Jabree Robertson v. United States
CourtCourt of Appeals for the Third Circuit
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket25-1401
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NOT PRECEDENTIAL
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT
___________
No. 25-1401
__________
JABREE ROBERTSON,
Appellant
v.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
____________________________________
On Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania
(D.C. Civil Action No. 2:23-cv-02729)
District Judge: Honorable Harvey Bartle III
____________________________________
Submitted Pursuant to Third Circuit LAR 34.1(a)
September 18, 2026
Before: BIBAS, CHUNG, and BOVE, Circuit Judges
(Opinion filed November 20, 2026)
___________
OPINION*
___________
PER CURIAM
Jabree Robertson appeals, pro se, from the District Court’s judgment, entered after
*
This disposition is not an opinion of the full Court and pursuant to I.O.P. 5.7 does not
constitute binding precedent.
a bench trial, in favor of the United States of America on his assault and battery claim
under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA), 28 U.S.C. §§ 1346(b) and 2680(h). For the
following reasons, we will affirm.
On March 18, 2020, Robertson was wanted by the Chester Police Department for
first-degree murder with a weapon. That morning, a task force of local and federal law
enforcement officers, including members of the United States Marshals Violent Crime
Fugitive Task Force, arrived at a house in Chester, where Robertson was staying with his
girlfriend, to execute an arrest warrant and take him into custody. An adult granted the
officers permission to enter the house, and Robertson’s girlfriend acknowledged that he
was upstairs; however, she would not tell the officers whether he was armed. Robertson,
who was 6’4”, weighed 200 pounds, and had a violent criminal history, ignored repeated
calls to surrender and hid under a bed in an upstairs bedroom. The officers attempted to
use a remote camera to locate Robertson upstairs, to no avail. After twenty minutes
passed without a response from Robertson, several officers proceeded upstairs, cleared
other rooms, evacuated an occupant of another bedroom, and then entered the bedroom in
which Robertson was hiding.
Once officers cleared the closets of the room, Officer Clark lifted the bed, finding
Robertson lying on his stomach with his hands underneath him. Officer Eckman saw
what he believed to be an AR-15 rifle underneath Robertson and announced, “Gun!” (It
was later determined to be a paintball gun.). In response, one officer sat on top of
Robertson and held down his head, while other officers tried to get his hands out from
under him. Because Robertson resisted releasing his hands from underneath him, two
2
officers delivered compliance strikes to his side, which ultimately allowed them to
handcuff him. Robertson was taken downstairs and relinquished to local law
enforcement. Later that day, in response to his counsel’s request, Robertson was taken to
the hospital, where it was determined that he had fractured ribs, abrasions to his face, and
an injury to his left wrist.
Robertson filed a counseled complaint against the United States under the FTCA,
alleging a claim for assault and battery stemming from the encounter. After a bench trial
on liability, the District Court issued findings of fact and conclusions of law, determining
that the officers acted reasonably in their use of force and, thus, that the United States
was not liable for assault and battery. The District Court entered judgment in favor of the
United States, and this timely appeal ensued.
The District Court had jurisdiction under the FTCA pursuant to 28 U.S.C
§ 1346(b). We have jurisdiction over this appeal pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1291. After a
bench trial, we review the District Court’s factual findings for clear error, and “give due
regard to the trial court’s opportunity to judge the witnesses’ credibility.” Am. Soc’y for
Testing & Materials v. Corrpro Cos., 478 F.3d 557, 566 (3d Cir. 2007) (quotation marks
and citation omitted). We exercise plenary review over the District Court’s conclusions
of law. Kosiba v. Merck & Co., 384 F.3d 58, 64 (3d Cir. 2004).
Contrary to Robertson’s claim, the District Court applied the proper law.
Pennsylvania law governs the assault and battery claim under the FTCA. See 28 U.S.C.
§ 1346(b)(1); Molzof v. United States, 502 U.S. 301, 305 (1992) (noting that “the extent
of the United States’ liability under the FTCA is generally determined by reference to
3
state law”). “Similar to a Fourth Amendment claim,” Pelzer v. City of Philadelphia, 656
F. Supp. 2d 517, 539 (E.D. Pa. 2009), a police officer is not liable for assault and battery
under Pennsylvania law if he uses reasonable force to make a lawful arrest. See Renk v.
City of Pittsburgh, 641 A.2d 289, 293 (Pa. 1994).
The District Court also properly considered the following factors in determining
whether the use of force was objectively reasonable: “the severity of the crime at issue,
whether the suspect[s] pose[s] an immediate threat to the safety of the officers or others,
and whether [he] is actively resisting arrest or attempting to evade arrest by flight” as
well as “the physical injury to the plaintiff, the possibility that the person[ ] subject to the
police action [is] [himself] violent or dangerous, the duration of the action, whether the
action takes place in the context of effecting an arrest, the possibility that the suspect may
be armed, and the number of persons with whom the police officers must contend at one
time.” El v. City of Pittsburgh, 975 F.3d 327, 336 (3d Cir. 2020) (citations and quotation
marks omitted).
Robertson asks us to set aside the District Court’s judgment, arguing that it
“abused [its] discretion” in determining that the officers used reasonable force against
him. Appellant’s Br. at 3. Rather than challenge the judgment as against the weight of
the evidence, Robertson challenges certain factual findings made by the District Court.
In particular, Robertson argues that he was “laying on the ground” not being a threat to
“anyone,” while emphasizing that no one testified that he “was armed with a weapon in
his hands” and that he was never charged with resisting arrest. Appellant’s Br. at 5. He
further argues that the District Court minimized the severity of his injuries, claiming that
4
“[t]o break bones and tear lig[a]ments it takes alot (sic) of force which is excessive.” Id.
Robertson also challenges the District Court’s finding that he walked down the staircase
of the house from the upstairs bedroom, claiming that eyewitnesses watched the officers
drag him down the stairs and out of the house. Finally, he claims that the District Court
abused its discretion in permitting the officers to testify that he was laying on a paintball
gun when there was no DNA or fingerprint evidence and no pictures were taken when the
“excessive force took place.” Id. at 5.
We find no clear error with the District Court’s findings. First, it determined that
Robertson was not credible to the extent his testimony differed from its findings.
Because credibility determinations are “quintessentially the province of the trial court,”
we reject them only in “rare circumstances,” and there is no basis to reject the credibility
determination here. Dardovitch v. Haltzman, 190 F.3d 125, 140 (3d Cir. 1999). As
relevant to this appeal, there is no reason to reject the District Court’s decision to
discount Robertson’s testimony that he became unconscious while he was upstairs and
“woke up at the bottom of the stairs,” so officers “must have dragged” him down the
staircase. Trial Tr. at 13-14. At trial, Robertson did not claim to remember being
dragged, and five officers testified that he never lost consciousness and walked down the
stairs on his own. To the extent Roberston claims on appeal that there were eyewitnesses
who would testify otherwise, he failed to present them at trial.
Next, the fact that the weapon was not in Robertson’s hands and he was not
charged with resisting arrest does not undermine the District Court’s finding that he
posed a threat to the officers. As the District Court noted (1) Robertson had a violent
5
criminal history and was wanted for first-degree murder with a firearm, which had not
been recovered; (2) he had a prior conviction for resisting arrest; and (3) he had not
turned himself in for the murder nor did he surrender at the house, despite 20 minutes of
calls by officers to do so. And his girlfriend refused to say whether he was armed. Given
those undisputed facts, the District Court did not clearly err in finding that “[t]he
circumstances led to the reasonable conclusion that [Robertson] had the capacity for
lethal violence, that he would not comply if confronted, and that he was probably armed.”
ECF No. 46 at 8.
We also find no clear error with the District Court’s conclusion that the use of
force was objectively reasonable and lasted no longer than necessary to effectuate the
arrest. The fact that the paintball gun was not tested for DNA or photographed during the
struggle to arrest Robertson neither precludes nor undermines the officers’ testimony
regarding the gun. In particular, the officers testified that, when the bed was lifted,
Robertson was found lying on his stomach with both his hands and the gun underneath
him. To the officers, the gun looked like an AR-15 rifle because only the barrel and fore
grip were visible; Officer Eckman announced “gun,” prompting the officers to make
contact with Robertson to prevent him from using the weapon. One officer jumped on
Robertson’s back and pushed his head down to prevent him from getting up. Two other
officers delivered compliance strikes to Robertson’s rib section because he would not
release his hands out from under him. Given Robertson’s refusal to release his hands, the
officers were forced to make “split-second judgments” regarding the use of force to
prevent his use of the gun. Graham, 490 U.S. at 396-97 (“The calculus of reasonableness
6
must embody allowance for the fact that police officers are often forced to make split-
second judgments -- in circumstances that are tense, uncertain, and rapidly evolving --
about the amount of force that is necessary in a particular situation.”). Within 45 seconds
after the bed was lifted, Robertson was in handcuffs and the use of force ceased.
Finally, we agree with the District Court that Robertson’s injuries were consistent
with the reasonable use of force. Robertson presented hospital medical records from the
day of his arrest which indicate that he had “an injured wrist, ‘abrasions’ to his face, and
fractured ribs.” ECF No. 46 at 9; see also Trial Tr. at 153-54, 175. As the District Court
noted, the medical records stated that the injury to the wrist is “likely a chronic injury.”
Trial Tr. at 175; ECF No. 46 at 9. The fractured ribs are consistent with the use of
compliance strikes in response to Robertson’s resistance. And, contrary to his claim on
appeal, there was no credible evidence at trial that Robertson had a torn ligament or a
concussion, or that the abrasions he suffered were more than a minor injury.
Based on the foregoing, we will affirm the District Court’s judgment.1
1
Appellant’s “Supplement Extension Petition Brief in Support of Extension of Time” is
denied.
7