State v. Miller
CourtNebraska Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 17, 2026
DocketA-25-910
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE NEBRASKA COURT OF APPEALS
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND JUDGMENT ON APPEAL
(Memorandum Web Opinion)
STATE V. MILLER
NOTICE: THIS OPINION IS NOT DESIGNATED FOR PERMANENT PUBLICATION
AND MAY NOT BE CITED EXCEPT AS PROVIDED BY NEB. CT. R. APP. P. § 2-102(E).
STATE OF NEBRASKA, APPELLEE,
V.
COREY R. MILLER, APPELLANT.
Filed November 17, 2026. No. A-25-910.
Appeal from the District Court for Lancaster County: RYAN S. POST, Judge. Affirmed.
Brett McArthur, of the Law Office of Brett McArthur, for appellant.
Michael T. Hilgers, Attorney General, and Jacob M. Waggoner for appellee.
RIEDMANN, Chief Judge, and BISHOP and WELCH, Judges.
WELCH, Judge.
INTRODUCTION
Corey R. Miller appeals his conviction for violation of a domestic abuse protection order
with a prior offense. On appeal, he assigns as error that the district court erred in denying his
motion to suppress, allowing Rule 404 evidence of his prior bad acts into evidence, failing to allow
him to provide a complete defense of his choosing, imposing an excessive sentence, and that his
trial counsel was deficient. For the reasons set forth herein, we affirm.
STATEMENT OF FACTS
In November 2023, Miller, who was incarcerated, sent a letter to his ex-girlfriend’s father,
with a portion of the letter directed to her. Because a protection order had previously been issued
in favor of the ex-girlfriend and was still in effect, the State charged Miller with violation of a
domestic abuse protection order.
-1-
A jury trial was held in May 2025. At the conclusion of the trial, the jury was deadlocked
and unable to reach a verdict and the court declared a mistrial. Following a second jury trial in
September 2025, Miller was convicted of the charged offense.
As relevant to this appeal, prior to trial, Miller filed a motion to suppress evidence of
statements he made to officers while he was incarcerated; the State filed a Rule 404 motion seeking
to introduce evidence that Miller previously violated the protection order against him; and the State
asserted motions in limine to exclude certain details governing Miller’s prior relationship with his
ex-girlfriend and “any mention of . . . Miller not having any further communication with the
protected party in this case after the letter was sent” on the basis that all such information was not
relevant to the present charge. The court denied Miller’s motion to suppress and, at trial, allowed
evidence of prior protection order violations but not the convictions thereon. The court also granted
the State’s motions in limine on the basis that certain details governing Miller’s prior relationship
and his proposed assertion that he did not communicate with her after issuing the letter was not
relevant to the charged offense.
Following Miller’s conviction, and an enhancement hearing regarding Miller’s prior
convictions, the district court sentenced Miller to a term of 2 years’ imprisonment. This appeal
followed.
ASSIGNMENTS OF ERROR
On appeal, Miller assigns as error that the district court erred in (1) denying his motion to
suppress; (2) allowing Rule 404 evidence of his prior bad acts in as evidence in front of the jury
as it was propensity evidence and was more prejudicial than probative; (3) failing to allow him to
provide a complete defense of his choosing; and (4) imposing an excessive sentence. He also
contends that his trial counsel was deficient.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
When reviewing a trial court’s ruling on a motion to suppress based on a claimed violation
of the Fourth Amendment, an appellate court applies a two-part standard of review. State v. Perry,
318 Neb. 613, 17 N.W.3d 504 (2025). Regarding historical facts, an appellate court reviews the
trial court’s findings for clear error, but whether those facts trigger or violate Fourth Amendment
protections is a question of law that an appellate court reviews independently of the trial court’s
determination. Id.
Where the Nebraska Evidence Rules commit the evidentiary question at issue to the
discretion of the trial court, an appellate court reviews the admissibility of evidence for an abuse
of discretion. State v. Ramos, 319 Neb. 511, 23 N.W.3d 640 (2025). A judicial abuse of discretion
exists only when the reasons or rulings of a trial judge are clearly untenable, unfairly depriving a
litigant of a substantial right and denying a just result in matters submitted for disposition. Id.
The determination of whether procedures afforded an individual comport with
constitutional requirements for procedural due process presents a question of law. State v.
McCurry, 296 Neb. 40, 891 N.W.2d 663 (2017).
An appellate court will not disturb a sentence imposed within the statutory limits absent an
abuse of discretion by the trial court. State v. Rejai, 320 Neb. 599, 29 N.W.3d 225 (2026). An
-2-
abuse of discretion occurs when a trial court’s decision is based upon reasons that are untenable or
unreasonable or if its action is clearly against justice or conscience, reason, and evidence. Id.
Whether a claim of ineffective assistance of trial counsel may be determined on direct
appeal is a question of law. In reviewing claims of ineffective assistance of counsel on direct
appeal, an appellate court decides only whether the undisputed facts contained within the record
are sufficient to conclusively determine whether counsel did or did not provide effective assistance
and whether the defendant was or was not prejudiced by counsel’s alleged deficient performance.
State v. Delgado, 322 Neb. 364, 39 N.W.3d 476 (2026).
ANALYSIS
DENIAL OF MOTION TO SUPPRESS
Miller first assigns and argues that the district court erred in denying his motion to suppress
certain statements he made to officers while he was incarcerated. But although the district court
denied Miller’s motion to suppress certain statements, Miller failed to object during trial or renew
his motion when the statements were testified to at trial.
Where there has been a pretrial ruling regarding the admissibility of evidence, a party must
make a timely and specific objection to the evidence when it is offered at trial in order to preserve
any error for appellate review. State v. Lowman, 308 Neb. 482, 954 N.W.2d 905 (2021). And more
specifically as to a ruling on a pretrial motion to suppress, “[t]he failure to object to evidence at
trial, even though the evidence was the subject of a previous motion to suppress, waives the
objection, and a party will not be heard to complain of the alleged error on appeal.” Id. at 490, 954
N.W.2d at 915.
Having failed to object or renew his motion at the time of trial to the testimony that was
the subject of Miller’s motion to suppress, Miller has failed to preserve the suppression issue for
appellate review.
RULE 404 EVIDENCE
Miller next argues that the district court erred in granting the State’s Rule 404 motion
governing the admissibility of testimony about Miller’s prior violations of the protection order.
Miller argues that the court erred in allowing testimony about his prior violations because it
constituted propensity evidence of prior bad acts and did not fall under any exceptions stated within
Rule 404 which would allow its admission. But a more thorough examination of Rule 404 and its
exceptions is not warranted on this record.
During Miller’s case-in-chief, Miller himself testified to having violated the protection
order in the past, and that his intent in issuing the letter on this occasion was to provide some
closure to his relationship with his ex-girlfriend. During this line of testimony, Miller
acknowledged having tried to get around the protection order in the past including by sending his
ex-girlfriend a letter with someone else’s name on it and using another inmate’s phone account to
call her.
But as the Nebraska Supreme Court held in State v. Surber, 311 Neb. 320, 333, 972 N.W.2d
64, 74 (2022), “[t]he introduction of evidence by the defense waives any objection to the earlier
introduction of evidence on the same subject by the State.” Because Miller introduced evidence in
-3-
his case-in-chief on the same subject matter offered by the State which he claims was erroneously
allowed into evidence by the district court, Miller waived this assignment of error.
PREVENTION OF PRESENTING COMPLETE DEFENSE
Miller next contends that the district court erred in sustaining the State’s motions in limine,
which prohibited the introduction of evidence from Miller governing certain details about his
relationship with his ex-girlfriend prior to the issuance of his letter, and that, after sending the
letter, he no longer violated the protection order.
Miller’s entire argument in support of this assignment is that
First, [he] was not allowed to adduce any evidence or testimony about the nature and
circumstances of his relationship with the protected party. This was necessary to show why
he sent a letter to [his ex-girlfriend’s father] giving [Miller] closure. Second, the fact that
there had not been any additional alleged protection order violations since the time the
letter was written to [his ex-girlfriend’s father,] goes to show the intent that [Miller] had
when he sent that letter.
Brief for appellant at 13. Miller argues that these pretrial rulings denied him the opportunity to
present a complete defense.
“Whether rooted directly in the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment or in the
Compulsory Process or Confrontation Clauses of the 6th Amendment, the federal Constitution
guarantees criminal defendants a meaningful opportunity to present a complete defense.” State v.
Ramos, 319 Neb. 511, 547, 23 N.W.3d 640, 668 (2025), cert. denied ___ U.S. ___, 146 S. Ct.
1477, 223 L. Ed. 2d 539 (2026). However, this general rule is not without limitation. As the
Nebraska Supreme Court further noted in Ramos, “[d]efendants have a constitutional right to a
meaningful opportunity to present a complete defense, but this right is not without evidentiary
limits.” State v. Ramos, 319 Neb. at 548-49, 23 N.W.3d at 669. “[T]he accused does not have an
unfettered right to offer testimony that is incompetent, privileged, or otherwise inadmissible under
standard rules of evidence.” Id. at 549, 23 N.W.3d at 669.
Prior to trial, the district court granted the State’s motions in limine requesting that the
court prohibit Miller from mentioning:
1. Any reference or mention of the birth certificate[s] for any of the children of
[Miller’s ex-girlfriend;]
2. Any reference or mention of the reason for the end of [Miller’s ex-girlfriend] and
“Amber’s” friendship[;]
3. Any reference or mention of [Miller’s ex-girlfriend’s] husband’s or ex-husband’s
knowledge of [the ex-girlfriend’s] relationship with [Miller] or to the same’s reaction or
response to the relationship of [the ex-girlfriend’s] relationship with [Miller;]
4. Any reference or mention of [Miller] proposing marriage to [his ex-girlfriend] or
her response to any such proposal[; and]
5. Any reference or mention of any communication or photograph [Miller’s
ex-girlfriend] made to [Miller] indicating her desire to harm herself or commit suicide.
-4-
Additionally, the court granted the State’s oral motion to prohibit Miller from adducing evidence
that he did not attempt to contact his ex-girlfriend after he sent the letter which led to the current
charge.
Notwithstanding these rulings, at trial, Miller argued that the purpose of his letter was to
gain “closure” with his ex-girlfriend. So, as it relates to his specific assignment that he was denied
the opportunity to make a complete defense as to his rationale for violating the domestic abuse
protection order, we reject that contention. But more importantly, assuming that Miller is arguing
that he was legally entitled to elicit all of the information that was the subject of the State’s motions
in limine, we disagree. Miller was charged with violating a protection order which he had
previously violated. And regardless of the details raised by the State in its motions in limine
governing his prior relationship at the time he sent the letter, or regardless of whether this was the
last time he intended to violate the order, that information did not make his violation any less of a
crime. As such, the additional information Miller sought to elicit was not relevant and the court
did not err in excluding it. And because the right to a complete defense does not include the right
to offer evidence otherwise in violation of the rules of evidence, we reject Miller’s assignment of
error.
EXCESSIVE SENTENCE
Miller next contends that the district court imposed an excessive sentence. He contends
that the district court “abused its discretion by overemphasizing the nature of the offense while
ignoring the possibility of rehabilitation” and failed to take into account his limited drug history
“or the lack of credible evidence on the amount of drugs [he] had previously possessed or sold.”
Brief for appellant at 15.
Miller was convicted of violation of a domestic abuse protection order with a prior offense,
which is a Class IV felony. See Neb. Rev. Stat. § 42-924(4) (Cum. Supp. 2024). We note that this
section was transferred to Neb. Rev. Stat. § 26-103 (Supp. 2025) effective September 3, 2025.
Miller’s sentence of 2 years’ imprisonment is within the statutory sentencing range for Class IV
felonies which are punishable by a minimum of no imprisonment and a maximum of 2 years’
imprisonment and 0 to 12 months’ post-release supervision, a fine of $10,000, or both. See Neb.
Rev. Stat. § 28-105 (Cum. Supp. 2024).
Where a sentence imposed within the statutory limits is alleged on appeal to be excessive,
the appellate court must determine whether a sentencing court abused its discretion in considering
and applying the relevant factors, as well as any applicable legal principles in determining the
sentence to be imposed. State v. Jones, 318 Neb. 840, 19 N.W.3d 499 (2025).
When imposing a sentence, the sentencing court is to consider the defendant’s (1) age, (2)
mentality, (3) education and experience, (4) social and cultural background, (5) past criminal
record or record of law-abiding conduct, and (6) motivation for the offense, as well as (7) the
nature of the offense, and (8) the amount of violence involved in the commission of the crime. Id.
However, the sentencing court is not limited to any mathematically applied set of factors. Id. The
appropriateness of a sentence is necessarily a subjective judgment that includes the sentencing
judge’s observations of the defendant’s demeanor and attitude and all the facts and circumstances
surrounding the defendant’s life. Id.
-5-
We note that Miller’s claim that the court failed to properly weigh the relevant factors
relating to sentencing is merely a request for this court to conduct its own de novo review of those
factors. It is not the proper function of an appellate court to conduct a de novo review of the record
to determine what sentence it would impose. State v. Hagens, 320 Neb. 65, 26 N.W.3d 174 (2025).
According to the presentence investigation report, Miller was 36 years old, single and had
one dependent. He had obtained a GED and an associate’s degree and he served in the Army
Reserves from 2019 to 2021, at which time he was discharged after being incarcerated. Miller’s
criminal history includes eight convictions for violating a protection order and one conviction each
for disorderly conduct, criminal mischief ($500-$1,500), and injuring or destroying the property
of another. The level of service/case management inventory assessed Miller as a high risk to
reoffend. He admitted to using alcohol, marijuana, cocaine, and mushrooms. The victim submitted
a victim impact statement that stated that she believed that the letters sent by Miller to her family
members “were sent with the intent to bring emotional harm. And indeed, they have.” The victim
stated that “Miller’s continued contact has resulted in distress that I must continue to work through
to maintain a healthy life not only for myself, but for that of my family.” She further stated that,
during the last 5 years, she has expended more than $50,000 in psychological care. The victim
further stated that the worst part of Miller’s offenses “is living in a chronic state of fear.”
Based on factors including that the sentence imposed is within the statutory sentencing
range, Miller’s criminal history including multiple violations of protection orders, his high risk to
reoffend, and the distress Miller’s actions have caused the victim, we find that the district court
did not abuse its discretion in the sentence imposed.
INEFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL
Miller’s final assignment of error is that “[t]rial counsel was deficient.” Brief for appellant
at 6. This general assignment of ineffective assistance that does not specify counsel’s deficiency
is insufficient to raise the claim on direct appeal, and we do not address it further. See State v.
Mrza, 302 Neb. 931, 926 N.W.2d 79 (2019), disapproved on other grounds, State v. Hagens, supra
(assignments of error on direct appeal regarding ineffective assistance of trial counsel must
specifically allege deficient performance, and appellate court will not scour remainder of brief in
search of such specificity).
CONCLUSION
For the reasons set forth herein, we affirm Miller’s conviction and sentence.
AFFIRMED.
-6-