Com. v. Parker, D.
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket2957 EDA 2024
JudgeNichols
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
J-A14040-26
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. :
:
:
DEMETRIUS PARKER :
:
Appellant : No. 2957 EDA 2024
Appeal from the Judgment of Sentence Entered August 7, 2024
In the Court of Common Pleas of Delaware County Criminal Division at
No(s): CP-23-CR-0005150-2022
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. :
:
:
DEMETRIUS PARKER :
:
Appellant : No. 2958 EDA 2024
Appeal from the Judgment of Sentence Entered August 7, 2024
In the Court of Common Pleas of Delaware County Criminal Division at
No(s): CP-23-CR-0000724-2023
BEFORE: DUBOW, J., NICHOLS, J., and MURRAY, J.
MEMORANDUM BY NICHOLS, J.: FILED NOVEMBER 19, 2026
Appellant Demetrius Parker appeals from the judgments of sentence
imposed after a jury found him guilty of a series of firearm and drug charges. 1
Appellant seeks to vacate the judgment of sentence on the basis of insufficient
____________________________________________
1 At Appellant’s request, this Court consolidated Appellant’s appeals from two
separate trial court dockets. See Order, 3/24/25.
J-A14040-26
evidence and contends that evidence obtained from a search of his home
should have been suppressed. After careful consideration, we affirm.
Under docket number CP-23-CR-5150-2022 (Case 1), Appellant was
charged with possession of firearms prohibited, receiving stolen property, and
possession of a controlled substance with intent to deliver.2 Under docket
number CP-23-CR-724-2023 (Case 2), Appellant was charged with two counts
each of possession of firearms prohibited, conspiracy to possess prohibited
firearms; firearms not to be carried without a license; and illegal sale of
firearms.3 See Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 1-5. The trial court set forth the
factual and procedural history as follows:
On October 6, 2022[,] Appellant [] was arrested and charged in
two cases because 1) Appellant and Co-Defendant Dyshon Lucas
[(Co-Defendant Lucas),] on August 30, 2022[,] sold firearms to
a[] confidential informant at the Jackpot convenience store owned
by Co-Defendant [] Lucas located at 23 Garrett Road, Upper
Darby, Delaware County, Pennsylvania. . . and 2) the execution
[on October 6, 2022] of multiple search warrants for Appellant [],
his home located at 723 Mason Avenue in Drexel Hill, Delaware
County, Pennsylvania, and his red Jeep Cherokee. . .
On November 16, 2022. . .a preliminary hearing was held on
[Case 1] and on December 14, 2022, Appellant [] was arraigned.
On Feb[ruary] 6, 2023[,] in Case [2], a preliminary hearing was
held and on March 15, 2023[,] Appellant [] was arraigned.
* * *
On September 13, 2023[,] the Commonwealth filed a motion to
consolidate the cases; following a hearing, on November 21,
____________________________________________
2 18 Pa.C.S. §§ 6105(a)(1) and 3925(a), respectively.
3 18 Pa.C.S. §§ 6105(a)(1), 903, 1606(a)(1), and 6111(a)(1), respectively.
-2-
J-A14040-26
2023[,] the motion to consolidate was granted. On November 30,
2023[,] Appellant [] filed a motion for reconsideration . . . [and]
consolidation[,] and on January 5, 2024[,] the motion was denied.
On October 12, 2023[,] in Case [1], Appellant [] filed a motion to
suppress the evidence sized on October 6, 2022[,] when police
executed the search warrants. On November 16, 2023[,] a
hearing on the motion was held. On January 11, 2024[,] the
motion to suppress was denied. [Prior to trial, the trial court
bifurcated the charges in Case 2.]
On January 29, 2024[,] Appellant’s [] jury trial commenced.
* * *
[At] trial, the Commonwealth elicited testimony from several
witnesses and presented a voluminous amount of evidence to the
jury[,] including reports, voice recordings, and physical exhibits.
. . . The jury [found that] the Commonwealth proved beyond a
reasonable doubt Appellant [] inter alia engaged in a conspiracy
with Co-Defendant [] Lucas to sell firearms, illegally sold firearms
to a confidential informant, possessed firearms without a license
and is a person prohibited from possessing firearms, received
stolen property (a firearm), [and] possessed methamphetamine
with the intent to deliver.
Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 1-3, 7-8 (footnotes omitted and some formatting
altered). The jury found Appellant guilty of possession of two counts each of
possession of a firearm prohibited and conspiracy to possess a prohibited
firearm. See id. at 3. The trial court imposed an aggregate sentence for both
cases of fifteen to thirty years’ incarceration, to be followed by seven years’
probation. See id. at 5.
Appellant filed post-sentence motions for both Case 1 and Case 2. See
id. at 5. Therein, inter alia, Appellant asked for reconsideration of the motion
to suppress on the basis that his trial counsel had “provided such obvious
ineffective assistance of counsel” for failing to file a timely motion to suppress.
-3-
J-A14040-26
See Post-Sentence Mot., 8/15/24, at 21. The trial court denied all post-
sentence motions on October 7, 2024. See Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 5.
Appellant filed a timely notice of appeal and both Appellant and the trial
court complied with Pa.R.A.P. 1925.
Appellant presents two issues for our review:
1. Whether the Commonwealth presented sufficient evidence to
sustain convictions for receiving stolen property and the
firearm-related conspiracy charges where it offered no
evidence that [Appellant] knew or believed that a firearm was
stolen and failed to prove any agreement between [Appellant]
and another person beyond a mere buyer-seller relationship.
2. Whether the trial court erred in denying [Appellant]’s motion
to suppress where the search warrant for his residence lacked
probable cause, was overbroad, relied on stale information,
and failed to establish a nexus between the alleged criminal
activity and the home; and whether, if trial counsel failed to
preserve this claim, the error constituted apparent and
extraordinary ineffectiveness warranting review under
Commonwealth v. Holmes [,79 A.3d 562 (Pa. 2013)].
Appellant’s Brief at 5 (some formatting altered).
As a preliminary matter, we note that Appellant raises three claims, not
two, as the allegation of ineffective assistance of trial counsel is an issue the
Court must analyze separately from the sufficiency of the evidence and
whether evidence should be suppressed.
Sufficiency of Evidence
In his first claim, Appellant argues that the Commonwealth introduced
insufficient evidence to establish that he received stolen property or conspired
with Co-Defendant Lucas to illegally sell firearms. See Appellant’s Brief at 22-
25. Because the Commonwealth “introduced only hearsay testimony that one
-4-
J-A14040-26
firearm was reported stolen” and “presented no ownership or non-permission
evidence and no evidence that [Appellant] knew or believed the firearm was
stolen,” Appellant contends, the Commonwealth failed to establish the
sufficient mens rea element of intent required under 18 Pa.C.S. § 3925. Id.
at 23-25.
Specifically, Appellant argues that “the Commonwealth cannot prove the
most basic element of [a receiving stolen property charge]: that the property
belonged to another and was possessed by [Appellant] without the true
owner’s permission.” Id. at 23. Appellant asserts that the only evidence
about the ownership of the firearm was police testimony that the gun had
been reported stolen, and that this fell short of demonstrating the requisite
elements of receiving a stolen firearm. See id. Further, Appellant argues
that the Commonwealth failed to establish that he had “guilty knowledge” that
he possessed a stolen firearm because mere possession of a stolen item is
insufficient to establish or permit an inference of guilty knowledge. See id.
at 24-25 (citing Commonwealth v. Robinson, 128 A.3d 261, 265, 267 (Pa.
Super. 2015) (en banc) (citations omitted)).
The Commonwealth argues that its evidence established that the
firearm recovered was stolen around July 1, 2022, from Arkansas, and that
the testimony of Appellant’s paramour and housemate, Ms. Rhonda
Richardson, regarding her own knowledge of the firearm, supported a
reasonable inference of Appellant’s guilt. See Cmwlth.’s Brief at 17.
-5-
J-A14040-26
In reviewing a sufficiency of the evidence claim, this Court determines
whether the evidence admitted at trial, and the reasonable inferences drawn
therefrom, are sufficient to support each element of the offense when viewed
in a light most favorable to the verdict winner. See Commonwealth v.
Hopkins, 747 A.2d 910, 913 (Pa. Super. 2000). We need only address the
elements of the crime specifically challenged by the appellant. See
Commonwealth v. Cain, 906 A.2d 1242, 1244 (Pa. Super. 2006). This Court
may not reweigh evidence or substitute its judgment for that of the finder of
fact. See Hopkins, 747 A.2d at 913. We evaluate the entire trial record and
all evidence received in the aggregate, “not as fragments isolated from the
totality of the evidence.” Id. at 914 (citations omitted). If the factfinder could
reasonably have determined, based on the evidence adduced, that all
necessary elements of the crime were established, then the evidence will be
deemed sufficient to support the charges. See id.
For the offense of receiving stolen property involving firearms, the
Commonwealth must prove the defendant possessed the firearm with “guilty
knowledge,” meaning the defendant knew or believed the gun was probably
stolen. Commonwealth v. Dunlap, 505 A.2d 255, 257 (Pa. Super. 1985),
(citations omitted). Mere possession of a stolen firearm is insufficient, on its
own, to establish the mens rea element of intent. Commonwealth v.
Robinson, 128 A.3d 261, 268 (Pa. Super. 2015) (en banc). Instead, the
Commonwealth must introduce additional evidence—whether direct or
-6-
J-A14040-26
circumstantial—to show the defendant knew or had reason to believe the gun
was stolen. See id.
A person is guilty of receiving stolen property if that person intentionally
received, retained, or disposed of movable property of another, knowing that
it has been stolen, or believing it has likely been stolen. See Commonwealth
v. Riley, 302 A.3d 112, 115-16 (Pa. Super. 2023). The crime has three
elements: 1) intentionally taking possession of another person’s movable
property, 2) knowing or believing it has been stolen, and 3) an intent to
deprive the rightful owner of their property permanently. See id.; see also
Robinson, 128 A.3d at 265.
Circumstantial evidence of guilty knowledge as contemplated in the
receiving stolen property offense may include, inter alia, “the place or manner
of possession . . .the defendant’s conduct or statements at the time of arrest
. . . a false explanation for the possession . . . or any other evidence connecting
the defendant to the crime.” Id. at 268 (citations omitted). Courts may also
consider whether a defendant was prohibited from possessing firearms in
reviewing for guilty intent. See Commonwealth v. Arias, 286 A.3d 341,
351 (Pa. Super. 2022). Furthermore, the guilty knowledge element of this
offense, “can be shown entirely through circumstantial evidence. While it is
clear that mere possession without more is insufficient to show that the
defendant knew or should have known that the property was stolen, other
facts can make the inference of guilty knowledge reasonable, even
-7-
J-A14040-26
compelling.” Commonwealth v. Carson, 592 A.2d 1318, 1321 (Pa. Super.
1991) (emphasis added).
Here, the trial court noted that “[t]he jury heard and saw evidence
demonstrating from whom [the firearm] was stolen and when it was reported
stolen . . . [and] how the firearm was stored, concealed[,] and hidden in a
backpack in a closet in Appellant []’s bedroom.” Trial Ct. Op, 1/22/25, at 29-
30; see also N.T., Trial, 1/31/24, at 101-03. The trial court concluded that
the Commonwealth’s evidence demonstrated Appellant, at minimum, should
have known, or actually did know, the firearm was stolen. Trial Ct. Op,
1/22/25, at 28-29. Thus, the evidence, viewed in the aggregate, “was
sufficient for the jury” to conclude that the Commonwealth had proved,
beyond a reasonable doubt, that Appellant had guilty knowledge and, further,
was guilty of receiving stolen property. Id.
The firearm recovered from Appellant’s closet was recorded as stolen in
the National Crime Information Center (NCIC) database, meaning it could not
be legally transferred between individuals. See N.T., Trial, 1/31/25, at 9.
Consequently, this evidence established that Appellant was not the rightful
owner of the firearm recovered from his closet during the search of his home.
Further, Ms. Richardson testified she had a license to carry, a safe inside which
to store her firearm, and that her own gun, a Taurus 9-millimeter pistol, was
legally purchased and in her purse at the time of the search warrant execution
because she was planning on bringing it out with her that day. See N.T.,
Trial, 1/31/24, at 102; see also Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 12. She disavowed
-8-
J-A14040-26
any knowledge or ownership of the gun stored in the backpack inside the
closet. See N.T., Trial, 1/31/24, at 104.
While Appellant relies on Robinson, we note that this authority is
distinguishable from the facts here for a significant reason: in Robinson, the
Commonwealth presented no evidence that would support a guilty knowledge
inference, other than the mere possession of a stolen firearm. See Robinson,
128 A.3d 261, 269. Here, the Commonwealth relied on both the firearm’s
stolen status and Ms. Richardson’s testimony, in addition to Appellant’s
possession or constructive possessive of the firearm. Further, a factfinder
may consider a defendant’s status as a person prohibited from possessing
firearms as a factor supporting that the defendant knew, or had reason to
believe, that the firearm was stolen. See 18 Pa.C.S. § 3925(a); see also
Commonwealth v. Bowens, 265 A.3d 730, 744 (Pa. Super. 2021).
In sum, we discern no error in the trial court’s finding that the evidence
supported the jury’s determination that the Commonwealth had proffered
sufficient evidence establishing the requisite guilty knowledge mens rea. As
noted, our review of a sufficiency of evidence claim requires us to examine
the “totality of the circumstances” to determine whether the trier of fact could
have found each element of the offense was proved beyond a reasonable
doubt. See id; see also Hopkins, 747 A.2d at 913.
Here, the Commonwealth’s evidence demonstrated the gun was stolen
and the two adults sharing the searched bedroom both denied knowledge of
the gun’s existence. Ms. Richardson’s testimony described her own typical
-9-
J-A14040-26
practice in storing her separate, legally-purchased firearm in her safe. As
noted, circumstantial evidence, including “any other evidence connecting
defendant to the crime” is permissible to establish guilty knowledge. See
Robinson, 128 A.3d at 268. The jury was free to determine that Ms.
Richardson’s testimony supported the inference that the gun and contraband
were not hers; the extent to which this inference connected Appellant, instead,
to the stashed firearm and contraband was, then, up to the jury to consider.
See id.
The jury was also free to deduce, if the gun was in his possession or
constructive possession, that Appellant—a person prohibited from controlling
a firearm—had the requisite guilty knowledge. See 18 Pa.C.S. § 3925(a);
see also Bowens, 265 A.3d at 746 (finding it could be reasonably inferred
that an appellant, as a person prohibited from possessing a firearm, “was
unable to obtain any firearm legally, and would have to resort to illegitimate
means and product streams to procure a firearm”) (citations omitted)).
Accordingly, as a person prohibited, there is no way for Appellant to have
obtained a gun legally. It was, therefore, reasonable for the jury here to
conclude that Appellant had guilty knowledge regarding the gun’s origin or
status. See id.
Because the jury could reasonably have found all necessary elements of
the crime of receiving a stolen firearm, we find that the record reflects that
the Commonwealth had proffered sufficient evidence for this charge, and we
- 10 -
J-A14040-26
affirm the conviction. See Hopkins, 747 A.2d at 913-14; see also Dunlap,
505 A.2d at 245; Robinson, 128 A.3d at 265; Riley, 302 A.3d at 115-16.
We note that, while Appellant refers primarily to the August 22, 2024
firearm sale in his argument that the Commonwealth failed to prove the
elements of a receiving stolen property charge, he also states the conspiracy
charges were not supported by sufficient evidence for the same reasons—
namely because, he alleges, there is a lack of evidence as to shared criminal
intent between him and any other party. See Appellant’s Brief at 27-35.
As for the contraband police discovered during the August 30, 2024
search warrant execution, because the search warrant did not cover drugs,
the officers “immediately stopped the search” upon finding methamphetamine
in the basement. See Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 21; see also N.T., Trial,
1/31/24 at 27, where Officer John News of the Upper Darby Police Department
testified, “So when I observed what I believed to be methamphetamine
through my training experience, obviously[,] I know it’s an illegal substance,
so at that point[,] we have to stop the search. We can’t seize that at that
time because it’s not on the search warrant. So we stopped. . .” See also
N.T., Trial, 107, 115 (Ms. Richardson’s testimony, in which she disavows
knowledge and association with the methamphetamine, and denies any
association between the contraband and her children.). Further, Officer News
testified,
If you move the [basement] ceiling tile, there was a black bag that
was above the [] tile. Within that black back, there was a United
States passport, a birth certificate, a social security card. . . all in
- 11 -
J-A14040-26
the name of [] [Appellant] . . . If you remove [a] tabletop [in the
basement] . . . [inside an old wash tub] was a large Ziploc bag,
which contained a hard crystal like substance. There were new
and unused packaging. There were three digital scales[,] and all
contained a residue from a hard crystal [like] substance. And
there was a metal sifter.
N.T., Trial, 1/31/24, at 26.
The trial court determined the Commonwealth presented sufficient
evidence from which the jury could reasonably conclude the contraband was
Appellant’s:
. . . [T]he jury heard evidence the controlled substance [] was
found in the basement. . . the Commonwealth presented evidence
of a ‘go bag’ [] found concealed in the [basement] ceiling . . .
containing identification, important documents, money . . . the
Commonwealth presented evidence the other people, including []
Richardson and the five children, in the residence[,] also had
access to the basement. The jury was free to accept as fact that
Appellant [] possessed the methamphetamine and having all of
this testimony and evidence, the jury believed Appellant []
possessed the methamphetamine. . .
Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25 at 39-40.
Challenging the sufficiency of the evidence for the conspiracy
convictions, Appellant contends that the Commonwealth failed to prove an
agreement between Appellant and any other individual to commit a firearm
offense or drug transaction, a necessary element of a conspiracy offense. See
Appellant’s Brief at 33.
The Commonwealth, in response, notes the evidence that Appellant and
Co-Defendant Lucas associated prior to the sale of the firearm, during the
planning of the time and location of the sale, and during the sale itself. See
- 12 -
J-A14040-26
Cmwlth.’s Brief at 26-27. Appellant “both brought the firearms to the sale
and collected the money from the sale.” Id. at 27.
In evaluating a sufficiency of the evidence claim pertaining to a
conspiracy charge, we note that a conspiracy offense is defined as follows:
(a) Definition of conspiracy.--A person is guilty of conspiracy
with another person or persons to commit a crime if with the intent
of promoting or facilitating its commission he:
(1) agrees with such other person or persons that they or one or
more of them will engage in conduct which constitutes such crime
or an attempt or solicitation to commit such crime; or
(2) agrees to aid such other person or persons in the planning or
commission of such crime or of an attempt or solicitation to
commit such crime.
18 Pa.C.S. § 903(a).
To sustain a conviction for criminal conspiracy, the Commonwealth must
establish the defendant entered into an agreement with another person to
commit or aid in an unlawful act, that the parties had a shared criminal intent,
and that an overt act was done in furtherance of the conspiracy. See
Commonwealth v. Wellman, 344 A.3d 13, 19 (Pa. Super. 2025). The
“essence” of a criminal conspiracy—that is, what distinguishes this crime from
accomplice liability—is the agreement made between the co-conspirators.
Id., citing Commonwealth v. Murphy, 844 A.2d 1228, 1238 (Pa. 2004). It
is essential that co-conspirators have a shared criminal intent. See id.
Here, the trial court reasoned that:
Appellant [] was neither charged nor convicted of conspiracy with
[] Richardson or the confidential informant; he was charged and
- 13 -
J-A14040-26
convicted of conspiring with Co-Defendant [] Lucas to illegally
possess and sell firearms.
* * *
Appellant [] suggests the evidence shows Lucas merely acted as
a buyer’s agent and not a conspirator. . . . [However,] Lucas pled
guilty to [two] counts conspiracy to the sales of firearms and [two]
counts of conspiracy to possession of firearms prohibited. . . . The
evidence demonstrated [that Appellant and Co-Defendant Lucas]
together they coordinated the transaction, they met by design[,]
and plan[ned] and scheduled their meeting. . .
They were cousins, and the reason for the encounter was for the
confidential informant to purchase the Glock and the AR15 style
rifle. These facts wove a web of evidence linking Appellant [] and
Co-[D]efendant [] Lucas in the conspiracy, and the evidence
proved beyond a reasonable doubt the existence of an agreement
between co-[d]efendant [] and Appellant [], and shared a criminal
intent – the “sine qua non” – to illegally possess and sell the
firearms.
Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 31, 34-36 (some formatting altered).
The trial court also noted that, after Appellant arrived at Jackpot, he
parked where Co-Defendant Lucas told him to park, talked with Lucas, and
accepted money the confidential informant had given Lucas for the firearm.
See id. at 35. As the trial court states, the entire reason for this meeting was
for the confidential informant to purchase the Glock and AR15 style rifle. See
id. at 36. Thus, the trial court concludes, it was apparent there was a shared
criminal intent, as required by statute. See id. Further,
[T]here were several overt acts made in furtherance of the
conspiracy.” Id. For example, the trial court notes Co-Defendant
[] Lucas arranging and confirming the sale with Appellant []; the
nonverbal communication between them outside of the Jackpot
store, the verbal communication between them when the
confidential informant and Co-Defendant [] Lucas approached
- 14 -
J-A14040-26
Appellant [], [and] the transfer of the money from [] Lucas to
Appellant[.]
Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 36.
After our review of the record, we agree that the jury reasonably
concluded, based on the trial record, that the Commonwealth presented
sufficient evidence to sustain all elements of a conspiracy charge. See
Wellman, 344 A.3d 13, 18. Appellant’s argument as to insufficiency of
evidence linking Appellant to the methamphetamine and contraband lacks
merit for the same reason as above: the jury heard testimony from Richardson
as well as law enforcement officers and was free to determine whether this
evidence supported an inference of Appellant’s guilt. See Carson 592 A.2d
at 1321-22. While Appellant argues he was merely present and associated
with the proposed unlawful act, the jury was free to reasonably conclude that
there was evidence showing the elements of conspiracy—including shared
criminal intent—between Appellant and Co-Defendant Lucas. See Appellant’s
Brief at 25-26; see also 18 Pa.C.S. § 903(a); Murphy, 844 A.2d at 1238.
Suppression
In Appellant’s suppression claim, he argues that the search warrant was
“unsupported by probable cause, was facially overbroad, relied on stale
information, and failed to establish the constitutionally required nexus
between the alleged street-level transaction and the residence.” Appellant’s
Brief at 36.
The Commonwealth urges that we find Appellant’s suppression
argument waived because he failed to file a motion to suppress until almost
- 15 -
J-A14040-26
eleven months after his arraignment and nine months after receiving
discovery. See Commonwealth’s Brief at 27.
Pennsylvania Rule of Criminal Procedure 579(A) requires an omnibus
pretrial motion to be filed and served within 30 days after arraignment. The
exceptions to this timely filing requirement are when an opportunity to file
earlier did not exist, where the defendant or defense attorney was not aware
of the grounds for the motion, or when the time for filing had been extended
by the court, for cause, shown under Rule 579. See Pa.R.Crim.P. 579. Under
Rule of Criminal Procedure 581(B), unless the opportunity did not previously
exist or the interests of justice require otherwise, a suppression motion must
be contained in the omnibus pretrial motion. See Pa.R.Crim.P. 581(B). If a
motion to suppress is not timely filed, the Court shall deem the issue of
suppression of such evidence waived. See id. (providing that “[i]f timely
motion is not made hereunder, the issue of suppression of such evidence shall
be deemed to be waived”).
Here, the trial court states,
This court considered Pa.R.Crim.P 579[,] requiring the omnibus
motion be filed within 30 days following arraignment. This court
recognized an approximate [ten] month time period is on its face
[in] violat[ion] of the rule but also considered often times the facts
and circumstances concerning suppression issues are not readily
known and may come to light during discovery. . . [However,] the
evidence of the search warrant and its contents were available to
and known by [Appellant] from the inception of this case. . . .
Additionally, there were several court listings for this case[,] and
Appellant [] never raised the issue of suppression[,] nor did [he]
request any extension of time to file the motion. As a result, the
- 16 -
J-A14040-26
reason this court denied the motion was Appellant’s [] inexcusable
Rule 579 violation.
Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 44.4
After our review of the record, we find none of the above-mentioned
exceptions in Rule 581(B) apply. Accordingly, Appellant has waived his
suppression argument. See Pa.R.Crim P. 579, 581.
Ineffective Assistance under Holmes
Finally, Appellant contends it is “obvious,” based on the record, that the
defense’s trial counsel “made errors” in his case, so, to the extent the trial
court deemed the suppression claim waived based on trial counsel’s alleged
failures, this case presents precisely the type of exceptional circumstances
contemplated in Commonwealth v. Holmes. See Commonwealth v.
Holmes, 79 A.3d 562 (Pa. 2013); see Appellant’s Brief at 59-60.
While ineffective assistance claims are generally deferred until collateral
review, our Supreme Court has noted that “there may be extraordinary
circumstances where a discrete claim (or claims) of trial counsel
ineffectiveness is apparent from the record and meritorious to the extent that
immediate consideration best serves the interests of justice.” Holmes, 79
A.3d at 563-64. While the trial court retains discretion to address
____________________________________________
4 We note the trial court, “in an abundance of caution,” reviewed Appellant’s
suppression motion despite finding it waived. See Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at
44. The trial court found Appellant’s claims that the search warrant was
overbroad, stale, and lacking a nexus between the residence and the alleged
criminal activity all lacked merit. See id. Because we determine that
Appellant’s suppression motion was waived, we need not address the merits
of this claim.
- 17 -
J-A14040-26
ineffectiveness claims on post-sentence motions, “the presumption weighs
heavily in favor of deferring such claims to collateral review.”
Commonwealth v. Knox, 165 A.3d 925, 928 (Pa. Super. 2017). The
Holmes Court delineated two exceptions possibly justifying trial stage
ineffective assistance claims. See Holmes, 79 A.3d at 563-64. Here,
Appellant concedes the second exception, which requires a PCRA waiver, does
not apply to his case; he argues only that the first exception—which holds that
ineffective assistance must be both “apparent” and “meritorious”—must be
considered by this Court. See Appellant’s Brief at 56. Our Supreme Court
subsequently added a third exception, which requires the trial court to address
claims challenging trial counsel’s performance where the defendant is
statutorily precluded from obtaining later PCRA review. See Commonwealth
v. Watson, 310 A.3d 307, 311 (Pa. Super. 2024). This third exception does
not apply to the instant case.
Pursuant to Holmes, Appellant argues that his trial counsel made such
egregious errors—most notably failing to file a timely suppression motion—
that counsel’s ineffective assistance was plain from the record and, therefore,
the judgment must be vacated and the matter remanded for a new trial. See
Appellant’s Brief at 55-56.
The extraordinary circumstances contemplated in the first exception
recognized in Holmes are those where “counsel’s ineffectiveness is so blatant
and ‘so shocking to the judicial conscience’ that there is no need for a hearing
and the court is compelled to grant relief.” Commonwealth v. James, 297
- 18 -
J-A14040-26
A.3d 755, 761 (Pa. Super. 2023) (citations omitted). Whether an
ineffectiveness claim was “meritorious and apparent from the record” as
recognized in Holmes should be limited “to the rarest of circumstances,” as,
“otherwise, the exception would swallow the general rule of deferring
ineffectiveness claims to collateral review.” Commonwealth v. Alford, 1052
WDA 2020, 2021 WL 2907814 at *3 (Pa. Super. filed July 9, 2021)
(unpublished mem.).5
In considering whether Appellant has established the first exception
recognized in Holmes, this Court has held that a claim “is not apparent from
the record if the trial court needs to schedule an evidentiary hearing to
determine the merits of the claim.” Commonwealth v. Watson, 310 A.3d
307, 311 (Pa. Super. 2024) (citation omitted).
Here, the trial court, despite finding waiver of Appellant’s motion to
suppress because it was untimely filed, held a hearing on the merits of the
claim “out of an abundance of caution.” See Trial Ct. Op., 1/22/25, at 44.
After hearing the claim, the trial court found that the search warrant was
lawful and therefore Appellant’s suppression motion lacked merit. See id.
Accordingly, even if Appellant’s trial counsel had rendered ineffective
assistance by failing to file a timely motion to suppress, the record fails to
reflect that such a timely-filed suppression motion would have been granted.
Therefore, on this record, we conclude that a meritorious argument regarding
____________________________________________
5 We may cite to unpublished memorandum decisions of the Superior Court
filed after May 1, 2019, for their persuasive value. See Pa.R.A.P. 126(b).
- 19 -
J-A14040-26
the ineffectiveness of Appellant’s trial counsel was not so apparent from the
record as to establish Appellant’s right to direct review of the claim pursuant
to the first exception in Holmes. See Watson, 310 A.3d at 311; see
Holmes, 79 A.3d at 563-64.
Finding no merit to any of Appellant’s claims, we affirm the judgments
of sentence.
Judgments of sentence affirmed. Jurisdiction relinquished.
Date: 11/19/2026
- 20 -