United States v. Morgan
CourtDistrict Court, District of Columbia
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
DocketCriminal No. 2023-0239
JudgeJudge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
Defendants.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA )
)
v. ) No. 23-cr-239 (CKK)
)
ILYA LICHTENSTEIN and )
HEATHER MORGAN, )
)
)
OMNIBUS MEMORANDUM OPINION
(November 19, 2026)
Pending before this Court is Non-Party Richard Roe’s [344] Redacted Motion to File an Out-
of-Time Motion to Intervene and a Verified Ancillary Petition (“Roe Mot.”); Petitioner Bitfinex’s
[386] [redacted] Opposition to Non-Party Richard Roe’s Motion (“Bitfinex Opp’n”); and Richard
Roe’s [349] Reply to Bitfinex’s Opposition (“Roe Reply”).' Non-Party Richard Roe (“Roe”) asserts
an interest in the property that is subject to forfeiture under the Second Preliminary Order of
Forfeiture, ECF No. 178, and consequently, he moves to file an out-of-time motion to intervene in
the ancillary proceeding in this case. Roe’s Motion is ripe for resolution by this Court. For the
reasons explained herein, Roe’s [344] Motion to File an Out-of-Time Motion to Intervene and a
Verified Ancillary Petition shall be DENIED.
Also pending before this Court and discussed herein are various Petitioners’ motions to
intervene, which shall be GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART, and one Petitioner’s
motion for leave to file an amended ancillary petition, which shall be GRANTED IN PART and
DENIED IN PART. Additionally pending before this Court are several motions to dismiss certain
Petitioners, but those motions will be addressed by means of a separate opinion.
' iFinex, Inc. and BFXNA Inc. together are referred to as “Bitfinex.”
1
I. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Because this case involves an ancillary forfeiture proceeding involving Bitfinex and fifteen
other Petitioners, some of whom are acting pro se, the Court includes a rather extensive procedural
background, which reiterates some information from previous opinions and order.
A. Restitution and Forfeiture
Defendants Ilya Lichtenstein (“Lichtenstein”) and Heather Morgan (“Morgan”)
(collectively, the “Defendants”) pleaded guilty to one count of Money Laundering Conspiracy
(Lichtenstein), and one count of Money Laundering Conspiracy and one count of Conspiracy to
Defraud the United States (Morgan). In their plea agreements, both Defendant acknowledged that
“the Court has an obligation to determine whether, and in what amount, mandatory restitution
applies in this case under 18 U.S.C. § 3663A at the time of sentencing.” Plea Agrmt., ECF No. 96
(Lichtenstein), at 9-10; ECF No. 101 (Morgan), at 10. Apart from that determination regarding
mandatory restitution, and because this case involved Defendants’ hack into Bitfinex’s system to
steal cryptocurrency, both Defendants agreed to “pay restitution to Bitfinex in an amount to be
determined at sentencing.” Jd.
Defendants Lichtenstein and Morgan were sentenced on November 14, 2024, and November
18, 2024, respectively, with their Judgments entered on December 3, 2024 [Lichtenstein, ECF No.
195], and December 11, 2024 [Morgan, ECF No. 198]. Attached to both Judgments is a Second
Amended Preliminary Order of Forfeiture, which indicates that “any property, real or personal,
involved in the offense alleged in Count One against Defendant Lichtenstein, and any property
traceable to such property” and “any property, real or personal, which constitutes or is derived from
proceeds traceable to a violation of the offense alleged in Count Two against Defendant Morgan” is
subject to forfeiture. See Second Am. Prelim. Orders of Forfeiture, ECF Nos. 195-1 & 198-1, at 1-
2; see also Corrected Second Am. Attachment A (listing the property, which is hereinafter referred
2
to as the “forfeiture assets” or “forfeited assets”).
1. The Government Provides Notice to Third Parties
Prior to sentencing (and any determination regarding restitution), the Government filed its
[141] Consent Motion for Order Authorizing Alternative Notification Procedures Out of an
Abundance of Caution, which provided a procedure for notifying persons who qualified as “victims”
pursuant to the Crime Victims’ Rights Act, 18 U.S.C. §3771, or for restitution pursuant to the
Mandatory Victim Restitution Act, 18 USC §3663A. The Government indicated its intent to
establish a website for notifying persons possibly affected by the Bitfinex hack, although the
Government proffered that it was their view that there were no “victims” under the CVRA, or for
purposes of restitution under the MVRA. Consent Mot., ECF No. 141, at 1 & n.1. Nevertheless,
the Government recognized that persons affected by the Bitfinex hack should have the opportunity
to raise claims about victim status and/or restitution prior to sentencing. Jd. at 1, 6, 9. On October
10, 2024, this Court entered its [145] Order Authorizing Alternative Notification Procedures.
On November 13, 2024, one day prior to Mr. Lichtenstein’s sentencing, the Government
filed its [171] Notice and Motion for Delayed Restitution Hearing, which moved to defer a final
determination of any victims’ losses and the accompanying restitution order by a period of 90 days.
Also on that day, the Government provided its [173] Notice Regarding Statements from Self-
Identified Persons Impacted by the Defendants’ Conduct. On the following day, the Government
provided its [175] Supplemental Notice Regarding Statements from Self-Identified Persons
Impacted by the Defendants’ Conduct. Both the Notice and the Supplemental Notice explain that:
Pursuant to the Court’s Order Authorizing Alternative Notification Procedures, ECF No. 145,
the government established a website with case-specific information and a process for
members of the public to submit statements regarding how they may have been impacted by
the defendants’ conduct. Individuals were instructed to provide statements by email by
November 12, 2024, and were advised that the information would be relayed to the Court.
The government received multiple submissions from individuals who claim to have been
impacted by the defendants’ conduct.
Govt. Notice, ECF No. 173, at 1; Govt. Supp. Notice, ECF No. 175, at 1.
On November 21, 2024, three days after Ms. Morgan’s sentencing, the parties filed their
[184] Consent Motion to schedule a restitution hearing for February 21, 2025, and they attached a
proposed scheduling order. On November 21, 2024, this Court granted the Consent Motion and set
a restitution hearing for February 21, 2025. See Order, ECF No. 185. That [185] Order further set
a January 28, 2025 deadline for third parties to file any motions to intervene/objections as well as
deadlines for supplemental briefing by the parties regarding restitution. After the Court issued its
[185] Order, multiple persons and entities (“third parties”) filed a multitude of motions and petitions.
These third parties requested the right to intervene, to assert victim status, and to have their property
returned.” Some of these motions were filed pro se and others with the assistance of counsel.
2. The Government Indicates its Position on Restitution and Forfeiture
On January 14, 2025, the Government filed its [202] Supplemental Motion: Regarding
Restitution, which reasserted its position that, under the MVRA, “there [was] no “victim” for the
specific offenses of conviction in this proceeding,” but acknowledged that the Court had the
authority to order “voluntary restitution [that] is appropriate and authorized under the defendants’
plea agreements,” regarding Bitfinex, and that such voluntary restitution should “include the residue
of the property that was stolen from Bitfinex in the 2016 hack[.]” Govt. Supp. Mot., ECF No. 202,
at 1. The Government asserted that because these stolen assets represented “specific property lost”
due to the hack, those assets could be paid to Bitfinex as restitution in kind. Jd. The Government
asserted further that “[a]ll other assets seized by the [G]overnment (which are listed in the Corrected
2 Some third parties requested permission to proceed anonymously and or under seal, and those
issues were addressed by the Court in its [278] Omnibus Memorandum Opinion and Order, granting
in part and denying in part six motions by third parties for leave to file pseudonymously and/or under
seal, permitting the parties to proceed via pseudonym and to seal personally identifying information,
but not including the total amount of assets being claimed by a third party.
4
Second Amended Attachment A (ECF No. 195)) should be subject to the ongoing third-party
ancillary forfeiture proceeding.” Jd. at 1-2; see 21 U.S.C. §853(n) (describing the procedure for
determining third-party claims against the assets that have been forfeited to the Government); Fed.
R. Crim. P. 32.2(c) (discussing ancillary proceedings). The Government anticipated that “one or
more parties may be able to assert valid claims in the third-party ancillary proceeding regardless of
whether they would be considered “victims” entitled to restitution under the MVRA.” Govt. Supp.
Mot., ECF No. 202, at 5.
3. The Court Requests Additional Briefing because of Issues Raised by Third Parties
Because the third parties raised issues relating to the propriety of awarding voluntary
restitution to Bitfinex of the property stolen during the 2016 hack — which they claimed as their own
property — the Court requested additional briefing by the Government as to “the appropriate
disposition of assets subject to forfeiture and the transfer to Bitfinex as voluntary restitution.” See
January 28, 2025 Order (setting a February 4, 2025 response date). In the Government’s [229]
Response, it noted that “if the Court is concerned about removing specific properties from the third-
party ancillary proceeding, it could order $0 restitution and adjudicate the disposal of the seized
properties solely through the third-party ancillary proceeding.” Govt. Resp., ECF No. 220, at 4n.1.
The Government noted further that “[t]he Court is required to order restitution agreed to by the parties
in a plea agreement (as is the case here), 18 U.S.C. § 3663A(a)(3), but where the plea agreement is
silent as to the form or amount of restitution, the Court retains the discretion to fashion an appropriate
restitution order[.]” Govt. Resp., ECF No. 220, at 4 n.1 (citing United States v. Peterson, 268 F.3d
533, 535 (7th Cir. 2001)).
Subsequently, this Court issued its [247] Memorandum Opinion and Order explaining the
posture of the case and requesting additional briefing from the Government on three issues that related
to third-party concerns regarding mandatory restitution, voluntary restitution, and the way in which
5
restitution claims might affect the ancillary forfeiture proceeding. In that Opinion and Order, the
Court indicated that:
Specifically, regarding the MVRA, some [third parties] argue that because the underlying
offense of conviction is a conspiracy, courts may look at the defendant’s criminal conduct
during that conspiracy as a basis for restitution. Additionally, some [third parties] contest that
in-kind restitution should be awarded to Bitfinex, on grounds that the [third parties] are the
owners of the property that was hacked and furthermore — contrary to representations by
Bitfinex — they have not been adequately compensated (made whole) regarding the property
that was stolen because of the hack.
Mem. Op. and Order, ECF No. 247, at 5. In conjunction with the request for additional information
from the Government, this Court vacated the restitution hearing that was scheduled for February 21,
2025, to allow time for the Government’s briefing. See February 11, 2025 Minute Order.
4, The Court Modifies Slightly the Ultimate Deadline for Filing of Ancillary Petitions
On February 14, 2025, this Court issued its [250] Order, which summarized in brief the
procedural posture of the case and noted the prior deadlines that it had set for third-party motions
and objections. The Court noted further that it had not similarly indicated on the docket any deadline
for ancillary petitions, and as such (and because some petitions were originating from overseas), the
Court indicated a final deadline of February 19, 2025, for the receipt of any ancillary petitions by
third parties who had not previously filed anything with the Court. That February 19, 2025 deadline
altered by a few days the February 15, 2025 deadline established by the Government in its Notice
of Forfeiture, ECF No. 361-1, at 7.°
5. The Government Revises its Position on Restitution and Forfeiture
On February 23, 2025, the Government filed its [262] Response to the Court’s request for
additional information on three issues related to arguments raised by various third parties (who are
also referenced herein as “Petitioners”). The Government noted that “[1]n light of the complex issues
3 The Court notes that February 15, 2025 was a Saturday, and furthermore, Monday, February 17,
2025 was a federal holiday.
6
of fact and law raised by the parties and third-party petitioners regarding restitution, and in
consideration of the Court’s orders and opinions,” the Government “now recommends that the Court
order $0 restitution and adjudicate the disposal of the seized properties solely through the third-party
forfeiture ancillary proceeding.” Govt. Resp., ECF No. 262, at 1-2. The Government asserted that:
Such an outcome would be consistent with the government’s analysis of the MVRA—that no
party is a “victim” of the defendants’ money laundering offenses under the technical legal
definition of that term in the MVRA, 18 U.S.C. §3663A(a)(2)—as well as the MVRA’s carve-
out for excessively complex restitution issues, 18 U.S.C. § 3663A(c)(3)(B) (“This section
shall not apply” where “determining complex issues of fact related to the cause or amount of
the victim’s losses would complicate or prolong the sentencing process to a degree that the
need to provide restitution to any victim is outweighed by the burden on the sentencing
process.”)
Govt. Resp., ECF No. 262, at 2.
5. The Court Awards $0 in Restitution to Bitfinex and Indicates it will Proceed with a Third-
party Ancillary Forfeiture Proceeding.
On April 4, 2025, the Court issued its [300] Memorandum Opinion addressing Defendants’
restitution obligations and discussing the ancillary proceeding, “which will be held for the purpose
of determining claims of entitlement to the forfeited property by Bitfinex and Petitioners/Third-Party
Claimants.” Mem. Op., ECF No. 300, at 1. The Government proffered that there were more than
a dozen third-party petitioners with competing claims, ranging from individual pro se third parties
to major accountholders, and that discovery in support of their claims might be requested. /d. at 18-
19. Furthermore, the Government indicated that it was “unable to independently verify or fully
validate the third-party petitioners’ alleged ownership interests” nor did it know whether these third
parties were Bitfinex accountholders at the time of the hack, their account balances, or the service
arrangements between them and Bitfinex. /d. at 19.
The Court noted that these issues (highlighted by the Government) would have to be addressed
in connection with the ancillary proceeding. Moreover, the Court indicated also that “the tracing of
the accounts in a cryptocurrency case involving hacking is in and itself complex.” Jd. (noting that
7
the Court would have to determine superior interests in the forfeited assets that were being claimed
by both the third parties and Bitfinex). The Court “agree[d] with Government’s characterization of
this litigation as potentially ‘complex, prolonged, and burdensome.”” Jd. at 18-19. Accordingly,
the Court concluded that:
[B]ecause of the complex issues of fact and law raised by the parties, Petitioners, and Bitfinex
regarding restitution, $0 restitution shall be awarded to Bitfinex; the Court will not hold a
restitution hearing; and adjudication of the disposal of the forfeited assets shall proceed solely
through a third-party forfeiture ancillary proceeding.
Mem. Op., ECF No. 300, at 2; see also Order, ECF No. 299.
B. Ancillary Proceeding and Petitioners with Ancillary Claims
The Court’s [300] Memorandum Opinion set forth the claims to forfeited assets by Bitfinex,
id. at 18, and it recognized sixteen Petitioners with timely claims and indicated their claimed losses.
See id. at 18 n.11 (listing (1) A.B. (1896.43 ETH and 1876.6 ETC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No.
282]; (2) AH-1 (391.98 BTC, 3156.14 ETH, $48, 324.34 USD) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 288];
(3) Pablo Garcia Illescas (188.9583353 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 253]; (4) Jonas Paasch
(94.9 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 263]; (5) Hjalmar Peters (12.94485805 BTC) [Ancillary
Petition, ECF No. 376]; (6) Allan Newman (8.76586537 BTC, 22.113265451 LTC) [Ancillary
Petition, ECF No. 203]; (7) Dolan Harrington (2.35436113 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 366];
(8) Christian Dressler (0.90305977 BTC, 91.1871525 ETH) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 365]; (9)
Juergen Lankat (4.78591312 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 248]; (10) Charles Reed Venturella
(13.03662881 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 266-1]*; (11) Company Doe and director/sole
shareholder Tom Doe (57.84809770 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 283]; (12) Francisco
Cavazos (14.994 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 252]; (13) Louis Zuijderwijk (3.2743 BTC)
[Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 215]; (14) XYZ Inc. (2,770.48034004 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF
4 As noted later herein, Mr. Venturella’s Ancillary Petition shall be docketed by counsel as a separate
document as opposed to an attachment to a motion to intervene.
8
No. 289-4]; (15) Rafal Bielenia (33.06537432 BTC) [Ancillary Petition (erroneously styled as a
motion to intervene), ECF No. 254]®; and (16) John Doe (670.68637 BTC) [Ancillary Petition, ECF
No. 285]).
II. PENDING MOTIONS
Prior to addressing Roe’s motion to file out-of-time, which is the central motion underlying
this Memorandum Opinion, the Court detours briefly, in part to update the pro se Petitioners as to
some recent docket activity, and in part to address one Petitioner’s motion for amendment of his
ancillary petition and several Petitioners’ motions to intervene.
A. Dismissal of One Claim, Amendment of Three, and a Pending Request to Amend
After the Court’s issuance of its [300] Memorandum Opinion determining that the disposal of
forfeited assets would proceed solely through an ancillary forfeiture proceeding involving Bitfinex
and the sixteen Petitioners, on February 17, 2025, Petitioner AH-1 filed his [373] Notice of
Voluntary Dismissal with Prejudice of his petition and request for ancillary relief. Accordingly,
AH-1 (and AH-1’s counsel) are no longer a part of the ancillary proceeding, and the Clerk’s Office
shall be instructed to amend the docket to reflect that dismissal.
Furthermore, the Court notes that three Petitioners have amended their previously-timely
ancillary petitions regarding the amounts of cryptocurrency being claimed, as follows: (1) Hjalmar
Peters (17.5071 BTC) [Amended Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 376]; (2) Dolan Harrington
(6.52774318 BTC) [Amended Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 377]; (3) Louis Zuijderwijk (9.07868043
BTC) [Amended Ancillary Petition, ECF No. 345].
Finally, pending before this Court is a Motion to Amend Petition by Petitioner Jonas Paasch,
filed at ECF No. 360. Unlike the motions by Petitioners Peters, Harrington, and Zuijderwijk,
> XYZ Inc.’s Petition shall also be docketed separately as opposed to an attachment to another
motion.
6 Petitioner Bielenia filed a separate motion to intervene, which is docketed at ECF No. 255.
9
Petitioner Paasch’s motion does not seek to amend the amount of cryptocurrency he claims, but
instead he seeks to “correct terminological inaccuracies” and “add newly discovered, public tracing
detail into Exhibit A” and “shorten [his] petition.” Mot. to Amend, ECF No. 360, at 1. The Court
notes that there have been several prior iterations of this Petitioner’s petition (which were submitted
to the Court/Clerk’s Office as corrected versions), and as such, Petitioner Jonas Paasch’s [360]
Motion to Amend shall be GRANTED IN PART, to permit an addition to the tracing detail, but
otherwise DENIED IN PART, as unnecessary.’
B. Intervention Requests by Petitioners
The Court notes that there are several outstanding motions on the docket that request
intervention, namely:
e Motion to Intervene and Assert Victim Status, ECF No. 190 (Cavazos), ECF No. 207
(Zuijderwijk)
e Motion to Intervene and Request for Leave to Appear as an Interested Party under the
CVRA and MVRA, ECF No. 229 (Bitfinex)
e Motion to Intervene, ECF No. 230 (Dressler, Lankat, Peters, Newman, Harrington),
ECF Nos. 238 & 255 (Bielenia), ECF No. 266 (Venturella), ECF No. 268 (Tom Doe
and Company Doe)
e Motion to Intervene and for an Order of Restitution, ECF Nos. 241 & 286 (John Doe)
The Court notes that these motions were filed prior to the Court’s determination that — because
of the complex issues of fact and law — no award of $0 restitution was applicable and furthermore,
that claims to the forfeited assets would be addressed by means of an ancillary forfeiture proceeding.
As such, this Court made no determination that Bitfinex or any of the Petitioners were “victims”
pursuant to the CVRA and MVRA. This Court reiterates its acknowledgment that these Petitioners
7 The Court references its March 7, 2025 Minute Order which notes that “the endless filing of
documents, supplementation thereof (in large part, duplicative) and substitution of previous filings (to
correct errors) is straining the resources of the Clerk’s Office and this Court” and the “constant stream
of filings in this case only serves to delay” this proceeding.
IC
who requested intervention (as well as A.B., Pablo Garcia Illescas, and Jonas Paasch — who did not
file independent motions to intervene, and XYZ Inc. — which filed a motion to intervene as an
attachment to another motion, see ECF No. 289-1) are recognized by this Court as Petitioners with
timely ancillary claims. See 21 U.S.C. § 853(n) (discussing third-party interests). Pursuant to 21
U.S.C. § 853(k), “[e]xcept as provided in subsection (n), no party claiming an interest in property
subject to forfeiture under this section” may intervene in a trial or appeal of a criminal case involving
the forfeiture of that property or bring an action against the United States relating to validity of the
party’s alleged interest...” Accordingly, all motions to intervene (ECF Nos. 190, 207, 229, 230,
238, 241, 255, 266, 268, 286, 289-1) are GRANTED IN PART as they pertain to the Petitioners
“intervening” for purposes of the ancillary forfeiture proceeding and DENIED WITHOUT
PREDJUDICE otherwise.’ As noted previously, for purposes of docket management, Petitioner
Venturella’s [266-1] Ancillary Petition shall be docketed by his counsel as a separate document as
opposed to an attachment to his motion to intervene. Similarly, Petitioner XYZ Inc.’s [289-4]
Ancillary Petition [public version] shall also be docketed by its counsel as a separate document as
opposed to an attachment to another motion.
The Court turns now to the primary motion underlying this Memorandum Opinion — a motion
to file an out-of-time motion to intervene and ancillary petition by Richard Roe.
C. Non-Party Roe’s Motion to File an Out-of-Time Motion to Intervene and Ancillary Petition
In this case, Non-Party Richard Roe (“Roe”) requests this Court’s permission for leave to file
a motion to intervene and an ancillary petition, which is opposed by Petitioner Bitfinex. Roe argues
that he has an “interest in the property that is subject to forfeiture” and that disposition of this case
may “impair his ability to protect those interests.” Roe Mot., ECF No. 344, at 1. Furthermore, Roe
8 At this point in the ancillary proceeding, the Court denies in part such motions because at least some
of these motions are not strictly limited to a request for intervention but instead request victim status
or refer to restitution, issues that were previously considered by the Court.
1]
asserts that he “meets the standard for ‘excusable neglect’ under Rule 6(b)(1)(B),” because he has
an extremely busy work schedule and he did not receive personal notification of the forfeiture, id.
at 1, 3-5. Moreover, he asserts there is no prejudice to any party and that his delay is minimal. Jd.
at 6-6.
Petitioner Bitfinex asserts that Rule 6(b) does not extend the mandatory statutory deadline set
forth in Section 853(n)(2), nor does Roe demonstrate excusable neglect, pursuant to Rule 6(b), or
seek equitable tolling.” The Court now proceeds with its discussion of the merits of Roe’s motion,
beginning with Roe’s contention that direct notice is required and was not provided.!°
1. Roe Contends that He was Entitled To but Did Not Receive Direct Notice
Roe proffers that his ancillary petition is “timely under Section 853(n)” because the “time
period set by that statute does not begin to run unless and until the petitioner receives direct notice
as required by Rule 32.2 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure.” Roe Reply, ECF No. 349, at
6 (emphasis added); see Roe Affidavit, ECF No. 433-2 912 (indicating that he did not receive direct
notice from the U.S. Government or Bitfinex of his right to file an ancillary petition). Bitfinex
asserts however, and this Court agrees, that the Government provided notice that met or exceeded
statutory requirements. The Court turns now to notification requirements and a review of the notice
that was provided to third parties in this case.
a. Notification Required
Rule 32.2 states that: “[i]f the court orders the forfeiture of specific property, the government
must publish notice of the order and send notice to any person who reasonably appears to be a
® Roe does not raise the issue of equitable tolling in his Motion, and accordingly, the Court need not
address it herein.
10 Roe “challenges” Bitfinex’s standing to oppose Roe’s Motion, but such “challenge” is based on the
contingency that this Court will grant Petitioner XYZ’s motion to dismiss Bitfinex’s ancillary
petition. The Court notes that such “challenge” is without merit as it is based on a speculative future
ruling.
12
potential claimant with standing to contest the forfeiture in the ancillary proceeding.” Rule
32.2(b)(6)(A) (Publishing and Sending Notice).'' This issue of notification is explained further in
21 U.S.C. § 853(n), which states that:
(1) Following the entry of an order of forfeiture under this section, the United States shall
publish notice of the order and of its intent to dispose of the property in such manner as the
Attorney General may direct. The Government may also, to the extent practicable, provide
direct written notice to any person known to have alleged an interest in the property that is the
subject of the order of forfeiture as a substitute for the published notice as to those persons so
notified.
(2) Any person, other than the defendant, asserting a legal interest in property which has been
ordered forfeited to the United States pursuant to this section may, within thirty days of the
final publication of notice or his receipt of notice under paragraph (1), whichever is earlier,
petition the court for a hearing to adjudicate the validity of his alleged interest in the property.
The hearing shall be held before the court alone, without a jury.
21 U.S.C. §853(n)(1) & (2) (emphasis added).
b. Publication of Notice of Foreclosure
In this case, the Declaration of Publication, ECF No. 361-1, notes that the Notice of
Foreclosure was “posted on an official government internet site . . . for at least 30 consecutive days,
beginning on December 17, 2024 and ending on January 15, 2025.” The Notice of Foreclosure
states that:
The United States hereby gives notice of its intent to dispose of the forfeited property in such
manner as the United States Attorney General may direct. Any person, other than the
defendant(s) in this case, claiming an interest in the forfeited property much file an ancillary
petition within 60 days of the first date of publication (December 17, 2024) of this Notice on
this office government internet site, pursuant to Rule 32.2 of the Federal Rules of Criminal
Procedure and 21 U.S.C. § 853(n)(1). The ancillary petition must be filed with the Clerk of
the Court, 333 Constitution Ave., NW, Washington, DC 20001, and a copy served upon
Assistant United States Attorney Rick Blaylock, 601 D. Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20530.
The ancillary petition shall be signed by the petitioner under penalty of perjury and shall set
forth the nature and extent of the petitioner’s right, title or interest in the forfeited property,
the time and circumstances of the petitioner’s acquisition of the right, title and interest in the
forfeited property and any additional facts supporting the petitioner’s claim and the relief
sought, pursuant to 21 U.S.C. § 853(n).
'! Subsection (B) addresses the “Content of the Notice” while subsection (C) addresses the “Means of
Publication; Exceptions to Publication Requirement.” Rule 32.2 (b)(6)(B) & (C).
13
Notice of Forfeiture, ECF No. 361-1, at 7. The Government “sen[t] notice to any person who
reasonably appear[ed] to be a potential claimant with standing to contest the forfeiture in the
ancillary proceeding.” Govt’s Supp. Mot. Regarding Restitution, ECF No. 202, at 5 (referencing
Fed. R. Crim. P. 32.2(b)(6)(A)). The Court finds that the public notification provided by the
Government complied with statutory requirements.
c. Other Prior Notifications
The Court notes further that, prior to the publication of that Notice of Foreclosure, there were
numerous other “notifications” provided to the public, including three Government press releases
disclosing that there would be a forfeiture proceeding. Bitfinex explains that there was media coverage
of this case for years and “[m]Jany of these articles specifically mentioned ‘a court process by which
victims can reclaim the stolen assets and the need for shareholders to file claims.” Bitfinex Opp’n, ECF
No. 386, at 10-11 & n.2 (referencing news sources). See also Declaration by Christopher Martin, '*
ECF No. 386-1, at 1-4 (identifying information the Government made available on the internet about
the Department of Justice’s (“DOJ’s”) prosecution in connection with the Bitfinex hack). Mr. Martin
discusses, inter alia, the following exhibits attached to his Declaration:
e Ex. A [August 3, 2023 DOJ press release] (announcing Defendants’ guilty pleas and
providing notification — “Consistent with standard practice in criminal forfeiture cases, there
will be a formal process at the conclusion of the case pursuant to Rule 32.2 of the Federal
Rules of Criminal Procedure for third-party claimants to submit claims for any seized and
forfeited property)
e Ex. B [second August 3, 2023 DOJ press release, updated on February 6, 2025] (reiterating
the information in Ex. A)
e Ex. C [August 3, 2023 Internal Revenue Service press release, updated on April 7, 2025]
(reiterating the information in Exs. A and B)
d. Notification related to the Restitution Determination
'2 Mr. Martin is the Associate Managing Director in the New York office of Nardello & Co., LLC, a
global investigations firm.
14
Furthermore, during the “restitution” stage of this case, the Government indicated that “there
[were] potentially thousands of {Bitfinex] accountholders whose accounts lost value in 2016 as a
result of this hack [and] [t]he [G]overnment has attempted to locate those victims, including by
requesting a list of all accountholders from [Bitfinex], but such efforts have been unsuccessful.”
Consent Mot. for Order Authorizing Alternative Notification Procedures Out of an Abundance of
Caution, ECF No. 141, at 6-7. Accordingly, the Government’s Consent Motion requested
authorization of alternative notification procedures to notify persons potentially harmed by the
offenses to which the Defendants pled guilty, because “the government d[id] not know the identity
or contact information for all [Bitfinex] accountholders.” Id. at 7-8.
That Motion was granted by this Court on October 10, 2024, Order, ECF No. 145, at 1, and
that Court-approved notification process included establishing a case-specific website and posting a
link on the DOJ’s website for large cases. See Consent Motion, ECF No. 141, at 8; see also Martin
Decl., Exs. D & E:
e Ex. D [webpage titled “2016 Bitfinex Hack” published on October 17, 2024 on the website
for the United States Attorneys’ Office for the District of Columbia] (summarizing the case,
and including a section titled “Notice to Person Impacted by the Defendants’ Conduct —
Soliciting Impact Statements” with a webpage to contact the Government and a link to the
Court’s October 10, 2024 Order Authorizing Alternative Notification Procedures) (last
updated on October 29, 2024)
e Ex. E [webpage titled “United States v. Ilya Lichtenstein and Heather Morgan” published on
October 31, 2024 on a part of the DOJ’s website containing “Information for Victims in
Large Cases” and a link to the webpage referenced in Ex. D]
Moreover, on November 7, 2024, the U.S. Attorneys’ Office for the District of Columbia
issued a press release titled “Website Related to Multi-Billion Dollar Bitfinex Hack Established”
containing links to the webpage titled “2016 Bitfinex Hack” and the Court’s October 10, 2024 Order.
See Martin Decl., Ex. F That press release announced the establishment of the case-specific website
and solicited information from anyone who had potentially been harmed by the Bitfinex Hack,
including accountholders:
1s
Notice to the public to solicit and receive information from all persons potentially
harmed by the Bitfinex Hack, including affected Bitfinex accountholders
The Department of Justice has established a website to provide any person who claims status
as a potential crime victim of the crimes described below to assert any rights under the Crime
Victims’ Act (CVRA), 18 U.S.C. § 3771, and with the opportunity to complete a statement to
relay information about how they may have been harmed by the charged conduct and/or
offenses.
* * *
If you wish to complete a statement about the impact of the offenses on you and/or to relay
information about how you may have been victimized, please send that statement to the United
States to be conveyed to the U.S. District Court judge who will make decisions in the case,
including by sentencing the defendants. Specifically, please submit a statement by no later
than November 13, 2024, via email to USADC.BitfinexHack2016@usdoj.gov. As stated
above, the sentencings are currently scheduled for November 14 and 15, 2024.
Additional information is available on the Department of Justice’s website for large cases,
[link provided].
Martin Decl., Ex. F.
On November 14, 2024, the day that Defendant Lichtenstein was sentenced, the Government
issued another press release, which reiterated that “there will be a formal process pursuant to Rule
32.2 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure for third-party claimants to submit claims for any
seized and forfeited property.” Martin Decl., Ex. G.
Finally, on December 17, 2024, the Government published its Notice of Forfeiture (discussed
in subsection 2a.), As previously noted herein, the deadline for persons to file their petitions was
Saturday, February 15, 2025, with a United States’ holiday on the next business day — Monday,
February 17, 2025 — and accordingly, the Court extended the deadline by two days, to February 19,
2025. Bitfinex and sixteen others filed timely petitions while Roe’s Petition was not timely filed.
Considering the issue of notification in this case, the Court finds that the Government’s
publication of the Notice of Forfeiture was sufficient notice pursuant to the statute, and here, not
only did the Government comply with its publication requirements, but there was additional public
notification leading up to the December 17, 2024 posting off the Notice of Forfeiture. Furthermore,
1€
direct notice to all affected parties is not statutorily required, nor was it feasible here.'? Accordingly,
Roe’s contention — that the time in Section 853(n) has not started to run because direct notice was
required — is without merit. Having found that: (1) it was not practicable for the Government to
provide direct notice; (2) the notice given by the Government was sufficient pursuant to the statute;
and (3) the response period set forth in the Government’s Notice [and slightly modified by this
Court] concluded before Roe filed his instant Motion, the Court turns now to the parties’ arguments
about “excusable neglect.”
2. Excusable Neglect Standard
Roe contends that “excusable neglect” is the standard applicable to the Court’s analysis of
Roe’s request to file his ancillary petition out of time. Roe Mot., ECF No. 344, at 3 (referencing
Fed. R. Civ. P. 6(b)). Bitfinex argues however that “Rule 6(b) cannot extend deadlines set by
statute” such as the mandatory statutory deadline set pursuant to 21 U.S.C. § 853(n)(2). Bitfinex
Opp’n, ECF No. 386, at 16.
a. Applicability of this Standard
Bitfinex notes that “[a]s the D.C. Circuit held in Sherrod v. Breitbart, binding precedent,
‘(motions under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 6(b) cannot extend statutory time limits.”
Bitfinex Mot., ECF No. 386, at 16 (citing Sherrod, 720 F.3d 932, 938 (D.C. Cir. 2013)). In Argentine
Republic v. Nat’l Grid Plc., the D.C. Circuit made clear that “[e]very court to have considered this
question has held that Rule 6(b) may be used only to extend the time limits imposed by the court
itself or by other Federal Rules, but not by statute.” 637 F.3d 365, 368 (D.C. Cir. 2011). Roe
contends however that he “does not seek to extend statutory deadlines . . . but instead is seeking
'3 Bitfinex explains that “[i]t appears that individuals who contacted the government [in response to
an earlier notification relating to person affected by the Defendants’ Hack] received direct notice of
the forfeiture action.” Bitfinex Opp’n, ECF No. 386, at 10 & n.9 (referencing statements from certain
Petitioners’ ancillary petitions indicating that they received notice on December 17, 2024).
17
relief from the Court’s so-ordered deadline of February 19, 2025.” Roe’s Reply, ECF No. 349, at
14-15 (additionally noting that neither the Sherrod case nor the Argentine Republic case involves
the criminal forfeiture context).!4 Because this case involves a deadline that was slightly modified
by the Court — and in the interest of judicial efficiency, since Roe has indicated his intention to
challenge any final order of forfeiture — this Court will consider Roe’s Rule 6(b) excusable neglect
argument. The Court notes that Bitfinex has fully briefed its opposition to this argument.
b. Excusable Neglect - Four Factors to Consider
Four factors guide the Court’s determination of when a late filing may constitute “excusable
neglect” as follows: (1) the danger of prejudice to the opposing party, (2) the length of delay and
potential impact on the judicial proceedings, (3) the reason for the delay, including whether it was
within the reasonable control of the movant, and (4) whether the movant acted in good faith. See In
re Vitamins Antitrust Class Action, 327 F.3d 1207, 1209 (D.C. Cir. 2003) (citing Pioneer Inv. Servs.
Co. v. Brunswick Assocs. Ltd. P’ship, 507 U.S. 380, 395 (1993)). This determination as to whether
neglect is excusable “is at bottom an equitable one, taking account of all relevant circumstances
surrounding the party’s omission.” Pioneer, 507 U.S. at 395.
“*Excusable neglect is not easily demonstrated, nor was it intended to be.”” Jn re Smith, Case
No. 11-00481, 2013 WL 3156639, at *4 (Bankr. D.D.C. June 21, 2013) (analyzing “excusable
neglect” under Rule 60(b)) (quoting Thompson v. E.I. DuPont de Nemours & Co., 76 F. 3d 530, 534
(4th Cir.