John Rubio and Reinaldo Dennes v. Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Bobby Lumpkin, Criminal Institutions Division, Eric Guerrero, Bob Castleberry, Unknown Pharmacy, Unknown Pharmacist(s), Unknown Testing Laboratory, and Unknown Laboratory Analyst(s)
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 15th District
Date FiledNovember 9, 2026
Docket15-26-00200-CV
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Dismissed and Memorandum Opinion filed November 9, 2026
In The
Fifteenth Court of Appeals
NO. 15-26-00200-CV
JOHN RUBIO AND REINALDO DENNES, Appellants
V.
TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE, BOBBY LUMPKIN,
CRIMINAL INSTITUTIONS DIVISION, ERIC GUERRERO, BOB
CASTLEBERRY, UNKNOWN PHARMACY, UNKNOWN
PHARMACIST(S), UNKNOWN TESTING LABORATORY, AND
UNKNOWN LABORATORY ANALYST(S), Appellees
On Appeal from the 261st District Court
Travis County, Texas
Trial Court Cause No. D-1-GN-26-006939
MEMORANDUM OPINION
John Rubio and Reinaldo Dennes, inmates under sentence of death, appeal
from the district court’s order dismissing their claims against the Texas Department
of Criminal Justice and several of its officials for want of jurisdiction. Because
Rubio’s execution is currently scheduled for November 12, 2026, 1 we expedite our
disposition of this appeal. 2
This Court has jurisdiction over suits against the State and state officials only
if the suit arises out of a “civil” case.3 We “look to the essence of the case to
determine whether the issues it entails are more substantively criminal or civil.” 4
Criminal-law matters are those “such as guilt or innocence, the propriety of a
sentence, the criminal nature of particular conduct proved to have occurred, or
compliance with the procedural guarantees of the federal and Texas Constitutions in
a given case.”5
Appellants seek a temporary injunction and declaratory relief “prohibiting
Defendants from continuing to compound, procure, possess, distribute, use, or
administer expired or beyond-BUD pentobarbital” to him during his execution “in
violation of the Texas Constitution, Texas law, and the U.S. Constitution.” The
timing, method, and procedures governing carrying out a sentence of death, as well
as constitutional challenges to them, are clearly matters arising out of or related to a
criminal case, not a civil case. 6 Accordingly, this Court has no jurisdiction.
1
Plaintiff LeJames Norman was executed on September 16, 2026.
2
We suspend operation of Rule 42.3, which provides that we may dismiss an appeal on our
own initiative only after giving ten days’ notice to all parties. See TEX. R. APP. P. 2 (“On a party's
motion or on its own initiative an appellate court may—to expedite a decision or for other good
cause—suspend a rule’s operation in a particular case and order a different procedure”).
3
TEX. GOV’T CODE § 22.220(d) (“The Court of Appeals for the Fifteenth Court of Appeals
District has exclusive intermediate appellate jurisdiction over the following matters arising out of
or related to a civil case: (1) matters brought by or against the state or a board, commission,
department, office, or other agency in the executive branch of the state government . . . or by or
against an officer or employee of the state or a board, commission, department, office, or other
agency in the executive branch of the state government.”).
4
In re Tex. House of Representatives, 702 S.W.3d 330, 338 (Tex. 2024).
5
Id.
6
See State ex rel. Holmes v. Honorable Court of Appeals for Third Dist., 885 S.W.2d 389,
394 (Tex. Crim. App. 1994) (holding that injunction which had effect of staying execution was
2
CONCLUSION
We dismiss this appeal for want of jurisdiction so that appellants may file in
a proper court.
/s/ Scott A. Brister
Scott A. Brister
Chief Justice
Before Chief Justice Brister and Justices Field and Farris.
criminal-law matter within exclusive jurisdiction of the Court of Criminal Appeals); Tex. Dep’t of
Criminal Justice v. Canales, 715 S.W.3d 810, 820–21 (Tex. App.—Austin 2024, pet. denied).
(“Because the relief sought by Plaintiffs, at least in part, is a stay of their executions based on the
method of execution (i.e., using non-compliant or expired pentobarbital), their civil suit seeks an
order that the district court has no jurisdiction to render.”).
3