure of the cause of those symptoms.
B. Employer’s Evidence
HR Director testified5 about Claimant’s position as a marketing representative
and that Claimant was involved in three vehicle-related incidents: the January 2023
incident where Claimant was involved in an altercation with another driver, although
no collision occurred; the March 2023 accident; and a March 15, 2023 incident when
his Employer-provided vehicle was broken into while parked outside of Claimant’s
brother’s house. Claimant advised Employer of the March 15, 2023 break-in and
filed an incident report, but did not indicate that anything had been stolen from the
vehicle. Based on Claimant having “too many incidents,” HR Director informed
Claimant that he would no longer be able to use a company vehicle and Employer
would pay for him to use public transportation. (C.R., Item 16 at 13.) HR Director
was subsequently notified that charges occurred on Claimant’s Employer-provided
gas card on March 21 and 25, 2023, and she discussed the activity with Claimant,
4
Although there are some medical reports attached to Dr. Pavlou’s deposition, they do not
relate to Claimant.
5
HR Director’s deposition testimony is summarized in finding of fact 6 and is found at
Item number 16 of the Certified Record.
5
advising him that they were considered unauthorized and he would be terminated.
It was only then that Claimant stated that the gas card had been stolen on March 15,
2023.
Dr. Pande,6 who is board-certified in physical medicine and rehabilitation,
performed an Independent Medical Examination (IME) of Claimant on July 27,
2023. Dr. Pande’s physical examination of Claimant revealed normal results with
no objective findings to support Claimant’s ongoing complaints, as well as
submaximal effort. He noted that records from Claimant’s other providers reflected
he showed greater strength for them than Claimant showed during Dr. Pande’s
examination, where Claimant presented as though his “entire left upper extremity
was paralyzed.” (FOF ¶ 8(j).) Dr. Pande observed that: Claimant’s March 9, 2023
hospital note indicated Claimant complained of left shoulder, left knee pain, left
sided back pain, as well as a headache; the March 12, 2023 note showed complaints
of leg, left shoulder, and body pain; and the March 13, 2023 note reflected that
Claimant had no complaints of pain, his neurologic and musculoskeletal
examinations were normal, and Claimant asked to be released to work. Based on
his examination of Claimant and review of Claimant’s hospital records immediately
following the March 2023 accident, Concentra records, and Dr. Pavlou’s records up
until the IME, Dr. Pande concluded that Claimant’s work-related injuries consisted
of a head contusion and left shoulder and knee strains and sprains, and cervical spine
and lumbar spine strains and sprains. Dr. Pande opined that Claimant had fully
recovered from these injuries as of July 27, 2023, needed no further medical
treatment, and could return to full-duty work. Dr. Pande specifically denied that
Claimant suffered a work-related concussion, opining that a head contusion results
6
Dr. Pande’s deposition testimony is summarized in finding of fact 8 and found at Item
number 17 of the Certified Record.
6
in headaches and there were no neurocognitive abnormalities documented in
Claimant’s records. (C.R., Item 17 at 52.)
C. WCJ’s Decision
Upon review of the evidence, the WCJ credited Claimant’s testimony as to
there being an incident on March 8, 2023, but “not as to any ongoing physical
complaints or disabilities” based on Claimant’s comportment and demeanor. (FOF
¶ 9 (emphasis omitted).) The WCJ additionally pointed to discrepancies in the
description of the mechanism of the injury, with Claimant testifying and telling the
emergency room and Concentra that he was struck on the driver’s side of the vehicle
and Dr. Pavlou indicating that Claimant’s vehicle was rear ended. (Id.) The WCJ
further observed that Claimant refused to acknowledge prior work injuries until
cross examination, and that “Claimant was evasive and noncompliant” in answering
questions about the March 2023 accident, the vehicle break-in, and his ongoing
complaints and disabilities. (Id.)
The WCJ credited HR Director’s testimony, which acknowledged knowing
about the March 2023 work injury. (Id. ¶ 10.) The WCJ observed that while
Claimant may have been discharged for cause, this did not negate Claimant’s
entitlement to benefits because Claimant provided a plausible basis for the charges
on the gas card. (Id.) As to the medical experts, the WCJ accepted Dr. Pande’s
opinions over those of Dr. Pavlou where they differed, citing numerous objective
reasons. (Id. ¶ 11.) Those reasons included Dr. Pande’s “training and qualification
in the field in which he is asked to offer his opinion,” Dr. Pande’s years of experience
in evaluating and treating pain patients, and Dr. Pande’s opinions being consistent
with the mechanism of injury that Claimant gave the emergency room and Concentra
physicians and with Claimant’s medical records and history. (Id.) The WCJ also
7
observed that Dr. Pavlou’s opinions of Claimant’s ongoing disability were based on
Claimant’s subjective complaints, which the WCJ had not credited, and could not
relate Claimant’s ongoing complaints regarding his left upper extremity to the March
2023 accident. (Id.)
Based on these credibility determinations, the WCJ found that Claimant
suffered left shoulder and knee, cervical, and lumbar strains and sprains due to the
March 2023 accident, from which Claimant had fully recovered as of July 27, 2023.
(Id. ¶¶ 12-13.) Accordingly, the WCJ concluded that Claimant met his burden of
proof on the Petition for a limited period and granted the Petition for the closed
period of March 8, 2023, to July 27, 2023. (Id. ¶ 14; Conclusion of Law (COL) ¶ 2.)
D. Board’s Opinion
Claimant, now representing himself, appealed to the Board. In his appeal,
Claimant asserted facts he believed supported the award of ongoing benefits and
demonstrated that the WCJ erred in terminating his benefits. Claimant asserted that
the WCJ’s Decision was based on “misinformation” and was inaccurate. (C.R., Item
No. 7.) While the Board “empathized with Claimant’s belief that his injuries
continue[d],” it found no error or abuse of discretion in the WCJ’s Decision based
on the WCJ’s credibility determinations, which the Board could not review.7 (Board
Opinion (Op.) at 7.) Because the credited evidence supported the grant of benefits
for a closed period with a termination of Claimant’s benefits as of the date of the
IME, the Board upheld the WCJ’s Decision.
Claimant now petitions this Court for review.
7
As before this Court, Claimant attempted to submit extra-record evidence to the Board
but it, like this Court, can only consider the record certified to it. Kimberly Clark Corp., 790 A.2d
at 1075-76.
8
II. DISCUSSION
A. Parties’ Arguments
Claimant argues the WCJ erred in terminating his benefits because he
continues to receive care from Dr. Pavlou and other physicians for his work-related
injuries, including left shoulder surgery in February 2024. (Claimant’s Brief (Br.)
at 4.) According to Claimant, “[d]espite [his] unbroken continuum of care, the WCJ
relied solely on a single [IME] by Dr. Pande, whose assessment predated all
diagnostic imaging, surgical findings, and later treatment.” (Id. at 4.) Claimant cites
numerous records that he asserts preclude termination based on his full recovery.
(Id. at 5.) Claimant argues Dr. Pande’s opinions based on his one-time evaluation
should not have been credited over Dr. Pavlou’s testimony because Dr. Pande’s IME
and opinions occurred prior to Claimant’s subsequent diagnostic testing and surgery.
(Id.) Finally, he asserts the WCJ’s Decision was not reasoned because “[t]he WCJ
relied on demeanor observations and an incomplete record rather than objective
medical documentation” to make credibility determinations. (Id.)
Employer responds that the Board did not err in affirming the WCJ’s Decision
where the WCJ, acting as factfinder, weighed the record evidence and made
credibility determinations, and the credited evidence supports the WCJ’s termination
of Claimant’s benefits as of the date of Dr. Pande’s IME. (Employer’s Br. at 7.)
According to Employer, Dr. Pande’s opinions are consistent with Claimant’s
medical records immediately following the March 2023 accident, particularly as
they relate to the claimed concussion, and those available to him at the time. (Id. at
9.) Employer asserts Claimant did not submit competent evidence relating any
shoulder surgery to a work injury as no physician testified relating the two, and Dr.
Pavlou’s opinions were based on Claimant’s uncredited subjective complaints, could
9
not relate the ongoing shoulder neuropathy to the March 2023 accident, and were
inconsistent with the emergency room and Concentra records, all of which released
Claimant to full-duty work. (Id. at 9-11.)
Claimant filed a reply brief8 to “clarif[y] the record” and dispute Employer’s
arguments that the WCJ’s termination of his benefits were supported by the record,
rather than “a capricious disregard of objective medical findings.” (Claimant’s
Reply Br. at 2.) Citing various records that he asserts support his claims, Claimant
maintains Employer, the WCJ, and the Board ignore Dr. Pavlou’s clinical, objective
findings, as well as those of his neurologist, surgeon, and physical therapists. (Id. at
3-4.) Dr. Pande’s IME, Claimant argues, cannot nullify these records and findings,
nor can this medical evidence be rejected due to demeanor-based credibility
determinations. (Id. at 4-5.) Claimant argues that because Employer’s evidence did
not address these other injuries, it was insufficient to support the termination of his
benefits. (Id. at 6.) Additionally, Claimant asserts that: the WCJ mischaracterized
the accident; the WCJ’s credibility determinations were based on irrelevant
Employer accusations relating to the use of the gas card; and his due process rights
were violated by the WCJ not considering all of the medical evidence.9 The WCJ’s
failure to issue proper credibility determinations, Claimant asserts, rendered the
8
In a single filing, Claimant presented two briefs in response to Employer’s brief, one
labeled “reply brief” and one labeled “Brief for the Appellant.” In both, Claimant sets forth reasons
why Employer’s arguments should be rejected and why the Board and WCJ erred in terminating
his benefits.
9
Claimant asserts numerous other reasons for why the Board’s Order should be reversed,
but they, essentially, reiterate his contentions relating to his receipt of ongoing medical treatment,
the WCJ’s credibility determinations, and alleged mischaracterizations of the accident. Claimant
also argues the Board erred in stating that he returned to Dr. Pavlou’s care in July 2024; however,
a review of the Board’s opinion contains no such statement.
10
WCJ’s Decision not reasoned under Section 422(a) of the Workers’ Compensation
Act (Act), 77 P.S. § 834.10
B. Analysis
Before we begin, we must stress the limitations of this Court’s review. Under
the law, this Court’s review “is limited to determining whether necessary findings
of fact are supported by substantial evidence, whether an error of law was
committed, or whether constitutional rights were violated.” Elberson v. Workers’
Comp. Appeal Bd. (Elwyn, Inc.), 936 A.2d 1195, 1198 n.2 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2007). The
Court cannot make its own credibility findings, but must accept those of the WCJ if
supported by substantial evidence. Dennis v. Inglis House, 303 A.3d 559, 566 (Pa.
Cmwlth. 2023). This Court’s review is also limited to reviewing only the record that
was made before the WCJ. Kimberly Clark Corp. v. Workers’ Comp. Appeal Bd.
(Bullard), 790 A.2d 1072, 1075-76 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2001).
At issue before the WCJ was Claimant’s Petition, in which he sought ongoing
benefits based on his sustaining numerous injuries in the March 2023 accident. In a
claim petition proceeding, a claimant bears the burden of proving the existence and
continuance of a work-related injury that causes a loss of earning power. Inglis
House v. Workmen’s Comp. Appeal Bd. (Reedy), 634 A.2d 592, 595 (Pa. 1993). If
the causal relationship between the work incident and disability is not obvious, the
claimant must present unequivocal medical evidence to establish that relationship.
Dennis, 303 A.3d at 564. An employer may obtain the termination of benefits if it
proves that all disability related to a compensable injury has ceased. Udvari
v. Workmen’s Comp. Appeal Bd. (USAir, Inc.), 705 A.2d 1290, 1291 (Pa. 1997).
10
Act of June 2, 1915, P.L. 736, as amended, 77 P.S. § 834.
11
“Where the evidence supports a finding of disability for a closed period, the WCJ
may so limit benefits.” Dennis, 303 A.3d at 564 (citation omitted).
Here, the WCJ found that Claimant met his burden of proving that he
sustained some injuries in the March 2023 accident and was disabled thereby but
also concluded that Employer met its burden of proving that Claimant was fully
recovered from the suffered work injuries as of the date of Claimant’s IME, crediting
Dr. Pande’s opinions over those of Dr. Pavlou. Accordingly, the WCJ awarded
Claimant benefits for a closed period of time, consistent with Dennis.
Claimant’s arguments that it was error for the WCJ to terminate his benefits
arise, essentially, from his challenge of the WCJ’s credibility determinations.
Claimant contends the WCJ should not have credited Dr. Pande’s opinions where he
only saw Claimant once, and where numerous medical records and Claimant’s
ongoing treatment with various medical professionals, support Claimant’s ongoing
injury and disability, which were unaddressed by Dr. Pande, the WCJ, the Board,
and Employer. Claimant also challenges the WCJ’s rejection of his testimony,
maintaining it was improper to rely on Claimant’s demeanor and a misconception of
the severity of the March 2023 accident and mechanism of his injury.
However, under the law, a WCJ, as factfinder, “is free to accept or reject, in
whole or in part, the testimony of any witness, including medical witnesses.”
Dennis, 303 A.3d at 564 (citation omitted). Determinations of credibility and
evidentiary weight “are the prerogative of the WCJ.” Id. (citation omitted). Our
Supreme Court has explained, in the context of a Section 422(a) reasoned decision
challenge, that
when the issue involves the credibility of contradictory witnesses who
have actually testified before the WCJ, it is appropriate for the judge to
base his or her determination upon the demeanor of the witnesses. In
12
such an instance, there often is not much to say, nor is there a need to
say much, in order for a reviewing body to determine that the decision
was reasoned. Such a credibility determination may involve nothing
more than the fact[]finder’s on-the-spot, and oftentimes instinctive,
determination that one witness is more credible than another. The basis
for the conclusion that certain testimony has the “ring of truth,” while
other testimony does not, may be difficult or impossible to articulate-
but that does not make such judgments invalid or unworthy of
deference. . . . Accordingly, in a case where the fact[]finder has had
the advantage of seeing the witnesses testify and assessing their
demeanor, a mere conclusion as to which witness was deemed
credible, in the absence of some special circumstance, could be
sufficient to render the decision adequately “reasoned.”
....
[A]bsent the circumstance where a credibility assessment may be
said to have tied to the inherently subjective circumstance of
witness demeanor, some articulation of the actual objective basis
for the credibility determination must be offered for the decision to
be a “reasoned” one which facilitates effective appellate review.
Daniels v. Workers’ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Tristate Transp.), 828 A.2d 1043, 1052-53
(Pa. 2003) (emphasis added). This does not mean that “the WCJ’s prerogative to
determine the credibility of witnesses and the weight to be accorded evidence has []
been diminished by” these principles; those “determinations are [still] binding on
appeal unless made arbitrarily and capriciously.” Casne v. Workers’ Comp. Appeal
Bd. (Stat Couriers, Inc.), 962 A.2d 14, 19 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2008) (citation omitted).
Thus, “[w]e must view the [WCJ’s] reasoning as a whole and [can] overturn the
credibility determination only if it is arbitrary and capricious or so fundamentally
dependent on a misapprehension of material facts, or so otherwise flawed, as to
render it irrational.” Id. (emphasis added).
Initially, we observe that the majority of Claimant’s well-presented arguments
are based on medical records and opinions that were not offered into evidence
before the WCJ. These records and opinions relate to treatments and diagnostic
13
testing that took place after the record closed on his case, which occurred on January
17, 2024. (C.R., Item 11 at 41.) “It is well settled that items which are not part of
the record may not be considered by the fact-finding tribunal, or the appellate body
on review.” Kimberly Clark Corp, 790 A.2d at 1075-76 (citation omitted). Thus,
that neither the WCJ nor Dr. Pande referenced treatments or testing that had not yet
occurred or opinions not yet given, and, therefore, could not be evidence in this
case, is not a basis to find the WCJ erred or abused her discretion or to reject Dr.
Pande’s testimony, as Claimant argues.11 Claimant did not seek to introduce any
other expert testimony, for example, that of his neurologist or orthopedist, or to hold
the record open for the completion of additional testing and treatment. As of January
17, 2024, the record in this matter closed, and, with it, Claimant’s ability to present
evidence in support of his claim for ongoing benefits.
Claimant relies heavily on his having had surgery in February 2024 as proof
that his injuries continued after Dr. Pande’s IME. However, while Claimant testified
about surgery on his left shoulder being scheduled for February 2024, (C.R., Item
11 at 19-20), he is not a medical expert and is not competent to testify as to the causal
relationship between that surgery and the March 2023 accident. See Dennis, 303
A.3d at 564 (holding that unequivocal medical evidence must be presented to
establish the causal relationship between the work incident and disability if causation
is not obvious). Moreover, while Claimant testified that this surgery would be on
the nerves of his left shoulder, (C.R., Item 11 at 19-20), Dr. Pavlou, Claimant’s own
expert, explained that Claimant’s numbness, weakness, and pain going down the left
arm did not begin until three months after the March 2023 accident, (C.R., Item 14
11
For this same reason, Claimant’s argument that the WCJ violated his due process rights
fails because only those records presented to the WCJ prior to the closing of the record could be
considered.
14
at 17, 20, 24, 33). Dr. Pavlou could not explain, at the time, this development or its
cause because those symptoms typically derive from cervical radiculopathy and
Claimant “never injured his neck and never complained about his neck.” (Id. at 22,
33-34.) Thus, the record as it exists would not have supported Claimant’s assertion
that these symptoms and their treatment were work-related.
This leaves Claimant’s other challenges to the WCJ’s credibility
determinations and his argument that the WCJ did not render a reasoned decision.
Upon careful review, we conclude these are not bases for reversing the Board’s
Order.
Because Claimant testified live before the WCJ, the WCJ had “the advantage
of seeing the witnesses testify and assessing their demeanor” and was within her
authority to make a credibility determination based only on Claimant’s demeanor.
Daniels, 828 A.2d at 1053. While Claimant argues there are reasons why his
demeanor should not have been considered, demeanor-based determinations are
sufficient under Daniels. And although Claimant argues the WCJ should not have
relied on Employer’s allegations relating to the improper use of the gas card in her
credibility determination, the WCJ ultimately concluded that Claimant’s explanation
for the gas card’s usage was plausible and did not find his discharge to be a reason
for denying benefits. (FOF ¶¶ 9-10.) In other words, it was Claimant’s demeanor
when testifying on the topic, not Employer’s allegations and Claimant’s testimony
itself, that impacted the WCJ’s credibility determination. Finally, the WCJ provided
additional reasons for not crediting all of Claimant’s testimony, including differing
descriptions of the mechanism of the injury and his refusal to acknowledge prior
work injuries until cross-examination. (Id. ¶ 9.) These reasons are supported by
record evidence, not a misapprehension of material facts, and the WCJ’s credibility
15
determinations are not otherwise arbitrary or capricious; therefore, those
determinations are binding. Casne, 962 A.2d at 19.
Claimant’s attacks on the WCJ’s credibility determinations of the medical
experts fare no better. Because Dr. Pande and Dr. Pavlou testified by deposition,
and the WCJ could not assess their demeanor, the WCJ was required, under Daniels,
to “articulat[e] [an] actual objective basis for the credibility determination.” 828
A.2d at 1053. “There are countless objective factors which may support a WCJ’s
credibility determinations.” Dorsey v. Workers’ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Crossing
Constr. Co.), 893 A.2d 191, 195 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2006) (citation omitted). Such
reasons include that an expert “may be unqualified or less qualified than the
opposing party’s expert; or may be impeached with inconsistencies or contradictions
in his or her testimony or reports; or may be impeached in some other convincing
fashion.” Daniels, 828 A.2d at 1053. An expert’s superior experience or
qualifications are objective bases for accepting one expert’s testimony over the
other. Verizon Pa. Inc. v. Workers’ Comp. Appeal Bd. (Mills), 116 A.3d 1157, 1164
(Pa. Cmwlth. 2015).
Here, the WCJ offered several objective bases for her credibility
determinations, including that Dr. Pande had “train[ed] and qualifi[ed] in the field
in which he is asked to offer his opinion,” that Dr. Pande had years of experience in
evaluating and treating pain patients, and that Dr. Pande’s opinions were consistent
with the mechanism of injury that Claimant gave the emergency room and Concentra
physicians and with Claimant’s medical records and history. (FOF ¶ 11.) The WCJ
also cited Dr. Pavlou’s reliance on Claimant’s subjective complaints of ongoing
disability for his opinions, and those subjective complaints were found to be not
credible by the WCJ. (Id.) These objective reasons are sufficient under Daniels.
16
And, to the extent Claimant argues Dr. Pavlou’s testimony should have been given
greater weight because he was his treating physician, the courts have rejected that a
WCJ is required to give deference to claimant’s treating physician’s testimony. Ashe
v. Workmen’s Comp. Appeal Bd. (Dep’t of Lab. & Indus.), 648 A.2d 1306, 1307-08
(Pa. Cmwlth. 1994). Ultimately, the WCJ’s reasons are supported by record
evidence, not a misapprehension of material facts, and the WCJ’s credibility
determinations are not otherwise arbitrary or capricious; therefore, those
determinations are binding. Casne, 962 A.2d at 19.
Finally, we address Claimant’s contention that the WCJ did not issue a
reasoned decision. “To constitute a reasoned decision within the meaning of Section
422(a), a WCJ’s decision must permit adequate appellate review.” Dorsey, 893 A.2d
at 194 (citation omitted). “[W]hile summaries of testimony alone would be
insufficient to satisfy the reasoned decision requirement, where a WCJ summarizes
testimony and also objectively explains [the WCJ’s] credibility determinations, the
decision will satisfy the requirement.” Amandeo v. Workers’ Comp. Appeal Bd.
(Conagra Foods), 37 A.3d 72, 76 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2012). Reviewing the WCJ’s
Decision, we conclude it is reasoned because it clearly and concisely states and
explains the WCJ’s rationale, objectively explains the credibility determinations,
which are supported by the record and are not arbitrary and capricious, and allows
for meaningful appellate review. Therefore, this is not a reason to reverse the
Board’s Order.
III. CONCLUSION
We, like the Board, empathize with Claimant, but reviewing only the record
made before the WCJ (as we must), the WCJ’s binding credibility determinations,
and the law, we are constrained to find no error in the Board’s affirming the WCJ’s
17
Decision granting Claimant benefits for a closed period of time and terminating
those benefits based on Dr. Pande’s credited testimony of Claimant’s full recovery.
Accordingly, we affirm the Board’s Order.
RENÉE COHN JUBELIRER, President Judge
18
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Elhadj Conde, :
Petitioner :
:
v. : No. 919 C.D. 2025
:
Lycatel, LLC (Workers’ :
Compensation Appeal Board), :
Respondent :
ORDER
NOW, November 16, 2026, the Order of the Workers’ Compensation Appeal
Board, entered in the above-captioned matter, is hereby AFFIRMED.
RENÉE COHN JUBELIRER, President Judge