State v. Villavicencio
CourtCourt of Appeals of North Carolina
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket25-425
JudgeJudge Christopher Freeman
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
An unpublished opinion of the North Carolina Court of Appeals does not constitute
controlling legal authority. Citation is disfavored, but may be permitted in accordance with
the provisions of Rule 30(e)(3) of the North Carolina Rules of Appellate Procedure.
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF NORTH CAROLINA
No. COA25-425
Filed 18 November 2026
Mecklenburg County, Nos. 22CR011682-590, 22CR011683-590, 22CR210300-590
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
v.
RENE VELEZ VILLAVICENCIO
Appeal by defendant from judgment entered 18 September 2024 by Judge
Reggie McKnight in Mecklenburg County Superior Court. Heard in the Court of
Appeals 14 January 2026.
Attorney General Jeff Jackson, by Special Deputy Attorney General Jocelyn C.
Wright, for the State.
Goodman Carr, PLLC, by W. Rob Heroy, for defendant-appellant.
FREEMAN, Judge.
Defendant appeals from judgment entered upon a jury’s verdict finding
defendant guilty of second-degree rape, second-degree sexual offense, second-degree
forcible rape, and first-degree kidnapping. On appeal, defendant argues the trial
court erred by (1) denying defendant’s motion to dismiss the rape and sexual offense
charges, (2) excluding defendant’s impeachment evidence under Rule 412, and (3)
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
handing down conflicting sentences. After careful review, we find no error in part,
vacate in part, and remand.
I. Factual and Procedural Background
In 2019, L.C.1 became “best friends” with her coworker, Mariana. L.C. met
defendant after he and Mariana started dating in December 2019. L.C. testified that
she and defendant were cordial, but not close. L.C. maintained that she and
defendant never had consensual sex.
On 14 August 2020, defendant planned Mariana’s twenty-first birthday party
at his cousins’ house. The house was a split-level with a swimming pool in the back.
Upon entering, stairs up to the main floor led to a kitchen and living area, while the
stairs down led to a sunken “bonus room” with a couch and TV, a guest bedroom with
an extra bed or “pallet” made up on the floor, and a hall bathroom. At the house party
were defendant, his cousins, Mariana, L.C., a woman named Maria, and other invited
guests.
The party began around 9:30 P.M. with an alcohol drinking game in the
kitchen. L.C. arrived alone around 10:00 P.M., not planning to stay the night.
Defendant and Mariana were the only guests L.C. knew when she arrived and joined
the drinking game.
1 Initials used by agreement of the parties to shield the victim.
-2-
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
Mariana testified that she and L.C. took Adderall during the party.2
Defendant also testified that L.C. gave Mariana an unidentified pill to help her hold
her alcohol. Nonetheless, Mariana soon retreated to the small downstairs bathroom
to vomit. Defendant went with her to assist. L.C., by this time “very heavily
intoxicated,” had “fuzzy,” “patchy” memories of joining them to check on Mariana.
Defendant testified that L.C. wanted to change into her bathing suit and began
removing her clothes in front of him and Mariana, which prompted defendant to look
up at the wall and try to turn his back to L.C. The defense elicited testimony that
L.C., while undressed, tried to kiss Mariana, but the State objected under Rule 412
and this line of questioning was prohibited.
Maria also came downstairs to check on Mariana. Defendant took Mariana to
the bedroom across the hall, where they went to sleep.3 L.C. and Maria remained in
the bathroom together for another hour and a half, talking and taking Snapchat
photos.4 L.C. testified that by this point in the evening, she had consumed so much
alcohol that her memory was “patchy” and “splotchy,” and she did not remember
talking with Maria or taking the photos presented.
2 L.C. testified she did not remember taking any pills or drugs.
3 At this point, Mariana testified that she “blacked out” from alcohol consumption and
remembered little more beyond lying down to sleep, being briefly awakened by the arrival of more
party guests, and going back to sleep for the rest of the night.
4 Although defendant testified that L.C. changed into her swimsuit before he left the bathroom,
L.C. was still wearing regular clothes in her photos with Maria.
-3-
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
The defense proffered further testimony that L.C. steered the photos in a
suggestive direction, kissed Maria twice, got partially undressed, and propositioned
Maria sexually, but the State objected under Rule 412 and the jury did not hear most
of this.
Upon leaving the bathroom, L.C. found defendant and Mariana in the bedroom
across the hall, lying on the “pallet” floor bed. L.C. woke them by lying down on top
of them—later testifying that she did not remember doing so, although photo evidence
showed her in this position.
A second drinking game began in the downstairs bonus room. Defendant
testified that he and the other participants were taking shots of Jack Daniels
whiskey. L.C. tried to join the game, but defendant claimed he cut her off, saying
she’d had too much to drink already.
At approximately 3:00 A.M., Maria left the party, and others began to consider
getting into the swimming pool or going to bed. L.C., now wearing her swimsuit, got
into the pool alone. Defendant and Mariana also came outside, but they had an
argument and did not get into the pool. Defendant testified that he too had begun to
“black out” from alcohol consumption and remembered little about the pool or what
followed.
Still in the wee hours of the morning, L.C. realized she was too drunk to drive
home. Though she testified she did not remember changing, L.C. got back into her
-4-
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
regular clothes. Then she lay down next to Mariana on the pallet in the downstairs
bedroom. The lights were off. At some point, L.C. fell asleep.
Having testified earlier that he fell asleep on the couch in the bonus room after
the Jack Daniels drinking game, defendant later testified that he lay down on the
pallet with Mariana after the pool trip. A crate for the family’s pit bull made the
bedroom cramped and kept defendant from lying down comfortably or falling asleep.
Defendant testified that he got up and left the room to go lie on the couch as soon as
L.C. lay down beside Mariana.
L.C. was awakened by someone lying down next to her, on the opposite side
from Mariana. The room was so dark that L.C. did not see who it was. Without
speaking, an unknown male pushed aside L.C.’s shorts and underwear and vaginally
penetrated her with his fingers, followed by his penis. This went on for an unspecified
length of time. L.C. testified that she remained still and silent, feeling “froze[n],”
“scared,” “disassociated,” and “still pretty intoxicated.” The unknown male then
withdrew and left the room. Mariana remained asleep.
L.C. lay there, “disoriented,” for an unspecified length of time, “trying to
process what just happened” and unsure if it was real due to her intoxication. She
decided to leave the party and return home. Without waking Mariana, L.C. left the
pallet and crossed the hall to the bathroom, where she closed the door and stood in
the dark to try to collect her wits before leaving. An unknown male entered the
bathroom behind L.C. and pinned her against the sink with his full body weight, not
-5-
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
speaking or turning the lights on. She felt him restrain her arms behind her back
with one hand while he removed her shorts and underwear with the other. L.C.
testified she “could not move” or fight back. She felt the unknown male force her head
down into the sink and vaginally penetrate her from behind with his penis. This
continued until he ejaculated. Then he left the bathroom.
These events reminded L.C. of a sexual assault she had suffered as a preteen.
She left the bathroom “visibly upset,” “shaken up,” and “crying.” By the light of the
TV in the bonus room, L.C. saw defendant standing near the couch, preparing to lie
down. She went over to ask him to walk her to her car. At this point, L.C. did not
think defendant was her assailant.
L.C. testified that defendant had just lain down and closed his eyes as she
approached. When she roused him, defendant repeatedly insisted that he had been
sound asleep, but he agreed to walk her to her car.5
Seeing L.C. still upset, defendant sat on the street and talked to L.C. through
her open car door for about thirty minutes. L.C. was unsure how many of her
memories were real, so she only disclosed to defendant that she had just had a bad
“memory” or “dream” reminiscent of a negative experience from her childhood. L.C.
testified that defendant responded to this by asking if she was currently on birth
5 Defendant testified that L.C. shook him awake from a deep sleep, and that he had been asleep
on the couch since the Jack Daniels drinking game; but when he saw how upset she was, he agreed to
accompany her outside. According to defendant, L.C. asked when she woke him if he had “come” inside
her, which confused defendant because he did not remember having sex with L.C.
-6-
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
control.6 Discomfited by his question, L.C. ended the conversation and drove home
alone in the early morning hours of 15 August 2020.
The following day, 16 August 2020, L.C. texted Mariana about the assaults by
the unknown male at the party and asked her not to tell defendant. Despite L.C.’s
request, Mariana repeated the story to defendant. Mariana testified that defendant
did not visibly react at first, but later he was “freaking out,” scared, and taciturn,
which was not his usual persona. Defendant texted L.C., offering to “assume all
responsibility” for what had happened to her at his party and asking her not to tell
his family because the news would “break them.” L.C., not understanding how
defendant could “take responsibility,” stopped speaking to him and Mariana.
L.C. went to Atrium Health later that day and had a sexual assault nurse
examination (SANE exam) performed by a certified nurse examiner (Nurse). L.C.
told the Nurse that she did not know who her assailant was. The pain in L.C.’s
shoulders and arms, the fresh bruises on her skin, and the results of her genital exam
were consistent with her description of the assaults.
A Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police detective (Detective) interviewed L.C. on 21
August 2020 and downloaded copies of her 16 August texts with defendant. Within
the week following L.C.’s SANE exam, the Detective separately interviewed and took
6 Defendant testified he did not remember asking L.C. this.
-7-
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
voluntary DNA samples from defendant, Mariana, Maria, and other guests.7
Defendant denied having any sexual contact with L.C.
Almost two years later, forensic analysis confirmed defendant as the source of
the DNA and seminal fluid collected during L.C.’s SANE exam. A warrant for
defendant’s arrest was issued on 1 April 2022.
Defendant was charged with two counts of second-degree forcible rape, one
count of second-degree forcible sexual offense, and one count of first-degree
kidnapping. He was indicted on 29 August 2022. On 30 May 2024, superseding
indictments were entered; the first three of the charges listed were now second-degree
rape, second-degree forcible rape, and second-degree sexual offense.
On 9 September 2024, the matter came on for trial. The court sustained the
State’s objections to testimony and evidence about the following matters: (1) L.C.’s
alleged sexual advances toward Maria, followed by L.C.’s alleged attempts to hide
evidence of their bathroom encounter after L.C. regained sobriety; (2) an allegation
that L.C.’s rape accusation could have stemmed from a consensual encounter that she
later regretted; and (3) L.C.’s alleged brandishing of a pocketknife at the party as
evidence of her bizarre behavior while intoxicated.
7 L.C.’s then-boyfriend, Kyle, also provided a DNA sample, but the Detective did not interview
him because Kyle was not at the party.
-8-
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
The defense moved to dismiss all charges for insufficient evidence when the
State rested and again at the close of all evidence. Both motions were denied. On 17
September 2024, the jury found defendant guilty of all four charged offenses.
The court consolidated defendant’s four charges into two pairs for sentencing
purposes. The bedroom assaults, for which defendant was charged with second-
degree rape and second-degree sexual offense, received an oral sentence of 73 to 148
months, which the court verbally amended to “70 to 148” months a few seconds later.
The bathroom assault, for which defendant was charged with second-degree forcible
rape and first-degree kidnapping, received a consecutive oral sentence of 73 to 148
months. Defendant gave oral notice of appeal.
II. Jurisdiction
This Court has jurisdiction to review a final judgment of a superior court
pursuant to N.C.G.S. §§ 7A-27(b)(1). “A defendant who has entered a plea of not
guilty to a criminal charge, and who has been found guilty of a crime, is entitled to
appeal as a matter of right when final judgment has been entered.” N.C.G.S. § 15A-
1444(a) (2025).
III. Discussion
Defendant raises three issues on appeal. Defendant seeks to vacate his two
convictions that pertain to the bedroom assaults, alleging insufficient evidence of
L.C.’s physical helplessness, and to reverse his two convictions that pertain to the
bathroom assault and remand for a new trial, citing the exclusion of the defense’s
-9-
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
impeachment evidence under Rule 412. In the alternative, defendant asks this Court
to remand for resentencing.
A. Mental Incapacitation or Physical Helplessness
Defendant argues the trial court erred by denying his motions to dismiss for
insufficiency of the evidence because the State did not prove all required elements of
the two charges relating to the bedroom assaults: namely, second-degree rape and
second-degree sexual offense.
“The question for a court on a motion to dismiss for insufficient evidence ‘is
whether there is substantial evidence (1) of each essential element of the offense
charged, or of a lesser offense included therein, and (2) of [the] defendant’s being the
perpetrator of such offense.’ ” State v. Bradsher, 382 N.C. 656, 658 (2022) (quoting
State v. Powell, 299 N.C. 95, 98 (1980)). “Substantial evidence is the amount
‘necessary to persuade a rational juror to accept a conclusion.’ ” State v. Ditenhafer,
373 N.C. 116, 125 (2019) (quoting State v. Mann, 355 N.C. 294, 301 (2002)). “In
evaluating the sufficiency of the evidence to support a criminal conviction, the
evidence must be considered ‘in the light most favorable to the State; the State is
entitled to every . . . reasonable inference to be drawn therefrom.’ ” Id. at 125–26
(quoting Powell, 299 N.C. at 99).
“This Court reviews the trial court’s denial of a motion to dismiss de novo.
Under a de novo review, this Court considers the matter anew and freely substitutes
- 10 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
its own judgment for that of the lower tribunal.” State v. Fraley, 299 N.C. App. 463,
469 (2025) (cleaned up).
Here, as it appeared at the date of defendant’s conviction, section 14-27.22 of
our General Statutes defined second-degree rape as follows, in relevant part:
(a) A person is guilty of second-degree forcible rape if the
person engages in vaginal intercourse with another person:
(1) By force and against the will of the other person; or
(2) Who . . . is mentally incapacitated or physically
helpless, and the person performing the act knows or
should reasonably know the other person . . . is mentally
incapacitated or physically helpless.
N.C.G.S. § 14-27.22(a) (2018).
As it appeared at the date of defendant’s conviction, section 14-27.27 of our
General Statutes defined second-degree sexual offense as follows, in relevant part:
(a) A person is guilty of second degree forcible sexual
offense if the person engages in a sexual act with another
person:
(1) By force and against the will of the other person; or
(2) Who . . . is mentally incapacitated or physically
helpless, and the person performing the act knows or
should reasonably know the other person . . . is mentally
incapacitated or physically helpless.
N.C.G.S. § 14-27.27(a) (2018).
Section 14-27.20, as it appeared at the date of defendant’s conviction, defined
the operative terms at issue here as follows:
(2) Mentally incapacitated.—A victim who due to any act is
- 11 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
rendered substantially incapable of either appraising the
nature of his or her conduct, or resisting the act of vaginal
intercourse or a sexual act.
....
(3) Physically helpless.—Any of the following:
a. A victim who is unconscious.
b. A victim who is physically unable to resist an act of
vaginal intercourse or a sexual act or [to] communicate
unwillingness to submit to an act of vaginal intercourse or
a sexual act.
(4) Sexual act.— . . . the penetration, however slight, by
any object into the genital or anal opening of another
person’s body. . . .
N.C.G.S. §§ 14-27.20(2), (3)–(4) (2019).
The following elements of each charge must be proven: (1) defendant engaged
in “vaginal intercourse” or “a sexual act,” respectively, with L.C.; (2) L.C. was
“mentally incapacitated or physically helpless” during these acts by defendant; and
(3) defendant knew or reasonably should have known of L.C.’s mental incapacitation
or physical helplessness when he performed these acts.
Defendant contests the trial court’s finding that the second element of both
charges was satisfied: that L.C. was mentally incapacitated or physically helpless,
such that she did not consent to sex with defendant. Defendant’s arguments and
cited authority focus almost entirely on physical helplessness. He contends that L.C.
was not physically helpless because no evidence tended to show she was unconscious
or immobile during the bedroom assaults. When asked whether she could “scream or
- 12 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
fight back” during her two vaginal penetrations by defendant in the bedroom, L.C.
only answered that she did not. Defendant presents this testimony as dispositive
that the second element of both charges was not met.
However, physical helplessness is not the only finding that can satisfy this
element. If the jury found L.C. was mentally incapacitated, the second element of
both charges would be equally satisfied. State v. Haddock, 191 N.C. App. 474, 481
(2008). “Any act,” including her own voluntary choice to become intoxicated, can
render a rape victim “substantially incapable” of consenting to or resisting sex; this
qualifies as mental incapacitation, even if the victim’s level of intoxication falls “short
of unconsciousness or physical helplessness.” Id. at 483; see also State v. Aiken, 73
N.C. App. 487, 499 (1985). The victim in Aiken was so drunk, her friends believed
she was unconscious when the defendant raped her. 73 N.C. App. at 490, 497–98.
Recalling the events of that night, however, the victim testified that she was
conscious enough to recognize “a light coming on” and “someone yelling,” but “she
thought it was all a dream.” Id. at 491. This Court found no error in the Aiken
defendant’s conviction of second-degree rape. Id. at 501.
Here, as in Aiken, L.C. testified that she was still so intoxicated when she
awoke, she was unsure if the assaults were really happening. Later, she still
questioned whether she had been in a “dream” or flashing back to a sexual assault in
her early adolescence when she felt defendant penetrate her. The Nurse testified
that gaps in memory and partial or full blackouts are common in patients who
- 13 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
experience sexual trauma.
In the light most favorable to the State, substantial evidence was presented to
convince a rational jury that even if L.C. did not meet the statutory definition of
“physically helpless,” in that she was not unconscious or immobile either time
defendant penetrated her vagina in the bedroom, she was mentally incapacitated by
her intoxication during these events. All three elements of both charges, second-
degree rape and second-degree sexual offense, were met.
On defendant’s challenge to the trial court’s denial of his motion to dismiss
these charges for insufficient evidence, we discern no error.
B. Application of Rule 412
Defendant next argues the trial court reversibly erred by excluding relevant
evidence under Rule 412. He alleges that his proffered impeachment evidence
regarding L.C.’s prior sexual behavior fell under an exception to Rule 412, requiring
the court to weigh it under Rule 403 for its probative value before barring it.
We review a trial court’s decision to exclude evidence under Rule 412 for abuse
of discretion. State v. Edmonds, 212 N.C. App. 575, 579 (2011). On the question of
whether the excluded evidence was relevant, we do not review for abuse of discretion
but give deference on appeal because the trial court is “better situated to evaluate
whether a particular piece of evidence tends to make the existence of a fact of
consequence more or less probable.” State v. Khouri, 214 N.C. App. 389, 406 (2011)
(citing State v. Tadeja, 191 N.C. App. 439, 444 (2008)).
- 14 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
If the trial court erred in excluding the evidence, the appellant must also show
“a reasonable probability that had the error not been committed, a different result
would have been reached at trial.” N.C.G.S. § 15A-1443(a) (2025). A new trial is
awarded only if the appellant shows the court’s error was prejudicial in this way.
State v. Wilkerson, 363 N.C. 392, 415 (2009).
Here, as it appeared at the date of defendant’s trial, Rule of Evidence 412 read
in relevant part:
(a) As used in this rule, the term “sexual behavior” means
sexual activity of the complainant other than the sexual act
which is at issue in the indictment on trial.
(b) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the sexual
behavior of the complainant is irrelevant to any issue in
the prosecution unless such behavior:
....
(3) Is evidence of a pattern of sexual behavior so distinctive
and so closely resembling the defendant’s version of the
alleged encounter with the complainant as to tend to prove
that such complainant consented to the act or acts charged
or behaved in such a manner as to lead the defendant
reasonably to believe that the complainant consented; . . .
....
(d) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, unless and
until the court determines that evidence of sexual behavior
is relevant under subdivision (b), no reference to this
behavior may be made in the presence of the jury and no
evidence of this behavior may be introduced at any time
during the trial of any of the following:
(1) A charge of rape . . .
- 15 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
(2) A charge of a sex offense . . .
...
Before any questions pertaining to such evidence are asked
of any witness, the proponent of such evidence shall first
apply to the court for a determination of the relevance of
the sexual behavior to which it relates. . . .
N.C.G.S. §§ 8C-1, Rule 412(a), (b)(3), (d), (d)(1)–(2) (2018) (emphases added).
The defense cited this Court’s decision in State v. Shoffner, 62 N.C. App. 245
(1983), to argue that evidence of L.C.’s sexualized advances toward Mariana and
Maria earlier in the evening should have been admitted under Rule 412(b)(3), the
“modus operandi” exception. In Shoffner, the alleged victim publicly propositioned
both defendants for sex in the same way those defendants (and other witnesses) had
seen her entice other men. 62 N.C. App. at 246–49.
Shoffner is distinguishable. No one, not even defendant, testified that L.C.
made sexual advances toward defendant, nor that he reasonably could have perceived
L.C. as pursuing sex with him based on her behavior with Mariana and Maria.
Mariana testified that she and L.C. had a “loving,” “touchy” friendship even
before the events of Mariana’s twenty-first birthday. Testimony also confirmed that
defendant had seen L.C. intoxicated around Mariana before that night. A rational
jury could therefore conclude that even if L.C. did remove her clothes in the presence
of Mariana and defendant, and even if L.C. did attempt to kiss Mariana while
undressed, defendant would not have been led to a reasonable belief that L.C. wanted
- 16 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
to have sex with him.
While the photos in the record confirm that L.C. and Maria spent time together
in the bathroom, no evidence was presented that defendant learned the nature of
their interactions until after L.C. had left the party. A rational jury could therefore
conclude that even if L.C. did proposition Maria, defendant would not have been led
to a reasonable belief that L.C. wanted to have sex with him.
Evidence of a victim’s prior sexual behavior must “so closely resembl[e] the
defendant’s version of the alleged encounter with the complainant as to tend to prove
that such complainant consented . . . or behaved in such a manner as to lead the
defendant reasonably to believe that the complainant consented” before that evidence
can be admitted. N.C.G.S. § 8C-1, Rule 412(b)(3) (emphasis added). Here, defendant
has presented no version of this type of encounter with L.C. Defendant has
maintained that he does not remember having sex with L.C. Without defendant’s
version of the story, there is nothing for the defense to compare with L.C.’s prior
sexual behavior in alleging that L.C. had solicited defendant for sex in a manner
consistent with her alleged modus operandi. Defendant cannot show that a different
result would have been reached had the evidence hinted at by his counsel been
presented to the jury in full.
The trial court considered the relevance of the proffered evidence before
determining that the analysis in Shoffner does not control here. The court noted both
that (1) L.C.’s alleged sexual behavior was directed toward third parties, not toward
- 17 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
defendant, and (2) defendant offered no version of his own encounter with L.C. to
compare with her alleged modus operandi. Evidence of L.C.’s alleged sexual behavior
at the party with anyone other than defendant did not tend to make any fact of
consequence regarding her encounter with defendant more or less probable,
rendering such evidence irrelevant and therefore properly excluded under Rules 412
and 403. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in so ruling.
Concluding our analysis on this point, we note that in the process of invoking
Rule 412’s exceptions, the defense violated the Rule’s guidelines for introducing
evidence. Rule 412(d) requires: “no reference to [the complainant’s prior sexual]
behavior may be made in the presence of the jury”; and, “[b]efore any questions
pertaining to such evidence are asked of any witness, the proponent of such evidence
shall first apply to the court” to determine whether the intended evidence falls under
a Rule 412 exception.
On three occasions, defense counsel asked a witness about L.C.’s prior sexual
behavior (after the trial court had already ruled to exclude any evidence barred by
Rule 412). Only after the State objected and the jury left the room did counsel argue
that the answers he intended to elicit qualified under a Rule 412 exception. This
order of operations was impermissible.
On defendant’s challenge to the trial court’s exclusion of his proffered
impeachment evidence under Rule 412, we conclude no abuse of discretion and no
error is shown.
- 18 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
C. Inconsistency in Sentencing
Lastly, defendant argues that because his written and oral sentences did not
match, his sentence was unlawful and we should remand for resentencing. Though
the State counters that any discrepancies were likely clerical errors, it concedes that
the trial court’s miscalculation of the statutory minimum sentences for defendant’s
convictions requires correction.
We review alleged sentencing errors, including clerical errors, de novo. State
v. Allen, 249 N.C. App. 376, 379 (2016). “A clerical error is defined as an error
resulting from a minor mistake or inadvertence, especially in writing or copying
something from the record, and not from judicial reasoning or determination.” State
v. Horne, 931 S.E.2d 280, 284 (N.C. Ct. App. 2026) (quoting State v. Jarman, 140 N.C.
App. 198, 202 (2000)). “When, on appeal, a clerical error is discovered in the trial
court’s judgment or order, it is appropriate to remand the case to the trial court for
correction because of the importance that the record speak the truth.” Id. (quoting
State v. Smith, 188 N.C. App. 842, 845 (2008)).
A judgment is rendered when given orally, but it is not entered until it is
written and filed. In re J.C., 236 N.C. App. 558, 562 (2014). “If the written judgment
conforms generally with the oral judgment, the judgment is valid.” Id. (quoting
Edwards v. Taylor, 182 N.C. App. 722, 727 (2007)). “However, if there is a
discrepancy between the written order and the oral rendering of the order in open
court as reflected by the transcript, the transcript is considered dispositive.” Id.; see
- 19 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
also In re O.D.S., 247 N.C. App. 711, 719–20 (2016). Following this principle, we have
vacated and remanded a sentence for a discrepancy of three months between the oral
and written judgments. See State v. Leaks, 240 N.C. App. 573, 578 (2015).
After orally sentencing defendant to either “73 to 148 months” or “70 to 148”
months for the bedroom assaults, the trial court entered a written judgment reflecting
the higher sentence of the two: 73 to 148 months. Next, after orally sentencing
defendant to “73 to 148 months” for the bathroom assault, the court entered a written
judgment reflecting a sentence of 78 to 148 months.
The trial court’s original oral judgment on the first sentence matches its
written judgment of 73 to 148 months. However, the second oral rendering of “70 to
148” poses a problem. Even if the court merely misspoke, under J.C. and O.D.S., the
transcript controls. We therefore vacate this sentence and remand for resentencing
so that the written judgment entered conforms to the oral judgment rendered.
The trial court’s original oral judgment on the second sentence of “73 to 148
months” does not match its written judgment of 78 to 148 months. Under N.C.G.S.
§ 15A-1340.17 (2013), the minimum sentence allowable for the Class C felony of
second-degree rape is 73 months. The written judgment listing a minimum of 78
months is more than a mere clerical error. Therefore, we also vacate this sentence
and remand for resentencing to resolve these discrepancies.
- 20 -
STATE V. VILLAVICENCIO
Opinion of the Court
IV. Conclusion
We conclude there is no error in the trial court’s decisions regarding the State’s
proof of all elements of defendant’s charges of second-degree rape and second-degree
sexual offense. We further conclude the court did not abuse its discretion by
excluding the defense’s proffered impeachment evidence regarding L.C.’s prior sexual
behaviors. We vacate defendant’s sentences and remand for resentencing with
instructions to the trial court to correct the discrepancies between its oral and written
judgments.
NO ERROR IN PART; VACATED IN PART; AND REMANDED FOR
RESENTENCING.
Judges TYSON and WOOD concur
Report per Rule 30(e).
- 21 -