Edmond McClinton v. Dexter Payne, Director, Arkansas Division of Correction
CourtSupreme Court of Arkansas
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Cite as 2026 Ark. 192
SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS
No. CV-26-277
Opinion Delivered: November 19, 2026
EDMOND MCCLINTON
APPELLANT PRO SE APPEAL FROM THE
LINCOLN COUNTY CIRCUIT
COURT
V.
[NO. 40CV-25-107]
DEXTER PAYNE, DIRECTOR, HONORABLE JODI RAINES
ARKANSAS DIVISION OF DENNIS, JUDGE
CORRECTION
APPELLEE AFFIRMED.
KAREN R. BAKER, Chief Justice
Appellant Edmond McClinton appeals from the dismissal of his petition for writ of
habeas corpus filed pursuant to Arkansas Code Annotated section 16-112-102 (Repl. 2016).
In the petition he filed in circuit court, McClinton alleged that the trial court lacked
jurisdiction because he was deprived of a first appearance where he should have been
arraigned and bound over for trial. The circuit court dismissed the petition, finding that
McClinton had not demonstrated a lack of jurisdiction and failed to show that he was being
illegally detained.
A Jefferson County jury convicted McClinton of raping a mentally handicapped
sixteen-year-old girl, and he was sentenced as a habitual offender to a term of life
imprisonment. The conviction was affirmed on appeal. McClinton v. State, 2015 Ark. 245,
464 S.W.3d 913.
A circuit court’s decision on a petition for writ of habeas corpus will be upheld unless
it is clearly erroneous. Jefferson v. Payne, 2025 Ark. 174, 722 S.W.3d 769. A decision is
clearly erroneous when, although there is evidence to support it, the appellate court, after
reviewing the entire evidence, is left with the definite and firm conviction that a mistake
has been made. Id.
On appeal, McClinton contends that the trial court did not have subject-matter
jurisdiction because it failed to conduct “bind-over proceedings.” McClinton asserts that
the failure to conduct a first appearance whereby defendants are bound over for trial deprives
the trial court of subject-matter jurisdiction. The record includes a transcript of a pretrial
hearing wherein McClinton raised the lack-of-first-appearance issue. The trial court
informed McClinton that he had been provided with sufficient due process when the
prosecutor filed the information and warrant that had been served on McClinton. The issue
was not raised on direct appeal. See McClinton, 2015 Ark. 245, 464 S.W.3d 913.
McClinton subsequently filed a petition for postconviction relief in accordance with
Arkansas Rule of Criminal Procedure 37.1 wherein he alleged that the trial court did not
have jurisdiction to convict him because he did not receive a preliminary first-appearance
“bind-over,” or probable-cause hearing. See McClinton v. State, 2018 Ark. 116, 542 S.W.3d
859. This court rejected McClinton’s jurisdictional claim, finding that it amounted to an
allegation of trial error and that the lack of a prompt first appearance or proper arraignment
was not a fundamental error that would have voided the judgment. Id. In sum, this court
made clear that the lack of “bind-over proceedings” does not give rise to a question of
2
subject-matter jurisdiction. Despite this previous holding, McClinton attempts to raise the
issue a second time.
Because res judicata applies, we hold that the circuit court did not clearly err in
denying McClinton’s petition. Claim preclusion prevents a party that has already had a fair
trial on the matter from relitigating a claim or cause of action. Burgie v. State, 2025 Ark. 94.
Claim preclusion is an aspect of res judicata and bars relitigating a subsequent suit when five
factors are present: (1) the first suit resulted in a final judgment on the merits; (2) the first
suit was based on proper jurisdiction; (3) the first suit was fully contested in good faith; (4)
both suits involve the same claim or cause of action; and (5) both suits involve the same
parties or their privies. Id. Privity exists when two parties are so identified with one another
that they represent the same legal right. Gulley v. State ex rel. Jegley, 2023 Ark. 70, 664
S.W.3d 421. The State and appellee Dexter Payne represent the same legal right in that
Payne is named in this action in his official capacity as director of the Division of Correction.
An action filed against a State official in that person’s official capacity is not a suit against
that person; rather, it is a suit against that official’s office and, as such, is no different than an
action against the State itself. See Banks v. Jones, 2019 Ark. 204, 575 S.W.3d 111.
Whether the circuit court lost jurisdiction when it failed to provide McClinton with
a first appearance has been decided. This court made clear that the absence of a first-
appearance hearing is not a jurisdictional issue, nor is it considered a fundamental error.
Rather, it is a question of trial court error that should have been addressed on direct appeal.
A petitioner for the writ who does not allege his or her actual innocence and proceed
under Act 1780 of 2001 must plead either the facial invalidity of the judgment or the circuit
3
court’s lack of jurisdiction and make a showing, by affidavit or other evidence, of probable
cause to believe that he or she is being illegally detained. Jefferson, 2025 Ark. 174, 722
S.W.3d 769. In habeas proceedings, assertions of trial error and due-process claims do not
implicate the facial invalidity of the judgment or the trial court’s jurisdiction. Crockett v.
Payne, 2026 Ark. 62. McClinton’s allegation that he was not provided with a first hearing
did not establish that his conviction is facially invalid or that the trial court was deprived of
jurisdiction, and he is precluded from raising the claim that was raised and rejected in a
previous postconviction proceeding. Burgie, 2025 Ark. 94. The circuit court did not clearly
err when it dismissed McClinton’s petition for writ of habeas corpus.
Affirmed.
Special Justices CORY COX and CLINTON DEWITT join.
WEBB and BRONNI, JJ., not participating.
Edward McClinton, pro se appellant.
Tim Griffin, Att’y Gen., by: Michael Zangari, Ass’t Att’y Gen., for appellee.
4