People v. Ware CA4/1
CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
DocketD085223
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Filed 11/16/26 P. v. Ware CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or or dered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D085223
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SCD302137)
RASHAD WARE,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Joan P. Weber, Judge. Affirmed as modified.
Carl Fabian, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant
and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Arlene A. Sevidal, Assistant Attorney General,
Christopher P. Beesley and Kristen Kinnaird Chenelia, Deputy Attorneys
General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Rashad Ware, a member of the Neighborhood Crips gang, appeals
from a judgment imposed after a jury convicted him of first degree murder
and related crimes on the theory that he was the actual perpetrator of an
October 2021 shooting in rival gang territory that caused the death of
Rahman Thomas. Ware contends that: (1) there is insufficient evidence of
his identity as the shooter; (2) the sentence on one of his convictions for
possession of ammunition must be stayed under Penal Code1 section 654;
and (3) the abstracts of judgment must be amended to correct various errors
and award one additional day of custody credits. The People contest the first
issue but concede the other two. We conclude there is sufficient evidence to
support the jury’s verdict and accept the People’s concessions as to the other
issues. We modify the judgment accordingly and affirm the judgment as so
modified.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Gang Rivalry
5-9 Brim is a Blood gang that claims the Mountain View neighborhood
of southeast San Diego as its territory, including the 3600 block of Ocean
View Boulevard where Mike’s Market is located. In 2021, Mike’s Market was
a well-known hangout for 5-9 Brim members.
Neighborhood Crips is a Crip gang that claims territory near the 5-9
Brim territory. Neighborhood Crips and 5-9 Brim are bitter rivals. There
have been numerous shootings and violent crimes between the two gangs.
In October 2021, Ware was a member of the Neighborhood Crips gang
and its subset the “xtras.” He had Neighborhood Crips tattoos and used the
1 All further unspecified statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
screen name “c_xtraz” for his social media accounts, which included gang-
related postings and communications. Ware stipulated that he had
previously been convicted of a felony.
B. The Shooting
Around 2:00 a.m. on October 19, 2021, a group of about 6-8 people were
hanging out across the street from Mike’s Market in the heart of 5-9 Brim
territory. They were talking, laughing, drinking, and using crack cocaine.
The group included Rahman Thomas, Tammy J., and Marvin T. Tenney C.
was also present near or inside his blue Toyota Camry. According to Tammy,
most of the people in the group were gang-affiliated.
Rahman had recently been released from prison. He had a large “5-9
Brim” tattoo on his back and was wearing a black shirt and jeans.
Shortly after 2:00 a.m., someone started shooting at the group from the
corner of Ocean View Boulevard and Olivewood Terrace. Rahman sustained
a total of seven gunshot wounds to his head and legs. He died at the scene
from the gunshot wound to the head. Another bullet shattered the rear
windshield of Tenney’s Toyota Camry.
People scattered after the gunshots. At 2:04 a.m., Tammy called 911
to report the shooting. When the operator asked Tammy if she saw the
person who did the shooting, she responded, “no I did not.” She told the
operator: “[W]e were sitting on the wall. They walked right to the corner, lit
it up. And uh, everybody started scattering.” The police arrived at the scene
at 2:08 a.m.
3
C. The Initial Investigation
The police found six 9-millimeter shell casings on the ground at the
corner of Ocean View Boulevard and Olivewood Terrace.
The police also recovered motion-activated Ring camera footage from
a nearby apartment complex. The footage showed the group gathered across
the street from Mike’s Market, but not the shooter. In footage recorded at
1:51 a.m., a person Tammy identified as Marvin walked towards the group
with a bag over his shoulder. Additional footage recorded between 1:53 a.m.
and 2:00 a.m. showed the group having a good time and possibly using a
lighter for crack cocaine. The Ring footage did not show any altercation or
anyone walking away from the group towards Olivewood Terrace. At
2:06 a.m., the Ring footage showed everyone gone except for the decedent
lying on the ground.
Tammy spoke to the police at the scene, then again on the phone later
the same morning, and at her home two days later. At the scene, she was
talking very quickly, rambling, and saying things that were difficult to
understand. Her demeanor was consistent with being under the influence of
alcohol or cocaine. In her initial statements, Tammy said she would not
recognize the shooter and could not describe his facial features, but also said
she believed she knew who the shooter was and wanted confirmation from
the police. She told the police she thought the shooter was someone with
whom she went to high school but did not provide a name. She described the
shooter as a dark-skinned, Black male who was “fuller-figured” and had a
“voluptuous figure.” She also stated that Marvin “headed off in that direction
and he had . . . to have come eye to eye with the shooter.”
In the final interview at her home, Tammy named two individuals she
thought might have committed the shooting: Marvin and Jeffrey H. She
4
identified Marvin as the person she knew from high school. Tammy spent
most of the interview talking about her belief that Marvin could have been
the shooter. She also said she believed she was the intended target because
she had a verbal altercation with Marvin and the decedent that night.
Tammy told the police that if Marvin was the shooter, “he was aiming at me.”
Tammy also said Marvin had left the group before the shooting and walked
toward the corner where the shooting occurred. She thought Marvin either
was the shooter or saw the shooter face-to-face.
In one brief portion of this interview, Tammy told the police that if
Marvin was not the shooter, it might have been Jeffrey H. She mentioned
that Jeffrey was a 5-9 Brim member and had been involved in other robberies
and drug usage. But then she immediately recanted and said, “Well, that
doesn’t make any sense because this wasn’t like a robbery.” Tammy went
back to explaining her belief that Marvin could have been the shooter. She
asked the police several times: “If you find out who it was, please tell me so
I’ll know if I’m in danger.” Tammy never definitively identified the shooter
or said she knew who it was.
D. Evidence of Rhodes’s Connection to Murder Weapon
The crime lab tested the recovered shell casings for DNA and got a hit
for Thomas Rhodes, a known Neighborhood Crips gang member in the “xtras”
subset.2 There was very strong support for Rhodes being a contributor for 87
percent of the DNA on one of the casings.
The San Diego police learned that Rhodes had been arrested in a traffic
stop by Escondido police 21 days after the shooting. At the time of arrest,
2 Rhodes exercised his Fifth Amendment right to remain silent when
called to testify at trial. At the prosecutor’s request, the court granted him
immunity and ordered him to testify. Called as a witness in front of the jury,
5
Rhodes was considered a parolee at large. Rhodes had a backpack in his
vehicle containing a loaded 9-millimeter Glock handgun with a laser
attachment and extended magazine. The police seized the Glock handgun
as well as a cell phone Rhodes had on his person. Ballistics testing later
determined that the Glock handgun had fired the six shell casings found at
the scene of the October 19, 2021 shooting.
The police extracted data from Rhodes’s cell phone. They discovered
a text exchange that occurred three days after the shooting in which Rhodes
unsuccessfully tried to sell the Glock handgun to another Crip member.
The text exchange included a photo of the gun showing the serial number,
which matched the serial number of the gun seized from Rhodes and
identified as the murder weapon.
Rhodes was considered a prime suspect in the murder, but the police
eventually determined that he was not at the scene when it occurred.
Rhodes was a parolee on GPS ankle monitoring in October 2021. The GPS
monitoring records showed that Rhodes was at or near his apartment in
Escondido far from southeast San Diego on October 18 and 19, 2021,
including at the time of the murder. If the GPS device had been tampered
with or disconnected, it would have sent a signal and the parole agent would
have been notified, which did not occur.
In June 2022, when Rhodes was in custody on another matter, the
police placed a confidential informant into the jail cell with him. Before or
during the operation, the police confronted Rhodes with incriminating
Rhodes still refused to testify. The court held him in contempt and instructed
the jury that Rhodes did not have the right to refuse to testify and it could
consider his refusal in deliberations.
6
evidence, including that they had the gun seized from him in Escondido and
they knew it was the gun used in the shooting. In his secretly recorded
conversation with the confidential informant, Rhodes said he gave the gun
to the person who did the shooting. The informant said to Rhodes: “I want to
ask you a hypothetical question. You said that the homie came and got the
thang from you. Why did you let him give it back to you?” The word
“thang” refers to a firearm. Rhodes responded: “I was supposed to take it
(unintelligible). (Whispering) you know what I’m say? (unintelligible) take it
over there.” In another audio clip, the informant asked, “So when your homie
went to go put it down, did that [n-word] wind up coming back to your house
afterwards?” Rhodes responded, “He did. . . . It wasn’t right afterwards. He
came like the next morning type shit.”
E. Evidence of Ware’s Involvement
The police examined records for the cell phone taken from Rhodes,
which had a phone number ending in 2721. They discovered that someone
using a phone number ending in 3619 had texted Rhodes about 10 minutes
after the shooting. There were a total of 16 calls or texts between these two
phones on October 18 and 19, 2021, but no transactions between them on any
other days between July and November 2021. The phone with the number
ending in 3619 was registered to Candace W. at an address on 37th Street in
San Diego.3
Candace was Ware’s girlfriend. They were stopped by the police in a
vehicle together seven months before the shooting and again on two occasions
3 For clarity, we refer to each phone by the name of the person it was
registered to rather than its number. As we will explain, however, the
prosecution’s theory was that Candace was using her husband Lavorus W.’s
7
in the two years after the shooting, including once when Ware identified
Candace as his wife.4 They had a child together in August 2022, ten months
after the shooting.
From September through November 2021, the cell phone records for
Rhodes’s phone showed 29 transactions with a phone number ending in 1194
that was registered to Ware. Ware’s number was saved in the contacts list
for Rhodes’s phone under the name c_xtraz. Ware and Rhodes also messaged
each other on Instagram in this time period.
There was only one transaction between Ware’s phone and Candace’s
phone between July and November 2021. However, there were hundreds of
contacts between Ware’s phone and another phone with a number ending in
2562, which was registered to Candace’s husband Lavorus W. Lavorus was
in jail from June 2021 through March 2022 but his phone was still being used
heavily in the time period leading up to the murder in October 2021. In a
traffic stop one month after the murder, Candace gave the police a phone
number that was one digit off from Lavorus’s phone number. It is not
unusual for subjects to give the police a phone number that is only slightly
altered from the real number.
The police analyzed cell tower data for the phones registered to Rhodes,
Candace, Ware, and Lavorus. Cell phones are always trying to connect to the
phone during the relevant time period and Ware was using Candace’s phone
on the night of the murder.
4 Ware was actually married to another woman named Sasha E. who
invoked the marital privilege outside the presence of the jury and refused to
testify at trial. Social media messages between Ware and Sasha suggested
they had separated by early October 2021.
8
cell tower with the strongest signal. When a cell phone changes locations, it
will switch connections to another cell tower with a stronger signal.
On several dates in September and October 2021, including four days
before the shooting, Ware’s phone and Rhodes’s phone each connected to the
same cell tower in Escondido around the same time.
On October 18, 2021, the day before the shooting, Candace’s phone and
Ware’s 1194 phone both connected to a cell tower in the vicinity of Candace’s
home on 37th Street multiple times and the two phones appeared to be in the
same general area throughout the day.
Minutes before the shooting, at 1:57 a.m., 1:58 a.m., and 1:59 a.m. on
October 19, 2021, Candace’s phone connected with a different cell tower
near the shooting for an incoming text and calls. This cell tower was located
.07 miles from where the shooting occurred. About 10 minutes after the
shooting, Candace’s phone sent a text message to Rhodes’s phone. Shortly
after the shooting, Candace’s phone was again using a cell tower near
Candace’s home on 37th Street.5
About two hours after the murder, there was communication from
Candace’s phone to a phone number ending in 6144 that was associated with
a Neighborhood Crips gang member named Dajon J. There were no other
contacts between these two phones in the time period from July 2021 through
January 2022, but there were regular contacts between Dajon’s phone and
both Ware’s phone and Rhodes’s phone.
5 The parties have not transmitted any of the trial exhibits to us and the
reporter’s transcript does not indicate the distance between Candace’s home
on 37th Street and the location of the shooting. The prosecutor told the jury
they were “nowhere near” each other.
9
Ware’s phone had no usage events in the hours before and immediately
after the shooting. The next morning, however, there were phone calls
between Ware’s phone and Rhodes’s phone and Ware’s phone traveled from
San Diego to the area of Rhodes’s residence in Escondido. Rhodes’s phone
remained in the same location in Escondido from the morning before the
shooting to the evening after the shooting.
The police suspected that Candace was using Lavorus’s phone at the
time of the murder and Ware was using both his own phone and Candace’s
phone. There was no record of any contacts between Lavorus’s phone and
Rhodes’s phone.
DNA analysis of swabs taken from the textured area of the murder
weapon showed a mixture of DNA from five individuals, including a 64
percent contributor and a 10 percent contributor. There was very strong
support for Rhodes as the 64 percent contributor and strong support for Ware
as the 10 percent contributor. It was 232,000 times more likely that Ware
was a contributor than not. The total amount of DNA on this swab was
approximately one nanogram and Ware’s DNA was only 10 percent of the
total.
Ware was excluded as a contributor of the DNA on two other swabs,
one taken from the trigger and trigger guard and another from the exterior of
the magazine. Rhodes was identified as the largest contributor of DNA on
these two other samples. Rhodes’s DNA was identified on the swabs from the
cartridge casings and Ware was excluded as a contributor.
F. Tammy’s Trial Testimony
For the first time at trial, Tammy identified the shooter as Jeffrey H.
She claimed she had told the police she thought the shooter was Jeffrey and
denied telling them it could have been Marvin. She identified Jeffrey as
10
someone with whom she grew up and went to school. According to Tammy,
she had a verbal argument with Marvin and the decedent before the
shooting. Tammy grew up with Marvin and did not get along with him.
After the argument, Marvin left the group, walked to the corner where the
shooter was, and spoke to the shooter for three to five minutes immediately
before the shooting. Contrary to what Tammy told the police, she was certain
Marvin was not the shooter. She also testified she had never seen Ware
before trial.
Tammy admitted she had been drinking that night. She was probably
drinking hard liquor and beer for an hour or two before the shooting. Tammy
was not certain whether she had also been using crack cocaine but “nine
times out of ten” she would have been.
G. Other Evidence Relating to Marvin
Marvin spoke to the police for the first time in July 2024. He was
friendly and cooperative and willingly provided a DNA sample. The DNA
analysis excluded Marvin as a contributor of the DNA on the swabs from the
firearm.
Marvin asserted his Fifth Amendment rights but then testified at
trial under a grant of immunity. He was present with the rest of the group
at the time of the shooting but never walked towards the corner of Olivewood
Terrace where the shooter was and never spoke with the shooter. He saw fire
and a blue laser light coming from the gun but could not describe the shooter.
When the shooting started, Marvin dove in front of the Toyota then took off
running. Marvin denied that he was carrying a bag that night and testified
that the person with the bag shown in the Ring video was not him.
Marvin attended high school with Tammy and did not get along with
her. He did not know the decedent, Ware, or Rhodes.
11
H. Other Evidence Relating to Jeffrey
Jeffrey also asserted his Fifth Amendment rights but then testified at
trial under a grant of immunity. He was not present or involved in any way
with the shooting. Jeffrey was a childhood friend of the decedent’s and
remained friends with his family. He denied knowing Tammy or Rhodes.
Jeffrey had lived down the street from Mike’s Market his whole life and was
associated with the 5-9 Brim gang. He was 59 years old at the time of trial.
No other witness or evidence placed Jeffrey at the scene of the shooting
or in the area at the time. After Tammy’s trial testimony, additional DNA
testing excluded Jeffrey as a contributor of the DNA on the swabs taken from
the murder weapon. There was also no evidence of any association between
Jeffrey and Rhodes. According to the homicide detectives, it would not make
sense for a 5-9 Brim member to have committed the shooting or for the gun
used in the shooting to have been provided by a Neighborhood Crips member
(Rhodes) to a rival Brim 5-9 member.
Police identified multiple phone numbers associated with either Marvin
or Jeffrey. None of those phone numbers appeared in the records for the
phones registered to Ware, Rhodes, or Candace.
I. Trial Court Proceedings
A jury found Ware guilty of first degree murder (§ 187, subd. (a);
count 1), unlawful possession of a firearm (§ 29800; count 2), unlawful
possession of ammunition (§ 30305; count 3), and shooting at an inhabited
vehicle (§ 246; count 4), and found true firearm use allegations accompanying
the murder count (§§ 12022.53, subd. (d), 12022.5, subd. (a)). In a bifurcated
bench trial, the court found that Ware had a prior strike conviction (§§ 667,
subds. (b)-(i), 668, 1170.12). The court sentenced Ware to a total of 55 years
12
to life in prison, including concurrent terms of two years each for the firearm
possession (count 2) and ammunition possession (count 3).
DISCUSSION
I
There Was Sufficient Evidence of Ware’s Identity as the Shooter
Ware first argues there was insufficient evidence of his identity as the
shooter. Although there was no direct evidence identifying Ware as the
shooter, we conclude that the totality of the circumstantial evidence was
sufficient for the jury to conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that he was the
person who committed the shooting.
We apply the substantial evidence standard in reviewing a claim of
insufficient evidence. We must examine the record “in the light most
favorable to the judgment to determine whether it contains evidence that is
reasonable, credible, and of solid value from which a trier of fact could find
the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” (People v. Zaragoza (2016)
1 Cal.5th 21, 44.) In doing so, we “presume in support of the judgment the
existence of every fact the jury could reasonably have deduced from the
evidence.” (Ibid.) The relevant question for purposes of substantial evidence
review “is whether, in light of all the evidence, ‘any reasonable trier of fact
could have found the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.’ ” (Ibid.)
Reversal based on insufficient evidence is warranted only if “it appears ‘that
upon no hypothesis whatever is there sufficient substantial evidence to
support [the conviction].’ ” (People v. Bolin (1998) 18 Cal.4th 297, 331.)
Substantial evidence includes circumstantial evidence and any
reasonable inferences that can be drawn from the evidence. (People v. Clark
(2011) 52 Cal.4th 856, 943.) We presume every reasonable inference from the
13
evidence to support the judgment. (People v. Covarrubias (2016) 1 Cal.5th
838, 890.)
“[T]he judgment is not subject to reversal on appeal simply because the
prosecution relied heavily on circumstantial evidence and because conflicting
inferences on matters bearing on guilt could be drawn at trial. Although the
jury is required to acquit a criminal defendant if it finds the evidence
susceptible of two reasonable interpretations, one of which favors guilt and
the other innocence, it is the jury, not the appellate court, which must be
convinced of his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.” (People v. Millwee (1998)
18 Cal.4th 96, 132.) “If the circumstances reasonably justify the trier of fact’s
findings, the opinion of the reviewing court that the circumstances might also
be reasonably reconciled with a contrary finding does not warrant a reversal
of the judgment.” (People v. Perez (1992) 2 Cal.4th 1117, 1124, internal
quotation marks omitted.)
“An inference is a logical and reasonable deduction or conclusion
to be drawn from the proof of preliminary facts.” (People v. Massie (2006)
142 Cal.App.4th 365, 373–374; see also Evid. Code, § 600, subd. (b).)
“The strength of an inference may vary widely. In some circumstances,
the preliminary facts may virtually compel the conclusion. In other
circumstances, the preliminary facts may minimally support the conclusion.
But to constitute an inference, the conclusion must to some degree reasonably
and logically follow from the preliminary facts. If, upon proof of the
preliminary facts, the conclusion is mere guesswork, then we refer to it by
such words as speculation, conjecture, surmise, suspicion, and the like; and
it cannot rise to the dignity of an inference.” (People v. Boatman (2013) 221
Cal.App.4th 1253, 1265–1266, internal quotation marks omitted.)
14
On this record, the inference that Ware was the shooter was a logical
and reasonable deduction from the totality of the evidence presented at trial.
Rhodes and Ware were members of the same subset of the Neighborhood
Crips gang, which had a violent rivalry with the 5-9 Brim gang. Rhodes tried
to sell the murder weapon three days after the shooting and was arrested in
possession of the murder weapon three weeks later. However, Rhodes’s
phone records and GPS ankle monitoring records showed that he did not
leave Escondido on October 18 or 19, 2021, so the jury could reasonably
conclude the shooter must have been someone else who was connected to
Rhodes. Rhodes himself told the confidential informant that he gave the gun
to the person who did the shooting and the shooter returned it to him the
next morning.
Ware’s phone traveled from San Diego to the area of Rhodes’s residence
in Escondido four days before the shooting and again the morning after the
shooting. His girlfriend Candace’s phone connected to a cell tower right near
the shooting minutes before it occurred; it texted Rhodes about 10 minutes
after the shooting; it called or texted Rhodes a total of 16 times on October 18
and 19, 2021; and it communicated with another Neighborhood Crips
member named Dajon J. two hours after the shooting. Notably, Candace’s
phone did not communicate with either Rhodes or Dajon on any other dates
in July through November 2021, but Ware’s phone regularly communicated
with both of them and they were all members of the same gang. Ware’s
phone and Candace’s phone were in the same area of Candace’s residence for
the entire day before the shooting and the phones were together again in the
same area the next morning. Moreover, the jury could reasonably infer that
Candace was using Lavorus’s phone while he was in custody, as the records
for this phone showed hundreds of communications between it and Ware’s
15
phone, and Candace herself provided this phone number to the police (with
one digit altered) one month after the shooting.
Based on the foregoing, the jury could logically deduce that Ware was
using Candace’s phone to communicate with his fellow gang members on
the night of the murder. There was no evidence that anyone else with a
connection to Rhodes or Dajon used or had access to this phone. The jury
could also conclude that whoever was using Candace’s phone must have been
the shooter because this phone was in the area of the shooting minutes before
it occurred, it was used to text Rhodes about 10 minutes afterwards, and the
murder weapon was ultimately recovered from Rhodes. The jurors were free
to believe Rhodes’s statement that the shooter returned the gun to him the
next morning, and to infer from this and the cell tower records that Ware
traveled to Rhodes’s residence in Escondido to obtain the gun from him before
the shooting and return it the morning of October 19, 2021. Finally, Ware’s
DNA was found on the murder weapon, there was no evidence the shooter
had any accomplice with him at the scene, the shooting occurred in the heart
of 5-9 Brim territory, and Ware and Rhodes were members of the same
subset of a rival gang who were in regular communication with one another
in the months surrounding the shooting.
In arguing that the evidence of identity was insufficient, Ware contends
that no eyewitness identified him as the shooter or placed him at the scene;
no one saw him in possession of a firearm; Tammy identified Jeffrey as the
shooter at trial; Tammy’s testimony was more credible than Jeffrey’s; the
phone that connected to the cell tower near the murder was registered to
Candace rather than Ware; the cell tower evidence established only the
general area of the phone rather than its exact location; it was Rhodes who
was arrested in possession of the murder weapon; Rhodes’s DNA was found
16
on the expended shell casings at the scene as well as the handle, trigger, and
magazine of the murder weapon; and only a small amount of Ware’s DNA
was found on the textured portion of the murder weapon, which could have
been a result of a secondary or tertiary transfer.
These were all reasonable arguments for Ware to make to the jury, but
they do not establish insufficient evidence as a matter of law. Direct evidence
of identity is not required; circumstantial evidence may be sufficient to
connect a defendant with the crime and prove his guilt beyond a reasonable
doubt. (People v. Abilez (2007) 41 Cal.4th 472, 504.) Moreover, in reviewing
the sufficiency of evidence to support a conviction, we do not redetermine the
weight of the evidence or the credibility of witnesses. (People v. Gaines (2023)
93 Cal.App.5th 91, 110.)
To accept Ware’s arguments, we would have to redetermine the weight
of the evidence and credibility of the witnesses. There was ample reason
for the jury not to accept Tammy’s surprise identification of Jeffrey as the
shooter at trial, including her prior inconsistent statements, her use of drugs
and alcohol on the night of the shooting, Jeffrey’s contrary testimony, the
detectives’ opinions that it would not make sense for a 5-9 Brim member
to commit the shooting in 5-9 Brim territory using a gun supplied by a
Neighborhood Crips member, and the fact that no other witness or evidence
even placed Jeffrey at the scene. Although the cell tower evidence may not
have pinpointed the exact location of Candace’s phone, it did place the phone
in the area of the shooting, and the same phone was used to text Rhodes
about 10 minutes after the shooting and communicate with him 16 times on
the day of and the day before the shooting. When combined with the fact that
the murder weapon was ultimately recovered from Rhodes three weeks later,
the jury could reasonably conclude it was no coincidence that this phone was
17
in the area of the shooting minutes before it happened. Although the phone
was registered to Candace, the evidence supported the inference that she was
using a different phone and Ware was using Candace’s phone the night of the
murder. Moreover, it was for the jury to assess the weight and significance of
Ware’s DNA on the firearm considering the totality of the evidence, including
the cell phone evidence logically connecting Candace’s phone to the crime and
Ware to the phone.
Viewing the totality of the evidence in the light most favorable to the
jury’s verdict and presuming the jury drew all reasonable inferences in favor
of the prosecution, we conclude that the evidence was sufficient for the jury to
find beyond a reasonable doubt that Ware was the shooter.
II
The Sentence on Count 3 Must be Stayed Under Section 654
Ware contends that his two-year concurrent sentence for possession of
ammunition (count 3) should be stayed under section 654 because it was
committed with the same objective as his possession of a firearm (count 2).
The People concede the issue. We accept the People’s concession and will
therefore modify the judgment to stay the sentence on count 3. (See People v.
Wright (2025) 113 Cal.App.5th 832, 846; People v. Sok (2010) 181 Cal.App.4th
88, 100; People v. Lopez (2004) 119 Cal.App.4th 132, 138.)
III
The Abstracts of Judgment Must be Amended to Correct Errors and Award
One Additional Day of Custody Credits
Ware contends there are errors in the abstracts of judgment as follows:
(1) section 13 of the abstract of judgment for his determinate sentence
erroneously states that his total term is “20 years plus 75 years to life” rather
than 55 years to life; (2) section 16 of the abstract of judgment for his
18
determinate term erroneously reflects zero days of actual custody credits and
300 days of total credits, when the figure should be 301 days for both; and
(3) section 8 of the abstract of judgment for his indeterminate term
erroneously states that he was sentenced pursuant to the Three Strikes Law
(Pen Code, § 667, subds. (b)-(i), 1170.12).
The People concede each of these errors and agree that the abstracts of
judgment should be corrected accordingly. We accept the concession and will
therefore direct that the abstracts of judgment be corrected.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is modified to (1) vacate the concurrent sentence imposed
for count 3 and stay the sentence on that count under section 654; and
(2) award one additional day of custody credits for a total of 301 days. As so
modified, the judgment is affirmed. The clerk of the superior court is directed
to issue amended abstracts of judgment reflecting these modifications and
correcting the following errors: (1) correct section 13 of the abstract of
judgment for the determinate sentence by stating that the total term is 55
years to life rather than “20 years plus 75 years to life”; (2) correct section 16
of the abstract of judgment for the determinate term to reflect 301 days of
actual custody credits and 301 days of total credits, and correct section 15 of
the abstract of judgment for the indeterminate term to reflect the same
figures; and (3) uncheck the box in section 8 of the abstract of judgment for
the indeterminate term which currently indicates that Ware was sentenced
“pursuant to PC 667(b)-(i) or PC 1170.12.” The clerk of the superior court is
19
directed to forward a copy of the amended abstracts of judgment to the
California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
BUCHANAN, J.
WE CONCUR:
DATO, Acting P. J.
KELETY, J.
20