Bobby Joe Patrick v. State of Tennessee
CourtTennessee Supreme Court
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
DocketM2025-01058-SC-R11-PC
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
11/19/2026
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE
AT NASHVILLE
BOBBY JOE PATRICK v. STATE OF TENNESSEE
Circuit Court for Grundy County
No. 5445
___________________________________
No. M2025-01058-SC-R11-PC
___________________________________
ORDER
This case came before the Court upon the application for permission to appeal of
the petitioner, Bobby Joe Patrick. For the reasons set forth below, we summarily grant the
application, reverse the judgment of the Court of Criminal Appeals, and remand the matter
to the Court of Criminal Appeals for consideration of the petitioner’s allegation that trial
counsel was ineffective for failing to adequately communicate with him.
A Grundy County jury convicted the petitioner of two counts of rape of a child.
After a sentencing hearing, the trial court imposed an effective sixty-seven year sentence.
The petitioner’s convictions and sentence were affirmed on appeal. State v. Patrick, No.
M2019-02026-CCA-R3-CD, 2021 WL 2102914 (Tenn. Crim. App. May 25, 2021), perm.
app. denied (Tenn. Feb. 10, 2022).
The petitioner timely filed a petition for post-conviction relief alleging ineffective
assistance of counsel, among other issues. Following a hearing on the petition, the post-
conviction court denied relief. On appeal, the petitioner alleged trial counsel failed to
adequately communicate with him, failed to object to prejudicial character evidence, and
due to illness, inadequately represented the petitioner at trial. The Court of Criminal
Appeals determined that of the three grounds asserted, only the claim related to counsel’s
failure to object to prejudicial character evidence was raised in the petition and at the
evidentiary hearing on the petition. The court also found that the post-conviction court only
made findings on that one claim. Patrick v. State, No. M2025-01058-PC-R3-CD, 2026
WL 1362716, at *6 (Tenn. Crim. App. May 15, 2026). Therefore, the court found that the
other two grounds alleged––counsel’s failure to adequately communicate with the
petitioner and counsel’s inadequate representation due to illness––were waived because
they were not raised in the petition or ruled on by the post-conviction court.
As a general rule, appellate courts do not address issues that were not raised in the
petition or addressed in the post-conviction court. Holland v. State, 610 S.W.3d 450, 458
(Tenn. 2020); see Tenn. Code Ann. § 40-30-106(g) (providing that, with limited
exceptions, “[a] ground for relief is waived if the petitioner personally or through an
attorney failed to present it for determination in any proceeding before a court of competent
jurisdiction in which the ground could have been presented.”). However, if evidence of an
issue not raised in the petition is presented at the post-conviction hearing and decided by
the post-conviction court without objection, then the appellate court may consider the issue
on appeal. See Holland, 610 S.W.3d at 458 (citing Williams v. State, No. W2018-01269-
CCA-R3-PC, 2019 WL 2407157, at *11 (Tenn. Crim. App. June 7, 2019) (interpreting
Tennessee Supreme Court Rule 28, section 8(D)(5) to hold that an issue may not be waived
if it was “raised at the post-conviction hearing and ruled on by the post-conviction court”
without objection because the petitioner would not have been aware of the need to amend
the petition to include the issue), perm. app. denied, (Tenn. Oct. 11, 2019)); see also Tenn.
Sup. Ct. R. 28, § 8(D)(5) (directing the post-conviction court to allow amendments to the
petition “freely” if a party objects to evidence concerning issues not raised in the petition).
A review of the record in this case indicates that the petitioner did present evidence
at the post-conviction hearing that counsel failed to adequately communicate with him.
Trial counsel testified about his communication with the petitioner and his family, and the
petitioner and his mother also testified about their communication with trial counsel. The
post-conviction court questioned the petitioner and the petitioner’s mother about their
communication with trial counsel. The State not only questioned the petitioner and the
petitioner’s mother about their communication with trial counsel but also mentioned issues
with communication in its closing arguments to the post-conviction court.
In its written order denying post-conviction relief, the post-conviction court made
multiple findings of fact related to the communication between trial counsel and the
petitioner. Though the post-conviction court’s conclusion of law was much more general
in nature, the court held that it “[could not find] from the proof that trial counsel [] was
deficient in his representation of the Petitioner. On the contrary, he clearly worked on the
case, met with his client and his client’s close family, prepared for trial, and made strategic
decisions for articulable reasons based on his knowledge of Grundy County and, more
particularly, Grundy County juries.”
In Holland, this Court cited with approval to several unreported decisions in which
panels of the Court of Criminal Appeals determined that an issue was reviewable on the
merits on appeal, despite not being raised in the post-conviction petition, because evidence
on the claim was presented during the post-conviction hearing and decided by the trial
court without objection by the State. 610 S.W.3d at 458 (citing Starner v. State, No.
2
M2018-01015-CCA-R3-PC, 2019 WL 3856852, at *13 (Tenn. Crim. App. Aug. 16, 2019)
(holding that an issue was “reviewable on the merits” because the petitioner argued it
during the post-conviction hearing with no objection from the State); Williams, 2019 WL
2407157, at *11; Matthews v. State, No. W2018-00966-CCA-R3-PC, 2019 WL 1110101,
at *9 (Tenn. Crim. App. Mar. 11, 2019) (considering an issue on the merits that was not
specifically mentioned in the post-conviction petition, though alleged generally, because it
was litigated at the post-conviction hearing without objection); Brown v. State, No. W2017-
01755-CCA-R3-PC, 2019 WL 931735, at * 10 (Tenn. Crim. App. Feb. 22, 2019)
(considering an issue not included in petition but argued at the post-conviction hearing
without objection); Yarboro v. State, No. W2017-00125-CCA-R3-PC, 2018 WL 4441364,
at *7 (Tenn. Crim. App. Sept. 17, 2018) (deciding an issue not presented in the petition
because it was argued at the post-conviction hearing and not objected to by opposing
counsel and petitioner was no longer able amend the petition); State v. Herron, No. 03C01-
9109-CR-00284, 1992 WL 43273, at *4 (Tenn. Crim. App. Mar. 10, 1992) (“On the other
hand, if an issue is not specially pled, we do not view [our case law] as prohibiting a trial
court from ruling on it if it is litigated by the parties in a post-conviction hearing without
objection.”)).
Accordingly, based on the evidence presented at the evidentiary hearing, the State’s
failure to object to the inclusion of testimony on issues not raised in the post-conviction
petition and its reliance on that testimony in its argument, the trial court’s numerous
findings of fact related to trial counsel’s communication with the petitioner, and the trial
court’s albeit brief conclusion of law that counsel was not ineffective, we find that the issue
concerning the adequacy of counsel’s communications with the petitioner was raised and
decided by the post-conviction court without objection by the State. We reverse the
judgment of the Court of Criminal Appeals finding the petitioner waived his claim that
counsel was ineffective for failing to adequately communicate with him and remand the
case to the Court of Criminal Appeals to consider that ground of ineffective assistance of
counsel. As the petitioner is indigent, costs are taxed to the State of Tennessee.
This order is designated for publication pursuant to Tennessee Supreme Court
Rule 4.
PER CURIAM
3