Full Opinion

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF IOWA _______________ No. 25-1206 Filed November 18, 2026 _______________ State of Iowa, Plaintiff–Appellee, v. Ashton Wayne Root, Defendant–Appellant. _______________ Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Buchanan County, The Honorable Joel Dalrymple, Judge. _______________ AFFIRMED _______________ Matthew L. Noel of Noel Law Office, Dubuque, attorney for appellant. Brenna Bird, Attorney General, and David Banta, Assistant Attorney General, attorneys for appellee. _______________ Considered without oral argument by Schumacher, P.J., and Langholz and Sandy, JJ. Opinion by Sandy, J. 1 SANDY, Judge. Ashton Root appeals his conviction for assault with intent to inflict serious injury, a lesser included offense of the attempted murder charge on which the jury acquitted him. He contends the district court should have declared a mistrial after the jury heard a recorded reference to unrelated pending charges in violation of the court’s order in limine, and that the evidence was insufficient to sustain the conviction. Because the court acted within its discretion when it chose to cure the evidentiary error by redaction and instruction, and because substantial evidence supports each element of the offense, we affirm. BACKGROUND FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS Michael Root lived in Winthrop with his wife, Brenda, and their two adult sons, Asa and the defendant, Ashton Root. For years Michael drove a truck for a living, a job that kept him on the road much of the time. That changed around April 2024, when he lost the job and began spending far more time at home. The added time together strained the household. Brenda described the family’s interactions as teasing and bickering that could “get a little physical” but, in her words, “never rose to anything seriously physical.” By late April, the friction between Michael and Ashton had sharpened, and on the evening of April 26, Michael told Ashton he should leave the home. The following morning, April 27, was Winthrop’s annual “junk day,” when residents set unwanted items at the curb for free collection. Michael and Asa spent the morning carrying items out of the house. An argument arose over what was being discarded, with Ashton contending that some of his belongings were being thrown away. As Michael walked out the front door, he was shot. The bullet traveled a roughly horizontal path, entering his abdomen and striking his right forearm. 2 Asa was setting trash at the curb when he heard the gunshot. He did not see the shooting, but he saw his father walking toward him bleeding. Asa drove Michael to the Buchanan County Health Center. Ashton remained at the house. Michael was later transferred to the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, where a surgeon operated and removed bullet fragments; his injuries were not life-threatening. From his first contact with hospital staff, Michael said he believed his son had shot him, and he repeated that account to the nurses, to responding law enforcement, and, after surgery, to the operating surgeon. Deputies, who responded to the hospital first, secured a handgun found in Michael’s pocket. Agents of the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) went to the Root residence, where they observed blood and tissue on and around the front door; the spatter pattern suggested the shot had been fired from inside the house toward the outside, and later DNA testing confirmed the blood was Michael’s. An agent interviewed Ashton at the scene. Ashton told investigators that Michael had been handling Ashton’s Taurus .357 revolver and that the gun discharged when Michael dropped it; Ashton said he then picked the gun up and threw it into a corner of the room. Officers recovered a Taurus .357 revolver in that room with one spent cartridge inside. A DCI firearms examiner later testified that the revolver was in good working order and was designed so that it would not fire if dropped. Two days after the shooting, DCI Special Agent Jon Turbett interviewed Michael in the hospital, and the interview was recorded in a roughly ninety-minute audio file, which the State later introduced at trial. In it, Michael again said he believed Ashton had shot him. The recording also included, in its final minutes, references to Ashton being “on paper” and out 3 on bail in connection with unrelated conduct involving a gun and methamphetamine. The State charged Root by trial information with attempt to commit murder in violation of Iowa Code section 707.11(1) (2024). Both parties moved in limine before trial, and the district court granted both motions in full. Relevant here, Root’s motion sought to exclude any reference to his prior convictions or pending charges. At trial, Michael testified he recalled little of what he had told his medical providers and the investigators, and on cross- examination he stated that he did not believe Root shot him. The State relied in large part on Michael’s earlier out-of-court statements, which it introduced through other witnesses and recordings. The mistrial dispute arose during the State’s examination of Agent Turbett, when the audio file exhibit was published in its entirety to the jury and the jury then heard the closing references to Root’s unrelated pending criminal charges. Root immediately moved for a mistrial, arguing that the publication violated the court’s order in limine. The parties disputed responsibility for the error, and they continue to do so on appeal. The State maintained it had intended to play only selected portions of the recording and that the final three minutes reached the jury only because Root insisted the exhibit be published in full. Root responded that the State controlled the exhibit, had already reviewed its contents, and had offered it into evidence unredacted, and so defense counsel reasonably assumed the recording already conformed to the limine ruling. The district court denied the motion for mistrial. The court found that the challenged references had been made “in passing” and were not “the main focus of the trial,” and it concluded that a cautionary instruction could cure any prejudice. The court addressed the matter through a curative 4 instruction in the final charge rather than a contemporaneous admonition, and it directed the State to redact the offending material, separately designating the redacted recording and the unredacted recording. The curative instruction told the jury that “any reference, if made, to a pending charge of the defendant shall be disregarded” and was not to be considered in deliberations. A separate instruction, number 12, directed the jury that a witness’s prior inconsistent out-of-court statements could be used only to assess the witness’s credibility and not as substantive evidence. In denying the mistrial, the court characterized the evidence against Root as “ample” though “not overwhelming,” observing that “[a]ll fingers point to Mr. Root” while noting that the State’s proof was comparatively weaker on the element of intent. The case went to the jury after the close of evidence. The jury reported itself deadlocked after roughly two hours, was sent home for the night, and resumed deliberations the next morning. On the next day, it acquitted Root of attempted murder and found him guilty of the lesser included offense of assault with intent to inflict serious injury, an aggravated misdemeanor under Iowa Code section 708.2(1). The district court sentenced Root to an indeterminate term not to exceed two years’ imprisonment, imposed and suspended an $855 fine, and entered a five-year no-contact order protecting Michael. Root raises two issues on appeal: whether the district court abused its discretion in denying his motion for mistrial, and whether the evidence was sufficient to sustain the conviction. 5 STANDARD OF REVIEW We review the denial of a mistrial for abuse of discretion, affording the district court considerable discretion and reversing only where the record lends no support to its ruling. State v. Kieffer, 17 N.W.3d 651, 658 (Iowa 2025). We review a sufficiency challenge for correction of errors at law, upholding the verdict if, when considering the record in the light most favorable to the State, substantial evidence supports the verdict. State v. Lee, 6 N.W.3d 703, 706–07 (Iowa 2024). DISCUSSION I. Mistrial Near the end of the ninety-minute recording, the jury heard references to Root being “on paper” and out on bail for unrelated conduct involving a gun and methamphetamine. Root’s brief characterizes the inadmissible evidence as follows: “Michael made mention that Ashton had pending charges for possession of methamphetamine and charges involving the possession of a shotgun.” The State’s brief characterizes it like this: “The three minutes at issue contained references to Root being ‘on paper’ and out on bail for conduct involving ‘guns and meth.’”1 The verbatim exchange occurred as follows: MICHAEL: Ash is also, uh, he’s on some paper for some other bullshit that he got himself into. INVESTIGATOR: Okay. 1 We disagree with the State’s characterization that the exhibit was published “in full” only because Root insisted on it. Even though defense counsel requested “that the exhibit be published,” nowhere did counsel use the phrase “in full.” 6 MICHAEL: I think this kind of goes against that. INVESTIGATOR: Like this would be a violation of his probation or something? MICHAEL: Well, it’s not his probation, but he’s out on bail. INVESTIGATOR: Okay. MICHAEL: But, in fact, I was the one [unclear] for his bail. INVESTIGATOR: I don’t know about that. I heard he’d been pulled over a while back, maybe? Maybe there was a drug thing or something like that? MICHAEL: Yeah, there was some stupid shit. He went out to haul somebody’s truck back to the shop to fix, and they found something in the bed of his pickup. INVESTIGATOR: Sounds like some methamphetamine, maybe, or something? MICHAEL: Some shit like that. INVESTIGATOR: Yeah, that’s what I heard. MICHAEL: So I had nothing to do with that. I really asked no questions. He also had some of my guns, or at least one of them, in the truck at the time, and they took that shit too. INVESTIGATOR: That’s a bad combo. You don’t want to have guns with drugs. That gets everybody all excited. You don’t want to do that. MICHAEL: I don’t know why the hell he had my damn shotgun with him. INVESTIGATOR: Yeah, he’s not doing you any favors there. MICHAEL: Yeah, no shit. I haven’t seen that for a few months. The State concedes the jury should not have heard the reference to Root’s pending charges. The parties dispute who is responsible, but we need not resolve that dispute, because the court acted within its discretion even if 7 the fault lay entirely with the State. When inadmissible evidence reaches the jury and the court takes corrective action, a mistrial is required only in the extreme case where the prejudicial effect of the evidence remains despite that action and influences the jury. See State v. Brotherton, 384 N.W.2d 375, 381 (Iowa 1986). In making that assessment, we consider the severity and pervasiveness of the error, its significance to the central issues, the strength of the State’s evidence, the curative measures taken, and the extent to which the defense invited the error. See State v. Graves, 668 N.W.2d 860, 869 (Iowa 2003) Those considerations support the district court’s ruling. The reference occupied about three minutes of a ninety-minute recording and was never repeated—the kind of isolated lapse our cases treat as curable. See State v. Newell, 710 N.W.2d 6, 32–33 (Iowa 2006). And though the reference mentioned a gun, it added little to what the jury already knew from Root’s own account: the revolver was his, and he handled it moments after the shot. The contested question was whether he fired it deliberately, and a passing mention of an unrelated charge did not speak to that question. The court redacted the exhibit and instructed the jury to disregard any reference to a pending charge, and we presume the jury followed that instruction. Id. True, the instruction came in the final charge rather than when the error occurred, but that was the approach Root requested, and he cannot fault the court for honoring it. A court’s decision to cure improper evidence by instruction rather than mistrial is entitled to broad deference and will suffice “in all but the most extreme cases.” State v. Plain, 898 N.W.2d 801, 815 (Iowa 2017) (citation omitted). Here, the district court was better positioned to gauge the 8 reference’s effect than we are, and it acted within its discretion. Kieffer, 17 N.W.3d at 658. II. Sufficiency The instructions required that the State had to prove Root assaulted Michael, had the apparent ability to do so, and acted with specific intent to cause serious injury. Substantial evidence supports each element. The circumstantial evidence alone allows a rational finding that Root fired the shot. Root’s reliance on instruction number 12 is misplaced. That instruction limited only prior inconsistent statements, and the circumstantial case sustains the conviction without Michael’s statements identifying Root as the shooter. His own account placed him with the firearm at the moment of the shooting and immediately after, when he admitted picking it up and throwing it aside. Officers found that revolver, with a spent cartridge, concealed under objects where Root said he threw it. The horizontal wound path and the examiner’s testimony that the revolver could not fire if dropped refuted Root’s accidental-discharge account, and the spatter showed the shot came from inside the house. Specific intent, seldom provable directly, could be inferred from these circumstances and the escalating conflict between the two men; a jury could find that one who fires a working revolver across a room intends the serious injury that follows. See State v. Ernst, 954 N.W.2d 50, 55 (Iowa 2021) (“Specific intent will often be shown by circumstantial evidence and the reasonable inferences drawn from that evidence.” (cleaned up)). The wounds required emergency surgery and were plainly serious. Substantial evidence supports each element. AFFIRMED. 9