State ex rel. Hilgers v. Herman
CourtNebraska Supreme Court
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
DocketS-26-694
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Nebraska Supreme Court Online Library
www.nebraska.gov/apps-courts-epub/
11/20/2026 09:03 AM CST
- 873 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
State of Nebraska ex rel. Michael T. Hilgers,
Attorney General of the State of Nebraska,
and Lee Polikov, Sarpy County Attorney,
relators, v. Demetria Herman,
Special Deputy Sarpy County
Attorney, respondent.
___ N.W.3d ___
Filed November 20, 2026. No. S-26-694.
1. Prosecuting Attorneys: Appeal and Error. A motion for the appoint-
ment of a special prosecutor is addressed to the discretion of the trial
court, and absent an abuse of discretion, a ruling on such a motion will
not be disturbed on appeal.
2. Judgments: Appeal and Error. The abuse of discretion standard of
review recognizes there is a range of rationally available rulings that can
be supported by the facts and governing law in a particular case.
3. ____: ____. When an appellate court reviews a trial court’s ruling for
an abuse of discretion, it is considering whether the ruling exceeded
the bounds of permissible choice, given the evidence presented and the
applicable law.
4. Prosecuting Attorneys: Statutes. County attorneys’ offices are statuto-
rily required to represent the interests of the State in criminal, civil, and
juvenile proceedings.
5. Words and Phrases. The use of the word “shall” in Neb. Rev. Stat.
§ 23-1202 (Reissue 2022) indicates a mandatory directive inconsistent
with the idea of discretion.
6. Statutes. Statutes pertaining to the same subject matter should be con-
strued together as if they were one law, giving effect to every provision
and refraining from reading into them words that are not there.
7. Conflict of Interest: Words and Phrases. A conflict of interest exists
when a defense attorney is placed in a situation inherently conducive to
divided loyalties.
- 874 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
8. Attorney and Client: Conflict of Interest: Words and Phrases. The
phrase “conflict of interest” denotes situations where a lawyer’s rep-
resentation of one client is rendered less effective by reason of his or
her representation of another client, where it becomes a lawyer’s duty
on behalf of one client to contend for that which the lawyer’s duty to
another client would require him or her to oppose, or where fulfilling
a lawyers duty to the client may be to the detriment of the attorney’s
personal interest.
9. Prosecuting Attorneys: Conflict of Interest. The purpose of Neb. Rev.
Stat. § 23-1205 (Reissue 2022) is the protection of the public by mak-
ing certain that a county attorney’s duties shall not be influenced by
private interests.
10. Trial: Judges: Words and Phrases. An ex parte communication occurs
when a judge communicates with any person concerning a pending or
impending proceeding without notice to an adverse party.
11. Prosecuting Attorneys: Witnesses: Conflict of Interest. The advocate-
witness rule discourages combining roles of advocate and witness in the
same proceeding, recognizing the two different roles could give rise to
conflicts of interest.
12. Trial: Prosecuting Attorneys: Witnesses. A court will not allow
defense counsel to raise the possibility of calling the prosecutor as a
witness merely to disqualify the prosecutor from the trial of the case.
13. Trial: Attorneys at Law: Witnesses: Evidence. A court cannot order
disqualification simply upon the moving party’s representation that the
lawyer it seeks to disqualify is a necessary witness; the key is the evi-
dence showing that the lawyer is a necessary witness.
14. Trial: Attorneys at Law: Witnesses: Evidence: Proof. A party seeking
to call opposing counsel must prove that counsel is a necessary witness
by showing that (1) the proposed testimony is material and relevant to
the determination of the issues being litigated and (2) the evidence is
unobtainable elsewhere.
15. Prosecuting Attorneys: Witnesses: Conflict of Interest. Conflicts of
interest that arise from the advocate-witness rule are generally not
imputed to other members of the law office.
16. Constitutional Law: Statutes: Prosecuting Attorneys: Conflict of
Interest. Because of the unique constitutional and statutory duties
of a county attorney’s office, the entire county attorney’s office will be
disqualified due to a conflict of one of its attorneys only in the rarest
of situations.
17. Prosecuting Attorneys. When an individual prosecutor is disqualified,
generally a different prosecutor in the same office may be appointed,
- 875 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
absent some unusual circumstance warranting disqualification of the
entire office.
18. Public Officers and Employees: Public Policy. The de facto doctrine
validates, on grounds of public policy and prevention of failure of public
justice, the acts of officials who function under color of law.
19. Prosecuting Attorneys: Courts. The authority of someone who is
appointed as a special prosecutor ends at the point in time when a court
makes a legal ruling that the appointment was invalid and orders as a
matter of law that the individual’s authority is terminated.
Original action. Judgment of ouster.
Michael T. Hilgers, Attorney General, Lee K. Polikov, Sarpy
County Attorney, Cody S. Barnett, and Andrea Gosnold-Parker
for relators.
No appearance for respondent.
Funke, C.J., Cassel, Stacy, Papik, Freudenberg,
Bergevin, and Vaughn, JJ.
Freudenberg, J.
INTRODUCTION
This is an original action for quo warranto challenging the
district court’s sua sponte appointment of a special prosecu-
tor from the Attorney General’s office to replace the Sarpy
County Attorney’s office in a criminal prosecution, after
defense counsel alleged, for the first time in district court,
that the deputy county attorney had engaged in ex parte
communications with the county court judge during a pause
in preliminary hearings. After the case was bound over to
the district court, the deputy county attorney was no longer
assigned to the case. During a hearing scheduled in district
court for the defendant’s plea in bar and motion to quash
the information, defense counsel explained she wished to
have the deputy county attorney testify to create a record
for appeal or future litigation. The district court appointed
the special prosecutor based on a conflict with the Sarpy
County Attorney’s office and the appearance of impropriety
- 876 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
stemming from allegations of improper conduct by the deputy
county attorney. Subsequently, defense counsel did not call
the deputy county attorney to testify, and the court found that
a motion to quash defense counsel’s subpoena of the deputy
county attorney was moot.
BACKGROUND
A criminal complaint against Delmar Alexander Rodriguez
Morales was filed in the county court for Sarpy County alleg-
ing first degree sexual assault of a child under 12 years of age.
Peter Pirsch, a deputy Sarpy County Attorney, was the pros-
ecutor assigned to the preliminary hearing. The preliminary
hearing was held before the county court judge, who found
probable cause to bind the matter over to the district court
for Sarpy County, where an information was filed on June 2,
2026. Defense counsel did not raise in county court any issue
of ex parte communications, courtroom procedures, or other-
wise question if the county attorney’s office had a conflict of
interest or had committed misconduct in relation to the prelimi-
nary hearing.
Once the matter was bound over to the district court, the
county court judge no longer presided over the matter, which
was assigned to a district court judge who presided over the
case from that point forward. Further, a different deputy Sarpy
County Attorney became the prosecutor for the district court
file. Pirsch did not participate as a prosecutor in any of the
proceedings in district court.
Plea in Abatement and Motion
to Quash Information
Defense counsel filed in the district court a plea in abate-
ment challenging the sufficiency of the evidence at the pre-
liminary hearing. Defense counsel also filed a motion to quash
the information. Neither motion alleged unconstitutional court-
room procedures or that Pirsch had committed any misconduct,
engaged in any improper ex parte communications, or had a
conflict of interest.
- 877 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
June 22, 2026, Allegations of
Ex Parte Communications
Defense counsel raised Pirsch’s alleged ex parte communi-
cations for the first time at a hearing in the district court on
June 22, 2026, in which Rodriguez Morales’ plea in abatement
and motion to quash the information were scheduled to be
heard. Before proceeding with her argument on the motions,
defense counsel told the court she “would also like to make
a record regarding the probable cause hearing . . . for appeal
for future litigation.” When the court pointed out that the
probable cause hearing was already on the record, defense
counsel said she had “concerns about other issues,” which she
described as “ex parte communications” and “the procedures
for the probable cause hearing in county court.” The district
court questioned how that would be done, and defense counsel
indicated she would need to call Pirsch as a witness. The hear-
ing was continued to July 6, so that defense counsel would
have time to subpoena Pirsch.
July 6, 2026, Hearing Appointment
of Special Prosecutor
Defense counsel subpoenaed Pirsch to testify on Rodriguez
Morales’ behalf at the July 6, 2026, hearing. The county attor-
ney’s office moved to quash the subpoena on the grounds that
(1) it was beyond the scope of the allegations of the motion
to quash, (2) defense counsel had presented no extrinsic evi-
dence to show any ex parte communication of any kind, and
(3) defense counsel was inappropriately using the subpoena
power to collaterally attack prosecutors and prejudice the abil-
ity of the State to perform its statutory duties.
At the July 6, 2026, hearing, Pirsch was not called to testify
and none of the pending motions were addressed. Instead, the
district court raised, sua sponte, whether the allegations war-
ranted the appointment of a special prosecutor.
The Sarpy County Attorney’s office objected to appoint-
ment of a special prosecutor because no extrinsic evidence
- 878 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
had been offered to support defense counsel’s allegations. It
argued that appointment of a special prosecutor was not only
unnecessary, but “it would make the role of the prosecuting
office incredibly difficult if every time an attorney didn’t like
an outcome,” they could “conflict[]” the office out of the mat-
ter by general allegations of ex parte communications.
Defense counsel was in favor of appointment of a special
prosecutor, “[n]ot only because of the allegations of miscon-
duct, but also irregularities in the process.” She elaborated on
these irregularities: “[f]rom drafting of the arrest affidavit to
who signs the arrest affidavit to who holds the preliminary
hearing to how the county handles preliminary hearings, and
so on and so forth,” and she emphasized she was “raising con-
stitutional irregularities here.” She said, “[T]here is enough
here, because . . . Pirsch is an officer of the court, as am I, so
there’s enough here that if I raise an irregularity, there should
be some credence to what I’m trying to say to the Court.” She
confirmed for the court that Rodriguez Morales was “okay
with the additional delays” stemming from appointing a spe-
cial prosecutor.
Pursuant to Neb. Rev. Stat. § 23-1205 (Reissue 2022), the
district court appointed the Attorney General’s office as spe-
cial prosecutor. It explained at the hearing that there were
allegations of improper conduct that created an appearance of
impropriety. In its written order, the court explained it had “sua
sponte raised the issue of a potential conflict with the Sarpy
County Attorney’s [o]ffice.” Following the order, Demetria
Herman, an assistant attorney general, entered her appearance
for the State as special prosecutor.
July 27, 2026, Denial of
Motion to Reconsider
The hearing on Rodriguez Morales’ plea in abatement and
motion to quash, as well as on the Sarpy County Attorney
office’s motion to quash the subpoena, was postponed to
July 27, 2026. The Sarpy County Attorney’s office moved
- 879 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
to reconsider the appointment of the special prosecutor. Pirsch
was again subpoenaed to testify. The Sarpy County Attorney’s
office again moved to quash the subpoena. Only the motion to
reconsider and the motion to quash the subpoena were taken up
at the July 27 hearing.
The Sarpy County Attorney’s office asserted that the district
court’s sua sponte determination of a conflict of interest was
premature and without supporting evidence, permitting defense
counsel to engage in “‘prosecutor shopping.’” It pointed out
there was no evidence of any ex parte communication, nor
factual allegations that Pirsch and the county court judge spoke
about substantive issues related to the case, nor allegations that
Pirsch had a personal conflict of interest. Further, the Sarpy
County Attorney’s office pointed out that if the alleged com-
munication was to ask on defense counsel’s behalf to move the
order of the cases for probable cause hearings, then defense
counsel had notice of the communication. And Pirsch had no
control over the procedures of the county courtroom.
The Sarpy County Attorney’s office argued that the court’s
order “implies that wrongdoing occurred on the part of cer-
tain prosecutors within the Sarpy County Attorney’s [o]ffice,
finding a mere allegation of impropriety as factual without
allowing due process to the Sarpy County Attorney’s office
to defend against such allegation.” Even assuming an ex parte
communication occurred, the remedy should have been recusal
of the judge, rather than removal of the prosecutor’s office.
Also, Pirsch could not be compelled by the defense to be a
witness where there are other viable methods available to
Rodriguez Morales for the introduction of evidence. Finally,
even assuming Pirsch must be a witness or otherwise had a
conflict of interest, the Sarpy County Attorney’s office argued
Pirsch could be screened so disqualification of the entire office
was inappropriate. The office described defense counsel’s sub-
poena of Pirsch as, at best, a “fishing expedition.”
Defense counsel argued the district court did not abuse
its discretion in appointing the special prosecutor because
- 880 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
“[m]isconduct stems from . . . Pirsch’s ex parte communica-
tions or alleged unilateral communication with the county
court judge . . . .” She then pointed to the alleged lack of
the underlying support for the probable cause determination
and “constitutional irregularities” at the hearing. Defense
counsel elaborated that the “constitutional irregularities”
involved defense counsel’s limited access to the courtroom
and the resultant need for Pirsch to convey to the county court
judge defense counsel’s “emergency motion.” Defense coun-
sel explained she was “expected to perform her duties from
inside the enclosed glass holding cell designated for inmates”
and “was prevented from physically accessing the courtroom
or making an emergency motion to the court.” At the same
time, “prosecutors [were] allowed full and unfettered access
to the court.” Defense counsel asserted that her “communica-
tions to the court [were] filtered through the county attor-
ney[,] as was undersigned counsel’s emergency motion which
was ignored,” and that this “defies all notions of fairness and
impartiality of the judiciary.” She supported her complaint
with evidence of a sign outside the courtroom that read:
ATTENTION DEFENDANTS & COUNSEL
If you are here for a preliminary hearing, please have a
seat. Due to limited seating in the courtroom, we ask that
only the County Attorney have a seat at counsel table.
When your case is called, please go to defense table to
address your case.
Defense counsel argued she was “raising not just an ex parte
communication, but misconduct in general”; “[i]t’s about how
things are being handled” in Sarpy County, and she was calling
into question “the procedures and protocol” and “the impartial-
ity of the judiciary.” Defense counsel said Pirsch was a neces-
sary witness because “I can’t testify as to the facts of the case.
The only other person that would know the facts of the case is
. . . Pirsch . . . .” Defense counsel believed that, because of the
appearance of impropriety, she did not need to provide “actual
proof of ex parte communications.”
- 881 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
When pressed by the court for more particulars, defense
counsel elaborated that, on the day of the probable cause hear-
ing in the county court, she told Pirsch she “wanted to get in
as soon as I possibly could,” because she “needed to leave
because I had an emergency with one of my children.” Pirsch
told her that he would “contact or e-mail the Judge and see
if we can see where he’s at.” She then observed Pirsch go
speak to the judge but could not hear what was said because
she had been removed by another county attorney from the
courtroom. She surmised Pirsch was talking to the judge about
her client. She also surmised, based on Pirsch’s informing
her thereafter that Rodriguez Morales’ preliminary hearing
would be last, that they were not speaking about her schedul-
ing request. Closely tied to defense counsel’s allegations was
her complaint that she was not allowed to be in the courtroom
while waiting for Rodriguez Morales’ preliminary hearing and
was unable to approach the judge herself to ask about mov-
ing up the hearing. She apparently was allowed to be present
during the preliminary hearing itself, and the county court did
eventually move up Rodriguez Morales’ preliminary hearing to
accommodate defense counsel’s request.
Following defense counsel’s detailed unsworn description of
events, the district court inquired whether defense counsel her-
self might also be a necessary witness for her claims pertaining
to the preliminary hearing in county court, since she would be
the only person able to rebut certain assertions by Pirsch about
what took place. Defense counsel responded that she believed
Rodriguez Morales’ “right to an attorney of his choice would
go above becoming a necessary witness.”
The court denied the Sarpy County Attorney’s office’s
motion to reconsider its appointment of the special prosecu-
tor. The remaining motions were continued to August 7, 2026,
to allow the court to discuss with the Counsel for Discipline
of the Nebraska Supreme Court defense counsel’s potential
conflict of interest if Pirsch were called to testify.
- 882 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
August 7, 2026, Motion to Quash
Subpoena Dismissed as Moot
At the August 7, 2026, hearing, defense counsel did not
call any witnesses to testify. She submitted into evidence the
transcription of the probable cause hearing. Since Pirsch was
not called as a witness, the court found the Sarpy County
Attorney’s office’s motion to quash the subpoena was moot.
The motion to quash the information and the plea in abate-
ment were taken under advisement, and the parties were given
time to submit briefs. Defense counsel’s briefing on those
motions did not raise any allegations pertaining to Pirsch or
the procedures of the county court for Sarpy County.
Original Quo Warranto Action
We granted the application of the State of Nebraska, through
elected officials—Michael Hilgers, Attorney General, and
Lee Polikov, Sarpy County Attorney (together referred to as
“Relators”)—for leave to commence an original action for
a writ of quo warranto. 1 Relators challenge Herman’s right
to exercise the office of Sarpy County Attorney. They seek
her removal as special prosecutor in the State’s case against
Rodriguez Morales. Relators argue that there was insufficient
evidence to warrant the appointment of a special prosecutor for
a conflict of interest as set forth in § 23-1205.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
In a quo warranto action, the burden of proof rests on the
party asserting a right to the office for which the party has been
ousted. 2
ANALYSIS
[1-3] The question presented in this original action is
whether the Attorney General’s office, and specifically, the
assigned assistant attorney general appointed by the district
1
See Neb. Rev. Stat. §§ 25-21,122 and 24-204 (Reissue 2016).
2
State ex rel. Condon v. Braaten, 320 Neb. 214, 26 N.W.3d 532 (2025).
- 883 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
court, is unlawfully holding or exercising the public office of
the Sarpy County Attorney. The answer depends upon whether
the district court validly exercised its authority by appointing
a special prosecutor for the State’s case against Rodriguez
Morales, thereby preventing the Sarpy County Attorney’s
office from performing its statutory duty to represent the State
in criminal actions within its jurisdiction. A motion for the
appointment of a special prosecutor is addressed to the dis-
cretion of the trial court, and absent an abuse of discretion, a
ruling on such a motion will not be disturbed on appeal. 3 The
abuse of discretion standard of review recognizes there is a
range of rationally available rulings that can be supported by
the facts and governing law in a particular case. 4 Thus, when
an appellate court reviews a trial court’s ruling for an abuse of
discretion, it is considering whether the ruling exceeded the
bounds of permissible choice, given the evidence presented
and the applicable law. 5 We hold that the district court abused
its discretion by appointing a special prosecutor pursuant to
§ 23-1205, over the Sarpy County Attorney office’s objection,
when there was no evidence presented at all, let alone that sup-
ported a disqualifying conflict of interest.
[4,5] The Sarpy County Attorney’s office, as with all other
county attorneys’ offices, is statutorily required to represent
the interests of the State in criminal, civil, and juvenile pro-
ceedings. 6 As relevant here, § 23-1202 requires that “[e]ach
county attorney shall appear on behalf of the state before any
magistrate, and prosecute all complaints made in behalf of the
state of which any magistrate shall have jurisdiction . . . .” The
use of the word “shall” in § 23-1202 indicates a mandatory
directive inconsistent with the idea of discretion. 7
3
State v. Edwards, 286 Neb. 404, 837 N.W.2d 81 (2013).
4
See State v. Damore, 320 Neb. 914, 31 N.W.3d 604 (2026).
5
Id.
6
Neb. Rev. Stat. §§ 23-1202 (Reissue 2022) and 43-261 (Reissue 2016).
7
See State v. Jackson, 320 Neb. 609, 29 N.W.3d 232 (2026).
- 884 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
[6] Under § 23-1205, a special prosecutor may be appointed
to replace the county attorney’s office under the limited circum-
stances of “absence, sickness, disability, or conflict of interest
of the county attorney and his or her deputies, or upon request
of the county attorney for good cause.” Statutes pertaining to
the same subject matter should be construed together as if they
were one law, giving effect to every provision 8 and refraining
from reading into them words that are not there. 9 Thus, we will
not read into § 23-1205 grounds for appointment of a special
prosecutor that are not specifically set forth therein.
The Sarpy County Attorney’s office did not request the
appointment of a special prosecutor. Under the facts and argu-
ments presented below, the only potentially applicable provi-
sion of § 23-1205 was appointment due to a “conflict of inter-
est of the county attorney and his or her deputies.”
[7-9] A conflict of interest exists when a defense attorney
is placed in a situation inherently conducive to divided loy-
alties. 10 The phrase “conflict of interest” denotes situations
where a lawyer’s representation of one client is rendered less
effective by reason of his or her representation of another cli-
ent, where it becomes a lawyer’s duty on behalf of one client
to contend for that which the lawyer’s duty to another cli-
ent would require him or her to oppose, or where fulfilling
a lawyers duty to the client may be to the detriment of the
attorney’s personal interest. 11 We have said that the purpose
of § 23-1205 is the protection of the public by making certain
that a county attorney’s duties shall not be influenced by pri-
vate interests. 12
8
See Dirt Road Development v. Hirschman, 316 Neb. 757, 7 N.W.3d 438
(2024).
9
See Johnson v. Village of Polk, 319 Neb. 352, 23 N.W.3d 96 (2025).
10
State v. Mata, 321 Neb. 566, 36 N.W.3d 432 (2026).
11
See, id.; State v. Malone, 308 Neb. 929, 957 N.W.2d 892 (2021), modified
on denial of rehearing 309 Neb. 399, 959 N.W.2d 818.
12
In re Complaint Against White, 264 Neb. 740, 651 N.W.2d 551 (2002).
- 885 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
The phrase “appearance of impropriety” is not listed in
§ 23-1205 as a reason for appointing a special prosecutor,
and in State v. Kinkennon, 13 we adopted the stance that “[t]he
appearance of impropriety alone is simply too slender a reed
on which to rest a disqualification order except in the rarest
of cases.” 14 An “appearance of impropriety” rests primarily
on perception, rather than actual or even potential conflicts
of interest. 15
[10] For a court to disqualify a county attorney’s office
under § 23-1205 for a conflict of interest, there must be some
reliable evidence presented to support a court’s finding that
there is a situation inherently conducive to divided loyal-
ties. And at no point did defense counsel present evidence
relating to her underlying claims. Whether oral or written,
mere arguments and unsworn fact statements of counsel are
not evidence. 16 But even setting aside the purely speculative
nature of defense counsel’s summation that an ex parte com-
munication had in fact occurred, it is unclear why the district
court may have believed the alleged ex parte communication
between Pirsch, who was no longer the prosecutor assigned
to the case, and the county court judge, who was no longer
presiding, created a conflict of interest for the entire Sarpy
County Attorney’s office in its prosecution of Rodriguez
Morales’ case in district court. Our case law considering ex
parte communications between judges and prosecutors focuses
on whether the judges should have recused themselves 17 and
13
State v. Kinkennon, 275 Neb. 570, 747 N.W.2d 437 (2008).
14
Id. at 577, 747 N.W.2d at 444 (internal quotation marks omitted).
15
See Sigrid Fry-Revere & David Bjorn Malmstrom, More Regulation
of Industry-Supported Biomedical Research: Are We Asking the Right
Questions?, 37 J.L. Med. & Ethics 420, 423 (2009).
16
See State v. Roundtree, 11 Neb. App. 628, 658 N.W.2d 308 (2003).
17
See, State v. Lierman, 305 Neb. 289, 940 N.W.2d 529 (2020); State v.
Thompson, 301 Neb. 472, 919 N.W.2d 122 (2018); State v. Thomas, 268
Neb. 570, 685 N.W.2d 69 (2004); State v. Jenson, 232 Neb. 403, 440
N.W.2d 686 (1989).
- 886 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
does not suggest ex parte communications create attorney
conflicts of interest. An ex parte communication occurs when
a judge communicates with any person concerning a pending
or impending proceeding without notice to an adverse party. 18
There is no reason to believe that ex parte communication
between Pirsch and the county court judge, if it occurred, was
inherently conducive to divided loyalties or otherwise created
for Pirsch a divided loyalty or private interest.
Also, we have held that an objection to an ex parte com-
munication must be timely; “[o]ne cannot know of improper
judicial conduct, gamble on a favorable result by remaining
silent as to that conduct, and then complain that he or she
guessed wrong and does not like the outcome.” 19 At no point
did defense counsel complain in the county court that she
believed the county court judge and Pirsch had engaged in ex
parte communications, which would have given Pirsch and
the county court judge an opportunity to address what defense
counsel had observed. Instead, defense counsel raised the
alleged ex parte communication after the unfavorable outcome
of the county court’s determining there was probable cause to
bind the case over to the district court and after the county
court judge and Pirsch were no longer directly involved in the
case and readily available to respond to the allegations.
[11] The district court’s concern about a potential conflict
of interest may have revolved around defense counsel’s stated
intent to call Pirsch as a witness during a pretrial hearing
and the issuance of subpoenas for that purpose, which was
an undisputed fact. Defense counsel emphasized that Pirsch’s
testimony was necessary not only to discover if Pirsch and
the county court judge had engaged in ex parte communica-
tions about Rodriguez Morales, but also to provide evidence
18
State v. Thomas, supra note 17.
19
State v. Lotter, 255 Neb. 456, 475, 586 N.W.2d 591, 610 (1998), modified
on denial of rehearing 255 Neb. 889, 587 N.W.2d 673 (1999), and
disapproved on other grounds, State v. Hagens, 320 Neb. 65, 26 N.W.3d
174 (2025) (internal quotation marks omitted).
- 887 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
of allegedly unconstitutional county court procedures for
preliminary hearings. The advocate-witness rule discourages
combining roles of advocate and witness in the same pro-
ceeding, recognizing the two different roles could give rise to
conflicts of interest. 20
[12-14] But we have held that a court will not allow
defense counsel to raise the possibility of calling the prosecu-
tor as a witness merely to disqualify the prosecutor from the
trial of the case. 21 Thus, a court cannot order disqualification
simply upon the moving party’s representation that the lawyer
it seeks to disqualify is a necessary witness; the key is the
evidence showing that the lawyer is a necessary witness. 22 A
party seeking to call opposing counsel must prove that coun-
sel is a necessary witness by showing that (1) the proposed
testimony is material and relevant to the determination of
the issues being litigated and (2) the evidence is unobtain-
able elsewhere. 23
There was no evidence that Pirsch’s proposed testimony
was material and relevant to the issues being litigated or
that the evidence was unobtainable elsewhere. The alleged
irregularities were limited to the county court. Yet, defense
counsel did not include them as grounds for the plea in abate-
ment or motion to quash the information. Her reference to
making a record “for appeal for future litigation” did little
to clarify how Pirsch’s testimony was material and relevant to
the issues being litigated before the district court. Indeed, any
20
See, State ex rel. NSBA v. Neumeister, 234 Neb. 47, 449 N.W.2d 17
(1989); Susan P. Shapiro, Bushwhacking the Ethical High Road: Conflict
of Interest in the Practice of Law and Real Life, 28 Law & Soc. Inquiry
87 (2003); § 39:183. See, also, 6 Robert A. Matthews, Jr., Annotated
Patent Digest § 39:183 (Nov. 2026 update) (outlining policy objectives of
advocate-witness rule).
21
See State v. Reeves, 216 Neb. 206, 344 N.W.2d 433 (1984).
22
Beller v. Crow, 274 Neb. 603, 742 N.W.2d 230 (2007), overruled on other
grounds, Heckman v. Marchio, 296 Neb. 458, 894 N.W.2d 296 (2017).
23
See id.
- 888 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
issues Pirsch’s testimony could have shed light on seem better
suited for a postconviction action. Further, defense counsel did
not explain why the evidence of the alleged irregularities could
not be obtained elsewhere. Certainly, defense counsel herself
could have testified, and court staff could have given testimony
of courtroom procedures.
Furthermore, the record reflects that any potential conflict
of interest derived from calling Pirsch as a witness was ren-
dered moot when defense counsel ultimately decided not to call
Pirsch to testify. 24 For this reason, the district court ultimately
ruled that the Sarpy County Attorney’s office’s motion to quash
defense counsel’s subpoena was moot. The district court’s deci-
sion to appoint a special prosecutor before ruling on the motion
to quash the subpoena and before knowing if Pirsch would
actually be called to testify was, if nothing else, premature.
[15-17] Finally, even if Pirsch had a conflict of interest and
even if any such conflict was not rendered moot when he was
not called to testify, it is the general rule that conflicts of inter-
est that arise from the advocate-witness rule are not imputed
to other members of the law office. 25 More broadly, under
any source of a conflict of interest, it follows that because
of the unique constitutional and statutory duties of a county
attorney’s office, the entire county attorney’s office will be
disqualified due to a conflict of one of its attorneys only in the
rarest of situations. 26 We have never held that a conflict of a
deputy county attorney, who handled the preliminary hearing
in county court but is no longer the prosecutor for the case in
district court, is imputed to the other attorneys of the county
attorney’s office. 27 To the contrary, we have held that, so long
as the disqualified attorney is effectively screened from any par-
ticipation in the prosecution of the defendant, the prosecutor’s
24
See State v. Land, 435 N.J. Super. 249, 88 A.3d 193 (2014).
25
See Shapiro, supra note 20.
26
See, e.g., U.S. v. Bolden, 353 F.3d 870 (10th Cir. 2003).
27
See State v. Kinkennon, supra note 13.
- 889 -
Nebraska Supreme Court Advance Sheets
322 Nebraska Reports
STATE EX REL. HILGERS v. HERMAN
Cite as 322 Neb. 873
office may, in general, proceed with the prosecution. 28 This is
in line with the general rule in other jurisdictions that when
an individual prosecutor is disqualified, a different prosecu-
tor in the same office may be appointed, absent some unusual
circumstance warranting disqualification of the entire office. 29
There was no evidence presented below to suggest an unusual
circumstance that warranted disqualification of the entire Sarpy
County Attorney’s office.
The district court’s power to appoint, sua sponte, a special
prosecutor is narrowly circumscribed by statute. There was
no evidence supporting a finding of a conflict of interest, let
alone one that could be imputed to the entire Sarpy County
Attorney’s office. There was no evidence presented at all.
No testimony, affidavits, or exhibits were received into evi-
dence at the pretrial hearings. There was merely defense coun-
sel’s unsworn factual allegations, speculation, and argument.
Without any evidence that could support a conflict of interest,
the district court abused its discretion in disqualifying the
Sarpy County Attorney’s office and appointing a special pros-
ecutor. We enter a judgment ousting the Attorney General’s
office as special prosecutor.
We note that neither party has argued that any acts per-
formed by the special prosecutor until this judgment of ouster
are invalid. Thus, we do not decide this question. However,
we observe that in other cases, it has been held that the acts
of a de jure officer appointed as de facto special prosecutor
are valid. 30 In this original action, the Attorney General is not
28
Id.
29
6 Wayne R. LaFave et al., Criminal Procedure § 22.5(a) (5th ed. 2025).
30
See, United States v. Lindsley, 148 F.2d 22 (7th Cir. 1945); Ex parte
Johnson, 15 Neb. 512, 19 N