Full Opinion

SIXTH DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL STATE OF FLORIDA _____________________________ Case No. 6D2023-0739 Lower Tribunal No. 19-CF-000606-A _____________________________ SHEILA O’LEARY, Appellant, v. STATE OF FLORIDA, Appellee. _____________________________ Appeal from the Circuit Court for Lee County. Bruce Kyle, Judge. November 20, 2026 MIZE, J. Appellant, Sheila O’Leary (“Defendant”), timely appeals her convictions and sentences for first-degree murder, aggravated child abuse, aggravated manslaughter of a child, child abuse, and two counts of child neglect. 1 Defendant makes a number of arguments, only one of which we discuss. Defendant argues that the trial court erred by prohibiting her from cross- examining her ex-husband – a key State witness – regarding the fact that 1 This case was transferred from the Second District Court of Appeal to this Court on January 1, 2023. Defendant previously accused the ex-husband’s mother of sexual abuse. Defendant sought to cross-examine the ex-husband concerning this issue in order to establish that the ex-husband was biased against the Defendant. The Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution, Article I, Section 16(a) of the Florida Constitution, and the Florida Evidence Code 2 all protect the right of a criminal defendant to cross-examine a State witness to show that the witness is biased. Middlebrook v. State, 403 So. 3d 508, 511-15 (Fla. 6th DCA 2025). Thus, “evidence of a State witness’s bias against a criminal defendant is always relevant and a proper subject of cross-examination.” Id. at 515. “The trial court does not have the discretion to exclude questions which touch upon interest, motive, or animus.” Id. at 514 (quoting Tomengo v. State, 864 So. 2d 525, 530-31 (Fla. 5th DCA 2004). “Moreover, it is not just the fact of bias itself or the general idea of bias that is relevant and a proper subject of cross-examination. Rather, a criminal defendant is entitled to cross-examine a State witness regarding the specific facts which might cause the witness to be biased against the defendant.” Id. at 515 (citing Davis v. Alaska, 415 U.S. 308, 318 (1974)). “This includes 2 Section 90.608(2), Florida Statutes (2022), provides that “[a]ny party, including the party calling the witness, may attack the credibility of a witness by . . . . [s]howing that the witness is biased.” Section 90.612(2), Florida Statutes (2022), likewise provides that “[c]ross-examination of a witness is limited to the subject matter of the direct examination and matters affecting the credibility of the witness.” (emphasis added). 2 matters that are not otherwise related to the crime charged and that were not the subject of the State’s direct examination of the witness.” Id. at 515. The fact that Defendant accused her ex-husband’s mother of sexual abuse was certainly a possible reason for the ex-husband to be biased against Defendant. Accordingly, because Defendant was entitled to cross-examine a State witness regarding any grounds that might cause the witness to be biased against her, the trial court erred by prohibiting Defendant from cross-examining her ex-husband regarding the fact that Defendant previously accused the ex-husband’s mother of sexual abuse. The State argues that even if the trial court erred by prohibiting Defendant from cross-examining her ex-husband regarding the fact that Defendant previously accused the ex-husband’s mother of sexual abuse, the error was harmless because Defendant’s ex-husband was examined concerning other reasons that he had negative feelings toward Defendant. We previously rejected this argument in Middlebrook, and we reject it again here. “A criminal defendant is entitled to cross-examine a State witness regarding the specific facts which might cause the witness to be biased against the defendant.” Middlebrook, 403 So. 3d at 516 (citing Davis, 415 U.S. at 318). “Thus, an examination of the witness regarding the facts surrounding one possible ground for bias is no substitute for the right to cross- 3 examine the witness regarding another, different ground for bias.” Id. at 516-17 (citing McDuffie v. State, 341 So. 2d 840, 841 (Fla. 2d DCA 1977)). The trial court erred by prohibiting Defendant from cross-examining her ex- husband regarding the fact that Defendant previously accused the ex-husband’s mother of sexual abuse, and the error was not harmless. Defendant’s convictions and sentences are reversed, and this case is remanded for a new trial. REVERSED and REMANDED. STARGEL and NARDELLA, JJ., concur. Blair Allen, Public Defender, and Jason Reid, Special Assistant Public Defender, Bartow, for Appellant. James Uthmeier, Attorney General, Tallahassee, and Clara V. Murga, Assistant Attorney General, Tampa, for Appellee. NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF TIMELY FILED 4