Elston v. Board of Douglas County Comm'rs
CourtCourt of Appeals of Kansas
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket129214
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NOT DESIGNATED FOR PUBLICATION
No. 129,214
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF KANSAS
GARY L. ELSTON AND LINDA R. ELSTON REVOCABLE TRUST,
AND MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC
Appellants,
v.
BOARD OF DOUGLAS COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,
Appellee.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Appeal from Douglas District Court; CARL FOLSOM III, judge. Oral argument held August 18,
2026. Opinion filed November 20, 2026. Affirmed.
Justin J. Johl, of Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, of Kansas City, Missouri, and Jessica A.E.
McKinney, pro hac vice, of the same firm, for appellants.
Matthew D. Stromberg, of Foulston Siefkin LLP, of Overland Park, and Jake G. Holly, of the
same firm, of Topeka, for appellee.
Before HILL, P.J., SCHROEDER and COBLE, JJ.
HILL, J.: One of the aims of good governance is to plan for future growth. In
Kansas, land-use planning is done by city and county planning commissions. Ultimately,
a county commission makes the final decision on land use in our counties. At times such
decisions are judicially reviewed for reasonableness. This is an appeal from such a
judicial review.
1
Mid-States Materials, LLC, appeals Douglas County's denial of its application for
a conditional use permit to open a 242-acre limestone quarry about 1 mile east of Eudora,
Kansas. After being denied a permit on the administrative level, Mid-States then appealed
to the district court which affirmed the administrative denial of the permit. Bringing the
question to our court, our review of the record leads us to now hold that the court's denial
of the permit was reasonable, and we affirm that ruling.
Anticipating a need for limestone, a company seeks to expand its operation.
In September 2022, Mid-States submitted a conditional use permit application
proposing a 242-acre limestone quarry first proposed for a 30-year time limit but later
reducing the proposal to a 20-year limit. The proposed quarry site is on land zoned for
agricultural use in Douglas County. The site lies between Eudora and the Douglas
County—Johnson County boundary line.
The land adjoining the proposed quarry contains a mix of agricultural and
residential properties. There is a platted residential subdivision called Hesper Heights,
containing 14 homes, immediately to the southwest of the proposed quarry. There's an
existing quarry operated by Hamm, Inc., immediately to the north of the proposed site.
The administrative history of that adjacent Hamm quarry is instructive and affects
the permit denial ruling. Earlier, in January 2022, the Board of Douglas County
Commissioners (Board) approved an expansion of the Hamm quarry from 250 to 411
acres. There are 114 minable acres remaining in that site. When the Hamm quarry
expansion was approved, the Board revealed their concern for the growth trajectory of
Eudora. But a large area on the west side of that mine (closest to Eudora) may not be
mined under their current permit. In other words, Hamm cannot go into the area directly
adjacent to Eudora's urban reserve area under that permit. And the Board limited the
2
permit to end in 2038. The Hamm quarry renewal was approved before the
announcement that a new Panasonic battery plant would be located nearby.
In November 2022, staff of the City of Lawrence Planning Commission
recommended approval of the Mid-States conditional use permit with a time limit of 20
years before the City of Eudora grew into the area. Basically, the Commission staff
concluded it was better to harvest the resources now before Eudora grows and it would
then be too late. The staff did, however, note that the new quarry could have a significant
impact on residential areas and nearby farmland. Like the Hamm quarry, the western side
of the proposed quarry is adjacent to the Eudora urban reserve.
Taking an opposing view, the staff of the City of Eudora Planning Commission
recommended that the permit should be denied. The staff had concerns that the proposed
quarry would hinder Eudora's planned growth and degrade the quality of life in nearby
residential areas. The staff also had concerns about the environmental effects of two
quarries so close to each other.
The planning commissions meet jointly.
With a spirit of cooperation, in November 2022, the Lawrence-Douglas County
Planning Commission and the City of Eudora Planning Commission held a joint public
session to review the application. Members of the public expressed concerns about the
permit: the possible harm to Eudora's future growth trajectory toward the quarry, and
possible harm to the residences already located just adjacent to the proposed quarry.
There were also many concerns about two Eudora schools on the probable quarry truck
route.
The Panasonic battery plant will be located approximately three miles from the
Eudora city limits and is expected to spawn about 4,000 jobs in this area. In addition, a
3
STAR-bond district with commercial development is already planned just south of state
highway K-10, about one mile from the proposed quarry.
Both the Lawrence-Douglas County Planning Commission and the City of Eudora
Planning Commission recommended to the Douglas County Board of County
Commissioners that they should deny Mid-States' proposed conditional use permit.
Wanting to propose a new truck route for its trucks to use, Mid-States asked the
Board of Commissioners to return the issue to the planning commissions for
consideration. The Board sent it back and in February 2023, the conditional use permit
application was heard again by the City of Eudora and Lawrence-Douglas County
Planning Commissions. At this meeting once again, many concerns were raised by
members of the community about the new quarry. Several people offered testimony.
Dave Knopick, a planning consultant for the City of Eudora, advised that the
City's central concern was not the road, but how close the proposed quarry was to the
area of future growth for Eudora. The recent activities guiding the City's future growth
plans were the STAR-bond district and the Panasonic plant announcement. Eudora's
comprehensive plan was designed before those projects were announced. There was a
present need for quality residential neighborhoods. The City was working to update its
plans. Knopick expected that Eudora's short-term growth would be "greater, faster, and
extended further into the growth area than originally anticipated" when its comprehensive
plan and urban growth agreement were adopted.
Kevyn Gero, Eudora's Interim City Manager, presented a draft future land use map
addressing the anticipated growth due to the Panasonic plant and STAR-bond district.
The map showed planned residential development along the entire western boundary of
the proposed quarry and extending south. Because of the Panasonic plant, the anticipated
populated growth will occur at a faster rate than the comprehensive plan depicted. Eudora
4
was working on updating its comprehensive plan. And the City was applying for a 21-
million-dollar grant for critical infrastructure for the STAR-bond district.
Once again, both the Lawrence-Douglas County and Eudora City Planning
Commissions recommended that the Douglas County Commissioners Board should deny
the conditional use permit.
The conditional use permit question comes before the Board.
In March 2023, the Board held a public hearing on the application. There were
many objections by members of the community, who shared their concerns about the
traffic, groundwater degradation, declining property values, health, safety, dust, noise,
blasting, and home damage from the proposed quarry. One resident submitted studies
demonstrating negative health effects for residents living near quarries.
There were conflicting studies submitted regarding how quarry sites impact home
values. Real estate agents familiar with the area stated that the quarry would decrease
home values and lower the potential for residential growth in the area.
Some people objected, stating there was a lack of market demand for limestone
and that existing quarries in the area could handle any growing demand. There was
contrasting testimony stating there was a need for nearby rock to support development of
the Panasonic plant and the STAR-bond district, and to lower the prices with
competition. Mid-States stated they had already received an order for 25,000 tons from
their Big Springs quarry on the other side of the county for the Panasonic plant.
The central objection was that the proposed quarry was not compatible with
anticipated population growth and development. Alex Curnes, a City Commissioner of
Eudora, testified that the quarry would impact the growth planned by the City as it would
5
be located a quarter mile from the Eudora urban growth area and planned development
corridor.
Gero again testified about the draft population growth maps that were presented at
the previous joint planning commission meeting, addressing the anticipated growth due to
the Panasonic plant and STAR-bond district. The City was working to update its
comprehensive plan to account for the faster population growth that will occur to the
south.
Knopick also advised that Eudora's comprehensive plan and future growth map
were designed before the announcement of the Panasonic plant and the nearby STAR-
bond district. Knopick now believes that their urban growth area would be populated
much faster than had been previously anticipated. Eudora can only grow to the south and
southeast due to the geography of the area. He believed Eudora would expand into the
urban reserve adjacent to the proposed quarry in the next 20 years. Knopick testified that
City of Eudora staff were fielding calls from developers and property owners interested
in residential and commercial development in response to the Panasonic announcement.
Grant Martin, chair of the City of Eudora Planning Commission, advised that the
City of Eudora had spent considerable time and effort on plans for the STAR-bond
project. Such projects are funded through use of state sales tax revenues. Eudora was
anticipating accelerated residential development to the south.
The County Commissioners acknowledged and discussed the Golden factors
which are named for a well-known Kansas Supreme Court case about real estate values.
Golden v. City of Overland Park, 224 Kan. 591, 598, 584 P.2d 130 (1978).
Commissioner Willey acknowledged that the availability of nearby rock is essential to the
county. Commissioner Kelly believed the proposed quarry was not compatible with the
area, noting the significant residential development diagonally adjacent to the proposed
6
quarry, making it different than the Hamm quarry. Commissioner Reid agreed and stated
that there had not been enough evidence presented of an imminent need for the rock to
justify the compounding impacts of two quarries right next to each other. Commissioner
Willey also noted the lack of data on the need for rock at the current time, and thought
the proposed quarry was too close to Eudora and its plans. Commissioner Kelly also
stated the proposed quarry was too close to Eudora's urban growth area where it expects
to expand residentially.
The Board unanimously denied the conditional use permit. The Board did not
issue written findings. Mid-States sought judicial review of this permit denial from the
Douglas County District Court after the permit was again denied.
The district court found the Board acted reasonably when it denied the conditional
use permit requested by Mid-States. Mid-States brings this appeal.
Five issues arise in this appeal.
1. Was it reasonable to deny Mid-States' quarry expansion even though the Board
had approved expansion of the Hamm quarry?
2. Was the Board's conclusion that a second quarry would be incompatible with the
character of the area reasonable? And was it so wide of the mark that it was
beyond reasonable debate?
3. Do we reweigh the evidence of the future need for quarry material?
4. Did the Board relinquish its quasi-judicial role and adopt irrelevant personal
concerns of members of the public rather than consider the community at large?
Was this a plebiscite?
7
5. Was the Board's decision unreasonable because it failed to issue written findings?
Zoning authorities and reviewing courts look for eight factors when weighing the
reasonableness of a Kansas zoning decision.
Almost fifty years ago, the Kansas Supreme Court, in Golden v. City of Overland
Park, 224 Kan. at 598, established several factors that should be considered by zoning
authorities when they are making zoning decisions. But the Golden factors are
suggestions, and other factors may be equally or more important depending on the
circumstances of the case. McPherson Landfill, Inc. v. Board of Shawnee County
Comm'rs, 274 Kan. 303, 306, 49 P.3d 522 (2002).
A zoning board should consider the following nonexclusive list of factors when
hearing requests for zoning changes:
1. "The character of the neighborhood;"
2. "the zoning and uses of properties nearby;"
3. "the suitability of the subject property for the uses to which it has been
restricted;"
4. "the extent to which removal of the restrictions will detrimentally affect nearby
property;"
5. "the length of time the subject property has remained vacant as zoned;"
8
6. "the relative gain to the public health, safety, and welfare by the destruction of
the value of plaintiff's property as compared to the hardship imposed upon the
individual landowner;"
7. "the recommendations of permanent or professional staff;" and
8. "the conformance of the requested change to the adopted or recognized master
plan being utilized by the city." Golden, 224 Kan. at 598.
This decision is reasonable.
To the district court, Mid-States argued that it was unreasonable to deny its
proposed new quarry although it is adjacent to an existing quarry that had just been
approved for expansion. The district court ruled that the cases were different because of
the new Panasonic plant and the residential subdivision located catty-corner to the
proposed quarry.
Our task here is clear. The reasonableness of a zoning board's action is a question
of law, to be determined on the basis of the facts which were presented to the zoning
authority. Combined Investment Co. v. Board of Butler County Comm'rs, 227 Kan 17, 28,
605 P.2d 533 (1980). There is a presumption that the zoning authority acted reasonably
which the challenging party must rebut by a preponderance of the evidence. 227 Kan. at
28. Appellate courts conduct the same review of the zoning authority's action as did the
district court. 227 Kan. at 28. What is important and controlling under our law is that the
action taken must not be arbitrary, capricious, or unreasonable. 227 Kan. at 29.
Generally, a proposed quarry is compatible with the area when the adjoining property
contains an existing quarry. But each case is decided on its own facts. Two cases
exemplify this statement.
9
In Combined Investment Co., the court held the board's action denying a rezoning
application for a quarry in Butler County was unreasonable as a matter of law. 227 Kan.
at 30-31. The surrounding properties were agricultural with an existing quarry adjoining
the proposed site. There was an average of three or fewer scattered homes on nearby
sections. There were no highly developed residential areas on the surrounding land. The
site was best suited for quarrying. There was no evidence that public health, safety, and
welfare would be promoted by denial of the application. There was evidence that the road
aggregate was needed for state highway projects nearby and was expensive to import to
the area. 227 Kan. at 30-31.
In Blessant v. Board of Crawford County Comm'rs, No. 89,916, 2003 WL
23018238, at *1, 3-4 (Kan. App. 2003) (unpublished opinion), a panel of this court held
the board's denial of a conditional use permit to establish a rock quarry on agricultural
land in Crawford County was unreasonable. Several months before denying the
application, the board had unanimously approved the expansion of another quarry located
within 1 mile of the proposed quarry. The proposed quarry would be more than a mile
from any house in the direction of the prevailing wind. There was evidence that the dust
and blasting problems associated with the proposed quarry would be much less than the
existing quarry.
In this case, there is a platted residential subdivision containing 14 homes
diagonally adjacent to the proposed site. The nearby Panasonic plant was announced after
the Hamm quarry expansion was approved. There was extensive testimony concerning
the need for Eudora to grow residentially to the south in the area adjacent to the proposed
quarry. The growth would likely occur during the lifetime of the proposed quarry.
The Hamm and Mid-States quarry proposals are easily distinguishable based on
the proximity to the Hesper Heights neighborhood, and the intervening announcement of
the construction of the new nearby Panasonic plant. Hamm is farther away from Hesper
10
Heights. There are more homes in close proximity to the proposed quarry than the Hamm
quarry. The Panasonic plant was announced after the Hamm quarry expansion was
approved. When the Board considered the expansion of the Hamm quarry, substantially
increased residential development of the area was not imminent. But the evidence in front
of the Board at the Mid-States hearing was that Eudora's residential growth would be
accelerated by the Panasonic plant.
Mid-States argues the Combined Investment and Blessant cases are nearly
identical to this case. But neither case involved a platted, residential subdivision
diagonally adjacent to the proposed site. Neither case involved a nearby development
project like the Panasonic plant which would bring 4,000 jobs to the area. Here, there was
extensive testimony from Eudora government officials explaining that the City needed to
grow to the south adjoining the proposed site. The officials believed that the residential
growth would occur during the lifetime of the proposed quarry. The City was working to
update its comprehensive plan. And the City was applying for a $21 million grant toward
development of the nearby STAR-bond district.
In Board of Johnson County Commissioners v. City of Olathe, 263 Kan. 667, 680-
81, 952 P.2d 1302 (1998), the Kansas Supreme Court found the city's zoning decision
changing an area zoned for agricultural to single family residential reasonable. At the
time of the decision, the character of the area was rural residential with a mix of
agricultural, large lot residential, and suburban homesteads. But the character of the
neighborhood was changing. The City of Olathe's development was encroaching on the
area, and the arrival of city sewer services was imminent. The court noted that the
presumption favors the zoning authority and held it was reasonable for the city to
consider the changing nature of the surrounding area. 263 Kan. at 680-81.
Here it was reasonable for the Board to consider these changed circumstances
when rejecting the Mid-States quarry proposal. There was ample testimony that the
11
character of the area next to the proposed quarry was changing. There was already a
residential neighborhood catty-corner to the proposed site. The area adjacent to the
proposed quarry was Eudora's urban growth area. With the announcement of the
Panasonic plant, Eudora's residential growth was expected to encroach on the area within
the lifetime of the quarry. There were no utilities in the area yet, but there was evidence
that Eudora officials were fielding calls from developers. It cannot be said that the
Board's decision was so wide of the mark that its unreasonableness lies outside the realm
of fair debate.
Was the Board's conclusion that a second quarry would be incompatible with the
character of the area reasonable?
Three of the factors that the Board considers when making a zoning decision are
the character of the neighborhood, the zoning and uses of properties nearby, and the
extent to which removal of the restrictions will detrimentally affect nearby property.
Golden, 224 Kan. at 598. Those three factors will be examined here.
The property proposed for the quarry is approximately 1 mile east of the City of
Eudora on agriculturally zoned land. The area adjoining the proposed quarry contains a
mix of agricultural and residential property, with a quarry Hamm operates immediately to
the north. There is a platted residential subdivision catty-corner to the proposed quarry
containing 14 homes.
First, the Hamm quarry renewal was approved before the announcement of the
Panasonic plant. Hamm cannot go into the area directly adjacent to Eudora's urban
reserve area under their current permit.
We add that there were many objections by members of the community to the
combability of the proposed quarry to the area including traffic, groundwater, property
12
values, health, safety, dust, noise, and blasting. Real estate agents familiar with the area
stated that the quarry would decrease home values along with the potential for residential
growth in the area.
It is important to note that the central objection was that the proposed quarry was
not compatible with anticipated population growth and development of Eudora. City
officials believed Eudora would expand into the urban reserve adjacent to the proposed
quarry within the next 20 years. City staff were fielding calls from developers and
property owners interested in residential and commercial development in response to the
Panasonic announcement. Eudora was working on updating its comprehensive plan. The
City presented draft population growth maps addressing the anticipated growth due to the
Panasonic plant and STAR-bond district. And the City was applying for a 21-million-
dollar grant.
Due to the current residential and agricultural character of the area, the planned
residential development, and our deferential standard of review, we hold the Board's
decision to be reasonable.
The Board found the harm of the proposed quarry outweighed the benefits to the
community. The proposed quarry would have been located next to an established
residential subdivision, much closer than the Hamm quarry. The record contains
substantial evidence that the proposed quarry would have a negative impact on residences
nearby. These impacts included environmental, health, safety, and property values. There
was testimony that an additional quarry would worsen the problems that the Hamm
quarry already causes.
Such a quarry would inhibit future residential development. The City of Eudora
officials testified that they planned to residentially develop the area abutting the proposed
quarry within 20 years. Eudora's comprehensive plan had assumed population growth at a
13
lower rate based on historical trends, but the growth maps were devised before the
Panasonic announcement. Eudora officials said they were working to update the
comprehensive plan. The City submitted a draft growth map that showed residential
development all along the west side of the proposed quarry.
The evidence of Eudora's future growth was not mere speculation. The Panasonic
plant and STAR-bond district were in process. Eudora had already planned to grow
residentially to the southeast toward the quarry. The Panasonic plant announcement just
accelerated the anticipated growth. Eudora city officials were taking concrete steps such
as seeking bids to update their comprehensive plan, taking calls from developers, and
applying for a $21 million grant. The officials believed Eudora would begin to populate
that area before 2040. Mid-States' attempts to show that officials stated otherwise are
taken out of context. The nonexistence of water and sewer services in the urban growth
area does not make the Board's decision unreasonable considering all the facts. Mid-
States admits that under Eudora's comprehensive plan, annexation is possible in the urban
reserve area west of the quarries.
The cases cited by Mid-States are distinguishable. In Taco Bell v. City of Mission,
234 Kan. 879, 678 P.2d 133 (1984), the city denied a zoning change for a Taco Bell
restaurant on Johnson Drive. The city speculated that the land may in the future be used
for office buildings. But there was evidence presented from real estate experts that office
buildings in the area were vacant, big rent concessions were being made to keep tenants,
there had been no activity on some office buildings listings for over a year, and no office
buildings were being constructed on Johnson Drive. The trial court's finding that it was
not feasible to develop the site as an office building was upheld on appeal. 234 Kan. at
888-89.
14
Here, in contrast, there was substantial evidence that the area was suitable for
residential development and that residential development was needed in the area due to
the upcoming STAR-bond district and Panasonic plant.
In Pierson v. Board of Pottawatomie County Comm'rs, 66 Kan. App. 2d 20, 26-27,
576 P.3d 860 (2025), the court held the board was reasonable when it approved a permit
for a proposed quarry on rural agricultural land in Pottawatomie County with four houses
within 1,000 feet of the quarry. The court found that four houses within 1,000 feet of a
quarry more or less conformed with the density of homes surrounding the other four
major quarries in the county.
Here, in contrast, there was an established residential development directly
adjacent to the proposed quarry with 14 homes and other residences nearby. Moreover, as
stated above many times, the central concern was the planned future residential
development.
The Board found that the proposed quarry was not compatible with the area,
noting the significant residential development already present, and that the proposed
quarry was too close to Eudora's urban growth area and its plans to expand. The Board's
decision was reasonable.
Do we reweigh the evidence about the need for quarry material?
Some testified to the Board that there was a lack of market demand for limestone
and that existing quarries in the area could handle any growing demand. There was
contrasting testimony stating there was a need for nearby rock to support development of
the Panasonic plant and the STAR-bond district, and to lower the prices with
competition. Mid-States stated they had already received an order for 25,000 tons from
their Big Springs quarry on the other side of the county for the Panasonic plant.
15
There was conflicting evidence of the imminent market need for the quarry
material. Everyone acknowledged the general need for nearby rock. But the record does
not contain undisputed evidence that the Hamm quarry, and other nearby quarries, could
not handle the demand. Mid-States managed to fulfill an order for the Panasonic plant
from its other quarry in the county. A closer quarry would reduce trucking costs. But the
Board weighed that against the other interests of the community. Mid-States merely asks
this court to reweigh the evidence. With one quarry already at that location, the Board
found the market need did not outweigh the other interests of the community. But there
was more at stake here than a need for limestone.
Both the Planning Commissioners and Board Commissioners had what can only
be described as a fair debate on the matter. The Board weighed the need for rock to build
infrastructure against the compounding impacts of two quarries right next to each other
and the need for residential development to the southeast of Eudora.
We follow our standard of review on zoning decisions and conclude that this
decision was not so arbitrary that it was made without regard to the community at large
nor was it so wide of the mark that its unreasonableness lies outside the realm of fair
debate. We will not substitute our judgment for the judgment of the Board. This Board
properly considered all the interests of the community, not just the need for limestone.
Was this a plebiscite?
These types of land-use decisions can be controversial. The question we must
answer is: did the Board relinquish its quasi-judicial role and adopt irrelevant personal
concerns of members of the public rather than consider the community at large?
The caselaw is clear on this point. "'Zoning is not to be based upon a plebiscite of
the neighbors, and although their wishes are to be considered, the final ruling is to be
16
governed by consideration of the benefit or harm involved to the community at large.'"
Taco Bell, 234 Kan. at 891-92 (quoting Waterstradt v. Board of Commissioners, 203
Kan. 317, Syl. ¶ 3, 454 P.2d 445 [1969]); see also Zimmerman v. Board of Wabaunsee
County Comm'rs, 289 Kan. 926, Syl. ¶ 7, 218 P.3d 400 (2009).
There is an emotional component to our concerns here. "An impermissible
plebiscite occurs when the zoning board relinquishes its quasi-judicial role to adopt the
public sentiment expressed by a vocal majority. Such a plebiscite is impermissible
because popular support for, or opposition to, a proposed construction project might be
based upon irrelevant environmental, financial, or personal concerns." Leffel v. City of
Mission Hills, 47 Kan. App. 2d 8, 25, 270 P.3d 1 (2011).
Cleary, there was a vocal opposition to the quarry. Some spoke about personal
concerns, but many analyzed the Golden factors and spoke about the community at large.
The central concern was the need for Eudora to expand.
In our view, the Board did not engage in impermissible plebiscite voting. Instead,
the Board engaged in a fair debate between the imminent need for residential expansion
outside of Eudora and the valuable limestone resource in the ground. There was strong
vocal opposition at the hearing from residents in the area, but the Board in making its
decision considered the community at large. Many of the residents submitted written
opposition with an analysis of the Golden factors. Eudora City officials testified
regarding the transformation of the area to accommodate residential development,
addressing Golden factors 1 and 2. The Board specifically weighed the benefit to the
community at large of the quarry against the harm of the quarry. This record shows that
the system worked as it was intended to work; rational decisions were made based on
public and private reasons and not unmindful emotional reactions.
17
Was the Board's decision unreasonable because it failed to issue written findings?
Mid-States argued to the district court that the Board's failure to issue written
findings of fact reflected unreasonableness. The district court rejected the argument. So
do we.
Formal findings and conclusions from a zoning authority are not mandatory if the
record is adequate to determine reasonableness. And a zoning decision is not
unreasonable merely because the Golden factors are not specifically enumerated. City of
Olathe, 263 Kan. at 677-79.
"Although strongly encouraged, a governing body is not required to make formal findings
of fact concerning its decisions regulating land use. It is more important that there exists a
record of what the governing body considered before making its decision so that the
reviewing court is not left in a quandary as to why the decision was made." Zimmerman,
289 Kan. 926, Syl. ¶ 11.
Likewise, the court in City of Olathe reviewed the City Council's decision despite the
City Council's failure to enumerate any reasons for its decision. 263 Kan. at 679.
The Golden factors may be implicit in the record. The court in Landau v. City
Council of Overland Park, 244 Kan. 257, 262-64, 767 P.2d 1290 (1989), reviewed each
Golden factor on appeal although the city only considered two of the factors in its written
findings.
The burden is on the party making a claim to designate a record sufficient to
present its points to the appellate court and to establish its claims. Bicknell v. Kansas
Dept. of Revenue, 315 Kan. 451, 462-63, 509 P.3d 1211 (2022). See Supreme Court Rule
6.02(a)(4) (2026 Kan. S. Ct. R. at 36). Including documents in the appendix of a brief
does not make those documents part of the record that can be considered for appellate
18
review. Rodriguez v. U.S.D. No. 500, 302 Kan. 134, 144, 351 P.3d 1243 (2015). See
Supreme Court Rule 6.02(b).
This record is disorganized and incomplete. But the failure to designate a record
goes against Mid-States as the appellant. The Board's failure to issue written findings
does not upend the presumption of reasonableness or Mid-States' burden on appeal.
Simply put, this record contains substantial evidence to support the reasonableness of the
Board's decision.
Affirmed.
19