State v. Edelin
CourtSuperior Court of Delaware
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket1912028616, 1912028560, 1912029331
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
STATE OF DELAWARE, )
)
Plaintiff, )
)
)
v. ) Cr. ID. Nos. 1912028616;
) 1912028560;
) 1912029331
MICHAEL D. EDELIN, )
)
Defendant. )
Submitted: October 20, 2026
Decided: November 19, 2026
COMMISSIONER’S REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION THAT
DEFENDANT’S MOTION FOR POSTCONVICTION RELIEF
SHOULD BE DENIED
AND
POSTCONVICTION COUNSEL’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
SHOULD BE GRANTED
Dominic A. Carrera, Esquire, Deputy Attorney General, Department of Justice,
Wilmington, Delaware, Attorney for the State.
Patrick J. Collins, Esquire, Collins, Price, Warner, Woloshin, Wilmington,
Delaware, Attorney for Defendant Michael D. Edelin.
SALOMONE, Commissioner.
This 19th day of November 2026, upon consideration of Michael D. Edelin’s
(“Defendant” or “Edelin”) First Motion for Postconviction Relief,1 the Motion to
Withdraw as Counsel2 and accompanying Appendices,3 the Affidavit of Trial
Counsel,4 the State’s Response to Appointed Counsel’s Motion to Withdraw,5
Defendant’s Second Motion for Postconviction Relief,6 and the record in this matter,
it appears to the Court as follows:
FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
On December 5, 2019, Edelin was released from custody at James T. Vaughn
Correctional Center (“JTVCC”).7 The Defendant had just finished serving sentences
for convictions related to a robbery spree committed in 2014.8 Edelin was picked
up from JTVCC by Sherene Davis (“Davis”), a relative of his child, and given an
all-black outfit that he had previously requested.9 Davis drove Edelin to Acme
Market, where he presented a note to the Citizens Bank teller located inside the
1
State v. Michael D. Edelin, Delaware Superior Court Criminal Docket, ID No. 1912028616 at 66
(hereinafter, “D.I. __”). Defendant filed his initial Motion for Postconviction Relief on July 10,
2024. Thereafter, he filed similar motions for postconviction relief on each of July 25, 2025 and
September 16, 2025, which appear to reiterate and/or amend his initial claims (collectively, the
“First Postconviction Motion”). D.I. 84, 85, 94.
2
D.I. 80.
3
D.I. 81–82. (Appendices to Memorandum in Support of Motion to Withdraw). All references to
the Appendices to Memorandum in Support of Motion to Withdraw provided by postconviction
counsel are hereinafter referred to as “A___”.
4
D.I. 93. Affidavit of John S. Edinger, Jr., Esquire. (hereinafter, “D.I. 93 at __”).
5
D.I. 94.
6
D.I. 95.
7
D.I. 49 at 2.
8
Id.
9
Id.
2
supermarket stating “give me all of your cash, or I will shoot you.”10 The teller
handed Edelin $2,092.00 in cash.11 Davis then drove the Defendant to the Super
Lodge motel, where he paid $301.00 in cash for a weeklong rental.12 Edelin had
previously robbed this exact Citizens Bank branch during his aforementioned
robbery spree in 2014.13
On December 12, 2019, Edelin was picked up in a white Mustang and driven
to a Citizens Bank branch on Market Street.14 He entered the building and presented
a note to the bank teller, stating, “Give me all the money.”15 The teller handed Edelin
$1,525.00 in cash.16
On December 18, 2019, Defendant was picked up by the same white Mustang
and driven to Community Plaza, where he presented a note to a teller at an M&T
Bank branch that stated, “GIVE ME All the Money.”17 The teller gave Edelin
$649.00, $96.00 of which was in $2 bills.18 The Defendant had robbed this specific
M&T Bank branch three times prior.19 Thereafter, Edelin returned to the Super
10
Id.
11
Id.
12
Id.
13
Id.
14
Id.
15
Id.
16
Id.
17
Id. at 3.
18
Id.
19
Id.
3
Lodge in the white Mustang, where he was arrested later that day. 20 At the time of
his arrest, Edelin was in possession of thirty-four $2 bills.21
On February 17, 2020, Edelin was indicted for the following offenses: (i)
Robbery 1st Degree, (ii) two counts of Wearing a Disguise, and (iii) two counts of
Robbery 2nd Degree.22 Edelin retained John S. Edinger, Jr. (“Trial Counsel”) to
represent him.23
On September 22, 2020, Edelin wrote to the Court asking to dismiss Trial
Counsel because Trial Counsel did not file a motion for bail reduction.24 On October
13, 2020, the Court denied his Motion.25 On May 12, 2021, the State filed a Motion
in limine, seeking to admit evidence of Edelin’s prior bank robberies to help establish
intent and modus operandi.26 On June 30, 2021, the Court issued an order denying
the State’s Motion.27
On October 25, 2021, trial commenced, and Edelin was convicted of all
aforementioned charges in connection with the robberies.28 On July 27, 2022, the
State filed a Motion to Declare Defendant a Habitual Offender, which was granted
20
Id.
21
Id.
22
D.I. 6; D.I. 80 at 1–2.
23
A71–73.
24
D.I. 18; D.I. 80 at 2.
25
D.I. 19.
26
D.I. 29; D.I. 80 at 2–3.
27
D.I. 35.
28
D.I. 42–43.
4
during sentencing.29 On April 14, 2023, Edelin was sentenced to the mandatory
minimum of thirty-five (35) years, plus twenty-three (23) years for probation
violations, for a total of fifty-eight (58) years.30
On May 12, 2023, Edelin filed a Notice of Appeal to the Delaware Supreme
Court.31 On June 24, 2024, the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed Defendant’s
conviction.32 On July 10, 2024, Edelin filed his first pro se Motion for
Postconviction Relief.33 On August 2, 2024, the Court appointed postconviction
counsel for Defendant.34 On January 7, 2025, Patrick J. Collins, Esquire
(“Postconviction Counsel”), was appointed, and a briefing schedule was set.35
On May 30, 2025, Postconviction Counsel filed a Motion to Withdraw as
Counsel because of a lack of meritorious postconviction claims.36 On February 13,
2026, Trial Counsel filed an affidavit responding to the factual allegations of the
ineffective assistance of counsel claims raised in Defendant’s First Postconviction
Motion.37 On April 17, 2026, the State responded to Postconviction Counsel’s
Motion to Withdraw and Defendant’s First Postconviction Motion.38 On April 22,
29
D.I. 45-49; A654.
30
D.I. 49; D.I. 80 at 4.
31
D.I. 50.
32
D.I. 65.
33
D.I. 66.
34
D.I. 69.
35
D.I. 74–75.
36
D.I. 79–82.
37
D.I. 93.
38
D.I. 94.
5
2026, Edelin filed an application for sentence modification for medical reasons
pursuant to 11 Del. C. § 4217.39 On April 30, 2026, Edelin filed a Second Motion
for Postconviction Relief.40 On July 1, 2026, Edelin filed a letter with the Court
regarding his case and character.41 On October 20, 2026, the Court summarily
dismissed Edelin’s motion for modification of sentence, noting, inter alia, that
Defendant’s medical conditions do not meet good cause grounds of serious medical
illness.42 The matter is now ripe for decision.
DEFENDANT’S CLAIMS FOR POSTCONVICTION RELIEF
In his First Postconviction Motion, Edelin raises four claims for relief.43 First,
Edelin asserts an ineffective assistance of counsel claim against Trial Counsel,
claiming Trial Counsel did not object to the admission of circumstantial evidence
during trial or otherwise object at any time during trial.44 Second, Edelin alleges an
“Error in Sentencing,” claiming he was sentenced without a pre-sentence
investigative (“PSI”) report.45 Third, Edelin asserts a claim for “Close Minded
Sentencing,” contending he was sentenced without a PSI report.46 Fourth, Edelin
asserts an ineffective assistance of counsel claim against Postconviction Counsel,
39
D.I. 97.
40
D.I. 95.
41
D.I. 96.
42
D.I. 98.
43
D.I. 66; D.I. 84.
44
Id. at 3.
45
Id.; D.I. 94 ¶ 4.
46
D.I. 66 at 3.
6
alleging that Postconviction Counsel requested five extensions, failed to read his file,
and then withdrew from the case.47
In his Second Postconviction Motion,48 Edelin raises four additional claims
for relief.49 First, Edelin asserts an ineffective assistance of counsel claim against
Trial Counsel because he “did not declare [a] lying witness on [the] stand to be
treated as [a] ‘hostile witness’ because she cried.”50 Second, Edelin asserts a claim
for “Exceptional departure” from historic practice.51 Third, Edelin makes a claim
for “Unlawful Sentencing” in accordance with the Armed Career Criminal Act. 52
Fourth, Edelin raises another “Closed-Mind” claim relating to his sentencing, which
appears to be the same claim as the one set forth in his First Postconviction Motion.53
For the following reasons discussed below, each of these claims is meritless.
47
D.I. 84 at 3.
48
Although Edelin initially filed several motions for postconviction relief, the Second
Postconviction Motion appears to be a successive motion. In the Second Postconviction Motion,
Edelin acknowledged that he had previously filed one motion for postconviction relief, an
indication he did not make in his prior motions. Further, with the exception of Ground Four, the
Second Postconviction Motion purports to raise distinct claims from those asserted in his prior
motions. D.I. 66, 84, 85, 95.
49
D.I. 95 at 3.
50
Id.
51
Id.
52
Id.
53
Id.
7
APPLICABLE LAW FOR POSTCONVICTION RELIEF
Rule 61 and Procedural Bars to Relief
Superior Court Criminal Rule 61 (“Rule 61”) governs the procedures by
which an incarcerated individual may seek to have his conviction set aside based on
the court’s lack of jurisdiction or any other ground that is a sufficient factual and
legal basis for a collateral attack upon the conviction.54 Rule 61 is a means by which
the court may correct Constitutional infirmities in a conviction or sentence.55 “Rule
61 is intended to correct errors in the trial process, not allow defendants unlimited
opportunities to relitigate their convictions.”56
Considering this limitation, the Court must first determine whether there are
any procedural bars to his Postconviction Motions before considering the merits of
any of Edelin’s claims for postconviction relief.57 Rule 61(i) establishes four such
procedural bars for postconviction relief.58 Rule 61(i)(1) requires that a motion for
postconviction relief must be filed within one year of the date when the conviction
becomes final.59 Rule 61(m) provides that a judgment of conviction is final for
purposes of Rule 61(i) thirty (30) days after the Court imposes sentence if the
defendant does not file a direct appeal, and (ii) if the defendant files a direct appeal,
54
Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(a)(1).
55
Harris v. State, 410 A.2d 500 (Del. 1970).
56
Ploof v. State, 75 A.3d 811, 820 (Del. 2013).
57
Younger v. State, 580 A.2d 552, 554 (Del. 1990).
58
Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(i)(1)-(4).
59
Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(i)(1).
8
when the Supreme Court issues its mandate or order finally determining the direct
appeal.60
Rule 61(i)(2) bars second or subsequent motions for postconviction relief
unless certain conditions are met.61 In that regard, Rule 61(d)(2)(i)-(ii) provides as
follows:
(2) Second or subsequent postconviction motions. A
second or subsequent motion under this rule shall be
summarily dismissed, unless the movant was convicted
after a trial and the motion either:
(i) pleads with particularity that new evidence exists
that creates a strong inference that the movant is
actually innocent in fact of the acts underlying the
charges of which he was convicted; or
(ii) pleads with particularity a claim that a new rule of
constitutional law, made retroactive to cases on
collateral review by the United States Supreme
Court or the Delaware Supreme Court, applies to
the movant’s case and renders the conviction or
death sentence invalid.62
Pursuant to Rule 61(i)(3) and (4), any ground for relief that was not previously
raised is deemed waived, and any claims that were formerly adjudicated, whether in
the proceedings leading to the judgment of conviction, in an appeal, in a
postconviction proceeding, or in a federal habeas corpus proceeding, are thereafter
60
Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(m).
61
Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(i)(2).
62
Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(d)(2).
9
barred.63 However, ineffective assistance of counsel claims cannot be raised at any
earlier stage in the proceedings and are properly presented by way of a motion for
postconviction relief.64
Edelin’s ineffective assistance of counsel claim against Trial Counsel and
Postconviction Counsel are not procedurally barred. This Court sentenced Edelin
on April 14, 2023.65 Since Edelin filed a direct appeal, his conviction became final
when the Delaware Supreme Court issued its mandate on June 24, 2024.66 Edelin
filed his initial pro se Motion for Postconviction Relief on July 10, 2024, within one
year of his conviction becoming final.67 As such, the First Postconviction Motion
was timely filed. The ineffective assistance of counsel claims set forth in the First
Postconviction Motion are not procedurally barred by Rule 61(i)(3) and (4), as these
claims could not have been raised in any earlier stage in the proceedings.68
For Edelin’s First Postconviction Motion, the procedural time bar against
repetitive motions outlined in Rule 61(i)(2) does not apply; however, as discussed
below, Edelin’s Second Postconviction Motion is procedurally time-barred.
63
See Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(i)(5) and (d)(2)(i), (ii).
64
Sabb v. State, 2021 WL 2229631, at *1 (Del. May 28, 2021); Green v. State, 238 A.3d 160, 187-
188 (Del. 2020); Whittle v. State, 2016 WL 2585904, at *3 (Del. Apr. 28, 2016); State v. Evans-
Mayes, 2016 WL 4502303, at *2 (Del. Super. Ct. Aug. 25, 2016).
65
D.I. 49.
66
D.I. 65.
67
D.I. 66.
68
See State v. Johnson, 2014 WL 6679070 (Del. Super. Nov. 20, 2014); Duross v. State, 494 A.2d
1265, 1267 (Del. 1985).
10
Standard of Review for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims
To prevail on a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, a defendant must
satisfy the two-prong standard set forth in Strickland v. Washington.69 This test
requires a defendant to show: (a) counsel’s performance was deficient, i.e., that his
attorney’s performance “fell below an objective standard of reasonableness,”70 and
(b) prejudice.
The first prong requires the defendant to show by a preponderance of the
evidence that defense counsel was not reasonably competent.71 Judicial scrutiny
under the first prong is highly deferential. Courts must ignore the distorting effects
of hindsight and proceed with a strong presumption that counsel’s conduct was
reasonable.72 The Strickland Court explained that a court deciding an actual
ineffectiveness claim must judge the reasonableness of counsel’s challenged conduct
on the particular facts of the case, viewed as of the time of counsel’s conduct.73
The second prong asks whether a defendant has been prejudiced and requires
the movant to show that “there is a reasonable probability that, but for counsel’s
unprofessional errors, the result of the proceeding would have been different. A
reasonable probability is a probability sufficient to undermine the confidence in the
69
Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (1984).
70
Id. at 688.
71
Id. at 687-88, 694.
72
Id. at 689.
73
Id. at 690.
11
outcome.”74 Not every error that conceivably could have influenced the outcome
undermines the reliability of the result of the proceeding.75 The court must consider
the totality of the evidence and must ask if the movant has met the burden of showing
that the decision reached would reasonably likely have been different absent the
errors.76 “The benchmark for judging any claim of ineffectiveness must be whether
counsel’s conduct so undermined the proper functioning of the adversarial process
that the trial cannot be relied on as having produced a just result.”77
The burden of proving ineffective assistance of counsel lies with the
defendant.78 A defendant must make and substantiate concrete allegations of actual
prejudice; mere allegations of ineffectiveness or conclusory statements will not
suffice.79 The court must be convinced that the alleged errors were so serious that
counsel was not properly functioning as the “counsel” guaranteed to a defendant by
the Sixth Amendment.80 It is not enough for a defendant to demonstrate that the
error had some “conceivable effect” on the outcome, but rather that the error
undermined the reliability of the result of the proceeding.81
74
Id. at 694.
75
Id. at 693.
76
Dale v. State, 2017 WL 443705, at * 2 (Del. Jan. 31, 2017); Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S.
668, 695-696 (1984).
77
Cooke v. State, 977 A.2d 803, 840 (Del. 2009) (quoting Strickland, 466 U.S. at 686).
78
Oliver v. State, 2001 WL 1751246, at *1 (Del. Oct. 16, 2001).
79
Younger v. State, 580 A.2d 552, 556 (Del. 1990).
80
State v. Gonzalez, 2019 WL 1762976, at *1 (Del. Super. Ct. Apr. 18, 2018).
81
Id.
12
The Strickland standard is highly demanding and leads to a strong
presumption that counsel’s conduct fell within a wide range of reasonable
professional assistance.82 While not insurmountable, there is a strong presumption
that defense counsel’s conduct constituted sound trial strategy.83
Motion to Withdraw
A Motion to Withdraw as Postconviction Counsel is governed by Rule
61(e)(6). Rule 61(e)(6) provides that:
If counsel considers the movant’s claim to be so lacking in
merit that counsel cannot ethically advocate it, and counsel
is not aware of any other substantial ground for relief
available to the movant, counsel may move to withdraw.
The motion shall explain the factual and legal basis for
counsel’s opinion and shall give notice that the movant
may file a response to the motion within 30 days of service
of the motion upon the movant.84
To evaluate Edelin’s Motions and determine whether his Postconviction
Counsel’s motion to withdraw should be granted, the Court should be satisfied that
Postconviction Counsel made a conscientious examination of the record and the law
for claims that could arguably support the Motions. In addition, the Court should
82
Albury v. State, 551 A.2d 53, 59 (Del. 1988); Salih v. State, 2008 WL 4762323, at *1 (Del. Oct.
31, 2008).
83
Strickland, 466 U.S. at 689 (1984).
84
See Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(e)(6).
13
conduct its own review of the record to determine whether the Motions are so totally
devoid of any, at least, arguable postconviction claims.85
With this backdrop in mind, the Court turns to Edelin’s specific postconviction
claims.
EDELIN’S FIRST POSTCONVICTION MOTION
A. Trial Counsel Properly Argued Evidence and Objected During Trial
Edelin argues in ground one of his First Postconviction Motion that Trial
Counsel’s representation was ineffective because (i) he failed to object to the
admission of circumstantial evidence and (ii) he did not object during trial.86 Edelin
appears to be under a misapprehension regarding the use of circumstantial evidence
in Delaware courts. Contrary to Edelin’s belief, Trial Counsel is not required to
argue against the admission of circumstantial evidence; under Delaware law, “guilt
may be proven exclusively through circumstantial evidence since this Court does not
distinguish between direct and circumstantial evidence in a conviction context.” 87
Additionally, the jury was instructed on this point.88 As such, Trial Counsel’s failure
to object to circumstantial evidence at trial was not unreasonable.
85
Matos v. State, 2015 WL 5719694, *2 (Del. Supr. Sept. 29, 2015).
86
D.I. 66 at 3.
87
Seward v. State, 723 A.2d 365, 379 (Del. 1999) (quoting Davis v. State, 706 A.2d 523, 525 (Del.
1998)).
88
D.I. 82 at A607–08.
14
Edelin’s assertion that Trial Counsel was ineffective because he did not object
during trial is also without merit because the record shows that Trial Counsel
successfully objected to the admission of evidence at several points during the trial.89
For example, Trial Counsel objected to several videos taken at the Super Lodge
Motel based on authenticity concerns, which were ultimately resolved between the
parties.90 Trial Counsel also objected to a paragraph in the State’s PowerPoint
presentation which was removed.91 Similarly, Trial Counsel objected to the use of
the phrase “bank robbery spree” in the same PowerPoint presentation on the basis of
it being argumentative, which language the Court also instructed the State to
modify.92
During direct examination of Detective McDerby, Trial Counsel objected to
the detective identifying the individual wearing black clothing in a video provided
by the State as the suspect.93 This objection was also successful.94 Trial Counsel
also objected to a document the State displayed during the detective’s direct
examination because it contained the phrase “For law enforcement purposes only”
at the bottom.95 The Court sustained the objection and the language was stricken.96
89
D.I. 81 at A139–40, A142, A185, A188, A191, A217, A357, A367–68.
90
Id.
91
Id. at A142.
92
Id.
93
Id. at A185.
94
Id.
95
Id. at A188.
96
Id.
15
During the direct examination of one of the bank tellers, Trial Counsel
objected to a leading question, which the State then rephrased. 97 During direct
examination of Ragesh Mevawela, Trial Counsel objected to the authenticity of a
video.98 This objection led to the entire video being excluded from evidence.99
During the direct examination of Brian Dunphy, Trial Counsel again objected to a
leading question.100 The Court sustained the objection and asked the State to
rephrase the question.101
Considering the many successful objections that Trial Counsel raised during
trial, the Court cannot find merit in Defendant’s ineffective assistance of counsel
claim for failing to raise objections. Decisions about when and whether to object
during trial are within the purview of counsel,102 and Trial Counsel exercised his
discretion appropriately throughout the trial. Moreover, Edelin’s failure to articulate
any specific moments during trial when Trial Counsel should have objected and
failed to do so or otherwise argue that the result of the proceedings would have been
different but for his failure to object, prevents the Court from finding any prejudice
97
Id. at A191.
98
Id. at A217.
99
Id. at A357.
100
Id. at A367–68.
101
Id. at A368.
102
See State v. Appiah, No. 1808022193, 2023 WL 5608927, at *8 (Del. Super. Aug. 28, 2023)
(explaining that trial counsel has discretion to make strategic choices regarding trial strategy,
including which objections to raise, witnesses to call, and defenses to pursue).
16
resulted from Trial Counsel’s actions or inactions.103 As such, this claim is without
merit.
B. Edelin’s Sentencing was Properly Conducted with a PSI
Edelin argues in grounds two and three of his First Postconviction Motion that
he was sentenced without a PSI and that this sentencing was close-minded.104 These
claims are procedurally barred because they raise trial court error and therefore
should have been raised on direct appeal to the Delaware Supreme Court.105
Moreover, Edelin has not specifically stated any cause for relief from the procedural
default or any prejudice that occurred to overcome this procedural bar as required
by Rule 61(i)(3).106
However, even if the claims were not procedurally barred, Edelin admitted
that a PSI did take place, stating that an officer asked him two questions and
produced a seven-page PSI report.107 Upon further inquiry, Postconviction Counsel
learned that what Edelin intended to argue was that his PSI was inadequate because
it lasted only a few minutes.108 Postconviction Counsel explained that Edelin’s
presentence interview may have been brief because the PSI report specifically
103
D.I. 66 at 3.
104
Id.
105
State v. Pinkston, 2013 WL 3819637, at *5 (Del. Super. July 22, 2013) (explaining that
Defendant should have raised claims on direct appeal because they allege trial court error).
106
Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(i)(3); see D.I. 66 at 3.
107
D.I. 85 at 3.
108
D.I. 80 at 16.
17
referenced Edelin’s prior presentence reports regarding his social and developmental
history.109 As such, the interviewer did not need to take time to ask those questions
during his interview. Also, the record reflects that the Court considered the PSI
report in Edelin’s favor at sentencing and found his acceptance of responsibility (for
at least one robbery) as a mitigating factor.110 Finally, Edelin was sentenced to the
mandatory minimum, so it cannot be found that the judge was closed-minded or that
a longer presentence investigation or PSI report would have reduced Edelin’s
sentence any further or otherwise prejudiced him.111 Therefore, these claims are also
without merit.
C. Edelin Cannot Raise an Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claim against
Postconviction Counsel
Edelin argues in ground four of his First Postconviction Motion that
Postconviction Counsel was ineffective because he asked for five extensions, never
fully read his file, and then withdrew.112 Postconviction Counsel’s extensive Motion
to Withdraw with accompanying appendices suggest otherwise.113 Regardless,
Edelin cannot claim that Postconviction Counsel was ineffective because there is no
109
Id. at 17.
110
Id.; D.I. 82 at A666–67; D.I. 94 at 3. Although Defendant admitted to the first robbery, his
statements in numerous letters to the Court suggest that he does not appreciate the violent nature
of his crimes. Defendant describes himself as “far from a violent person” and states that he does
not “condone gun violence or any violence for that matter.” D.I. 85.
111
D.I. 80 at 17.
112
D.I. 84.
113
D.I. 80–82.
18
constitutional right to counsel in postconviction proceedings. 114 Therefore, Edelin
cannot obtain relief based on Postconviction Counsel’s alleged mistakes.115
EDELIN’S SECOND POSTCONVICTION MOTION
A. Edelin’s Claims Are Procedurally Barred
Rule 61(d)(2)(i)-(ii) requires that a second postconviction motion be
summarily dismissed unless the motion “pleads with particularity that new evidence
exists that creates a strong inference that the movant is actually innocent in fact of
the acts underlying the charges of which he was convicted” or “pleads with
particularity a claim that a new rule of constitutional law, made retroactive to cases
on collateral review by the United States Supreme Court or the Delaware Supreme
Court, applies to the movant’s case and renders the conviction or death sentence
invalid.”116 Here, Edelin’s Second Postconviction Motion asserts neither exception
expressly.117 In ground one, Edelin alleges that Trial Counsel was ineffective for
failing to request that a certain witness be treated as “hostile” and, in grounds two,
114
Watson v. State, 2009 WL 2006883, at *2 (Del. July 13, 2009) (holding that a claim of
ineffective assistance of postconviction counsel was not viable because there is no constitutional
right to counsel in postconviction proceedings and, alternatively, the defendant failed to
demonstrate prejudice).
115
Id.
116
Super. Ct. Crim. R. 61(d)(2).
117
See D.I. 95 at 3. The Court notes that Edelin cites to the United States Supreme Court decision
in Apprendi v. New Jersey, 530 U.S. 466 (2000), and its progeny in his Second Postconviction
Motion, presumably in an attempt to meet the pleading requirement set forth in Rule 61(d)(2).
While the Third Circuit Court of Appeals expressly held that Apprendi announced a new rule of
criminal procedure, it further held that the rule does not apply retroactively to cases on collateral
review. See United States v. Swinton, 333 F.3d 481 (2003).
19
three, and four, he asserts additional claims of improper sentencing.118 None of these
grounds plead with the particularity required to create a strong inference that Edelin
is innocent or that a new rule of constitutional law applies to his case retroactively.119
Rather than pleading his innocence, Edelin admitted to the robberies in his various
submissions to the Court.120 Moreover, all of these claims appear to be variations
and/or reiterations of the arguments as set forth in his First Postconviction Motion.121
While these claims should be summarily dismissed on procedural grounds, these
claims are also substantively meritless.
B. Trial Decisions Are Within Trial Counsel’s Discretion
Edelin argues in ground one of his Second Postconviction Motion that Trial
Counsel was ineffective because he failed to request that the Court declare a witness
to be “hostile” when she cried.122 Although worded differently, this claim is
substantially similar to the claims set forth in Edelin’s First Postconviction Motion
in which he asserts that Trial Counsel failed to object during trial.123 Just as decisions
regarding whether to make objections are within the discretion of trial counsel, a
request to declare a witness as “hostile” is a strategic choice likewise entirely within
118
Id.
119
See id.
120
See D.I. 66, 96.
121
D.I. 95 at 3.
122
Id. A “hostile witness” is a witness whose testimony is so unfavorable, evasive, or contradictory
to previous statements that the court allows the party who called the witness to question him as if
he were an adverse witness, using leading questions normally reserved for cross-examination.
123
D.I. 66 at 3.
20
counsel’s purview.124 Additionally, since Edelin does not articulate with specificity
the reason Trial Counsel should have made this request or how he was prejudiced
by Trial Counsel’s failure to do so, the Court cannot find merit in this claim.
C. Edelin Was Correctly Declared a Habitual Offender
Edelin’s argument in ground two of his Second Postconviction Motion relates
to his habitual offender status, wherein he argues that there was an “exceptional
departure” from historic practice in his sentencing because the fact that he had prior
convictions was used to declare him a habitual offender.125 This argument, however,
demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of how habitual offender status is
determined under Delaware law. To be declared a habitual criminal offender in
Delaware, a person must have been convicted three times of a Title 11 violent
felony.126 Under Title 11, robbery in the first degree and robbery in the second
degree are both violent felonies.127 Additionally, the Delaware Supreme Court has
interpreted the habitual offender statute as imposing a rehabilitation requirement,
under which the offender must have “committed still a third offense after having had
two prior convictions followed by two separate chances to reform.”128 Once
124
See Appiah, 2023 WL 5608927, at *8 (explaining that trial counsel has discretion to make
strategic choices regarding trial strategy, including which objections to raise, witnesses to call, and
defenses to pursue).
125
This argument was discerned from his Second Postconviction Motion as well as the numerous
letters Edelin sent to the Court stating his issues with being declared a habitual offender. See D.I.
66, 85, 95, 96.
126
DEL CODE ANN., tit 11, § 4214(a) (2018).
127
DEL CODE ANN., tit 11, § 4201(c)(1) (2026).
128
Hall v. State, 473 A.2d 352, 356 (Del. 1984).
21
declared a habitual offender, the offender “shall receive a minimum sentence of the
statutory maximum statutory penalty provided elsewhere in this title for the third or
subsequent Title 11 violent felony.”129
Here, Edelin had been convicted of two counts of robbery in the first degree
and two counts of robbery in the second degree in 2008, and was then given a chance
to reform before he was convicted of one count of robbery in the first degree and
one count of robbery in the second degree in 2014.130 Edelin was given another
chance to reform while serving his sentence for his 2014 convictions but, after
completing his sentence in 2014 and being released, he immediately returned to
robbing banks and was convicted a third time in 2019 for one count of robbery in
the first degree and two counts of robbery in the second degree.131 Therefore, the
Court correctly declared Edelin a habitual offender in accordance with the statute.
With habitual offender status, the mandatory minimum for these 2019 violent
felonies became the statutory maximum of thirty-five (35) years, with a maximum
sentence of life.132 The Court, however, chose to apply the mitigating factor of
remorse, leading Edelin to be sentenced to the mandatory minimum of thirty-five
129
DEL CODE ANN., tit 11, § 4214(d) (2026).
130
D.I. 45.
131
Id.
132
See D.I. 82 at A654.
22
(35) years for these related violent felonies instead of the maximum term of life
imprisonment.133
In support of his claim for improper sentencing, Edelin cites the United States
Supreme Court decision in Apprendi v. New Jersey, where the Supreme Court held
“[t] he Constitution requires that any fact that increases the penalty for a crime
beyond the prescribed statutory maximum, other than the fact of a prior conviction,
must be submitted to a jury and proved beyond a reasonable doubt.”134 Notably, the
Supreme Court made an explicit exception to the requirement that enhanced
sentencing be submitted to a jury for the “fact of a prior conviction.”135 Because of
this exception, the Court may take into account Edelin’s prior convictions in
determining his habitual offender status without the need for a jury determination.136
Edelin likewise cites the United States Supreme Court decision in Mathis v.
United States to support his claim for improper sentencing.137 The Mathis decision
addresses the Armed Career Criminal Act (“ACCA”), which is a federal law that
“imposes a 15–year mandatory minimum sentence on a defendant convicted of being
a felon in possession of a firearm who also has three prior state or federal convictions
‘for a violent felony.’”138 In determining whether the ACCA applied, the Mathis
133
See id. at A667.
134
530 U.S. 466, 466 (2000).
135
Id. at 490.
136
See id.
137
D.I. 95 at 3.
138
Mathis v. U.S., 579 U.S. 500, 500 (2016).
23
Court cited Apprendi, stating that a court may use the mere fact of a prior conviction
to enhance a sentence, but not the underlying facts of that conviction.139 Based on
his citation to the foregoing cases, the Court gleans that Edelin believes that the
underlying facts of his prior convictions were considered improperly when he was
sentenced as a habitual offender. That, however, is not true. In deciding whether
Edelin qualified for habitual offender status, the Court considered only his prior
convictions, not the underlying facts of those convictions.140 Therefore, this claim is
without merit.
D. Edelin Was Not Sentenced Under the ACCA
Edelin argues in ground three of his Second Postconviction Motion that he
was “unlawfully sentenced in accordance with the Armed Career Criminal Act,”
which he asserts does not pertain to him as he contends he is not a violent criminal.141
The Court agrees that the ACCA does not apply to him. Indeed, Edelin was not
sentenced under the ACCA because the ACCA pertains to federal as opposed to state
crimes.142 The crimes that constitute violent felonies under Delaware are
enumerated by statute,143 regardless of how Edelin views himself or his crimes. For
139
Id. at 511.
140
D.I. 45.
141
D.I. 95 at 3.
142
See 18 U.S.C. § 922.
143
DEL CODE ANN., tit 11, § 4201(c) (2026).
24
these reasons, the Court also finds Edelin’s claim of unlawful sentencing under the
ACCA to be without merit.
Finally, Edelin argues again in ground four of his Second Postconviction
Motion that the judge sentenced him with a “Closed Mind.” For the reasons
previously discussed, this claim is without merit.144
CONCLUSION
The Court has reviewed the record carefully and has concluded that Edelin’s
First Postconviction Motion and Second Postconviction Motion are without merit
and devoid of any other substantial claims for relief. The Court is also satisfied that
Postconviction Counsel made a conscientious effort to examine the record and the
law and has properly determined that Defendant does not have a meritorious claim
to be raised in his postconviction motion. For the foregoing reasons, Edelin’s First
Motion for Postconviction Relief and Second Motion for Postconviction Relief
should be DENIED, and Postconviction Counsel’s Motion to Withdraw should be
GRANTED.
IT IS SO RECOMMENDED.
/s/ Janine M. Salomone
The Honorable Janine M. Salomone
144
See id.
25
oc: Prothonotary
cc: John S. Edinger, Jr.
Michael Edelin (SBI #00262150)
26