Com. v. Piper, N.
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket1396 WDA 2025
JudgeBowes
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
J-A22013-26
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. :
:
:
NYAL BARTON PIPER :
:
Appellant : No. 1396 WDA 2025
Appeal from the Judgment of Sentence Entered September 26, 2025
In the Court of Common Pleas of Bedford County Criminal Division at
No(s): CP-05-CR-0000138-2024
BEFORE: BOWES, J., OLSON, J., and MURRAY, J.
MEMORANDUM BY BOWES, J.: FILED: November 16, 2026
Nyal Barton Piper appeals from the judgment of sentence of ninety
months to forty years of imprisonment, followed by twelve months of re-entry
supervision, imposed after he entered an open plea of nolo contendere to
twenty counts each of cruelty to animals and aggravated cruelty to animals,
and ten counts of failure to keep a dog license. We affirm.
On December 31, 2023, the Pennsylvania State Police responded to the
Bedford Township residence owned by Appellant and his wife, Renee Lynn
Piper (“Co-defendant”) to conduct a welfare check on animals believed to be
inside. Troopers observed that the couple were dirty and covered in feces, as
were multiple dogs in the backyard, one of which had an open wound on its
ears. After obtaining consent to search, troopers found the house in a
deplorable condition. The floors were covered in feces, cages holding the
J-A22013-26
animals were stacked three high throughout the residence, and no clean food
or water was provided or accessible to the animals. Volunteers from the
Bedford County Humane Society (“BCHS”), as well as other local shelters,
removed ninety dogs, eight cats, and a tortoise from the home.1 Four dogs
had to be euthanized at the scene, and a fifth was euthanized the following
day. Many of the surviving animals required veterinary procedures, including
dental extractions, treatment for severe skin infections and sores, and surgery
for infected wounds. Only nine of the dogs were licensed. See N.T. Plea,
6/17/25, at 30-31.
The Commonwealth charged Appellant and Co-defendant with nearly
500 offenses. On the day scheduled for jury selection, Appellant entered an
open plea of nolo contendere to the charges enumerated above, with the
remaining charges to be nolle prossed.2 The parties agreed that the forty
cruelty counts corresponded to forty separate animals. Id. at 22, 24. During
the colloquy, the court explained that a nolo contendere plea meant that
Appellant was “not agreeing factually as to what happened in the case with
the Commonwealth’s evidence,” but was “conceding that if a jury were to hear
all the evidence in the case, that they could convict [him] of those counts.”
____________________________________________
1 BCHS manager Kathy Ramsey testified at sentencing that their agency had
removed ninety-four dogs. See N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 17.
2 Co-defendant entered an identical plea at the same proceeding. Her
separate appeal from her judgment of sentence, docketed at 1394 WDA 2025,
is addressed in a separate memorandum.
-2-
J-A22013-26
Id. at 22. The court further advised Appellant that each felony count of
aggravated cruelty carried a statutory maximum of seven years of
imprisonment, that the sentences could be imposed consecutively, and that
sentencing was open to the court’s discretion. Id. at 23. The court accepted
the plea, ordered a pre-sentence investigation (“PSI”) report, and deferred
sentencing.
The court sentenced Appellant on September 26, 2025. In fashioning
the sentence, the court considered the PSI report, sentencing memoranda
from all parties with exhibits, the Commonwealth’s photographs and videos of
the residence and the animals, letters from rescuers, volunteers, and adoptive
owners, and the report of the defense expert, Wayne D’Agaro, Psy.D. The
Commonwealth presented the testimony of a representative of the Bedford
County Humane Society, Ms. Ramsey, and Appellant presented the testimony
of Dr. D’Agaro and Co-defendant’s mother, Mary Ann Hazen. Appellant also
exercised his right of allocution.
Ms. Ramsey recounted the rescue, the condition of the animals, the five
dogs that had to be euthanized, and the burden borne by the shelter, its staff,
and the community. See N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 15-22. The
Commonwealth requested that the court impose consecutive sentences for
each animal that Appellant harmed and that the respective terms of
imprisonment fall at the top of the standard range or in the aggravated range.
Id. at 23-24.
-3-
J-A22013-26
Appellant presented the testimony of Dr. D’Agaro, who evaluated him
and found no cognitive impairment, but identified that he suffered from severe
depression and anxiety. Id. at 42. He explained several subtypes of animal
hoarding, including the “overwhelmed caregiver,” who attempts to care for
animals but becomes overwhelmed psychologically and financially, and the
more culpable “exploiter” and “breeder” hoarders, who lack empathy for the
animals. Id. 37-38. He placed Appellant in the overwhelmed-caregiver
subtype, explaining that Appellant felt particularly overwhelmed because age,
diabetes, and neuropathy left him unable to provide his wife with the
assistance she needed. Id. at 36-38, 42-43. On cross-examination and in
response to the court’s questions, Dr. D’Agaro acknowledged that his opinions
were based solely on his interviews and information supplied by counsel, and
that he had not reviewed the photographs or videos of the home, information
about the couple’s retirement benefits or financial assets, or any statement
from Ms. Hazen. Id. at 43-46.
In his allocution, Appellant apologized for the time and expense his
“animal hoarding” had caused and denied ever knowingly harming an animal
but devoted much of his statement to criticizing BCHS and its supporters for
their public comments about the case and for allegedly disseminating the
evidentiary photographs. Id. at 63-66. His counsel highlighted his twenty
years of service in the United States Navy, his age, health, and remorse, and
requested a mitigated-range sentence of probation. Id. at 66-67.
-4-
J-A22013-26
The court then explained its sentence at length. Id. at 67-96. It
recounted its review of the entire record, which it had read “at least three to
five times,” and described the photographs as “some of the most extreme” it
had seen in approximately twenty years as a prosecutor and judge. Id. at
68-69. The court rejected Dr. D’Agaro’s overwhelmed caregiver opinion as
resting on an incomplete factual basis and found that Appellant was “more
closely aligned with an exploiter hoarder.” Id. at 81-88.
After addressing the gravity of the offenses, the protection of the public,
and Appellant’s rehabilitative needs, the court imposed the following sentence.
On the five counts of aggravated cruelty that corresponded to the five animals
that had to be euthanized, the court imposed aggravated-range sentences of
six to twenty-four months of imprisonment. On each of the remaining fifteen
counts, it imposed four to twenty-four months of imprisonment, which was at
the top of the standard range. All twenty felony sentences were set to run
consecutively. On one count of cruelty to animals, the court imposed twelve
months of re-entry supervision, consecutive to the felony sentences. On each
of the remaining nineteen counts of cruelty to animals, it imposed a concurrent
term of twelve months of probation. On the ten counts of failure to keep a dog
license, it imposed no penalty other than costs. The aggregate sentence was
-5-
J-A22013-26
ninety months to forty years of imprisonment, followed by twelve months of
re-entry supervision.3
Appellant filed a timely post-sentence motion, which the court denied,
and a timely notice of appeal. He complied with the court’s order to file a
concise statement of errors pursuant to Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b). In lieu of a Rule
1925(a) opinion, the trial court stated that its reasons for the sentence were
fully set forth on the record at the sentencing hearing and referred this Court
to the transcript. See Trial Court Memorandum, 1/7/26, at 1.
Appellant presents the following issues for our review:
I. Whether the sentencing court abused its discretion and
imposed a manifestly excessive sentence, one inconsistent
with sentencing principles, of [ninety] months to [forty]
years[’] incarceration where the Appellant was [eighty-two]
years old at the time of sentencing, had a prior record score
of zero, served [twenty] years in the U.S. Navy, entered an
open nolo contendere plea, and the sentence constitutes a
de facto life sentence?
II. Whether the sentencing court abused its discretion and
imposed a manifestly excessive sentence by relying upon a
factual and psychological conclusion not supported by the
record—specifically, its determination that Appellant was
more consistent with an “exploiter hoarder” rather than an
“overwhelmed caregiver”—and then relying on that
____________________________________________
3 The court also found Appellant eligible for the Recidivism Risk Reduction
Incentive (“RRRI”) program and, pursuant to 18 Pa.C.S. § 5555, prohibited
him from owning, possessing, or caring for animals for forty years. See
Sentencing Order, 9/26/25, at ¶¶ 2, 7. It declined the Commonwealth’s
request for restitution to the rescue organizations, a ruling that is not at issue
in this appeal. See N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 9-13. The court also rejected
Appellant’s argument that his sentences merged, because each count
represented a separate animal. Id. at 8-9.
-6-
J-A22013-26
characterization in determining the severity and structure of
the sentence?
III. Whether the sentencing court placed undue weight on the
nature of the offense, while failing to give meaningful
practical effect to Appellant-specific mitigating
circumstances, resulting in a sentence that is unreasonable
and inconsistent with the individualized sentencing required
by Pennsylvania law?
Appellant’s brief at 7 (cleaned up).
We begin our review mindful of the following legal principles. “An
appellant is not entitled to the review of challenges to the discretionary
aspects of a sentence as of right.” Commonwealth v. Bowens, 265 A.3d
730, 762–63 (Pa.Super. 2021) (en banc) (cleaned up). Rather, as we have
explained:
[A]n appellant challenging the discretionary aspects of his
sentence must invoke this Court’s jurisdiction. We determine
whether the appellant has invoked our jurisdiction by considering
the following four factors: (1) whether appellant has filed a timely
notice of appeal; (2) whether the issue was properly preserved at
sentencing or in a motion to reconsider and modify sentence; (3)
whether appellant’s brief has a fatal defect; and (4) whether there
is a substantial question that the sentence appealed from is not
appropriate under the Sentencing Code.
Id. at 763 (cleaned up).
A substantial question is raised when an appellant sets forth a colorable
argument that his sentence is either: “(1) inconsistent with a specific
provision of the sentencing code; or (2) contrary to the fundamental norms
which underlie the sentencing process.” See Commonwealth v. Radecki,
180 A.3d 441, 468 (Pa.Super. 2018) (cleaned up). In addressing whether an
-7-
J-A22013-26
appellant has presented a substantial question, “[o]ur inquiry must focus on
the reasons for which the appeal is sought, in contrast to the facts underlying
the appeal, which are necessary only to decide the appeal on the merits.”
Commonwealth v. Rhoades, 8 A.3d 912, 916 (Pa.Super. 2010) (cleaned
up). To determine whether an appellant has raised a substantial question,
our review is generally confined to the appellant’s Rule 2119(f) statement,
although we may also consider the statement of questions presented. See
Commonwealth v. Dodge, 77 A.3d 1263, 1271 (Pa.Super. 2013).
Here, Appellant timely appealed, preserved his sentencing challenges in
a post-sentence motion, and included a Rule 2119(f) statement in his brief.
The Commonwealth concedes that the first three requirements are satisfied
but contends that Appellant has not raised a substantial question. See
Commonwealth’s brief at 4.
The Commonwealth is correct that a bald challenge to the court’s
exercise of its discretion to impose consecutive rather than concurrent
sentences and that a claim that the court failed to give adequate weight to
mitigating factors does not, standing alone, raise a substantial question. See
Commonwealth v. DiSalvo, 70 A.3d 900, 903 (Pa.Super. 2013);
Commonwealth v. Austin, 66 A.3d 798, 808 (Pa.Super. 2013). In this vein,
Appellant’s third issue, which asserts that the court allowed the gravity of the
offenses to overwhelm the mitigating circumstances of his lack of criminal
history, military service, and rehabilitative needs, does not raise a substantial
-8-
J-A22013-26
question. See DiSalvo, 70 A.3d at 903. Critically, Appellant does not contend
that the court failed to consider those circumstances. He concedes that the
court reviewed the mitigating evidence and challenges only the weight the
court assigned to it. See Appellant’s brief at 37. In so far as this claim
implicates neither a misapplication of the sentencing code nor the court’s
fundamental misunderstanding of the sentencing process, we will not address
it. See Bowens, 265 A.3d at 763.
However, Appellant’s two remaining claims are not as limited as the
Commonwealth contends. In his first issue, he alleges that the consecutive
imposition of twenty felony sentences produced an aggregate sentence that
is clearly unreasonable and amounts to a de facto life sentence in light of his
age. In his second issue, he contends that the court relied upon a
characterization of him as an ‘exploiter hoarder’ that lacked support in the
record. See Appellant’s brief at 18-20.
As we explained in Dodge, “a defendant may raise a substantial
question where he receives consecutive sentences within the guideline ranges
if the case involves circumstances where the application of the guidelines
would be clearly unreasonable, resulting in an excessive sentence; however,
a bald claim of excessiveness due to the consecutive nature of a sentence will
not raise a substantial question.” Dodge, 77 A.3d at 1270 (cleaned up). “The
key to resolving the preliminary substantial question inquiry is whether the
decision to sentence consecutively raises the aggregate sentence to, what
-9-
J-A22013-26
appears upon its face to be, an excessive level in light of the criminal conduct
at issue in the case.” Commonwealth v. Mastromarino, 2 A.3d 581, 587
(Pa.Super. 2010).
Appellant’s first issue is not a bald challenge to the consecutive nature
of his sentences. Rather, he presents a plausible argument that running
twenty felony sentences consecutively, as applied to an eighty-two-year-old
offender with no prior record, raised the aggregate sentence to a level that is
clearly unreasonable in light of his criminal conduct. See Dodge, 77 A.3d at
1270; Mastromarino, 2 A.3d at 587. Appellant’s second issue, which asserts
that the court relied upon a characterization of him that lacked support in the
record, likewise presents a substantial question. See Commonwealth v.
Downing, 990 A.2d 788, 792 (Pa.Super. 2010) (holding that a claim that the
sentencing court relied upon an improper factor raised a substantial question).
We therefore proceed to the merits.
The following principles govern our review of Appellant’s challenges:
To prevail, Appellant must demonstrate that the sentencing court
abused its discretion. In this context, an abuse of discretion is not
shown merely by an error in judgment. Rather, Appellant must
establish, by reference to the record, that the sentencing court
ignored or misapplied the law, exercised its judgment for reasons
of partiality, prejudice, bias or ill will, or arrived at a manifestly
unreasonable decision.
Commonwealth v. Solomon, 247 A.3d 1163, 1168 (Pa.Super. 2021)
(cleaned up). Where, as here, the trial court has the benefit of a PSI report,
“it is presumed that the court is aware of all appropriate sentencing factors
- 10 -
J-A22013-26
and considerations, and that where the court has been so informed, its
discretion should not be disturbed.” Commonwealth v. Torres, 303 A.3d
1058, 1065 (Pa.Super. 2023) (cleaned up). “We cannot re-weigh the
sentencing factors and impose our judgment in the place of the sentencing
court.” Commonwealth v. Macias, 968 A.2d at 773, 778 (Pa.Super. 2009).
While it is broad, “the trial court’s discretion is not unfettered.”
Commonwealth v. Coulverson, 34 A.3d 135, 144 (Pa.Super. 2011). The
sentence imposed “should call for confinement that is consistent with the
protection of the public, the gravity of the offense as it relates to the impact
on the life of the victim and on the community, and the rehabilitative needs
of the defendant.” 42 Pa.C.S. § 9721(b). A sentencing court must weigh the
specific facts of the offense alongside the defendant’s character, looking to
factors such as criminal history, age, individual traits, and prospects for
rehabilitation. See Commonwealth v. Taylor, 277 A.3d 577, 593
(Pa.Super. 2022).
Furthermore, “the court shall make as a part of the record, and disclose
in open court at the time of sentencing, a statement of the reason or reasons
for the sentence imposed.” 42 Pa.C.S. § 9721(b). Where, as here, each
individual sentence falls within the standard range of the sentencing
guidelines, we may grant relief only if “the case involves circumstances where
the application of the guidelines would be clearly unreasonable.” 42 Pa.C.S.
§ 9781(c)(2). In making that assessment, we consider the nature and
- 11 -
J-A22013-26
circumstances of the offense and the history and characteristics of Appellant,
the opportunity of the sentencing court to observe Appellant, including any
PSI report, the findings upon which the sentence was based, and the
sentencing guidelines. See 42 Pa.C.S. § 9781(d). An unreasonable sentence
is one that is “irrational” or “not guided by sound judgment.”
Commonwealth v. Walls, 926 A.2d 957, 963 (Pa. 2007). Our deference to
the sentencing court reflects that it “is in the best position to determine the
proper penalty for a particular offense based upon an evaluation of the
individual circumstances before it,” as it “can accord the proper weight to the
defendant’s character, displays of remorse, defiance or indifference, and the
overall effect and nature of the crime.” Id. at 961 (cleaned up).
Mindful of these principles, we turn to the merits of Appellant’s
sentencing challenge. We first address Appellant’s contention that his
aggregate sentence is clearly unreasonable, considering his arguments
regarding the mitigating evidence insofar as they bear on that contention. We
then turn to his challenge to the court’s assessment that he was more closely
aligned with an “exploiter-hoarder.”
Appellant contends that his sentence is, in practical effect, a life
sentence for an eighty-two-year-old Navy veteran with no prior record, who
would not complete the minimum term until approximately age ninety. He
emphasizes that the court acknowledged that protection of the public was not
a critical consideration and that the future-risk concern could be addressed by
- 12 -
J-A22013-26
barring him from owning animals. He further maintains that the court allowed
the gravity of the offenses to overwhelm the mitigating evidence, and that the
imposition of the same sentence on him and his much younger wife
demonstrates that his sentence was not individualized. See Appellant’s brief
at 21-28, 35-40.
Our review of the record reveals no abuse of discretion. At the outset,
the court had the benefit of a PSI report, which was expressly reviewed along
with the sentencing memoranda, Dr. D’Agaro’s report and testimony, and
Appellant’s written statement. See N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 2-5, 67-68,
79, 85-86. We therefore presume that the court was aware of and weighed
the mitigating circumstances Appellant highlights, including his age, health,
lack of a criminal record, and military and government service. See Torres,
303 A.3d at 1065. Indeed, Appellant acknowledges that his argument “does
not depend upon claiming that the court failed to review mitigation.”
Appellant’s brief at 37. His disagreement is with the weight the court assigned
to it.
The record further confirms that the court applied each of the
considerations required by § 9721(b). Regarding the gravity of the offenses,
the court detailed the deplorable and inhumane conditions depicted in the
photographs and videos, which included the carcass of a dog in a kennel with
living dogs that was so decomposed that the court could not tell “where the
dog carcass ends and the floor begins.” N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 68-71.
- 13 -
J-A22013-26
It found that the accumulation of filth reflected neglect over a long period of
time, and it reviewed the accounts of rescuers and adoptive owners describing
dogs rescued from Appellant’s home that could not walk, play, or pass through
a doorway after lives spent confined in crates. Id. at 69-76. The court also
considered the substantial impact on the community, including the shelter
staff, volunteers, and organizations that absorbed the rescue and
rehabilitation of nearly one hundred animals. Id. at 71-76, 92-93. It
concluded that this was “an extreme case” of animal abuse. Id. at 90.
The court did not ignore the remaining § 9721(b) considerations. It
recognized that protection of the public was not “a critical consideration” and
that the primary future risk was that Appellant might again possess animals.
Id. at 91. As to rehabilitative needs, it expressly commented that the
Appellant “[is] advanced in age” and that he has medical needs, but found
those needs to be normal for his age and better met in a state correctional
setting than by county resources. Id. The court also reflected upon what it
found to be Appellant’s lack of genuine remorse and appreciation for the harm
he caused, and it remarked that it did not impose the sentence “with any type
of celebration” or “take joy in the fact of incarcerating anyone in [his] age.”
Id. at 91-92. The court thus weighed each of the statutory considerations
and explained why the gravity of the offenses warranted a significant term of
incarceration notwithstanding Appellant’s age and the limited risk Appellant
posed to the public.
- 14 -
J-A22013-26
Appellant’s reliance on the court’s observation that public protection was
not a critical concern is misplaced. Section 9721(b) directs the court to
fashion a sentence consistent with protection of the public, the gravity of the
offense as it relates to the impact on the victim and the community, and the
defendant’s rehabilitative needs. The court’s candid recognition that one
factor weighed less heavily here demonstrates that it considered all three, not
that it failed to individualize the sentence.
The court also explained the reasons for the structure of the sentence.
Each of the twenty felony counts represented a different animal subjected to
the conditions described above, as Appellant agreed when entering the plea.
See N.T. Plea, 6/17/25, at 22, 24-25. With an offense gravity score of eight
and a prior record score of zero, the standard-range minimum sentence on
each count of aggravated cruelty to animals was one to four months of
incarceration, plus or minus three months. See N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at
6. The court imposed sentences at the top of the standard range on fifteen
counts. “[W]here a sentence is within the standard range of the guidelines,
Pennsylvania law views the sentence as appropriate under the Sentencing
Code.” Commonwealth v. Moury, 992 A.2d 162, 171 (Pa.Super 2010). On
the remaining five counts, it imposed aggravated range sentences, explaining
that those counts corresponded to the five animals that had to be euthanized.
The guidelines for the torture variant of aggravated cruelty to animals, to
- 15 -
J-A22013-26
which Appellant pled, do not account for that aggravating circumstance.4 See
N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 95-96. Appellant does not challenge that
rationale. Moreover, a defendant is not entitled to a “volume discount” for
multiple crimes by having all sentences run concurrently. See
Commonwealth v. Brown, 249 A.3d 1206, 1216 (Pa.Super. 2021). In light
of the number of animals involved, the prolonged and severe nature of their
suffering, and the deaths of five of them, an aggregate minimum of ninety
months does not appear excessive on its face.
We are likewise unpersuaded by Appellant’s contention that his age
renders the sentence a de facto life sentence that is excessive as a matter of
course. Age is one of the characteristics a sentencing court must consider,
and the court did so here. See Taylor, 277 A.3d at 593. It observed that
Appellant was about twenty years older than his wife but noted that
Dr. D’Agaro found him cognitively intact and fully ambulatory for his age, and
____________________________________________
4 The aggravated cruelty statute provides in pertinent part:
A person commits an offense if the person intentionally or
knowingly does any of the following:
(1) Tortures an animal.
(2) Violates section 5532 (relating to neglect of an animal)
or 5533 (relating to cruelty to an animal) causing serious
bodily injury to the animal or the death of the animal.
18 Pa.C.S. § 5534(a). Appellant pled to the torture variant set forth in
subsection (a)(1), which does not require that the animal die.
- 16 -
J-A22013-26
that he had continued to drive his wife throughout the state for her legal work
after his retirement. See N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 79, 85-86. It also
considered that his medical needs, while greater than his wife’s, were typical
for his age and would be met in a state facility. Id. at 91. Appellant cites no
authority, and we are aware of none, requiring a sentencing court to structure
a sentence so that it concludes within a defendant’s life expectancy, and we
decline to hold that the court was obligated to discount the gravity of his
offenses because of his age. See Macias, 968 A.2d at 778.
Appellant also argues that the court abused its discretion by rejecting
Dr. D’Agaro’s unrebutted opinion that he was an overwhelmed caregiver and
instead concluding that he was more consistent with an exploiter hoarder,
then relying on that characterization in determining the severity and structure
of the sentence. Appellant concedes that the court was free to reject Dr.
D’Agaro’s conclusions and to assign them little or no weight. See Appellant’s
brief at 32. He maintains, however, that the court crossed a line by adopting
an alternative characterization that no witness supported. Relying on
Commonwealth v. Downing, 990 A.2d 788 (Pa.Super. 2010), and
Commonwealth v. P.L.S., 894 A.2d 120 (Pa.Super. 2006), he asserts that
the court’s characterization lacked evidentiary support because nothing in the
record established that he acted from indifference or selfish motivation. See
Appellant’s brief at 29-35.
- 17 -
J-A22013-26
We discern no abuse of discretion in the court’s assessment of
Appellant’s culpability. The court did not purport to render a psychological
diagnosis. To the contrary, it acknowledged, “I’m not a doctor, so I can’t
diagnose [Appellant and Co-defendant] as the exploiter hoarders,” and it
concluded from the evidence presented only that they were “closer to” and
“more closely aligned with” that subtype than with the overwhelmed-caregiver
subtype. See N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 84, 88. The court used Dr.
D’Agaro’s own framework in reaching that conclusion. By way of background,
Dr. D’Agaro described the overwhelmed caregiver as someone with a strong
attachment to the animals who wants to provide proper care, but lacks the
financial resources or emotional capacity to do so, and he distinguished the
exploiter and breeder subtypes by their lack of empathy for the animals. Id.
at 36-38, 79-80. Having accepted that framework, the court permissibly
assessed which description better fit the evidence before it.
Appellant’s argument that the court could reject Dr. D’Agaro’s opinion
but could not make contrary findings would, in effect, require the court to
accept an expert’s factual premises even after finding them contradicted by
the record. The law imposes no such requirement.
Finally, we note that the court’s assessment of Appellant’s responsibility
did not dictate the structure of the sentence in the manner Appellant suggests.
The court imposed aggravated-range sentences only on the five counts
corresponding to the animals that died, for reasons unrelated to the hoarding
- 18 -
J-A22013-26
subtype, and it imposed standard-range sentences on the remaining fifteen
felony counts. See N.T. Sentencing, 9/26/25, at 95-96. Assessing a
defendant’s culpability and character is a core function of the sentencing court,
and the court properly considered them here. See 42 Pa.C.S. § 9721(b);
Taylor, 277 A.3d at 593.
In sum, the court considered the circumstances of the offenses,
Appellant’s character, his lack of a prior record, his age and health, his
rehabilitative needs, and his role in the offenses, and it placed on the record
its reasons for the sentence imposed. Appellant has failed to show that the
court’s weighing of any of these factors was manifestly unreasonable or based
on partiality, prejudice, bias, or ill will. See Solomon, 247 A.3d at 1168.
Rather, he merely asks us to substitute our judgment for that of the
sentencing court and reweigh the sentencing factors, which we cannot do. See
Macias, 968 A.2d at 778. Since Appellant has failed to establish that the court
abused its discretion in imposing his sentence, we have no cause to disturb it.
Accordingly, we affirm his judgment of sentence.
Judgment of sentence affirmed.
DATE: 11/16/2026
- 19 -