State of Tennessee v. John Arlie Rich
CourtCourt of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee
Date FiledNovember 13, 2026
DocketM2025-01401-CCA-R3-CD
JudgeJudge John W. Campbell, Sr.
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
11/13/2026
IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TENNESSEE
AT NASHVILLE
Assigned on Briefs October 20, 2026
STATE OF TENNESSEE v. JOHN ARLIE RICH
Appeal from the Circuit Court for Wayne County
No. 91CC1-2020-CR-16781 Julie Carrell Heffington, Judge
___________________________________
No. M2025-01401-CCA-R3-CD
___________________________________
The Defendant, John Arlie Rich, was convicted in the Wayne County Circuit Court of first
degree felony murder; second degree murder, a Class A felony; and two counts of
aggravated rape, a Class A felony, and received an effective sentence of life plus thirty
years in confinement. On appeal, he claims that the evidence is insufficient to support his
convictions and that the successor judge at the hearing on his motion for new trial
improperly concluded that she could sufficiently familiarize herself with the record to act
as the thirteenth juror. Based on our review, we affirm the Defendant’s convictions but
remand the case to the trial court for entry of amended judgments to reflect that the
conviction of second degree murder in count two merges into the conviction of first degree
felony murder in count one.
Tenn. R. App. P. 3 Appeal as of Right; Judgments of the Circuit Court Affirmed,
Case Remanded
JOHN W. CAMPBELL, SR., J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which TIMOTHY L.
EASTER and JILL BARTEE AYERS, JJ., joined.
Jennifer Lynn Thompson (on appeal), Nashville, Tennessee, and John S. Colley, III (at
trial), Columbia, Tennessee, for the appellant, John Arlie Rich.
Jonathan Skrmetti, Attorney General and Reporter; Courtney N. Orr, Deputy Attorney
General; Brent Cooper, District Attorney General; and Patrick Butler and Jessica Parrish,
Assistant District Attorneys General, for the appellee, State of Tennessee.
OPINION
FACTS
On the morning of February 1, 2020, law enforcement responded to a 911 call placed
from the Defendant’s home and found the victim, Brentlyn Victoria Hunt, deceased in a
bedroom. In March 2020, the Wayne County Grand Jury indicted the Defendant for first
degree felony murder, second degree murder, and two counts of rape. The Defendant filed
a pretrial motion to suppress evidence obtained from a digital video recorder (“DVR”) that
he turned over to a police officer two days after the victim’s death, but the trial court denied
the motion after a hearing. The State later amended the indictment to first degree felony
murder, second degree murder, and two counts of aggravated rape, and the Defendant
proceeded to trial in April 2024.
At trial, Lieutenant Dale Palmer of the Collinwood Police Department (“CPD”)
testified that he responded to the 911 call and arrived at the Defendant’s home on Broadway
Street at 6:34 a.m. First responders were already present, and the Defendant was sitting at
a table in the dining room. Lieutenant Palmer went to the back bedroom and saw the
victim, who was clothed, lying on the bed. He described her body as follows:
[I]t appeared that she was having like a seizure when she died because her
hands and fists were [clenched] real tight and she was biting her lip and she
was real stiff, but she was also extremely hot, too. She was warm to the
touch. . . . Like she’d been running a fever.
Lieutenant Palmer noticed “places on her body that looked suspicious.” An abrasion was
on her foot, but no blood was on the wound even though the skin had been almost
completely removed. Lieutenant Palmer also noticed a furnace grate in the floor directly
outside the bedroom. He did not think the victim died of natural causes, so he requested
assistance from an investigator with the district attorney’s office.
Lieutenant Palmer testified that he tried to take a statement from the Defendant but
that the Defendant was “extremely distraught” and physically unable to write a statement.
The Defendant’s daughter was present, so she wrote the Defendant’s statement as he told
her what happened. According to the statement, which Lieutenant Palmer read aloud for
the jury, the Defendant and the victim had sex about 2:00 a.m. The victim was fine at that
time. The victim kept falling asleep on the couch, so the Defendant “took her to bed.” The
victim looked gray and started shaking and twitching, but the Defendant did not have a
telephone to call for help. He stayed with the victim for five or ten minutes because he
was worried she would fall off the bed. When the victim’s condition did not improve, he
went to get help from his neighbors, Casey Johns and Kristen Thompson. Ms. Thompson
checked the victim for a pulse at about 6:00 a.m., but the victim did not have a pulse.
Lieutenant Palmer testified that he had been inside the Defendant’s house many
times previously and that the Defendant had a video surveillance system in the home. On
-2-
the morning of the victim’s death, Lieutenant Palmer saw a video camera in the living
room, which was “unusual.” He thought the Defendant and the victim may have been
recording themselves. Two or three days later, Lieutenant Palmer returned to the
Defendant’s house and conducted a “knock-and-talk” with the Defendant. Lieutenant
Palmer asked the Defendant about the surveillance system and if the Defendant had a DVR.
The Defendant “retrieved” the DVR for Lieutenant Palmer, and Lieutenant Palmer
provided the Defendant with a property receipt for the equipment.
On cross-examination, Lieutenant Palmer acknowledged that the medical examiner
arrived at the scene and that the two of them estimated the victim had been deceased about
four hours, which put her time of death at about 2:30 a.m. Defense counsel asked if
Lieutenant Palmer had personal knowledge of the victim being “a heavy drug user,” and
Lieutenant Palmer answered, “No.”
Investigator Jeff Dunn of the Twenty-Second Judicial District Attorney General’s
Office testified that on February 1, 2020, he responded to Lieutenant Palmer’s request for
assistance at the Defendant’s home on Broadway Street. The Defendant was not present,
and the victim’s body had been transported to the hospital morgue. Investigator Dunn went
to the morgue and viewed the body. The victim was biting her bottom lip, and both hands
were clenched. Investigator Dunn noticed possible injuries on her feet and legs and
identified photographs of the injuries for the jury. The photographs showed abrasions on
the top, ankle, and little toe of the victim’s left foot and bruising on both legs and knees.
Investigator Dunn said that the abrasions had not bled and that, based on his training, he
thought they occurred after the victim’s death, possibly as she was being moved from one
location to another.
Investigator Dunn testified that he returned to the Defendant’s home on Broadway
to process the scene and look for anything that could have caused the victim’s injuries. He
also looked for surveillance equipment. A video camera was mounted outside the front of
the home and was turned toward the driveway. A second camera was mounted outside the
back of the home and was turned toward the backyard. A third camera was mounted onto
a metal can in the living room. Investigator Dunn looked for a DVR that could have
recorded video surveillance. He said that he found “a disturbance in the dust where there
was a possibility that [a DVR] box could have been” but that he did not find a DVR.
Lieutenant Palmer later obtained a DVR from the Defendant.
Investigator Dunn testified that on February 4, 2020, the Defendant came to the
CPD to speak with him about the statement written by the Defendant’s daughter on the
morning of February 1. The Defendant was not a suspect at that time. Investigator Dunn
and the Defendant reviewed the statement, and Investigator Dunn asked if there was
anything the Defendant wanted to change. The Defendant said no. Subsequently,
-3-
Investigator Dunn obtained video from the Defendant’s DVR. The video showed that all
three cameras were recording on the morning of the victim’s death.
The State played for the jury three video clips recorded by the living room camera,
and we have reviewed the black and white video clips, which did not have audio. The first
clip was recorded at 3:30 a.m. and showed the victim on the couch.1 She appeared to be
sleeping soundly on her right side in a fetal position, and her upper body was rising and
falling steadily as she breathed. The Defendant came into view with items in his hands.
The victim awoke briefly but went back to sleep. At 3:41 a.m., the Defendant moved the
camera so that it showed the victim’s bare left thigh, buttocks, and genitalia. He used the
tip of a medical syringe to crush something in a cup. At 3:42 a.m., he placed the syringe
into the cup and drew up a liquid into the syringe. He applied a lubricant to the syringe;
lifted the victim’s left leg to expose her anus; and inserted the syringe, up to the plunger,
into the victim’s rectum. The victim did not move when the Defendant inserted the syringe.
The Defendant leaned over, appeared to perform cunnilingus on the victim, and pushed the
plunger on the syringe. At 3:43 a.m., the Defendant got off the victim, and the syringe slid
out of the victim’s rectum. The Defendant moved out of the camera’s view.
The second video clip showed that about fifteen minutes later, the victim was still
asleep on the couch but was beginning to stir. At 4:04 a.m., the Defendant, fully clothed,
fondled the victim’s vaginal area with his finger. At that point, the camera was knocked
onto the floor. At 4:41 a.m., about an hour after the Defendant inserted the syringe, the
Defendant repositioned the camera so that it showed the couch again. The victim was fully
awake and was sitting on the couch beside the Defendant, who was naked. The victim was
wearing what appeared to be a nightgown and a man’s plaid shirt. The nightgown kept
slipping off her shoulders, exposing her breasts. She was talking and laughing with the
Defendant, and she appeared restless. Over the course of the next fifteen minutes, the
victim’s movements became more erratic. At 4:56 a.m., the victim, who was on her knees,
briefly performed fellatio on the Defendant, who was still sitting on the couch. She then
continued moving her body erratically. At 4:59 a.m., about an hour and fifteen minutes
after the Defendant inserted the syringe into the victim, the video showed the victim lying
on her back on the couch. She appeared to be writhing, and the Defendant appeared to
insert his penis into her vagina.
In the third clip, which was a continuation of the second clip, the Defendant removed
his penis from the victim. When he tried to reinsert it, she sat up and held her open hand
up to his face. However, he appeared to reinsert his penis into her vagina. At 5:06 a.m.,
1
Investigator Dunn later testified that the time stamp on the surveillance video was incorrect.
However, using information from 911 dispatch, he was able to determine the correct time by adding one
hour to the time stamp on the video and by changing “p.m.” on the video to “a.m.” We have followed
Investigator Dunn’s instructions to determine the correct time of the video.
-4-
about one hour and twenty-five minutes after the Defendant inserted the syringe into the
victim’s rectum, he moved her from the couch to an ottoman that was in front of a leather
recliner. The Defendant repeatedly tried to insert his penis into the victim, who was lying
on her back and was moving erratically. At 5:09 a.m., the victim could be seen writhing
on the floor. The Defendant picked her up and set her on her feet, but she appeared unable
to stand. At 5:11 a.m., about an hour and thirty minutes after the Defendant inserted the
syringe into the victim, the victim was writhing on the floor, and the Defendant could be
seen straddling her. The Defendant and the victim then moved out of the camera’s view.
Five minutes later, the Defendant moved the camera so that it showed the couch. In moving
the camera, the victim could be seen writhing on the floor. The Defendant picked up the
victim, laid her on the couch, and tried to insert his penis into her vagina. The victim
continued writhing, and her fists were clenched. The Defendant stopped trying to penetrate
the victim but began touching her vaginal area with his hand. At 5:19 a.m., the victim was
still writhing on the couch. Her arms were above her head, her fists clenched, and the
Defendant was on top of her. At 5:20 a.m., the camera did not record any additional
movements.
Next, the State played the driveway video for the jury. The video showed the
Defendant, who was smoking a cigarette, quickly leaving in his pickup truck at 6:05 a.m.
Two to three minutes later, he returned with two people, who Investigator Dunn identified
as Ms. Thompson and Mr. Johns. The three of them got out of the truck and ran toward
the Defendant’s house. At 6:09 a.m., Mr. Johns left in the Defendant’s truck. Soon
thereafter, Ms. Thompson ran to the house across the street. Ms. Thomspon returned to
the Defendant’s house at 6:12 a.m., and Mr. Johns pulled into the driveway at 6:14 a.m.
The Defendant’s neighbor from across the street also arrived, and Mr. Johns and the
neighbor walked toward the Defendant’s house. First responders began arriving at 6:30
a.m.
After the driveway video was played for the jury, the State resumed its direct
examination of Investigator Dunn. Investigator Dunn testified that the living room video
showed the victim wearing a nightgown and a shirt; she was naked from the waist down.
However, when Investigator Dunn viewed her body at the morgue, she was wearing the
nightgown and a pair of shorts. He opined that if someone dragged the victim into the
bedroom, the metal grate in the floor outside the bedroom could have caused the abrasions
on her feet. Investigator Dunn executed a search warrant on the Defendant’s home on
February 13, 2020, but he did not find the living room camera, the syringe, the cup, or the
bottle of lubricant.
Investigator Dunn testified that the Defendant voluntarily came to the CPD on
February 13, 2020. The Defendant waived his constitutional rights, and Investigator Dunn
-5-
and Lieutenant Palmer interviewed him. The Defendant did not know at the time of his
interview that the officers had obtained and viewed the video.
The Defendant’s interview was audio recorded, and the State played the recording
for the jury. At the outset of the interview, which was about one hour in duration,
Investigator Dunn told the Defendant to tell him what happened on the day of the victim’s
death. The Defendant stated as follows: On January 31, 2020, he and the victim used
methamphetamine and spent time in Florence. The victim told the Defendant that she had
had a seizure and had hit her head. Sometime after dark, they returned to the Defendant’s
house on Broadway and were there for a while. Then they went to the Defendant’s second
home on Wayne Street and did some cleaning. When they returned to the Defendant’s
home on Broadway, the victim did not feel well and said she was going to lie down. The
victim was acting “confused.” The Defendant took a shower while the victim was lying
on the couch. When the Defendant got out of the shower, he lay down with the victim,
who seemed to be feeling better. The Defendant gave the victim a “booty bump,”
explaining to the officers that the victim mixed methamphetamine and water in a cup. She
crushed the methamphetamine with a syringe and drew up the solution into the syringe.
The Defendant inserted the syringe into the victim’s rectum and dispelled the solution into
her body. The victim performed oral sex on the Defendant, and they had sexual intercourse.
However, the Defendant could not maintain an erection, so they stopped. Afterward, they
lay on the couch and talked. When they were ready to go to bed, the victim walked to the
bedroom herself. However, she was still acting “confused” or “dazed,” so the Defendant
helped her by putting his arm around her and leading her to the bedroom. The victim began
having “a spell” in the bedroom, and the Defendant held onto her so she would not fall off
the bed. The Defendant could not call for help because his cellular telephone was “tore
up,” and he did not want to leave the victim alone. The victim seemed to get “a little
better,” so the Defendant left in his truck to get help. He picked up Ms. Thompson and
Mr. Jones, who lived nearby, and brought them to his house.
The Defendant told the officers that he had administered a “booty bump” to the
victim several times previously and that she had administered “booty bumps” to herself “a
lot of the times.” The Defendant said that he did not know if his video cameras were
recording at the time of the incident and acknowledged that he voluntarily provided his
DVR to Lieutenant Palmer. Investigator Dunn asked the Defendant, “If I were to tell you
that that camera recorded the majority of the incident, would you want to keep your story
the same, or would you want to tell me something different?” The Defendant answered,
“That’s what happened, sir.” Investigator Dunn asked what happened to the syringe and
the cup in which the victim mixed the methamphetamine, and the Defendant said that he
did not know but that he probably threw them away. At the conclusion of the Defendant’s
interview, Investigator Dunn asked if there was anything else the Defendant “needed” to
tell him, and the Defendant said, “No, sir.”
-6-
After the State played the Defendant’s interview, Investigator Dunn testified that
the Defendant was cooperative and answered all questions presented to him. However, the
Defendant continuously shifted in his seat, avoided eye contact, and appeared “extremely
nervous.”
On cross-examination, Investigator Dunn acknowledged that according to the
Defendant, he and the victim smoked methamphetamine two or three times before the
“booty bump.” Investigator Dunn acknowledged that at one point in the video, the
Defendant could be seen holding a methamphetamine pipe.
Dr. David Zimmerman, a medical examiner for Davidson County and an expert in
forensic pathology, testified that he performed the twenty-five-year-old victim’s autopsy,
which included internal and external examinations of her body and the collection of bodily
fluids for toxicology testing. Dr. Zimmerman observed bruises and abrasions on the
victim, and he identified six autopsy photographs of her injuries for the jury. The first
photograph showed an abrasion and a bruise on the victim’s left ankle. The second
photograph showed bruises on the side of the victim’s left thigh. The third photograph
showed a bruise and an abrasion on the top of the victim’s left foot. The fourth photograph
showed bruises on the victim’s left knee and on the side of her left lower leg. The fifth
photograph showed bruises and an abrasion on the victim’s right knee and bruises on her
right lower leg. The sixth photograph showed bruises on the victim’s left knee and left
lower leg and an abrasion on her left lower leg. Dr. Zimmerman opined that the injuries
occurred “around” the time of her death. The victim also had congestion and edema of the
lungs, but Dr. Zimmerman did not find any abnormalities in her organs that explained her
death.
Dr. Zimmerman testified that toxicology testing showed caffeine, clonazepam,
oxycodone, gabapentin, amphetamine, and methamphetamine in the victim’s blood. The
amount of methamphetamine was 18,000 nanograms per milliliter. The level of
methamphetamine in most methamphetamine overdose cases was 300 to 500 nanograms
per milliliter. Dr. Zimmerman said that methamphetamine could be absorbed through the
rectum and that the level of methamphetamine in the victim’s blood was enough to cause
her death. However, the levels of gabapentin alone and amphetamine alone also were
enough to cause her death. Dr. Zimmerman concluded that the victim’s cause of death was
“acute combined drug toxicity.” The State introduced the victim’s autopsy report into
evidence. According to the report, the victim’s manner of death was homicide.
On cross-examination, Dr. Zimmerman acknowledged that gabapentin could be
used to treat seizures. He described the amount of methamphetamine in the victim’s blood
as “astronomical” and said that a high level of methamphetamine would cause a person’s
-7-
respiratory rate, heart rate, and brain activity to increase. The effects would occur
“quickly” after using the drug, and the amount of time needed for the drug to affect the
body would be the same whether the methamphetamine was smoked or absorbed through
the rectum. Investigator Dunn provided Dr. Zimmerman with information about the
circumstances surrounding the victim’s death, but the information did not include the
victim’s use of methamphetamine the day before her death or her history of seizures. The
fluid in the victim’s lungs was caused by the combination of drugs in her system, but the
fluid did not cause her death.
Dr. Justin Brower of NMS Labs and an expert in forensic toxicology testified that a
medical examiner was responsible for determining cause and manner of death whereas he
was responsible for using toxicology results “to help explain” the cause and manner of
death. In this case, the medical examiner’s office requested that he review the victim’s
toxicology report. He said the amount of methamphetamine in the victim’s blood was
“extremely high” at 18,000 nanograms per milliliter. For comparison, the average amount
of methamphetamine in cases of driving under the influence was 350 nanograms per
milliliter, and the average amount of methamphetamine in cases of death by overdose was
1,000 nanograms per milliliter. He said that of the 5,000 methamphetamine cases he had
reviewed, the amount of methamphetamine in the victim’s blood was “probably the top
five or ten highest.”
Dr. Brower testified that methamphetamine metabolized into amphetamine. The
victim’s level of amphetamine, 230 nanograms per milliliter, was much lower than her
level of methamphetamine. Therefore, Dr. Brower opined either that the victim died soon
after the methamphetamine was administered or that her liver was unable to function
properly so that it could metabolize the methamphetamine into amphetamine. He
acknowledged that the victim may have ingested amphetamine.
Dr. Brower testified that methamphetamine stimulates the heart and that it could
cause the heart to have to work harder to pump blood. The drug also stimulates the nervous
system, which causes paranoia, hyperactivity, and excessive talking. High concentrations
of methamphetamine could cause hallucinations, psychosis, seizures, coma, and death. It
also could cause hyperthermia, meaning the body would be warmer than normal and feel
warm to the touch. Methamphetamine most commonly enters the body via smoking or
snorting but also could be administered rectally. He said that the drug would be absorbed
through the thin membrane of the rectum “fairly quickly” and that a person would feel the
effects in about fifteen minutes.
On cross-examination, Dr. Brower testified that the phrase “acute combined drug
toxicity” referred to “a combination of drugs that are found to add together to determine
the cause and manner of death.” He acknowledged that the amount of methamphetamine
-8-
in the victim’s blood could have resulted from several administrations. He said, though,
that the victim still would have had to ingest a large amount of methamphetamine for the
amount to be 18,000 nanograms per milliliter.
After Dr. Brower’s testimony, the State rested its case and made the following
election of offenses: Count one, felony murder, the Defendant killed the victim in the
perpetration of aggravated rape in count three; count three, aggravated rape, the Defendant
sexually penetrated the victim with the syringe of methamphetamine, the effects of which
caused her death; and count four, aggravated rape, the Defendant sexually penetrated the
victim with his penis, which caused bruising, contusions, and abrasions to her body. The
Defendant proceeded with his proof.
Sherry Lynn Weathers, the mother of Mr. Johns, testified that the Defendant and the
victim came to her home to visit her sons between 10:00 and 10:30 p.m. on January 31,
2020. Ms. Weathers was watching television in her bedroom when they arrived. The
victim came into Ms. Weathers’ bedroom and said, “Feel this.” Ms. Weathers said she felt
a knot, the size of a silver dollar, on the back of the victim’s head. Ms. Weathers asked
what happened, and the victim said she had a seizure, fell, and hit her head on a coffee
table. The victim and the Defendant were at Ms. Weathers’ home about thirty minutes.
On cross-examination, Ms. Weathers testified that the victim did not say when the
seizure occurred. The knot was sore, and Ms. Weathers urged the victim to see a doctor.
Ms. Weathers had known the victim about six months at the time of the incident and
considered the victim a friend, but she did not attend the victim’s funeral. Ms. Weathers
had known the Defendant about twenty-three years. The State asked if Ms. Weathers
noticed anything unusual about the victim on the night of January 31, and Ms. Weathers
stated, “She talked really fast. I had to tell her to slow down, let an old woman catch up a
couple of times. . . . Other than that, no.” Ms. Weathers gave a statement to Lieutenant
Palmer on February 10, 2020. She did not talk with the Defendant prior to giving her
statement.
Richard Anthony Davis testified that he used to live in Collinwood and that he knew
the victim. Sometime after 10:00 p.m. on January 31, 2020, the victim knocked on his
apartment door. Mr. Davis was asleep but answered the door, and the victim stayed at his
apartment less than thirty minutes. Mr. Davis said the victim was “[v]ery fidgety, just
wide-eyed” and that she “[c]ouldn’t be still.” The next morning, Mr. Davis gave a
statement to Lieutenant Palmer in which he told the officer that the victim “appeared to be
[extremely] high on methamphetamine.” The victim did not tell Mr. Davis that she had
used methamphetamine.
-9-
On cross-examination, Mr. Davis testified that he thought the victim came to his
apartment sometime between 2:00 and 4:00 a.m. He had known the victim since she was
a child, but he had not seen her in two or three years when she showed up at his door. Mr.
Davis said the victim wanted him “to go with her to get some stuff from [the Defendant’s]
house.” However, Mr. Davis refused because he did not want to get involved. He said the
victim “talked like she was afraid of [the Defendant], but she didn’t appear to be afraid of
him.” Mr. Davis described his relationship with the Defendant as “acquaintances.”
At the conclusion of the proof, the jury convicted the Defendant of first degree
felony murder in count one, second degree murder in count two, and aggravated rape in
counts three and four. After a sentencing hearing, the trial court sentenced the Defendant
to life for the felony murder conviction and as a Range II, multiple offender to thirty years
for each of the remaining convictions. The trial court ordered that the Defendant serve the
thirty-year sentence for aggravated rape in count four consecutively to the life sentence for
total effective sentence of life plus thirty years in confinement.
I. Sufficiency of the Evidence
The Defendant claims that the evidence is insufficient to support his convictions.
The State argues that the evidence is sufficient. We agree with the State.
When the sufficiency of the evidence is challenged on appeal, the relevant question
of the reviewing court is “whether, after viewing the evidence in the light most favorable
to the prosecution, any rational trier of fact could have found the essential elements of the
crime beyond a reasonable doubt.” Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307, 319 (1979); see also
Tenn. R. App. P. 13(e) (“Findings of guilt in criminal actions whether by the trial court or
jury shall be set aside if the evidence is insufficient to support the findings by the trier of
fact of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.”); State v. Evans, 838 S.W.2d 185, 190-91 (Tenn.
1992); State v. Anderson, 835 S.W.2d 600, 604 (Tenn. Crim. App. 1992).
Therefore, on appeal, the State is entitled to the strongest legitimate view of the
evidence and all reasonable inferences that may be drawn from it. State v. Williams, 657
S.W.2d 405, 410 (Tenn. 1983). All questions involving the credibility of witnesses, the
weight and value to be given the evidence, and all factual issues are resolved by the trier
of fact. State v. Pruett, 788 S.W.2d 559, 561 (Tenn. 1990). “A jury conviction removes
the presumption of innocence with which a defendant is initially cloaked and replaces it
with one of guilt, so that on appeal a convicted defendant has the burden of demonstrating
that the evidence is insufficient.” State v. Tuggle, 639 S.W.2d 913, 914 (Tenn. 1982).
The guilt of a defendant, including any fact required to be proven, may be predicated
upon direct evidence, circumstantial evidence, or a combination of both direct and
- 10 -
circumstantial evidence. State v. Pendergrass, 13 S.W.3d 389, 392-93 (Tenn. Crim. App.
1999). The standard of review for the sufficiency of the evidence is the same whether the
conviction is based on direct or circumstantial evidence or a combination of the two. State
v. Dorantes, 331 S.W.3d 370, 379 (Tenn. 2011).
Relevant to this case, first degree felony murder is “[the] killing of another
committed in the perpetration of or attempt to perpetrate any . . . rape[.]” Tenn. Code Ann.
§ 39-13-202(a)(2) (2018). “No culpable mental state is required for conviction . . . except
the intent to commit the [underlying felony].” Id. § 39-13-202(b). Based on the indictment
and the State’s election of offenses, “[a]ggravated rape is unlawful sexual penetration of a
victim by the defendant” and “[t]he defendant causes bodily injury to the victim[.]” Id. §
39-13-502(a)(2). “‘Sexual penetration’ means sexual intercourse, cunnilingus, fellatio,
anal intercourse, or any other intrusion, however slight, of any part of a person’s body or
of any object into the genital or anal openings of the victim’s . . . body, but emission of
semen is not required[.]” Id. § 39-13-501(7). “‘Bodily injury’ includes a cut, abrasion,
bruise, burn or disfigurement, and physical pain or temporary illness or impairment of the
function of a bodily member, organ, or mental faculty[.]” Id. § 39-11-106(a)(3).
As charged in this case, second degree murder is “[a] killing of another that results
from the unlawful distribution of any . . . Schedule II drug, when the drug is the proximate
cause of the death of the user[.]” Id. § 39-13-210(a)(2). Methamphetamine is a Schedule
II controlled substance. Id. § 39-17-408(d)(2).
The Defendant claims that the evidence is insufficient to support his conviction of
first degree felony murder in count one and second degree murder in count two because
the evidence fails to show that his injecting methamphetamine into the victim’s rectum was
the proximate cause of her death. In support of his claim, he contends that the proof showed
the victim was “high” on methamphetamine before he injected the drug and that the State
failed to present any proof as to how much methamphetamine he administered to the
victim. The State argues that the evidence is sufficient. We agree with the State.
As this court has explained, “[C]ausation is an essential element of every homicide
offense[.]” State v. Robinson, No. W2020-00246-CCA-R3-CD, 2021 WL 2982928, at *7
(Tenn. Crim. App. July 15, 2021) (quoting State v. Farner, 66 S.W.3d 188, 204 (Tenn.
2001)), no perm. app. filed. “[P]roximate causation ‘is generally established in Tennessee
by showing that the victim’s death was the natural and probable result of the defendant’s
unlawful conduct.’” Id. (quoting Farner, 66 S.W.3d at 203). Causation is a question of
fact to be determined by the jury. Id. (citing Farner, 66, S.W.3d at 204).
Taken in the light most favorable to the State, the evidence shows that the victim
was sleeping soundly and that she was not in any distress before the Defendant injected the
- 11 -
methamphetamine into her rectum at 3:42 a.m. However, fifteen minutes after the
injection, she began to stir. One hour after the injection, she was fully awake and unable
to sit still. Over the course of the next thirty minutes, the victim’s body movements became
more erratic, and her condition declined so that she was unable to stand and was writhing
on the floor. The last few seconds of the living room video showed the victim writhing on
the couch with her eyes open, her arms above her head, and her hands clenched into fists.
About 6:00 a.m., the victim did not have a pulse. The results of the victim’s toxicology
testing showed 18,000 nanograms per milliliter of methamphetamine in her blood, which
Dr. Zimmerman described as an “astronomical” amount. In comparison, the average
overdose death resulted from just 1,000 nanograms per milliliter of methamphetamine. Dr.
Brower testified that methamphetamine administered rectally would be absorbed into the
body quickly and that a person would feel the effects of the drug in about fifteen minutes,
which explained the victim’s stirring from sleep fifteen minutes after the Defendant
injected the methamphetamine into her rectum. The evidence is more than sufficient to
show that the Defendant’s rectal administration of methamphetamine to the victim caused
her death.
The Defendant also claims that the evidence is insufficient to support his conviction
of aggravated rape in count three, and consequently his conviction of felony murder in
count one, because the evidence does not show that he “sexually” penetrated the victim
with the syringe. Specifically, he contends that his insertion of the syringe into the victim’s
rectum was for the purpose of administering the methamphetamine and was not sexual in
nature. However, the definition of “sexual penetration” only requires the insertion of any
object into a victim’s anal opening. See State v. Carter, No. E2010-01193-CCA-R3-CD,
2012 WL 460459, at *28 (Tenn. Crim. App. Feb. 14, 2012) (noting that “[c]onspicuously
absent from this definition is any requirement that the penetration at issue be done for
purposes of sexual gratification”), no perm. app. filed. Therefore, under the plain language
of the statute, the State was not required to show that the Defendant’s penetration of the
victim was sexual in nature. Id. In any event, there was evidence that the Defendant’s
insertion of the syringe was for the purpose of sexual arousal or gratification because, while
doing so, he performed cunnilingus on the victim.
Next, the Defendant contends that the evidence is insufficient to support his
conviction of aggravated rape in count four because the video does not show that he
sexually penetrated the victim with his penis, that he used force to do so, or that he caused
any of her physical injuries. We disagree with the Defendant.
During its election of offenses, the State read count four to the jury as follows:
“Count 4 is regarding the Defendant’s sexual penetration of [the victim’s] body with his
penis by force, which caused bruising, contusions, and abrasions to her body.” We note
that in addition to aggravated rape being defined as unlawful sexual penetration causing
- 12 -
bodily injury, the offense is also defined as unlawful sexual penetration in which “[f]orce
or coercion is used to accomplish the act and the defendant is armed with a weapon or any
article used or fashioned in a manner to lead the victim reasonably to believe it to be a
weapon[.]” Tenn. Code Ann. § 39-13-502(a)(1). However, the State never asserted that
the Defendant was armed with a weapon, so the latter definition of force while armed with
a weapon is not at issue here, and the State was not required to show force in order for the
jury to convict the Defendant of aggravated rape. Nevertheless, as we will explain, the
video showed the Defendant using force while sexually penetrating and attempting to
sexually penetrate the victim with his penis.
The living room video was graphic and disturbing. It showed the Defendant
administering the “booty bump” to the victim at 3:42 a.m. The victim’s left thigh was
clearly visible, and there were no bruises on her thigh at that time. One hour later, the
victim could be seen on the couch with the Defendant. Her legs were clearly visible, and
there were no bruises on her lower legs or knees. At 4:49 a.m. the victim was lying on her
back on the couch, and the Defendant, who was naked, was between her legs. The
Defendant lifted the victim’s pelvis, appeared to insert his penis into her vagina, and made
thrusting motions. The Defendant then sat back, and his erect penis came out of the victim.
The victim held her palm up to his face as if motioning for him to stop, but the Defendant
appeared to reinsert his penis into her vagina. At 5:08 a.m., the Defendant tried to insert
his penis into the victim’s vagina while she was lying on her back on the ottoman. Her
lower left leg was clearly visible, and there were no bruises on her leg at that time. At 5:09
a.m., the Defendant appeared either to insert or try to insert his penis into the victim’s
vagina, and, for the first time, bruises could be seen on the victim’s left thigh. The bruises
matched the bruises in the photograph of the victim’s thigh that was taken during her
autopsy. Dr. Zimmerman concluded that the bruises occurred near the time of death, and
the video confirms that the bruises occurred during the Defendant’s manhandling of the
victim. Therefore, while the Defendant’s use of force may not have been an element of the
offense of aggravated rape in this case, his use of force while repeatedly penetrating or
attempting to penetrate her was significant because it explained the numerous bruises on
her lower body. Moreover, the jury could have reasonably inferred from the victim’s and
the Defendant’s movements in the video that penetration, however slight, occurred.
Therefore, the evidence is sufficient to support all of the Defendant’s convictions.
II. Successor Judge as Thirteenth Juror
The Defendant claims that the successor judge at the hearing on his motion for new
trial improperly concluded that she could sufficiently familiarize herself with the record,
particularly the hearing on his motion to suppress, to act as the thirteenth juror. The State
argues that the Defendant is not entitled to relief on this issue. We agree with the State.
- 13 -
On May 15, 2020, the Defendant filed a pretrial motio