Full Opinion

Filed Washington State Court of Appeals Division Two November 17, 2026 IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON DIVISION II FUTUREWISE, No. 61665-3-II Appellant, v. KITSAP COUNTY, and the STATE OF UNPUBLISHED OPINION WASHINGTON, GROWTH MANAGEMENT HEARINGS BOARD, Respondents. MAXA, P.J. – Futurewise appeals a Final Decision and Order of the Growth Management Hearings Board (the Board) dismissing one of its challenges to Kitsap County’s 2024 amendments to its comprehensive plan and certain development regulations. This administrative appeal arose from Futurewise’s argument that Kitsap County (the County) was required but failed to revise its comprehensive plan and development regulations to protect surface and groundwater as required by various statutes, including RCW 36.70A.590. The Growth Management Act (GMA), chapter 36.70A RCW, requires counties to create a comprehensive plan to guide their land use and development decision making. The GMA also requires counties to enact development regulations that implement and are consistent with the No. 61665-3-II comprehensive plan. Comprehensive plans and development regulations are subject to continuing review and evaluation. The County conducted a periodic review and amended its comprehensive plan in 2016. In January 2018, the legislature enacted RCW 36.70A.590, which states that a county “may rely on or refer to applicable minimum instream flow rules” to comply with the provisions of the GMA relating to surface and groundwater resources, and that “[d]evelopment regulations must ensure proposed water uses are consistent with” certain other statutes involving water use. In February 2018, the County enacted Ordinance 551-2018, a development regulation. Ordinance 551-2018 requires building permit applicants to produce evidence of water availability in the building permitting process. In 2024, the County conducted another periodic review and enacted Ordinance 637-2024, which updated the County’s comprehensive plan and certain development regulations. Futurewise filed a petition for review to the Board challenging various aspects of the County’s 2024 amendments to its comprehensive plan and development regulations in Ordinance 637-2024. Among other issues, in what the Board referred to as Issue 13, Futurewise argued that during its periodic review the County was required to but failed to (1) limit withdrawals of water from permit exempt water wells to 5,000 gallons per day and (2) improve the environment by enacting water regulations. Futurewise’s petition for review did not challenge Ordinance 551- 2018. The County responded that it was not required to update its water regulations in Ordinance 637-2024 because Ordinance 551-2018 already had responded to the GMA amendments regarding water regulations. In reply, Futurewise argued that Ordinance 551-2018 did not bring the County into compliance with RCW 36.70A.590. 2 No. 61665-3-II Regarding Issue 13, the Board declined to address Ordinance 551-2018 and summarily dismissed Futurewise’s water regulation challenge to Ordinance 637-2024 without discussion or analysis. We hold that (1) the Board erred in refusing to address Ordinance 551-2018 because the County asserted that ordinance as a defense to Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637-2024, and (2) the Board failed to decide all issues requiring resolution of Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637-2024. Accordingly, we vacate the discussion of Issue 13 in the Board’s Final Decision and Order and remand to the Board for further proceedings regarding that issue. FACTS GMA Background The GMA requires counties to adopt a comprehensive plan and adopt development regulations that are consistent with and implement the comprehensive plan. RCW 36.70A.040(3)(d). A comprehensive plan is a “generalized coordinated land use policy statement of the governing body of a county or city.” RCW 36.70A.030(9). Comprehensive plans must include a land use element that provides for the protection of the quality and quantity of groundwater used for public water supplies, and a rural element that protects surface water and groundwater resources. RCW 36.70A.070(1), (5)(c)(iv). Development regulations are “the controls placed on development or land use activities by a county or city, including, but not limited to, zoning ordinances, critical areas ordinances, shoreline master programs, official controls, planned unit development ordinances, subdivision ordinances, and binding site plan ordinances together with any amendments thereto.” RCW 36.70A.030(14). RCW 36.70A.130(1)(a) states that a county “shall take legislative action to review and, if needed, revise its comprehensive land use plan and development regulations to ensure the plan 3 No. 61665-3-II and regulations comply with the requirements of [the GMA]” before certain deadlines in the statute. This section required the County to take action to review its comprehensive plan and development regulations in both 2016 and 2024. RCW 36.70A.130(4)(b), (5)(a). “Legislative action means the adoption of a resolution or ordinance . . . indicating at a minimum, a finding that a review and evaluation has occurred and identifying the revisions made, or that a revision was not needed and the reasons therefor.” RCW 36.70A.130(1)(c). The County’s Comprehensive Planning and Development Regulations In 2016, the County conducted a periodic review and updated its comprehensive plan and development regulations, as required by RCW 36.70A.130(4)(b). But in January 2018, the legislature enacted RCW 36.70A.590, which states, For the purposes of complying with the requirements of [the GMA] relating to surface and groundwater resources, a county or city may rely on or refer to applicable minimum instream flow rules adopted by the department of ecology under chapters 90.22 and 90.54 RCW. Development regulations must ensure that proposed water uses are consistent with RCW 90.44.050 and with applicable rules adopted pursuant to chapters 90.22 and 90.54 RCW when making decisions under RCW 19.27.097 and 58.17.110. In February 2018, the County enacted Ordinance 551-2018, which addressed requirements associated with water availability in the building permitting process. Ordinance 551-2018 added provisions requiring a building permit applicant to provide evidence of an adequate water supply. Specifically, Ordinance 551-2018 stated that when a building site is “supplied by a permit exempt well constructed on or after January 19, 2018 . . . [t]he annual average withdrawal is limited to nine hundred fifty (950) gallons per day per connection for domestic use.” Admin. Rec. (AR) at 3165. In 2023, the legislature amended RCW 36.70A.020(10), adding “and enhance” to goal 10 of the GMA, which now states, “Protect and enhance the environment and enhance the state’s 4 No. 61665-3-II high quality of life, including air and water quality, and the availability of water.” (Emphasis added.) In 2024, the County conducted a periodic review and enacted Ordinance 637-2024. Ordinance 637-2024 adopted an updated comprehensive plan and amended certain development regulations. Procedural History Futurewise filed a petition for review to the Board challenging Ordinance 637-2024. Among other issues, Futurewise’s petition posed the following question as an issue presented for review (referred to as Issue 13): Did the adoption of Ordinance No. 637-2024, the comprehensive plan, the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map, Title 16 (Land Division and Development), and Title 17 (Zoning), protect surface and ground water as required by RCW 36.70A.020(10), RCW 36.70A.070, RCW 36.70A.070(1), RCW 36.70A.070(5)(c)(iv), RCW 36.70A.130(1) and (5)(a), RCW 36.70A.290(2), or RCW 36.70A.590? AR at 609.1 Futurewise’s petition did not challenge Ordinance 551-2018. The Board consolidated Futurewise’s petition with other challenges to Ordinance 637- 2024. Futurewise argued that the updated comprehensive plan and development regulations did not comply with RCW 36.70A.590 because none of its provisions limited withdrawals of water from permit exempt water wells to 5,000 gallons per day as required by that statute. Futurewise contended that because the comprehensive plan and development regulations “did not require compliance with applicable minimum instream flow rules” as discussed by RCW 36.70A.590, it violated the GMA provisions that require a comprehensive plan to include elements that protect 1 Futurewise asserted other challenges to Ordinance 637-2024 before the Board. Those challenges are not at issue in this appeal. 5 No. 61665-3-II surface and groundwater resources. AR at 1977-78. Futurewise also argued that Ordinance 637- 2024 violated the amended RCW 36.70A.020(10) “[b]y failing to improve land use regulations to protect hydrology.” AR at 1977. In addition, Futurewise argued that Ordinance 637-2024 failed to comply with (1) RCW 36.70A.070(1),which requires that “[t]he land use element shall provide for protection of the quality and quantity of groundwater used for public water supplies”; and (2) RCW 36.70A.070(5)(c)(iv), which requires that “[t]he rural element shall include measures that apply to rural development and protect the rural character of the area, as established by the county, by: . . . Protecting surface water and groundwater resources.” AR at 1977-78. The County responded that it was not required to revise its comprehensive plan and development regulations in response to RCW 36.70A.590 and RCW 36.70A.020(10) during its periodic update because it already had brought itself into compliance with those regulations by enacting Ordinance 551-2018. In addition, the County argued that RCW 36.70A.590 did not require it to incorporate minimum instream flow rules under chapters 90.22 and 90.54 RCW because it merely stated that the county “may rely on or refer” to those rules. AR at 2289. Further, the County stated that the development regulations enacted by Ordinance 551-2018 complied with RCW 36.70A.590 because they incorporated the requirements for obtaining a permit exempt well found in RCW 90.94.030(4)(a)(iv)(B). At the hearing on the merits of Futurewise’s petition, the County also argued that Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 551-2018 was time barred. Futurewise responded that because the County failed to produce a publication date for Ordinance 551-2018, it could not establish that the statute of limitations period to challenge an ordinance under the GMA had run. And Futurewise emphasized that Ordinance 551-2018 did not comply with RCW 36.70A.590 6 No. 61665-3-II because it did not limit withdrawals from wells constructed before 2018 at all and did not limit withdrawals from permit exempt wells to 5,000 gallons per day. The Board’s Final Decision and Order include a section regarding Issue 13. The Board recounted the parties’ arguments regarding Issue 13 and then stated, The Board would not anticipate the Index of Record in this matter to include the publication from a 2018 Ordinance, nor would the County presume to include it as the Issue deals with Ordinance No. 637-2024, and not Ordinance 551-2018. Thus, the Board is not persuaded by Futurewise’s argument regarding the 2018 Ordinance and find[s] issues related to that Ordinance would not be properly before this Board in this matter. Futurewise has not convinced this Board that this Ordinance is clearly erroneous. Accordingly, issue 13 is dismissed. AR at 3240. Futurewise filed a motion for reconsideration regarding Issue 13. Futurewise argued that (1) the Board committed an error of fact by finding that the need for a notice of publication of Ordinance 551-2018 was unanticipated, (2) that the Board committed an error of law by implicitly concluding that the challenge to Ordinance 551-2018 was time barred, and (3) the Board should have decided the issue on the merits. The Board denied the motion. In its order, the Board twice pointed out that Ordinance 551-2018 was “not under review by Futurewise’s Petition in this matter.” AR at 3398-99. Futurewise filed a petition for judicial review in Thurston County Superior Court, seeking review of both the Board’s Final Decision and Order and the order on reconsideration. The petition was transferred directly to this court pursuant to RCW 34.05.518(2)(a)(i). ANALYSIS A. STANDARD OF REVIEW The Administrative Procedure Act (APA), chapter 34.05 RCW, governs our review of the Board’s order. King County v. Friends of Sammamish Valley, 3 Wn.3d 793, 802, 556 P.3d 132 7 No. 61665-3-II (2024). RCW 34.05.570(3) provides nine grounds for invalidating an administrative agency’s order. Futurewise argues that three of these grounds apply in this appeal: (1) the Board “erroneously interpreted or applied the law,” RCW 34.05.570(3)(d); (2) the Board’s order “is not supported by evidence that is substantial when viewed in light of the whole record before the court,” RCW 34.05.570(3)(e); and (3) the Board did “not decid[e] all issues requiring resolution,” RCW 34.05.570(3)(f). Under the APA, we may grant relief only if we determine that the party “seeking judicial relief has been substantially prejudiced by the action complained of.” RCW 34.05.570(1)(d). A party asserting error carries the burden of demonstrating that the Board’s order erroneously interpreted the law or is not supported by substantial evidence. Friends of Sammamish Valley, 3 Wn.3d at 802. Under the APA, we give deference to the Board because of its specialized expertise. Id. Substantial evidence is “a sufficient quantity of evidence exists in the record that a fair-minded person could be persuaded of the truth or correctness of the Board’s order.” Id. at 802-03. The GMA also guides our review of the Board’s order. “The board shall find compliance unless it determines that the action by the state agency, county, or city is clearly erroneous in view of the entire record before the board and in light of the goals and requirements of this chapter.” RCW 36.70A.320(3) (emphasis added). An action is clearly erroneous when the Board has a firm and definite conviction that a mistake has been committed. Friends of Sammamish Valley, 3 Wn.3d at 802. B. GMA PRINCIPLES As noted above, the GMA requires counties to adopt a comprehensive plan and adopt development regulations that are consistent with and implement the comprehensive plan. RCW 8 No. 61665-3-II 36.70A.040(3)(d). Comprehensive plans, development regulations, and amendments thereto are presumed valid upon adoption. RCW 36.70A.320(1). An unchallenged comprehensive plan “is conclusively deemed legally compliant” with the GMA. Thurston County v. W. Wash. Growth Mgmt. Hr’gs Bd., 164 Wn.2d 329, 345, 190 P.3d 38 (2008). Counties must periodically review, and “if needed, revise [their] comprehensive land use plan and development regulations to ensure the plan and regulations comply with the requirements of [the GMA].” RCW 36.70A.130(1)(a). Similarly, RCW 36.70A.130(5) states that “following the review of comprehensive plans and development regulations . . . , counties . . . shall take action to review and, if needed, revise their comprehensive plans and development regulations to ensure the plan and regulations comply with the requirements of [the GMA].” “[T]he GMA does not explicitly require a county to revise every aspect of its comprehensive plan and [this court] refuse[s] to imply such an onerous requirement in the absence of an explicit GMA provision to the contrary.” Thurston County, 164 Wn.2d at 343-44. In Thurston County, the Supreme Court addressed when a party may challenge a county’s failure to update its comprehensive plan in a manner consistent with GMA amendments. Id. at 344. The court stated, [A] party may challenge a county’s failure to revise a comprehensive plan only with respect to those provisions that are directly affected by new or recently amended GMA provisions, meaning those provisions related to mandatory elements of a comprehensive plan that have been adopted or substantively amended since the previous comprehensive plan was adopted or updated, following a [periodic] update. This rule provides a means to ensure a comprehensive plan complies with recent GMA amendments, recognizes the original plan was legally deemed compliant with the GMA, and preserves some degree of finality. Id. RCW 36.70A.290(1) states “All requests for review to the growth management hearings board shall be initiated by filing a petition that includes a detailed statement of issues presented 9 No. 61665-3-II for resolution by the board. . . . The board shall not issue advisory opinions on issues not presented to the board in the statement of issues, as modified by any prehearing order.” (Emphasis added.) To challenge an enactment’s compliance with the GMA, a party must file a petition for review within 60 days of publication of a comprehensive plan or development regulation. RCW 36.70A.290(2). C. CHALLENGE TO ORDINANCE 551-2018 Futurewise argues that the Board erred in ruling that Ordinance 551-2018, which enacted certain development regulations relating to water, was not properly before the Board. We agree. 1. Basis of Board’s Ruling As a threshold issue, the parties disagree about the basis of the Board’s dismissal. Futurewise asserts that the Board implicitly ruled that its challenge to Ordinance 551-2018 was time barred. The County argues that the Board dismissed this issue based on the scope of its jurisdiction. The Final Decision and Order is somewhat unclear. But the order stated, “issues related to [Ordinance 551-2018] would not be properly before this Board in this matter.” AR at 3240. And the Board’s order on Futurewise’s motion for reconsideration twice pointed out that Ordinance 551-2018 was not properly raised in Futurewise’s petition for review. Therefore, we conclude that the basis of the Board’s decision was Futurewise’s failure to challenge Ordinance 551-2018 in its petition, and that it did not find that Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 551- 2018 was time barred.2 2 Futurewise argues at length that (1) the Board’s implicit ruling that its challenge to Ordinance 551-2018 was time barred constitutes an error of law and (2) substantial evidence does not support the Board’s implicit ruling that its challenge to Ordinance 551-2018 was time barred because the County did not produce a publication notice for Ordinance 551-2018. Because we 10 No. 61665-3-II 2. Board’s Decision Not to Consider Ordinance 551-2018 Futurewise argues that the Board erred in refusing to address issues relating to Ordinance 551-2018. We agree. To the extent that Futurewise was challenging the validity of Ordinance 551-2018, the Board’s ruling was correct. RCW 36.70A.290(1) states, “All requests for review to the growth management hearings board shall be initiated by filing a petition that includes a detailed statement of issues presented for resolution by the board” and “The board shall not issue advisory opinions on issues not presented to the board in the statement of issues, as modified by any prehearing order.” (Emphasis added); see also WAC 242-03-810(2). Futurewise’s petition does not identify Ordinance 551-2018 in its statement of issues. Instead, the statement of issues only identifies Ordinance 637-2024. The Board was therefore not at liberty to “issue advisory opinions on [the] issue[]” of whether a 2018 development regulation complied with RCW 36.70A.290(1). However, Futurewise emphasizes that it did not seek to invalidate Ordinance 551-2018 or argue that the County should have revised Ordinance 551-2018 during its periodic review. Instead, Futurewise challenged whether Ordinance 637-2024 complied with the GMA. The County’s defense to that challenge was that Ordinance 637-2024 did not need to address RCW 36.70A.590 because Ordinance 551-2018 satisfied that statute. Futurewise argues that the Board was required to assess the validity of that defense by analyzing whether Ordinance 551-2018 satisfied RCW 36.70A.590. conclude that the Board did not rule that any challenge to Ordinance 551-2018 was time barred, we do not address these arguments. 11 No. 61665-3-II We agree with Futurewise. The County argued that Ordinance 551-2018 satisfied the new GMA requirements passed in 2018, and therefore the County was not required to further amend its development regulations during its 2024 periodic review process. In order to evaluate that defense, the Board needed to address whether Ordinance 551-2018 satisfied, or even addressed, the requirements of RCW 36.70A.590. If that ordinance did not, RCW 36.70A.130(1)(a) and (5) may have required the County to modify its comprehensive plan or development regulations in 2024. Therefore, even though Futurewise did not reference Ordinance 551-2018 in its petition, the adequacy of that ordinance was directly at issue with regard to Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637-2024. We hold that the Board erred in failing to address Ordinance 551-2018 in the context of the County’s defense to Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637-2024. D. FAILURE TO DECIDE ALL ISSUES REQUIRING RESOLUTION Futurewise directly challenged Ordinance 637-2024, asserting that the passage of that ordinance was insufficient to satisfy the County’s periodic review obligation under RCW 36.70A.130(1)(a). Futurewise argues that the Board failed to decide all issues requiring resolution when it summarily dismissed its challenge to Ordinance 637-2024. We agree. RCW 36.70A.290(1) states that “[t]he board shall render written decisions articulating the basis for its holdings.” In Low Income Housing Institute v. City of Lakewood, this court remanded a GMA case where “the Board summarily ruled that [the petitioner] failed to carry its burden to show” an error under the GMA. 119 Wn. App. 110, 118, 77 P.3d 653 (2003). The court stated, “the Board present[ed] no basis for its decision” and concluded that the Board failed to decide all issues requiring resolution under RCW 34.05.570(3)(f). Id. at 119. 12 No. 61665-3-II Grounds for remand under RCW 34.05.570(3)(f) arise “[w]hen an agency fails to address an issue or supplies no reason for a decision, based on an erroneous legal conclusion that leads an agency either to not decide or to inadequately decide an issue.” Suquamish Tribe v. Cent. Puget Sound Growth Mgm’t Hr’gs Bd., 156 Wn. App. 743, 778, 235 P.3d 812 (2010). Futurewise argued before the Board that between the County’s 2016 periodic review and its 2024 periodic review, the legislature amended the GMA to include two provisions that required the County to modify either its comprehensive plan or development regulations. The Board’s Final Decision and Order did not expressly address this argument. The County argues that the Board addressed Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637- 2024 in its Final Decision and Order by stating that “Futurewise has not convinced this Board that this Ordinance is clearly erroneous” after previously referring to Ordinance 551-2018 as “that Ordinance.” AR at 3240. But even if the Board was referring to Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637-2024 – which is somewhat unclear – the Board’s Final Decision and Order was insufficient. The order summarily rejected Futurewise’s challenge and offered no analysis, citation to the record, or citation to authority in support of its decision. However, the Board was required to provide a basis for its decision that Futurewise failed to establish clear error with respect to Ordinance 637- 2024. Low Income Hous. Inst., 119 Wn. App. at 118-19. Accordingly, we conclude that the Board failed to articulate a basis for its decision as required by RCW 36.70A.290(1) and failed to decide all issues requiring resolution in the action as required by RCW 34.05.570(3)(f). The Board appears to have declined to address Futurewise’s arguments directed at the County’s 2024 periodic review because it considered them to be an inappropriate attack on Ordinance 551-2018, which it ruled was not before the Board. This conclusion caused the Board 13 No. 61665-3-II to address Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637-2024 inadequately. But several potentially dispositive issues remained unaddressed. These issues may include, but are not limited to, (1) whether Ordinance 637-2024 complied with water protection statutes enacted after the 2016 update, (2) whether the intervening passage of Ordinance 551-2018 obviated the need to revise all water-related development regulations during the County’s 2024 periodic review, (3) what RCW 36.70A.590 required of the County during its 2024 review process, (4) what the amendment to RCW 36.70A.020 Goal 10 adding the phrase “and enhance” required of the County during its 2024 review process, (5) whether Ordinance 637-2024 satisfied the requirements of RCW 36.70A.070(1) and (5)(c)(iv), and (6) the effect of the rule in Thurston County on the outcome of Futurewise’s appeal.3 Because the Board’s legal error caused it to inadequately address Futurewise’s challenge to the County’s 2024 periodic review, we conclude that there is a basis to remand under RCW 34.05.570(3)(f). Suquamish Tribe, 156 Wn. App. at 778. To remand, we must determine that Futurewise was “substantially prejudiced” by the Board’s decision. RCW 34.05.570(1)(d). The County argues that the Board’s failure to address Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637-2024 adequately is not prejudicial because the law supports its position on the merits. But the Board’s opinion is unclear as to whether it considered or resolved any of the issues identified above. Resolution of those issues may result in Futurewise prevailing in its challenge to Ordinance 637-2024. Therefore, we conclude that Futurewise was prejudiced by the Board’s failure to address all issues requiring resolution. The County also argues that we should decide any questions the Board failed to address (or address adequately) and reject Futurewise’s arguments on appeal. We disagree. 3 We express no opinion regarding the merits of these issues. 14 No. 61665-3-II “Where an issue is not decided but remains relevant to the challenged action, the appropriate remedy is to remand for the agency to exercise its judgment and make a decision.” Suquamish Tribe, 156 Wn. App. at 778. And remand is particularly appropriate here because the Board was created to interpret issues arising under the GMA and we defer to the Board’s decisions because of its specialized knowledge. See Friends of Sammamish Valley, 3 Wn.3d at 802. Because the Board failed to address all of Futurewise’s arguments, it was not able to apply its specialized knowledge to Futurewise’s petition. Therefore, we remand for the Board to decide the issues raised in Futurewise’s challenge to Ordinance 637-2024 in Issue 13 consistent with this opinion. CONCLUSION We vacate the discussion of Issue 13 in the Board’s Final Decision and Order and remand to the Board for further proceedings regarding that issue. A majority of the panel having determined that this opinion will not be printed in the Washington Appellate Reports, but will be filed for public record in accordance with RCW 2.06.040, it is so ordered. MAXA, P.J. We concur: LEE, J. CHE, J. 15