Com. v. Fehr, R.
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket1092 WDA 2025
JudgePanella
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
J-A18012-26
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. :
:
:
RICHARD J. FEHIR, JR. :
:
Appellant : No. 1092 WDA 2025
Appeal from the PCRA Order Entered August 6, 2025
In the Court of Common Pleas of Beaver County
Criminal Division at No(s): CP-04-CR-0000434-2016
BEFORE: PANELLA, P.J.E., KING, J., and LANE, J.
MEMORANDUM BY PANELLA, P.J.E.: FILED: NOVEMBER 16, 2026
Richard J. Fehir, Jr. appeals pro se from the order of the Court of
Common Pleas of Beaver County denying his petition filed pursuant to the Post
Conviction Relief Act (“PCRA”), 42 Pa.C.S.A. §§ 9541-9546. Fehir challenges
the PCRA court’s denial of his claims of ineffective assistance of trial counsel
and direct appeal counsel. Additionally, for the first time on appeal, Fehir
raises new claims of his PCRA counsel’s ineffectiveness pursuant to
Commonwealth v. Bradley, 261 A.3d 381 (Pa. 2021).1
After careful review, we affirm the PCRA court’s order denying Fehir’s
PCRA petition. However, we are constrained to remand to the PCRA court for
____________________________________________
1 In Bradley, our Supreme Court held that “a PCRA petitioner may, after a
PCRA court denies relief, and after obtaining new counsel or acting pro se,
raise claims of PCRA counsel’s ineffectiveness at the first opportunity to do so,
even if on appeal.” Bradley, 261 A.3d at 401.
J-A18012-26
proceedings it deems necessary for it to consider in the first instance one of
Fehir’s Bradley claims raised on appeal. The remand is due to no fault of the
PCRA Court because, as stated above, Fehir raised this claim for the first time
on appeal. Fehir’s other six Bradley claims are denied.
On January 19, 2018, Fehir was found guilty of twenty-three counts of
sex offenses related to the sexual abuse of his stepdaughter (“Victim”) over a
ten-year period starting in 1998 when she was around the age of five. The
typical pattern of abuse involved Fehir putting his mouth on Victim’s vagina
and rubbing his penis on her vagina. When Fehir would put his mouth on her
vagina there was penetration with his tongue and on a few occasions, one of
which when she was six or seven years old, he penetrated her vagina with his
penis.
At trial, Victim, Detective Anthony McClure, Detective Dawn Shane, K.J.,
and J.W. testified. Detective McClure, who in November 2015 was the captain
of detectives in the Beaver County District Attorney’s Office, testified
regarding the procedure for obtaining the wiretap authorization for the
recorded in person conversation between Victim and Fehir. He testified that
they initially intended to perform a “pretext call” and filed the necessary
paperwork to get that accomplished. See N.T., 1/18/18, at 377. When that
never came to fruition, they planned on performing an in-person consensual
wiretap and, after submitting the necessary paperwork to a trial judge,
obtained approval for it. See id. at 378. Thereafter, on November 7, 2015,
-2-
J-A18012-26
Detective McClure participated in the recording of a conversation between
Victim and Fehir that took place in Fehir’s parked vehicle.2 See id. at 379.
Trial counsel objected to Detective Shane testifying to why in her
“professional experience” sexual assault victims delay reporting. See N.T.,
1/18/2018, at 395, 400. The trial court permitted Detective Shane to testify
as to her own experience for how often sexual assault victims delay reporting.
See id. at 397, 400. Detective Shane testified to the fact that in her
experience sexual assault victims delay reporting but did not offer any
testimony explaining the reasons for why that occurs.3 See id. at 397-401.
____________________________________________
2 Detective Shane also participated in the recording of the conversation
between Victim and Fehir.
3 Specifically, Detective Shane testified:
Q. Detective Shane, in your years of experience as a police
enforcement officer and specifically as a . . . detective
investigating sexual assault cases, are you familiar with delayed
reporting?
A. Yes.
Q. And in your experience is that something that happens often
when you are working these cases?
A. Yes.
Q. How often would you say it occurs?
A. Most, most of the cases that I get it’s a delayed report. It’s very
rare that I get a report immediately.
(Footnote Continued Next Page)
-3-
J-A18012-26
K.J., Victim’s cousin, and J.W., Victim’s friend, testified about similar
incidents of abuse that happened to them at Fehir’s house when they were
young teenagers.4 K.J. testified that on one occasion Fehir entered the
bedroom in which she was sleeping and attempted to remove her pants. See
N.T., 1/18/18, at 421. J.W. testified to more than one incident in which Fehir
stuck his hand down her pants and laid on top of her with an erect penis when
she was sleeping. See id. at 461-65. They both also testified about how they
and Victim disclosed the sexual abuse to each other before going to the
police.5 See id. at 424-25, 465-67.
Additionally, portions of a two-hour recorded conversation from
November 2015 between Victim and Fehir, and transcripts of that testimony,
were admitted into evidence. See id. at 490. During the conversation, Fehir
stated “I never thought about you and what I, what I did can do to you[]” and
____________________________________________
Q. Now, in this case when you met with [Victim] did you address
delayed reporting with her?
A. Yes, I did.
N.T., 1/18/18, at 401.
4 K.J. and J.W. are a few years older than Victim.
5 The Commonwealth initially brought charges against Fehir based on K.J. and
J.W.’s allegations, but the charges were nolle prossed.
-4-
J-A18012-26
Victim told him, “it changed my whole life[.]” Id. at 499. Victim testified that
these comments referred to Fehir “raping and molesting” her.6 Id.
Fehir was sentenced to 306 to 612 months of incarceration followed by
three years of probation.7 He filed a post sentence motion which was denied
and this Court affirmed his judgment on sentence. See Commonwealth v.
Fehir, No. 1355 WDA 2018, 2019 WL 6999909 (Pa. Super. filed Dec. 20,
2019) (unpublished memorandum). On direct appeal, he unsuccessfully raised
claims of sufficiency of the evidence and challenged the trial court’s allowance
of the Commonwealth to re-open its case in chief after resting. Fehir did not
seek further review with our Supreme Court. Therefore, Fehir’s judgment of
sentence became final on January 19, 2020. See 42 Pa.C.S.A. ֻ§ 9545(b)(3).
Fehir filed a timely pro se PCRA petition on December 22, 2020. See id.
at § 9545(b)(1). On May 16, 2022, appointed counsel filed a no merit letter
and withdrew from the case. Thereafter, Fehir filed a series of pro se amended
PCRA petitions. Fehir obtained private counsel and, on November 15, 2024,
filed a fourth amended PCRA petition.
____________________________________________
6 In its closing argument, the Commonwealth referred to additional statements
made in the recorded conversation. See N.T., 1/19/18, at 569. Fehir disputes
that those statements were included in the conversation. See Appellant’s
Brief, at 31.1. However, he does not dispute the above quoted statements.
7 For his term of confinement, only the sentences for rape of a child (count
three), 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 3121(c), 240 to 480 months, and involuntary deviate
sexual intercourse (“IDSI”) with a person less than thirteen years old (count
eight), 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 3123(b), 66 to 132 months, were imposed
consecutively.
-5-
J-A18012-26
On May 27, 2025, a hearing was held. At the hearing, the
Commonwealth and defense counsel stipulated that Fehir was entitled to relief
regarding trial counsel and appellate counsel’s failure to raise the statute of
limitations regarding the charge of unlawful contact with a minor (18 Pa.C.S.A.
§ 6318(a)(1)). Trial counsel and appellate counsel testified.8
On August 1, 2025, the PCRA court entered an order vacating Fehir’s
sentence for unlawful contact with a minor, which did not impact his overall
sentence because the sentence for unlawful contact with a minor was imposed
concurrently, and denying his PCRA petition in all other respects. His private
counsel was granted leave to withdraw and Fehir timely appealed pro se. Both
Fehir and the PCRA court complied with Pennsylvania Rule of Appellate
Procedure 1925. See Pa.R.A.P. 1925(a)-(b).
Fehir raises the following issues for our review.
1). Whether PCRA counsel who was “also” Pre-Trial counsel was
ineffective for not (under obligation) immediately advising his
client and the [c]ourt of the conflict with the limits or pitfalls to
“both” representations, due to not being able to reasonably argue
against himself, which has denied a full and fair review of the case
pursuant to the Sixth Amendment[?]
2). Whether PCRA counsel was ineffective for failing to raise his
and Trial counsel’s ineffectiveness, because their failure to compel
the Commonwealth to provide in discovery the wiretap order,
wiretap application and affidavit of probable cause under the
mandatory disclosure provisions of Pa.R.Crim.P. 573(B)(1)(g) and
____________________________________________
8 In addition to his trial counsel, Fehir was represented by two different
attorneys at different stages of his direct appeal. All three testified at the PCRA
hearing. We also note that Fehir’s counsel during the PCRA proceedings
represented him pretrial until Fehir withdrew his guilty plea before trial.
-6-
J-A18012-26
the Wiretapping Act 18 Pa.C.S.[A.] § 5701-5782, has denied
[Fehir] the ability to preserve in a pretrial motion to suppress the
procedural defects establishing probable cause, denying a fair trial
pursuant to the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendment(s)[?]
3). Whether PCRA counsel was ineffective for failing to raise Trial
counsel’s ineffectiveness for not objecting to the admission at trial
of the narrated edited portions of the recorded wiretap audio and
the transcript, because allowing the witness to narrate portions of
this evidence was inadmissible hearsay and edited portions was
misleading and taken out of context, denying a fair trial pursuant
to the Sixth Amendment[?]
4). Whether PCRA counsel was ineffective for failing to raise Trial
counsel’s ineffectiveness for not impeaching at trial the witness
with prior police, wiretap audio, and preliminary hearing
statement[s], because the record supports that if counsel would
have utilized the extensive information it would cast doubt on the
witness’s credibility and reasonable doubt to whether a jury would
convict, denying a fair trial pursuant to the Sixth Amendment[?]
5). Whether PCRA counsel was ineffective for failing to raise Trial
counsel’s ineffectiveness for failing to put on available character
witnesses who were willing to testify, because there was no
strategic reasonable basis to not call these witnesses and absent
their testimony denied a fair trial, pursuant to the Sixth
Amendment[?]
6). Whether PCRA counsel was ineffective for failing to raise Trial
counsel’s ineffectiveness for not objecting to irrelevant picture(s)
being admitted by the Commonwealth and sent out with the jury
during deliberations, because such evidence (adolescent pictures)
had no place in trial and thereby inflamed the jury affecting the
outcome of the trial, pursuant to the Sixth Amendment[?]
7). Whether PCRA counsel was ineffective for failing to raise Trial
counsel’s ineffectiveness for failing to raise the trial court’s error
in not merging both 18 Pa.C.S.[A.] § 3121(c) and 18 Pa.C.S.[A.]
§ 3123(a)(6) under 42 Pa.C.S.[A.] § 9765 requiring merger for
sentencing purposes, because the statutory elements are the
same and the criminal act for each offense is the same making the
sentence illegal, pursuant to the Sixth Amendment[?]
-7-
J-A18012-26
8). Whether the lower court abused its discretion in denying relief
based on Appellate Counsel being ineffective for failing to raise
Trial Counsel’s preserved objection(s) arising from Detective
Dawn Shane’s testimony about [V]ictim’s delayed reporting, when
based on that detectives training, experience, and specialized
knowledge constitutes expert testimony, and whether permitting
such testimony from a lay witness is inconsistent with the plain
language of Pa.R.E. 701 and 702 and Commonwealth v. Jones,
240 A. 3d 881 (Pa. 2020)?
9). Whether the lower court abused its discretion by denying relief
where Trial Counsel was ineffective for failing to object to the jury
being permitted to have during deliberations a printed copy of the
audio “transcript” which was viewed as an admission or
confession, because Pa.R.Crim.P. 646(B)(1) & (2) prohibits the
jury from taking into the jury room a transcript of “any” trial
testimony or written or otherwise recorded confession of [Fehir],
pursuant to the Sixth Amendment[?]
10). Whether the lower court abused its discretion by denying
relief where Trial counsel was ineffective for failing to request a
limiting instruction or object to the Commonwealth’s improper
application of Pa.R.E. 404(b), because there is no “valid” prior
evidence of other crimes or wrongs or other acts and the use of
any opposing witness testimony is clearly hearsay and trial
counsel had no conceivable strategic purpose for defense, denying
a fair trial pursuant to the Sixth Amendment[?]
Appellant’s Brief, at viii-xi (citations omitted).
In issues eight through ten, Fehir asserts that the PCRA court erred by
denying him relief on his claims of ineffective assistance of trial and appellate
counsel. We address these issues first for ease of disposition.
Our standard of review from the denial of a PCRA petition is limited
to examining whether the PCRA court’s determination is supported
by the evidence of record and whether it is free of legal error. The
PCRA court’s credibility determinations, when supported by the
record, are binding on this Court; however, we apply a de novo
standard of review to the PCRA court’s legal conclusions.
-8-
J-A18012-26
Commonwealth v. Miranda, 317 A.3d 1070, 1075 (Pa. Super. 2024)
(brackets and citation omitted).
We presume counsel is effective, and an appellant bears the burden to
prove otherwise. See Commonwealth v. Bennett, 57 A.3d 1185, 1195 (Pa.
2012). To establish a successful ineffective assistance of counsel claim, a
petitioner must establish:
(1) the underlying claim is of arguable merit;
(2) that counsel had no reasonable strategic basis for his or her action
or inaction; and
(3) but for the errors and omissions of counsel, there is a reasonable
probability that the outcome of the proceedings would have been
different.
Commonwealth v. Orlando, 156 A.3d 1274, 1281 (Pa. Super. 2017)
(citation omitted). A failure to satisfy any prong of the test for ineffectiveness
will require rejection of the claim. See Commonwealth v. Solano, 129 A.3d
1156, 1163 (Pa. 2015).
In issue eight, Fehir asserts that the PCRA court erred in denying relief
based on his claim that appellate counsel was ineffective for failing to raise
trial counsel’s preserved objection to Officer Dawn Shane’s testimony. See
Appellant’s Brief, at 25-29. This claim does not merit relief.
At the conclusion of trial, the trial court gave the following instruction
regarding Victim’s delayed report:
The evidence of [Victim’s] delay in making a complaint does not
necessarily make her testimony unreliable, but may remove from
it the assurance of reliability accompanying the prompt complaint
or out[]cry that the victim in cases such as these would ordinarily
be expected to make.
-9-
J-A18012-26
Therefore, the delay in making a complaint should be considered
in evaluating [Victim’s] testimony and deciding whether the acts
occurred at all.
You must not consider [Victim’s] delay in making a complaint as
conclusive evidence that the acts did not occur. Her failure to
complain promptly and the nature of any explanation for that
failure are factors bearing on the believability of her testimony
and must be considered by you in light of all of the evidence in
the case.
N.T., 1/19/18, at 590-91.
The PCRA court explained why the underlying claim lacked arguable
merit.
To begin, it is a well-established legal precedent that counsel
cannot be held to be ineffective for failing to anticipate a change
in law. See Commonwealth v. Duffey, 889 A.2d 56 (Pa. 2005).
In the present case, this Court recognizes that the Supreme Court
case of Commonwealth v. Jones, 240 A.3d 881 (Pa. 2020)
established that previous case law was effectively overruled by 42
Pa.C.S. § 5920 and subsequent Superior Court cases such as
Commonwealth v. Williams, 274 A.3d 722 (Pa. Super. 2022)
clearly establish that a detective or law enforcement officer cannot
provide testimony on the delayed reporting of sexual assault
victims without being properly qualified as an expert.
However, these cases post date the filing of the appeal by some
time. In fact, the Superior Court decision in Commonwealth v.
Jones, No. 1636 WDA 2016, 2018 WL 3598642 (Pa. Super. July
27, 2018) though non-precedential, was issued just a few months
prior to the appeal in this case and seemed to indicate that a
detective could testify about such issues in light of their personal
experience and not need to be qualified as an expert. . . .
As such, it is understandable that [trial counsel] felt as though the
direction and limitation given by this [c]ourt, specifically
narrowing the scope of Officer Dawn Shane’s testimony to her
personal experiences and facts from cases she had worked on,
was sufficient. N.T., 5/27/25, at 14-17. It is also clear why
- 10 -
J-A18012-26
Attorney Quinn, on appeal, did not raise the issue in light of the
case law at the time and his understanding of it. Id. at 86-87.
Given that the Jones decision was not issued until 2020, roughly
two years after the appeal was filed in this case, appellate counsel
cannot be held as ineffective for failing to raise the issue given the
state of the law.
PCRA Court Opinion, 10/27/25, at 12-13 (unpaginated) (record citation format
altered).
We find no error with the PCRA court’s assessment and adopt it as our
own.
Next, Fehir argues that the PCRA court erred in not granting him relief
on his claim that trial counsel was ineffective for failing to either object to, or
ask for an instruction regarding, the jury being allowed to have the transcript
of the recorded conversation between Victim and Fehir in violation of
Pa.R.Crim.P. 646. See Appellant’s Brief, at 30-31. Fehir argues that the
transcript contained a confession which unfairly prejudiced him. See id. The
Commonwealth argues that, although the transcript contains “admissions,” it
does not contain a “confession.” Appellee’s Brief, at 15. Further, the
Commonwealth argues that Fehir is not entitled to relief because failure to
object to a violation of Rule 646 is not per se ineffective assistance of counsel
and trial counsel had a reasonable strategic basis for not objecting. See id. at
14-18.
Pennsylvania Rule of Criminal Procedure 646 prohibits, in pertinent part,
the jury from having “a copy of any written or otherwise recorded confession
- 11 -
J-A18012-26
by the defendant[.]” Pa.R.Crim.P. 646(C)(2). A violation of Rule 646(C) does
not constitute per se ineffective assistance of counsel, and is subject to the
traditional three-prong test for ineffectiveness. See Commonwealth v.
Postie, 200 A.3d 1015, 1030 (Pa. Super. 2018) (en banc).
The PCRA court explained its reasoning for denying Fehir’s claim.
[Trial counsel] clearly outlined his strategic reasonings for his
actions at the PCRA Hearing. See N.T., 5/27/25, at 28-39, 52-55.
[Trial counsel] recognized that the recordings had been properly
admitted at trial as exhibits and that they could be played for the
jury at any point. He also noted that there were statements made
in the recording that were problematic for the defense, stating
that considering the recording and the overall state of the case,
“we had a long road to hoe . . . and I didn’t want to hide those []
statements.” Id. at 38. Instead, [trial counsel’s] strategy was to
attempt to explain and contextualize those statements and utilize
the entirety of the recorded conversation in an attempt to
humanize [Fehir] in the eyes of the jurors. Id. at 28, 29, and 39.
[Trial counsel further explained that the “long” “civilized
conversation” between Fehir and [V]ictim demonstrated “a
comfort level that she had with him[.]” Id. at 29.]
Given the above, this [c]ourt found that trial counsel had a
reasonable basis for the decision to allow the transcript to go back
[with] the jury during deliberations. [Fehir’s] argument fails the
Strickland test. Trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to
object to the transcript going back [with] the jury, given the
overarching strategy.
PCRA Court Opinion, 10/27/25, at 14 (unpaginated) (record citation format
altered).
We agree with the PCRA court. In closing, trial counsel described the
record conversation to the jury as “a lot of catching up, mutual support,
normal conversation from having not seen one another for some time, which
in itself is a little bit strange given the context for which we are dealing with
- 12 -
J-A18012-26
all of this here and what prompts that conversation to occur.” N.T., 1/19/18,
at 538. Trial counsel attempted to have the jury focus on the apparent
emotional connection and level of comfort between Victim and Fehir, which
was demonstrated in the recorded conversation, as a reason to disbelieve that
sexual abuse occurred. Allowing the jury to have the transcript of the recorded
conversations during deliberations is consistent with that strategy. The fact
that the jury was unpersuaded does not render trial counsel’s strategy
unreasonable. Therefore, the PCRA court did not err in denying this claim.
In issue ten, his final claim of error by the PCRA court, Fehir argues that
the PCRA court erred in denying his claim that trial counsel was ineffective by
failing to object to K.J. and J.W.’s testimony. See Appellant’s Brief, at 32-33.
The entirety of his argument is that the testimony was inadmissible because
it did not demonstrate a common scheme, plan or design to be admissible
under Rule 404(b). See id. at 33-34. Fehir does not try to distinguish the facts
of Victim’s allegations from K.J. and J.W.’s allegations but rather states that
the difference between them is that his charges pertaining to K.J. and J.W.
were nolle prossed. See id. He also states in conclusory fashion that “there is
an issue of hearsay.” Id. at 34. Based on these bare assertions and
undeveloped arguments, Fehir has waived this issue.9 See Commonwealth
____________________________________________
9 Additionally, the PCRA court explained:
(Footnote Continued Next Page)
- 13 -
J-A18012-26
v. Caruso, 361 A.3d 588, 602 (Pa. Super. 2026) (finding issue waived for
lack of development).
Fehir’s remaining claims, issues one through seven, assert for the first
time on appeal, pursuant to Bradley, that PCRA counsel was ineffective. Since
this is his first opportunity to do so, he is permitted to raise these claims on
appeal. See Bradley, 261 A.3d at 401. In considering such claims we “have
the ability to grant or deny relief on straightforward claims, as well as the
power to remand to the PCRA court for the development of the record.” Id. at
403. Our Supreme Court has further instructed:
____________________________________________
Here, [Fehir] had two other criminal cases involving sex crimes
against minors which were nolle prossed, the Commonwealth
sought to produce 404(b) testimony by those alleged victims to
show evidence of a common scheme, plan or design where the
crimes are so related that proof of one tends to prove the others
and was admissible as such. The mere fact that the cases did not
result in a conviction did not render them to be not “valid” as
claimed by [Fehir] in his concise statement. As the evidence was
properly admissible[,] [] there was no underlying reason for [trial
counsel] to object. Though unnecessary in light of the above, we
also take specific notice of [trial counsel’s] stated trial strategy
and intention to use the testimony of the alleged other victims to
show collusion and attack the Commonwealth’s attempt to paint
[Fehir] having operat[ed] under a certain modus operandi. N.T.,
5/27/25, at 24-28. For both the reasons that the underlying claim
had no merit and because the trial attorney had a reasonable basis
for allowing the 404(b) testimony into the case, this [c]ourt finds
that [Fehir’s] claim fails the Strickland test.
PCRA Court Opinion, 10/27/25, at 16-17 (unpaginated) (record citation format
altered).
- 14 -
J-A18012-26
In some instances, the record before the appellate court will be
sufficient to allow for disposition of any newly-raised
ineffectiveness claims. However, in other cases, the appellate
court may need to remand to the PCRA court for further
development of the record and for the PCRA court to consider such
claims as an initial matter. Consistent with our prior case law, to
advance a request for remand, a petition would be required to
provide more than mere boilerplate assertions of PCRA counsel’s
ineffectiveness; however, where there are material facts at issue
concerning claims challenging counsel’s stewardship and relief is
not plainly unavailable as a matter of law, the remand should be
afforded.
Id. at 402 (citations, brackets, and quotation marks omitted).
Bradley does not displace the long-established roles of “the PCRA court
as the court of first impression[,]” which “should have the first opportunity to
address factual and legal claims[,]” and the appellate court’s role of
“review[ing] the PCRA court’s decision for an error of law or an abuse of
discretion.” Commonwealth v. Greer, 316 A.3d 623, 630-31 (Pa. 2024)
(citations and footnote omitted). Consequently, our ability to address an
ineffective assistance of counsel claim in the first instance, “applies only where
there is [not] any question about the merit of the newly-raised ineffectiveness
claim.” Id. at 630 n.4.
Because these claims raised by Fehir challenge PCRA counsel’s failure
to raise claims of ineffectiveness of pretrial and trial counsel, they are layered
ineffective assistance of counsel claims.
Layered claims of ineffectiveness are not wholly distinct from the
underlying claims, because proof of the underlying claim is an
essential element of the derivative ineffectiveness claim. In
determining a layered claim of ineffectiveness, the critical inquiry
is whether the first attorney that the defendant asserts was
- 15 -
J-A18012-26
ineffective did, in fact, render ineffective assistance of counsel. If
that attorney was effective, then subsequent counsel cannot be
deemed ineffective for failing to raise the underlying issue.
Commonwealth v. Gibson, 318 A.3d 927, 932 (Pa. Super. 2024) (citation
omitted).
Fehir requests that we either grant him relief or remand for the PCRA
court to develop the record and consider the claims in the first instance. See
Appellant’s Brief, at 2. To his credit, Fehir raises cogent arguments that mostly
contain more than mere boilerplate assertions as to why PCRA counsel was
ineffective. In its Rule 1925(a) opinion, the PCRA court found that these claims
were waived for not raising them in the PCRA court and the Commonwealth
does not address them. See PCRA Court Opinion, 10/27/25, at 10
(unpaginated). Therefore, we are without any substantive adversarial
argument against Fehir’s Bradley claims.
In issue one, Fehir argues that his PCRA counsel was ineffective for
failing to advise Fehir and the PCRA court of his inherent conflict of interest
since PCRA counsel also represented Fehir pretrial. See Appellant’s Brief, at
3-5. For this issue, Fehir does not allege that PCRA counsel’s prior
representation led to PCRA counsel’s failure to raise certain claims regarding
his ineffectiveness while acting as pretrial counsel and instead appears to
argue that the representation itself constituted a breach of the duty of loyalty.
See id. at 4-5. This is the sole claim where he asserts that the only appropriate
remedy is a remand. See id. at 5.
- 16 -
J-A18012-26
“The phrase ‘duty of loyalty’ appears in the context of examining
counsel’s primary obligation to his own individual client.” Commonwealth v.
Washington, 880 A.2d 536, 543 (Pa. 2005) (citation omitted). “The duty of
loyalty is the obligation of counsel to avoid actual conflicts of interest that
would adversely affect his ability to perform on behalf of his client.” Id.
(citation omitted). A claim that counsel violated a duty of loyalty to the client
must be established within the confines of the three-prong test for
ineffectiveness. See id. at 545. Because such claims are addressed within the
confines of the test for ineffective assistance of counsel, ineffective assistance
of counsel can only be established if PCRA counsel’s prior representation as
pretrial counsel caused PCRA counsel not to raise a meritorious issue
regarding counsel’s own prior representation. We see no basis to provide relief
on a generalized claim that PCRA counsel’s pretrial representation of Fehir per
se constituted ineffective assistance of counsel. Because Fehir fails even to
plead the three prongs of the ineffectiveness test, we can determine in the
first instance that Fehir’s first issue lacks legal merit.
Next, Fehir argues that PCRA counsel was ineffective for failing to raise
both his own ineffectiveness when acting as pretrial counsel and trial counsel’s
ineffectiveness. Specifically, he claims both counsel failed to compel the
Commonwealth to produce the wiretap order, wiretap application, and
affidavit of probable cause in discovery, under the mandatory disclosure
provisions of Pa.R.Crim.P. 573(B)(1)(g) and the Wiretapping Act, 18 Pa.C.S.A.
- 17 -
J-A18012-26
§§ 5701-5782, which denied him the ability to challenge procedural defects in
a pretrial motion to suppress. See Appellant’s Brief, at 6-8. He asserts that,
had the documents related to the wiretap been provided, counsel would have
been able to move for suppression pursuant to 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 5721.1(b)(1)
(grounds for excluding contents of intercepted communications). See id. at
8.
Pennsylvania Rule of Criminal Procedure 573(B)(1)(g) provides in
relevant part,
(B) Disclosure by the Commonwealth.
(1) Mandatory. In all court cases, on request by the defendant,
and subject to any protective order which the Commonwealth
might obtain under this rule, the Commonwealth shall disclose to
the defendant’s attorney all of the following requested items or
information, provided they are material to the instant case. The
Commonwealth shall, when applicable, permit the defendant’s
attorney to inspect and copy or photograph such items.
....
(g) the transcripts and recordings of any electronic
surveillance, and the authority by which the said
transcripts and recordings were obtained.
Pa.R.Crim.P. 573(B)(1)(g) (emphasis added).
If counsel would have requested the authority for authorizing the
recording, the Commonwealth would have been required to disclose that
information. See id.; Commonwealth v. Shreffler, 201 A.3d 757, 767 (Pa.
Super. 2018). However, Fehir cannot establish he was prejudiced by counsel’s
failure to do so because, even if the mandatory disclosure had been produced,
- 18 -
J-A18012-26
he has failed to establish that any underlying suppression claim would have
had arguable merit.
Section 5721.1(b) of the Crimes Code sets forth the grounds for
excluding evidence obtained from a wiretap and provides in pertinent part,
(b) Motion to exclude.--Any aggrieved person who is a party to
any proceeding in any court, board or agency of this
Commonwealth may move to exclude the contents of any wire,
electronic or oral communication, or evidence derived therefrom,
on any of the following grounds:
(1) Unless intercepted pursuant to an exception set
forth in section 5704 (relating to exceptions to
prohibition of interception and disclosure of
communications), the interception was made without
prior procurement of an order of authorization under
section 5712 (relating to issuance of order and effect)
or an order of approval under section 5713(a)
(relating to emergency situations) or 5713.1(b)
(relating to emergency hostage and barricade
situations).
18 Pa.C.S.A. § 5721.1(b)(1).
Relevant here is Section 5704(2)(ii) which applies when one of the
parties to the conversation has consented to the recording.
It shall not be unlawful and no prior court approval shall be
required under this chapter for:
....
(2) Any investigative or law enforcement officer or any
person acting at the direction or request of an
investigative or law enforcement officer to intercept a
wire, electronic or oral communication involving
suspected criminal activities, including, but not limited
to, the crimes enumerated in section 5708 (relating to
order authorizing interception of wire, electronic or
oral communications), where:
- 19 -
J-A18012-26
....
(ii) one of the parties to the
communication has given prior consent to
such interception. However, no
interception under this paragraph shall be
made unless the Attorney General or a
deputy attorney general designated in
writing by the Attorney General, or the
district attorney, or an assistant district
attorney designated in writing by the
district attorney, of the county wherein
the interception is to be initiated, has
reviewed the facts and is satisfied that the
consent is voluntary and has given prior
approval for the interception; however,
such interception shall be subject to the
recording and record keeping
requirements of section 5714(a) (relating
to recording of intercepted
communications) and that the Attorney
General, deputy attorney general, district
attorney or assistant district attorney
authorizing the interception shall be the
custodian of recorded evidence obtained
therefrom[.]
18 Pa.C.S.A. § 5704(2)(ii).
In considering suppression claims of such recordings, “the consent of a
party to the communication lessens the constitutional concerns related to
privacy as compared to those which pertain to non-consensual interceptions.”
Commonwealth v. Spangler, 809 A.2d 234, 240 (Pa. 2002) (footnote
omitted). Under such circumstances, the Wiretap Act requires “that the
informant acts consensually, that his consent is voluntary, and that the
informant acts under the direction of an investigative or law enforcement
- 20 -
J-A18012-26
officer to intercept oral communications involving suspected criminal
activities.” Commonwealth v. Lissmore, 313 A.3d 1050, 1060 (Pa. Super.
2024) (citation omitted).
Here, at trial, Victim testified that she voluntarily participated in the
recorded conversation with Fehir. See N.T., 1/17/18, at 287-89. Detective
McClure testified about the process for obtaining approval, including the
district attorney’s review and approval, and Victim’s voluntary participation in
the process. See N.T., 1/18/18, at 376-79. “[T]he failure to file a suppression
motion under some circumstances may be evidence of ineffective assistance
of counsel.” Commonwealth v. Watley, 153 A.3d 1034, 1044 (Pa. Super.
2016) (citations omitted). “However, if the grounds underpinning that motion
are without merit, counsel will not be deemed ineffective for failing to so
move.” Id. (citation omitted). Therefore, because the trial testimony clearly
established Victim’s voluntary consent and the proper procedure for obtaining
the recorded conversation, Fehir’s claim fails because counsel cannot be
ineffective where his suggested grounds for suppression would have been
without merit.
In his third Bradley claim, Fehir argues that PCRA counsel was
ineffective for failing to raise trial counsel’s ineffectiveness for failing to object
to Victim’s testimony about portions of the recorded conversation. See
Appellant’s Brief, at 8-11. He argues that Victim’s narration created a
misleading impression about the content of the conversation, trial counsel
- 21 -
J-A18012-26
should not have stipulated to only excerpts of the recording being played, and
pursuant to