Full Opinion

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF KANSAS No. 129,295 STATE OF KANSAS, Appellee, v. CARLOS ANDERSON-HONEYCUTT, Appellant. SYLLABUS BY THE COURT 1. Evidence is exculpatory for Brady purposes if it tends to disprove a fact in issue which is material to guilt or punishment. 2. When evidence was not favorable to the defense, its suppression does not violate Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 87, 83 S. Ct. 1194, 10 L. Ed. 2d 215 (1963). Appeal from Sedgwick District Court; JEFFREY GOERING, judge. Oral argument held September 14, 2026. Opinion filed November 20, 2026. Affirmed. Kristen B. Patty, of Wichita, argued the cause and was on the brief for appellant. Julie A. Koon, assistant district attorney, argued the cause, and Marc Bennett, district attorney, and Kris W. Kobach, attorney general, were with her on the brief for appellee. 1 The opinion of the court was delivered by ROSEN, C.J.: Carlos Anderson-Honeycutt was convicted of first-degree premeditated murder for killing Brittnee Wicker. He moved for a new trial, arguing that the State had committed a Brady violation by failing to disclose evidence before the conclusion of trial. The district court denied the motion. This is Anderson -Honeycutt's direct appeal. We affirm the district court. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND In November 2023, Connie Wicker found her daughter, Brittnee Wicker, dead in the home Brittnee shared with her boyfriend Anderson-Honeycutt. Wicker had two gunshot wounds to the head. The State charged Anderson-Honeycutt for Wicker's death. It theorized that Anderson-Honeycutt premeditated the killing, then staged the scene to make it look like a gang member had killed Wicker, and lied to police to cover up his involvement. Anderson-Honeycutt eventually admitted to shooting and killing Wicker, but he claimed it was not premeditated. He testified that a few days before the shooting, Wicker had broken up with him after discovering he had cheated on her. Upon being told the relationship was going to end, Anderson-Honeycutt called the police to tell them he was having suicidal thoughts. This resulted in Anderson-Honeycutt spending three days in the hospital. Anderson-Honeycutt testified that Wicker picked him up from the hospital on November 11 and took him back to their home. The two had sex, and Anderson- Honeycutt packed up his belongings while they continued to talk about the relationship and Wicker confirmed it was over. Anderson-Honeycutt thought he could change Wicker's mind if they went out together, so he tried to ask her to go to a club wit h him. 2 Wicker got upset and told Anderson-Honeycutt that she had oral sex with another man while Anderson-Honeycutt had been in the hospital. Anderson-Honeycutt testified that upon hearing this news, he pointed a gun at his own head and walked toward Wicker. Wicker then hit Anderson-Honeycutt and grabbed the gun and Anderson-Honeycutt shot Wicker twice. After confirming Wicker was dead, Anderson-Honeycutt grabbed some belongings, the gun, and Wicker's credit and debit cards, then switched the license plate on Wicker's car, and fled to Mexico. When authorities eventually located Anderson - Honeycutt, he denied any involvement in Wicker's murder. As part of the investigation, officers interviewed Wicker's neighbor, Jasa Finkbeiner, who lived across the street. Finkbeiner told Officer Koby Mackey she had a motion and sound-activated doorbell camera and let him use her phone to see the short video clips captured by her camera. Officer Mackey's body camera recorded this interaction. That footage showed that Finkbeiner's camera captured 292 videos on the day of Wicker's death. Detective Robert Chisholm spoke with Finkbeiner later in the investigation so that he could look for videos from her doorbell camera from a specific timeframe. He also used Finkbeiner's phone to view the video her camera captured. Chisholm used his own phone to record his use of Finkbeiner's phone. This recording showed small thumbnail snippets of each video and indicated how long each video was, when it was recorded, and what triggered the recording. Before leaving, Chisholm told Finkbe iner not to delete any videos, but at some time prior to these proceedings, Finkbeiner cleared them from her storage. The State provided initial discovery to the defense on January 2, 2024. This discovery included the Mackey body camera footage. The State provided additional 3 discovery in March, April, and July of 2024. None of these disclosures included the recording Chisholm took on his phone of the videos captured by Finkbeiner's doorbell camera. On February 18, 2025, the case detective sent the prosecutor an email indicating he was forwarding him some evidentiary "documents" that he had not yet sent over. These items included Chisholm's phone recording. On February 21, 2025, Anderson-Honeycutt waived his right to a jury trial. Counsel for defendant and the defense investigator met with the prosecution for a discovery review in March 2025. The prosecutor showed them everything that the State had on its discovery drive and on evidence.com. The prosecution was unaware at the time that the items sent by the detective on February 18, 2025, had not yet been processed and placed on the drive or evidence.com. The case proceeded to a bench trial, and the court convicted Anderson -Honeycutt of premeditated first-degree murder on March 26, 2025. On March 27, 2025, the February 18th evidentiary "documents" from the detective were added to the discovery folder. Anderson-Honeycutt filed a motion for new trial on the same day. At some point between March 27, 2025, and April 17, 2025, the prosecution alerted the defense to this newly uploaded discovery, which included the Chisholm video. On May 22, 2025, Anderson-Honeycutt supplemented his motion for new trial to argue that the belated disclosure of the Chisholm video constituted a Brady violation. After an evidentiary hearing, the district court denied the motion. Anderson - Honeycutt filed this appeal. 4 ANALYSIS Anderson-Honeycutt argues he is entitled to a new trial because the State committed a Brady violation when it failed to disclose the Chisholm video before trial. Standard of Review An appellate court reviews a district court's decision on a motion for new trial for an abuse of discretion. State v. Breitenbach, 313 Kan. 73, 97, 483 P.3d 448 (2021). A district court abuses its discretion if its decision is arbitrary, fanciful, or unreasonable; is based on an error of law; or is based on an error of fact. State v. Younger, 320 Kan. 98, 137-38, 564 P.3d 744 (2025). Whether a Brady violation occurred is ultimately a legal question subject to de novo review, but this court gives deference to any of the district court's findings of fact embedded in that inquiry. State v. Collins, 319 Kan. 439, 443, 555 P.3d 693 (2024). Discussion The Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution prohibits the State from depriving "any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law." U.S. Const. amend. XIV, § 1. This due process guarantee imposes an affirmative duty on the prosecution in a criminal case "to disclose evidence favorable to the accused," including exculpatory and impeachment evidence. State v. DeWeese, 305 Kan. 699, 710, 387 P.3d 809 (2017); Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 87, 83 S. Ct. 1194, 10 L. Ed. 2d 215 (1963) ("[T]he suppression by the prosecution of evidence favorable to an accused upon request violates due process where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment, irrespective of the good faith or bad faith of the prosecution ."). 5 A defendant must establish the following three elements to prove a Brady violation occurred: "'(1) The evidence at issue must be favorable to the accused, either because it is exculpatory, or because it is impeaching; (2) that evidence must have been suppressed by the State, either willfully or inadvertently; and (3) the evidence must be material so as to establish prejudice.'" DeWeese, 305 Kan. at 710 (quoting State v. Moore, 302 Kan. 685, 700, 357 P.3d 275 [2015]). In considering whether evidence was material, this court decides whether "'there is a reasonable probability that, had the evidence been disclosed to the defense, the result of the proceeding would have been different. A "reasonable probability" is a proba bility sufficient to undermine confidence in the outcome.'" DeWeese, 305 Kan. at 710 (quoting State v. Williams, 303 Kan. 585, 597, 363 P.3d 1101 [2016]). Anderson-Honeycutt argues that the prosecution committed a Brady violation when it withheld Detective Chisholm's body camera video. The parties agree that Anderson-Honeycutt established the second element of a Brady violation because the State inadvertently suppressed that footage. But they disagree on whether Anderson - Honeycutt showed the Chisholm video met the first and third elements of a Brady violation. In district court, Anderson-Honeycutt argued that the Chisholm video was exculpatory and material because it could have supported his defense that the killing was not premeditated. He pointed to a list of 15 clips from the Chisholm video that indicated the doorbell camera was triggered periodically throughout the evening leading to Wicker's death. He argued that these clips would have substantiated his claim that he had been packing his car all afternoon and planning to move out of the house as Wicker had requested. He also argued that, had he known these clips existed , he would have introduced a text from Wicker in which she stated that Anderson -Honeycutt was packing his things but would stay the night. He contended this all would have supported his 6 defense that he did not act with premeditation because it showed that the house was "calm, peaceful, and not chaotic" before Wicker was shot. Anderson -Honeycutt also pointed out that Chisholm's video indicated there was a clip recorded from around the time Wicker was shot; he argued that recording may have shown the gunshots were very close in time and thus the shooting was not premeditated. The district court concluded that Anderson-Honeycutt failed to establish the Chisholm video was favorable or material. We conclude the district court did not abuse its discretion when it denied the motion for new trial. Brady element 1: The district court made no error in concluding the Chisholm video was not favorable to Anderson-Honeycutt. The district court rejected Anderson-Honeycutt's claim that the Chisholm video was exculpatory and thus favorable. It ruled that the only thing the Chisholm video showed was that there were 292 doorbell camera recordings from the day of Wicker's murder, and this fact was established by the Mackey video. The caselaw supports the court's conclusion. "[E]vidence is exculpatory if it tends to disprove a fact in issue which is material to guilt or punishment." Breitenbach, 313 Kan. at 97-98. Because it was not a fact at issue that the doorbell camera captured 292 videos, a video establishing that fact is not exculpatory. Anderson-Honeycutt does nothing to attack the district court's observation that the existence of the 292 videos was not a fact at issue. Instead, he insists that the Chisholm video added additional facts, i.e. time stamps, a short clip, and the reason for the recording. He claims these things were exculpatory because they may have shown h e was packing throughout the evening and that the gunshots were close in time. It is at 7 times unclear if he is arguing that the Chisholm video alone would have done this, or if the Chisholm video would have prompted him to acquire the full videos, and those would have supported his defense. Either way, the argument fails. Anderson-Honeycutt has not established that this extra information in the Chisholm video was exculpatory. None of the short clips on the video are clear enough or long enough to depict Anderson-Honeycutt packing his car, and they do not have sound so they cannot support the theory that the gunshots were close in time. As the district court concluded, the Chisholm video tends to prove nothing more than that there were 292 videos captured—which was not a fact at issue. Any argument that the Chisholm video would have prompted Anderson -Honeycutt to retrieve the full videos does not satisfy a Brady analysis. Anderson-Honeycutt offers no authority supporting the notion that the Brady test inquires whether withheld evidence would have pushed the investigation in a different direction had it not been withheld. Instead, the Brady test asks whether the withheld evidence itself was exculpatory or impeaching. See United States v. Kennedy, 819 F. Supp. 1510, 1519 (D. Colo. 1993) ("Brady requires the production of material information which is 'favorable to the accused,' that is, exculpatory information, not information which is merely, 'not inculpatory' and might therefore form the groundwork for some argument for the defendant."). Moreover, even if we were to look at whether the full 292 video recordings would have been exculpatory, Anderson-Honeycutt has not shown that they would have been. Those videos are no longer available and, consequently, no one knows what they would reveal. Anderson-Honeycutt only speculates that they would reveal him calmly packing his car and would have captured the gunshot sounds. 8 In sum, the district court made no error in concluding that the Chisholm video was not exculpatory and thus not favorable. We can affirm the district court's ruling on this basis alone because there can be no Brady violation if the evidence was not favorable to the defense. See DeWeese, 305 Kan. at 710 (defendant must establish all three elements to show a Brady violation). We affirm the district court's conclusion that there was no Brady violation and its decision denying Anderson-Honeycutt's motion for new trial. Affirmed. 9