Full Opinion

Filed 11/18/26 P. v. Montoya CA3 NOT TO BE PUBLISHED California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115. IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT (Sacramento) THE PEOPLE, C103690 Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. 21FE008202) v. EDWIN MONTOYA, Defendant and Appellant. A jury found defendant Edwin Montoya guilty of rape and of penetrating the genital opening by a foreign object. The trial court sentenced him to six years in prison. On appeal, defendant contends the trial court prejudicially erred by finding a juror’s comment was inadmissible to establish juror misconduct. We disagree, because there was no substantial likelihood the juror’s comment improperly influenced any juror to defendant’s detriment: the jury remained deadlocked after the alleged misconduct and that deadlock was broken only after further arguments from counsel, which jurors had requested. We affirm. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND Victim alleged defendant digitally and sexually penetrated her without her consent. During the police investigation, defendant told a detective the victim’s actions and demeanor led him to believe she wanted to have sex with him. At trial, defendant 1 similarly testified victim made comments that he believed were an invitation to have sexual interactions with her. As part of the police investigation, victim made a pretext telephone call to defendant and sent pretext text messages to him. As instructed by a detective, victim pretended she was pregnant and expressed her concerns to defendant about having a baby who was conceived during their nonconsensual sex. She then asked defendant why he did not stop when she said no. Defendant responded that he thought victim said, “No, don’t stop.” Victim added she was hitting defendant and telling him to get off her, and defendant claimed he did not remember what happened. The People charged defendant with penetration of the genital opening by a foreign object (Pen. Code, § 289, subd. (a)(1)) and rape (Pen. Code, § 261, subd. (a)(2)). Jury deliberations began on the morning of Friday, April 4, 2025. On the afternoon of Monday, April 7, the jury informed the trial court it was hung on both counts. All 12 jurors told the trial court further deliberations would not result in a verdict. But several jurors stated further arguments from counsel may help. On April 8, counsel for both sides provided additional arguments with the trial court’s permission. The jury found defendant guilty of both counts one hour after hearing counsel’s arguments. On April 23, defendant moved for a new trial based on juror misconduct and attached Juror No. 9’s declaration in support. According to the declaration, several jurors expressed disappointment that the pretext text messages started with victim’s fake pregnancy as they thought it influenced defendant’s response. In this context, Juror No. 7 said on April 7 he independently researched and concluded victim’s pretext telephone call and text messages to defendant were not entrapment. Juror No. 9 and one other juror told Juror No. 7 he was not supposed to conduct the independent research. As part of the same conversation, Juror No. 7 added, “rapists repeat their crime, so if we let the defendant go, when he rapes again it will be the responsibility of those that are voting 2 ‘not guilty.’ ” Several jurors nodded in agreement. Juror No. 9 believed the comment was directed at him, one of the two “not guilty” votes at the time. He felt the comment characterized him as “pro rape.” Shortly after Juror No. 7’s comments, the jury held a final vote and remained deadlocked. The trial court denied the motion for a new trial. It found the only admissible portion of Juror No. 9’s declaration was Juror No. 7’s statement about his research on entrapment. And while the research was misconduct, it was not prejudicial. DISCUSSION Defendant contends the trial court prejudicially erred by finding Juror No. 7’s comment about recidivism of rapists inadmissible to establish juror misconduct. Assuming without deciding the comment was admissible and established juror misconduct, we conclude there was no substantial likelihood that any juror was improperly influenced to defendant’s detriment. “When a party seeks a new trial based upon jury misconduct, a court must undertake a three-step inquiry. The court must first determine whether the affidavits supporting the motion are admissible. [Citation.] If the evidence is admissible, the court must then consider whether the facts establish misconduct. [Citation.] Finally, assuming misconduct, the court must determine whether the misconduct was prejudicial.” (People v. Perez (1992) 4 Cal.App.4th 893, 906.) “Once misconduct has been established, prejudice is presumed; reversal is required unless the reviewing court finds, upon examination of the entire record, there is no substantial likelihood that any juror was improperly influenced to the defendant’s detriment.” (People v. Duran (1996) 50 Cal.App.4th 103, 113.) Here, there was no substantial likelihood that Juror No. 7’s recidivism comment improperly influenced any juror to defendant’s detriment. Juror No. 7 made this comment on April 7, 2025, in the same conversation where he was admonished by fellow jurors for conducting independent research. While the comment made Juror No. 9 3 uncomfortable, Juror No. 9 did not claim it changed his or the other holdout juror’s vote. Indeed, the comment was unpersuasive, as the jury held a final vote on that same day, shortly after hearing the comment, and hung on both counts. The jury promptly informed the trial court of the deadlock that same afternoon, and all 12 jurors believed further deliberations would not lead to a verdict. In other words, none of the jurors thought further discussions of the case among themselves, after hearing Juror No. 7’s comments, would change their or their fellow jurors’ minds. Following the deadlock, on April 8, counsel made further arguments to the jury, and the jury reached a verdict just one hour later. The record shows counsel’s additional arguments broke the deadlock, not Juror No. 7’s recidivism comment. DISPOSITION The judgment is affirmed. /s/ MESIWALA, J. We concur: /s/ MAURO, Acting P. J. /s/ KRAUSE, J. 4