People v. Coykendall CA5
CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
DocketF088093
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Filed 11/19/26 P. v. Coykendall CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
THE PEOPLE,
F088093
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. BF189267A)
v.
BRIAN MATTHEW COYKENDALL,
OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Kern County. Kenneth C.
Twisselman II, Judge.
William G. Holzer, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief Assistant Attorney
General, Kimberley A. Donohue, Assistant Attorney General, Ivan P. Marrs and Eric L.
Christoffersen, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
Defendant Brian Matthew Coykendall (defendant) was convicted of involuntary
manslaughter in connection with the death of his girlfriend’s ex-boyfriend. He argues
there was insufficient evidence to support the conviction, and that the trial court gave an
erroneous jury instruction on involuntary manslaughter. We reject both claims and
affirm the judgment.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
On November 4, 2022, the Kern County District Attorney filed an amended
information charging defendant and Erwin Moore, Jr. with deliberate and premeditated
murder (count 1; Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a).) 1 The information alleged defendant
committed the murder by means listed in section 189 and that he personally and
intentionally discharged a firearm (§ 12022.53, subd. (d).) The information alleged
against defendant aggravating circumstances under California Rules of Court,
rule 4.421(a)(1)–(4), (a)(8), and (b)(1).
The information also charged Moore with evading a police officer in a vehicle
(count 2; Veh. Code, § 2800.2).
On April 23, 2024, a jury acquitted defendant of murder and the lesser included
offenses of second degree murder and voluntary manslaughter and found the firearm
enhancement and section 189 circumstance not true but convicted defendant of
involuntary manslaughter. Codefendant Moore was acquitted of all charges.
The trial court suspended imposition of sentence on the involuntary manslaughter
conviction, and placed defendant on two years of probation. One term of probation was
to serve one year in the county jail, but he was given credit for time served.
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code unless otherwise
indicated.
2.
FACTS
In 2018, Matthew Petersen bought a house on South Porter Street in Ridgecrest.
Later that year, defendant moved in with Petersen. The two were coworkers. Defendant
stayed at Petersen’s home during the week for work and left on weekends. Eventually,
defendant stopped leaving on weekends.
On October 31, 2019, Jessica and Hannah moved into Petersen’s home on South
Porter. Jessica was uncertain how long she and Petersen had dated prior to her moving in
but estimated that it was a matter of “months.” Over the next two years that they were
together, Jessica indicated that they had issues because Petersen had a drinking problem
and was physically violent with Jessica.
On November 19, 2019, Petersen drove a vehicle with Jessica and Hannah as
passengers while he was intoxicated and crashed. Hannah had a concussion, ribcage
contusions, and costochondritis. Jessica’s spine eventually herniated. Petersen was
convicted of driving under the influence (DUI) and child endangerment.
After the crash, Petersen became more violent with Jessica. Petersen slammed her
head into a wall, pinched her, poked her, pushed and pulled her, and threw things at her.
Police were called out for two incidents. In one incident, Petersen punched Jessica in the
eye. Jessica declined to file a restraining order, so law enforcement said they would file
one. In the other incident, Petersen grabbed Hannah by her shoulder and then ran toward
Jessica with a broken glass bottle. While the violence never occurred in defendant’s
presence, Jessica confided in defendant about some of the incidents while they were
friends and defendant would give her advice. Eventually, Petersen was arrested and
convicted of domestic violence against Jessica. At various times, in 2020 and while
3.
Petersen was in custody, protective orders were in place, and Petersen was ordered not to
have contact with Jessica and/or Hannah. 2
Around Thanksgiving 2020, Petersen came to work intoxicated and was fired.
Jessica ended her relationship with Petersen after he pulled out an AR-15 “on
[her,]” loaded it, and pulled the trigger. Defendant later told Jessica he had removed the
firing pin prior to the incident, fearing that Petersen would injure someone in the house
after learning of another occasion where Petersen loaded and pointed the AR-15 at
Jessica. A few months later, on December 8, 2020, Petersen went to prison after a
probation search yielded evidence he was in illegal possession of firearms.
Jessica and defendant quickly became affectionate with each other. Defendant’s
wife filed for divorce and moved to Kentucky with their three children. Defendant
resigned from his job and planned to move to Tennessee to be closer to his children.
Jessica and defendant began dating and lived together in the house on South Porter while
Petersen was in prison. Once they were in a dating relationship, Jessica told defendant
more about the violent “incidents” between Petersen and her.
Jessica observed signs that defendant had posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
However, defendant was respectful to her and not abusive.
Defendant knew Hannah was terrified of Petersen. Defendant told Hannah that if
Petersen ever became aggressive with her, he would “make sure” Hannah was not hurt.
When Jessica told defendant she feared Petersen returning home, defendant said he
would “make sure” they were not hurt. Defendant told a coworker that he might “have it
out” with Petersen—meaning have some kind of altercation with him.
2 Based on the trial testimony, it appears a restraining order protecting both Jessica
and Hannah was terminated as to Jessica only on March 21, 2021. According to the
testimony of Officer Matthew Rowland, Hannah remained a protected party on the date
of March 4, 2022.
4.
Shortly after he was arrested, Petersen told Jessica he no longer wanted to live in
California. Petersen said he would come to the house after his release to get his things
and move to Oregon. However, thereafter, Petersen’s father and brother came and
gathered Petersen’s belongings.
While Petersen was still in prison, he discussed selling the house to Jessica via a
short sale. At other times, he said he would sell it to someone else. Eventually, Petersen
was transferred to a halfway house.
Petersen accused Jessica of posting nude photographs of herself on social media.
Petersen was also upset by a social media photograph of Jessica and defendant, which
portrayed them as being in a relationship. Petersen told Jessica he had hoped they would
get back together and she responded that would not happen.
Late on the night of January 19, 2022, defendant knocked on the door of his
neighbor, C.B. Defendant asked C.B. if any of his cameras had voice recording. When
C.B. gestured toward his doorbell camera, defendant asked to speak in a different
location. After they moved some distance away, defendant said Petersen was getting out
of jail and asked C.B. if he could turn off his cameras “for plausible deniability.” C.B.
agreed to appease defendant.
On February 2, 2022, Petersen moved to a sober living home. Petersen eventually
sought and obtained a pass to temporarily leave the sober living home to “close out his
house.”
Events of March 4, 2022
Petersen told his friend John S. he was allowed to leave his halfway house and
asked for a ride. John S. picked up Petersen at around 10:00 or 10:30 a.m. from the
halfway house on March 4, 2022.
John S. believed Petersen thought he was still in a relationship with Jessica.
However, Petersen said Jessica had “ghosted” him and would not talk to him. Petersen’s
plan was to find a job and live in his house on South Porter if his relationship with Jessica
5.
was still “solid.” If their relationship was not “solid,” then Petersen planned to sell the
house and move to Oregon.
John S. dropped Petersen off at his house sometime between 1:30 and 2:00 p.m.
John S. asked Petersen if he should come in but Petersen said he did not need John S. to
be there.
C.B.’s girlfriend overheard defendant “joke[]” that Petersen would “get what he
deserved” when he came home. Jessica laughed.
Defendant and Hannah returned home from a movie that afternoon to find
Petersen outside. Hannah was surprised, but Petersen said her mother knew he was going
to be there. Hannah called Jessica at around 3:00 p.m. Jessica denied knowing Petersen
would be at the house. Jessica asked defendant to pick her up, but he declined to do so.
At 3:31 p.m., defendant called codefendant Moore, and the call lasted 27 seconds.
One minute later, defendant texted Moore the address of Petersen’s house. One minute
after that, defendant sent a text message to C.B., saying, “ ‘Could you do me that favor I
asked you for now, please.’ ” C.B. did not turn off his camera, but when he saw
defendant outside later, he gave defendant a thumbs up. At 3:33 p.m., Moore’s phone
texted defendant’s phone, “150 miles.”
Hannah picked up Jessica from work at 5:00 p.m. and drove her to the house.
When Jessica arrived at the house, Petersen and defendant were sitting in the living room,
using their phones. Jessica said she did not have an issue with Petersen staying there as
long as he was sober, but also said she did not really want him there because she has
“ ‘PTSD.’ ”
Jessica and Petersen spoke in the front yard. Petersen said he knew she and
defendant were “together,” and that he was thinking of short selling the house to them but
would talk about it later. Petersen then said he wanted to talk about “ ‘us.’ ” Jessica said
there was no “us,” and Petersen was upset. Jessica said she did not want to discuss that
6.
tonight, and Petersen raised his voice. However, all of Jessica’s interactions with
Petersen were ultimately civil and cordial.
Petersen told Jessica he could not transfer his probation to Oregon as originally
planned and asked if he could stay at the house for a week. Petersen said he was okay
sleeping on the couch and was not there to cause problems. Jessica said it would make
her uncomfortable, but “that he technically owned the home.”
Petersen and Jessica watched a movie in the living room. Hannah went to her
room and eventually called Jessica to come lay with her. They watched a movie together
and eventually fell asleep. The next thing Jessica remembered was Hannah telling her
she thought someone was knocking. Jessica went to the kitchen, got water, and walked
down the hallway to the restroom when she saw flashing “police lights.”
Hannah observed that defendant spent most of his time in his room and seemed
quieter than normal.
Moore’s Phone
Moore’s phone remained in the area of Camp Pendleton near Oceanside until at
least 12:26 p.m. on March 4, 2022. The phone then began moving in a northeasterly
direction, and was in the area of Temecula by 1:06 p.m. The phone stayed in Temecula
until about 5:47 p.m., when it began traveling north. At 7:41 p.m., defendant’s phone
texted Moore’s phone: “ ‘You okay? I know traffic is probably horrendous.’ ” “ ‘Just
checking on you.’ ” Moore’s phone continued to move north until it arrived at the area
of Petersen’s home at about 8:36 p.m. The phone remained in that area from 8:36 to
8:45 p.m.
C.B.’s Observations on March 4, 2022
C.B. heard a scuffle outside and saw a dim light hit the ground. C.B. went inside,
told his girlfriend to call 911, and retrieved his firearm. As he opened the door preparing
to head out, he heard Petersen screaming for help and then a gunshot. C.B. knew it was
7.
Petersen screaming for help because he had a distinctive voice. C.B.’s girlfriend also
heard Petersen’s screams.
C.B. went back inside his home and watched through the window. He saw three
or four people loading bags into a small car while a body lay in the street. The body was
facedown with a tie-down strap tied to its hands and feet. There was a pool of blood near
the head. The three or four people were “rushing” and making multiple trips to the
house. The vehicle sped off down the street.
Officer Kyle Cushman was dispatched to Petersen’s neighborhood at around
8:55 p.m. and arrived within four to five minutes. Cushman illuminated the solid red
light on his police vehicle before arriving at the scene. As he approached Petersen’s
house, he saw brake lights on a black vehicle. The brake lights turned off and the vehicle
fled southbound. Cushman observed a “subject” lying in the roadway in front of
Petersen’s address, so he drove around it. Cushman informed other officers of the subject
via radio. The vehicle did not have its headlights or taillights on, was traveling at least
50 miles per hour in a 25-mile-per-hour zone, and ran through multiple stop signs.
Cushman activated his siren. The vehicle eventually came to a stop in the middle of the
road.
Moore exited the driver’s side of the vehicle. Cushman observed blood on
Moore’s boots, right arm, and hands. Moore said he was there to help somebody. Moore
was placed in a patrol vehicle. A firearm magazine was located in Moore’s left front
pocket.
Cushman found two handguns in the trunk of the vehicle Moore had been driving.
One was a black semiautomatic handgun and the other was a chrome 1911-style handgun
with wood grips. Another officer observed what appeared to be blood on the firearms
that was still wet.
Officer Michael Ogas observed defendant walking down the driveway of
Petersen’s house to the sidewalk. Ogas asked defendant what happened, and he replied
8.
that he was trying to help him. Although defendant did not indicate or gesture to whom
he was referring, he was looking at Petersen at the time. Defendant had a laceration on
his index finger that looked like a newer injury that was still bleeding, as well as a bruise
or scratch to his stomach. Defendant had blood on the thigh area of his pant leg and on
his shoe.
Cushman contacted defendant in front of a house on South Porter Street.
Defendant’s boots were covered in what appeared to be blood. Defendant declined
medical treatment but was eventually taken to the emergency room anyway.
Paramedics pronounced Petersen dead at the scene. The county’s forensic
pathologist determined Petersen’s cause of death to be multiple injuries to the head.
Petersen suffered multiple abrasions to the skull, each representing separate blunt force
blows to the head. The pattern of several of the abrasions showed they were made by a
manufactured object, not a naturally occurring one like a rock. The pathologist counted
11 separate areas where Petersen’s head was hit, as shown by patterned injuries. The
coloring demonstrated that all of Petersen’s injuries occurred while he still had
reasonably good blood pressure. The blunt force injuries were lethal.
Petersen had also suffered a through-and-through gunshot wound to the back of
his head that traveled toward the front. There were no signs of trauma to Petersen’s
brain, indicating the projectile never hit his brain. Because the projectile did not go into
the brain and instead hit vessels in the neck and throat, it was the type of gunshot wound
that “might not result in death for 30 minutes, an hour, a couple hours, maybe even the
body be saved in the hospital.”
The pathologist testified Petersen’s cause of death was “unusual” because “usually
it’s a gunshot or multiple gunshot wounds of the head or body. But in this case, there’s
such severe blunt-force injuries to the head, those injuries were classified as lethal type of
injuries as well, so that it is the combination of the blunt injuries to the head and face …
9.
and a gunshot wound to the head, all together. Not just one or the other but lumped
together as the cause of death.”
Firearm Evidence
The 1911 handgun was registered to Moore and the XD handgun was registered to
defendant. A firearms expert tested the 1911 handgun and it functioned properly. The
expert opined the 1911 handgun likely had a titanium firing pin, which meant it was
“next to impossible for the weapon to fire on impact without pulling the trigger.”
Consequently, the expert opined the person handling the 1911 handgun would have had a
“proper firing grip and pulled the trigger in order for this weapon to fire.”
The expert also opined that some of Petersen’s injuries were caused by the floor
plate of the 1911 handgun.
Defendant’s DNA and Petersen’s DNA were found in the blood on the grip of the
1911 handgun, while Moore was excluded as a contributor. Defendant’s DNA and
Petersen’s DNA were also found on the magazine of the 1911 handgun, while Moore was
excluded as a contributor. Moore’s DNA and Petersen’s DNA were found on the 1911
handgun’s slide, but testing was inconclusive as to whether defendant also contributed
DNA to the sample. Petersen’s DNA was found on the 1911 handgun’s trigger, but
testing of the same sample was inconclusive as to whether Moore was a contributor,
while defendant was excluded as a contributor.
Defendant’s DNA was found on the trigger of the XD handgun, while Petersen
and Moore were excluded. Defendant’s DNA and Petersen’s DNA were found on the
slide of the XD handgun, while Moore was excluded as a contributor. Defendant’s DNA
and Petersen’s DNA were found on the grip of the XD handgun, while Moore was
excluded as a contributor.
10.
Defendant’s Testimony
Defendant served in the Marine Corps for about nine and a half years. Defendant
testified that he suffered every single symptom of PTSD after his two deployments to
Afghanistan.
Defendant bought a house in San Jacinto but eventually got a job 150 miles away
in Ridgecrest because it paid well. Initially, defendant stayed in hotels until Petersen
offered to rent him a room in his house at a very reasonable price. Defendant initially
traveled home every weekend.
Defendant described Petersen as being over six feet tall and weighing
“250 pounds-plus,” depending on how he was eating. Defendant described himself as
5 feet 6 inches and 170 pounds “on a good day.”
On several occasions, Petersen said he could beat up defendant. Defendant took
Petersen to be a threat from that point forward. According to defendant, Petersen was a
heavy drinker and was “always drunk.”
Defendant was concerned that Petersen would use his AR-15 to kill everyone in
the house, so defendant disarmed it. Jessica later told defendant that Petersen had tried to
shoot her. She later clarified that he did not “ ‘really’ ” try to shoot her but instead “ ‘got
his gun out and laid it on the bed next to me and told me that he just wants to shoot
something.’ ” Defendant believed Petersen was exhibiting signs of ill intent. Defendant
took the firearm and put it in his car.
Later, Jessica said Petersen told her he would beat her up until she told him where
the gun was. Defendant removed the firing pin and placed the gun where he had initially
found it. Less than one week later, Jessica said, Petersen had loaded the gun, racked the
slide, pointed it at her face and pulled the trigger.
When Petersen went to prison, defendant and Jessica were initially friends and
defendant paid rent to Jessica. Defendant’s wife sought a divorce because defendant had
11.
been unfaithful and he was inattentive, forgetful, and not as caring to his children as she
wanted him to be.
When defendant and Jessica began dating, Jessica told him more about Petersen’s
domestic violence. Jessica told defendant that Petersen had “stalked” outside of her
home with night-vision goggles and a tarp.
Defendant had a sticker on the back of his truck with Jessica’s middle name on it.
Defendant believed that Petersen knew he was with Jessica based on social media posts
and the sticker on his truck, but he was not sure.
Defendant was aware Petersen contacted Jessica from prison. Jessica expressed
concern about what would happen when Petersen was released. In January, Jessica told
defendant that Petersen would be released any day.
Defendant admitted going to C.B. and asking him to turn off his cameras.
Defendant testified, “I think I was trying to control my environment, I think.” Defendant
denied having any plans to harm Petersen.
Defendant was trying to get to Tennessee to be with his children. On March 2,
2022, defendant’s mother asked when he was leaving and he responded, “probably
Monday or Tuesday.”
On March 4, defendant took Hannah to the movies. He had no prior notice
Petersen would be at the house that day. As he returned from the movies, he saw
Petersen and panicked. Defendant was “freaking out” and called Moore because he
wanted someone to “have [his] back.” Moore was defendant’s friend; they shared a
similar military background, hobbies, and had met through a common friend between
“late 2017, early 2018.”
Defendant claimed he did not remember what he told Moore, but he did remember
that he did not tell Moore about his issues with Petersen. Defendant admitted he texted
C.B. and asked for a favor.
12.
Defendant heard Petersen raise his voice and saw him “charging” at Hannah.
Petersen looked at defendant, stopped, and went into the house. Inside, Petersen had a
bag that was large enough to hold a firearm. This led defendant to retrieve his own
firearm (the XD handgun) and place it in his carry holster. Defendant claimed he never
drew his weapon.
Hannah left to get Jessica, and defendant went to sit on the couch. When Jessica
got home, Petersen stood up and approached her. Petersen asked if they could talk and
Jessica suggested they go outside. As Petersen, defendant, and Jessica headed outside,
Petersen stepped between defendant and Jessica in a manner defendant interpreted as
hostile. After Petersen and Jessica sat down outside, defendant stepped away a few feet
as they talked. Eventually, they all returned inside the home.
At one point, Jessica asked defendant, “ ‘What do we do?’ ” Defendant told her to
relax. At one point, Jessica asked defendant to help her unzip her dress to change out of
her work attire. Petersen grunted, stomped out of the house, and slammed the door.
Jessica and Hannah then went to get food at a fast-food restaurant, and defendant
went to take a nap. Afterwards, defendant played a game with the volume down so he
could hear the activity in the house. Defendant mostly stayed in his room, occasionally
coming out to smoke. Jessica was sitting on the couch watching a movie, and Petersen
was in the same room either playing on his phone or watching a movie.
During one of defendant’s smoking sessions, he noticed Jessica was no longer in
the living room and that Moore was arriving. Defendant claimed he had a “premonition”
to go outside at that time, but it was also “partly coincidence” that Moore arrived at that
time. Once outside, defendant and Moore were discussing Moore’s speakers when
defendant suddenly noticed Petersen looming over his left shoulder. Defendant took a
step back, and Petersen asked Moore something. Defendant looked to Moore to see his
response and “the next thing [he] knew,” defendant was on the ground with Petersen on
top of him. Defendant heard a loud boom and Petersen sat up covering his ears and was
13.
groaning. As defendant tried to get up, Petersen lunged at him. Defendant hit and kicked
Petersen in the head and face. Defendant claimed he never fired a gun, nor did he hit
anyone with his or Moore’s firearm.
Petersen eventually stopped trying to fight, and defendant assumed he was
exhausted or had gotten knocked out. Defendant told Moore to get something from
defendant’s truck to tie Petersen’s hands. Moore handed defendant his firearm, and
defendant grabbed his own firearm and tossed them in the front yard. Defendant tried to
tie Petersen’s hands but defendant was shaking so badly that he gave up. Defendant also
heard sirens at that point. He grabbed the firearms, put them in Moore’s car, and told
Moore to leave. Defendant tried to pull Petersen out of the street but could not lift him,
so he went inside the house. Defendant took off his jacket, washed his hands, and went
outside to speak with the responding officer.
Defendant claimed he did not remember what he told responding officers. On
cross-examination, defendant admitted he said things that “weren’t entirely truthful”
because he was afraid of getting in trouble. Defendant admitting lying to conceal his
involvement by telling police that he heard something, went outside, and saw Petersen
lying in the street. Defendant never claimed self-defense to the police.
Defendant claimed he never planned or tried to kill Petersen and was only
defending himself. On cross-examination, defendant was asked whether it was possible
that during the times he does not remember, he picked up the gun and “thumped”
Petersen so he would never come back. Defendant testified, “Sure, it’s possible.”
Defendant also admitted it was possible he caused the injuries to Petersen depicted in
several photographs.
Moore’s Testimony
Moore signed up for the Marine Corps at age 17 and served in 13 countries.
14.
Defendant called Moore 3 on the phone and said something along the lines of, “ ‘I
need help.’ ” Defendant’s voice was low, calm, and collected, without fear or urgency.
Moore’s first thought was suicide.
Defendant and Moore had a second phone call, during which Moore was checking
on defendant and reassured him Moore would come. Moore committed to coming before
learning defendant was way up in Ridgecrest.
Moore owned a brand-new 1911 handgun, which he would store without a round
chambered. When Moore left for Ridgecrest, the gun’s thumb safety was engaged. One
reason Moore brought his gun was in case defendant “was armed and went berserk.”
When Moore arrived, he put his gun into the back of his waistband.
Moore and defendant engaged in small talk, including about Moore’s speakers.
Moore went to turn on his car to give defendant a demonstration of the speakers. While
he was walking to turn on the car, he heard a scuffle to his left. Moore saw “a massive
dude” on top of defendant. The two were fighting viciously. Moore told Petersen 4 to
stop and tried to kick him off. The second time Moore tried to kick him, Petersen
grabbed his leg. Moore fell down, felt his gun slip out, and realized it was no longer at
his back. Moore reached for his gun but could not find it. Moore was afraid for his life
and concerned for defendant’s safety.
Moore saw Petersen with the gun, and it was pointed at Moore. Moore, defendant,
and Petersen all reached for the gun and it discharged. Moore did not pull the trigger and
did not see who did pull the trigger. When the gun discharged, all three of them
“stopped.” Defendant then began kicking Petersen. Moore did not think Petersen looked
3 Context makes clear this call occurred on March 4, 2022.
4 Moore did not generally use Petersen’s name during his testimony, relying
primarily on general male pronouns. However, other evidence clearly shows this
individual was Petersen, and that inference is favorable to the judgment. Consequently,
we will refer to the person as Petersen.
15.
like he had been shot. Moore moved away from Petersen and saw defendant was holding
the gun. Nonetheless, Moore does not “think” defendant pulled the trigger, though he did
not see. Moore did not use the 1911 handgun to club Petersen, and did not see defendant
doing so.
Defendant told Moore to get something to tie Petersen’s hands and Moore
complied. When Moore returned, defendant was kicking Petersen in the face and head,
like a soccer ball. Moore would estimate defendant kicked Petersen for 40 seconds.
Moore “froze up” because that was something he was not used to seeing.
Moore looked for his gun and saw that defendant had it. When asked if defendant
was telling the truth when he said Moore gave him the gun voluntarily, Moore testified,
“I don’t think so, no.”
Moore does not know how the guns ended up in his car; he did not put them there.
Defendant told Moore to leave. Moore claimed that he was not trying to avoid law
enforcement by leaving. Moore told responding officers that he “ ‘might have thrown
away [10] years of my life here,’ ” because he knew the situation would not look good.
PTSD
The defense called Joan Knowlden, an expert on combat PTSD. Knowlden
testified that people with PTSD exhibit sleep disturbance, anxiety, hyperarousal (meaning
they become hyper-startled), nightmares, weight issues, and, most of the time, substance
use. PTSD “episode[s]” can be triggered by perceived danger or danger to those they
care about. When someone is in “a full PTSD response,” they are not logical but instead
focused on survival.
Defendant had explained to Knowlden that he had to clean up “human debris” left
behind by a helicopter crash or “IED.” 5 The Department of Veterans Affairs found
defendant to “have a posttraumatic stress disorder disability of 50 percent.”
5 Presumably referring to an improvised explosive device.
16.
It would not surprise Knowlden that a Marine combat veteran with PTSD would
call someone else in the Marine Corps for help if he perceived being in danger.
Defendant’s friends and family described him after his military deployments as
“withdrawn,” responsive to loud noises, and having lost interest in things he was
previously interested in. They also generally testified that defendant was not violent or
aggressive, was protective, and thought things through before acting. Premeditated and
deliberate murder was inconsistent with defendant’s character.
DISCUSSION
I. Substantial Evidence Supported the Involuntary Manslaughter Conviction
Defendant claims there was insufficient evidence to support the jury’s verdict of
guilty as to involuntary manslaughter.
Law
When considering a substantial evidence challenge, “ ‘ “we review the entire
record in the light most favorable to the judgment to determine whether it contains …
evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of solid value—from which a reasonable trier of
fact could find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” ’ ” (People v. Holmes,
McClain and Newborn (2022) 12 Cal.5th 719, 780.)
“ ‘ “[I]t is the jury, not the appellate court that must be convinced of the
defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.” ’ ” (People v. Clark (2016) 63 Cal.4th
522, 625–626 (Clark).) In contrast to the jury—which must acquit if it finds the
circumstantial evidence susceptible to two reasonable interpretations, one of which
suggests guilt and the other innocence—an appellate court must accept logical inferences
in favor of the judgment if supported by the circumstantial evidence. (Ibid.) Thus,
“ ‘[w]here the circumstances reasonably justify the trier of fact’s findings, a reviewing
court’s conclusion the circumstances might also reasonably be reconciled with a contrary
finding does not warrant the judgment’s reversal.’ ” (Id. at p. 626.)
17.
“[A] defendant commits involuntary manslaughter by committing a homicide with
the mens rea of criminal negligence. (People v. Butler (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 998,
1006–1007.) The offense must be based on one of three predicate acts: (1) killing in the
commission of a misdemeanor (§ 192, subd. (b)); (2) killing ‘in the commission of a
lawful act which might produce death, in an unlawful manner, or without due caution and
circumspection’ (ibid.); or (3) killing in the commission of ‘a noninherently dangerous
felony ... “committed without due caution and circumspection.” ’ ([People v.] Bryant[
(2013)] 56 Cal.4th [959,] 966; see People v. Penny (1955) 44 Cal.2d 861, 879 [a ‘lack of
“due caution and circumspection” ’ means ‘ “criminal negligence” ’].) ‘The performance
of an act with criminal negligence supplies the criminal intent for involuntary
manslaughter, regardless whether the conduct underlying the offense is a misdemeanor, a
lawful act, or a noninherently dangerous felony.’ (Butler, at p. 1008.)” (People v. Sevilla
(2025) 115 Cal.App.5th 618, 626 (Sevilla).)
“ ‘Criminal negligence is “ ‘aggravated, culpable, gross, or reckless ... conduct ...
[that is] such a departure from what would be the conduct of an ordinarily prudent or
careful [person] under the same circumstances as to be incompatible with a proper regard
for human life ....’ ” [Citation.] “Under the criminal negligence standard, knowledge of
the risk is determined by an objective test: ‘[I]f a reasonable person in defendant’s
position would have been aware of the risk involved, then defendant is presumed to have
had such an awareness.’ ” ’ (People v. Valdez (2002) 27 Cal.4th 778, 783.)” (Sevilla,
supra, 115 Cal.App.5th at p. 627.)
Analysis
Criminal Negligence
Defendant first contends there was insufficient evidence he acted with criminal
negligence. He argues that he did not act in a grossly reckless manner, but instead acted
reasonably after Petersen, a violent and abusive man, attacked him. He goes on to cite
evidence supporting this claim. However, defendant is presenting the evidence in the
18.
light most favorable to him. We are tasked with considering the evidence in the light
most favorable to the judgment. Doing so, it becomes clear that the jury could have
reasonably inferred from the evidence that defendant acted with criminal negligence.
Defendant repeatedly kicked Petersen in the head after he was shot. Moore
estimated defendant kicked Petersen for forty seconds. Moore, a former Marine, “froze
up” when defendant did this because it was not something he was used to seeing.
Moreover, there was evidence that Petersen was clubbed with one of the firearms.
The jury could have reasonably believed Moore’s denial that he was the one who clubbed
Petersen and could have reasonably disbelieved defendant’s denial of the same. Indeed,
defendant’s DNA and Petersen’s DNA were found in the blood on the grip of the 1911
handgun, while Moore was excluded as a contributor. Defendant himself admitted it was
“possible” he had struck Petersen with the gun without remembering it. If the jury
accepted these inferences, then defendant would have repeatedly clubbed Petersen with a
firearm and kicked him in the head for a substantial period of time. These blunt force
injuries were severe enough to be a cause of death.
Moreover, there was plenty of evidence that defendant was not acting in
self-defense. 6 Defendant asked a neighbor to turn off cameras facing the house. The
neighbor’s girlfriend overheard defendant say that Petersen would “get what he
deserved” when he came home. During the scuffle, the neighbor and his girlfriend heard
Petersen screaming for help before he was shot. Petersen’s hands and feet were tied.
Defendant lied to responding officers. Moore told responding officers he “ ‘might have
6 The fact that the jury acquitted defendant of more serious charges is immaterial
here. Substantial evidence review for one count is “ ‘ “ ‘independent of the jury’s
determination that evidence on another count was insufficient.’ [Citation.]” [Citation.]
“An inconsistency may show no more than jury lenity, compromise, or mistake, none of
which undermines the validity of a verdict.” ’ ” (People v. Price (2017) 8 Cal.App.5th
409, 452; see People v. Miranda (2011) 192 Cal.App.4th 398, 405–407.)
19.
thrown away [10] years of my life here,’ ” because he knew the situation “would[ not]
look good.”
Based on this evidence and related inferences, a jury could reasonably conclude
defendant’s acts were “ ‘ “ ‘aggravated, culpable, gross, or reckless’ ” ’ ” and
“ ‘ “ ‘incompatible with proper regard for human life’ ” ’ ” (Sevilla, supra, 15
Cal.App.5th at p. 627), and therefore criminally negligent. Because there was evidence
supporting the judgment on this point, it is immaterial that there was other evidence cited
by defendant that “ ‘might also reasonably be reconciled with a contrary finding.’ ”
(Clark, supra, 63 Cal.4th at p. 626.)
Cause of Death
Defendant next claims there was insufficient evidence he caused Petersen’s death.
Not so. As described above, there was substantial evidence from which a jury could infer
defendant kicked Petersen in the head and face repeatedly and clubbed him with a pistol.
A pathologist testified that Petersen’s blunt force injuries were lethal.
While Petersen also suffered a gunshot wound—which defendant claims he did
not fire—the bullet likely missed his brain, and it was the type of gunshot wound that
“might not result in death for 30 minutes, an hour, a couple hours, maybe even the body
be saved in the hospital.” Consequently, the pathologist ultimately opined that there was
“such severe blunt-force injuries to the head, those injuries were classified as lethal type
of injuries as well, so that it is the combination of the blunt injuries to the head and face
… and a gunshot wound to the head, all together. Not just one or the other but lumped
together as the cause of death.”
Defendant suggests he was not the person who struck Petersen with the pistol and
cites supporting evidence. But that is an inference contrary to the judgment. On
substantial evidence review, we indulge reasonable inferences in favor of the judgment.
There was significant evidence that either Moore or defendant struck Petersen with a
pistol. While both men denied being the one to do it, the jury was free to accept Moore’s
20.
denial while rejecting defendant’s denial. In oth