CK v. White, S.
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket350 WDA 2026
JudgeDubow
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
J-A26001-26
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
C.K., A MINOR BY TAYLOR GARRETT : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. :
:
:
STEPHANIE WHITE AND RAYMOND :
STROUD :
: No. 350 WDA 2026
:
APPEAL OF: STEPHANIE WHITE :
Appeal from the Judgment Entered February 19, 2026
In the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County Civil Division at
No(s): AR-25-5196
BEFORE: DUBOW, J., KUNSELMAN, J., and BECK, J.
MEMORANDUM BY DUBOW, J.: FILED: November 20, 2026
Appellant, Stephanie White, appeals from the February 19, 2026
judgment entered in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas following
a non-jury trial on damages only. Appellant contends that this Court should
vacate the judgment against her because the prothonotary failed to provide
her with notice of the date of the assessment of damages hearing. Appellant,
however, failed to file a post-trial motion where she could have raised this
issue, thus, providing the trial court with the opportunity to address it.
Consequently, we are constrained to find that she has waived this challenge
to the judgment and we affirm.
The relevant facts and procedural history are as follows. On June 25,
2025, Appellee, C.K., a minor, by Taylor Garrett, his parent and natural
guardian, filed a complaint in arbitration alleging that Stephanie White
J-A26001-26
(“White” or “Appellant”) and Raymond Stroud (“Stroud”)1 negligently failed to
control their dog and, as a result, Appellee sustained injuries when the dog bit
him. Appellee served the complaint on White and Stroud on July 14, 2025.
The lower court clerk scheduled an arbitration hearing for November 25, 2025.
When White and Stroud failed to file an answer to the complaint,
Appellee filed a praecipe for entry of default judgment. On September 11,
2025, the prothonotary entered a default judgment as to liability against White
and Stroud. A November 18, 2025 docket entry indicates that the Arbitration
Center cancelled the arbitration hearing scheduled for November 25, 2025, in
light of the default judgment.
On November 26, 2025, Appellee filed a praecipe to schedule an
arbitration hearing on damages. In the praecipe, Appellee requested that the
clerk schedule an arbitration hearing for January 7, 2026. Appellee included
with the praecipe a certificate of service indicating that he had served White
and Stroud with a copy of the praecipe. The docket reflects, however, that
neither the court nor any administrative office of the Allegheny County Court
of Common Pleas subsequently entered any order or provided any further
____________________________________________
1 White and Stroud are co-owners of the property where the dog lived. Stroud
is not a party to this appeal.
-2-
J-A26001-26
notice to the parties scheduling the assessment of damages hearing for
January 7, 2026, as required by Allegheny County Local Rule 1303(1)(a). 2
On January 7, 2026, Appellee appeared for the arbitration hearing, but
neither White nor Stroud appeared. Because White and Stroud failed to
appear, the matter “transferred immediately to a [j]udge of the [c]ourt of
[c]ommon pleas for an ex parte hearing on the merits and entry of a non-jury
trial verdict[.]” PA Allegheny Cty. LR 1303(a)(2)(1); see also Pa.R.Civ.P.
1303.
After considering Appellee’s testimony and evidence pertaining to the
scope and severity of the dog-bite injuries, the trial court entered a verdict in
Appellee’s favor in the amount of $50,000.3 The trial court clerk docketed the
verdict that same day and the docket entry includes a notation reflecting that
“[a]s per Rule 236 Notice, copies sent to all parties 01/08/26.” Docket Entry,
1/7/26.
Of most significance to our analysis, we note that Appellant failed to file
a post-trial motion within 10 days as required by Pa.R.Civ.P. 227.1. On
February 19, 2026, the trial court entered judgment in favor of Appellee and
against White and Stroud for $50,000.
____________________________________________
2 Local Rule 1303(1)(a) provides, in relevant part that, “the Department of
Court Records shall give notice to the filing party of the date, time and place
of hearing before a Board of Arbitrators through the electronic filing system.”
PA Allegheny Cty. LR 1303(1)(a).
3 We note that by failing to appear for the arbitration hearing, White and
Stroud forfeited their “right to a trial de novo on appeal.” Id. at
1303(a)(2)(1).
-3-
J-A26001-26
On March 5, 2025, Appellant filed a notice of appeal to this Court. The
trial court did not order Appellant to file a Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) statement. The
trial court has authored an opinion in which it highlights that, because
Appellant failed to file a post-trial motion, she has waived any challenge to
the verdict.
Appellant raises the following issue on appeal:
Whether the judgment should be vacated as Appellant did not
receive notice of the hearing to determine damages[?]
Appellant’s Br. at 3.
Before we address the merits of Appellant’s claim, we consider whether
Appellant, who failed to file a post-trial motion, preserved for our review the
issue of the defective notice of the assessment of damages hearing.
Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 227.1 provides, in relevant part
that in the case of a jury trial, a party must file post-trial motions within ten
days after the verdict. Pa.R.C.P. 227.1(c)(1). “The purpose for Rule 227.1 is
to provide the trial court with an opportunity to correct errors [] and avert the
need for appellate review.” Chalkey v. Roush, 805 A.2d 491, 494 n.9 (Pa.
2002). “Failure to raise an issue in a post-trial motion waives appellate review
of the claim.” Bensinger v. Univ. of Pittsburgh Med. Ctr., 98 A.3d 672,
682 (Pa. Super. 2014). See also Board of Supervisors of Willistown
Township v. Maine Line Gardens, Inc., 155 A.3d 39, 46 (Pa. 2017)
(citations omitted) (“[I]f an issue has not been raised in a post-trial motion it
is waived for appeal purposes.”).
-4-
J-A26001-26
Instantly, Appellant acknowledges that she did not file a post-trial
motion within 10 days of the verdict as required by Pa.R.Civ.P. 227.1.
Appellant’s Br. at 11-12. She argues, however, that because the trial court
failed to provide her with notice of the assessment of damages hearing on
January 7, 2026, she is relieved of the obligation to file a post-trial motion.
Following our review of the record, we disagree. As noted above, the
docket reflects, and Appellant does not dispute, that the lower court clerk
served Appellant with notice of the verdict pursuant to Pa.R.Civ.P 236 on
January 8, 2026. Thus, even assuming that Appellant did not receive notice
of the January 7, 2026 assessment of damages hearing, she received notice
of the verdict. Since Appellant received notice of the verdict, she had the
opportunity to raise the defective notice issue in a post-trial motion. Since
Appellant did not file a post-trial motion, she deprived the trial court of the
opportunity to correct the defective notice. She has, therefore, waived her
challenge to the defective notice.
Additionally, Appellant has failed to provide us with any legal authority,
and we have found none, that a party is relieved of the obligation to file a
post-trial motion when the court fails to provide notice of an assessment of
damages hearing, but provides notice of the verdict. Rather, the law is clear
that Appellant waived this challenge by failing to file a post-trial motion.
Judgment affirmed.
-5-
J-A26001-26
DATE: 11/20/2026
-6-