Com. v. Suder, M.
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket1395 WDA 2025
JudgeSullivan
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
J-S19014-26
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. :
:
:
MELISSA LYNN SUDER :
:
Appellant : No. 1395 WDA 2025
Appeal from the Judgment of Sentence Entered July 7, 2025
In the Court of Common Pleas of Bedford County Criminal Division at
No(s): CP-05-CR-0000525-2023
BEFORE: SULLIVAN, J., NEUMAN, J., and STEVENS, P.J.E.*
MEMORANDUM BY SULLIVAN, J.: FILED: NOVEMBER 20, 2026
Melissa Lynn Suder (“Suder”) appeals from the judgment of sentence
following her jury convictions for two counts of attempted murder, seven
counts of attempted murder of a law enforcement officer, seven counts of
assault of a law enforcement officer, seven counts of aggravated assault of a
police officer, eleven counts of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, one
count of discharge of a firearm into an occupied structure, four counts of
terroristic threats, one count of propelling a missile into an occupied vehicle,
eleven counts of simple assault attempted bodily injury, eleven counts of
simple assault fear of bodily injury, and eleven counts of recklessly
endangering another person.1 Suder’s claims that the Commonwealth failed
____________________________________________
* Former Justice specially assigned to the Superior Court.
1 See 18 Pa.C.S.A. §§ 901(a), 2501(a), 2507(a). 2702.1(a)(1), 2702(a)(2),
2702(a)(4), 2707.1(a), 2706(a)(1), 2707(a), 2701(a)(1), 2701(a)(3), 2705.
J-S19014-26
to present sufficient evidence to support her convictions and the trial court
abused its sentencing discretion are without merit. However, for the reasons
discussed below, we amend her illegal flat sentences for assault of a law
enforcement officer from twenty years of incarceration to a term of twenty to
forty years of incarceration. Because the illegal sentences imposed were run
concurrent to the aggregate sentence and do not affect the overall sentencing
scheme, we choose to impose the modified sentence and do not remand to
the trial court for resentencing.
In early August 2023, Suder spent about one week in the hospital after
suffering a seizure. See N.T., 5/5/25, at 30. The hospital gave Suder anti-
seizure medication and changed another medication. See id. at 31. Upon
her return to her home, Suder became upset that nobody had done any work
around the house. See N.T., 4/30/25, at 42. She was intoxicated, “[s]lurring
her words, [and] couldn’t walk straight.” Id. at 41.
Suder’s son Dillon, (“Dillon Suder”), Dillon’s friend Shay Graham
(“Graham”), Suder’s daughter Madison (“Madison Suder”), and Madison’s
boyfriend Nick Thompson (“Thompson”) were at the residence when Suder
arrived. See id. at 62. Graham testified, while she was in Dillon Suder’s
bedroom, she could hear Suder arguing with her children and Thompson. See
id. at 43. During the argument, Suder threatened to stab her son in the eyes
with a fork and her daughter in the eyes with a kitchen utensil. See id. at 54,
96. Suder also said everyone in the house was going to die that night and
-2-
J-S19014-26
she was going to shoot everybody at the house. See id. at 95. Madison
Suder told her mother they needed to get milk for a recipe; Suder responded
if she left to get the milk, she would shoot her. See id. at 96.
Graham and Dillon Suder attempted to leave the residence; Graham
entered her car while Dillon Suder stood outside on the phone. See id. at 45.
Dillon Suder watched Suder come out of the house holding a can of Mike’s
Hard Lemonade and a car key; Dillon Suder told her not to drink and drive.
See id. at 74. Suder walked to her car and pulled out a gun, which she loaded,
and chambered a bullet. See id. at 45, 97. Suder pointed her gun at her
son, and he ran. See id. at 45-46. Madison Suder called 911 from inside the
house. See id. at 97. Suder walked to the deck and fired a shot, pointed the
gun at her son again, and came up to Graham in the car. See id. at 47, 97.
Suder went back and forth between her son and Graham, then came up to
Graham in the driver’s seat and fired a shot at Graham. See id. at 48.
Graham testified that Suder shot at her from an arms-length away. See id.
at 49. Graham attempted to back up and drive away; Suder shot her tire.
See id. at 50. Although Suder’s shots did not hit Graham, Graham sought
medical attention at a hospital for injuries sustained from glass shattering
because of Suder’s shots. See id. at 52-53.
Suder shot through the bay window of her home towards Thompson and
her daughter. See id. at 98. Madison Suder and Thompson ran out of the
-3-
J-S19014-26
back of the house and into the woods. See id. at 99. At some point, Suder
returned to her residence.
Major Matthew Nickey (“Major Nickey”) testified that state troopers,
upon their response to the scene, were pinned down or trapped on the
property by gunfire. See id. at 115. Trooper Thad Ferguson (“Trooper
Ferguson”), one of the seven members of the Pennsylvania State Police who
initially approached the residence, testified that they indicated to Suder they
were police officers and attempted to hail her out of the residence. See id.
at 165. Suder screamed at them from the doorway, told them to leave, and
yelled profanities. See id. at 165, 194; N.T., 5/1/25, at 8. Suder retreated
inside the house and began to shoot at the police officers. See N.T., 4/30/25,
at 166; N.T., 5/1/25, at 9. Trooper Ferguson testified that he heard multiple
shots and saw them hit near where the officers were hiding. See N.T.,
4/30/25, at 167. The troopers were extracted after approximately four hours
because of the potential for more gunfire. See id. at 124-26. Major Nickey
testified that law enforcement attempted to contact Suder over a loudspeaker
for four hours. See id. at 127. Suder eventually exited her home. See id.
at 128. Major Nickey described the situation as “life or death.” Id. Trooper
Levi Neuder (“Trooper Neuder”), Corporal John R. Romeo (“Corporal Romeo”),
Trooper Patrick Kelly (“Trooper Kelly”), Trooper Colton Wassell (“Trooper
-4-
J-S19014-26
Wassell”), and Trooper Luke Hoover (“Trooper Hoover”), who all initially
responded to the scene, also testified that Suder shot at them.2
In May 2025, a jury convicted Suder of the above-listed offenses. As it
pertains to her other charges, the jury acquitted Suder of two counts of
attempted murder. In July 2025, the trial court sentenced Suder to an
aggregate term of fifty-eight and one-half to one hundred and thirty-five years
of imprisonment. This sentence included a twenty-year flat sentence for each
count of assault of a law enforcement officer pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S.A.
§ 9719.1(a) (“Section 9719.1(a)”), to run concurrently to each other and to
her remaining sentences.3
Suder filed post-sentence motions challenging the discretionary aspects
of sentence, legality of sentence, weight of the evidence, and sufficiency of
the evidence. See Post-Sentence Motion, 7/16/25. The trial court denied the
motions in their entirety. See Order, 9/30/25. Suder timely appealed, and
Suder and the trial court complied with Pa.R.A.P. 1925.
Suder raises the following issues for our review:
1. Whether the [t]rial [c]ourt erred in denying [Suder’s] [m]otion
for [j]udgment of [a]cquittal, where the Commonwealth failed
to present sufficient evidence to establish that [Suder]
____________________________________________
2 Trooper Daniel White (“Trooper White”), the seventh officer who initially
responded to the scene was unavailable to testify at the time of trial.
3 Section 9719.1(a) states that a person convicted of 18 Pa.C.S.A.
§ 2702.1(a)(1), relating to assault of a law enforcement officer, shall be
sentenced to a mandatory term of imprisonment of not less than twenty years.
-5-
J-S19014-26
possessed the specific intent to kill two . . . civilian victims,
which is a required element of the two . . . counts of [c]riminal
[a]ttempt – [c]riminal [h]omicide, and seven . . . law
enforcement officers, which is a required element of the seven
. . . counts of [c]riminal [a]ttempt [m]urder of a [l]aw
[e]nforcement [o]fficer of the [f]irst [d]egree?
2. Whether the [t]rial [c]ourt erred in denying [Suder’s] [m]otion
for [j]udgment of [a]cquittal, where the Commonwealth failed
to present sufficient evidence to establish that [Suder]
possessed the specific intent to cause serious bodily injury to
any of the law enforcement victims, which is a required
element of the seven . . . counts of [a]ggravated [a]ssault –
[d]esignated [i]ndividuals?
3. Whether the [t]rial [c]ourt erred in denying [Suder’s] [m]otion
for [j]udgment of [a]cquittal, where the Commonwealth failed
to present sufficient evidence to establish that [Suder]
possessed the specific intent to cause bodily injury to any of
the victims, which is a required element of the seven . . . counts
of [a]ssault of a [l]aw [e]nforcement [o]fficer – [f]irearm
[d]ischarged, and eleven . . . counts of [a]ggravated [a]ssault
– [a]ttempts to [c]ause or [c]auses [b]odily [i]njury with a
[d]eadly [w]eapon?
4. Whether the [t]rial [c]ourt abused its discretion by imposing a
manifestly excessive and unduly harsh aggregate sentence of
incarceration, where the [c]ourt failed to give appropriate
consideration and weight to the evidence supporting
mitigation, and the mandatory sentencing considerations
pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S.[A.] §[]9721(b), to include the
protection of the public, gravity of the offense, and the
rehabilitative needs of [Suder]?
5. Whether the [t]rial [c]ourt erred, as a matter of law, by
imposing an illegal sentence, where the [t]rial [c]ourt
sentenced [Suder] to a flat period of twenty . . . years[ of]
incarceration at each of the seven . . . counts of [a]ssault of
[l]aw [e]nforcement [o]fficer . . . to run concurrently with each
other and all other sentences imposed, in violation of 42
Pa.C.S.[A.] § 9756(b)(1), which prohibits the imposition of flat
sentences of confinement?
Suder’s Brief at 4-6 (claims reordered for ease of disposition).
-6-
J-S19014-26
Suder’s first three claims challenge the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting her convictions for attempted murder, attempted murder of a law
enforcement officer, assault of a law enforcement officer, and aggravated
assault. Suder challenges the elements of specific intent to kill, cause serious
bodily injury, and cause bodily injury. Our standards of review for sufficiency
is as follows:
A claim challenging the sufficiency of the evidence is a question of
law. Evidence will be deemed sufficient to support the verdict
when it establishes each material element of the crime charged
and the commission thereof by the accused, beyond a reasonable
doubt. Where the evidence offered to support the verdict is in
contradiction to the physical facts, in contravention to human
experience and the laws of nature, then the evidence is insufficient
as a matter of law. When reviewing a sufficiency claim the court
is required to view the evidence in the light most favorable to the
verdict winner giving the prosecution the benefit of all reasonable
inferences to be drawn from the evidence.
Commonwealth v. Rivera, 238 A.3d 482, 495 (Pa. Super. 2020) (internal
citation omitted).
Regarding intent, the Crimes Code defines “criminal attempt” as follows:
“A person commits an attempt when, with intent to commit a specific crime,
he does any act which constitutes a substantial step toward the commission
of that crime.” 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 901(a). To be found guilty of attempted
murder, this Court has noted:
[T]he Commonwealth must establish specific intent to kill.
Therefore, if a person takes a substantial step toward the
commission of a killing, with the specific intent in mind to commit
such an act, he may be convicted of attempted murder. The
Commonwealth may establish the mens rea required for first-
-7-
J-S19014-26
degree murder, [18 Pa.C.S.A. § 2502(a),] specific intent to kill,
solely from circumstantial evidence.
Commonwealth v. Tucker, 143 A.3d 955, 964 (Pa. Super. 2016) (internal
citations, quotations, and brackets omitted). A person is presumed to intend
the natural and probable consequences of his actions. See Commonwealth
v. Lewis, 911 A.2d 558, 564 (Pa. Super. 2006).
A person commits assault of a law enforcement officer if she “attempts
to cause or intentionally or knowingly causes bodily injury to a law
enforcement officer, while in the performance of duty and with knowledge that
the victim is a law enforcement officer, by discharging a firearm.” 18
Pa.C.S.A. § 2702.1(a)(1).
A person commits aggravated assault if she, inter alia, “attempts to
cause or intentionally, knowingly or recklessly causes serious bodily injury to
any [police officer]” or “attempts to cause or intentionally or knowingly causes
bodily injury to another with a deadly weapon[.]” 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 2702(a)(2),
(4).
We have explained the elements of aggravated assault as follows:
“Serious bodily injury” has been defined as “[b]odily injury which
creates a substantial risk of death or which causes serious,
permanent disfigurement, or protracted loss or impairment of the
function of any bodily member or organ.” 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 2301.
For aggravated assault purposes, an “attempt” is found where an
“accused who possesses the required, specific intent acts in a
manner which constitutes a substantial step toward perpetrating
a serious bodily injury upon another.” An intent ordinarily must
be proven through circumstantial evidence and inferred from acts,
conduct or attendant circumstances.
-8-
J-S19014-26
Commonwealth v. Fortune, 68 A.3d 980, 984 (Pa. Super. 2013) (some
internal citations and quotations omitted).
In her first claim, Suder contests the sufficiency of the evidence showing
her specific intent to kill. Suder asserts the following: there was insufficient
evidence she took a substantial step towards killing her daughter or had the
specific intent to do so because the Commonwealth presented no evidence
she pointed a gun or fired at Madison Suder; there was insufficient evidence
she intended to kill her son because there was no evidence of threats made
to Dillon Suder immediately prior to shooting at him or her proximity to her
son; there was insufficient evidence to show she intended to kill Graham
because “[t]he evidence presented by the Commonwealth proves only that
[Suder] fired a single bullet into a vehicle occupied by [Graham];” and there
was insufficient evidence to prove she specifically intended to kill Thompson
because there was no evidence she saw him through the bay window. Suder’s
Brief at 57, 59, 61-64. Regarding law enforcement, Suder asserts there was
no proof that she knew exactly where the officers were hiding and she did not
shoot, physically injure, or kill any of the officers present at the scene. See
id. at 67-69. Suder claims, had she “intended to kill the [officers], she had
the firepower and ammunition to relentlessly fire upon them for hours, while
they were pinned down.” Id. at 70. Likewise, in her second and third issues,
Suder contests the sufficiency of the evidence establishing her specific intent
to cause serious bodily injury, with respect to her seven convictions of
-9-
J-S19014-26
aggravated assault of a law enforcement officer, and intent to cause bodily
injury, with respect to her seven convictions of assault of a law enforcement
officer and eleven convictions of aggravated assault.
The trial court considered Suder’s sufficiency claims altogether and
concluded they merited no relief. Specifically, the trial court explained:
The Commonwealth’s evidence was that [Suder] had made
threats of violence and to kill and then proceeded to shoot
firearms at eleven different people. In doing so, [Suder] narrowly
missed shooting the nine victims she was convicted for by inches,
according to the Commonwealth’s evidence. While [Suder] did
not actually hit any of the victims, the Commonwealth’s testimony
regarding how close the bullets came to hitting all of the victims—
in conjunction with [Suder’s] threats of violence—were enough to
support the jury’s verdicts. In short, [Suder’s] intent was a
question left for the jury to decide, [and] their verdicts were
sufficiently supported by the evidence.
Trial Court Opinion, 12/31/25, at 3-4 (footnote omitted).
Preliminarily, we are perplexed that nowhere in the record does it
indicate which two individuals the jury acquitted Suder of attempting to
murder. We have reviewed, among other documents, the Criminal
Information, the verdict slip, Suder’s post-sentence motions, the appellate
briefs, and six transcripts. We are particularly confounded by the trial court’s
following statement to Suder at sentencing:
[Y]ou attempted to murder your own family members. Now,
whether or not the jury convicted you of that. I don’t know.
They found you not guilty of two of the people, so. But,
nonetheless, you are convicted of agg[ravated] assault of your
family members, that’s for sure.
- 10 -
J-S19014-26
N.T., 7/7/25, 32-33 (emphasis added). Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of
Criminal Procedure 560, a criminal information does not always need to
specify the victim pertaining to each count. However, considering Suder
contested the weight of the evidence on the last day of trial, prior to the jury’s
verdict, we do not understand how the trial court did not inquire as to which
two victims the jury acquitted Suder of attempting to murder. Moreover,
Suder does not argue this was in error, and instead contests the sufficiency
of the evidence for all four individuals at the house, knowing that she was
acquitted of attempting to murder two of them.
However, this issue is not dispositive because the Commonwealth
presented sufficient evidence to find Suder possessed the specific intent to
murder all eleven victims. The testimony at trial established Suder said
everyone in the house was going to die that night and, specifically, she was
going to shoot everybody at the house. See N.T., 5/5/25, at 95. Suder later
walked to her car, retrieved her gun, and loaded it before pointing it at her
son. See id. at 45-46, 97. Suder fired the weapon several times at her son
and Graham. See id. at 47-48, 97. Suder then shot towards her home, where
Thompson and her daughter remained. See id. at 98. Suder took a
substantial step towards killing all four victims when she threatened to kill
everyone in the house, retrieved her firearm from her vehicle, and fired shots
at her son, Graham, and towards her house. See Tucker, 143 A.3d at 964.
Further, we presume Suder intended the natural and probable consequences
- 11 -
J-S19014-26
of her actions; the jury, as the finder of fact, was permitted to infer that death
is a natural and probable consequence of Suder shooting at the victims. See
Lewis, 911 A.2d at 564; Commonwealth v. Gease, 696 A.2d 130, 133 (Pa.
1997).
Suder committed similar actions towards law enforcement. The officers
identified themselves to Suder when they were outside of her residence. See
N.T., 5/5/25, at 165. Suder told them to leave and began to yell profanities,
including “fuck you, I’ll show you a laser” before opening fire on the officers.
Id. at 194. Suder took a substantial step towards killing the seven officers
when she threatened to “show them a laser” and opened fire on them. See
Tucker, 143 A.3d at 964. The natural and probable consequence of her
actions was death. See Lewis, 911 A.2d at 564; Gease, 696 A.2d at 133.
Suder repeatedly states that because her shots missed the victims, she
did not possess the specific intent to kill. Our longstanding precedent
establishes that a shot does not need to strike the intended victim in order to
establish the specific intent to kill. See Commonwealth v. Jones, 629 A.2d
133, 135 n.2 (Pa. Super. 1993); Commonwealth v. Cross, 331 A.2d 813,
815 (Pa. Super. 1974). Moreover, the Commonwealth presented evidence
that Suder verbally and directly indicated her intent to kill her son, her
daughter, Graham, Thompson, and all seven law enforcement officers. See
id. at 814 (holding the evidence established a specific intent to kill where the
appellant yelled “this is for your brother” and then shot the victim).
- 12 -
J-S19014-26
We acknowledge the jury, out of lenity or some other motive, acquitted
Suder of attempting to murder two of the victims. See generally
Commonwealth v. Frisbie, 889 A.2d 1271, 1273 (Pa. Super. 2005)
(discussing inconsistent verdicts and explaining that they are not a basis for
reversal). We recognize that because the evidence was sufficient to support
a finding of Suder’s specific intent to kill all of the victims, her convictions for
attempted murder stand.
Suder advances no independent factual or legal argument to defend her
position regarding her lack of specific intent to commit aggravated assault and
aggravated assault of a law enforcement officer. Instead, she incorporates by
reference the facts and legal analysis she discusses in her first claim,
pertaining to the specific intent to kill. See Suder’s Brief at 73, 75-76. The
evidence supporting a finding that Suder specifically intended to kill all eleven
victims also supports a finding that she intended to cause serious bodily injury
to all eleven victims. By its own definition, “serious bodily injury” means
“[b]odily injury which creates a substantial risk of death.” Fortune, 68 A.3d
at 984. Suder announced her intention to shoot everyone and acted upon
that intention, firing her weapon several times that day. Thus, there was
sufficient evidence to support a finding that Suder intended to cause serious
bodily injury and, inherently, bodily injury. Therefore, her first three claims
are without merit.
- 13 -
J-S19014-26
In her fourth claim, Suder argues the trial court abused its discretion by
imposing a manifestly excessive and unduly harsh sentence and failed to
appropriately consider mitigating factors and mandatory sentencing
considerations. Suder’s fourth issue implicates the discretionary aspects of
sentencing.
Our standard of review for challenges to the discretionary aspects of
sentencing is well settled: “[S]entencing is vested in the discretion of the trial
court, and will not be disturbed absent a manifest abuse of that discretion.”
Commonwealth v. Brown, 249 A.3d 1206, 1211 (Pa. Super. 2021). An
abuse of discretion is more than an error in judgment. See Commonwealth
v. Lucky, 229 A.3d 657, 663 (Pa. Super. 2020). To demonstrate an abuse of
discretion, an appellant “must establish, by reference to the record, that the
sentencing court ignored or misapplied the law, exercised its judgment for
reasons of partiality, prejudice, bias or ill will, or arrived at a manifestly
unreasonable decision.” Id. (internal citation omitted).
There is no absolute right to challenge the discretionary aspects of a
sentence. See Commonwealth v. Moury, 992 A.2d 162, 170 (Pa. Super.
2010). Rather, an appellant challenging the sentencing court’s discretion
must invoke this Court's jurisdiction by:
(1) filing a timely notice of appeal; (2) properly preserving the
issue at sentencing or in a motion to reconsider and modify the
sentence; (3) complying with Pa.R.A.P. 2119(f), which requires a
separate section of the brief setting forth “a concise statement of
the reasons relied upon for allowance of appeal with respect to the
discretionary aspects of a sentence[;]” and (4) presenting a
- 14 -
J-S19014-26
substantial question that the sentence appealed from is not
appropriate under the Sentencing Code.
Commonwealth v. Padilla-Vargas, 204 A.3d 971, 975 (Pa. Super. 2019)
(citation omitted) (brackets in original); see also 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 9781(b).
Suder timely appealed, her brief includes a Rule 2119(f) statement, and
she raised her discretionary aspects of sentencing claims in her post-sentence
motion. This Court has held “an excessive sentence claim[—]in conjunction
with an assertion that the court failed to consider mitigating factors[—]raises
a substantial question.” Commonwealth v. Raven, 97 A.3d 1244, 1253 (Pa.
Super. 2013). Therefore, Suder has presented a substantial question, and we
will address the merits of her discretionary aspects of sentencing claim.
When a sentence is within the standard range of the sentencing
guidelines, Pennsylvania law views the sentence as appropriate under the
Sentencing Code. See Commonwealth v. Walls, 926 A.2d 957, 963 (Pa.
2007); Moury, 992 A.2d at 171. We may only vacate a sentence within the
guidelines where the sentence is “clearly unreasonable.” 42 Pa.C.S.A.
§ 9781(c)(2). In addition, when the trial court had the benefit of a PSI, we
“presume that the sentencing judge was aware of relevant information
regarding the defendant’s character and weighed those considerations along
with mitigating statutory factors.” Commonwealth v. Devers, 546 A.2d 12,
18 (Pa. 1988). Lastly, “[l]ack of remorse is an appropriate sentencing
consideration.” Commonwealth v. Summers, 245 A.3d 686, 695 (Pa.
Super. 2021).
- 15 -
J-S19014-26
Suder asserts the trial court abused its discretion in imposing her fifty-
eight and one-half to one-hundred and thirty-five-year sentence. Specifically,
Suder argues the trial court erred by: making assumptions about her past
conduct in order to determine that the sentence served the protection of the
public and did not offer any legitimate reason to support that determination;
giving little to no consideration to Suder’s medical and psychiatric history,
including degenerative disc disease, stomach and bowel issues, seizure
disorder, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; and running her
sentences for two counts of attempted murder and seven counts of attempted
murder of a law enforcement officer consecutively, a de facto life sentence
that failed to consider mitigating evidence. See Suder’s Brief at 35-51.
The trial court disagreed with Suder’s claim and, instead of providing an
analysis, referred this court to the sentencing transcript. See Trial Court
Opinion, 12/31/25, at 1-2.
After careful review, we conclude Suder’s standard-range sentences
were neither excessive nor clearly unreasonable and discern no abuse of
discretion in sentencing. See, e.g., Moury, 992 A.2d at 171; see also Raven,
97 A.3d at 1254-55. Suder’s aggregate sentence was composed of nine terms
of six-and-one-half to fifteen years of incarceration for attempted murder of
two civilians and seven police officers. Each of these sentences fell within the
standard range of the guidelines. See 204 Pa. Code §§ 303.3(c), 303.15,
- 16 -
J-S19014-26
303.16(a), 303.17(b).4 Suder has failed to persuade us that her standard-
range sentence is clearly unreasonable. The trial court imposed consecutive
sentences only on her convictions for attempted murder. As the trial court
explained, it is a miracle Suder did not kill anyone that day. See N.T., 7/7/25,
at 28. Moreover, the trial court was in possession of a PSI, so we presume it
was “aware of relevant information regarding the defendant’s character and
weighed those considerations along with mitigating statutory factors.”
Devers, 546 A.2d at 18. However, the trial court noted Suder showed a lack
of remorse, see Summers, 245 A.3d at 695, and emphasized the gravity of
the offense and the need to protect the public. See N.T., 7/7/25, at 32-33.
The court did not abuse its discretion when it considered relevant sentencing
factors but weighed them in a manner inconsistent with Suder’s wishes. See
Commonwealth v. Proctor, 156 A.3d 261, 274 (Pa. Super. 2017).
Therefore, we discern no abuse of the trial court’s sentencing discretion in
weighing mitigating factors and imposing this standard-range sentence.
In her fifth and final issue, Suder claims the trial court imposed an illegal
flat sentence of twenty years for her convictions of assault of a law
enforcement officer, and that the trial court instead should have imposed a
minimum and maximum term. Such a claim goes to the legality of sentence.
See Commonwealth v. Postie, 110 A.3d 1034, 1043 (Pa. Super. 2015).
Our standard of review for a challenge to the legality of sentence is de novo
____________________________________________
4 The Seventh Edition, Sixth Amendment of the Sentencing Guidelines apply
because Suder committed the underlying crimes in August 2023.
- 17 -
J-S19014-26
and our scope of review is plenary. See Commonwealth v. Perzel, 291
A.3d 38, 45 (Pa. Super. 2023).
“If this Court determines that a sentence must be corrected, we are
empowered to either amend the sentence directly or to remand the case to
the trial court for resentencing.” Commonwealth v. Benchoff, 700 A.2d
1289, 1294 (Pa. Super. 1997). If this Court’s correction may upset the overall
“sentencing scheme envisioned by the trial court, the better practice is to
remand.” Id. (internal citation omitted).
Suder was convicted of assault of a law enforcement officer under 18
Pa.C.S.A. § 2702.1(a)(1) (“Section 2702.1”). Section 2702.1(b) states the
penalty as follows:
Notwithstanding [S]ection 1103(1) (relating to sentence of
imprisonment for felony), a person convicted under subsection
(a)(1) shall be sentenced to a term of imprisonment fixed by the
court at not more than 40 years.
18 Pa.C.S.A. § 2702.1(b) (emphasis added).
Suder was sentenced pursuant to Section 9719.1(a), which states, in
relevant part:
(a) Mandatory sentence.--A person convicted of the following
offense shall be sentenced to a mandatory term of
imprisonment as follows:
18 Pa.C.S.[A.] § 2702.1(a)(1) (relating to assault of law
enforcement officer) - not less than 20 years.
42 Pa.C.S.A. § 9719.1(a) (emphasis added).
- 18 -
J-S19014-26
Therefore, when read together, Suder should have received a sentence
of not less than 20, but not more than 40, years of imprisonment. See 18
Pa.C.S.A. § 2702.1(b); 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 9719.1(a). Her flat sentence is illegal.
Suder acknowledges the mandatory minimum sentence is applicable to
her seven convictions of assault of a law enforcement officer. See Suder’s
Brief at 54. Suder also is aware that these sentences ran concurrently to each
other and to her sentences on the other charges. See id. at 52.
At sentencing, the trial court clearly indicated its reasoning for the
aggregate sentence. Specifically, the trial court explained that it sentenced
consecutively on the attempted murder convictions because they were the
most serious crimes. See N.T., 7/7/25 at 38. The trial court then explained
it would impose the mandatory minimum for Suder’s convictions of assault of
a law enforcement officer, and that its intent was to impose all other offenses
concurrently. See id. Moreover, it appears clear that the trial court meant
to sentence Suder to the minimum mandatory sentence under Section
2702.1(b); specifically, at least twenty years.
The Sentencing Code provides that a “court shall impose a minimum
sentence of confinement which shall not exceed one-half of the maximum
sentence imposed.” 42 Pa.C.S.A. §9756(b)(1). Here, therefore, where the
trial court intended to impose the mandatory minimum term of twenty years,
the maximum would be at least forty years in order to comply with 42
Pa.C.S.A. §9756(b)(1). Section 2702.1(b) prohibits sentences over forty
- 19 -
J-S19014-26
years for a conviction of assault of a law enforcement officer. See 18
Pa.C.S.A. § 2702.1(b). Thus, Suder’s correct sentence, considering the trial
court’s intent, would be twenty to forty years of imprisonment.
Suder requests that this Court vacate the judgment of sentence. See
id. at 54. Instead, we will amend Suder’s seven sentences for assault of a
law enforcement officer to a term of twenty to forty years on each charge.
These sentences continue to run concurrently to each other and to the overall
sentencing scheme; as such, they do not disrupt Suder’s aggregate sentence,
which is composed of consecutive sentences solely on her attempted murder
convictions. See Benchoff, 700 A.2d at 1294. Suder’s aggregate sentence
remains fifty-eight and one-half to one hundred and thirty-five years of
imprisonment.
Judgment of sentence affirmed.
DATE: 11/20/2026
- 20 -