Full Opinion

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS NOs. WR-96,732-01 & WR-96,732-02 EX PARTE SCOTT ANTHONY HETRICK, Applicant ON APPLICATIONS FOR WRITS OF HABEAS CORPUS CAUSE NOs. 25315A & 25517A IN THE 91st DISTRICT COURT EASTLAND COUNTY Finley, J., delivered the opinion of the Court in which Richardson, Newell, Walker, and Parker, JJ., joined. Schenck, P.J., and Yeary, Keel, and McClure, JJ., dissented. 1 OPINION In the late 1980s, Tom Peters popularized the concept “under promise, over deliver” in business and management literature. The same concept rings 1 Presiding Judge Schenck and Judges Yeary, Keel, and McClure, would deny the application for a writ of habeas corpus. HETRICK— 2 equally true in trial litigation. In the instant habeas applications, Applicant was charged with and convicted of three counts of sexual assault of a child (the -01 writ) and one count of continuous sexual abuse of a child (the -02 writ). Applicant’s trial attorney repeatedly promised throughout Applicant’s trial that the jury would hear from Applicant’s wife, Elizabeth Hetrick (“Hetrick”). For example, in opening statements, Applicant’s trial attorney told the jury that “I expect that Liz Hetrick will take the witness stand and testify.” Later in opening statements, Applicant’s trial attorney repeatedly emphasized that nobody knew the child complainant better than Hetrick and that she has “stuck by her husband every day since,” because “the more she learned and the more she understood, she understood, hey, the answer is it didn’t happen. It didn’t happen.” Applicant’s trial attorneys then brought up Hetrick several times during the cross- examination of numerous State witnesses. Inexplicably, Applicant rested his case-in-chief without ever calling Hetrick to the stand. Applicant was then convicted on all counts and sentenced to twenty years’ and fifty years’ confinement, respectively. In the instant habeas applications, Applicant alleges that his trial attorneys were ineffective for failing to call Hetrick to testify. Hetrick has filed two affidavits which aver that she would have provided testimony that would have shown the complainant’s motive to lie HETRICK— 3 the complainant’s character for dishonesty, and would have refuted two incidents alleged by the complainant. Applicant’s lead trial attorney, David Stokes, has since passed away. Second-chair counsel, Colemon Stokes, David Stokes’s son, filed two affidavits that provide less than concrete answers for why Hetrick was not called to testify. We conclude that the failure of Applicant’s trial attorneys to call Hetrick to testify after the jury was repeatedly promised that they would hear from Hetrick permitted the jury to draw negative adverse inferences against Applicant. See, e.g., Harris v. Reed, 894 F.2d 871, 879 (7th Cir. 1990) (“the jury likely concluded that counsel could not live up the claims made in the opening”); see also Anderson v. Butler, 858 F.2d 16, 17 (1st Cir. 1988) (holding that “little is more damaging than to fail to produce important evidence that had been promised in an opening” and it was “inexcusable to have given the matter so little thought at the outset as to have made the opening promise”). Accordingly, Applicant has shown, by the applicable preponderance standard, that his trial attorneys were constitutionally ineffective and that Applicant was prejudiced by their inadequate representation. We grant Applicant habeas relief in the form of a new trial. I. Factual Background The court of appeals’ opinion on direct appeal summarized the evidence as follows: HETRICK— 4 The events leading to [Applicant]’s convictions came to light in October 2018 when B.C., then 15 years old, confided her fear of being pregnant to her best friend and high school classmate, H.P. B.C. told H.P. [Applicant] had raped her three or four weeks earlier. B.C. testified that she was afraid to tell her mom because they relied on [Applicant] to pay the bills, and if he went to jail, there would be no one to pay the bills since her mom was going to school. She asked H.P. to get her a pregnancy test. H.P. obtained a pregnancy test for B.C. and brought it to her at school. B.C. told her other good friend and classmate, A.C., she was going to take the pregnancy test. But because A.C. was “good friends” with B.C.’s mom and [Applicant] “and everybody,” B.C. did not want to tell A.C. about [Applicant] raping her. Instead, B.C. told A.C. there was a boy from another town. A.C. did not believe her, and B.C. eventually revealed to her that she had been raped by [Applicant]. B.C. disclosed the rape to more of her friends and classmates in the subsequent days, asking that they not tell anyone. But some of these friends and classmates reported the rape to the high school counselor. After speaking briefly to B.C. on October 24, 2018, the counselor alerted the authorities. On that day, B.C.’s mother drove B.C. to the crisis advocacy center to be interviewed and then accompanied her to the hospital to be examined. At the hospital, B.C. was examined by Erica Gooding, a sexual assault nurse examiner (SANE). During the nonacute forensic examination, B.C. related to Gooding that [Applicant] had raped her weeks before and had also sexually abused her since she was about nine years old. Gooding memorialized the findings of her forensic examination in a SANE report. In the meantime, Eastland Police Chief David Hullum interviewed [Applicant] at the behest of Gorman Police Chief Steve Anderson. Anderson had requested Hullum’s assistance because of Hullum’s extensive training and experience in investigating sexually based offenses and interviewing suspects. During the interview, which was HETRICK— 5 recorded on video, Hullum accused [Applicant] of being deceptive when denying B.C.’s allegations. [Applicant] was indicted in 2019, and the consolidated trial commenced in March 2023. At trial, the State presented three witnesses during the guilt/innocence phase: Hullum, Gooding, and B.C. When Hullum testified at trial, he was the recently elected Eastland County Judge. After the State established that Hullum was a highly experienced and highly trained sexual-assault investigator, the videorecording of [Applicant]’s police interview was admitted and played for the jury. The interview and Hullum’s thoughts on it were the subject of the remainder of Hullum’s testimony on direct, cross, redirect, and recross examinations. On cross-examination, defense counsel broached the subject of deceptiveness, asking Hullum if breaking eye contact meant that the person was being deceptive. Hullum responded that breaking eye contact was indicative of deception but did not mean anything by itself. After cross- examination concluded, the State argued at a bench conference outside the jury’s presence that defense counsel had “opened the door” to the issue of [Applicant]’s deceptiveness. The trial court agreed. When redirect examination began, the State asked Hullum to opine on whether he believed [Applicant] had been deceptive in denying B.C.’s allegations. Over objection, Hullum testified that he believed [Applicant] had been deceptive, mirroring, in part, his comments to [Applicant] directly on the videorecording, addressing eye-contact along with other indications of deception. Gooding took the witness stand next. During direct examination, the SANE report was admitted into evidence without objection, though it would not be published to the jury until B.C. testified. Testifying from the report, Gooding related the detailed sexual assault and abuse allegations made by B.C. After relating this information, Gooding was asked to testify about her impressions of B.C. Gooding described B.C. as shy and embarrassed but “a very good historian.” The State then asked Gooding if she believed B.C. had fabricated the HETRICK— 6 allegations. Over objection, Gooding testified that she believed B.C. was being truthful. Further testifying from the report, when asked about there being no injury noted to B.C.’s cervix, vagina, and anus, Gooding explained it was common not to see injuries to those areas in post-pubescent girls because of estrogenization. She indicated that they see injuries in less than 5% of rape victims after 72 hours after a rape. At the conclusion of direct testimony, Gooding was again asked if she had any concern that B.C.’s story was fabricated. Defense counsel did not object, and Gooding answered she did not. B.C., 19 years old at the time of trial, was the State’s last witness. Soon after taking the stand, B.C. identified 13 photographs of her at various ages. These photographs were admitted into evidence without objection. Then, in testimony spanning more than 50 pages of the reporter’s record, B.C. recounted in great detail the countless sexual assaults [Applicant] committed against her, ending with the rape when she was 15 years of age. B.C. described a multitude of sexual assaults increasing in frequency and invasiveness over time prior to the rape at age 15. For instance, B.C. explained that [Applicant]’s actions went from: (a) playing games with her where he would touch her “upper chest” and her “bottom” and have her kneel down while he tried to shoot semen into her mouth when she was 4 or 5 years old; to (b) waking up to [Applicant]’s penis in her mouth while he was holding her head until he ejaculated into her mouth when she was 7 years old; to (c) in addition to putting his penis in her mouth, touching and licking her upper chest and private parts, rubbing her genital area, and inserting his fingers inside of her vagina at least twice per week beginning when she was 9 or 10 years old and continuing until she was 13 or 14. B.C. described how [Applicant] vaginally and anally raped her shortly after her fifteenth birthday. One afternoon while they were alone at home watching a movie on a mattress in the living room, in a struggle lasting 30 to 40 minutes, [Applicant] groped her, succeeded in pulling down her pants, and, despite B.C. crying, screaming, telling him no, and trying to fight him off, [Applicant] inserted his penis into her vagina and subsequently into her anus while she was on her HETRICK— 7 stomach. B.C. explained that she bled from her anus for approximately one week thereafter. During direct and cross-examination, B.C. denied fabricating the allegations and explained that she did not disclose the abuse and assaults to anyone over time for various reasons, including because, having grown up with it, she thought it was ordinary behavior; she was afraid of [Applicant] and his threats; and she feared disclosure would ruin the family. [Applicant] testified at trial; he presented no evidence or other witnesses. On both direct and redirect examination, he denied sexually abusing and assaulting B.C. During its deliberations, the jury asked the Court for copies of the SANE report and the videorecording of [Applicant]’s police interview. The videorecording was played for the jury in the courtroom. Hetrick v. State, No. 08-23-00093-CR, 2023 WL 8284409, at *1–3 (Tex. App.— El Paso Nov. 30, 2023, pet. ref’d). The court of appeals affirmed Applicant’s convictions. Id. at *10. This Court refused discretionary review. II. Habeas Claims and Evidence Applicant alleges that trial counsel was ineffective by promising the jury in opening statements that they would hear from Hetrick yet ultimately failing to call her to testify. Applicant alleges that Hetrick would have testified to the following: • She believes B.C. is a dishonest person and has a reputation in the community for being dishonest. HETRICK— 8 • She could corroborate that her sons—Alex Galvan and Vince Hetrick—conversed with B.C. at an indoor pool at the La Quinta in April 2019, while she and Manny Caballero—B.C.’s biological father—smoked cigarettes outside. • B.C.’s motivation for fabricating the allegations against Applicant. • She would have rebutted B.C.’s testimony that (1) Applicant sexually assaulted B.C. while in bed with Hetrick, (2) B.C. complained to Hetrick about rectal bleeding on the day after being sexually assaulted by Applicant, and (3) Hetrick refused to take B.C. to a medical doctor after B.C. complained to her about a vaginal infection. a. Initial Habeas Affidavits i. Elizabeth Hetrick Hetrick filed an affidavit attached to Applicant’s habeas applications. In the affidavit, she avers: I’m writing this affidavit to provide information about my observations of my daughter, B.C., who was the complainant in [Applicant]’s sexual assault case. B.C. is my biological daughter and [Applicant] is her stepfather. I do not believe that B.C. is telling the truth about being sexually assaulted by [Applicant]. In my opinion, B.C. is a dishonest person. She also had a reputation for being dishonest among the community of peers, adults, and family members who knew her. Two of my sons, Vince Hetrick and Alex Galvan, informed me that while they were visiting B.C. at an indoor pool at the La Quinta in Eastland in April 2019, B.C. told them: ‘I’m not trying to hurt your Dad. I’m just trying to hurt your Mom.’ I recall the circumstances of HETRICK— 9 this visit, as B.C. and her father, Manny, had travelled from New Mexico for a child-custody hearing. B.C. wanted to see me, Alex, and Vince, so we went to the La Quinta after Alex and Vince finished school on a weekday, arriving around 4:00 p.m. We all hung out in the indoor pool area for a few hours. Manny and I would occasionally go outside to smoke cigarettes. Alex, B.C., and Vince stayed inside at the pool while Manny and I were outside. B.C. made the sexual-assault allegation against [Applicant] on October 24, 2018, which is about a week-and-a-half after Vince’s birthday party (Vince’s birthday is October 22nd, which was a Monday in 2018, and we had the party two weekends earlier on Saturday, October 13th). B.C. had a lot of attitude at the party because I made her attend instead of letting her go to a friend’s quincenera. I think that B.C. was trying to hurt me because she was mad at me about not letting her attend the quincenera. B.C. was also mad at me for other reasons. She wanted a piglet because her friend, Samantha Mauney, had one, but we didn’t have the proper yard space for a farm animal, so I wouldn’t let B.C. adopt a piglet. B.C. also wanted to have her own cell phone, and she blamed both me and [Applicant] for that. Also, she really did get a lot of what she wanted after she made the allegations and moved to New Mexico to live with her biological father, Manny. For example, B.C. got a piglet and a cell phone in New Mexico, and her boyfriend was allowed to stay with her. I’m aware that B.C. alleged that one of the sexual assaults occurred in my bed while I was sleeping next to [Applicant] and B.C. I don’t believe this for several reasons. First, B.C. never slept with me and [Applicant] in the bed in the master bedroom (sometimes she would sleep on the floor but they she never slept in our bed). Second, the only time B.C. was ever in our bed was when we watched movies together in the master bedroom, and I would always be in the middle on those occasions. Third, I’m a light sleeper, so I would’ve heard any rustling in the bed that might be sexual activity. I also find it HETRICK— 10 impossible to believe that if B.C. had tried to call out that I wouldn’t have heard her, even if [Applicant] had put his hand over her mouth. ‘I’m also aware that B.C. testified that she came to me for help with rectal bleeding the day after an alleged sexual assault and that I told her it was just a hemorrhoid. This is false. B.C. never came to me complaining of rectal bleeding. If she had done so, I would’ve immediately taken her to a doctor. Furthermore, I’m aware that B.C. testified that she told me about a vaginal infection and that I just gave her Vagisil instead of taking her to a doctor. This is also not true. B.C. complained to me that our regular body soap was irritating her vagina, so I gave her Vagisil soap, which is a soap specially designed for cleaning the vaginal area. B.C. is a fighter, and if someone does something to her that she doesn’t like, she fights back. I tried to spank her one time when she was 11-years-old, and she fought back tooth-and-nail. Also , we were supposed to prick B.C.’s finger to obtain blood for a diabetes test. When [Applicant] tried to prick her finger, she kicked him in the genitals, and we were unable to get a blood sample from her. I spoke to [Applicant]’s attorney, David Stokes, many times about [Applicant]’s case and my observations of B.C. Mr. Stokes told me that he planned to call me to the stand to testify, but he never did . In fact, I sat outside the courtroom during the entire trial (except closing arguments) because I was supposed to be called as a defense witness. I was available and willing to testify on [Applicant]’s behalf. ii. Alex Galvan Alex Galvan wrote an affidavit, which averred: In April 2019, B.C. was staying at the La Quinta Inn in Eastland with her biological father, Manny, because they had travelled from New Mexico to Eastland for a child-custody hearing. My mother (Elizabeth Hetrick), halfbrother (Vince Hetrick), and I went to visit HETRICK— 11 B.C. at the La Quinta while she was staying there. We visited after school on a weekday, and we arrived at the La Quinta at about 4:00 p.m. We hung out with B.C. in the indoor pool at the La Quinta for about 2-3 hours while my mother and Manny talked. During this visit at the indoor pool, my mother and Manny went outside to smoke a cigarette at one point. While they were outside, B.C. changed the subject of what we were talking about. B.C. then said, ‘I’m not trying to hurt your Dad. I’m just trying to hurt your Mom.’ Vince and I didn’t know that much about the allegations against my stepfather ([Applicant]) at this point, and we just nodded our heads when B.C. made this statement. When my mother and Manny returned to the pool from outside, B.C. stopped talking about the criminal case. My interpretation of B.C.’s statement was that she was admitting to creating a lie about my stepfather in order to hurt my mother. I do not believe that B.C. is telling the truth about being sexually assaulted by my stepfather. In my opinion, B.C. is a dishonest person. She also had a reputation for being dishonest among people who knew her. Vince and I provided all of this information to my stepfather’s attorney, David Stokes, in a meeting at his office about two years prior to the trial. Mr. Stokes said, ‘Thank you for bringing me this information. It’s very important. Your Dad won’t go to prison.’ However, Mr. Stokes never asked me or Vince to testify. I was available and willing to testify on my stepfather’s behalf. iii. Vince Hetrick Vince Hetrick also wrote an affidavit, which averred: In April 2019, B.C. was staying at the La Quinta Inn in Eastland with her biological father, Manny, because they had travelled from New Mexico to Eastland for a child-custody hearing. My mother (Elizabeth Hetrick), halfbrother (Alex Galvan), and I went to visit HETRICK— 12 B.C. at the La Quinta after school on a weekday, arriving around 4:00 p.m. We then visited B.C. at the motel’s indoor pool for about 2-3 hours. While we were hanging out with B.C. at the indoor pool, my mother and Manny went outside to smoke a cigarette. When they were outside, B.C. started talking about the case against my father without any prompting from me or Alex. B.C. said: ‘I’m not trying to hurt your Dad. I’m just trying to hurt your Mom.’ Alex and I didn’t know that much about the allegations against my father at this point, so we didn’t really say anything when B.C. made this statement. When my mother and Manny came back inside to the pool area, B.C. stopped talking about my father’s case. I interpreted B.C.’s statement as meaning that she was admitting to lying about the allegations against my father so that she could hurt my mother. I do not believe that B.C. is telling the truth about being sexually assaulted by my father. In my opinion, B.C. is a dishonest person. She also had a reputation for being dishonest among people who knew her. Alex and I provided all of this information to my father’s attorney, David Stokes, when we met with him at his office about two years before the trial. Mr. Stokes said, ‘Thank you for bringing me this information. It’s very important. Your Dad won’t go to prison.’ However, Mr. Stokes never asked me or Alex to testify. I was definitely available and willing to testify on my father’s behalf. b. Evidence on initial remand The habeas applications were prematurely forwarded to this Court. On June 18, 2025, this Court remanded the habeas applications to the habeas court for it to complete its fact-finding. Ex parte Hetrick, No. WR-96,732-01, 2025 WL 1703229, at *1 (Tex. Crim. App. June 18, 2025) (mem. op., not designated for publication). HETRICK— 13 i. Colemon Stokes Applicant’s second-chair trial counsel, Colemon Stokes, filed an affidavit, which averred: 1. My name is Colemon Stokes. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in the State of Texas. I served on the defense team for the Applicant in cause number Cause Number 25315 styled State of Texas v. Scott Anthony Hetrick, in the 91st Judicial District Court of Eastland, Texas. 2. I was not lead counsel during trial. Lead counsel was David Stokes, who was primarily responsible for interviewing witnesses, managing trial strategy, and making final determinations regarding which witnesses would testify at trial. 3. With respect to Ground One of the writ regarding Elizabeth Hetrick: It is true that David Stokes indicated during opening statements that the jury would likely hear testimony from Elizabeth Hetrick. That statement was made in good faith, based on information available at that time and our then-intention to call her as a wi1ness. 4. After the testimony of the complainant concluded, and following a more detailed assessment of Elizabeth Hetrick’s anticipated testimony, we determined that Elizabeth Hetrick’s testimony would corroborate certain allegations of the existence of physical evidence related to injuries sustained by the complainant during the alleged assault. The non-existence of any physical evidence supporting the allegations made by the complainant was a central theme of the trial and, in our opinion, Mrs. Hetrick’s testimony corroborating the existence of physical evidence or injuries sustained by the complainant would have significantly bolstered the State’s case. We viewed this as a substantial risk that outweighed any possible benefit from her other potential testimony. Based on that concern, we made a strategic decision not to call her to testify. This decision was not HETRICK— 14 made lightly, and it was informed by our duty to minimize the potential for prejudicial or harmful testimony. 5. With respect to Ground Two of the writ concerning Vince Hetrick and Alex Galvan: I did not personally interview either of these witnesses. I have no personal knowledge of their anticipated testimony, their characterizations of the complainant, or any statements allegedly made by the complainant at the La Quinta Inn. As noted above, David Stokes, as lead counsel, was responsible for all substantive witness interviews. To my knowledge, the decision not to call these witnesses was made as part of the broader strategy, based on the totality of evidence and anticipated impact. 6. In sum, while I was involved in trial proceedings and certain pretrial preparation, the ultimate decisions regarding witness testimony-including those involving Elizabeth Hetrick, Vince Hetrick, and Alex Galvan — were made based on strategic considerations grounded in our assessment of the risks and benefits of their respective testimony. ii. Elizabeth Hetrick’s Supplemental Affidavit Hetrick wrote a supplemental affidavit, responding to Colemon Stokes. In it, she averred: I’m now writing this affidavit in order to respond to the affidavit of Colemon Stokes, which was filed on July 14, 2025. In his affidavit, Colemon Stokes states that he and his father, David Stokes, made the decision to not call me to testify as a witness because my testimony would have corroborated ‘the existence of physical evidence or injuries sustained by the complainant.’ The implication of Colemon Stokes’ affidavit is that I would have testified in some way that corroborated the State’s allegations that [Applicant] abused B.C. This implication is completely false, as I never observed any injuries on B.C. that were the result of physical HETRICK— 15 or sexual abuse, and I certainly did not believe that [Applicant] had perpetrated any crime against her. Also, Colemon Stokes’ affidavit suggests that he and David Stokes discovered something damaging about my potential testimony after David delivered his opening statement. However, they did not have any substantive discussion about the case with me following opening statements. I believed both at the time of trial and today that my testimony would have helped [Applicant]’s case because I could dispute specific allegations by B.C., including her allegation that a sexual assault occurred while I was sleeping in the same bed with her and [Applicant] and an allegation that B.C. came to me for help with rectal bleeding. c. First Writ Hearing Testimonies i. Elizabeth Hetrick At the first habeas hearing, Hetrick testified: Q. Did you have any meetings with David Stokes to prepare for your testimony at trial? A. We had a few. Not a whole lot, but a few of them. Q. Okay. Was [Applicant] usually present at those meetings? A. Yes. Q. Did you ever have meetings with David and/or Cole Stokes where [Applicant] was not present? A. Not that I can recall, no. Q. Okay. And was Cole Stokes present at all these meetings? What was his role in the trial? HETRICK— 16 A. No, he was not present in all the meetings. He — as far as I knew, he was there just to help David Stokes with the technical aspects. Q. Okay. So your conversations preparing for trial, were they with David? A. Yes. Q. Okay. And did David ask you questions about the case as y’all prepared? A. Yeah. Q. Okay. Did he ever ask you something like whether you had ever observed physical signs of sexual abuse? A. Yes. Q. And what did you tell him? A. I told him no. Q. Okay. Did he ask that prior to trial? A. Yes. Q. Okay. And you were out in the hallway the whole trial, correct? A. Correct. Q. You were under the impression you were going to be testifying; is that correct? A. Correct. Q. Is one of the topics that you were going to testify about [B.C.]’s reputation or character for truthfulness? HETRICK— 17 A. Correct. Q. And if you had been called to the stand, what would you have testified to about your opinion about [B.C.]’s character for truthfulness? A. That [B.C.] lies. She’ll lie to get out of trouble. Q. And are you also aware of her reputation in the community that knows her for truthfulness? A. Yes. Q. And what was that reputation? A That she lies to get attention. Q. Okay. Would you have also been called to testify about the circumstances surrounding her initial outcry? A. Yes. Q. Okay. Was that in order to show a possible motive for fabricating allegations? A. Yes. * * * Q. The allegation — do you remember when the allegation was? A. I found out about it on October 24th of 2018. Q. Okay. And was there an incident about a week or two before that that made you think that [B.C.] had made up the allegation? A. Yes, there were several. HETRICK— 18 Q. What was the more immediate incident about a week and a half before that you were — A. She was mad because I would not let her go to a quinceanera because the quinceanera’s date was the same date as her brother Vincent’s birthday party. And she was very upset that she was not allowed to go. Q. How upset was she, Liz? A. She was upset. She was very standoffish. Just had — just was standing off to the side, mad the entire birthday party, not engaging with the guests or the family that was there. Q. Was there anything else that she was mad at you and [Applicant] about? A. That she wasn’t allowed to have a cell phone. We didn’t think she was old enough to have a cell phone yet. * * * Q. Do you have personal knowledge of any requests that you were supposed to get [B.C.] in order to make her happy? A. She asked for a cell phone, to be able to go out and hang out with her friends whenever she wanted, didn’t matter the time, and she requested to have a piglet. And we told her no. Q. Did any of her friends have a piglet? A. Yes. * * * Q. Were you aware that [B.C.] alleged that one of the sexual assaults occurred in your bed while you were present in there with [Applicant]? HETRICK— 19 A. I had heard about that, yes. Q. Was there ever a time that you were in a bed with [Applicant] that he molested [B.C.]? A. No. Q. If there was any kind of rustling in the bed, you usually wake up? A. Yes. Q. What type of sleeper are you? A. I’m a light sleeper. Q. Okay. And did [B.C.] ever sleep in the bed with y’all? A. No. She would lay in the bed and watch movies with us, but she never fell asleep and slept in the bed. And I was always in the middle. Q. You were always in the middle? A. Yes. Q. Okay. If [B.C.] were to call out, is that something you would hear? A. Yes. * * * Q. Are you aware that [B.C.] testified that she came to you following an alleged anal sexual assault and complained of rectal bleeding? A. Yes. HETRICK— 20 Q. How were you aware of that? A. I heard about it through reading the transcript. Q. Okay. Did that ever actually happen? A. No. Q. Okay. And you would remember if that happened, correct? A. Yeah. Because if it had happened, I would have taken her to the doctor. Q. Did she have hemorrhoids? A. No. Q. Did — and I’m not asking here about what [B.C.] said to you. Did you tell her, though, did you tell her it was a hemorrhoid? A. No. Q. Okay. Are you also aware that [B.C.] testified that she told you about a vaginal infection and that you gave her Vagisil instead of taking her to a doctor? A. Yes. Q. Is that true or false? A. That’s false. Q. Can you describe that incident? A. It wasn’t for any type of infection. She claimed that bar soap was irritating, and so I bought her something that was specifically designed for cleaning that area. HETRICK— 21 Q. So regular bar soap was irritating her vagina? A. Yeah. Q. And what did you buy her? A. I bought her Vagisil. Q. So it was a Vagisil soap you bought her? A. Yes. Q. Okay. But it had nothing to do with an infection? A. No, sir. * * * Q. Did David Stokes make it clear to you that he planned to call you to testify at trial? A. Yes, numerous times. Q. Okay. And were you under the rule? A. I’m sorry? Q. It’s legal jargon. Were you under the rule meaning that the witnesses have to be outside of the courtroom? A. Yes. Q. Okay. So did you sit outside of the courtroom the entire trial? A. Yes, until closing arguments. HETRICK— 22 Q. Okay. Did you ever have a conversation with David or Cole Stokes during that time that led you to believe that you would not be testifying? A. No. Q. Okay. Did you have any conversations with them during the trial? A. Just that they would say like the lineup, like we’re going to — this is the route we’re going to go. She’s testifying, and then we’re going to call [Applicant], and then we’re going to call you and then Jackie, so... Q. When you talked to David and/or Cole Stokes, would [Applicant] also be present? A. Yes. Q. Anybody else? A. My mother-in-law, Jackie. Q. Okay. And — A. Jacqueline Adams. Q. And was she a witness as well? A. Yes. Q. Who didn’t actually testify? A. Correct. Q. Okay. You were able to review Cole Stokes’ affidavit of July 31st, 2025; is that correct? HETRICK— 23 A. Correct. Q. Would you have testified in a way that was adverse to [Applicant]? A. No. Q. Okay. Was there any physical evidence or injuries that you ever observed on [B.C.] that you would have corroborated in your testimony? A. No. Q. Okay. Did you ever observe any injuries on [B.C.] that were consistent with either physical or sexual abuse? A. No. Q. Did you have any substantive discussion about the case with either Cole or David Stokes after opening statements were made? A. Any what? Q. Substantive discussion about the actual facts of the case. A. Not really, no. ii. Colemon Stokes At the first habeas hearing, Stokes testified: Q. I believe you provided an affidavit in response to the allegations contained in this 11.07 writ, correct? A. That’s correct. HETRICK— 24 Q. And you specifically address Ground 1 which was the decision not to call Elizabeth? A. That’s correct. * * * Q. Y’all’s decision was to not call Elizabeth to testify, correct? A. Correct. Q. And that was trial strategy? A. Correct. Q. And you agreed with that decision, correct? A. I agreed with that decision. Q. In regards to the two siblings, Alex and Vincent, it was also trial strategy not to call them to testify, correct? A. As far as I understand. I was less involved with that portion of it. And so David really took over responsibility for interviewing witnesses, and he had a better idea of that portion of it than I did. Q. Is it fair to say that your father and yourself, to some extent, had extensive contact with these witnesses? A. Yes. Q. Is it also fair to say that when a trial starts, they don’t always go the way you anticipate? A. That’s fair to say. HETRICK— 25 Q. And your trial strategy is fluid, and it changes as the trial progresses, correct? A. Yes. Q. Did y’all’s trial strategy change during the progression of this trial? A. It did. On cross-examination, Stokes testified: Q. Your role — could you describe your role on the case? A. I was second chair, so I don’t — it was very limited as far as trial. I don’t think I took any witnesses. You know, some people would call it a chair leader, essentially. I would talk to David about strategy, but he did most of the heavy lifting in that trial. Q. Do you have much recollection of like substantive things like the offense report, SANE exams, testimony? A. Yes. Q. Okay. Okay. But your role was less about making the substantive decisions; is that correct? A. Yeah. I was not the final decision-maker on everything. It was his case. And so we helped each other. Like if I had a trial, he would basically take the same role that I did in this one. Q. Okay. I had a few questions about Alex and Vince’s pool observations you said in your affidavit you didn’t have much knowledge of. Were there any notes in the case file on that from your father when you reviewed the case file prior to preparing your affidavit? HETRICK— 26 A. Not that I can recall. Q. Okay. So were you aware of that evidence at all from talking to your father about the case? A. I was aware of it. Q. Okay. Were you aware of why they weren’t called as witnesses or brought as witnesses? A. I don’t — I would say I’m aware that David did not think it would have an effect on the outcome of the trial. But as far as his conversation with them, I was not privy to it. Q. Okay. So you don’t know what the strategic reason was for not calling them? A. Not really other than David did not think it would have a significant factor in the jury’s decision. Q. Do you think that in a he-said, she-said type of case that having two siblings come in to testify that their sister recanted, do you think that that would be something helpful for the defense? A. It could, absolutely. d. Second Remand On February 12, 2026, this Court remanded the habeas applications once more. Ex parte Hetrick, No. WR-96,732-01, 2026 WL 390930, at *1 (Tex. Crim. App. Feb. 12, 2026) (mem. op., not designated for publi