People v. Joner
CourtAppellate Court of Illinois
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket5-25-0542
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NOTICE
2026 IL App (5th) 250542-U
NOTICE
Decision filed 11/20/26. The
This order was filed under
text of this decision may be NO. 5-25-0542 Supreme Court Rule 23 and is
changed or corrected prior to
the filing of a Petition for not precedent except in the
Rehearing or the disposition of
IN THE limited circumstances allowed
the same. under Rule 23(e)(1).
APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS
FIFTH DISTRICT
______________________________________________________________________________
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS, ) Appeal from the
) Circuit Court of
Plaintiff-Appellee, ) Champaign County.
)
v. ) No. 24-CF-509
)
EUGENE JOINER JR., ) Honorable
) Randall B. Rosenbaum,
Defendant-Appellant. ) Judge, presiding.
______________________________________________________________________________
JUSTICE VAUGHAN delivered the judgment of the court.
Justices Barberis and Clarke concurred in the judgment.
ORDER
¶1 Held: The trial court’s judgment is affirmed where sufficient evidence was presented to
find defendant guilty of aggravated criminal sexual assault.
¶2 Defendant, Eugene Joiner Jr., appeals his conviction on two counts of aggravated criminal
sexual assault. On appeal, he contends that insufficient evidence was presented to sustain his
convictions. For the following reasons, we affirm.
¶3 I. BACKGROUND
¶4 On April 22, 2024, defendant was charged, by information, with four counts of aggravated
criminal sexual assault, in violation of section 11-1.20(a)(1) of the Criminal Code of 2012 (720
ILCS 5/11-1.20(a)(1) (West 2016)). Count I alleged that defendant placed his fingers, through
force, in Brianna Clairess-Beard’s anus while armed with a firearm. Count II alleged that defendant
1
placed his penis in Brianna’s vagina, through force, while armed with a firearm. Count III alleged
that defendant placed his fingers in Brianna’s anus, through force, and struck her on the head with
a gun. Count IV alleged that defendant stuck his penis in Brianna’s vagina, through force, and
struck her on the head with a gun. All the counts were based on incidents occurring on March 17,
2024. Defendant was arraigned and counsel was appointed on April 22, 2024. Indictments on all
four counts were issued on May 2, 2024. On May 15, 2024, defendant pled not guilty, invoked his
speedy trial rights, and requested a jury trial.
¶5 Following numerous continuances requested by defendant, the jury trial began on January
7, 2025. The court, on motion of the State, struck the words “with a gun” from counts III and IV.
The jury was seated and on January 8, 2025, opening arguments were presented, and the following
evidence was adduced at the trial.
¶6 Brianna’s 911 call was played for the jury. In the call, Brianna was sobbing. She stated that
a man she knew wanted her to go with him to get a pregnancy test. She went with him and he raped
her in the backyard. She stated that he had a gun. She identified defendant as the person who raped
her and provided his age and a description of the clothes he was wearing. She further stated that
defendant hit her in the face with a gun and that she had not taken a shower. The operator asked
for the name of Brianna’s friend, who was with her when she called, but the friend would only
allow Brianna to provide his first name. The operator continued to ask for the friend’s last name
and Brianna eventually became angry that the operator was focused on the friend, not what
happened to Brianna.
¶7 Tyler Bialeschki, of the Champaign Police Department, responded to Brianna’s 911 call at
1116 Joanne Lane in Champaign, Illinois. He met Brianna who identified the suspect as defendant.
Defendant was not present at the location when Officer Bialeschki responded. The officer observed
2
that Brianna had a large, bleeding gash on her forehead and another on the top of her head. She
was sobbing and crying. She was taken to the hospital, accompanied by Officer Bialeschki, at
which time she provided a statement. Brianna arrived at the hospital around 3:30 to 3:45 a.m. and
was later seen by medical personnel. Officer Bialeschki left the hospital and returned with a photo
lineup. Brianna looked at the lineup, pointed at a picture of defendant and said, “That’s him. I’m
pretty sure that’s him.” Brianna circled the photo and said, “Yes, this is definitely him.” The photo
lineup was identified, admitted into evidence, and published to the jury. The officer stated that his
conversation with Brianna was recorded on his body camera.
¶8 On cross-examination, Officer Bialeschki stated that he spoke with Brianna outside her
residence. She indicated that she had friends inside the residence and insisted that the other officer
not go into the home and speak with them. Officer Bialeschki photographed Brianna’s injuries
while they were in the ambulance on the way to the hospital. He interviewed Brianna when they
arrived at the hospital and later returned with the photo lineup. Officer Bialeschki stated that
Officer Taveous Bell, who no longer worked at the police department, conducted the lineup
because he did not know anything about the case, who was named as a suspect, or what the suspect
looked like. Officer Bialeschki agreed that prior to the lineup, Brianna showed him a photograph
of her and defendant taken on a prior occasion when they were on a date.
¶9 Officer Bialeschki agreed that he later returned to a different address on Joanne Lane to try
to locate the scene where the incident occurred. He explained that he pulled up Google maps on
his phone in the ambulance so Brianna could identify where the incident occurred. He went to that
address, found the home was occupied, and spoke with the homeowner who had not heard
anything. He obtained the video from cameras at the home where the incident allegedly occurred
and did not find anything that depicted Brianna or defendant as having been there. He later found
3
out the address was incorrect. He agreed that Brianna became very upset in the ambulance when
she was told that the police were knocking on the door to talk to the occupants of the home where
police initially arrived. She wanted to get out of the ambulance and no longer talk to the police.
Officer Bialeschki confirmed that he never talked to anyone or took pictures of the inside of the
residence where Brianna’s friends were located.
¶ 10 Officer Bialeschki stated that they were looking for an Uzi-style weapon based on
Brianna’s statement. He was unaware of any calls to 911 reporting a female screaming in the early
morning hours of March 17, 2024, on Joanne Lane. Officer Bialeschki testified that he never went
to Days Inn to inquire about video evidence from that morning. The officer only went to Joanne
Lane. He agreed that there were pistols or handguns that shot pellets and BBs that looked very
similar to a regular handgun. He agreed that lasers or red dots could be affixed to a pellet or BB
gun. He stated that Brianna’s wounds were bleeding when he arrived and that she stated she was
bleeding everywhere and there would be blood where the incident occurred. He could not recall if
Brianna indicated that she lost her glasses at the scene.
¶ 11 Brianna testified that she met defendant on Snapchat in February 2024. They eventually
met, went on a date a couple of weeks before March 17, 2024, and had consensual sex. She stated
that defendant was very rude to her after the act. She stated that he also “stiffed the bill at the
restaurant and I ended up having to pay for it.” She also sent defendant money via Cash App. She
stated that the date left a bad taste in her mouth. She blocked him after the date and did not want
to see or have anything to do with him again. However, defendant harassed her via app messages,
sent her threats, and asked her for money for an abortion. She stated that defendant was also
stalking her Snapchat and making different profiles. She would block one and another would
4
appear. She denied hanging out with defendant between their first date and the incident on March
17, 2024.
¶ 12 Brianna testified that on the day of the incident, she had just gotten off work and arrived
home. She stated that she was the assistant manager of Domino’s. It closed around 1 a.m. and she
would usually leave around 2 a.m. However, she did not have any staff helping her that evening,
so she worked until 2:30 a.m. Defendant arrived at her residence shortly after she got home. She
was sitting on her bed with her friend, Bryson. She explained that she lived in a house and each
room was leased to different people like an apartment; it was called a shared home. She and Bryson
heard noises outside the bedroom window. When she looked out, defendant was standing outside
her window. She told Bryson that defendant was the guy she had been worried about and told
defendant to meet her at the front door so it would be recorded by her Ring doorbell. She opened
the front door. She testified that it seemed like defendant had been drinking and was loud. She
explained that the front door was near one of her housemate’s rooms and that housemate had
children so she was trying to think of how she could get him away from the house since the children
were sleeping and had school the next day. She further explained that she had just moved into the
residence and did not want any complaints to the landlord as she had previously been homeless.
¶ 13 Defendant told Brianna that he wanted her to walk with him to a store to get a pregnancy
test so she could prove to him that she was not pregnant with his child from when they had
consensual sex. She asked him to wait outside. She then went to get her coat and phone and told
her friend what was happening. She asked Bryson to go with her because she did not want to be
alone with defendant, but Bryson refused because he did not want anything to do with it. She then
heard a knock on her bedroom door. When she opened the door, defendant was standing there
5
despite her leaving him outside the residence moments before. She then left with defendant to get
him out of the house. She forgot to take her phone with her.
¶ 14 Defendant was wearing a letterman’s jacket and a stocking cap when he came to Brianna’s
residence. He also had a water bottle. She stated that she believed defendant heard her prior
conversation with her friend about walking to the gas station to get something to drink. She already
knew that she was going to the store and wanted to get him away from the residence because he
was being loud and disruptive. She was not scared of him at the time. She did not like his demeanor
and did not want to date him again but was not fearful that something would happen to her. She
stated that they walked in circles around the neighborhood toward the gas stations. They went to
Mach 1 and Circle K, but both were closed. They walked by two different hotels next to the gas
stations and defendant tried to get her to rent a room at the hotels. She did not rent a room because
she was not allowed to stay at either one because her dog had previously damaged something at
each place. She also did not want to rent a room in a hotel with defendant, but he would not listen
so she went into the Days Inn so he would take her seriously.
¶ 15 Defendant then asked Brianna how well she knew the neighborhood. Brianna told
defendant that she knew she could take McKinley to get to Joanne but did not know the
neighborhood well because she had recently moved there. Defendant offered to show her that her
street made a full loop and said she should know both ends of her neighborhood. He then took her
the long way and said they had things to discuss if they were going to be parents. Defendant told
her that there had been multiple women that had been pregnant with his child and it went badly for
him. He did not want to experience that again and was trying to ensure that Brianna was not going
to have a child that he did not want.
6
¶ 16 Brianna stated that defendant’s water bottle was empty and she remained thirsty since the
gas stations were closed. Defendant stated that they needed to go up a driveway because that was
where he had previously filled the water bottle. He went up to a few random houses on Joanne
Lane and turned the spigots, but no water came out of them. Defendant then told her that one of
the houses belonged to his friend and they would give him water. Defendant acted like he was
going to knock on the back door. He asked if she wanted a drink and she went to join defendant.
Once she got out of the streetlight, defendant grabbed her and dragged her into the backyard. She
stated there was never a person at the door, defendant never got water for the bottle, and it was all
a ruse. Defendant physically turned her around and pushed her against the house. Her hands were
on a window, and she remembered hoping that she left fingerprints on the window. Defendant then
proceeded to assault her vaginally. Then he tried to shove his fingers into her anal area. She got
tired of waiting for him to finish, so she stood up from being bent over and that forced defendant
to stop what he was doing. He then pushed her to the ground by her shoulders, grabbed her hair
and told her to finish what she had started. She explained that defendant wanted oral sex and she
refused. Defendant then took off his jacket. He had something in his hand that he was covering,
which ended up being a gun. Defendant eventually pulled the gun out and hit her on the side and
top of her head. Brianna stated that she got really dizzy, thought she was blacking out and was
“really warm.” She did not realize she was bleeding and continued to refuse oral sex. He still had
his genitals in her face, and she tried to bite him. He then hit her forehead with the gun.
¶ 17 Brianna testified that she heard defendant open a condom wrapper but never saw the
condom. She stated that she was crying when it started and asked him if he was finished but he
just kept going. After he hit her with the gun, she started pleading and begged him to stop. She
even offered to have him go back with her to the house to try to get him to stop. She stated that
7
defendant knew she did not want to have sex because she had previously told him such when he
was asking her to get a hotel room. She stated that she did not realize the object was a gun until he
hit her with it. It was black, had a red laser and an extended clip, and looked like a gun she had
seen on Call of Duty.
¶ 18 Brianna stated that she eventually got her pants pulled back up and she backed up against
a fence. She was trying to figure out how to get away from him and saw a police car patrolling the
neighborhood, but she could not call out because defendant was pointing the gun at her. He said
he was going to kill her and asked if she wanted to say anything before it happened. A branch fell
behind defendant and startled them both. Defendant put the gun away and ran from the backyard.
Brianna stayed there for a while because she did not want to encounter defendant again. After she
finally decided that enough time had passed so she could leave the area in the same direction taken
by defendant, she left. However, when she got around the corner, defendant was waiting for her.
He then walked her down the driveway with the gun pointed at her. They made a right out of the
driveway towards Brianna’s house. As they walked toward her house, defendant asked her why
she kept letting this happen to her. She realized at that point that they were in front of her house
and the Ring doorbell, so she felt safer. In response, she shoved him, knocked the gun out of his
hand, and ran to the door while defendant picked up what he dropped. She then got into the house
and called 911. She confirmed the assault occurred down the street from her house. She stated that
police arrived, she was transported to the hospital, and pictures of her injuries were taken in the
ambulance and at the hospital.
¶ 19 Brianna stated that she remembered speaking with the officers but had already told them
what happened multiple times. She was a little vague with them. She also spoke with the nurses at
the hospital. Photographs of Brianna were admitted and published to the jury that revealed a gash
8
on her forehead with blood on her face. Another photograph revealed blood that dripped into the
toilet. She stated she did not take a shower before the police arrived. She stated that she was
completely traumatized by the event. When she listened to the 911 call, she barely recognized her
own voice and could not listen to more than 10 seconds of the call without crying.
¶ 20 Brianna agreed that she had a friend at her house when she called the police. She stated
that her friend did not want any contact with the police. He had his own issues and did not want
his name mentioned to the police and thus did not go with her and defendant. He did not want to
be involved from the beginning. She stated that when she first arrived at the hospital, the staff were
“not really” taking care of her injuries and were just questioning her. She made statements at the
time about the lack of care. She later apologized to the officer before the hearing for how she acted
that day.
¶ 21 Brianna agreed that some of her statements to police were inconsistent. She remembered a
lot more detail once she was not as shaken up with everyone around her. After being able to sit
and think through the incident, she was able to provide more information than she did in her
original statement to the police. She agreed that nurses performed a sexual assault exam and took
swabs from her body. She stated she was alright physically, but not emotionally. She confirmed
that she never wanted to have sex with defendant on March 17, 2024. She stated that she was raped
and told him to stop when he was raping her.
¶ 22 On cross-examination, Brianna stated that she was recently divorced and no longer had
“Beard” as part of her last name. She agreed that she and defendant previously had a date, ate
dinner at Denny’s where she had to pay the bill, and had consensual sex. She further agreed that
she spoke with Officer Bialeschki three or four different times the night of the incident. She later
spoke with Detectives Rivest and Hill on March 26, 2024. She did not recall speaking with
9
Detective Rivest on the phone on March 19, 2024. She disputed the conversation with the officers
regarding the payment at the restaurant. She figured out during the meal that defendant did not
have enough money, and she would have to pay for breakfast.
¶ 23 Brianna stated there was a code on the door at 1116 Joanne Lake. If the door was closed,
the code had to be entered to open the door. She stated that she never gave the code to defendant.
However, she did not close the door all the way when she walked back into the house after initially
speaking to defendant at the door and defendant was able to get into the house. When she got
defendant back to the front door, Brianna agreed that she asked him why he was there, told him
she did not want anything to do with him, that she did not want to talk to him, and they had nothing
to talk about. She agreed that he initially responded in a very calm, collected, and respectful
manner. When she would not allow him into the house, defendant’s demeanor changed, and he
became loud and obnoxious. She did not recall telling the police that she had defendant step into
her house so that he would be on the landlord’s video feed. She explained that defendant could be
seen coming into the house by himself after she left him outside and that when he first arrived, she
did not let him in because he could be seen by the doorbell camera. After she walked away and
told him she was going to get her jacket, defendant then let himself into the house.
¶ 24 Brianna testified that she was screaming the entire time the assault occurred and defendant
told her to shut up. She agreed that she was screaming in an attempt to alert the neighbors. She
stated that, based on how it looked, the home where the assault occurred was either occupied or
had squatters. She stated the house was very desolate. She had been pushed up against a bedroom
window and was tapping on it. She stated that defendant tried to break into the house and nobody
came. She further stated that nobody came to the window to check on her when she was screaming.
She did not know there was a woman inside the house.
10
¶ 25 Brianna agreed that she told police defendant had an Uzi-style gun. She stated she had seen
something similar on Call of Duty. It had an extended clip and a red dot laser. She had never seen
one in real life. She only came into contact with the gun when defendant hit her in the face with it.
She stated that the gun was bigger than both of her palms together. She did not recall telling Officer
Bialeschki that it sounded like it held pellets and wondered if it was a real gun. She remembered
Officer Bialeschki pulling up Google maps in the ambulance and told him she was unsure but
would show him the house in person. She agreed that she pointed to a house where she believed
the incident occurred. She agreed telling the officers that she believed there would be blood at the
location because she was bleeding profusely. She stated that the reason she went up the driveway
with defendant was because defendant said he had water for her. She could not recall if she
provided the officers with that information. She did recall telling Detective Rivest that the bottle
defendant was carrying was empty and that she walked up to a house and tried to turn the water
on, but it would not work. She stated that she never knocked on a door nor asked for water. She
was uncomfortable but not fearful, because at the time she did not know defendant had a gun. She
stated that she did not just go home because defendant was holding her wrist most of the time after
they left Mach 1. She stated that after she tried to turn onto McKinley, which was her familiar
route, defendant got handsy with her. She stated that defendant followed her into the Days Inn and
was told there were no vacancies. She also asked to use the restroom but was told they were closed.
She asked to use the vending machine but was told everything was closed and they would not let
her into the hotel.
¶ 26 A couple of days later, Brianna went to the house where the assault occurred and retrieved
her glasses. She also wanted to see the scene of the crime in the daylight. She stated that she
recognized the home when she got there. She did not know the physical address because she had
11
never been there before the night she was raped. She rode in a vehicle with her family until she
found the house. She then got out of the vehicle, walked around the back and found her glasses.
She clarified that she knocked on the door of the home before she went into the backyard. A man
answered and she asked him for permission to go into the backyard. She stated that the owner was
concerned as to why she was in the driveway in the first place. She could not recall if she told the
officers that she lost her glasses and stated she was not even sure that she knew she lost her glasses
until she found them. She stated that she did not see blood when she was back there and it caused
her to ask the detectives if they had already been there to collect evidence and why they left her
glasses.
¶ 27 She agreed that she told Officer Bialeschki that there was a car running in a driveway about
two houses up when they were walking away from the incident, but there was no one in the vehicle.
She also remembered telling Detective Rivest that she told defendant there were people outside
when they were walking back from the incident. She stated it was not the same driveway or the
same people. She said the people outside were a block up the road. She stated that she was not
screaming because defendant still had the gun pointed at her. However, she did scream when she
was in the backyard. She was screaming at him to stop. She stated there was no screaming in the
front of the house because defendant had a gun and was walking with her, telling her that when
she got home, she had to take a shower and was not to talk to anyone. He further stated that he was
not going to leave once they got to her house. She stated that she did tell police officers that she
shoved defendant, which caused him to drop the gun, at which time she ran away. She said she
would be surprised if she told the police that she took the opportunity to run when they got close
to her house and was surprised when he was not behind her when she got to the door. She denied
telling the officers that she was never on her knees because she refused to get on the ground. The
12
only thing she recalled seeing on her sweatpants was blood. She agreed that she refused to provide
the officers with her sweatpants and explained that they were a gift. She disputed telling the nurses
that the assault occurred in a park or abandoned field.
¶ 28 Payton Lareau, a patrol officer for the City of Champaign, testified that he responded to a
911 call on April 18, 2024. He stated that the victim, Brianna, called 911 to report that her stalker
was following her and threatened to kill her. Brianna told the dispatcher that she pulled a knife on
defendant and described defendant as wearing a black sweatsuit having a black bag. She further
provided the direction he headed.
¶ 29 Officer Lareau located defendant and questioned him about what Brianna alleged.
Defendant stated that he did know her. Defendant was asked if he had any contact with Brianna
that day and eventually defendant stated that he had contact with her just outside a store. Defendant
initially claimed that he did not know Brianna, then later said he met her on the Internet. About
that time, Brianna walked up to the scene and stood across the street from them. When Brianna
was across the street, the officer asked defendant if he knew her and defendant responded that he
did not know her “from a can of paint.” The officer agreed that his interactions with defendant and
Brianna were recorded by his body camera.
¶ 30 When Officer Lareau first spoke with defendant, defendant said that a female approached
him after he left the store and told him the police were looking for him and that she was going to
get a restraining order against him. Defendant said that the woman threatened him with a knife, so
he began to record her and said to her, “Oh, you’re gonna *** stab me while you’re on camera.”
The officer was eventually able to review defendant’s recording of Brianna. He agreed that Brianna
told him that she pulled a knife on defendant. The officer did not see a knife in the video and the
two accounts of the incident did not exactly match up.
13
¶ 31 Officer Lareau later verified defendant’s identification and learned that he was wanted for
questioning in the incident that occurred on March 17, 2024. Thereafter, Officer Lareau spoke with
defendant, read him his Miranda rights, and spoke with defendant again.
¶ 32 Officer Lareau’s body camera footage was played for the jury. It was dated April 18, 2024,
and began at 3:02 a.m. The footage revealed the same information to which Officer Lareau
testified. At the conclusion of the body camera footage, the officer confirmed that after he spoke
with defendant, defendant was taken to the police station to meet with detectives. No cross-
examination was requested.
¶ 33 Kami Davis testified that she was an emergency department nurse and sexual assault nurse
examiner (SANE) at Carle Foundation Hospital. She was working at the hospital on March 17,
2024. Brianna arrived while Kami was near the end of her shift. Brianna stated that “she had been
raped and pistol whipped.” Kami explained that patients needed to be medically cleared before the
SANE exam could be performed. In Brianna’s case, there were wounds that needed attention and
CT scans that needed to be taken. The next shift SANE nurse came in at 7 a.m. Kami provided an
oral report to the next shift nurse that included Brianna’s disclosure about what happened to her
and the status of the CT scan results. Brianna was very sleepy, tearful, and withdrawn.
¶ 34 On cross-examination, Kami stated that Brianna provided the information to her, and she
did not ask Brianna questions. She wrote the information on a scratch piece of paper that was
transferred to the paperwork in the SANE kit. Brianna told her that the assault happened in an
abandoned field or park. Brianna was brought in around 4 a.m.
¶ 35 Jamie Elzy, an emergency department nurse and SANE examiner at Carle Foundation
Hospital, testified that she met Brianna on March 17, 2024. Brianna told her that she had been
sexually assaulted and stated that the man tried to put two of his fingers in her butt. She further
14
stated that the man wore a condom, initially tried to put his penis in her anus, but when it did not
fit, he put his penis in her vagina. Brianna also stated that she had been pistol whipped. Jamie
performed a medical forensic examination and collected evidence from Brianna. She believed
Brianna was brought in around 5 a.m. but stated the examination did not occur until around 8 a.m.
Jamie took vaginal and anal swabs. She noted that Brianna had anal and vaginal tenderness along
with cervical redness. The swabs were placed in a sealed sexual assault kit and eventually released
to the police.
¶ 36 On cross-examination, Jamie agreed she was the second SANE nurse to talk with Brianna.
She did not recall receiving any written report from the first nurse but agreed there was an oral
report when she came on shift. She stated that police arrived around 7:45 a.m. She was in the room
for about a minute but then stepped out to give them privacy. When Jamie returned, she obtained
a history from Brianna. Brianna stated that she had been strangled but would not provide any more
information about that besides showing how it occurred on the mannequin. There were injuries on
Brianna’s body that were consistent with choking, near her chin. Brianna declined to address any
alcohol or drugs she may have taken the prior evening. Jamie collected Brianna’s underwear and
a pair of pants. She also examined Brianna’s pants but found no dirt or bodily fluid on them.
¶ 37 Jennifer Acosta-Talbot, an expert in the field of DNA who worked for the Illinois State
Police Forensic Crime Laboratory, testified that she received and analyzed the swab samples
obtained from Brianna. She also received a buccal sample from defendant. She generated profiles
of the samples collected from Brianna and then compared the profiles to any standards she
received. Brianna’s swabs included vaginal, oral, anal, right ear, and left hip swabs. She also
received one that said “right” but had no idea where that was taken. There was insufficient male
DNA to analyze on the vaginal swabs. She clarified that there was male DNA, just not enough to
15
test. She agreed that a condom would act as a barrier, if one were used. The anal swab analysis
between defendant and an unknown individual resulted in a ratio where the DNA profile was
approximately nine quadrillion times more likely to have originated from defendant than an
unknown, unrelated individual. She stated that was “very strong support” that defendant was a
contributor to the DNA profile, which was the highest level of support that could come from her
lab.
¶ 38 On cross-examination, Jennifer stated that the amount of DNA found was “fairly high.”
She did not know if the DNA sample was skin, saliva, or sperm, and explained that because
everyone needed DNA testing quickly, they presumed semen was there. The testing did not show
how long the DNA had been on Brianna, but the laboratory policy would not test DNA swabs after
seven days, although they would test clothing. The oral swabs also revealed insufficient male DNA
for testing.
¶ 39 A stipulation regarding the Ring doorbell video evidence was read to the jury. It stated,
inter alia, that the video was located at 1116 Joanne Lane on March 17, 2024, “and accurately
displays the events there occurring. The video and date times displayed on said video, including
from approximately 1:40 a.m. to 1:50 a.m., are accurate to the events displayed.”
¶ 40 Lauren Hill, a detective for the Champaign Police Department, testified that she
interviewed defendant. Detective Hill briefly described that the Ring doorbell video footage
showed defendant at the entryway to the home as well as a facial shot of defendant. It also showed
defendant walking into the residence and down the hallway wearing a letterman-style jacket and
carrying a bottle. The Ring doorbell video evidence was then played for the jury and revealed the
same information to which Detective Hill testified.
16
¶ 41 Detective Hill continued her testimony. Defendant was taken into custody relative to the
matter herein on April 18, 2024. The detective interviewed him while wearing a body camera.
After Detective Hill confirmed that the body camera was working properly at the time of the
interview, it had been downloaded and placed into retention, and that the footage was an accurate
depiction of the interview, the footage was played.
¶ 42 In the footage, defendant stated that earlier on April 18, 2024, he had left the store and was
walking down the street when a lady followed and yelled at him. The lady had a knife. She looked
familiar, but he had “dealings” with a lot of ladies. He later clarified that “dealings” meant one-
night stands. The name “Brianna” did not sound familiar to him. He did not remember going to
breakfast with Brianna. Defendant later stated that the two actually did have a “one-night stand,”
but he had not been back to Brianna’s house since that time. He denied having had sex outside
recently and he denied assaulting Brianna. He also denied having a gun. He was sleeping the
morning of the alleged assault and was going to church later since it was a Sunday. When Detective
Hill pointed out to defendant that he was on video at Brianna’s house the early morning of the
assault, he stated he had not said they were not together that night, but that he “probably” paid her
$100 to have sex because she looked like a prostitute.
¶ 43 On cross-examination, Detective Hill confirmed that in addition to the Ring doorbell video,
Brianna provided her with another video that showed Brianna going to the door when the police
arrived. There was a facial shot of defendant approaching the door. The police received no
additional video evidence.
¶ 44 On the third day of trial, the State moved to present a portion of a jail call recording of
defendant and an unidentified woman as newly discovered evidence. It stated that the jail call
occurred 13 days prior to the current date but had only been found the day before by the State.
17
Defense counsel objected. The court overruled the objection, finding the disclosure of the phone
call to be “relatively timely,” the phone call was “very relevant because it does go to corroborate
the victim, it does go to impeach his prior statements to law enforcement,” there was no “unfair
surprise,” and there was “no lack of due diligence” on the State’s part.
¶ 45 Timothy Rivest, a detective with the Champaign Police Department, testified that his
primary role was to investigate sex crimes. He viewed the Ring doorbell video surveillance footage
and was familiar with it. The State then presented two shots from the footage to Detective Rivest.
The detective identified the first shot as being from the doorway of the interior of Brianna’s
residence. The date and time stamp depicted that the image was captured on March 17, 2024, at
1:16 a.m. The two individuals in the photograph were Brianna, who had her back to the camera,
and defendant, who was facing the camera. The second shot depicted defendant walking into the
house. The date and time stamp indicated the image was captured on March 17, 2024, at 1:30 a.m.
¶ 46 In 2024, Detective Rivest was assigned as the lead detective in this case. On October 9,
2024, he and Detective Hill met with defendant at defendant’s request and interviewed him at the
Champaign County Correctional Center. The interview was recorded by Detective Rivest’s body
camera. Detective Rivest described the conversation. When the detectives first met with defendant,
defendant stated that he wanted to discuss this case. The detectives reminded him that he had legal
counsel and then gave him the Miranda warning. Defendant indicated that he still desired to speak
to them. They then discussed the details of the case.
¶ 47 While discussing the Ring video footage with detectives, defendant stated that although he
was on the video, the date and time were not correct. He stated that the video actually captured
when he went to Brianna’s residence a couple weeks prior to the date on the video. That date is
when they had intercourse. Detective Rivest, Detective Hill, and defendant talked about two
18
separate dates that were captured on Ring recordings at Brianna’s residence. There was the Ring
video date from when defendant and Brianna had a consensual sexual encounter and then there
was a second date when the alleged assault occurred. Defendant stated that on the first date, he
was intoxicated on alcohol and high on marijuana, but on the second date, he was completely
sober.
¶ 48 Detective Rivest confirmed that the body camera footage was a true and accurate depiction
of the interview. The video of the interview was then played for the jury and was consistent with
Detective Rivest’s testimony.
¶