Shasta Gray, Individually and on Behalf of Her Daughter Julia Patton v. Underwriters at Lloyd's London, Comstock Oil & Gas Louisiana, INC., Pro Frac Services, LLC, Driq & Tiff's Trucking, LLC Modriques Deandre Roots
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket57,116-CA
JudgeHunter
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Judgment rendered November 18, 2026.
Application for rehearing may be filed
within the delay allowed by Art. 2166,
La. C.C.P.
No. 57,116-CA
No. 57,117-CA
(Consolidated Cases)
COURT OF APPEAL
SECOND CIRCUIT
STATE OF LOUISIANA
*****
No. 57,116-CA No. 57,117-CA
SHASTA GRAY, KATHRYN MCDONALD, IN
INDIVIDUALLY AND ON HER CAPACITY AS LEGAL
BEHALF OF HER GUARDIAN OF ELIJAH KOL
DAUGHTER JULIA PATTON, GRAY
DECEASED Plaintiffs-Appellants
Plaintiffs-Appellees
versus
versus
COMSTOCK RESOURCES,
UNDERWRITERS AT INC.; COMSTOCK OIL &
LLOYD’S LONDON, GAS-LOUISIANA, LLC;
COMSTOCK RESOURCES, PROFRAC SERVICES, LLC;
INC., COMSTOCK OIL & GAS SANDBOX LOGISTICS, LLC;
LOUISIANA, INC., PRO FRAC MODRIQUES ROOTS; DRIQ
SERVICES, LLC, DRIQ & & TIFF’S TRUCKING, LLC;
TIFF’S TRUCKING, LLC AND MENCAR, LLC
MODRIQUES DEANDRE Defendants-Appellees
ROOTS
Defendants-Appellees
*****
Appealed from the
Forty-Second Judicial District Court for the
Parish of DeSoto, Louisiana
Trial Court Nos. 82,188 and 82,973
Honorable Nicholas E. Gasper, Judge
*****
SCOTT CRICHTON LAW, LLC Counsel for Appellants
By: Scott J. Crichton
BROUSSARD KNOLL LAW FIRM
By: Christopher S. Mann
Laura Bishop Knoll
Jerold “Trey” Knoll
BROUSSARD & WILLIAMSON, LLC
By: Aaron James Broussard
MARY WATSON SMITH
THE PENN LAW FIRM
By: Eric T. Penn
Kelly D. Peacock
Byron Haney
DARRIN M. WALKER, P.C.
O’BRYON, SCHNABEL Counsel for Appellees,
& AFRICK, APLC Modriques Deandre
By: Kevin C. O’Bryon Roots, Driq & Tiff’s
Marta-Ann Schnabel Trucking, LLC, and
McKenna Rae Giovingo Mencar, LLC
William H. Africk
PERRIER & LACOSTE, LLC
By: Guy Dugue Perrier
Nathan Merritt Gaudet
Patrick Schmidt
TAYLOR, WELLONS, Counsel for Appellees,
POLITZ & DUHE, LLC Sandbox Logistics, LLC,
By: David Scott Rainwater and Sandbox
John David Harpole, III Transportation, LLC
Mark Thomas Assad
PETTIETTE, ARMAND, DUNKELMAN, Counsel for Appellee,
WOODLEY & CROMWELL, LLP Profrac Services, LLC
By: Donald James Armand, Jr.
Marshall Louis Perkins
Meredith P. Bro
*****
Before HUNTER, MARCOTTE, and ELLENDER, JJ.
HUNTER, J.
Plaintiff, Kathryn McDonald, in her capacity as legal guardian of
Elijah Kol Gray, appeals a district court’s judgment granting motions for
summary judgment filed by defendants, Modriques Roots, Driq & Tiff’s
Trucking, LLC, Mencar, LLC, Sandbox Logistics, LLC, and Sandbox
Transportation, LLC. For the following reasons, we affirm.
FACTS
On September 9, 2020, at approximately 4:30 a.m., defendant
Modriques Roots was operating an 18-wheeled tractor-trailer on Louisiana
Highway 765, a two-lane highway in DeSoto Parish. Roots, who was in the
process of delivering frack sand to an oil well site, had activated his right
turn signal and was waiting for another tractor-trailer to exit the private well
access road. While waiting for the other truck to exit the access road, Roots
stopped the tractor-trailer in the highway’s northbound lane of travel for
approximately two minutes.
Meanwhile, Julia Patton was operating a Jeep Patriot and was
traveling in the northbound lane of Hwy 765. Jaylie Gray (“Ms. Gray”) and
Troy Jordan were passengers in the vehicle. Ms. Patton approached Roots
from the rear and collided with the back of the tractor-trailer. Ms. Patton
and Ms. Gray died as a result of injuries sustained in the collision, and Mr.
Jordan was severely injured.
Subsequently, plaintiff, Kathryn McDonald, Ms. Gray’s mother, filed
a wrongful death/survival lawsuit in her capacity as the legal guardian of
Ms. Gray’s minor child, Elijah Kol Gray. Named as defendants were
Comstock Resources, Inc., Comstock Oil & Gas-Louisiana, LLC, ProFrac
Services, LLC,1 Sandbox Transportation, LLC, Sandbox Logistics, LLC,
Modriques Roots, Driq & Tiff’s Trucking, LLC, and Mencar, LLC.2 Driq &
Tiff’s, LLC was the owner of the truck operated by Roots at the time of the
collision, and Sandbox Transportation was the owner of the trailer. Mencar,
LLC was the motor carrier for which Roots was driving. 3
In the petition, plaintiff alleged, inter alia, Roots was negligent in
stopping in the right lane of travel during the dark, predawn hours. Plaintiff
also alleged Mencar was negligent for failing to properly recruit and train its
drivers and for failing to assess the location to which its drivers were
required to deliver. Additionally, plaintiff alleged Sandbox was negligent
for failing to properly assess the location at which it directed drivers to
deliver loads of sand. More specifically, plaintiff asserted the size of the
vehicles employed to transport the sand prohibited them from suitably
entering and exiting the driveway leading to the site; therefore, the trucks
were required to stop in a traffic lane of the public highway.
Subsequently, plaintiff filed an amended petition alleging Sandbox
Transportation was negligent in investigating and selecting Mencar as a
motor carrier to transport goods of public roadways. Plaintiff also alleged
Sandbox had control of and responsibility for the equipment and its driver,
1
Plaintiff’s claims against Comstock Oil & Gas-Louisiana, LLC, Comstock
Resources, Inc., and ProFrac Services, Inc. were compromised, and all claims against
those defendants were dismissed.
2
Ms. Patton’s mother, Shasta Gray, also filed a lawsuit individually and on behalf
of her deceased daughter against the same defendants. The lawsuits were consolidated by
a consent judgment dated August 25, 2022. The claims asserted by Shasta Gray are not
at issue in this appeal and will not be discussed herein.
3
ProFrac Services was the operator of the fracking project at the well site to
which Roots was transporting the fracking sand. ProFrac hired Sandbox Transportation
to transport the sand from Arkansas to the well site, and in turn, Sandbox Logistics, the
affiliate freight broker for Sandbox Transportation, made arrangements with Mencar to
transport the sand.
2
Roots, was Roots’ statutory employer and was therefore vicariously liable
for Roots’ actions. Plaintiff further alleged Mencar was negligent in failing
to properly screen, train, and supervise Roots and was vicariously liable for
Roots’ actions.
Mencar, LLC, Roots, and Driq & Tiff’s Trucking, LLC (collectively
“the Mencar defendants”) filed a motion for summary judgment arguing
Roots did not breach any duty owed regarding the following vehicle/rear-
end presumption set forth in La. R.S. 32:141(A). They also argued plaintiff
failed to produce any competent evidence to establish a genuine issue of
material fact. According to the Mencar defendants, Ms. Patton was solely
liable for the injuries sustained because she was driving the following
vehicle, was traveling 62 miles per hour in a 55 mile per hour speed zone,
there was nothing to impair her visibility, and there was no evidence that she
applied her brakes or took any evasive action prior to the impact.
Sandbox Logistics, LLC and Sandbox Transportation, LLC
(collectively “Sandbox”) also filed a motion for summary judgment arguing
plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that Roots breached a duty to Ms. Gray.
They argued Roots was lawfully traveling on the highway when he observed
an oncoming motorist, Carlos Douglas, traveling on the adjacent private
oilfield road. The private road was the access point to Roots’ destination,
Roots temporarily stopped to allow Douglas to exit the road to successfully
execute his right turn, and Ms. Patton struck his tractor-trailer from the rear.
Therefore, Ms. Patton, as the following motorist, was presumed to be at fault
for causing the rear-end collision.
Following a hearing, the district court granted both motions for
summary judgment. The court found the rulings in Hester v. Walker, 20-
3
01278 (La. 5/13/21), 320 So. 3d 362, and Liles v. Great West Cas. Ins. Co.,
54,565 (La. App. 2 Cir. 7/13/22), 342 So. 3d 1160, were “on point.”
Plaintiff appeals.
DISCUSSION
Plaintiff contends the district court erred in granting the motions for
summary judgment. She argues the court misapplied the rulings in Hester,
supra, and Liles, supra, and improperly relied on those cases. She also
argues she submitted sufficient evidence to establish that Roots breached a
duty by violating La. R.S. 32:141(A).
A summary judgment is reviewed de novo, with the appellate court
using the same criteria that govern the trial court’s determination of whether
summary judgment is appropriate, i.e., whether there is any genuine issue of
material fact and whether the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of
law. Samaha v. Rau, 07-1726 (La. 2/26/08), 977 So. 2d 880; Logan v.
Richland Par. Hosp., 56,127 (La. App. 2 Cir. 4/9/25), 408 So. 3d 1208,
reh’g denied (5/15/25), writ denied, 25-00760 (La. 10/1/25), 417 So. 3d 570.
A motion for summary judgment shall be granted if the motion,
memorandum, and supporting documents show that there is no genuine issue
as to material fact and that the mover is entitled to judgment as a matter of
law. La. C.C.P. art. 966(A)(3); Staten v. Glenwood Reg’l Med. Ctr., 53,220
(La. App. 2 Cir. 1/29/20), 290 So. 3d 280, writ denied, 20-00591 (La.
9/23/20), 301 So. 3d 1184.
The burden of proof on a summary judgment motion remains with the
mover. La. C.C.P. art. 966(D)(1). However, if the mover will not bear the
burden of proof at trial on the issue that is before the court on the motion for
summary judgment, the mover’s burden on the motion does not require him
4
to negate all essential elements of the adverse party’s claim, action, or
defense, but rather to point out to the court the absence of factual support for
one or more elements essential to the adverse party’s claim, action, or
defense. The burden is on the adverse party to produce factual support
sufficient to establish the existence of a genuine issue of material fact or that
the mover is not entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Id. If the opponent
of the motion fails to do so, there is no genuine issue of material fact and
summary judgment should be granted. Staten, supra.
A fact is “material” when its existence or nonexistence may be
essential to plaintiff’s cause of action under the applicable theory of
recovery. Peironnet v. Matador Res. Co., 12-2292 (La. 6/28/13), 144 So. 3d
791; McGee v. Ashford Place Apartments, LLC, 54,795 (La. App. 2 Cir.
11/16/22), 351 So. 3d 899. A genuine issue is one regarding which
reasonable persons could disagree; if reasonable persons could reach only
one conclusion, there is no need for a trial on that issue and summary
judgment is appropriate. Hines v. Garrett, 04-0806 (La. 6/25/04), 876 So.
2d 764; McGee, supra.
Furthermore, in determining whether an issue is genuine, a court
should not consider the merits, make credibility determinations, evaluate
testimony, or weigh evidence. McGee, supra; Marioneaux v. Marioneaux,
52,212 (La. App. 2 Cir. 8/15/18), 254 So. 3d 13. Finally, the court must
draw those reasonable inferences from the undisputed facts which are most
favorable to the party opposing the motion; likewise, all doubt must be
resolved in the opposing party’s favor. McGee, supra; Wyrick v. Golden
Nugget Lake Charles, LLC, 20-0665 (La. App. 1 Cir. 12/30/20), 317 So. 3d
708.
5
A threshold issue in a negligence action is whether the defendant
owed the plaintiff a duty. Hester, supra; Lemann v. Essen Lane Daiquiris,
Inc., 05-1095 (La. 3/10/06), 923 So. 2d 627. Whether a duty is owed is a
question of law. Hester, supra; Peterson v. Gibraltar Savings & Loan, 98-
1601, 98-1609 (La. 5/18/99), 733 So. 2d 1198; Faith in Farming Co., L.L.C.
v. State, Dep’t of Transp. & Dev., 55,011 (La. App. 2 Cir. 4/19/23), 361 So.
3d 1132, writ denied, 23-00708 (La. 9/26/23), 370 So. 3d 477.
According to plaintiff, defendants breached a duty imposed by La.
R.S. 32:141(A), which provides:
Upon any highway outside of a business or residence district,
no person shall stop, park, or leave standing any vehicle,
whether attended or unattended, upon the paved or main
traveled part of the highway when it is practicable to stop, park,
or so leave such vehicle off such part of the said highway.
La. R.S. 32:141 is designed to protect against the risk that a driver,
whether cautious or inattentive, would collide with a stationary vehicle.
Hester, supra; Laird v. Travelers Ins. Co., 263 La. 199, 267 So. 2d 714 (La.
1972). The statute does not delineate any temporal period for determining
whether a vehicle has been stopped. Nonetheless, the jurisprudence has
recognized La. R.S. 32:141 does not apply to vehicles which are stopped on
a highway on a temporary or momentary basis while waiting to turn. Hester,
supra; Liles, supra; Jenkins v. Hernandez, 19-0874 (La. App. 1 Cir. 6/3/20),
205 So. 3d 365.
Additionally, the driver of a motor vehicle shall not follow another
vehicle more closely than is reasonable and prudent, having due regard for
the speed of such vehicle and the traffic upon and the condition of the
highway. La. R.S. 32:81(A). A presumption of negligence arises when a
following motorist is involved in a rear-end collision. This is because a
6
following motorist who collides with a leading vehicle is presumed to have
breached the duties set forth in La. R.S. 32:81(A). Brewer v. J.B. Hunt
Transport, Inc., 09-1408, 09-1428 (La. 3/16/10), 35 So.3d 230; Howard v.
GEICO Cas. Co., 22-605 (La. App. 3 Cir. 3/29/23), 364 So. 3d 489.
In Hester, supra, the driver of a tractor-trailer stopped in the lane of
travel while waiting to execute a left turn. The tractor-trailer had been
stopped for 27 seconds because the driver was unable to complete a left turn
due to oncoming traffic and a tractor-trailer which had blocked the driveway
onto which he was attempting to turn. The following vehicle struck the rear
of the tractor-trailer. The Louisiana Supreme Court found the driver of the
tractor-trailer did not breach a duty under R.S. 32:141(A). The Court held
that R.S. 32:114 prohibits stopping a vehicle in a travel lane of a highway
when it is practicable to leave the vehicle off the highway, and “[a]ny
interpretation which would apply the statute to a brief temporary stop made
as a matter of necessity in the course of ordinary traffic would result in
absurd consequences.” Id. at 367. The Court specifically noted that the
plaintiffs failed to present any evidence to establish that the driver of the
tractor-trailer “intended to remain stopped for any appreciable period of time
after it became safe for him to complete his turn.” Id., at 368.
In Liles, supra, the driver of the tractor-trailer activated his hazard
lights and attempted to execute a right turn onto the driveway of a business;
however, he discovered that three parked trucks blocked his path. The
driver was unable to pull the tractor-trailer completely off the highway, and
he stopped with the trailer partially obstructing the right lane of the roadway
for approximately two minutes. The plaintiff rear-ended the back of the
7
trailer. The district court granted the defendants’ motion for summary
judgment, and citing Hester, supra, this Court affirmed. We stated:
We hold that it was not a breach of duty for [the driver of the
tractor-trailer] to commence the right turn when he could not
determine beforehand that he would be able to immediately
complete the turn. As recognized in Hester, supra, motor
vehicles often temporarily stop in a lane of travel and do so for
various reasons, including waiting to make a turn and avoiding
hitting pedestrians in a crosswalk. In making a right turn, the
motorist’s duties to following traffic are satisfied if the turning
motorist decelerates at a reasonable rate and timely activates the
appropriate signal lights. A motorist’s duty of care obviously
does not prohibit stopping in the lane of travel and waiting to
commence or complete a turn. Indeed, a motorist generally may
stop in the appropriate lane of the roadway and wait to
commence a turn when the say is not clear. Similarly, when a
motorist commences a right turn without being able to ascertain
in advance whether the turn can be completed, the motorist may
stop the vehicle in the roadway if an obstruction prevents
completion of the turn.
Id. at 1166-7.
In the instant case, in support of the motion for summary judgment,
defendants submitted into evidence Roots’ “Driver/Witness Voluntary
Statement” prepared in conjunction with the State of Louisiana’s Uniform
Motor Vehicle Traffic Crash Report. Roots stated as follows:
I was northbound [on Hwy.] 765[.] I was at a complete stop
with sign[al] light on waiting to turn right when another truck
was coming out[.] [A]bout [two] min[utes] later I heard a
boom[.] I came out my seat[,] look[ed] in my [mirror and] saw
[the] SUV on the left back of my trailer.
Defendants also introduced into the record excerpts from Roots’
deposition. Roots acknowledged his previous statement that he had stopped
for two minutes while waiting to make the turn. However, during his
deposition, he testified estimated the timing “off the top of [his] head,” it
could have been less than two minutes, but he stated he was sure it was no
8
longer than two minutes. Roots testified he was at a complete stop, and he
was utilizing his turn signal.
Defendants also submitted the statement signed by Carlos Douglas,
the driver of the exiting tractor-trailer on which Roots was waiting to exit the
lease road. In his statement, Douglas declared as follows:
I was leaving off lease road. A truck was coming from my left.
They slowed and turn[ed] on signal light. I looked to see if any
traffic was coming from the opp[o]site direction, heard a loud
crashing noise. A vehicle had hit the truck turning from behind.
The record also contains excerpts from Douglas’ deposition in which
he testified as follows:
I was leaving off the lease road. Where you turn on the lease
road at, it’s a gate, cattle guard there. Only one truck can come
in and out at a time right there. *** I was already staged to
come out. [Roots] was pulling up on the road, had his signal
light and stuff on. Like I said, I checked to look to see if any
traffic was coming the other way. The next thing I know, they
had the accident. *** From the way the lease road is, it’s on – it
was on, like a little hill, and then it was kind of – it’s open
pasture, so I [saw] him from a pretty good distance away that he
was coming. *** Like I say, he was getting ready to come into
the – or slowing down. You know, had his signal light and
everything on to turn in there. I mean, because everybody
knows when you’re coming in it’s only going to be either one
guy coming out or one guy coming in a time right there[.] ***
[T]here is no way that both of us is going to simultaneously, I
mean at the same time, make that turn. *** So either one of us
– one guy has to go or the other guy has to go. And then once
he’s completed the turn and out the way, then the other guy can
get – get in and out.
Douglas further testified he had made deliveries to the site on multiple
occasions, and in his experience, two vehicles could not fit side by side at
the entrance to the lease road. He stated in the past, he had to stop his
tractor-trailer on the road to allow other drivers to exit the road before he
could turn onto the road. Douglas testified that although the “mouth” of the
lease road is wide, it is “tight” in the area where the cattle gate is located.
9
Douglas was unable to gauge the amount of time that elapsed between the
time he saw Roots’ truck and the time of the collision. However, he stated
he believed it was “about a minute.”
Additionally, defendants introduced into evidence the video
deposition of Louisiana State Trooper Michael Antilley. Trooper Antilley
testified he investigated the fatal accident in dispute. He stated it was dark
when the accident occurred, but the weather was clear, the roadway was dry,
and there were no obscurements to impede Ms. Patton’s visibility. He also
stated the data obtained from Ms. Patton’s vehicle revealed her vehicle was
traveling 62 miles per hour in a 55 miles per hour speed zone, and there was
nothing to indicate she applied her brakes or took any other evasive action
before striking the rear of the tractor-trailer. Trooper Antilley further
testified he inspected the tractor-trailer operated by Roots, the headlights,
taillights, brake lights, and turn signals were all in proper working condition,
and the reflective tape on the back of the trailer was intact. After
investigating the accident, Trooper Antilley opined the tractor-trailer
operated by Roots should have been visible to traffic approaching from
behind, Roots did not commit any traffic violations, and the collision was
caused by Ms. Patton’s inattentiveness.4
Defendants also introduced into the record the deposition of Lt.
Joseph Mondello of the Louisiana State Police. Lt. Mondello agreed with
Trooper Antilley’s opinion that the accident was caused by Ms. Patton, and
Roots did not do anything to cause the collision.
4
In the accident report, Trooper Antilley stated, “The primary factor in the crash
was determined to be ‘Driver Violation,’ specifically Driver 1 [Ms. Patton] failed to
Yield to Vehicle 2 that was stopped preparing to make a right turn.”
10
In opposition to the motions for summary judgment, plaintiff
introduced into evidence, inter alia, an affidavit executed by its expert,
Brian Haygood, an engineer and accident reconstructionist. In the affidavit,
Haygood attested that in October 2020, he inspected and measured the
vehicles involved in the collision, inspected the scene of the accident, and
utilized an overhead drone to capture images of the scene. Haygood opined
the lease road was wide enough to accommodate the width of two tractor-
trailers. Therefore, according to plaintiffs, it was practicable for Roots to
remove the tractor-trailer from the highway by completing the turn and
proceeding through the gate onto the lease road.
Our review of the record reveals Roots unequivocally stated he
engaged his right signal to turn onto the lease road, but he came to a
complete stop in the roadway to wait for another tractor-trailer to exit the
road. According to Roots, he was delivering to the site for the first time, and
he was waiting for the oncoming vehicle to exit because he did not believe
the road was wide enough to accommodate both tractor-trailers.
Additionally, Douglas, who had traversed the lease road on multiple
occasions, testified the cattle gate was not wide enough to accommodate
both tractor-trailers.
Furthermore, the data obtained from the vehicle Ms. Patton was
driving established she was exceeding the speed limit, and the post-accident
investigation revealed she did not attempt to apply her brakes. The
investigating Louisiana State Police officers concluded the accident was
caused by Ms. Patton’s inattentiveness, and nothing Roots did caused or
contributed to the accident. The affidavit submitted by plaintiff’s expert, in
which he opined the width of the lease road could have accommodated both
11
tractor-trailers, was insufficient to rebut the presumption that Ms. Patton, as
the following motorist, was at fault for the accident.
As the Supreme Court stated in Hester, supra, La. R.S. 32:141(A)
“does not apply to vehicles which are stopped on a highway on a temporary
basis while waiting to turn.” Id., at 367. The evidence submitted established
that Roots activated his turn signal, stopped temporarily, and waited until he
could safely execute the turn and proceed through the gate. Based on the
evidence admitted for the purpose of summary judgment, we find Roots did
not violate La. R.S. 32:141(A) by stopping to wait for the other tractor-
trailer to exit the road before attempting to execute the right turn.
Consequently, we find plaintiff failed to produce factual evidence to support
the contention that Roots breached his duty of care. Because we conclude
plaintiff failed to satisfy her burden of establishing Roots breached any duty,
we find Mencar and Sandbox cannot be vicariously liable.
Plaintiff further argues that Sandbox was not entitled to summary
judgment because she also asserted a separate and independent negligence
claim against Sandbox for creating a dangerous condition on the highway.
According to plaintiff, Sandbox was responsible for coordinating the arrival
and departure of the delivery trucks, approximately 56 trucks entered and
exited the site per day, and only one truck at a time could enter/exit the gate.
Therefore, it was foreseeable that arriving trucks would have to stop on the
highway to wait for departing trucks to exit, and Sandbox failed to take any
measures to prevent collisions. Citing Hakim v. Albritton, 552 So. 2d 548
(La. App. 2 Cir. 1989), and Norman v. Michael A. Shelton Enter., Inc., 18-
1000 (La. App. 3 Cir. 5/29/19), 317 So. 3d 559, writ denied, 19-01093 (La.
10/8/19), 280 So. 3d 590, plaintiff contends that by failing to address the
12
traffic congestion at the entrance to the site, Sandbox failed to reasonably
mitigate risks to motorists on the highway.
Every act whatever of man that causes damage to another obliges him
by whose fault it happened to repair it. La. C.C. art. 2315. Under the
duty/risk analysis, to support a negligence claim under Article 2315, the
plaintiff must prove five separate elements: (1) the defendant had a duty to
conform his conduct to a specific standard (the duty element); (2) the
defendant’s conduct failed to conform to the appropriate standard (the
breach element); (3) the defendant’s substandard conduct was a cause-in-fact
of the plaintiff’s injuries (the cause-in-fact element); (4) the defendant’s
substandard conduct was a legal cause of the plaintiff’s injuries (the scope of
duty element); and, (5) proof of actual damages (the damages element).
Farrell v. Circle K Stores, Inc., 22-00849 (La. 3/17/23), 359 So. 3d 467;
Boykin v. Louisiana Transit Co., Inc., 96-1932 (La. 3/4/98), 707 So. 2d
1225. If the plaintiff fails to prove any one element by a preponderance of
the evidence, the defendant is not liable. Id.; Robert v. Turner Specialty
Servs., L.L.C., 50,245 (La. App. 2 Cir. 11/18/15), 182 So. 3d 1069.
In Hakim, supra, the plaintiff’s vehicle was struck by a motorist who
ran a stop sign. The sole issue on appeal was whether the third-party
defendant/landowner could be held liable to passing motorists when the
landowner allegedly created a hazard on adjacent property. This Court
reversed the district court’s ruling granting summary judgment finding that a
genuine issue of material fact existed as to whether the landowner caused or
contributed to the traffic congestion caused by a sale at its business which
was closely adjacent to the intersection whether the accident occurred. More
specifically, the Court stated, “[T]he jurisprudence has held that there is a
13
duty to not obstruct traffic and that a landowner may be liable for injuries to
persons on adjacent property caused by conduct on his premises.” Id. at
552.
In Norman, supra, a patron was attempting to exit the driveway of a
restaurant and execute a left turn but stated his vision of oncoming traffic
was obscured by a pickup truck parked along the edge of the parking lot.
Therefore, the patron decided to execute a right turn onto the highway
instead. The plaintiff was traveling on his motorcycle, and he struck the left
rear tire of the restaurant patron’s vehicle. The plaintiff filed a lawsuit
alleging his injuries were caused, in part, by the negligence of the restaurant
operator. The court of appeal reversed the district court’s ruling granting the
restaurant’s motion for summary judgment, finding, in part, the issue of
whether the landowner caused or contributed to the accident is a factual
issue not suitable for resolution by summary judgment.
In Lain v. Chapa, 48,000 (La. App. 2 Cir. 5/15/13), 114 So. 3d 563,
writ denied, 13-1753 (La. 11/1/13), 125 So. 3d 433, and writ denied, 13-
1759 (La. 11/1/13), 125 So. 3d 434, the plaintiff and his wife were rear-
ended by an 18-wheeler operated by a driver who failed to notice slowing
traffic on Interstate 20 in Bossier Parish. The plaintiff filed a lawsuit against
the operator of the 18-wheeler and her employer and later amended the
lawsuit to include as defendants the Louisiana Department of Transportation
and Development (“DOTD”) and Highway Graphics, Inc. (the company
employed to conduct striping at the center line along the interstate). Plaintiff
alleged DOTD and the striping company failed to properly warn motorists
approaching the operation. The evidence submitted revealed that DOTD
recognized the risk and amended its traffic control plan by requiring the
14
striping company to station an additional police vehicle at the tail of the
traffic queue. However, neither the DOTD nor the striping company
ensured that the measure was employed. This Court reversed the ruling
granting the defendants’ motion for summary judgment, stating,
“Reasonable minds could conclude that the resulting traffic congestion
caused by the impediment of the centerline operation near the intersection of
two high-volume roadways was foreseeable and that the halting of traffic on
a highspeed interstate highway without any advance notice posed a
significant hazard.” Id. at 566-67.
Plaintiff has set forth the obligations of the Sandbox defendants as
they relate to the coordination of drivers and the delivery of sand. However,
plaintiff has not presented any evidence to establish that Sandbox’s method
of staging the drivers and the timing of the deliveries caused or contributed
to this accident. Plaintiffs have not presented any evidence to controvert the
testimony and conclusions of the investigating officers, and we do not find
the existence of a genuine issue of material fact. Without the causation
element, we cannot connect any alleged violations attributable to Sandbox
with plaintiff’s damages. Because the causation element of negligence is not
supported by the record, we affirm the district court’s judgment granting
Sandbox’s motion for summary judgment.
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated herein, we affirm the district court’s judgment
granting the motions for summary judgment filed by defendants, Modriques
Roots, Driq & Tiff’s Trucking, LLC, Mencar, LLC, Sandbox Logistics,
LLC, and Sandbox Transportation, LLC.. Costs of this appeal are assessed to
15
the appellant, Kathryn McDonald, in her capacity as legal guardian of Elijah
Kol Gray.
AFFIRMED.
16