Com. v. King, D.
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket364 WDA 2026
JudgeBowes
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
J-A22011-26
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. :
:
:
DAVID M. KING :
: No. 364 WDA 2026
Appellant :
Appeal from the Order Entered December 10, 2025
In the Court of Common Pleas of Cambria County
Criminal Division at No(s): CP-11-CR-0000233-2015
BEFORE: BOWES, J., OLSON, J., and MURRAY, J.
MEMORANDUM BY BOWES, J.: FILED: November 16, 2026
David M. King appeals pro se from the order dismissing his “Motion to
Vacate Sentence,” concluding that he had exhausted his direct appeal and
Post Conviction Relief Act (“PCRA”) rights. We affirm, albeit on a different
basis.1
Appellant is serving a sentence of fifty-five to 110 years of imprisonment
that was imposed after a jury convicted him of more than fifty offenses related
to his decade-long sexual abuse of his minor child. Neither his direct appeal
nor his first, timely PCRA petition garnered him any relief. See
Commonwealth v. King, 190 A.3d 687, 2018 WL 1631584 (Pa.Super. 2018)
(unpublished memorandum), appeal denied, 195 A.3d 847 (Pa. 2018);
____________________________________________
1 See, e.g., Commonwealth v. Parker, 249 A.3d 590, 595 (Pa.Super. 2021)
(“[T]his Court may affirm a PCRA court’s order on any legal basis.”).
J-A22011-26
Commonwealth v. King, 241 A.3d 374, 2020 WL 5951388 (Pa.Super. 2020)
(non-precedential decision), appeal denied, 252 A.3d 1074 (Pa. 2021).
On November 3, 2025, the clerk of courts docketed the motion at issue
in this appeal, which Appellant dated October 30, 2025.2 Appellant insisted
at the outset of his filing that it was not a PCRA petition. Instead, he cited as
his bases for relief 42 Pa.C.S. § 5505 (providing the general rule that a court
has thirty days to modify or rescind an order if no appeal is taken), and
Commonwealth v. Walters, 814 A.2d 253, 256 (Pa.Super. 2002) (“[W]here
a showing of fraud or another circumstance so grave or compelling as to
constitute extraordinary causes justifying intervention by the court, then a
court may open or vacate its order after the [thirty]-day period [established
by § 5505] has expired.” (cleaned up)). Substantively, he contended that his
counsel and the prosecutor committed a fraud upon the court by proceeding
with his case without either holding a formal arraignment in accordance with
Pa.R.Crim.P. 571(A)-(C) or obtaining his signature on a written waiver
pursuant to Rule 571(D).
The Honorable Tamara R. Bernstein entered an order scheduling a video
hearing on the motion. After she recognized that she had been involved in
____________________________________________
2 Although the few-day discrepancy has no impact on this appeal, we accept
October 30, 2025 as the filing date pursuant to the prisoner mailbox rule. See
Pa.R.A.P. 121(f) (“A pro se filing submitted by a person incarcerated in a
correctional facility is deemed filed as of the date of the prison postmark or
the date the filing was delivered to the prison authorities for purposes of
mailing . . . .”).
-2-
J-A22011-26
Appellant’s prosecution, the case was reassigned to the Honorable Michael A.
Carbonara. Judge Carbonara canceled the hearing and entered an order
providing, in pertinent part:
[U]pon consideration of [Appellant]’s Motion to Vacate Sentence,
and the court determining that [Appellant]’s direct appeal rights
and PCRA rights have been exhausted to date, and [Appellant]
specifically advising that his Motion to Vacate Sentence is not filed
pursuant to the [PCRA], it is hereby ordered and decreed that the
motion is denied without hearing.
Order, 12/10/25 (cleaned up).
This timely appeal followed.3 The court did not order Appellant to file a
Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) statement of errors complained of on appeal, and he filed
none. The court pointed us to the text of its December 10, 2025 order in
satisfaction of its Rule 1925(a) obligations. Appellant’s brief does not contain
a statement of questions involved, but we readily ascertain that he asks us to
consider whether the court erred in holding that he was not entitled to relief
pursuant to § 5505 and Walters.
We begin with a review of the applicable legal principles. Our General
Assembly enacted the PCRA to provide “the sole means of obtaining collateral
relief[,] . . . encompass[ing] all other common law and statutory remedies for
the same purpose that exist[.]” 42 Pa.C.S. § 9542. Stated differently, “the
PCRA subsumes all forms of collateral relief . . . to the extent a remedy is
____________________________________________
3 The notice of appeal was not docketed until January 20, 2026, but we deem
it to have been filed on its post-marked date of January 9, 2026, pursuant to
Pa.R.A.P. 121(f).
-3-
J-A22011-26
available under such enactment.” Commonwealth v. West, 938 A.2d 1034,
1043 (Pa. 2007). The PCRA offers relief when a petitioner establishes that his
conviction resulted from, inter alia, a constitutional violation, ineffective
assistance of counsel, or the unavailability of subsequently discovered
exculpatory evidence. See 42 Pa.C.S. § 9543(a)(2).
A claim does not fall outside the domain of the PCRA “[s]imply because
the merits of the PCRA petition [at issue] cannot be considered due to previous
litigation, waiver, or an untimely filing[.]” Commonwealth v. Kutnyak, 781
A.2d 1259, 1261 (Pa.Super. 2001). Instead, a non-PCRA collateral proceeding
may be entertained only if the claims “fall outside the eligibility parameters of
the PCRA[.]” Commonwealth v. Masker, 34 A.3d 841, 850 (Pa.Super.
2011) (en banc).
Therefore, “issues that are cognizable under the PCRA must be raised in
a timely PCRA petition and cannot be raised in a habeas corpus petition or
other self-styled petition outside of the PCRA.” Commonwealth v. Mucci,
327 A.3d 1223, 1234 (Pa.Super. 2024) (cleaned up). To be timely, a PCRA
petition must be filed within one year of the date that the underlying judgment
of sentence became final unless the petitioner pleads and offers to prove one
of the statute’s enumerated timeliness exceptions. See 42 Pa.C.S.
§ 9545(b)(1) (providing exceptions in certain instances of governmental
interference, newly-discovered facts, and newly-recognized constitutional
rights). “[I]f [a PCRA] petition is untimely, courts lack jurisdiction over the
-4-
J-A22011-26
petition and cannot grant relief.” Commonwealth v. Fantauzzi, 275 A.3d
986, 994 (Pa.Super. 2022).
As noted, Appellant’s motion alleged that proceeding with his
prosecution in the absence of a formal arraignment or valid waiver thereof
amounted to a fraud that is correctable outside the confines of the PCRA. He
argues that this defect is a structural error that negated the trial court’s
subject matter jurisdiction, and, as such, it is subject to challenge at any time.
See Appellant’s brief at 5-6 (pagination supplied); Appellant’s reply brief at
2-3 (pagination supplied).
The Commonwealth, on the other hand, argues that Appellant’s motion
was a second, untimely PCRA petition. It construes Appellant’s fraud claim as
sounding in ineffective assistance of counsel, which is cognizable through the
PCRA. See Commonwealth’s brief at 5-8. The Commonwealth further
observes: “Simply stating that the motion is not a PCRA petition does not
make it so.” Id. at 9.
We agree that the issues raised by Appellant fall within the ambit of the
PCRA, regardless of Appellant’s protestations otherwise. The purpose of
arraignment, which is governed by Rule 571, “is to fix the identity of the
accused, to inform him of the nature of the charges against him and to give
him the opportunity of informing the court of his plea thereto.”
Commonwealth v. Leland, 204 A.3d 461, 465–66 (Pa.Super. 2019)
(cleaned up). As Appellant recognizes in his brief, the right to arraignment is
-5-
J-A22011-26
a matter of due process as recognized in the federal and Pennsylvania
constitutions. See Appellant’s brief at 7 (pagination supplied).
What Appellant fails to acknowledge is that the absence of an
arraignment is not a structural error with an automatic right to relief. Instead,
“defects in an arraignment do not constitute reversible due process error
unless they prejudice the defendant’s rights.” Leland, 204 A.3d at 466
(citing, inter alia, Garland v. Washington, 232 U.S. 642 (1914)).
Consequently, Appellant presents us not with an issue of fraud or lack of
subject matter jurisdiction, but a constitutional due process challenge that is
unquestionably cognizable by the PCRA. See 42 Pa.C.S. § 9543(a)(2)(i). As
indicated supra, the PCRA provides the only means for raising a constitutional
violation after a judgment of sentence has become final.4
Hence, Appellant’s attempt to utilize a § 5505 procedure to avoid the
time restrictions of the PCRA is unavailing. See Commonwealth v. Arnold,
256 A.3d 15, 2021 WL 1830367, at *6 (Pa.Super. 2021) (non-precedential
decision) (“To the extent Appellant contends [§] 5505 provides an avenue for
relief, we disagree. Appellant’s claim falls under the PCRA. Thus, he is
required to prove the applicability of one of the time-for-filing exceptions in
order to obtain relief pursuant to a facially untimely petition.”). Rather than
____________________________________________
4 To the extent that Appellant’s issue implicates the effectiveness of his
counsel in failing to secure his arraignment-related rights, that claim is, as
suggested by the Commonwealth, also subject to remedy through the PCRA.
See 42 Pa.C.S. § 9543(a)(2)(ii).
-6-
J-A22011-26
accept Appellant’s representation that his filing was not a PCRA petition, the
court should have treated it as such and determined whether it had jurisdiction
under that statute to consider its merits. Nevertheless, since we may review
that jurisdictional question sua sponte, we need not remand to the PCRA court
for it to conduct that analysis in the first instance. See, e.g.,
Commonwealth v. Giles, 357 A.3d 555, 559 (Pa.Super. 2026).
Appellant’s judgment of sentence became final in January 2019 when
the time for filing a writ of certiorari in the Supreme Court of the United States
expired. Accepting the date affixed to it as its date of filing, the instant petition
was filed in late October 2025, rendering it facially untimely. Appellant was
aware of the absence of an arraignment since the time of his trial, and further
complained about it in a 2020 letter to prior PCRA counsel. See Motion to
Vacate, 10/30/25, at Exhibit C. Therefore, it is not a newly-discovered fact.
Moreover, Appellant neither offers an indication that the government
interfered with his ability to present this claim earlier, nor invokes a newly-
recognized constitutional right. As such, it is apparent from the certified
record that no exception to the PCRA’s one-year time bar was available to
establish the PCRA court’s jurisdiction to entertain the merits of the claim, and
it was properly dismissed for that reason.
In sum, although the PCRA court failed to apply the proper legal analysis
in rejecting Appellant’s Motion to Vacate Sentence, it reached the proper
result. Consequently, we have no cause to disturb its order.
-7-
J-A22011-26
Order affirmed.
DATE: 11/16/2026
-8-