Full Opinion

NOTICE 2026 IL App (5th) 230944-U NOTICE Decision filed 11/16/26. The This order was filed under text of this decision may be NO. 5-23‑0944 Supreme Court Rule 23 and is changed or corrected prior to not precedent except in the the filing of a Petition for IN THE limited circumstances allowed Rehearing or the disposition of under Rule 23(e)(1). the same. APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS FIFTH DISTRICT ______________________________________________________________________________ THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS, ) Appeal from the ) Circuit Court of Plaintiff-Appellee, ) Champaign County. ) v. ) No. 21-CF-649 ) AMARI M. ROBINSON, ) Honorable ) Randall B. Rosenbaum, Defendant-Appellant. ) Judge, presiding. ______________________________________________________________________________ JUSTICE McHANEY delivered the judgment of the court. Presiding Justice Cates and Justice Sholar concurred in the judgment. ORDER ¶1 Held: The defendant’s first degree murder conviction is reversed and the cause remanded for a new trial where trial counsel rendered ineffective assistance in three respects: failing to object to inadmissible hearsay, failing to ensure the jury received required instructions on the defendant’s statements, and failing to request a required cautionary instruction on the officers’ identifications, each of which, on this closely balanced record, independently and cumulatively undermined confidence in the verdict. The defendant’s remaining ineffective-assistance and for-cause claims are rejected, the sufficiency of the evidence permits retrial without offending double jeopardy, and the sentencing challenges are moot. ¶2 Following a jury trial, the defendant, Amari M. Robinson, was convicted of first degree murder (720 ILCS 5/9-1(a)(1) (West 2018)) and found to have personally discharged a firearm that proximately caused Martin Morrow’s 1 death. The trial court sentenced her to 52 years’ 1 Although the victim’s name is listed as “Matthew Morrow” in the charging documents, he is referred to as “Martin Morrow” throughout the trial. 1 imprisonment, followed by 3 years of mandatory supervised release (MSR). On appeal, the defendant argues that she is entitled to a new trial based on numerous instances of ineffective assistance of trial counsel, including claims concerning jury selection, the admission and treatment of certain evidence, jury instructions, alternate-suspect evidence, and closing argument. She also contends that the trial court committed plain error by failing to excuse a prospective juror for cause. Alternatively, the defendant argues that her sentence should be vacated because the trial court improperly considered aggravating and mitigating factors and because her 52-year sentence is unconstitutional in light of her age and rehabilitative potential. She asks us to review the unpreserved sentencing claims under the plain-error doctrine or, alternatively, as claims of ineffective assistance of sentencing counsel. For the following reasons, we reverse. ¶3 I. BACKGROUND ¶4 On the afternoon of October 7, 2020, a gathering was held to commemorate the defendant’s brother, who had died several months earlier. Martin, sometimes referred to as “Dee,” attended the gathering. The defendant, who was 16 years old at the time, also attended. According to the State’s evidence, later that evening the defendant left the gathering with Martin, Prentiss Turner, and others to commit what was described as a “lick,” meaning a robbery, theft, or home invasion. Martin was thereafter shot multiple times and died from his injuries. ¶5 The State’s theory was that the defendant and Prentiss each shot Martin, with Prentiss firing a .45-caliber weapon and the defendant firing a 9-millimeter weapon. Cartridge casings of both calibers were recovered from the scene. The State sought to connect the defendant to the 9- millimeter firearm through social media videos in which she was depicted with a firearm. The State presented testimony and a body-camera recording concerning statements allegedly made by 2 the defendant after the shooting. The State also introduced evidence relating to a separate shooting in Joliet involving the same firearm. ¶6 The defense disputed that the State proved the defendant was one of the shooters. No witness testified that he or she saw the defendant shoot Martin, and the firearm attributed to the defendant was not recovered. The defense also challenged the State’s effort to connect the firearm depicted in the social media videos to the firearm used in Martin’s shooting and the reliability and significance of the statements attributed to the defendant. ¶7 A. Pretrial Hearing ¶8 Before trial, the State sought permission for Detective Stephen Vogel to identify the defendant in several videos obtained during the investigation. At a hearing on the motion, Detective Vogel testified that he had encountered the defendant in person on three occasions. His first interaction with her occurred on October 9, 2020, the day after Martin’s death, when he spoke with her at her residence for more than an hour during daylight hours. Detective Vogel subsequently encountered the defendant briefly at her residence in February 2021 and again at the county jail in April 2022, when he stood close enough to obtain buccal swabs from her. Detective Vogel also testified that he had reviewed numerous photographs and videos of the defendant obtained from her Snapchat and Facebook accounts. ¶9 The trial court found that Detective Vogel’s prior interactions with the defendant and his review of photographs and videos provided an adequate foundation for him to identify her in the videos. The trial court permitted the testimony but observed that it remained for the jury ultimately to determine whether the defendant was the person depicted. 3 ¶ 10 B. Jury Selection ¶ 11 Before jury selection began, trial counsel advised the trial court that the defense did not intend to call any witnesses unless the defendant elected to testify. During voir dire, the trial court advised the prospective jurors of the principles set forth in Illinois Supreme Court Rule 431(b) (eff. July 1, 2012), including that the defendant was presumed innocent, that the State bore the burden of proving her guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant was not required to offer evidence, and that her decision not to testify could not be considered against her. The prospective jurors relevant to this appeal each indicated that they understood and accepted those principles. ¶ 12 Trial counsel asked whether the prospective jurors felt that they needed to hear “both sides of the case or both sides of the story to make a fair decision.” Jurors 30, 55, 96, 121, 95, and 49 were among those who indicated that they wanted testimony or information concerning the defense’s side of the case. Juror 121 responded “Yes” when counsel asked whether she felt that she “would have to hear from the defendant to make a fair decision.” ¶ 13 Juror 96 explained, “I wouldn’t necessarily have to hear from her directly, but maybe just some explanation or, you know, some testimony towards what was being said.” Trial counsel moved to excuse Juror 96 for cause, arguing that her response indicated that she expected to hear the defendant’s side of the case. The trial court denied the challenge, noting that Juror 96 had indicated that she understood and accepted the Rule 431(b) principles and interpreted counsel’s questioning as asking whether the jurors would prefer to hear both sides rather than whether they required defense evidence before they could reach a fair verdict. The trial court described trial counsel’s questioning as “a little vague.” Trial counsel did not exercise a peremptory challenge against Juror 96, and she was selected to serve. Jurors 30, 55, 121, 95, and 49 also served on the 4 jury. Trial counsel did not challenge those jurors for cause or exercise peremptory challenges against them. ¶ 14 C. Jury Trial ¶ 15 1. Joliet Shooting ¶ 16 The State presented evidence concerning a shots-fired incident in Joliet, Illinois, approximately one month before Martin’s death, which it relied on as evidence connecting the defendant to the firearm it alleged she later used to shoot Martin. Officer Jesus Mendez of the Joliet Police Department testified that, at approximately 6:45 p.m. on September 6, 2020, he was dispatched to the 400 block of South Joliet Street following a report that shots had been fired from a moving vehicle. Officer Mendez and his partner received a description of the vehicle and subsequently located a matching vehicle parked approximately a four-minute drive from the reported shooting location. Officer Mendez testified that three people were associated with the vehicle: Adrian Laster, Anthony Holland, and the defendant. Holland was seated in the driver’s seat, Laster was standing near the rear of the vehicle, and the defendant was standing outside near the front passenger side. During pat downs, Officer Mendez recovered a loaded Glock firearm from Holland and a Taurus 9-millimeter firearm from Laster. Both firearms were taken into evidence. Officer Mendez testified that no firearm was recovered from the defendant. ¶ 17 On cross-examination, Officer Mendez testified that approximately 20 minutes had elapsed between the shots-fired dispatch and his contact with the vehicle. During that interval, the vehicle was not continuously under police surveillance. He further confirmed that the defendant was outside the vehicle when officers arrived and that no firearm was found on her. ¶ 18 Patrol Sergeant Hollis Weller of the Joliet Police Department testified that he also responded to the shots-fired call. Sergeant Weller canvassed the area and recovered a spent 5 cartridge casing from the middle of the intersection of Water and Jasper Streets. He testified that there was no indication that anyone had been struck by the gunfire. Sergeant Weller collected the casing, which was admitted as People’s Exhibit 61. Illinois State Police (ISP) forensic scientist Kathryn Doolin later compared People’s Exhibit 61 with People’s Exhibit 44, a cartridge casing recovered from the scene of Martin’s shooting. ¶ 19 2. Martin’s Shooting ¶ 20 At trial, the State sought to establish the circumstances surrounding Martin’s shooting through (1) testimony concerning the events before and after the shooting, (2) the defendant’s recorded interview with police, (3) social media evidence, (4) forensic and ballistic evidence, and (5) testimony and recordings concerning statements allegedly made by the defendant after the shooting. ¶ 21 a. Events Surrounding Martin’s Shooting ¶ 22 On October 7, 2020, family and friends gathered at the Fair Oaks residence in Champaign for a balloon release in memory of J.T., the defendant’s brother. Those present included Martin, the defendant, Prentiss Turner, Amario Turner, Patrick Jordan, and the residents, Alliyah Stevens and Tyija Walters. A Snapchat video later obtained from Prentiss’s account shows Prentiss and the defendant at the residence at approximately 1:34 a.m. on October 8, shortly before the shooting. ¶ 23 At trial, Stevens was asked about a conversation that occurred shortly before people began leaving the gathering. She stated she did not recall a conversation about what those individuals intended to do, but the State confronted her with a statement she gave Detective Vogel on the morning of the shooting that, while they were “chilling” and conducting the balloon release, “they said we finna walk and do a lick.” Stevens stated she did not recall making that statement, although 6 she recalled questioning how the group could “walk and do a lick.” She stated that she understood “lick” to mean getting drunk because the group had been drinking. ¶ 24 Amario testified that he left the gathering alone and that everyone went their own way, but was confronted with a prior statement in which he said he left with “Patrick, Mari, Dee, and my brother.” He said he did not recall the statement and did not identify “Mari” as the defendant. ¶ 25 Jordan testified that he was picked up and dropped off by his godbrother, Lavelle Drisdell, and that he had been “high” at the gathering. He initially stated that he left alone, but acknowledged telling Detective Vogel days after the shooting that he “left with all of them,” meaning the defendant, Prentiss, and Amario, and that Martin also left with the group before they split up. ¶ 26 Later that night, Stevens left briefly to go to a gas station but was called back by Tyija, who asked whether she had heard gunshots. Stevens had not heard shots but saw Martin lying in the roadway upon her return and flagged down police. ¶ 27 Sergeant Justin Prosser testified that he responded to a shots-fired call at approximately 2:08 a.m. and found Martin lying in the roadway near 3003 West William Street. Consistent with that location, Sergeant Prosser testified that he observed the subject “laying in the road in front of 3003 West William.” Prosser observed what appeared to be multiple gunshot wounds and began rendering medical aid but observed no signs of life. When shown a photograph of Martin at the scene, Prosser testified that he could not identify what was on Martin’s hands but observed something black on his left hand and something lighter, possibly white, on his right. He testified that Martin’s hands did not appear to be bare. The parties stipulated that Martin was transported by ambulance to the hospital, where he was pronounced dead. ¶ 28 Officer Matthew Silver arrived shortly thereafter and recovered two bullets from the scene, one from beneath Martin’s right armpit and another near his right hand. Detective Corey Phenicie 7 testified that, while searching the area outside 903 Fair Oaks, he located several cigarillo tips and a partially smoked cigarillo. One of the tips was admitted as People’s Exhibit 8. The parties later stipulated that DNA recovered from the cigarillo tip was a mixture of three individuals and that there was very strong support for the conclusion that both the defendant and Martin were contributors to that DNA. ¶ 29 David Frye, a digital forensics examiner with the Champaign Police Department, testified concerning Snapchat geolocation records associated with the defendant and Prentiss. Frye explained that the data reflected an area approximately 360 feet from the reported coordinates rather than an exact location and that Snapchat did not continuously collect location information. At approximately 1:49 a.m. and 1:56 a.m. on October 8, the locations reflected in the defendant’s Snapchat data were near the area where Martin was shot. ¶ 30 Frye described approximately six or seven hundred hours of training in digital forensics, forensic video, and geolocation. He explained that the Snapchat return arrives as a spreadsheet with three columns, latitude, longitude, and a timestamp, and read a representative value, a latitude of approximately 41.554 “plus or minus 39.66 meters.” He described latitude and longitude as the coordinate system used to describe a location on the earth’s surface. As to precision, Frye testified that data carried to three decimal points places a point “within about 360 feet of the actual location,” which he characterized as a rectangle or “box” rather than a pinpoint. As to continuity, he testified that Snapchat collects geolocation data through an algorithm he could not fully specify and that there can be “some time between each data point” rather than a reading every minute. He had geolocation data from both accounts around the time of the murder and plotted the data points on a map admitted as People’s Exhibit 30. 8 ¶ 31 On cross-examination, Frye acknowledged limits on the data. He agreed that Amario Turner’s account showed no location data for the relevant time period. He agreed there were times when the two phones were separate, or when the Snapchat application “wasn’t connecting and uploading.” And he confirmed that the Snapchat returns do not retain geolocation data for where a specific image or video was taken or uploaded. ¶ 32 b. The Defendant’s Recorded Interview ¶ 33 On October 9, 2020, Detectives Vogel and Phenicie interviewed the 16-year-old defendant outside her residence after her mother arrived. The interview was recorded on Detective Vogel’s body-worn camera, and a redacted 43-minute version was admitted as People’s Exhibit 9 and published to the jury. Vogel testified that nothing relating to the homicide was removed. ¶ 34 When the video was played, the jury heard the defendant state that she arrived at the gathering while it was still daylight and that Martin was already there. She said that she had smoked marijuana, consumed alcohol, taken two pills and became “messed up.” She described herself, Martin, Prentiss, Amario, Jordan, and others as leaving to do a “lick,” which she described as obtaining approximately $30,000 from a nearby house. She denied possessing a gun herself and said Prentiss and Amario were supposed to have weapons. Detective Vogel testified that, based on his training and experience, the term “lick” commonly referred to a theft, home invasion, or robbery. ¶ 35 In the recorded interview played for the jury, the defendant stated that she heard gunshots, saw what looked like a spark near her leg from behind, saw Martin fall, and ran. She said she then heard additional gunshots from farther away and believed someone might also have been trying to shoot her. She denied shooting Martin and denied possessing a firearm. Her descriptions of her position relative to Martin varied: she said she did not remember where she had been standing, 9 that she was next to him when shots came from behind, and that she had been “trying to lead the way” and was positioned in front of him. ¶ 36 The jury also heard Detective Vogel assert that he knew “for a fact” the defendant left with Martin and others to “go do a lick.” He told her that Martin had been shot “at least 10 to 12 times, at close range” and said this meant someone close to the group had killed Martin. Detective Vogel also told her that she needed to be honest because lying would prevent him from “helping” her, whereas honesty would allow him to help. He told her that if she lied, “the State’s Attorney’s Office, the judge, is gonna look at this, and it’s over.” ¶ 37 Detective Vogel testified that the defendant gave him a white cell phone during the interview, stating that it was the phone she used the night of the shooting. He said the phone contained no social media accounts and no evidentiary content, which he found surprising because Snapchat and Facebook records obtained earlier showed significant activity. Detective Vogel testified that the black phone the defendant had been using when officers arrived was never turned over. ¶ 38 Detective Vogel testified that, during the investigation, the defendant, Prentiss, Amario, Jordan, and Drisdell were all considered potential suspects in Martin’s death. On cross-examination, he acknowledged that Martin and Drisdell both had romantic involvement with Tyija and that the defendant expressed concern during the interview that Drisdell had been driving by Tyija’s residence. ¶ 39 On redirect examination, Detective Vogel testified that Drisdell initially was considered a potential suspect in Martin’s death but ultimately was ruled out. Detective Vogel testified that he spoke with witnesses who described Drisdell’s relationship with Martin as “fine,” reviewed Drisdell’s Facebook records and found no communications relevant to the investigation, and 10 reviewed Drisdell’s cell phone records and found no calls or text-message activity involving anyone connected to the case before the homicide. ¶ 40 c. Social Media Evidence ¶ 41 Detective Vogel testified that officers executed search warrants for Snapchat accounts associated with the defendant and Prentiss. Based on information provided during their interviews, he identified the defendant’s account and identified Prentiss’s account. Detective Vogel testified that he recognized the defendant and Prentiss in several videos obtained from those accounts, including a Snapchat video dated October 6, 2020, at approximately 8:28 p.m., depicting the two together in a vehicle. ¶ 42 Detective Vogel also obtained a search warrant for the defendant’s Facebook account. He testified that a Facebook conversation dated October 7, 2020, at 12:19 p.m. showed messages between the defendant’s account and an account associated with Darrion Wicks. The defendant’s account stated: “I feel you on dat one i wake up nd gts in mines everyday but i got a plan so thats the only thang that make me feel ok.” Wicks’s account responded, “we done execute da plan fasho,” and “ain’t got no choice but we aint gone speak onnat.” ¶ 43 Detective Vogel identified the defendant and Martin in a video from the defendant’s Snapchat account that was timestamped at approximately 8:10 p.m. on October 7, 2020, the day before Martin was shot. One video recovered from Prentiss’s account was timestamped approximately 1:34 a.m. on October 8, 2020, and depicted Prentiss and the defendant inside the Fair Oaks Drive residence. Detective Vogel identified the defendant as wearing an Atlanta Braves cap and a black-and-white sweater. ¶ 44 Detective Vogel identified Martin in another video obtained from the defendant’s Snapchat account, containing an arrow pointing toward Martin. Vogel testified that he had not added the 11 arrow, and that, based on his experience, the arrow was user-generated rather than automatically generated by Snapchat. He testified that the video was timestamped at approximately 4:18 p.m. on October 8, 2020. ¶ 45 He testified about another Facebook conversation between the defendant’s account and Wicks’s account on October 8, 2020, at 4:46 p.m. The Wicks account asked whether the defendant had gone to the hospital. The defendant’s account responded that she had not, stating, “I got grazed in my leg,” and describing being dropped off at a bowling alley and walking home. Additional videos obtained from the defendant’s Snapchat account depicted her with firearms before and after Martin’s death, including one video timestamped September 5, 2020, the day before the Joliet incident ¶ 46 d. Forensic and Ballistic Evidence ¶ 47 Officer Nate Epling of the Champaign Police Department testified that he assisted in processing the scene of Martin’s shooting. Officers recovered 12 spent 9-millimeter cartridge casings and 4 spent .45-caliber cartridge casings, along with several projectiles. Officer Epling testified that cartridge casings ejected from a semiautomatic handgun generally land several feet from the firearm, although he acknowledged that a casing may move after striking the ground. ¶ 48 During trial, the parties stipulated to evidence concerning a Smith & Wesson .45-caliber firearm. According to the stipulation, Deon Cavette Jr. stole the firearm from his father and gave it to Nehemiah Campbell, the brother of Amario and Prentiss. The stipulation also indicated Nehemiah would testify that Amario later took the firearm from him. A spent cartridge casing associated with the firearm was provided to law enforcement by Cavette’s father. ¶ 49 ISP forensic scientist Doolin testified as the State’s firearms-identification witness. She stated that she belongs to the Association of Firearm and Tool Mark Examiners (AFTE) and was 12 tendered and admitted as an expert in firearms identification without objection. She explained that firearms identification determines whether a fired bullet, cartridge case, or other ammunition component was fired by a particular firearm, “whether that firearm was submitted to the laboratory or not,” and that an identification rests on the reproduction and agreement of both class and individual characteristics. ¶ 50 Doolin described class characteristics as measurable features designed before manufacture, which for firearms include the caliber, breech-face markings, firing-pin shape, and rifling. She defined caliber as, among other things, “the nominal diameter of a bullet.” She described individual characteristics as the microscopic imperfections produced during manufacture or through use, abuse, and corrosion, which are “unique to that particular firearm.” She explained her method: if the class characteristics match to the naked eye, she then compares the individual characteristics on a comparison microscope, “two compound microscopes that are connected by an optical bridge” permitting simultaneous viewing, to determine whether the items were fired by the same firearm. ¶ 51 Applying that method, Doolin compared People’s Exhibit 44 (her Lab Item 8, the 9- millimeter casing from Martin’s scene) with People’s Exhibit 61 (her Lab Item 1) and concluded that they “were fired by the same firearm.” She explained that Exhibit 61 bore a different laboratory case number and had been submitted for comparison at a police-department request, reflecting its origin in the separate Joliet matter. She also compared People’s Exhibit 56 (Lab Item 13) with People’s Exhibit 70 (Lab Item 1) and likewise concluded that they “were fired by the same firearm,” the comparison associated with the stipulated .45-caliber weapon. Consistent with that testimony, Doolin compared a 9-millimeter casing recovered from Martin’s shooting with a casing recovered from the Joliet shooting and concluded that the two had been fired from the same 13 firearm, and she compared a .45-caliber casing recovered from Martin’s shooting with the comparison casing associated with the Smith & Wesson .45-caliber firearm described in the parties’ stipulation and concluded that those casings likewise had been fired from the same firearm. ¶ 52 Dr. Shiping Bao, who conducted Martin’s autopsy, testified that Martin sustained 14 gunshot entrance wounds, 8 exit wounds, and had 6 bullets remaining in his body. The entrance wounds included injuries to Martin’s face, neck, shoulder, chest, arm, and thigh, as well as two wounds to his upper back and posterior shoulder. Dr. Bao identified three wounds that perforated both lungs as fatal and concluded that Martin died from the gunshot wounds. He stated that although 9-millimeter and .45-caliber cartridge casings were recovered from the scene, he could not determine from the autopsy which caliber caused any particular wound. ¶ 53 Detective Sergeant Bradley Krauel testified concerning the firearms depicted in the social media videos. Sergeant Krauel had approximately 20 years of law-enforcement experience and had served as a SWAT officer, sniper-team leader, firearms instructor, and department armorer. He was certified as a master firearms instructor and testified that his firearms training included courses involving SWAT tactics, police-sniper training, tactical precision rifles, pistol and carbine instruction, and close-quarter and low-light firearms training. As a firearms instructor, he had trained other officers concerning the use and operation of firearms and diagnosing firearm-related problems and malfunctions. Sergeant Krauel had served as a department armorer since approximately 2011 and held several armorer certifications. He testified that his duties included inspecting firearms for functionality, diagnosing malfunctions, replacing worn or damaged components, and disassembling and reassembling firearms. The State tendered Sergeant Krauel as an expert in firearms identification. Trial counsel did not object and, when the trial court asked whether she had any questions concerning his expertise, counsel responded that she did not. 14 ¶ 54 After reviewing several videos and still photographs, Sergeant Krauel testified that the firearm depicted was consistent with a Taurus Millennium G2 and likely was a PT-111, which he testified was typically chambered for 9-millimeter ammunition. In reaching that opinion, he relied on characteristics including the contour of the muzzle and slide, the recoil spring, trigger guard, rail system, stippling, barrel color, and rear profile. He also compared one of the still images with a stock photograph of the Taurus Millennium G2. Sergeant Krauel further opined that the firearm depicted in several of the images was a real firearm rather than an Airsoft or pellet-gun replica. He testified that firearms shown in several of the videos appeared to be the same firearm or, at a minimum, the same model. ¶ 55 On cross-examination, Sergeant Krauel acknowledged that the PT-111 was a popular firearm and that more than one million Taurus Millennium G2 PT-111 firearms had been manufactured. He also acknowledged that 9-millimeter was a very common caliber. He further acknowledged that he could not determine from a video or photograph whether the depicted firearm had fired any particular casing or projectile recovered from a crime scene. When asked what the term “9-millimeter” measured, Sergeant Krauel initially described it as the “circumference” of the round, but then explained that it referred to the “width or diameter” of the projectile. ¶ 56 e. Statements Attributed to the Defendant ¶ 57 Konika Morrow, Martin’s sister, testified that her children did not get along with the defendant and her brothers. She stated that she overheard a video call between her son, Bailey, and the defendant. According to Konika, she saw the defendant’s face on Bailey’s phone and heard the defendant describe Martin lying on the ground, begging for his life and asking, “Why me?” Konika testified that the defendant said she told Martin to “shut up” before shooting him, mimicked 15 gunshots, and stated that Martin had purchased the bullets she used on him. Konika also testified that the defendant later laughed during a phone call informing the family of Martin’s death. She acknowledged animosity between the families and admitted she did not report the alleged laughter until nearly two years later. Konika testified that she stood to the side of Bailey’s cell phone during the call and was “recording,” explaining that she intentionally remained out of view because she did not want the defendant to know she was present. She could not recall the precise date of the call and acknowledged that there had been numerous communications between Bailey and the defendant. ¶ 58 Testifying in greater detail about the call, Konika stated that she overheard a video call between Bailey and the defendant and could see the defendant’s face. She testified that the defendant said Martin “was laying on the ground, rolling around, begging for his life, asking the Lord, ‘Why me?’ And she told him, ‘Bitch, shut up,’ and shot him in his shit.” Asked whether her own face appeared on the screen, she said it did not: “I was to the side of the phone, recording,” which she agreed was “by design” because she did not want the defendant to know she was in the room. She testified that when her son told the defendant “she set our murder up,” the defendant said, “I’m not a set-up bitch,” then “said about her shooting people,” described the shooting as “pow, pow, pow,” and said “my brother purchased the bullets that she used *** on him.” ¶ 59 Konika also testified that, on the morning after the shooting, while her family was traveling to Champaign, the defendant called and told them that Martin had died. When asked whether the defendant said anything during that call indicating that she had shot Martin, Konika testified, “She just was laughing, and I told my son to hang up.” Konika further testified that the defendant later sent Facebook friend requests to members of the family and that Konika told her to stop because, in Konika’s words, the defendant had “murdered my brother.” Konika testified that she had contact 16 with law enforcement shortly after Martin’s death and remained in contact with Detective Vogel during the investigation. However, she did not report the alleged phone call in which the defendant laughed about Martin’s death until September 2022, nearly two years later. On cross-examination, Konika also acknowledged animosity between members of the two families. The parties further stipulated that Konika had a pending case in another county for resisting a peace officer. That case was pending in Will County, and Detective Vogel testified that no detective or officer had sought consideration for Konika and that the state’s attorney’s office had not been involved with her case. ¶ 60 Donta Bailey, Martin’s nephew and the person participating in the video call described by Konika, testified that he communicated with the defendant after Martin’s death. According to Bailey, the defendant initially told him that she and Martin had been walking when someone pulled alongside them and began shooting. Bailey testified that the defendant “kept changing her story,” telling him that Martin had taken her to buy bullets the day before he died and that Martin was killed with those same bullets. ¶ 61 Bailey nevertheless denied at trial that the defendant ever admitted shooting Martin. When asked whether she told him that she was the person who shot Martin or that she “did it,” Bailey answered, “No.” He also denied hearing the defendant say that she shot Martin in the head while he was choking on his blood and testified that his mother had claimed to hear that statement. Bailey acknowledged that the defendant told him Martin had been shot in the leg and arm, but again testified that she did not identify herself as the shooter. Although Konika had testified she heard the defendant say that Martin’s last words were “Why me?” Bailey denied personally hearing the defendant make that statement. Bailey further acknowledged that his communications with the defendant were hostile at times and that the two had animosity stemming, at least in part, from comments concerning the defendant’s brother, J.T. 17 ¶ 62 Bailey’s trial testimony, recounted in greater detail, was as follows. Asked whether the defendant “ever tell you that she was the one who did the shooting,” Bailey testified, “No, she ain’t, she ain’t. She threw hands out there, but she ain’t never told me she did it.” Asked whether she said anything about choking, he answered that his mother “said she heard her on the phone saying he was choking” but “I don’t remember that.” He agreed he had accused the defendant of being a “set-up bitch,” and said he did not really remember her response, describing her as “laughing.” Confronted with a prior statement to Detective Vogel that the defendant said, “When we got up on him I shot his bitch ass in the head, and he was choking on his blood,” Bailey responded, “No, I ain’t tell him that. *** [M]y mom told him that.” He agreed the defendant told him Martin “was crying like a bitch” and that Martin had been shot “in his leg and in his arm,” but added, “She didn’t tell me she did it.” As to the asserted knowledge of Martin’s “last words” (“Why me?”), Bailey said his mother was next to him during the calls and that “I ain’t heard her say it,” explaining, “Sometimes I just set the phone down and walk away, and I don’t remember ***.” He did not recall telling Vogel that the defendant said Martin “got up hit with all types of shells.” ¶ 63 The State presented Detective Vogel’s testimony concerning a recorded telephone interview he conducted with Bailey approximately six weeks after Martin’s death. Vogel recorded the interview on his body-worn camera, and the resulting video was admitted as People’s Exhibit 77, along with a separately identified excerpt. Exhibit 77 was played for the jury without objection. In contrast to Bailey’s trial testimony, Detective Vogel stated that, during this recorded interview, Bailey reported that when he accused the defendant of being a “set-up bitch,” she responded that she was not a “set-up bitch,” but rather “the one that did it,” and that she “hit him in his shit nine times.” Vogel testified that, on the recording, Bailey “basically calls her a set-up bitch several times, and Amari responds that she’s not a set-up bitch, she’s the one that did it, hit him in his shit 18 nine times.” Bailey also provided additional vivid details in the recorded interview, including that Martin was “choking,” “crying,” and had been struck with “all types of shells,” descriptions the State relied upon as portraying direct, firsthand knowledge of the shooting. Whether any recording of the Morrow/Bailey call actually existed was not resolved; trial counsel testified none was produced, and the State maintained it possessed none. ¶ 64 f. Motion for Directed Verdict ¶ 65 After the State rested, trial counsel moved for a directed verdict, arguing that the evidence was insufficient to permit a reasonable jury to find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. The trial court denied the motion. Although the court characterized the State’s case as “somewhat of a circumstantial case,” it concluded that, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the State, sufficien